Latest / The So What? / Some You Win, Some You Lose
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website jplantman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:27In this conversation, a company's JP's newsletter dated the 18th of October 2024, titled Some
- 0:34You Win, Some You Lose. It has been a busy two weeks.
- 0:39Yes, indeed it has been. You know the old saying that there are weeks where nothing
- 0:43happens and then there are days when weeks happen. And certainly in the first two weeks
- 0:47of October, a lot of things have happened, both in the policy space and in the political
- 0:52space.
- 0:53Let's begin with policy.
- 0:55Well, first of all, we got a new visa regime and it's a new visa regime that has long been
- 1:00in the making, but at last it has now been gazetted in the government gazette. So this
- 1:05is now the law of the land, so to speak, and it provides for two things. It provides for
- 1:09a point based system when you apply for a South African visa. So that takes care of
- 1:15a lot of the subjectivity and discretion because there are points for this, points for that
- 1:20and that is clear and unambiguous. And secondly, it provides for a remote work visa so people
- 1:26can come to South Africa and live here, but work elsewhere. And of course, that is also
- 1:32enormously beneficial. We offer it, we have a lot to offer in terms of facilities and
- 1:37climate and personal services and so on. So for people to work elsewhere, but come and
- 1:42live here, spend the money here, buy goods and services here is clearly a big plus. So
- 1:48those two changes give us a much easier and much more modern visa regime.
- 1:54And that was only the latest in the project Wollend-Lehler's priority list.
- 2:01Yes, indeed. Project Wollend-Lehler had as its priorities water, electricity, water licenses
- 2:08really, electricity and a few other items and visas were one of them. Visas can now
- 2:14be ticked. The other items that can be ticked is spectrum release that was done and achieved
- 2:20and has unleashed a lot of investment. The electricity regulation reform that was done,
- 2:26Mr. Ramaphosa signed the bill, facilitating private sector investment into renewables.
- 2:32So far about 500 billion rand has been unlocked and counting that number keeps on going up.
- 2:38So that was done. Breaking up ESCOM, transmission has been separated out of ESCOM, distribution
- 2:44still remains to be done. Ensuring electricity supply, we are now over 200 days of no load
- 2:51shedding and again counting. It seems as if it's holding and water licenses had to be
- 2:58fixed and that was done. The bigger problems of water of which we in Gauteng are very well
- 3:03aware of that will be tackled in Wollend-Lehler 2. Wollend-Lehler 2 has not been announced
- 3:10yet but it will probably be coming out in the next couple of weeks and it will cover
- 3:14water security as opposed to water licenses, water security, logistics, more electricity
- 3:20reform, local government, spatial inequality and digital transformation. Now water, spatial
- 3:29inequality and local government, those are big and important issues. They are tough nuts
- 3:35to crack and it will be interesting to see how Wollend-Lehler 2 deals with that.
- 3:42Since you start with, you captioned this, some you win, some you lose, Transnet's loss
- 3:49in the court last week was also was a setback. Yes, it was a setback for project Wollend-Lehler.
- 3:55The port reform is part of logistics reform and what happened there was Transnet has under
- 4:01government pressure, government guidance, policy guidance, issued a 25-year concession
- 4:07to an international Philippine company to come and run the Durban port but also to invest
- 4:1311 billion rand to modernize the new equipment and so on. That went out on tender. There
- 4:19were about I think 22 people or 22 entities interested in the license. It was then awarded
- 4:27to the Philippine company. One other international logistics company, Maersk, who is quite well
- 4:32known in South Africa, one sees the name all over, objected and said Transnet did not apply
- 4:38the tender conditions correctly and they went to the high court to interdict the concessioning.
- 4:44The judge agreed with Maersk and Transnet was interdicted. Temporarily, there will now
- 4:51be a second phase where the case will be heard on the merits and we will then see what the
- 4:56judge decides. I hope the courts do not take a final decision on this because I don't think
- 5:02that's the way these things should be handled. You may remember that we've had a similar
- 5:06situation of spectrum release. When everything was set and gun ready to go, three companies
- 5:14three big ICT companies brought applications against spectrum release, claiming that it
- 5:20was prejudicing their particular business model. That issue in the end was resolved
- 5:25outside the courtroom. Executive decisions were taken, compromises were made and spectrum
- 5:30release was not only done but was done and dusted. So I'm looking to that example to
- 5:36be pursued in the case of this port concessioning. That's the way to resolve it, not via the
- 5:42courts. What's happening in the relationship between government and business? Well, they're
- 5:48quite interesting. The first phase of government business cooperation, which goes back about
- 5:53a year or so, has now been concluded with projects finalized and now on the 1st of October
- 5:59they signed what one can call a phase two agreement where they will carry on working
- 6:05together and they specialize in three areas particularly. The three areas are energy,
- 6:14ongoing energy reform, transport and logistics and crime and corruption. Since then, since
- 6:21the 1st of October, it has become clear that there's a fourth item that has been added
- 6:26to the list and that is water, particularly in Gauteng. So big companies have stepped
- 6:31forward and say they would like to play a role or they're capable of playing a role
- 6:36in resolving the water crisis. So those are the four areas on which business and government
- 6:41are cooperating and you will notice that it dovetails Willem Lela 1 and 2 almost perfectly.
- 6:47So the business government cooperation fits into making these reforms of Willem Lela
- 6:531 and 2 work. That's really where they fit in. How can business help when it comes to
- 6:59water because water is becoming an enormous problem? Indeed, absolutely, particularly
- 7:05in Gauteng. There are two ways. The first way is by way of seconding people and getting
- 7:11management expertise into the various water bodies, helping with planning and execution.
- 7:17But secondly, and in a sense more important, investment. Water is underinvested in South
- 7:24Africa. I'm not just referring to the big capital projects. The private sector is already
- 7:30involved but we're talking about distribution at local government level. In Johannesburg
- 7:35something- So pipes next to the road.
- 7:39That kind of thing. I mean the water infrastructure in Johannesburg, in Gauteng in general, is
- 7:44old and it has to be replaced and that is quite a member of task. You've got to figure
- 7:50out new ways of doing that on the construction side but also on the financing side. And that's
- 7:56where business could play a role.
- 8:00And to jump to a completely different thing, how do you see our international relationships
- 8:06at the moment? Is it possible really to be non-aligned?
- 8:10Yeah, absolutely. There are a number of very successful countries that are very successfully
- 8:16non-aligned. Think of India. They are probably the prime example. Brazil. Brazil is a very
- 8:22good example. They're close to the US. US is a big market but they retain a separate
- 8:28identity. India, as I've already said, is a past master in that. So yes, it is possible.
- 8:34What we saw in October is that President Ramaphosa went to China to attend the Africa-China Cooperation
- 8:41Summit but he was received by Xi Jinping on a state visit, which is quite an honour or
- 8:49a compliment. And it's quite clear that the Chinese are very keen on closer relations
- 8:54with South Africa. At the same time, last week, the United States Embassy in South Africa
- 9:01released a statement to say that they will have a bosporat with the South African government
- 9:07on future relations and they wanted to develop quote unquote a strategic relationship with
- 9:13South Africa. Now, if you take this US embassy statement and you compare it to the US embassy
- 9:20allegations around Lady R, all unsubstantiated allegations I must say.
- 9:25Was that only last December? That was very recent, yeah. Then you can see
- 9:31how far things have moved. So I think it's quite clear that the Americans would like
- 9:34to have a better relationship. We're having a good relationship with China. So let's see
- 9:40where this goes. But I think the fact that the US embassy is participating in this process
- 9:46and want to create a strategic relationship answers your question that yes, it is possible
- 9:52to be non-aligned. But you have to be very clever and you must box very cleverly.
- 10:00We might refer our listeners to a Netflix series we watched last night. It's called
- 10:07History 101. It's not new. It's been there for a while. But last night we watched a chapter
- 10:14called The Rise of China. It's 21 minutes and it's fascinating. It's a condensed overview,
- 10:20very worth watching. Oh yes, absolutely. We misunderstand China
- 10:25a lot. I think China also misunderstands the West a lot. But it is a reality. You can't
- 10:30ignore it. And yes, the listeners would benefit from watching it.
- 10:35Coming back to Home Ground, once again we have to talk about Gauteng. China was a disaster,
- 10:41is a disaster, as far as Johannesburg can see. What does it mean locally and nationally?
- 10:49Gauteng has always been a bit of an outlier in the sense that there are or were two centers
- 10:54of powers in ANC that would have preferred to make a coalition, not with the DA and the
- 11:01other parties that we currently have in the coalition, but with the EFF and nowadays with
- 11:06MK. This goes back quite a while. What happened in the election in May was that the ANC and
- 11:12KwaZuna Natal got thrashed. So they were taken out as a serious player. They only got 17%
- 11:18of the vote. And well, you know, in politics if you don't have votes, you have nothing.
- 11:23In Gauteng, the ANC did a bit better here. They got 35% of the vote, still a minority
- 11:28government, but they do control the province and they're using that power base to shun
- 11:33the DA and to shun other moderate parties in the current government of national unity.
- 11:41They would prefer to go with the EFF and also MK. So there's clearly, that's where Gauteng
- 11:47is an outlier. Has been the case for a while and that is simply playing out in Swanee.
- 11:52And I think what we see in Swanee is the ANC, Panja Zalasufi, the ANC leader in Gauteng,
- 11:59is very proud that the ANC has reconquered, so to speak, metros in Gauteng, Johannesburg
- 12:06Metro, Toronto Metro, that used to be governed by different coalitions and are now governed
- 12:11by an ANC coalition. It's a political aim and they've succeeded in doing that.
- 12:17Whether that will pay off? Well, that we will have to see. What happened in Swanee is in
- 12:22a sense, unfortunate. Action SA withdrew from the ruling coalition, the one that they had
- 12:29with the DA and other small parties, and then went into coalition with the ANC. Now they
- 12:36haven't really explained that. They said Michael Beaumont, their national spokesman or national
- 12:43leader, not national leader, but an important leader, said the election in May created a
- 12:51new reality and they had to adjust to this new reality of coalitions. Now that's fine,
- 12:57but why then swap one coalition for another? They claim that it's because the DA coalition
- 13:03was not willing to spend money on the black townships. I think, well, the DA of course
- 13:10denies that, but I think more important, they haven't tabled this issue in the coalition
- 13:15and I think it's just an excuse that they're using afterwards. So Action SA has really
- 13:21pulled the plug there. That has now resulted in the mayor being removed. It has resulted
- 13:26in ANC led coalition. And then a further unfortunate thing happens, which shows you that we're
- 13:33not yet used to coalition politics in South Africa. Alan Zille then said, well, if Suleyya
- 13:40Brin cannot be a mayor in Twane, then the DA is not going to have any further talks
- 13:46with ANC about Ekorileini, Johannesburg and now Sommandela Bay. Now that's very unfortunate
- 13:53because Panjaza Lusufi scored a victory in Twane. By now walking away from Ekorileini,
- 14:00you in a sense solidify his victory. Why do I say that? Well, the ANC mayor of Ekorileini
- 14:06is on record that he would prefer to have the DA in his mayoral committee, not exclusively,
- 14:13but he wants them in his committee, in his mayoral management team. Why? In his words,
- 14:19we only have two years to go before the elections. It's not time for new ideas or talking. It's
- 14:24not time for service delivery. And he thought the DA could help with that or having the
- 14:30DA in his mayoral committee will help with that. That door has now been shut when the
- 14:36DA said they're not going to talk about further talks. The people in Nelsomandela Bay will
- 14:41know that the situation there has been precarious for a long time, leading to instability. And
- 14:48likewise, this statement now has closed that door. So, you know, I think we have a situation
- 14:55there where some people philosophically do not want to deal with the DA or do not want
- 15:02to promote the idea of the government of national unity at local level. But other people-
- 15:08Some people in the ANC.
- 15:10Yeah. But other people through their style. It's also jeopardizing the government of national
- 15:15unity or the idea of national unity at local level. So that's where we are. We'll have
- 15:21to see how this plays out over the next two years.
- 15:24So what?
- 15:25Well, I think the so what is that I do not for one moment think that the shenanigans
- 15:30in Kharteng and Chuanhe and so on, that they are going to affect the government of national
- 15:37unity. I think the government of national unity will carry on with their program, which
- 15:42is clearly summarized in the Volandela program of action. That structural reform will play
- 15:50out. And when that structural reform has taken its course, it will certainly lift the economic
- 15:57growth in the country. We've got research from the Barofa Economic Research in Sanabas
- 16:03telling us, showing us that it's quite possible to achieve a growth rate of three to three
- 16:08and a half percent versus the one maximum one and a half percent we currently have.
- 16:14Now if we move from a one and a half percent economy to a three and a half percent economy,
- 16:20that's really a game changer. And that can come out of the Volandela reforms. And that
- 16:25is firmly in place.
- 16:28That actually summarizes all the separate points you make in your so what paragraph.
- 16:33The formation of national unity is a win. Kharteng is unlikely to upset or derail that.
- 16:40Big win that the process of structural reform at national level is proceeding apace and
- 16:45it opens the possibility of a return to three percent plus growth over the next few years.
- 16:53Thank you for listening to the So What podcast. If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 16:58to leave a review and a rating and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any
- 17:03future episodes. Also tell your friends. Remember you can find a written version of all JP's
- 17:09content at jplandman.co.za.