Latest / Iconoclasting / EP 03 - Iconoclasting with Caroline Benefield
Transcript
- Sarah Smith: Hey, this is Sarah Smith we are on Iconoclasting. Thank you so much for joining us. And today we have with us Caroline Benefield our digital marketing consultant from Southern Grit. Caroline, do you want to introduce yourself a little bit? Tell us what you're all about. Caroline Benefield: Like Sarah said, my name is Caroline Benefield. I am the owner and founder of Southern Grid Digital. We are a boutique digital marketing firm that focuses on small businesses, creatives, and entrepreneurs making marketing efficient and simple for you to execute. Our goal is to demystify the world of digital marketing because it can be overwhelming, it can be stressful. You're getting a million different opinions from a million different directions. And we try to give you a roadmap forward to make sure that you're able to grow and scale your business and that your marketing can grow and scale with you. Sarah Smith: I love that. And I love the services you provide. And to be candid, I've known you for over 10 years and ⁓ you are so steadfast in everything that you recommend. you're one of, not only are you one of my closest friends, but you're also one of my favorite people to go to and part of my personal board of directors. So I'm so excited that you could do this today. Yes. Pictures to follow. Caroline Benefield: Remember being a bridesmaid in your wedding and getting to celebrate that. At some point that dress disappeared in a moving purge, but I think that's one of my favorite bridesmaids dresses that I've ever worn. It's the only one where a zipper hasn't like broken or gotten stuck for me. So I take that as good luck and a sign of our long lasting friendship. Sarah Smith: That's it. ⁓ so Caroline, tell me how did you get started? What was you, did you have like a non-traditional pathway into what you're doing? Tell me everything. Caroline Benefield: I did have a, I would say non-traditional pathway into marketing. So my first big girl job was cleaning kennels at the Atlantic Humane Society. And it was what I needed at the time. It was stable. was my first job that had benefits, PTO, all those fun things. And I made $10 an hour. And back in 2012, you could make that work. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Caroline Benefield: And then I moved up into an adoption counselor position there, so helping people match with the right dog or cat for them. during that period, the development and marketing team realized that I could write and that I could write persuasively and effectively. So they started asking me to help them with programmatic portions of ⁓ grant applications. Sarah Smith: ⁓ interesting. Caroline Benefield: So I moved into doing that and it was infrequent, but it was enough for me to then move into an actual fundraising job at the Leukemia and Lymphoma Society. That was very much a frontline fundraising role, getting schools to participate in crowdfunding. But I started learning the basics of digital marketing there, making sure that we were getting information out to schools. I was putting together e-blasts I was putting together marketing materials for events and at that point I really thought I was going to go into special events as my career. Sarah Smith: So did you do, okay, first of all, did you name any of the animals at the Humane Society? Caroline Benefield: that was more on our admission side, but we would submit lists and usually groups when we came in, we would give them all a theme name. So we did 2000's rappers at one point. So we had Lil Wayne, had Lil Jon, all of the littles because they were little baby puppies. Yeah, so I participated in some of the naming, but... Sarah Smith: area. Yeah, yeah. Caroline Benefield: It was mostly being like, wouldn't this be a fun group idea? Sarah Smith: Yes, yeah, they're always like the boy bands and shits Greek has been the recent trend I saw of like when that was big. And my other question is, did you study, what did you study in college? Caroline Benefield: Yeah. I did the choose your own adventure major. So I did integrated studies. That's because when I was 19, I thought I was going to be a nurse. And then I took organic chemistry, which is one of the required classes. It was the weed out class and I got weeded. It didn't help that I had a professor who lectured very monotone at 9 a.m. about carbon chains. But yeah, I thought I was going to be a nurse. So then I had to figure out how to use all of those nursing prerequisite credits. Sarah Smith: you Caroline Benefield: and not add semesters of work on to school. So I ended up doing an interdisciplinary studies degree from Kennesaw State University with a focus in sociology and specifically medical sociology. So I did some undergraduate research about, actually, this was a pivotal point in me becoming interested in marketing. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Caroline Benefield: I did undergraduate research and presented at the Georgia Public Health Association Conference on marketing from cancer institutions and how that affected perceptions. In particular, this was 2010s. And so there was a lot of power of positive thinking, pop psychology out there. And now we have entire teams in the healthcare space to help people who are terminal deal with Sarah Smith: meeting. Hmm. Caroline Benefield: death. We have death doulas now. ⁓ Sarah Smith: Yes, yeah, it's a very interesting concept and I think one that's actually really needed. Caroline Benefield: Yes, but this marketing in early 2010s was very much geared towards we can prolong your life and then you look at the fine print and it's the average prolonged life is six to eight weeks. Sarah Smith: Yeah, and then you also have to factor in quality of life. Yeah, so that's tough. ⁓ Caroline Benefield: And it correlated with medical professionals being afraid to tell someone, you are terminal. There is nothing we can do. So I did ⁓ qualitative analysis. It's the same framework that Brene Brown uses. I clearly did it at a much lower level as a senior in college versus a PhD student. But it was fascinating ⁓ and really has shaped a lot of my values in the marketing world. ⁓ Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. So like when you talk about values in the marketing world, what does that mean for you? Because as somebody that I know exceptionally little about marketing, right? I know some things, but some of it is like, tell me what are values? What are things that like maybe you go against in what's typical? Caroline Benefield: Yeah, so the biggest thing is I'll talk actual brand values and I will talk strategic values. I have a top one for each with brand values. there is an element of trust that needs to be built. I don't mind a marketing gimmick ⁓ here and there. I did direct mail marketing for a tier one research institution for five years and did email marketing with them and social media marketing. ⁓ Really an omni-channel approach, including phone and text. And sometimes you need something to get someone to open your email, open your letter, ⁓ those kinds of gimmicks, ⁓ freebies and promo items, those all have a place. Where I take issue is manipulating the wording around your data and results to make it appear like you can provide results you can't. Sarah Smith: That's fair. That's a good, that's a you know, ⁓ line in the sand as it were. Caroline Benefield: Yeah. Yeah, marketing should build trust in what you can do. It should not build a facade that you're Superman or Superwoman and you can do anything on any timeline. And I have had to tell direct reports in the past, hey, this is not something that can be accomplished on this timeline. Or I've had doctors come to me and say, ⁓ well, can't I just fundraise for this for my research lab and I have to say this is a pet project. No. You people think that they are giving to this specific research and this is not closely related enough for that to work. You'll have to go talk to your finance team. So that's one of my hard lines in this end. And then strategically, my biggest value is we overcomplicate marketing for most people. And this is from the small business end. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Yeah. Caroline Benefield: all the way up to again, tier one research institution, massive employer. A lot of the buzzwords around marketing are around innovation and creativity and they're, of course you want to be innovative and creative, but not without the fundamentals in place. And even large corporations in a lot of cases, aren't taking a look at the fundamentals. Sarah Smith: That's a really good point. Cause I, I also do that in my work when I'm working with clients is organizations or individuals when I'm helping them understand like, how are we removing friction from their organizations, the drag, their lives in general, you know, what are the foundational pieces you have to have? And it comes from playing softball, right? And having my dad drill with me all the time, the fundamentals, you know, you have to be to catch a ball, throw a ball. Caroline Benefield: Mm-hmm. Sarah Smith: You know, you have a, you just have to practice, right? Yeah. So I love that you mentioned that. Thank you. Caroline Benefield: Mm-hmm. Yeah, absolutely. And I love what you said about removing friction because that is one of the things I want to be able to do in the digital marketing space. There's a lot of noise. There's a lot of friction. There are a lot of tools that say that they're going to help, but they don't necessarily work with the other tool that has said it's going to help. And then suddenly you are, you know, hours deep on the back end of a site trying to figure out how these pieces connect. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Caroline Benefield: And I want to save people that time or help them unravel that spider web of what should be an interconnected ecosystem is in fact, trapping them into a box. But with the fundamentals to grow your business and your marketing, your marketing should be simple, repeatable and testable. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Caroline Benefield: And if you are drastically overhauling your marketing strategy or taking a new marketing course or trying a new approach every month or every quarter, you're never getting any real tangible evidence of what you need to do next, of who your core audience is and what they actually want. Sarah Smith: Yeah. And I, I will say working with you, you've made that really simple for me of like, here's what we're doing. Not only that, but we're also testing baseline metrics. We're setting that up to see what's working, what's not. And you've been very clear, like this will take time to build and you're not going to have metrics right away because you haven't been doing anything. So that's been really helpful. And just, you know, you're saying demystifying it. really are. You're definitely, you know, walking the talk. Caroline Benefield: Thank you. I really appreciate that. That means a lot because that is the core identity of Southern Grid Digital is demystifying the digital marketing space. And we're recording this in January. And my social media feed is inundated with marketing professionals saying, take my course, participate in this 30 day challenge to grow your Instagram following to 10,000 people. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Caroline Benefield: that doesn't work for most people. For most of us, marketing is a grind and marketing feels boring. It's not exciting to people who aren't doing it. To me, it's incredibly exciting and fun and fills my creative well. For a lot of people, they look at it and say, isn't this basically the same thing that we sent out a month ago? And yes, yes it is. There's a reason for that. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Yeah. Because it's, you know, what is it? takes, I think research actually shows it's something more like 21 times for people to like have something and have it make sense and like register with them. And it's not even seven times like I think it used to be. It's because we're in that age of instant gitification. Caroline Benefield: Mm-hmm. Sarah Smith: know, everything is at your fingertips and how are there so much noise because everybody's trying to be present in whatever space you're in now. It's very interesting. Caroline Benefield: Okay. Yeah, as our attention economy continues to shrink, we're going to see that people need the same message over and over and over again with very simple changes. Maybe it's you change the contrast of your post. Maybe it is changing up the case study that you're sharing or changing out your freebie offer. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Caroline Benefield: every six months or so. But for the most part, people need to say the same thing, see the same thing over and over and over again to identify your message with your brand. Sarah Smith: Yeah. And it kind of goes into like, I was an English major also at KSU, Kinsos State. Woo woo, go Owls. I know got a, my husband gave me a sweatshirt that says, who do you want it? It's so cute. ⁓ and so our beloved Owls. Caroline Benefield: Woo! Girls, do you? Fantastic. Sarah Smith: Wondrous. yeah. So how did you get into like moving into doing your own thing? Because you're the owner, operator, founder, CEO, head marketing person. I mean, you're everything, right? So how did you move from that and from like the nonprofit corporate wherever you were into this? Caroline Benefield: Yeah, that is, I will warn listeners right now, it's a bit of a loaded story. It involves, it does involve a grief journey. So if you are in the middle of one right now, come back and listen to this later, be gentle with yourself. From the beginning of 2022 until the middle of 2023, I lived about a decade of life in 18 months. both professionally and personally. So at the beginning of 2022, I got engaged, which was so exciting. Wonderful. I love my husband. He's great. We bought a house. I took on interim executive director duties of the university marketing team. I sold my condo. We moved in together. I started, yep. Sarah Smith: Yes, teaching is hard. Caroline Benefield: started living with kids. Sarah Smith: Ooh, yeah, that's hard too. Caroline Benefield: was a big change. And then just as all that was starting to settle down, my dad died. And I crawled myself out of the grief hole. He had been going downhill for a while. That one was not, you know, it's painful to lose a parent, but I had been grieving him for about five years as he had gone downhill. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Caroline Benefield: So I continued working my university marketing job. We are planning our wedding. Everything is looking good. We're going to have a small wedding, but with like 50 to 60 of our closest friends and family. I was actually going to get married at the building that I worked in at the time, which was fun. I told my CMO that I was going to take getting ready pictures in his office. He was like, yeah, do it. He was great. And... I ended up getting really, really burned out. was on every task force you could possibly be on. I had implemented a new telephone calling system and stood it up on my own. ⁓ I was still taking on some executive director duties. I was splitting them with my co-director. I was having to start traveling again and I got burned out. And right as I was burning out, my mom died unexpectedly nine months after my dad. And they were divorced. lived, they both lived in Georgia, but they both lived more than an hour outside of Atlanta. I'm an only child. I was dealing with two estates, multiple hours apart from each other. So I took some FMLA leave. And during that time, I got some, it just, wasn't enough time to Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Caroline Benefield: deal with everything I had dealt with for the last 18 months. My husband and I ended up getting married with just his best friend officiating on our back porch because I wasn't going to have to deal with planning a wedding on top of everything. So we canceled our big wedding. I say big, but we canceled our wedding. And I decided, my therapist told me creativity was a great way to deal with grief. So I... Sarah Smith: Absolutely. Caroline Benefield: wrote a book. wrote a romance novel. kind cozy fantasy vibes, small town Georgia. And I decided I was going to write a full series about this and I did that. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Caroline Benefield: During that time, I attended some conferences for fellow authors. I ended up presenting on Email Marketing 101, which was really how do you set up your email marketing in a way that is going to keep you legally compliant. Sarah Smith: Wow. Like you presented at the author conferences. ⁓ wow. How funny. Cause I didn't even think those two go together, but obviously there's marketing involved with publishing. Caroline Benefield: Bye. Mm-hmm. There is so much marketing and in fact, even this is a presentation geared towards people publishing their books independently, but at this point, even the large publishing houses are expecting authors to have their own newsletters, to have their own social media presence, to have a marketing plan in place. ⁓ A friend of mine recently hit the USA Today bestseller list and very exciting. She hit top 10 on the list, ⁓ which is incredible. I am so proud of her. She worked so hard for it. And a lot of that is she has built a reliable, valuable social presence. Sarah Smith: ⁓ my gosh. Yeah. Yeah. I will say like I follow my favorite authors and as soon as they release something, I'm all over it. Yeah. Caroline Benefield: Mm-hmm. Yeah. So I was presenting to authors and I started getting requests from various writing groups around the country to join them for paid speaking opportunities to present to their writing groups. I presented to Maine Romance Writers, Georgia Romance Writers, a few other groups. And from there, I started getting questions about, do you provide additional services? Can I? do a consult with you and that was when I was like, okay, I need to, I need to spin this off into its own thing. And that's when I put together Southern Grit Digital. ⁓ At first I was focused only on authors, only on consultations so that I could still write my series. Series is complete, series is out. And I realized that, ⁓ right, I really like marketing. It's a lot of. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Caroline Benefield: fun for me. I love working with clients. I love seeing things click with my clients when they understand the why of what I'm proposing and why their roadmap looks the way it does. And I was like, okay, I want to expand this beyond just some here and there consults and initial packages. And that's when I spun this off into its own LLC and started Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Caroline Benefield: putting together website, more extensive B sheets, all of that. that's how I ended up here is I would not be here had my parents not died. I would not be here if I didn't have a very supportive husband who understands that I'm building a business. And that means that we have had to adjust our lifestyle a bit. ⁓ Sarah Smith: Mmm. Mm-hmm. Caroline Benefield: I'm ⁓ very grateful in the end to have ended up here. And also I recognize that it has been a very emotionally draining journey that I am still crawling my way out of. So I also try to provide very compassionate services to people who are dealing with burnout and overwhelm because I've been there. Sarah Smith: Yes. Yeah. You feel like you have to do everything all at once, especially if you're redesigning your building, your building, your business, or ⁓ maybe you are redesigning a building, like redesigning, relaunching, whatever it is. It feels like you do have to do a hundred things at once. And it's so helpful to have people like you who can take some of that pressure off too. Like for instance, we just launched my newsletter and it was so extraordinarily difficult and that if I did not have you, I would have just called it a day. Caroline Benefield: a lot of people, in particular the compliance side of digital marketing is much more complicated than people realize. yeah, that is one of the parts that is the most mystifying, I think. Sarah Smith: Yeah. And it's one of the things that's the least amount of fun. Yeah. Yeah. Caroline Benefield: Mm-hmm. And let's hear me. In which case, I'm like, let's go into the back end. Let's figure all of this out. Let's get the redirects in place. Let's get all your authentications done. My dad has spent most of his career as a systems architect. So translating business demands into programmer language. And when I was Sarah Smith: Yeah. Caroline Benefield: in large scale corporate marketing, I figured out I was also very good at that. And so my dad, up until he died, would make fun of me that I had told him I was never going to be a data analyst. I was never going to do any of that. And he was like, you understand you're basically doing the same job as me, just in a different industry, right? But I love it. Sarah Smith: That's so funny. Parents are home. Yeah. That's great. Well, what are three things that you would tell our listeners today about their personal brands, their business brands, about any of their marketing? What's like the top three things you would tell them? Caroline Benefield: My first tip is figure out your thesis statement. Sarah, we went through this exercise recently. ⁓ If you look at your logo, I want you to think of a three to seven word tagline for that logo. That is going to tell you a lot about your audience. My tagline is demystifying digital marketing. That tells me exactly who my audience is. It's people that want to be promoting their business. They want to be scaling their business. And they're overwhelmed or stuck. by all of the complications and roadblocks that come up with establishing a digital marketing presence. So figure out your thesis statement. And from that, I want you to make a list of five characteristics that you distill from that thesis statement of who your audience is. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Caroline Benefield: So that would be my first tip. And my second tip would be tie every piece of marketing back to your core audience. What is providing value to them? What is showing them that you're a human being? Because in the attention economy we have now, people are sold to every time they open their phones, every time they click on an email. How are you going to show them that you are a real person who understands their real problem? Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Yeah, exactly. Caroline Benefield: And that's going to come through storytelling, that is going to come through sharing the messy pieces of your work, as vulnerable and uncomfortable as that is. People want to see you be vulnerable. They don't want an all-knowing, perfect coach or consultant. They want someone who can say, I've been there, and this is how I'm going to get you through it. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah, it's the authenticity piece. Caroline Benefield: Mm-hmm. And I've actually been seeing a lot of pushback against that online from people selling marketing courses. And I think some of them are very well-intentioned. Hi, Lula. I think some of them are very well-intentioned. And I think some of them are less well-intentioned, and they are attacking the authenticity angle because that's harder to teach. It's easier to teach someone how to use buzzwords and how to ⁓ Sarah Smith: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Caroline Benefield: Use gimmicks. It's a lot harder to teach the real piece. The final piece of advice is keep it simple. If you are overwhelmed right now and you aren't in a place to bring on someone to guide you, pick one social media platform. Look at those five characteristics and say, where are they going to be? So Sarah, we looked at yours and we said, they're going to be on LinkedIn. Pick one social media platform. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Caroline Benefield: Post every other day. You don't have to post every day. Post, I would say if you're going to post three times a week, post one that is one of the messy or real moments. Post one thing that tells a story about how somebody in a similar messy moment got through it, how you helped them through it. And make only one post that really pushes any kind of paid content you have. Free content, great, push it as much as you want, but limit how much you're posting about your paid opportunities. That sounds really counterintuitive. The people who are going to engage with you are going to see, as they see the value in who you are and how you are navigating situations and in particular, how you are navigating your screw ups and the mess of building a business or scaling a business. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Caroline Benefield: the more they're gonna see that value in paying you to do it. And they're not going to feel like all you wanna do is sell to them. identify your thesis statement. Keep it very, very simple. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Caroline Benefield: And be authentic and real. Don't try to present a perfect veneer. That's going to backfire. And yeah, those would be my top three tips for the digital marketing economy we are in right now. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Yeah, well, that's great. Thank you so much for coming on today. What is, where can people reach you? Caroline Benefield: Yeah, so you can reach me at my email is caroline at southern great digital.com. And if you are hearing this and you know that you want to book an intro call with me and see how we can build a roadmap for your marketing, you can book time directly with me on southern great digital.com. Sarah Smith: Perfect. All right. Well, thank you so much and I cannot wait to talk with you again.