Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Volkswagen ID. Polo: A Comparative Analysis of Electric Rivals
Transcript
- 0:09OK, let's just jump right in. We're seeing one of the most
- 0:13intense and honestly fast moving battles in the car world right
- 0:18now. Oh.
- 0:18Absolutely. It's the fight for the small,
- 0:20affordable electric car. Exactly, it's where, you know,
- 0:23real world practicality has to meet a price people can actually
- 0:26afford. And this year we've really seen
- 0:29three main contenders emerge in that crucial sub 25,000 LB
- 0:34market. You've got the Renault 5E tech
- 0:36which has all that retro charm, then the Citron EC3 which is all
- 0:40about the budget, and then the the BYD Dolphin Surf.
- 0:44It is surprisingly powerful one, and today we're pulling from 2
- 0:47fantastic sources for you. Right.
- 0:49We have a full real world Rd. test comparing those three, but
- 0:52we're also bringing in a deep technical analysis of a brand
- 0:55new Challenger that's about to shake things up.
- 0:57The Volkswagen ID Polo. So our mission today is pretty
- 1:01clear. We're cutting through all the
- 1:03marketing noise to find out what these cars are actually like.
- 1:05For you, the listener, we're going to figure out which one
- 1:07really gives the best balance of, you know, range,
- 1:11performance, practicality, and cost.
- 1:13And since it's the last day of the year, December 31st, 2025,
- 1:18we're taking a final look at the battlefield as it stands right
- 1:21before VW drops this new challenger in 2026.
- 1:24Let's do it. I mean, you really can't
- 1:26overstate how important these cars are.
- 1:27They're filling a huge gap in the market.
- 1:29They really are. You've got the expensive sort of
- 1:32premium EVs like the Mini Cooper Electric on one side.
- 1:35And on the other, the Super, super cheap ones like the Dacia
- 1:38Spring, which are, let's be honest, pretty compromised.
- 1:40Right. These three promise to be
- 1:42affordable without you having to sacrifice everything that makes
- 1:45a car usable day-to-day. So tell us about the specific
- 1:48versions they tested. OK, so the sources were very
- 1:51specific to make it a fair fight.
- 1:53First up, the Renault 5 urban range, it was the mid spec
- 1:56techno version. The price on that it comes in at
- 1:5824,995. For that you get a 40 kWh
- 2:03battery and an official range of 193 miles.
- 2:07OK. And the Citroen.
- 2:08The EC 3 was the top spec Max version and it's actually a bit
- 2:11cheaper. 23,795 is a slightly bigger battery. 43.7 kilowatt
- 2:17hours for a claimed 199 mile range and the wild.
- 2:21Card the BYD. The BYD Dolphin Surf they tested
- 2:24the top trim comfort version that has a 43.2 kWh battery. 200
- 2:30mile official range. But here's the kicker, it
- 2:33undercuts the base Renault 5 on price.
- 2:36Wow. Yeah, and if you're purely
- 2:38budget driven, they have an even cheaper active model under 19
- 2:42grand. But the battery is tiny, only
- 2:44137 miles of range. I have to stop you there because
- 2:47the BYD naming is just baffling. It's something else, isn't it?
- 2:51They call the fast version comfort and the slower 1 boost.
- 2:55It makes absolutely no sense. And the color of the test car,
- 2:58it's a metallic yellow, but be what he calls it, lime green.
- 3:00It does feel like maybe something got lost in
- 3:02translation for the international market.
- 3:04For sure. So, quirks aside, what was the
- 3:06test itself? It was a proper real world
- 3:09journey. They drove from Twickenham in
- 3:11London all the way down to a surfing spot on the South Coast.
- 3:15So a good mix of motorway and country roads.
- 3:17Exactly. The whole point was to test real
- 3:20range, see how much luggage you can actually fit and just how
- 3:23they feel to drive in normal conditions.
- 3:25OK, so let's get into the interiors.
- 3:27This is where you live with the car?
- 3:28Yeah, the Renault 5 seems to be the benchmark here.
- 3:31Oh absolutely. For this price, the quality
- 3:34inside is just it's a step above.
- 3:36They use these really clever recycled materials like a denim
- 3:39effect fabric. And that Google based
- 3:41infotainment system is supposed to be excellent.
- 3:44It is, but honestly the biggest win for the R5 is so simple.
- 3:48It has physical buttons for the air conditioning.
- 3:50Yes, no digging through menus. That's a huge plus.
- 3:55For safety, for convenience. It really is, but there's always
- 3:59a but the back seats. All that style up front comes at
- 4:02a cost, the sources said. Knee room, foot room and
- 4:06headroom are all seriously tight.
- 4:08It's the smallest of the three by a long shot.
- 4:10So it's more of a two person car with occasional rear passengers.
- 4:13Pretty much. And that's where the Citronee C3
- 4:15comes in. The front feels, you know, built
- 4:17to a budget. Bit cheaper.
- 4:18A bit cheaper, less refined than there are no, but then you get
- 4:21in the back and it's a different world.
- 4:23Way more head and knee room. It's a proper small family car.
- 4:28But the Citroen has its own design quirks, right?
- 4:32I read they put the physical AC controls somewhere weird.
- 4:35They did. They're positioned so low on the
- 4:37dash that the steering wheel room actually blocks your view
- 4:40of them. It almost defeats the purpose of
- 4:42having them. OK, So what about the BYDS
- 4:45interior? The dolphin surf is quality wise
- 4:48probably closer to the Renault. It uses some unique materials.
- 4:53I think I read it feels like wet suit material.
- 4:55Yeah, neoprene, which is either a fun, clever nod to the Surf
- 4:58name or just plain weird, depending on your taste.
- 5:01But the storage is fantastic. Better than the others.
- 5:04Way better big cubby areas, a wireless charging pad.
- 5:08It just feels more thought out for stashing your stuff.
- 5:11And the climate controls? Another quirk, instead of
- 5:14degrees you get settings like H6 or L3.
- 5:17You have to use the touch screen for most things though.
- 5:19There is a three finger swipe shortcut, it's just not as
- 5:22simple as a dial. Right, let's talk boot space.
- 5:25The Citroen is biggest on paper, right?
- 5:27310 liters. It is, and they managed to fit 5
- 5:30suitcases in which is impressive.
- 5:33The big downside though is no under floor storage at all.
- 5:36So you're charging cables are just loose in the boot?
- 5:39Exactly. The Renault is the smallest at
- 5:43277 liters, but it's good shape. The BYD though has a secret
- 5:48weapon, massive deep under floor storage.
- 5:52You can fit a whole extra suitcase under there so it also
- 5:55holds 5. The only catch is the BYD is
- 5:58strictly A4 seater. The other two are 5 seaters.
- 6:00That's a really important distinction.
- 6:02OK, so how do they actually drive?
- 6:04This is where the Renault Five really shines.
- 6:07It's the clear winner. The ride, the handling, it's all
- 6:11down to it's more sophisticated rear suspension.
- 6:14It feels like a more expensive car.
- 6:16And the Citroen. The complete opposite, it's very
- 6:19soft, kind of wallowy over bumps.
- 6:21The steering is super light. Doesn't give you much confidence
- 6:23on a winding Rd. So the BYD sits in the middle.
- 6:26Right in the middle. It's quieter than the Renault on
- 6:28the motorway. Not as floaty as the Citroen,
- 6:30but not nearly as fun to drive as the R5.
- 6:32I did see 1 shared complaint though.
- 6:35Yes, the brakes. All of them were described as
- 6:38inconsistent and grabby. That's a bit worrying.
- 6:41It is. It seems to be a common issue
- 6:42with budget Ev's trying to blend the regenerative braking with
- 6:46the physical brake smoothly. None of them have quite nailed
- 6:48it. Let's get to the big numbers
- 6:50then. Range and charging.
- 6:51They drove about 140 miles before the first stop.
- 6:54Yep, and the BYD arrived with the most charge left, 29%
- 6:58showing 57 miles of range. The Renault had 17% and the
- 7:02Citroen 19%. So the Byd's real world range
- 7:06seems to hold up better. It definitely seems that way,
- 7:08and at the charger, the story was even clearer.
- 7:11The Citroen was the slowest, taking 39 minutes to get to 80%.
- 7:15Ouch. The Renault was much better, 28
- 7:17minutes, but the BYD was the winner, just 25 minutes.
- 7:19That's a big deal on a road trip.
- 7:21OK, now for my favorite part of the test, the Drag Race
- 7:24surprise. This was fascinating.
- 7:26The BYD Dolphin Surf Comfort officially does zero 62 in 9.1
- 7:31seconds. On paper, it's the slow one.
- 7:34But not in reality. Not at all, it just walked away
- 7:36from the others. It hit 0 sixty and eight point O
- 7:39seconds flat. The R5 took 17.1 seconds for the
- 7:43quarter mile. The EC3 was over 18 seconds.
- 7:46The BYD did it in 16.5. So it's a bit of a sleeper.
- 7:49What about overall efficiency for the whole trip?
- 7:51After 204 miles, the Renault 5 was the most efficient.
- 7:55It managed 3.9 miles per kWh. And the BYD.
- 7:59Right behind it 3.8 Very respectable.
- 8:01The Citroen though? The Citroen was surprisingly
- 8:03inefficient, only 3.5 miles per kWh.
- 8:07That poor efficiency basically canceled out its slightly bigger
- 8:10battery. It's real world range was about
- 8:12155 miles, identical to the Renault with its smaller pack.
- 8:15That's disappointing. Yeah, OK, Money.
- 8:17This is the whole point of these cars.
- 8:19Right. So buying with cash, the Citron
- 8:21is the cheapest and has the lowest total cost of ownership
- 8:24over three years. But only just.
- 8:26The BYD was the most expensive TCO.
- 8:29But what about finance? Because that's how most people
- 8:31buy cars. And here is the massive twist on
- 8:33APCP finance deal. Because of its predicted poor
- 8:36resale value, the Citroen becomes the most expensive per
- 8:40month. You're kidding.
- 8:41Nope. It's 343 lies a month.
- 8:44The BYD, because of its stronger predicted value, actually
- 8:47becomes the cheapest 309 nines a month.
- 8:50So the car that's cheapest to buy outright is the most
- 8:53expensive on finance. That's a huge trap for buyers.
- 8:56It's a critical point. You have to look past the
- 8:58sticker price. Which brings us to the future
- 9:01and this new Volkswagen. The ID Polo.
- 9:05This seems like a big strategy shift for VW.
- 9:07It's a huge shift. They're moving away from those
- 9:10slightly odd futuristic ID designs.
- 9:13The ID polo is all about familiar looks, traditional
- 9:17usability and a really sharp price point.
- 9:19They're aiming for around £25,000.
- 9:21Which in pounds is what about 22,000?
- 9:25Pounds, yeah. So it immediately undercuts all
- 9:27of these current contenders. And their strategy is to out
- 9:30balance the Renault 5 not on style, but on pure pragmatism.
- 9:33Exactly. They are focusing on interior
- 9:35space, putting more physical buttons back in and giving it a
- 9:38comfortable, composed ride. They're betting that most people
- 9:41care more about that than sharp handling.
- 9:43So let's look at the data for the base model.
- 9:45OK, the ID Polo base will have an 85 kilowatt motor and a 37
- 9:50kWh LFP battery. LFP just to remind everyone,
- 9:53that's a cheaper, more durable battery chemistry, right?
- 9:55Yeah, it is a bit less energy dense, but it gets that base
- 9:58price down and even with the smallest battery, it's WLT pay
- 10:02range is a competitive 300 kilometers, which suggests it's
- 10:06super efficient. And it has the biggest boot of
- 10:08all of them at 435 liters. By a mile, they are all in on
- 10:13practicality. What about the high performance
- 10:15versions? This gets even more interesting.
- 10:17There's a high end ID polo coming with 155 kilowatt motor
- 10:23and a bigger 52 kWh NMC battery. So.
- 10:26More power, more range. A lot more.
- 10:28It's priced higher around 35,000, but it gets 450
- 10:32kilometers of WLTP range. That easily beats the Renault
- 10:35Fives 412. And the charging speed.
- 10:38This is a key differentiator. The VW will charge at 1.6
- 10:41kilowatt hours per minute. The Renault and Mini Ace Man are
- 10:44stuck at 1.1. That means the VW is adding
- 10:47range over 40% faster. That is a massive advantage.
- 10:50OK, so let's try to wrap this up.
- 10:52Looking at the cars on sale right now, the Renault 5 is the
- 10:55winner of that three-way test. It is best to drive best
- 10:57interior, best tech. It's the most complete package.
- 11:00But the BYD is a really compelling alternative.
- 11:02Faster charging. Surprise performance.
- 11:05And better real world range. It's a very strong contender.
- 11:08The Citroen sadly comes in last. Poor efficiency and slow
- 11:12charging really hurt it. But.
- 11:13The big picture here is that VWID polo.
- 11:17It signals a huge shift. It does.
- 11:20VW is realizing that for EVs to go mainstream, they need to be
- 11:23practical, easy to use replacements for petrol cars,
- 11:26not weird science experiments. That focus on space, traditional
- 11:30controls and strong performance numbers, it's a huge threat to
- 11:34the Renault Fi's momentum heading into 2026.
- 11:36The choice for buyers is about to get very interesting.
- 11:39It's charm and driving fun versus pure straightforward
- 11:43utility. So that's the question for you,
- 11:45the listener, to think about When these cars land, does VW's
- 11:49return to basic space practicality win out over the
- 11:52style of the Renault or the surprise value of the Bydi?
- 11:55Think the key take away from all this is that the affordable EV
- 11:57battle is complex. You have to really focus on what
- 12:00matters for your life. Don't just look at the price
- 12:02tag. And here's a final thought for
- 12:03you to take into the new year. What's the overlooked feature
- 12:07that's going to become the next big thing?
- 12:09For example, the sources mentioned the BYD has a six year
- 12:12warranty. That's double what Renault and
- 12:14Citroen offer. Is that kind of long term Peace
- 12:18of Mind going to be the deciding factor for people in 2026?
- 12:22Something to think about. It's a great point as we close
- 12:24out the year on this December 31st.
- 12:27Thank you for diving deep with us.
- 12:28May 2026 be a year of fast charging, clear thinking and
- 12:33smooth rides for all of you. Happy New Year.