Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / FRAUD AND WHY NCUA MUST BE ONSITE
Transcript
- 0:00NCUA needs to show up.
- 0:01Them not showing up provides the opportunity.
- 0:04When there is that opportunity, there will be more fraud.
- 0:08When there is more fraud, there will be more failures
- 0:11Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:16I hope you enjoy.
- 0:21Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:25Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the Insider's View on passing
- 0:28your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:31The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:34Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:36If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions team and
- 0:40receive Support to optimize your results with NCUA, so you save time and money.
- 0:45Visit us@marktrico.com to find out more.
- 0:54Hey everyone, this is Mark Trico flying solo today on a short podcast
- 0:59on fraud, the Fraud Triangle, and how I believe that will mean NCUA.
- 1:04We'll always have some onsite exams and never be fully virtual.
- 1:10At least that's what I would do if I was still there and let me explain why.
- 1:15So what triggered this is a board meeting last week, which was the quarterly
- 1:21share insurance update and chairman Todd Harper talked about the fact that travel
- 1:26was going to go up and talked about.
- 1:29Uh, some of the failures in credit unions over the last several
- 1:33quarters, and that there was fraud involved in those institutions.
- 1:38So, and he made the point that while the budget's coming up, he
- 1:41believes that NCUA needs the extra.
- 1:44Travel costs because they need to have a presence on credit unions, particularly
- 1:48small credit unions, where the ability to segregate duties is, is less because
- 1:55they're just not the staff to do it.
- 1:56So there's an article and see you collaborate David Bowman, quoting some
- 2:01things that chairman Harper said, but here's the article saying that examiners
- 2:04have discovered problems at credit unions as they return to on site exams.
- 2:09NCUA Chairman Todd Harper warned Thursday that the agency's travel
- 2:13budget must increase to accommodate the need for in person visits.
- 2:17As examiners return on site, they have found an increase in record
- 2:21keeping deficiencies, problems with internal controls, and instances
- 2:25of fraud, Harper said at the agency's board monthly meeting.
- 2:29The NSUA staff has proposed an operating budget of 350 million
- 2:33next year, which represents a 9.
- 2:356 percent increase over this year's budget.
- 2:37The proposal includes a travel budget of 23 million, a 5 million boost.
- 2:43As an aside, I did a previous Podcast on their budget, my take on that 9.
- 2:506 percent is it's essentially at or below inflation and and so we
- 2:56had essentially a flat budget, at least for 1 or maybe 2 years.
- 3:00So that I think there's some pent up demand there.
- 3:02I don't think they can get it much load or lower.
- 3:04And I doubt when they approve it, that it will be much lower.
- 3:08So see, you collaborate goes on to say responses from credit union groups.
- 3:13Are that credit union trade groups have criticized the agency's budget, among
- 3:16other issues, they contend that the offsite exams that were conducted during
- 3:20the pandemic demonstrate that examiners can do an effective job remotely.
- 3:24However, Harper said that during the 1st, 3 quarters of this year,
- 3:274 credit unions failed, causing about 7 million dollars in losses.
- 3:32He noted that fraud was a contributing factor in all of the cases.
- 3:36Saying, even though we learned during the pandemic that many more of our
- 3:39examination procedures can be completed offsite, it is important that examiners
- 3:44go into credit unions to examine documents, ask questions, interact with
- 3:48staff, and review internal controls.
- 3:50I 100 percent agree with Chairman Harper, and I'll go into that a little bit.
- 3:54The article goes on to say, so as the insulate board considers the 2023 2024
- 3:59budget, we must ensure that our efforts to be penny wise and examinations
- 4:04don't ultimately result in being pound foolish when it comes to the strength
- 4:08and stability of the share insurance fund while not commenting on the
- 4:12budget and to a board member Randy Rodney Hood agreed that it is important
- 4:16for examiners to return on site.
- 4:19The NCUA has not approved a 2023 budget yet.
- 4:22It may be considered at the board's December meeting.
- 4:25So that's the end of the article citations I will have.
- 4:29So it will be decided at the December meeting.
- 4:32They have to have one while they, when I was at NCUA, we started doing
- 4:37a two year budget so that if the board couldn't vote and didn't vote, that we
- 4:42would have at least something to operate on to start the following January.
- 4:46And that was particularly important when we only had a two member board.
- 4:49Because you could have a tie and that could have gotten pretty precarious.
- 4:53So while there is a budget that they could use, it's not enough money since
- 4:58they're asking for 10 percent more, that would not be a good position for
- 5:02staff to be in going into the year.
- 5:04So come hell or high water, they will approve a budget by the end of December.
- 5:08All right.
- 5:08So again, I re I agree with chairman Harper.
- 5:11There's a value.
- 5:13What happens when you are driving along and you.
- 5:17You have an app you use to drive, I use Waze, you get a notification
- 5:23that there's a police reported ahead.
- 5:25What do you do?
- 5:25Well, I slow down and then you see the police car and you might slow
- 5:29down at least for a little while.
- 5:31That's what happens when NCOA shows up.
- 5:33There are psychological studies that show that there's a value to
- 5:37regulators showing up, to police having a presence, that it reminds people.
- 5:43To do good and to follow the rules reminds them that the rules exist,
- 5:47which gets me to another thing I wanted to make reference to, and
- 5:49I referenced in some podcasts.
- 5:51NCUA does educate some of its staff to become certified fraud auditors.
- 5:58Certified fraud auditors, when you talk to them, they talk about the fraud triangle.
- 6:03Now, what is the fraud triangle?
- 6:05The fraud triangle is a concept that explains the reasons behind committing
- 6:09fraud by workers at a workplace.
- 6:11And consists of three elements that are responsible for the fraud pressure,
- 6:16rationalization, and opportunity.
- 6:19According to this concept, fraud occurs when conditions for fraud are
- 6:23favorable to the fraud committer, and it is not a random occurrence.
- 6:29So the three elements.
- 6:30Pressure.
- 6:31The pressure is the motivation behind fraud committing, and that
- 6:34can be either personal financial pressure or pressure from superiors.
- 6:38Both the pressures give the motivation for committing fraud.
- 6:42If the pressure remains unsolved by rational and legal means, then
- 6:46individuals might go for irrational ways.
- 6:49Some common examples of personal financial pressure are non shareable
- 6:55financial problems, Pressure to pay loans and lifestyle maintenance.
- 6:59And some examples of pressure from superiors are window dressing of accounts,
- 7:03teaming and lading inventory, pilferage and selling, sharing secret information
- 7:08with competitors to earn money, et cetera.
- 7:11When a person cannot see the apparent path of achieving personal.
- 7:15Or work goals by honest means they may adopt dishonest alternatives.
- 7:20I can tell you, I recently chatted with a client who had a staff member
- 7:24leave, who had been hiding things from them so that they appeared to be in
- 7:28compliance with goals and appeared to be in compliance with policy.
- 7:33Number two, opportunity.
- 7:34When pressure is present, the employee looks for an opportunity to commit fraud.
- 7:38For example, if there is no internal control over the inventory room,
- 7:43then the employee finds the chance to pilferage it and sell it in the market.
- 7:48There are some cases out there where that happened that were
- 7:51reported in all the trades, you know, 4 years back, but it happens.
- 7:55It can be done by abusing the position, for example, pressure by superior to
- 8:00subordinate to show accounts by, again, window dressing what the reality is.
- 8:04Number 3 is rationalization.
- 8:07It is the last stage.
- 8:08In the fraud triangle, this stage requires fraudsters to justify fraud acceptably.
- 8:14Most fraud committers do not see themselves as criminals.
- 8:17Instead, they explain the situation of committing fraud.
- 8:21Similarly, fraud by management gives reasons for performance and pressure
- 8:25from shareholders for dividends to all.
- 8:27So that doesn't apply.
- 8:29But because credit unions, shareholders are their members, so that last sentence
- 8:34is a little incongruent with credit unions, but rationalization, you
- 8:38know, I was passed over for a raise.
- 8:39I should have got that promotion.
- 8:42I'm not paid enough to compared to, you know, the 4 other people
- 8:46who've been here longer than me.
- 8:48The rationalization allows them to believe that what they're doing has has
- 8:52good intent, but in reality, it doesn't.
- 8:56So, you know, this article goes on to talk about how you can mitigate
- 8:59it with strong internal controls, favorable employee policies,
- 9:03strong fraud, deterrent policies.
- 9:06And ethical training auditing, which is an important element.
- 9:11The fraud triangle has three elements, pressure,
- 9:13opportunity, and rationalization.
- 9:15And the most crucial factor is an opportunity.
- 9:19It is so because the opportunities available for committing
- 9:22the fraud, motivate the fraudster to commit the fraud.
- 9:27So let me repeat that.
- 9:28The opportunities available for committing the fraud motivate the
- 9:32fraudsters to commit the fraud.
- 9:35So here's the deal.
- 9:36NCUA needs to show up.
- 9:38Them not showing up provides the opportunity.
- 9:41When there is that opportunity, there will be more fraud.
- 9:44When there is more fraud, there will be more failures.
- 9:48And the industry will expect NCUA to have dealt with those.
- 9:52But if they're not on side and can't do some procedures, Particularly in
- 9:57the smaller credit unions, uh, to mitigate the potential for fraud.
- 10:01Not that NCOA does fraud audits and that they're going to, that
- 10:04they're going to catch all fraud.
- 10:06But again, the actual presence mitigates the opportunity and then the steps
- 10:11that are taken can catch it sooner.
- 10:15Then later, heaven forbid, we, you know, you're finding a situation
- 10:18where there's one of the large frauds that happen in credit unions.
- 10:21How can the Fraud Triangle help to identify fraud and avoid it?
- 10:25The motivation for fraud can vary from financial to non financial.
- 10:29To prevent fraud, companies must implement strong internal controls.
- 10:33As an organization with strong internal control, experience lower
- 10:37frauds and quickly identify frauds.
- 10:40Strong fraud deterrence policies also help prevent fraud as employees fear
- 10:45its consequences like losing their jobs and not getting a job anywhere.
- 10:50In audits, management audit and operational audits are motivated so
- 10:54that management fraud can be detected.
- 10:57So there we go.
- 10:58NCOA doesn't do an audit, they do an exam, but that is part of how.
- 11:05The opportunities can be limited in the case of the statutory audit.
- 11:09There's a clause where the auditor has to report whether fraud is committed by
- 11:13employees, management or a third party.
- 11:16So if you are a credit union that has a CPA opinion on it, you are probably asked
- 11:21several questions as it relates to that.
- 11:22Are you aware of any fraud?
- 11:24I was asked those questions as the executive director when
- 11:27we had our opinion audits.
- 11:29Another way to mitigate fraud.
- 11:30Potential of fraud.
- 11:32The article also says the fraud triangle comprises these components, pressure,
- 11:36opportunity and rationalization.
- 11:39It helps in preventing the fraud.
- 11:41If there are zero tolerance, surprise visits and audits and a code of ethics.
- 11:46So let's focus on surprise visits and audits.
- 11:49It says top management must have a system of surprise checks and visits and
- 11:53auditors should also do surprise audits to ensure that no frauds are committed.
- 11:58By or on the company.
- 12:00All right.
- 12:00So NCWA has mostly gotten away from surprise visits.
- 12:04They will do surprise visits on occasion.
- 12:07Back right before I started, they actually, when, when the exam started,
- 12:11they would walk in, they would put red tape on all the loan files.
- 12:16They would count cash.
- 12:17And it was more of an audit and it was more of a surprise.
- 12:20If you can't do surprise.
- 12:22audits, you should do audits where you are present in the building and, uh, taking
- 12:28some steps that can only be done on site.
- 12:31So these notes came from a website called the wallstreetmojo.
- 12:36com.
- 12:37When I Googled fraud triangle, that one caught my eye because it did
- 12:41a really good job of summarizing.
- 12:43So I want to give them credit for that.
- 12:45So again, in summary, in my opinion, we'll never do fully.
- 12:50Virtual exams.
- 12:52They always need to make some onsite presence.
- 12:54There are no absolutes where you can say, Hey, stay away, never come back on site.
- 13:00And I think it would be unwise for NCUA to take that position.
- 13:03And I believe the NCUA board will continue to operate in that fashion.
- 13:07All that being said, there should be less of a footprint moving forward because
- 13:12the COVID pandemic taught the world and taught NCUA that more can be done offsite.
- 13:19That's it.
- 13:20Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 13:25Okay.
- 13:31Thank you for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors.
- 13:35Subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter
- 13:39experts of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 13:43If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 13:47out our services at marktreichel.
- 13:49com.