Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / A World without Borders: Reflections on Humanity's Dividing Lines
Transcript
- 0:02Three The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheist this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking feels much more happiness, truth, beauty, and wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is The Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Said andrews Oh. I've
- 0:57been a bad example. I've been a bad boy. I'm a fugitive from
- 1:02justice. I'm lawless. Here's the story. I was coming back from a
- 1:11couple of tour stops in Texas. I'd spoken in Dallas, Texas. Then
- 1:15I went down to Houston and left on Sunday around one o'clock PM. From
- 1:21Houston Oasis, I was just going to drive all the way home, and
- 1:25I am not making this up. I'm not kidding. I was a great
- 1:30driver. I drove like two miles an hour over the speed limit all the
- 1:34way home, like nine hours. I obeyed the law. Okay, and
- 1:40one of the reasons is, and I got to admit this. A few
- 1:42weeks ago, I got pulled over for going a little bit fast and I
- 1:47was given a warning. Now, I haven't had a speeding ticket in decades.
- 1:52My driving record is immaculate. Okay, it's perfect, and so I
- 1:57didn't want to screw that up. So I'm driving the limit, got my
- 2:01audio book in, I'm just cruising right along, and eight hours into my
- 2:07nine hour drive, I end up going through this little one horse town called
- 2:14Henrietta in Oklahoma. Henrietta, the highway goes through and there's a stoplight,
- 2:21and then you go through this small section of highway or whatever. And I'm
- 2:23doing sixty five. Stop at the stop light, and then I cruise back
- 2:29up to sixty five. Okay, no harm, no foul. But I
- 2:34was listening to my audio book and apparent light didn't see these little signs and
- 2:39they didn't say sixty five for no reason on a stretch of highway near nothing,
- 2:46I mean, there's nothing got highway. It said forty five. And
- 2:53lo and behold in my rear view there are the police lights. Shit right,
- 2:59shit, nine o'clock at night. I'm tired, I'm cranky, I
- 3:04want to get home. I pull over and this small town police officer,
- 3:09you know, this Beauford Tea pusser. By the way, that's a seventies
- 3:14reference. Bauford Tea Pusser was a real police officer. It's a real shaff.
- 3:20Beauford Tea Pusser pulls me over and he walks up to the window and
- 3:23he's like, license and insurance please, And I was like, oh my
- 3:29god, I don't even know what the speed limit had been, right,
- 3:34I thought it was sixty five and I'd gone just a little bit over.
- 3:38The word speed trap going off in my mind. But I also know better
- 3:43than to try to weasel my way out of whatever's about to happen. Right,
- 3:46cops, they've heard every story, every excuse in the book. I'm
- 3:51late for work, my wife is pregnant, someone says, in a crisis,
- 3:54blah blah blah. I mean, why bother right? I mean,
- 3:58the best thing to do is just and over your stuff, own it,
- 4:00and hopefully you'll get some grace. So he takes my stuff and he goes
- 4:05back, and I can tell I'm getting a ticket because of the length of
- 4:10time it takes him to come back to the car finally comes back and he
- 4:15says, you realize you were going sixty seven and a forty five. Now
- 4:21I'm doing the math on that. I think over twenty miles an hour over
- 4:27the speed limit isn't just speeding. I think I think they can call that
- 4:30reckless driving. It's like I bumped her down to fifty five and a forty
- 4:36five. Best I can do for you. Here's your ticket, and I'm
- 4:42just looking at this thing. Thanks officer. Slow down out there now tonight,
- 4:47yes sir, yes, sir, and then I drive away. So
- 4:53for one quarter mile stretch in a nine hour journey, I a speed sign
- 5:01and got caught. And now I have a ticket, and I'm just pissed.
- 5:10And the writing on the ticket is like a carbon copy. I can't
- 5:13read anything. I can't read what is there a fine? Is there an
- 5:15amount? And then there's a court date, which I thought said this.
- 5:21Apparently it did not. So I had mailed my fine one hundred and forty
- 5:28nine dollars to the town of Henrietta. And you are welcome, okay,
- 5:32Henrietta. You just enjoy that money. You go buy everybody some donuts and
- 5:38do whatever you're going to do with this speed trap revenue that I have sent
- 5:42your way. Okay, But the next day I receive in the mail a
- 5:46letter that says you have missed your court date. You failed to appear before
- 5:54the judge. Holy shit, I'm now in content to court. What it's
- 6:03just been a few days. I'm lawless. I'm now a fugitive from justice.
- 6:09The men in dark sunglasses going to show up at my door and they're
- 6:12gonna hold me away, like the town of Henriette is going to send somebody
- 6:15an hour into Tulsa, Oklahoma to come get me. But you know,
- 6:18curse, your mind goes to places like what does this look like on my
- 6:23record? What are the consequences? I call the court clerk and I'm like,
- 6:26look, you should have a check with my name on it. I
- 6:30just don't want the ca stop to show up and do something to me,
- 6:36and I don't want anything bad on my record. And she laughed and she's
- 6:41like, you're fine, honey. I love it when small town people call
- 6:43you honey. It's like going into a to a little restaurant, you know,
- 6:46a little truck stop restaurant. They call you, hey, darling,
- 6:48can I get you some pancakes. There's just something so endearing about that.
- 6:51I just love it. So she's like, don't worry about it, honey,
- 6:56you know, give me the ticket number. I said, don't worry
- 6:59about not being able to read the writing. That always happens these police officers.
- 7:02Their writings just terrible. Don't you sweat it? Oh no, look,
- 7:05you've got a zero balance. We got your money, and so that
- 7:10letter goes out automatically. And don't you just throw that in the trash,
- 7:14dear, don't you worry about it. You are just fine. In fact,
- 7:17we don't report our tickets to the state, so it won't go on
- 7:21your record. Okay. And I've have two minds on this. One is
- 7:27my record remains clean. The second thought is, now I know this is
- 7:31a speed trap, right because it's not about the law. It's not about
- 7:39trying to make me a better driver and keep me in the straight and narrow
- 7:42under the limit. No, this is about one hundred and forty nine dollars,
- 7:45that's what that's about. So anyway, I just I'm walking around all
- 7:49the time telling people I'm lawless, fugitive from justice. You know, I
- 7:55can't be governed, I can't be contained. That's been the story I've been
- 8:00telling lately. Just an interesting and enjoyable anecdote to start the conversation today.
- 8:07What else is going on? Oh, here's another anecdote. It is.
- 8:15It's an example of how I'm not always the man I wish I could be.
- 8:20And I'm going to throw myself at your feet. I'm gonna throw myself
- 8:22at your mercy and the hopes that you will give me the grace and mercy
- 8:26that the Henry at a police officer did not. Because I screwed up.
- 8:31We went to go see Oppenheimer at the Imax. I'm not going to give
- 8:33you any spoilers here at all, so you're safe. Oppenheimer. The new
- 8:37Christopher Nolan film starring Silly and Murphy is brilliant. It is so thick and
- 8:45smart and challenging and amazing. I've never seen anything like it. Different than
- 8:50what I expected. I thought it was going to be more of a kind
- 8:52of a special effects showcase about bombs, you know, knowing Christopher Nolan,
- 8:58but it was really more a political thriller with so many gears in the machine,
- 9:03so many moving parts. I'm gonna have to see it again, maybe
- 9:05twice. More just to catch everything that was happening. But it was a
- 9:11big deal. So there are four of us, took my family, and
- 9:13after the tickets, Imax tickets, and popcorn, we're talking over one hundred
- 9:18dollars, so it's kind of a big deal. And we're in this packed
- 9:22matinee theater and the trailers are playing, and I noticed the couple next to
- 9:28me, the man and a woman, and they're both pulling their phones out
- 9:33of their pockets and talking to each other. Now, I let this slide
- 9:41during the trailers, even though you know how I feel about people talking and
- 9:46texting in a theater. You've heard my rant about social contracts and how the
- 9:50sign says don't be discourdious, don't talk or text, and people do it
- 9:54anyway. So I was already ramped up. The movie begins. It's a
- 10:00critical first ten minutes, as all of the pieces start coming into place.
- 10:05You really got to pay attention in a Christopher Nolan film. And during that
- 10:11first ten minutes, to my right, this man and this woman continue to
- 10:16yank their cell phones out of their pockets and start talking to each other so
- 10:22loud that I notice even Natalie is distracted. She's looking over at them.
- 10:26I'm looking over at them, And before I realized I was doing it,
- 10:31I leaned over and I said, hey, hey, stop talking. And
- 10:37this man, kind of a stocky bearded guy, looked at me and he
- 10:41said, why did't you mind your own business and shut the fuck off?
- 10:46And I said, why don't you shut the fuck up? Oh my god,
- 10:56I just I just said it. Before I realized, I said,
- 11:00what, you shut the fuck up? And immediately Natalie is like, you
- 11:03know, she's sort of pushing me back, and his wife's pushing It's not
- 11:07like we were going to go to blows, but we were definitely having words
- 11:09right there in the middle of a dark theater. It was so I mean,
- 11:13I have confronted people before, but this is the antithesis of the kind
- 11:20of behavior that I have been trying to exemplify in my life, which is
- 11:24being the adult in the room right being a de escalator. And I was
- 11:30guilty of all the things I've been condemning. And I sat there and I'm
- 11:33sure both of us were just ramped up. I'm sure he was over there
- 11:37steaming and I was over here steaming. And so the movie goes on for
- 11:41another half hour, Natalie, I'm sure wanted to crawl into her chair.
- 11:45I'd embarrassed her and made her weird. And then he gets up to go
- 11:48to the bathroom. Now I found out later that Natalie at this moment was
- 11:54concerned he was going to the parking lot to his car to get a gun
- 11:58and come back and kill me. I didn't know that at the time,
- 12:03but if he got up and he went out to the bathroom, I got
- 12:07up and I followed him out, and I could see him. He was
- 12:13walking down toward the men's restroom and I was behind him, and I walked
- 12:18into the restroom and there he is, and he's standing against the wall at
- 12:22the urinal and I was over near the sink, and I let him see
- 12:26me. And the first thing I said was, Man, I'm so sorry
- 12:31for blowing up at you in the theater. So I was just I screwed
- 12:35up. And he smiled and he said, oh, don't worry about it,
- 12:39you know, it's it's no big deal. It's and I said no,
- 12:43and then he said, well, the thing is, my daughter was
- 12:46in a car wreck. And so we were getting text and we were trying
- 12:50to figure out if you know what was going on, and I said,
- 12:54you know, I'm sorry to hear that, but honestly, there's no excuse
- 12:58no matter what you were talking about. I'm really sorry for my behavior.
- 13:01I totally screwed up. And he's like, well, I'm sorry too,
- 13:05you know, I I overreacted. And then there was a pause and he
- 13:09looked at me and he goes, you know, we're guys, me big
- 13:16man, get a thing. And so I sort of sagued over and I'm
- 13:22standing at the wall in another few moments passed and I said, you know,
- 13:28I apologized at the urinal. This is awkward, and we both busted
- 13:33out laughing again. And so we ended up back out in the lobby and
- 13:37we walked into the theater. He held the door for me and I both
- 13:43we both went back to our chairs, and Natalie just looked at me like,
- 13:48what the hell just happened? And I whispered in her ear we are
- 13:52best friends now, and she smiled, and everybody relaxed and we enjoyed the
- 14:00rest of the movie. But I I was driving home, I really felt
- 14:03a sense of shame. What's that about? You know, yes, they
- 14:09should have gone to the lobby, okay, but I didn't know what the
- 14:13context was. You know, they were going through a crisis. They probably
- 14:16weren't thinking about anybody else. They were thinking about their kid who could have
- 14:18been injured in a car wreck. There was something going on with their family.
- 14:22And my first thought was, you are inconveniencing me. I am watching
- 14:26the movie. And then I just went from zero to crazy. I just
- 14:31blew it. I just became what I despise. And so as we were
- 14:37driving home, we were kind of laughing about it. But I told Natalie,
- 14:41I'm like, you know, I know I was wrong, and I'm
- 14:43sorry I embarrassed you, and and you know, I hope you'll allow it.
- 14:48I can kind of grow through failure here and that I'll do better.
- 14:50I'm gonna make a commitment to try to just be better next time. And
- 14:54she was laughing, and I said, you know, I can be an
- 14:56asshole, but I'm also a good man, and she's like, you are
- 15:01a good man. It's okay, It's okay, yea. So it was
- 15:05a lot over a little, but it's still something I kind of blush about.
- 15:09What's wrong with me? Why did I go there? Why did it
- 15:13bother me so much? Why did I turn on this guy so quickly.
- 15:16I've been thinking about that kind of thing. No, I didn't know him.
- 15:20He was the stranger, he was the other. And then I'm watching
- 15:22the film Oppenheimer, which is rooted in the Second World War, And on
- 15:28the larger philosophical note, I'm thinking about the human desire and tendency, especially
- 15:35by men, to want to dominate and take over the world. Right,
- 15:39I mean, Hitler wanted world domination. Japan's emperor Hirohito wanted world domination at
- 15:48that time. Right, these were people who were willing to blow up the
- 15:52world, to consolidate power, to procure resources, and dominate everybody and everything.
- 16:00And I keep thinking about who drew the border lines. We see the
- 16:06nationalist here in the United States, we're better than everybody else, We're superior
- 16:11to everybody else. And once you cross this line, which was drawn here
- 16:15at this river or at this point, you know this geographical location, once
- 16:19you take a step over that, now you are in inferior territory with inferior
- 16:25people. They matter less. Well. Who drew the line, like some
- 16:30human beings, some subjective person drew that line, Who said the line can't
- 16:36be moved or changed or expanded or erased. Oh, there he goes,
- 16:42there he goes. He's going all John Lennon on us. You know,
- 16:45imagine a world, imagine Yeah, Okay, somebody somewhere took a sharpie and
- 16:56said, this land is my land? Why is the gospel? Why is
- 17:00that sacred? I just don't get it, this tribal thing. I mean,
- 17:04I get the benefit of tribes. I think I'm not opposed to having
- 17:08nations, but this idea that the lines are sacrosanct and that makes us superior
- 17:15and everybody else inferior. And then the dominionists want to go and they want
- 17:19to not just own what we have here and sign the line. They want
- 17:22to go and own everything outside the line. They want everything in this block
- 17:26and that group, and this continent whatever. We are a planet that's been
- 17:33marked up on a map by somebody somewhere, and we never stopped a question.
- 17:37Who drew the line, and why would it make us more important than
- 17:42somebody else. Now I was a Christian nationalist. I felt that we are
- 17:48superior more than anybody else. God has picked us right, and we are
- 17:52to go out and convert the world and make everybody like us. But when
- 17:56I came out of the faith. It was more like, we are all
- 17:59brothers and sisters, We are all the human condition. I love my country,
- 18:03but it doesn't mean I love anybody else less. Why would it have
- 18:07to be binary? Why does it have to be a zero sum game?
- 18:10Why can't I advocate for my neighbors on this part of the planet but not
- 18:15cast out or vilify those who might be my further neighbors outside the fence.
- 18:21And what if I was to take down the fence and we could all share
- 18:25the planet together as human brothers and sisters. That's a fantasy of mine.
- 18:30And watching Oppenheimer and the development of the Adam bomb to try to stop world
- 18:37domination by dominators and then all the interworking politics and the power grab going on
- 18:44within the United States just overwhelming. It's just overwhelming, at the very least
- 18:48regarding one of the messages behind Oppenheimer's I'm sick and tired of the dominionists trying
- 18:53to stomp out the rest of us. Let's take some call, but first
- 19:00short break, be right back. Glad you're here, Thanks for listening,
- 19:11Thanks for your supports. Commercial free show. You get two days early if
- 19:17you become a patron Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrews to the switchboard. We
- 19:26go, Alex, are you there? I am what is on your mind?
- 19:33Rebellion and reacting to pretty much what you just said. I've reached the
- 19:40point where not acting is causing harm. And I was living in Rochester Hills
- 19:48in a trailer park, Rochester Hills, Michigan, and my trailer was on
- 19:53a corner with the biggest bus stop in the entire park, basically, and
- 19:59I was seeing kids from elementary all the way to high school getting on and
- 20:03off the bus every day. So I started sitting in my window and just
- 20:07yelling out the window. God and Jesus are made up, just like Santa
- 20:11and the Easter Money. I was telling them, hey, kids, mom
- 20:14and dad have to hate you. Jesus commands it in order for them to
- 20:18follow him. I was putting all kinds of Bible verses out there for kids.
- 20:22I was sending them over to the Atheist Experience, to your Channel,
- 20:26to a lot of channels. Hugo and Jake back when they were doing the
- 20:30Bible Reloaded, it was actually super successful. I had a lot of kids
- 20:36come back privately and talk to me and ask questions and get sources. I
- 20:41know for a fact I turned quite a few kids atheists. Some of the
- 20:45parents moved with their kids out of the park. Some parents showed up at
- 20:48my house and we're circling the signs that I had in my yard, taking
- 20:52pictures and all kinds of craziness. But the words spread and nobody ever got
- 20:57physical with me, and the kids were sharing the information as well. And
- 21:04at the time I was threatened with eviction from the park, I had all
- 21:08kinds of just backlash. Police were called. It was pretty nuts. I've
- 21:15recently moved to Highland, Michigan, into a very Trump supporting park. My
- 21:21neighbor has a Trump flag hanging on his porch. So I'm telling you this
- 21:26to show you that we are making progress in the atheist community. We are
- 21:30waking people up. It's becoming normalized. I went to the office to ask
- 21:37for permission to put signs all over my house with the same Bible verses I
- 21:41used in Rochester Hills, and they said absolutely, you can do that.
- 21:48Years ago in the other park, I was not allowed to do that and
- 21:52was threatened by the park itself. So it's progress that I'm being allowed to
- 21:57have the same freedom my neighbor had, and I'm going to take full advantage
- 22:02of it. I plan to put the signs up this weekend. And there's
- 22:07a lot of kids, especially young girls, living directly on both sides of
- 22:11me. So I've already given a heads up to the women in those houses
- 22:17that I'm going to war against the men. Tell them to keep their hands
- 22:22off our bodies. And I'm going to post all the pro abortion verses and
- 22:27the verse where Jesus commands hatred of one's own children, the verse where Jesus
- 22:33says He's going to make you eat your own sons and daughters, you know,
- 22:37tell the truth about Jesus, that their mom and dad want them to
- 22:40commit their lives too. And it's stuff that's easy to look up in the
- 22:45Bible. Well, I've got what you think. I've got no problem with
- 22:51presenting in a private forum, even your own property, your concerns and condemnations
- 22:56of the religion. But if we were to reverse the streams, and if
- 23:02you were boarding a bus or your kids were getting on a bus, and
- 23:06somebody was nearby screaming out Bible versus and saying you're going to hell, well
- 23:11they're doing that here. They allow that here they allow the churches, even
- 23:15one of them as an IFB church, they allowed them to come in here
- 23:18and propagate their crap. That's what gave me the idea was to counter the
- 23:23lies that the churches are telling and show the truth about what the Bible really
- 23:30says. I would never be one to tell you to not do something that
- 23:33is bringing results. I myself blanche a little bit at the idea of yelling
- 23:41this stuff out at a bus stop, in a public square at children.
- 23:45These are conversations that need to be had. I worry a little bit about
- 23:48the process and the efficacy overall of saying the Old Testament says God wants people
- 23:55to eat babies. The verse may be in there. Oh, that's in
- 23:59Revelation. I know it. Actually it's the Old Testament too, I believe.
- 24:03Yeah, but it's you know, it is interesting, and I think
- 24:07on your own term, certainly on your own property, within the boundaries of
- 24:11your own life, being able to express your lack of faith in any sort
- 24:15of you know, magical other out there, and to condemn the atrocities and
- 24:19scripture. I think those are valid and you have every right to do that.
- 24:23It's been beautiful. I mean, I really thought I was going to
- 24:26get shot at some point, but I haven't. And I'm getting quite a
- 24:32bit of support from the women, which surprises me. It's waking them up
- 24:36too, So just no, we are helping out there. We're doing what
- 24:40we can. I may be weird, but if I wasn't getting good results,
- 24:45I wouldn't keep doing it. So thank you for everything you do.
- 24:49I know you don't encourage necessarily some of the stuff that I do. You
- 24:55and I may stand apart on the process, but I am interested in your
- 24:59story and if you are in fact getting results, and perhaps you can update
- 25:03us on this six months down the way, Okay, I definitely will.
- 25:07All right, hanging there, Alex, appreciate you. What are your thoughts.
- 25:11You're at a bus stop. You know there are a lot of religious
- 25:15kids who are getting on the bus, and you say, read your Old
- 25:19Testament. The Bible says God will burn you, or gay should be executed,
- 25:26or your parents in the Book of Matthew are required to hate their children
- 25:30for the sake of Christ if it comes down to that, because it's all
- 25:33the divine popularity contest, open your eyes, read your Bible, so if
- 25:40someone was shouting that over a parking lot, would that be effective to you?
- 25:44If it's effective to some, why is it effective? What are the
- 25:48ratios and percentages? I think this call brings about a lot of questions.
- 25:52It's not my thing, It's not what I would do, but I am
- 25:56interested in Alex's story and I appreciate her sharing it. Seven zero three,
- 26:03who's this Laura? Laura? Thanks for calling. What's on your mind?
- 26:07Well? First of all, oh, mister Andrews. I have been a
- 26:11fan of your radio show since I was about sixteen, so it's an honor.
- 26:15Thank you, Thank you, and please call me Seth. Mister Andrews
- 26:19just kills a part of my heart because it makes me sound like Methuselah.
- 26:23But you're very kind, you're very good. Go ahead. What do you
- 26:26want to talk about, mister Seth? Go ahead? I just wanted to
- 26:32talk about the issue of borders that you mentioned. I have to politely say
- 26:37that I disagree. I feel that stuff like that exists for a good reason,
- 26:41in both safety wise and in terms of giving people a sense of identity
- 26:47who otherwise might not feel like they really have one. I also have to
- 26:51say in terms of like national identity. And I know that this is a
- 26:55controversial view coming from an atheist, but I'm that actually a fan of the
- 27:00two states system. And I'm also well, first of all, I'm a
- 27:06big advocate for my fellow disabled community, and I feel that the disabled community
- 27:11kind of feels like here in the US, they don't really see us.
- 27:15I feel that we need an Israel of sorts. It's like this, you
- 27:22know how, at least on paper, Israel is seen as the home of
- 27:26the Jewish community. The reservations are seen as something like that for the Native
- 27:30Americans. At least on paper, it's more complicated. But I wonder what
- 27:34it would be like if the disabled community had the option of going somewhere where
- 27:41it's our bodies, ourselves, our laws, ourselves. People without disabilities could
- 27:47obviously live there, but I wonder what it would be like if we had
- 27:52the option of being able to say I'm not an American anymore. I live
- 27:56in whatever country would be specifically founded for people with disabilities. Do you feel
- 28:03like that would cheat the larger, more healthy I would say, more healthy
- 28:07attitude that we are all the human condition. I mean, wouldn't it further
- 28:11marginalized disabled people to lock them away. I mean many people would consider that
- 28:17to be, for lack of a better way of saying it, kind of
- 28:18an island of misfit toys. They would then be able to brush them off,
- 28:22lock them away. They would be othered. Isn't the goal to help
- 28:27those with disabilities actually be a parts, an equal part of life with the
- 28:32rest of us. Wouldn't that be a more worthy goal than segregation? However,
- 28:37I would also consider it a comfort to know that there would be an
- 28:41option where it's people that actually get us because they are us and we don't
- 28:47have that well, I myself would never try to nullify the perspective of someone
- 28:53who lives with a disability every single day. I think it's yeah, I
- 29:00called the end. I'm autistic. I can't really feel what you have felt.
- 29:03I can't see the world through your eyes. And I understand also the
- 29:10healthy benefit of tribes, you know, the community of people who suffer with
- 29:12cerebral palsy and autism who can get each other, perhaps share a space,
- 29:18support each other. You can pursue common goals to raise awareness, even money
- 29:22for research to help cure or at least treat some issues. I totally understand
- 29:27the benefit the pro social and productive aspects of tribes. I myself struggle a
- 29:33little bit with the idea of people sort of coordinate themselves off away from the
- 29:38rest of us, because I worry that a greater effect beyond the community you
- 29:44might feel is that you would be further cast off and not given the opportunities
- 29:48that we seek for everybody and to share the world equally. I don't know,
- 29:53it's an interesting idea that I've never heard said in that way before.
- 29:57Can you kind of let me chew on that for a while and everybody in
- 30:00the in the listening audience and have some discussion about it. Also, I
- 30:04kind of feel that in terms of disability advocacy, yeah, we have plenty
- 30:10of equivalence to Susan B. Anthony and Marl Luther King, But where our
- 30:14our equivalence to Emmeline Pankhurst and Malcolm X. Sometimes the non disabled majority needs
- 30:22to fear us. I understand why you wouldn't want a blind person with a
- 30:26gun, But wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait,
- 30:29wait on physically do that to fear you? No? No, no answer.
- 30:33Help me understand why would you want someone to fear you? Give me
- 30:37a context for that, because sometimes that's the only way that you can get
- 30:41people's attention. Sometimes you need muscle behind the revolution. And you would support
- 30:48in that context the use of what force and or violence against able lists,
- 30:56so long as as it was within a context of not hurting innocent people and
- 31:02only against those who are like intentionally trying to hurt us. Who would make
- 31:07that determination? Warming of the bastield? But how would you make the determination?
- 31:11Where would the line be drawn? I'm going to commit violence against this
- 31:15person because they are an agent of harm. Who would set the line?
- 31:19Who would determine what harm is specifically? And how would you mean? I'm
- 31:22not sure, but that's why we need a community to know. So a
- 31:27community would decide a guideline a specific someone says this sentence or tries to submit
- 31:33or propos or past this law, they would then be an agent of harm
- 31:37against the disabled, and we would then warrant or condone violence against them.
- 31:44Am I understanding that? Yeah? There are some laws within the US where
- 31:48it's like the early stages of what ke for ended up being I mean,
- 31:53you're not killing us outright admitting to it, but they're making it so well,
- 31:57you might as well say that you want to. You're acting like you
- 32:00wish we weren't here. Do you see it opening the door to a kind
- 32:05of reactive anarchy. People subjectively say you've harmed me. Now I'm going to
- 32:10pull out a baseball bat or a gun or run somebody over in a crowd,
- 32:16justified because I feel subjectively harmed. I'm not trying to marginalize when it
- 32:22works. I'm not an opponent that violence should only be the absolute plan z.
- 32:30However, sometimes plan z is necessary. Okay, well, I'm not
- 32:35opposing pushback, even by force, against aggressors against you. I'm just trying
- 32:40to understand. Does someone qualify aggression as a word spoken. If someone says
- 32:45a certain word, is violence warranted against them? If someone says it would
- 32:51be better if we were all dead. If someone says that they do not
- 32:55view us as equals, no matter how hard we try. If someone says
- 33:01that they are inherently more human than us because they quote unquote looks apart,
- 33:07I feel that that is the early stages of genocidal ableism. I myself want
- 33:15to express first and primarily, that I understand the tremendous frustration that the disabled
- 33:22feel in a world that has purposefully, in many cases been not fashioned for
- 33:28them. They've been dismissed and discarded. I have real concerns about calls for
- 33:31violence against people who have not been approached violently first. That's a conversation.
- 33:38I think we're probably gone. We've been approached first. This is self defect.
- 33:43If someone speaks a word against you, even protected speech, which is
- 33:47hate speech. I worry about living in a world where someone subjectively says I
- 33:54grew homes where they're letting people start. If somebody I'm not talking about one
- 34:00needs to storm the back field, if someone is starving people to death,
- 34:05it is different than I have spoken a hateful word, which is sadly but
- 34:10necessarily protected as free speech. The way to defeat that, I would argue
- 34:16is not to pull a gun and shoot them in the street and call it
- 34:19self defense. I worry about that kind of thinking, and I think that's
- 34:23fair for shooting people for speaking. I feel that we need to be able
- 34:29to defend ourselves against physical, emotional, sexual and mental harm. Okay,
- 34:36well, when now we're talking about someone who is perpetrating physical harm, which
- 34:39is a different conversation. It's like the punch a Nazi crowd. What they
- 34:45do is they say that someone who hates I'm sorry, I'm the image in
- 34:50my head of Sean Spicer, all right, but not that I advocate violence
- 34:55out of nowhere. But well, I appreciate your call very much, and
- 35:00we'll perhaps chat down the way. Okay, it was lovely to be on
- 35:04the shot, No, thank you. Where I was going with that is,
- 35:08if you run into a white supremacist on the street, someone who doesn't
- 35:14believe in equality and believes that people of color, etc. Are not of
- 35:17equal status, even not even human, is the way to defeat that to
- 35:23sucker punch them in the street. And there's a culture of people I understand
- 35:27their frustration, who believe that that is how we solve the problem. I
- 35:30don't think myself. I don't think we sucker punch our way to a better
- 35:35world. I think it feels good in the second we watch the video of
- 35:38somebody getting their ass kicked, a neo Nazi gets pummeled with a fist in
- 35:44the street, We're like, yeah, fuck that guy. I understand the
- 35:46emotional response, the satisfaction in the moment. I just don't think that's how
- 35:51we fix the world, and I don't think that's an unreasonable concern. These
- 35:55are difficult conversations, aren't they. There's certainly hot button conversation, but I
- 36:00think we should be able to talk about them. I've got Matthew, thanks
- 36:04for calling. What do you want to talk about? I've talked to you
- 36:07a few times. I've always been a huge fan of your work. By
- 36:08the way, thank you so much. Thank you. I heard you and
- 36:12Matt Della Hunty recently speaking about the twelve step program. I think you guys
- 36:15were maybe at a conference. I was curious your faults on the twelve step
- 36:20concept because I myself am a recovering addict. I am an atheist, and
- 36:25I'm pretty vocal humanist, and I know that we maybe had some disagreements here,
- 36:30but I think some of it may just be misunderstanding. So I'm really
- 36:32just curious to plish that out a little bit, if that's okay. My
- 36:37opposition to Alcoholics Anonymous and the twelve step program isn't that it hasn't worked for
- 36:45some people. In fact, for that reason, I will tell people who
- 36:49are recovering addicts that if the program helped you, I would never be the
- 36:52one to negate that I would never be the one to say you shouldn't have
- 36:57done it. You know, if it has helped you, then good for
- 37:00you. My challenge with AA is that it wasn't begun from a science based
- 37:07framework, and it relies heavily on the concept of a higher power. You
- 37:14put your trust or faith, you have an anchor in some other somewhere,
- 37:19and they're kind of nebulous about what that is. My challenge with that twelve
- 37:22step model is that it sort of robs you of responsibility and it cheats you
- 37:30of a feeling of real accomplishment when you do the heavy lifting of beating addiction.
- 37:36You know, it's saying, essentially you don't have it within you lean
- 37:39on a higher power. I think that's a legitimate concern, don't you It
- 37:45is. Yeah, yeah, absolutely, I will say I think that's a
- 37:47great takeaway. So I'm not arguing with you. I just I want you
- 37:52to if you can just maybe hear a little different perspective. So like myself,
- 37:55my sponsor, like a long line of the people that I'm in the
- 37:59Narcotics Anonymous program with, we're pretty much all atheists. Like I mean,
- 38:02there are so many religious people in our community. But like a lot of
- 38:05us are working towards We have what they call like conference agenda report, and
- 38:09I won't for you with all the details, but it's where we get together
- 38:12every couple of years and work towards changing the language in our literature. You
- 38:15know, some of it is an appeal to tradition. We see that fallacy
- 38:19along the lines of you know, how it was written, and a lot
- 38:22of us see those problems. You know, a lot of us are more
- 38:24focused on like the community aspect of you know, when I got clean,
- 38:29I needed somebody that had been there, you know, I needed somebody to
- 38:32call and say, you know, hey, Seth, look, I don't
- 38:35know why I'm thinking about using you know, but I am. And you
- 38:37know, somebody would say, hey, look I've been there, this is
- 38:39how I did it. It really does help, you know, that sense
- 38:42of community. I have an undergrad and psychologist kind of my thing, and
- 38:45that's the kind of nursing that I do, and we see it a lot.
- 38:47And I really think that if you can remove some of the religious language
- 38:52from the program, and a lot of us have I can't speak for people
- 38:54as a whole, but I can say that for me, it helped a
- 38:58great deal because it wasn't just about the higher power at that point, you
- 39:00know, it was about the power greater than myself. Was the people around
- 39:05me that helped me with my addiction. That has been there, you know,
- 39:07that unifying concept of hey, together we can. That's a that's a
- 39:10recurring theme in our literature, you know, together we can. When I
- 39:15hear community, I don't think God, I don't think spirits. I don't
- 39:20think higher power. I hear shared experience and human supports and love and no
- 39:30gods, no monsters. You know, to me, that sounds like the
- 39:32kind of thing I could really get behind. And it's only whenever people have
- 39:37their agency removed that I start to become concerns. But if it has helped
- 39:42you, man, I'm just glad that you are on the other side,
- 39:45and I'm glad that you've had success, and I wish you an addiction free
- 39:49life of freedom and happiness, love and goodness absolutely well. And so I
- 39:54completely agree with that. I think that the net is very big. It's
- 39:59kind of one of the biggest dogs in the fight, the whole twelve step
- 40:00program. I think that we still have a lot of reform with regards to
- 40:05the language, some of the religious language, some of the very gender specific
- 40:07language. You know, we recently have voted on the idea of doing away
- 40:12with this terminology of God, you know, for people that prefer to say
- 40:15higher power or whatever. I think that, like you said, I agree
- 40:21that the core tenants don't have to involve a lot of that. I guess
- 40:23I just wanted to give you a different picture. You know, a lot
- 40:25of us don't feel that way. I mean, I don't think you and
- 40:29I disagree. I hear a lot. There are also some secular sobriety programs
- 40:32out there that are starting to get noticed, and they do the same thing.
- 40:36It is about community. I think they may be a little more focused
- 40:39on the science of addiction, how is the body acting and reacting to substances,
- 40:45the psychology behind addictive behaviors, and then really focusing not on gods or
- 40:51higher powers, but on the power that we have as human beings. And
- 40:54if A does more of that, and the twelve step programs do more of
- 40:58that. Moving forward, delighted, But I think you and I largely line
- 41:01up, and I wish you all success in your journey. Okay, we
- 41:05definitely do it. Hey, Seth, thank you again for everything you do.
- 41:07I can't wait to see you at the at the next a bit you
- 41:10speak at buddy, very kind, so much. Thank you. We'll see
- 41:13you later. Two five six is it? Dan? Yeah? Dan,
- 41:17appreciate you man. What's up? What do you want to talk about?
- 41:21Well, I had a personal story I was wanting to tell you, but
- 41:23I'm listening to the previous conversation. I just had a comment about borders and
- 41:29national identity. And you know, I was born and raised in the US.
- 41:34I lived here, but through work, I have the opportunity to travel
- 41:39about two hundred days a year through Africa, eur Middle East, Asia,
- 41:45and through my experiences, the one thing I've determined is that we're really all
- 41:52the same. When you have the opportunity to get to know personally an African
- 41:59or a German, or a Greek or someone from the Middle East, and
- 42:04you sit down and you have a meal with them, those imaginary lines disappear
- 42:09really quickly, and you find that we all really do want the same things.
- 42:15We want, the same lives, we want, you know, we
- 42:17all seek the same happinesses and so yeah, if you want to criticize governments
- 42:23by all means. You know, criticize the looks religions by all means,
- 42:29but you always have to keep in mind that these people, they're just like
- 42:31us. There's the borders are like you said, they're drawn by some person,
- 42:37and they don't really mean anything in the lives of the people we meet.
- 42:43Who was it who said one of the best cures for bigotry is travel
- 42:49to go and meet the people that you have othered for so long. I'm
- 42:52fully aware that there are some right now who are screaming about the border wall.
- 42:57We need a wall and at the Mexican border because them Mexicans, you
- 43:00know, have come up, the illegals have come up. And yet you
- 43:04know, there have been so many instances where we are introduced to immigrants and
- 43:08people who are from other countries our southern border in past, and they meet
- 43:13them and realize that they are people who simply want to escape oppression, who
- 43:17love their families and want their protection, who work hard, who want to
- 43:21share this planet in peace. You know, when you see those walls,
- 43:23you see the bigotries come down and dissipate. You're right, Let's meet the
- 43:28people we share the planet with in good faith. Good things can happen.
- 43:31That's why my brother. What else did you want to talk about today?
- 43:37Well, I had a story that I think you might find interesting. It
- 43:39was it was my conversion story, and I haven't really heard anyone like it.
- 43:45A little backstory up in twenty twelve, me and my wife came out
- 43:50of the religion of that we were raised in by our parents through research and
- 43:55watching videos online and stuff, and I had got into a place where I
- 44:00was like, I'm okay with the fact that I don't believe my religion anymore.
- 44:06But I wasn't really interested in taking it any further. I was okay,
- 44:08I can believe in God, I can believe in heaven and Hell,
- 44:13and I don't have to believe my religion that I was raised in. But
- 44:19through my travels, I spend tons of time in hotel rooms and I passed
- 44:23my time a lot of times watching YouTube. And I was in bed one
- 44:29evening watching some videos and ended up falling asleep, and I had left the
- 44:35auto play on, so the videos just kept rolling through while I'm sleepy,
- 44:42and I wake up the next morning with these memories of these vivid dreams that
- 44:47I had been having at night, and I had this overwhelming aha moment where
- 44:53I'm like it all makes sense. I finally get it, and I had
- 45:00never felt it. It was a close I guess I could say a religious
- 45:04experience for a lack of a better term. But I realized at that moment
- 45:08that I don't believe anymore. And I noticed my YouTube was playing. So
- 45:15I was that voice in my head is so crystal clear. I could still
- 45:21hear that voice talking to me. So I'm like, was it something I
- 45:24was watching? So I started hitting the back button, back, back back,
- 45:30and I came to a video and it was Seth Andrews. Christianity made
- 45:35me sound like an idiot, no way, I know. I hit play.
- 45:40As soon as I hit play, I'm like, that was the voice
- 45:45in my head, That's what I was listening to. And so I was
- 45:50so focused on that video, watched it intently, and watched another one and
- 45:54another one. I probably spent the next twenty hours doing nothing but watching video.
- 46:00And it was like that voice in my head that and I don't know
- 46:05if it was that in my sleep. My cognitive dissonance wasn't able to kick
- 46:09in and shut it down. Like we've been taught through religion. You know
- 46:14you hear anything that contradicts you to shut it down. And it was the
- 46:19first time that I was able to when I woke up, tell myself I
- 46:23don't believe. And for the first time I know why. It all made
- 46:29sense. Every doubt I had had my entire life, every nagging question came
- 46:36pouring back of I finally understand. And I have wanted to thank you so
- 46:44deeply for the work that you do because it literally changed my life forever,
- 46:51and I'm so grateful to you. Dude. I came to you in a
- 46:54dream like it was like an apparition that appeared before the in the dream.
- 47:00That's just a story that I would like to tell at parties, you know,
- 47:04But it was it was that face, I mean, the voice you
- 47:07have for radio. It was so soothing and calming, and it just hooked
- 47:13me. For the first time, it all just made sense. Well,
- 47:17that's tremendous for me to hear. You know. I think all of us,
- 47:22no matter where we are, even at a point position somewhere, you
- 47:25know, I think sometimes we have imposter syndrome. You know, Do I
- 47:30really deserve to be doing this? There are other people more qualified? Doesn't
- 47:35really make a difference. And when someone tells you this kind of story,
- 47:37I mean, it's totally blows my mind and makes my day. And you
- 47:44encourage me. You've done the heavy lifting. You're the one who's now living
- 47:47an authentic life on your terms acknowledging that you don't buy it. I think
- 47:52that's inspiring and I'm so glad you told me. That's really amazing. Man.
- 47:57Well, if you ever have doubts about your work, just know that
- 48:01there's at least one person out there that owes you more than you'll know.
- 48:06Now, you're very kind. I hope we get a chance to shake hands
- 48:08in person someday. Okay, now, I'd look forward to that. All
- 48:12right, be safe. Thanks again. So if it works like that,
- 48:16could we lull other believers to sleep and then just sneak in and turn the
- 48:23speech on, like if the defenses are down? Would that work? Oh
- 48:29aren't you sleepy? Go to sleep? Go to sleep? Da da da
- 48:32da da dad. They're out, and then we go and put on a
- 48:37thinking atheist podcast. Maybe that's the way it. Maybe that's how we cut
- 48:42through. I don't know. Regardless, I am absolutely blown away by that
- 48:45call. Okay, if you want to go to sleep and listen to our
- 48:50final segment. Subliminally, now would be the time. I'll be right back
- 48:54after this break. Don't forget. I've got a second podcast of short form
- 49:04True Stories. Would love to have you check it out and subscribe True Stories
- 49:09podcast dot com. Three two three Are you there? What's your name?
- 49:17Joel? Joel? What's on your mind? Yeah? I was curious about
- 49:22attitudes of Evangelical Christians towards Jews while you were still an Evangelical Christian. Just
- 49:28for a background, I grew up Jewish and a liberal family in Los Angeles,
- 49:32and you know, there's still a fair amount of Jews here, but
- 49:36it's you know, there's still a very distinct minority. And you know,
- 49:39I would get a lot of I mean, most people were fine, but
- 49:43I would get people either who just cannot understand why my family didn't sell very
- 49:46Christmas down to kids who are telling me that I had murdered their Lord and
- 49:52things like that. And I'm just curious what you saw as attitudes towards Jews
- 49:57when you were still an Evangelical Christian. My family honored the Jews. In
- 50:01fact, until my father's death a couple of years ago. I think They
- 50:06had on the back of their car a pro Israel window sticker to show solidarity
- 50:12for God's Chosen people and the Holy Land. You know, they were very
- 50:15much Zionists in that way. They were fans of the Jews even it's which
- 50:21is weird because I don't believe Jewish tradition holds to Christ or Christ's return.
- 50:27Was that true in your case? Right? You weren't. You're not a
- 50:29Jesus oriented culture. If you're a Jew, Jesus is essentially irrelevant to Judaism.
- 50:35Yeah, yeah, which is so it's weird to see devout evangelicals who
- 50:38were really very pro Jewish state honored the Jewish people when the Jewish people in
- 50:45that very important way, it kind of rejected Jesus. You think it was
- 50:49because they really admired the Jewish people, or was it because they thought it
- 50:52was essential for the Book of Relation to play outs for the Jews to all
- 50:57go to Israel. I don't think it's binary. I saw both. My
- 51:00father took us to a film I was, you know, I couldn't really
- 51:05get into it. I was so young, but it was called The Chosen
- 51:07and the two characters in the film, one was sort of a mainstream,
- 51:13casual cultural Jew and the other was a hardcore Orthodox Jew. And they were
- 51:19both teenagers and their lives intersected, and it was sort of a contrast of
- 51:23cultures. But both of these young men lived under the umbrella of Judaism,
- 51:28and it showed how much they had in common against their differences, becoming human
- 51:32being sharing the same space, worshiping the same God. And my father thought
- 51:37that was an amazing story. He had real admiration for the Jewish people.
- 51:42But you bring to light one of the major excuses that white supremacists and other
- 51:47racist and bigots have against Jewish people. They're saying, well, the Jews
- 51:52reject Christ, so we reject the Jews, and we must do so biblically,
- 51:58morally, etc. You know, that's how they excuse bigotry against the
- 52:02Jewish people. It's pathetic. Do you think that work. Do you know
- 52:06what people thought about Jewish salvation and do they think they could still go to
- 52:09heaven even though they didn't accept Jesus. We never talked about that. I
- 52:15think in my mind, our culture had always just assumed, well, the
- 52:19chosen people are in man, you know, say you're the chosen people,
- 52:23so you always kind of got your back, right, You've already got the
- 52:27golden ticket. We're not too worried about the Jews. That was our I
- 52:30really do. I think that Christian homes are so varied the spectrum of this
- 52:37sort of custom fitted Christianity, from the hardcore to the casual to everybody in
- 52:42between. Different interpretations, different Bible translations, different prophets, pastors, agendas,
- 52:47etc. I mean, you can go to any Christian home and ask
- 52:50them about the Jews. You're probably going to get a different answer. But
- 52:52my culture where I came out of, we were very deferential. You know,
- 52:57we sort of honored the Jewish people because they were indeed chosen. But
- 53:01we are seeing in our headlines today a lot of Bible thumping Christians who have
- 53:06attacked and continued to attack Jewish people because they rejected Christ and or maybe they
- 53:12are just simply monstrous, awful people. So have you experienced as far as
- 53:17discrimination in that way? I mean, you live in the United States,
- 53:21are you feeling that heat? Not really? I mean, growing up I
- 53:24always get some ignorance and hostility, and especially kids telling me and either going
- 53:30to Hell or that we murdered their lord and things like that. I mean,
- 53:32as an adults, I've gotten very little, you know, I do
- 53:36see a lot of ignorance among other people about Judaism. And like I was
- 53:39having a conversation with a co worker a number of years ago. It was
- 53:43an evangelical Christian and she could not wrap her head around the fact that Jews
- 53:47did not believe in Jesus. That Jesus was irrelevant. Help me understand something.
- 53:52This is a conversation I'm interested in. Is being a Jew a belief
- 53:58system or is it a netchnicity? Like if I was to decide I'm an
- 54:01adherent to Judaism, would I then be a Jew? Or is jew more
- 54:07of a racial question? Or I mean, are these discussions that people have
- 54:10within Jewish cultures some extent? I mean, Judaism is a religion, it's
- 54:15not an ethnicity. But at least most Jews are of a particular of the
- 54:21Oscan Nazi ethnicity, which is extended from Jews who had settled, you know,
- 54:25many centuries ago in Eastern Europe. So that's my background, and so
- 54:30there's a certain culture associated with it. And you know, talking about what
- 54:34Jews believe, there's many, many different streams of Judaism, just like in
- 54:37Christianity. You know, I grew up Jewish, but I became an atheist
- 54:42when I was fairly young. And most Jews I know in la and Los
- 54:45Angeles are not practicing. They're either atheist or just not practicing. But you
- 54:51know, there's a certain cultural association with you know, Yiddish culture and some
- 54:55of the holidays and things like that, but most most Jews or not particularly
- 55:00religious. So it would be akin to we see Islam more attributed to those
- 55:07of Middle Eastern cultures and ethnicities. But you can be anybody and believe the
- 55:13Quran. You can hold to the religion of Islam. Would that be inaccurate?
- 55:16Sure? Is that similar to how Judaism works. Yeah, Like there
- 55:21are Muslims of all stripes, there are Jews of all stripes, but you
- 55:23know, most of them who fall into either the Hashkenazi or the Phardic ethnicities.
- 55:30Interesting that what is it fifty percent of Jews. I'm trying to remember
- 55:37the study. Somebody look it up in fact check me, but it's like
- 55:39roughly half of people who profess Judaism either don't believe in a God or have
- 55:45some significant doubts about God. Does that ring true for you? At least
- 55:52my experience, it does. I mean, there are Jewish communities that are
- 55:54very religious, but at least in my experience and Los Angeles that most Jews
- 56:00are not particularly religious. You know, they do believe in God, it's
- 56:02sort of a vague way. A lot of Jews I know who say they
- 56:07believe in God. You know, I think it's more they enjoy the you
- 56:09know, the culture and celebrating the holidays and going to temple and things like
- 56:14that, but they're not deeply religious at all. I support that. I
- 56:17love the idea of ritual to frame the human experience. No God's required,
- 56:22so you can enjoy the music and the tradition and the dress and the stuff.
- 56:28You know, you can fashion all of these accouterments for specific parts of
- 56:34your life, but you don't really necessarily needs supernatural thinking to be a part
- 56:38of it. And I think we're seeing this played out within much of the
- 56:43Jewish cultures out there, and I think that's very interesting to watch. You
- 56:46know. It's sort of a non theistic religion of tradition. Yeah, that's
- 56:51a good way to put up. Well, these are interesting questions. All
- 56:54I can say is from my experience, we honored the Jewish people. We
- 56:59wanted a Jewish state. Israel belongs to the Jews. Kind of thing against
- 57:04all the opposition. It is a holy war, if it must be,
- 57:07kind of thing in advance of the return of Christ, which the Jews didn't
- 57:12really believe in. But you know, welcome to religion. Right. Your
- 57:16brain just can compartmentalize it will, But I appreciate your call very much,
- 57:21my friend. Okay, thanks that all right, hang in there, we'll
- 57:23see you. I'm gonna call it my friends. Let me finish this by
- 57:28saying that I'm glad that this is a community that transcends borders. We are
- 57:34a globe, we are a planet without border lines. And it's so cool.
- 57:39When I did local radio, we'd have people within the city. You
- 57:44know, there's this sort of broadcast radius as pretty narrow. But in the
- 57:47age of the Internet, I get correspondence from Japan. I hear from listeners
- 57:53in Russia and Brazil and Mexico, and it's crazy. And so we may
- 58:00be an example of humanity without borders. Right belief systems, convictions about the
- 58:07world are humanistic values. These are not national values. They are human values.
- 58:15And we are all the human race. Love you much, have a
- 58:20great week. We'll see you bye. Follow the Thinking Atheist on Facebook and
- 58:23Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t
- 58:29shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and
- 58:34details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The
- 58:38Thinking Atheist dot com.