Latest / Stacking The Box, a Football Podcast / Caleb Williams Looks ELITE! + Hendrickson & Brian Robinson Trade Talk | NFL Preseason HEATS UP
Transcript
- 0:07[SPEAKER_00]: Tommy Jagai, a fan sighted here with NFL expert Marcus Mosher to talk about preseason week two football.
- 0:13[SPEAKER_00]: Some of the big performers, Marcus.
- 0:15[SPEAKER_00]: We've got to talk about Trey Henderson today also in a quiet storyline that for whatever reason it's kind of getting buried that we're going to close today's show with.
- 0:24[SPEAKER_00]: This is the no huddle show on stack in the box.
- 0:27[SPEAKER_00]: Marcus, let's talk about Caleb Williams first off here.
- 0:32[SPEAKER_00]: just played his first preseason action of the twenty twenty five summer.
- 0:36[SPEAKER_00]: It looks really good six of ten average ten point seven yards and a ten through a touchdown.
- 0:42[SPEAKER_00]: So some yak yards mixed in there to some yard after the catch, but he was on target.
- 0:47[SPEAKER_00]: He was on timing passes were accurate.
- 0:49[SPEAKER_00]: And he started to look like the Caleb Williams that we all thought the number one overall pit could be.
- 0:54[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I don't want to overreact too much based on what we see in the preseason, but Caleb Williams looked awesome on Sunday night and granted.
- 1:02[SPEAKER_01]: It's against Buffalo's backup defense.
- 1:04[SPEAKER_01]: There were a couple starters mixed in there, but what I care more about is the types of throws that Ben Johnson has Caleb Williams making very first throw was a little rolled out to coast of Lovelin and then he rips a ball down the middle of the field on a seam pass.
- 1:20[SPEAKER_01]: He just looks so much more comfortable and confident in his offense.
- 1:24[SPEAKER_01]: The reads are defined.
- 1:25[SPEAKER_01]: Guys are getting wide open.
- 1:27[SPEAKER_01]: And if you were a bear's fan, you know, worrying about some of the reports over the summer about, you know, his accuracy and picking up the offense.
- 1:35[SPEAKER_01]: I think this was a great sign that Ben Johnson knows what he's doing.
- 1:39[SPEAKER_01]: He's giving Caleb Williams a bunch of stuff.
- 1:42[SPEAKER_01]: And he's even said we're gonna peel it back as we get closer to the season.
- 1:47[SPEAKER_01]: But this bears offense, and again, in the limited sample that we saw, looks like it has a really, really bright future.
- 1:54[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, Marcus, and when it comes to Caleb Williams, it was never about the arm talent.
- 1:58[SPEAKER_00]: We knew that that was there from day one.
- 2:00[SPEAKER_00]: That's why he drew the Patrick Mahomes comparisons coming out of USC.
- 2:05[SPEAKER_00]: It was about the egregiously high sacrate holding onto the ball too long, uh, some inaccuracies throwing on the run.
- 2:12[SPEAKER_00]: Those are the things that he's
- 2:14[SPEAKER_00]: looks like he's cleaning up already and again, we don't want to overreact to preseason action here, but there's a lot of changes in changes for the positive in Chicago.
- 2:23[SPEAKER_00]: You've got Ben Johnson there now, the mastermind offensive mind from Detroit.
- 2:29[SPEAKER_00]: I Lutheran is there.
- 2:31[SPEAKER_00]: He didn't play with burden much.
- 2:32[SPEAKER_00]: We're going to talk about him in just a second, Colston Lovelin.
- 2:35[SPEAKER_00]: And so these additions, no doubt are going to make the team better.
- 2:39[SPEAKER_00]: How much of an impact does that have on the improvement that we're seeing from Kail Williams earlier?
- 2:45[SPEAKER_01]: having a competent play color.
- 2:47[SPEAKER_01]: I think Ben Johnson's better than a competent, but I mean, you look at what they had last year, a change of Waldron and just a really rough offense for a rookie quarterback.
- 2:56[SPEAKER_01]: Now you go to somebody who has all the answers, like Ben Johnson, it's a massive upgrade.
- 3:01[SPEAKER_01]: But I also think adding some guys on the offensive line two veterans, right?
- 3:04[SPEAKER_01]: Joe Toney, who actually did not play last night.
- 3:06[SPEAKER_01]: They were resting him.
- 3:08[SPEAKER_01]: And then Drew Dalman, who is one of the smartest centers in the league, that's been a problem for Chicago over the last couple of years.
- 3:15[SPEAKER_01]: And it's so nice to have a veteran center who can make all the line calls, who can help identify coverage is.
- 3:22[SPEAKER_01]: So your rookie or your young quarter back doesn't have to worry about all that kind of stuff.
- 3:26[SPEAKER_01]: So for me, that's just as big of a part of it as getting a course to love Linda Luther Bern, getting a veteran offensive line that's going to put him in good spots.
- 3:36[SPEAKER_01]: Everything is set up for Caleb Williams to have a monster season.
- 3:40[SPEAKER_01]: And again, based on the little bit that we saw last night, like I will be shocked if he doesn't have it.
- 3:45[SPEAKER_01]: This, this, this is an awesome environment.
- 3:49[SPEAKER_01]: And I do think Ben Johnson is going to put him in a position to succeed.
- 3:53[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I just got done with the all twenty two with Caleb and it's it's everything that you wanted to see rhythm passes timing hitting players in strides so that they can do damage after the catch all those changes seem to be positive.
- 4:05[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously the offensive line upgrades kind of get overlooked with the moves they made in the draft and obviously getting Ben Johnson, but this should be a much improved offense, Marcus.
- 4:15[SPEAKER_00]: So let's talk about another player from this offense who also had a good game in that is Luther Burton.
- 4:20[SPEAKER_00]: second round pick of the bears early on, especially if you go back to his twenty twenty three season at Missouri.
- 4:26[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, this guy looked like he was going to be like a future top ten pick ended up sliding in the drafts.
- 4:31[SPEAKER_00]: You and I are both bullish on him.
- 4:33[SPEAKER_00]: We are hot.
- 4:33[SPEAKER_00]: We were much higher than the consensus on burden because he's electric with the ball in his hands and you can see that in the limited action that he's had so far and his first preseason three catches for forty nine yards on three targets.
- 4:45[SPEAKER_00]: I watched the all twenty two watched try to diagnose all of
- 4:49[SPEAKER_00]: burdens routes, Marcus, and there was a lot to get excited about.
- 4:53[SPEAKER_00]: There were probably four or five other opportunities that he should have and probably could have been targeted by Tyson badge in there and didn't get the ball his way.
- 5:01[SPEAKER_00]: He could have made several more big plays in this game, but with the looks that he had he was incredibly efficient.
- 5:07[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, honestly, I don't even care about the routes and the yards after catch from this game.
- 5:14[SPEAKER_01]: One of the things that stood out was his blocking.
- 5:17[SPEAKER_01]: And I know the blocking doesn't get, you don't get fantasy points for blocking.
- 5:22[SPEAKER_01]: People aren't going to put it on social media, but there were several times, including on one of the rushing touchdowns on the first half, where he motioned down to the line of scrimmage, cleared out a linebacker, which set up the touchdown.
- 5:34[SPEAKER_01]: That is the kind of stuff that you need to be able to do as a slot receiver and Ben Johnson's offense.
- 5:39[SPEAKER_01]: It's why a monrasame round got on the field early during his rookie years because he could block.
- 5:45[SPEAKER_01]: And that's one of the things that Ben Johnson's been challenging Luther Burden is to really ramp up the physicality and become a useful blocker so that way he can earn more snaps and Greg Olson was loving it.
- 5:58[SPEAKER_01]: If you were watching the broadcast on Sunday night,
- 6:01[SPEAKER_01]: Greg Olson could not get over how good of a blocker Luther Burton was, and then he even slipped in a quote from Ryan Polls, which I thought was fascinating.
- 6:09[SPEAKER_01]: So the way that these productions work is Greg Olson will sit down with the head coach and the GM, and they'll kind of just talk about players and to get ready for the broadcast on Sunday night, and one of the things that Ryan Polls
- 6:24[SPEAKER_01]: told Greg Olson, which he wasn't supposed to say, is that they believe that Luther Bern is the best receiver on the roster, and he's got a higher ceiling than Roma Dunzey and DJ Moore, and they want to make him a featured part of the offense right away.
- 6:38[SPEAKER_01]: It's going to take him some time to get used to running NFL routes, but they think he has the highest ceiling of all three receivers.
- 6:44[SPEAKER_01]: We'll see what his role looks like early in the season because I do think all of it is the key.
- 6:49[SPEAKER_01]: It's going to get some work.
- 6:50[SPEAKER_01]: He scored a touchdown in this game, but it's clear that bears absolutely love Luther burden is got a big time role in this offense.
- 6:57[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, Marcus, you beat me to the blocking that I was going to get to as well.
- 7:00[SPEAKER_00]: I was enthralled by his blocking effort in this game, and especially when the ball was coming in his direction now, the player going away from him, wasn't didn't quite make the impact there, but man, he ran some defensive backs over in this game.
- 7:14[SPEAKER_00]: He talked about the one that made it for a walk in touchdown there.
- 7:18[SPEAKER_00]: But Marcus, I have to ask about Bird.
- 7:20[SPEAKER_00]: And if this is the case, and if the team really feels this way about him,
- 7:23[SPEAKER_00]: Why such a slow start in terms of not getting those reps with the first team offense?
- 7:28[SPEAKER_00]: Like we didn't see him come into the game until the first team offense had already been taken out.
- 7:33[SPEAKER_00]: We've heard at times already that he's been up and down at practice that he has had a little bit of a slower start.
- 7:40[SPEAKER_00]: Like how long is this transition going to take if they really feel this highly of of Luther burden with third.
- 7:46[SPEAKER_01]: Probably a while, it's worth mentioning that he missed almost all of the summer with a lower body soft tissue injury.
- 7:52[SPEAKER_01]: He missed all of many camps all of OTAs.
- 7:55[SPEAKER_01]: He missed the first two weeks of training camp.
- 7:57[SPEAKER_01]: So they're trying to slowly ramp him up and the thing is I just
- 8:02[SPEAKER_01]: I think they like Zacchaeus as well.
- 8:03[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, he has some ability to make plays after the catch.
- 8:06[SPEAKER_01]: They have two tight ends.
- 8:08[SPEAKER_01]: They want to use in Colcomet and Colston Loveland.
- 8:11[SPEAKER_01]: I think they want to give Luther burdensome work, but they don't want to overwork him early in the year.
- 8:17[SPEAKER_01]: They've got weapons.
- 8:18[SPEAKER_01]: They just have to figure out the best way to kind of utilize all of them as the season goes along.
- 8:24[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, Marcus, this bear's offense has been my not so subtle bet to be like the most improved offense in the NFL for obvious reasons.
- 8:32[SPEAKER_00]: You've got Caleb Williams in year two.
- 8:33[SPEAKER_00]: You got Luther Burden, Colston, Lovelin, Ben Johnson, the new look interior offensive line.
- 8:38[SPEAKER_00]: Like there's so much to get excited about.
- 8:40[SPEAKER_00]: This is a team that could be fun to watch this year.
- 8:43[SPEAKER_00]: So keep an eye on him.
- 8:44[SPEAKER_00]: We'll see if you did these guys play in the finale.
- 8:46[SPEAKER_00]: I would expect that Burden Wood will see about Caleb Williams.
- 8:52[SPEAKER_00]: Mark, let's talk about tray Hendrix in here.
- 8:55[SPEAKER_00]: The big story line of the day, and I want to read the quote from Dienerous.
- 9:00[SPEAKER_00]: See any here?
- 9:01[SPEAKER_00]: And teams of recently inquired about Bengals star tray Hendrix in were told, since now he's asking price includes a young defense of player and a twenty twenty six first round pick.
- 9:14[SPEAKER_00]: Marcus, first of all, I got a two-part question here.
- 9:16[SPEAKER_00]: How serious are the Bengals?
- 9:19[SPEAKER_00]: about an actual trade moving on from Trey Henrickson and I guess the situation here a little bit further is they're offering a huge APY still but it's the guaranteed money like it was from the start that is still far off are the bangles actually willing to trade him and is that what it would take.
- 9:41[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, I think the bangles are open to trading.
- 9:43[SPEAKER_01]: Listen, if you get a first wrong pick and a young defense player for a thirty plus year old pass-wester, I think you'd have to consider, right?
- 9:51[SPEAKER_01]: But to me, this reads like the brain and I uke situation from last year, which the forty-nine years let brain and I uke kind of go out and gauge the trade market.
- 10:00[SPEAKER_01]: And what they were really doing is letting other teams make offers in terms of like the contract
- 10:06[SPEAKER_01]: forebrain and you can then the forty hours we're just going to match whatever that team was willing to get right that's what happened with Pittsburgh and brain and I you can then the forty nine or so my guess is that with the teams we've heard so far the cults the Patriots and the Browns have all expressed interest in Henderson my guess is that the Bengals just want to see what kind of money is out there for him
- 10:28[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, if somebody's like, if New England's willing to give up, you know, Kyle Dugger and a first-rawn pick form, hey, you do that all day, right?
- 10:34[SPEAKER_01]: That's a first-rawn pick from a team that might not make the playoffs.
- 10:38[SPEAKER_01]: How realistic is that?
- 10:40[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think so.
- 10:41[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think it's gonna happen.
- 10:43[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and that brings me to the next point here is which teams would be suitors because according to Jordan Schultz, the Panthers, Browns, and Colts are among the teams that have shown interest in him, not exactly playoff contenders, at least we wouldn't expect Marcus.
- 10:56[SPEAKER_00]: And so you would have to think if you were trading for a pass rush, you were to in terms of thirty one years old during the season this year, I'll be at a good player, seventeen and a half sacks and back to back years, finish first team all pro, second and defense player, the year voting.
- 11:11[SPEAKER_00]: But you have to be a team that is on the cusp of a deep playoff run.
- 11:16[SPEAKER_00]: Otherwise, it doesn't make a lot of sense unless that's not the ultimate goal.
- 11:20[SPEAKER_00]: But well, I was going to say, you're one of those teams.
- 11:22[SPEAKER_00]: Would you trade?
- 11:24[SPEAKER_01]: In terms of, let's go like team by team, the cults, right?
- 11:27[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 11:27[SPEAKER_01]: Are the cults a playoff team?
- 11:29[SPEAKER_01]: Probably not.
- 11:31[SPEAKER_01]: However, I think if Chris Ballard and Shane Steichen don't make it to the playoff this year, they're probably both getting fired, right?
- 11:38[SPEAKER_01]: So to them, a first run pick and next year's draft doesn't really do you all that much good.
- 11:43[SPEAKER_01]: If you're going to be seven and ten, your rather trade,
- 11:46[SPEAKER_01]: But whether it's a first or second on pick trades and draft capital, add tray Hendricks into your defense and now you play him with the force Buckner and Quay Pay, you know, a lot to a lot to.
- 11:57[SPEAKER_01]: Now you have a really good defensive line.
- 12:00[SPEAKER_01]: Is that what the organization should do?
- 12:03[SPEAKER_01]: Probably not, but a lot of these GMs are in, you know, job saving mode, and that's probably how a tray like this is going to happen.
- 12:11[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I get that.
- 12:12[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I totally against that philosophy.
- 12:14[SPEAKER_00]: Like I would not trade for a guy in his thirties, but when your jobs are on the line, that's where a trade can possibly come.
- 12:21[SPEAKER_00]: Now, an indivision trade are the Bengals really going to give the Browns trade Henderson to go with miles.
- 12:27[SPEAKER_00]: Gary, I kind of doubt that that one would take place in the Browns are in the same situation though.
- 12:32[SPEAKER_00]: We're talking about a team that's projected to finish dead last in this division.
- 12:36[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know if Hendrix and Helps it enough
- 12:39[SPEAKER_00]: To change that narrative they have don't know what their quarterback situation is gonna be you're gonna roll with a forty-plus year old Joe Flacco more likely than not and then go from there But yeah, I mean you would think in an ideal situation obviously
- 12:52[SPEAKER_00]: you would want Hendrickson to go to a team where he couldn't compete for a championship and it doesn't look like those are the teams that have expressed interest in himself.
- 13:00[SPEAKER_01]: And this is the same thing for the Browns, right?
- 13:02[SPEAKER_01]: Andrew Barry, I think, is fighting for his job right now.
- 13:04[SPEAKER_01]: Now, they wouldn't trade their first rompick or Jacksonville's first rompick, but maybe Cleveland's second rompick and
- 13:12[SPEAKER_01]: something else.
- 13:13[SPEAKER_01]: Another young player.
- 13:14[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe that's enough to get it done.
- 13:16[SPEAKER_01]: And they're probably the same thing.
- 13:17[SPEAKER_01]: Hey, we have Miles Garrett.
- 13:18[SPEAKER_01]: We have Trey Hendrickson.
- 13:19[SPEAKER_01]: We just drafted Mason Graham.
- 13:21[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe our defense alone can help us, you know, be competitive.
- 13:25[SPEAKER_01]: And if we go eight, nine, yeah, we didn't make the playoffs, but that's a big step forward.
- 13:30[SPEAKER_01]: We need to remember that in a lot of these trades teams are just trying to save their jobs these GMs are always worried about if hey they go three and fourteen they're not going to be back.
- 13:41[SPEAKER_01]: So draft capital is kind of worthless to them.
- 13:44[SPEAKER_01]: So I wouldn't be a surprise if it's team that's kind of
- 13:47[SPEAKER_01]: outside that playoff picture that makes a bold move for treheter.
- 13:52[SPEAKER_01]: And ultimately though, I think the bangles are going to pay him.
- 13:54[SPEAKER_01]: I think they're going to pay him upwards of thirty two million dollars a year.
- 13:58[SPEAKER_01]: I think a lot of it's going to be guaranteed.
- 14:00[SPEAKER_01]: Well, when does it get done?
- 14:02[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, but I do think it ultimately gets done.
- 14:05[SPEAKER_00]: I agree, Marcus.
- 14:06[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's that same brand and I, you grow out where you're seeing what other teams would be willing to pay him in a trade and sign contract extension and then they'll probably match that offer.
- 14:17[SPEAKER_00]: Hypothetically, Marcus, if the Bengals were to get rid of trade, Henderson, this defense was absolutely pitiful last year.
- 14:23[SPEAKER_00]: And so reason why I've never seen anything like it before, where the combination of Joe Burrow, Jamar Chase was so lethal
- 14:30[SPEAKER_00]: And yet you had to scratch and claw your way back to a nine and eight record missed the playoffs because your defense was so bad.
- 14:36[SPEAKER_00]: How bad would it be if Henderson was not on this roster?
- 14:40[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, bad, but they're already bad.
- 14:41[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's part of the equation that Cincinnati is trying to figure out here is we're already one of the league's worst defenses is paying thirty, you know, let's say it's thirty two million dollars a year.
- 14:50[SPEAKER_01]: Paying thirty two million dollars a year for a past Russia in his thirties, is that the best, is that the best way to go about building your defense?
- 15:01[SPEAKER_01]: I think it probably is still the best decision, but I can at least hear the argument of, hey, let's build up some draft capital.
- 15:08[SPEAKER_01]: Let's have a young cheap defense and if they're going to be bad, let's make sure they're at least not expensive.
- 15:14[SPEAKER_01]: I don't see Cincinnati as a playoff team regardless of Henderson is back or not because they have so many holes elsewhere on this roster.
- 15:22[SPEAKER_01]: But there's still a team that's going to be putting up a lot of points that's fun to watch this year.
- 15:28[SPEAKER_00]: All right, we'll see how that plays out.
- 15:30[SPEAKER_00]: And again, I expect a Henderson to sign with the bangles as well.
- 15:33[SPEAKER_00]: Marcus, let's talk about another player who is, especially on the trade block now, and that is Commanders running back for Ryan Robinson Jr.
- 15:39[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know what the market would be for him, and I'm interested to ask you, he's played three seasons in the NFL.
- 15:45[SPEAKER_00]: All three he's had between seven hundred and eight hundred rushing yards.
- 15:49[SPEAKER_00]: Very average in terms of his run success rate.
- 15:51[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's forty nine point eight percent four point one yards per carry in his career.
- 15:55[SPEAKER_00]: Give you a little bit of receiving chops kind of a well-rounded back comes from air eight offense, a little bit of wide zone, a little bit of gap.
- 16:03[SPEAKER_00]: What's the market like for a Brian Robinson Jr.
- 16:07[SPEAKER_00]: What would you get for him out there?
- 16:09[SPEAKER_00]: He's twenty six and a half years old going into a contract here.
- 16:13[SPEAKER_01]: Well, the fact that it's getting reported that the commanders are shopping and tells me that there's not much of a market, right?
- 16:19[SPEAKER_01]: Because otherwise, that kind of stuff wouldn't be out there.
- 16:21[SPEAKER_01]: But here's what's going on in Washington right now.
- 16:23[SPEAKER_01]: They have a couple young backs that they really like.
- 16:26[SPEAKER_01]: They have Austin Eccler, who's going to be the passing down back.
- 16:29[SPEAKER_01]: I think they're going to utilize Debo Samuel as more of a running back this year.
- 16:33[SPEAKER_01]: They have Sean Rodriguez.
- 16:35[SPEAKER_01]: They have Jacori, Croskey Merit, who's an older, seventh-ron pick.
- 16:39[SPEAKER_01]: I just don't think
- 16:41[SPEAKER_01]: They want someone like Brian Robinson, who's more of a downhill runner than a wide zone runner.
- 16:47[SPEAKER_01]: And honestly, I think they're going to be playing even more air ray this year, under Cliff Kingsbury.
- 16:51[SPEAKER_01]: I think Brian Robinson, who I think is a good gap runner, but it's in the final year of his contract.
- 16:57[SPEAKER_01]: I think you're looking at like a six-room pick, you know, pick swap fit, maybe you give up a fifth, you get back a six.
- 17:03[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think there's much of a market here, but I do expect Brian Robinson to eventually get traded here.
- 17:10[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, if you're the commanders and you're a team that just won the eleven games and twelve games last year and a playoff, but you had playoff success.
- 17:18[SPEAKER_00]: Is this a move that's worth making?
- 17:21[SPEAKER_00]: If you're talking about late day three draft capital and what are the alternatives in Washington's backfield right now?
- 17:27[SPEAKER_00]: Who do they have to feel confident about?
- 17:29[SPEAKER_01]: Well, they really like this jacory crosskey merit who they got again in the seventh round.
- 17:34[SPEAKER_01]: He sat out most of last year because of a transfer issue, you know, NCA violation.
- 17:41[SPEAKER_01]: We'll see.
- 17:41[SPEAKER_01]: I'm always really hesitant about seventh round picks coming in and producing right away, but they really like Austin Eckler.
- 17:48[SPEAKER_01]: They really like Rodriguez who, uh, he's averaging over five yards per carry throughout his career.
- 17:53[SPEAKER_01]: I think they want to be a little bit more explosive in the back field.
- 17:57[SPEAKER_01]: And that's why Washington is looking at moving on from Brian Robinson.
- 18:03[SPEAKER_00]: Robinson the bigger type of running back six to two hundred twenty five pounds doesn't really excel in the explosive play department and so I understand the mindset there at the very least markets let's talk about Jackson Dart here for a little bit
- 18:18[SPEAKER_00]: He wowed us in the first preseason game, had the deep ball, forty plus chart play down the left sideline.
- 18:23[SPEAKER_00]: We saw him do that at Old Miss, but now he stacks back to back performances.
- 18:28[SPEAKER_00]: And so, darts in his second preseason action against the New York Jets, when fourteen of sixteen, hundred and thirty seven yards, eight point six yards per attempt with a touchdown, a hundred and twenty three point two, pass a rating.
- 18:41[SPEAKER_00]: And Marcus, I just put on his all twenty two tape before the show today.
- 18:47[SPEAKER_00]: There was a lot of screen passes mixed in, not really uncommon what we seen from him in his college career, either.
- 18:52[SPEAKER_00]: But he was on target and then over the middle of the field throws made two or three explosive plays down the middle of the field.
- 19:00[SPEAKER_00]: This is the type of stuff that you want to see from him.
- 19:02[SPEAKER_00]: And I think we're seeing it earlier than anyone expected.
- 19:05[SPEAKER_00]: This was a raw twenty one year old when he got drafted.
- 19:08[SPEAKER_00]: We assume that he needed a kind of a red shirt season to sit and learn the offense.
- 19:15[SPEAKER_00]: Is he going to need that after what we're seeing right now?
- 19:17[SPEAKER_00]: Are we overblowing his preseason performance?
- 19:21[SPEAKER_01]: I wouldn't react too much to base based on what we've seen the preseason.
- 19:24[SPEAKER_01]: However, I think he does, he looks good and now we put together back-to-back strong performances.
- 19:30[SPEAKER_01]: You're seeing table put him in some good situations where he can succeed.
- 19:34[SPEAKER_01]: We see the offense at the tempo.
- 19:36[SPEAKER_01]: The tempo is way up when Dart is in the game.
- 19:41[SPEAKER_01]: If I were a Giants fan, I would not want Dart to be rushed in to this situation.
- 19:46[SPEAKER_01]: Still an offensive line that's in development.
- 19:49[SPEAKER_01]: You have two veteran quarterbacks in Russell Wilson and James Winston, at least let those guys
- 19:55[SPEAKER_01]: take some of the lumps early in the year.
- 19:57[SPEAKER_01]: I want to read you the giant schedule to open the year just because you can see how hard it is.
- 20:02[SPEAKER_01]: They open up at Washington at Dallas home Kansas City home Chargers at the same sets in nice one home Philadelphia at Denver at Philadelphia home Forty Niners like that is a brutal stretch with with a bunch of really really good defenses.
- 20:19[SPEAKER_01]: I think I would give dart until maybe November, right?
- 20:23[SPEAKER_01]: Like, let him have two months of the NFL seeing the speed.
- 20:27[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe you give him a couple of series at the end of these games if it's not competitive, but I wouldn't want to put him out there before he's ready.
- 20:35[SPEAKER_01]: This isn't going to be a playoff team, regardless, because the NFC East is too good in the NFC as a conference.
- 20:41[SPEAKER_01]: It's too strong.
- 20:42[SPEAKER_01]: Let Dart ease his way into this the same way that Patrick Mahomes was eased in, Josh Allen was eased in, Michael Panic's last year, like give him some time and I think he's gonna be all right.
- 20:55[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, if not for that brutal early season slate there, I would say, maybe week four, week five, but I agree with you.
- 21:01[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think there's any sense of rushing him onto the field.
- 21:05[SPEAKER_00]: Even if Russell Wilson looks really bad, you could always turn to James Winston.
- 21:09[SPEAKER_00]: If you wanted to, the high variance quarterback there, nobody expects this giant team to be a contender this year.
- 21:16[SPEAKER_00]: It's about preserving the future.
- 21:18[SPEAKER_00]: You've got some assets in place with Jackson Dart, Abdul Carter.
- 21:22[SPEAKER_00]: You hope to have
- 21:23[SPEAKER_00]: your future building blocks.
- 21:26[SPEAKER_00]: Here for the foreseeable future, the last thing you want to do is rush him and ruin him by putting him in during a tough schedule.
- 21:34[SPEAKER_00]: I think if you're waiting till I think week ten might be the sweet spot.
- 21:38[SPEAKER_00]: If not Marcus, maybe that would be against Chicago.
- 21:41[SPEAKER_00]: Otherwise, maybe as late as week fourteen, buy and then come out of the buy and have him play the end of the season.
- 21:48[SPEAKER_00]: They are if the giants are already out of the race, but encouraging nonetheless
- 21:54[SPEAKER_00]: From what we've seen from Dart so far, and I love the fact that he is unfazed by those middle of the field balls.
- 22:01[SPEAKER_00]: Like nothing scares him.
- 22:03[SPEAKER_00]: He seems to shake it right off.
- 22:05[SPEAKER_00]: I liked Daniel Jeremiah's pre-draft comp for him, which was Jalen Hertz.
- 22:08[SPEAKER_00]: I think that he has some Jalen Hertz to his game.
- 22:11[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, we don't know if he's ever going to reach that ceiling, but in terms of play style and the confidence that he plays with, I'm liking what I'm seeing so far.
- 22:20[SPEAKER_00]: Marcus, let's talk about Justin Fields, the other quarterback that was in this game, obviously played early on when Russell Wilson was on the field for the Giants, but Justin Fields, the New York Jets quarterback, going into year five now, Marcus, we are not seeing what we want to see from him.
- 22:36[SPEAKER_00]: There were reports from camp that he was struggling with accuracy and now he goes into week two of the praises and one of five for four passing yards before his night was over.
- 22:47[SPEAKER_00]: We know that this is going to be the jet starting quarterback.
- 22:50[SPEAKER_00]: They don't have a legitimate option outside of him, but man, the jet's are putting a lot of faith.
- 22:56[SPEAKER_00]: Aaron Glenn is putting a lot of faith in a fifth year quarterback who just has not figured it out as a passer, Marcus, and at this point, if he hasn't figured it out, probably is not going to.
- 23:06[SPEAKER_01]: now he's been the same quarterback for the last four years and he's going to be the same quarterback in here five where the flashes are really exciting he'll hit a deep ball down the sideline with gorgeous touch and he can make plays with his legs and he's a really good short yardage runner
- 23:22[SPEAKER_01]: But the down to down consistency isn't there.
- 23:25[SPEAKER_01]: And that's what separates these talented quarterbacks from the guys that actually are good, that move offences.
- 23:31[SPEAKER_01]: And it's just going to be hard for the jets to have any sustained success on offense because you have a quarterback who is wildly inconsistent, who doesn't get to a second, third reads, who doesn't take the easy check downs and holds the ball too long.
- 23:46[SPEAKER_01]: I understand why the jets went outside because they want to be a physical run team.
- 23:50[SPEAKER_01]: They believe that, you know, let's limit the passing attempts.
- 23:53[SPEAKER_01]: Let Justin Fields run and let's lean on our rushing attack.
- 23:57[SPEAKER_01]: The problem is is that you can only do that for so long.
- 23:59[SPEAKER_01]: And it's too easy to game plan against that type of offense.
- 24:03[SPEAKER_01]: So it's, I think it's going to be a long year for this jets offense.
- 24:07[SPEAKER_01]: I do think they're going to run the ball extremely well.
- 24:11[SPEAKER_01]: But any hopes it like Justin feels is gonna turn around to be a franchise quarterback.
- 24:15[SPEAKER_01]: I think those are long gone.
- 24:16[SPEAKER_01]: Like we would have seen it by year three.
- 24:19[SPEAKER_01]: We're into year five right now.
- 24:20[SPEAKER_01]: Like it's, it's time.
- 24:22[SPEAKER_01]: And unfortunately, it doesn't seem like from all the reports from Jout's camp based on what we've seen in the preseason, it's gonna be a struggle for the Jets on offense.
- 24:31[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I agree.
- 24:32[SPEAKER_00]: And it's easy at times to get excited about field as arm strength, as rushing ability, obviously, very good in that department, but your legs can only get you so far if you're not improving mechanically.
- 24:42[SPEAKER_00]: I noticed some throws from that game some more high.
- 24:45[SPEAKER_00]: One of them skipped off the ground, like the accuracy is just not there on routine passes and over his first four seasons in his career.
- 24:54[SPEAKER_00]: So far, sixty one point one,
- 24:57[SPEAKER_00]: completion percentage and a thirty eight point five percent success rate those are not numbers that you can live by in an in expect to have consistent sustained results on offense I would be surprised that we got those this year I would have to assume Marcus right that this is his last opportunity as a starter in the NFL.
- 25:16[SPEAKER_01]: Probably the jets did give him ten million dollars guaranteed for twenty twenty six which I still have no idea why they decided to do that but yeah this is.
- 25:25[SPEAKER_01]: This is his last shot.
- 25:26[SPEAKER_01]: There were only two teams that were interested in signing him this off season.
- 25:29[SPEAKER_01]: It was his viewers and the jets.
- 25:31[SPEAKER_01]: Both of those teams were in quarterback purgatory.
- 25:34[SPEAKER_01]: They didn't really want to draft a quarterback.
- 25:36[SPEAKER_01]: They wanted some kind of veteran.
- 25:38[SPEAKER_01]: This is his last shot.
- 25:39[SPEAKER_01]: And listen, they're going to give him every opportunity.
- 25:42[SPEAKER_01]: The only other quarterback of note on this roster is Tyrod Taylor and he's dealing with an injury that's going to keep him out for the rest of the preseason and likely a couple of weeks into the regular season.
- 25:53[SPEAKER_01]: It feels as good to get to hold the year to show what he can do so far though, not so great.
- 25:58[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I think there was a reason why the Steelers were able to trade for him for a sixth round pick during last off season.
- 26:07[SPEAKER_00]: The market is just not high for him.
- 26:08[SPEAKER_00]: I think that most teams are out on him because of the lack of consistent passing ability.
- 26:13[SPEAKER_00]: So we'll see what he can do with the jets, but so far, not a lot to get encouraged about.
- 26:18[SPEAKER_00]: I think you're going to have to ride the coat tails.
- 26:21[SPEAKER_00]: of your defense and hope that your running game can get you to where you need to go, but that might be a few tile effort there.
- 26:27[SPEAKER_00]: Marcus, and I want to close today's show with a storyline that I don't feel is getting talked about enough.
- 26:33[SPEAKER_00]: And that is the help of quarterback Matthew Stafford, thirty seven year old quarterback.
- 26:38[SPEAKER_00]: So good still when he plays.
- 26:39[SPEAKER_00]: We saw that even last year, but this back injury is not going away.
- 26:44[SPEAKER_00]: He still is not practicing for the Rams.
- 26:48[SPEAKER_00]: Now we know that Sean McVay is
- 26:51[SPEAKER_00]: really hands off in the preseason doesn't like to play in starters hardly at all, but are we looking at a quarterback that's going to be ready to come out and compete when the season opens.
- 27:00[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, probably not, right?
- 27:01[SPEAKER_01]: Like if you just you're missing all of training camp in all the preseason, it's it's hard to believe, you know, we're three weeks away from the regular season.
- 27:08[SPEAKER_01]: It's hard to believe he's going to come right back in and be awesome.
- 27:11[SPEAKER_01]: He has a new receiver in Devante Adams.
- 27:14[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I have my doubts that he's going to come in and look good right away.
- 27:18[SPEAKER_01]: However,
- 27:20[SPEAKER_01]: From everything, Sean McVeigh has said, this isn't something that like he needs surgery on.
- 27:24[SPEAKER_01]: It's more of a pain tolerance issue.
- 27:26[SPEAKER_01]: We know that's never been a problem for Matt Stafford.
- 27:29[SPEAKER_01]: He'll go out there, grit his teeth, and play through just about anything.
- 27:33[SPEAKER_01]: The sports books haven't really overreacted to this at all.
- 27:36[SPEAKER_01]: They're Super Bowl odds haven't changed.
- 27:38[SPEAKER_01]: They're wind totals haven't changed.
- 27:40[SPEAKER_01]: Anything like that.
- 27:42[SPEAKER_01]: But it does feel like it's a very fragile situation in the sense of like, hey, one wrong hit or one twist that maybe was a little unexpected.
- 27:50[SPEAKER_01]: And all of a sudden, he's out for six weeks.
- 27:53[SPEAKER_01]: It reminds me a little bit of, you know, one of my former quarterbacks.
- 27:57[SPEAKER_01]: Tony Romo with the Cowboys, you're going into that twenty, sixteen season.
- 28:01[SPEAKER_01]: You know, he was dealing with a back injury.
- 28:03[SPEAKER_01]: He wanted to play a preseason game.
- 28:05[SPEAKER_01]: It kind of knocks some of the jitters out, right?
- 28:08[SPEAKER_01]: He goes in there.
- 28:09[SPEAKER_01]: He gets twisted up against Seattle.
- 28:12[SPEAKER_01]: And we see him play like five snaps for the rest of his career.
- 28:15[SPEAKER_01]: Like that's my fear with Matt Staffardus.
- 28:18[SPEAKER_01]: We're at the stage of his career where one wrong hit could be the end.
- 28:21[SPEAKER_01]: I hope that doesn't happen.
- 28:23[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm sure that's why Sean McVay is using every precaution to make sure that it doesn't happen.
- 28:29[SPEAKER_01]: But it is a very strange situation going on in LA right now.
- 28:35[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, if we're being honest, he's already
- 28:38[SPEAKER_00]: running on borrowed time, like outside of the few exceptions in recent generations, Marcus, like it's a thirty seven year old quarterback.
- 28:46[SPEAKER_00]: We know that he's got to be on his last legs, what's discouraging though is if not for this back injury, the arm talent still looks phenomenal.
- 28:53[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, the legs, it was never runner, but he used to be able to scramble.
- 28:57[SPEAKER_00]: That's all gone by the wayside, but the arm talent is still there.
- 29:01[SPEAKER_00]: He's still incredibly smart.
- 29:03[SPEAKER_00]: So we hope to see another good year of Stafford, but that back injury we don't know what the case is going to be.
- 29:09[SPEAKER_00]: So keep an eye on that and we'll see if he ends up returning to the field anytime soon, but not good news if you are a Rams fan.
- 29:17[SPEAKER_00]: All right, Marcus, anything else?
- 29:20[SPEAKER_01]: No, I'm glad the preseason is almost over.
- 29:23[SPEAKER_01]: I'm getting to where I really hate the preseason.
- 29:24[SPEAKER_01]: Now we're going to have that third preseason game this weekend.
- 29:27[SPEAKER_01]: We're almost nobody's going to play and yet we all have to cover it and watch it like it's meaningful.
- 29:32[SPEAKER_01]: But now we're getting closer and closer to the actual NFL season.
- 29:35[SPEAKER_01]: We're going to closer to cut down dates, which I'm sure will get lots of surprise news, but football is right around the corner.
- 29:42[SPEAKER_01]: I can't wait to be talking more about it.
- 29:45[SPEAKER_00]: All right, and we've got you guys covered.
- 29:46[SPEAKER_00]: We go live on the no-huttle show on stack in the box.
- 29:50[SPEAKER_00]: Every single Monday at eleven thirty a.m.
- 29:53[SPEAKER_00]: Eastern time you can follow me on X at Tommy jack.
- 29:56[SPEAKER_00]: I you can follow Marcus on X at Marcus under score.
- 30:00[SPEAKER_00]: Mosher thanks again for listening to the stack in the box.