Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 10/06/26 EPISODE 030: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN - OLD COMMONWEALTH 10 YEAR MAY 2026 RELEASE
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Mm-hmm. Well, folks, we are back. Thank you for joining us again for another week on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. This time we are doing a bottle breakdown. And ⁓ when I was preparing to do this episode, I was like, we're gonna fresh crack this bottle on the podcast. And then I got this I I was doing some research on it. It was like some people think ⁓ you should open it up and let it breathe and it tastes better after a couple weeks. But we are gonna be reviewing what ⁓ I'm I'm excited about this bottle. So we are talking about the Old Commonwealth 10 year old out of Old Commonwealth Distillery. And I want there's a lot of history behind this bottle. So I wanted to get into the history of this. Got my buddy John, John and James back in the room here. So ⁓ we've got it poured up already. So feel free to smell it along. ⁓ but I'm gonna I'm gonna give some history here ⁓ on this old Commonwealth and specific Old Commonwealth Distillery and specifically old Commonwealth 10 year old bourbon. So ⁓ the history on this on Old Commonwealth is incredibly rich. It's mul it's a multi-chapter saga tied to some of the most famous names in in whiskey history, including the Van Winkle family. Recently, a modern revival has brought the historic site and the brand back to life. So the physical story begins on the on the banks of the Hammonds Creek in Anderson County, Kentucky, where a businessman named S and S.O. Hackley broke ground on a distillery in 1889. So in in eighteen ninety three, Hackley partnered with Ike and George Hoffman, and the facility was renamed Hoffman Distilling Company. It became a it became famous for high quality or high quality pre prohibition brands like Old Hoffman and Old Spring. Following the repeal of Prohibition, Lawrenceburg Bourbon Barons, Robert and Ezra Rippy, whose brothers started what would become wild turkey just down the road. Bought the property in 1934. They ran it successfully for decades, though it eventually shut down in 1979 as the Bourbon Depression hit the industry. So the name Old Commonwealth Distillery was officially born in 1983. Julian Van Winkle III, the grandson of Pappy Van Winkle, needed a home to bottle his family's whiskey reserves after Diaggio closed down the Stitzel Weller facility. He bought the dormant Hoffman property and and rechristened it Old Com Commonwealth Distillery, and used it to bottle legendary old Rip Van Winkle products. In nineteen ninety seven, Julian Van Winkle released a highly limited, one hundred and seven proof weeded bourbon under the old Commonwealth tenure label, widely believed to be sourced from legendary Stitzelweller stock. When the Van Winkle family partnered with Buffalo Trace in two thousand and two, the Commonwealth Distillery facility was shuttered, and those original bottles now fetch thousands at auction. So in 2024, a team led by Zachary Joseph and Andrew English and Troy LeBlanc, officially revived old Commonwealth Distillery brand, operating as an independent bottler and blender. Their mission is to source premium hyper-age Kentucky whiskey and pair it with historic revived labels. The highly anticipated May 2026 release, Mark's Old Commonwealth 10 year olds, Mark's Old Commonwealth 10 year old batch three, and it represents a massive milestone for the new brand. So this bottle that we're drinking here is 10 years old, 107 proof, just the same, exact same proof that Pappy bottled ⁓ his at. The difference here is though, the mash bill is a low rye Kentucky straight bourbon. Departing from Van Winkle's weeded profile, but blended for a deep, rich sweetness. It's served in a light green glass bottle, traditionally used for fine cognacs, complete with a revived historic label. So all the labeling on this bottle is as it was back in the day when Julian was was doing it. ⁓ these bottles are MSRP'd at $200. ⁓ and why why is batch three significant though? So this is the third batch. The first batch was came out as like 131 proof. Batch number two was at 120 proof. And now batch three is at the original one ⁓ seven proof. So while the modern brand's first ten year release in came out in twenty twenty four, it came out at a hundred and thirty one point eight three proof. batch three is the first time the new the new team has proofed the liquid down to the exact one ⁓ seven proof ⁓ that Julian did back in nineteen ninety seven. So about twenty years later, right? Or Thirty years later, nineteen ninety seven. Thirty. Thirty years. Let's do math here. Almost. So on the tasting profile here is what they list it. So while the mota so the the the The the drop is blended to evoke that's weird. Why did it say that? The drop is blended to evoke a dusty bourbon profile, leaning away from the bright modern profiles and deep into heavy wood and a dark sugar influence. So on the o on the nose opens with br bright with caramel, vanilla bean cream, and deep dark cherry, but quickly transitions into an earthy ricouse funk. Toasted oak spice. And a unique a unique trace of ripe melon. Cantaloupe, whatever, honeydew. On the palate, its heavy, oily, full bodied, upfront notes of rich toffee, brown sugar, quickly gave way to an intense mid palate leather, dried tobacco leaves, dark chocolate shavings, and a seasoned oak barrel char. The finish, it's long, dry, and warming. The baking chocolate and tobacco carry the finish writing over a lingering dark cherry thread. So this is where I when I was putting this together, this pro tip is what caught me. ⁓ this batch rewards patience. Because of the heavy barrel char and the older wood wood profile used in the blend, whiskey enthusiasts note a slight sour wood note upon a fresh crack. Letting the bottle breathe for a week or two opens up the fruit and the caramel layers beautifully. So you guys have had an opportunity to nose this thing up. What do you think about the nose on this thing? Well, we're not worried about the nose. We've been drinking it. You've been drinking it too? The history of it? History. No, I'm kidding. It beautiful history. ⁓ Delicious. Profound statements, James. First nose. Yeah, what you said you got something on the nose that you normally don't get. What do you get? First nose, just quick sniff. I got baseball card bubblegum. Which is weird. ⁓ that like chalky bubblegum? Heart hard bubblegum? Bazooka. Okay. I could see that. Yeah. Nice little like that confectionery powdered sugar type note. But as you as I Knows it properly and breathe through it, I get the dark fruit. Dark cherry, a lot of vanilla. Yeah. Tons of vanilla. Dark caramel. I will say I've tasted it already as well. And this thing is well bound. So when I when I was putting this together in preparation for this a couple weeks back, I read that, I'm like, well damn, I don't want to open a bottle and it kinda sucks on the podcast. I need a so I did it I opened it and I filmed a review of it. So if you haven't seen that or go check out my ⁓ Instagram or YouTube or whatever, that'll be on there as well. But I was like, holy shit, this is amazing. Like, what are they talking about? It needs to open up for two weeks. I mean, what is it gonna taste like in two weeks? I I loved it when I did the fresh crack on it. And now? Still love it. I think I think this is an exceptional your your comment earlier, well balanced. Very well balanced. It doesn't get you get the the sweetness, you get the oak, you get a little bit of spice in there. It doesn't burn. That's my biggest thing, takeaway from this is it's well balanced. Yeah. This this this is a you know, if we threw this in a banger of bum profile, I'm I'm saying banger all day long. Like this is one where I'm like, damn, I w unfortunately this is a once a year release. This this bottle, if you didn't get one of these, you're not gonna get one again. You have do you have the other two? I have batch two. I don't I didn't get batch one. And it was gone in two minutes. Or like a minute, like less thirty se ⁓ thirty seconds. Like any any of these old Commonwealth products, even their They're cheap stuff, the sixty-five dollar bottles. If you don't like throw them in your cart and hit buy immediately, you're not getting it. I've literally had it in my cart and and and it'd be taken out of my cart. Even on that note, even if you like, I mean, it could just be Luck of the Draw. Luck of the draw. Someone's someone's got a quicker trigger figure. Yeah. I mean, it doesn't matter. Yeah, these these things, the packaging for me, I think, is really what sets old Commonwealth apart. They The green glass on this bottle, the didn't even recognize that. The reviving of the whiskey or the labeling, excuse me, from back in twenty, thirty years ago when Julian was doing it, all the labeling's the same. They got a couple little tweaks to it to modernize it, but ⁓ all in all, I think the big difference between this one so this one on the neck label, it says May twenty twenty six, batch one and batch two, it just says cask strength on the label. ⁓ This is a once a year release, at least for now. I'd maybe they'll do more. It's very interesting that they call it a May twenty twenty six release. Do you realize or do do you know how many bottles that were ⁓ were released? Released. Ooh, that's a great question. I don't know. But I could probably Google it real quick. Maybe just be curious. So you have batch two. I have batch two. I have that was at cast strength? That was a hundred and twenty proof. It is cast strength, but a hundred and twenty proof, yeah. And they proof this one down. They proof this one down to be at the same proof point that Julian did. Ju that Julian did. Which a hundred and seven, which kind of the sweet spot, right? What a lot of people think that's the sweet spot for Yeah. ⁓ Do you like it better at cat strength or is or I haven't tried the batch two. ⁓ okay. I haven't I haven't opened it yet. Gotcha. we need to. Should. If I had to guess the one thirty would be a little too overpowering. I like the one ⁓ seven's great. I like it, yeah. Because it's just it's a drink. Very well balanced. I don't know if the one thirty Quick guess. I'm not sure if it says how many bottles were released. We'll have to ask all Commonwealth. Yeah. Let us know in the comments and and hey, if any of the if any of the three gentlemen that ⁓ own the old Commonwealth brand would love to put in the comments ⁓ how many bottles were in this release. ⁓ 'cause we only got one out of three of us. We got one. ⁓ we try to get two. And it I mean it's exceptional. So Yeah, we tried to get to one of us was thirty seconds late to the to the dance. ⁓ but man, for ⁓ for me, this bottle is going on the list for best bourbons in twenty twenty six or best whiskies that we've tried. ⁓ I think I've got about ten or so already you have ten on the list. Yeah, but I mean th this one this one for me is probably in the top five of that list so far. ⁓ So we'll taste it again. End of the year, we'll line ⁓ all up. We'll taste through ⁓ We'll see which one's the best. So la any final thoughts on this thing? Are you ⁓ you know you tried to get one, you missed out? Yeah, I missed out literally by a click of the button. But ⁓ I'm excited for everything else they're putting out. I know they're just doing great things and every release literally goes within thirty seconds a minute. So just excited for And how many do you have of these? None. Of the old Commonwealth. You're O for O for one. On different like different releases. But you've grabbed a couple other bottles from Old Commonwealth. I grabbed what was the one this summer they Old Hoffman? I'd grabbed the Old Hoffman. That's the w only one I've got. But I've heard and that was like the the cheaper sixty five bucks, yeah. But I've heard fantastic things about that too. So if they're listening, you know, three two three Bourbon Library, you know, with Yeah. I mean I don't know if they do barrel picks, but man, that's be fun fun to be able to get not even barrel picks, just more just if they have anything they want to, you know, drop to you. Advertise. Advertise to get out there. They would be great to listen to get a bottle or we'll never say no to to sampling a whiskey. If you if you want us to do a review of your product, feel free to reach out. Hit me up. My the email three the three two three bourbon library at gmail dot com. ⁓ Actually ⁓ connected with four roses today. So nice. Maybe getting some four roses products in to to give a sample on and and try and give our thoughts about it. So but man, I Great job, guys. Do you guys think this is on your twenty twenty six best of the year? I don't know if I've had enough bangers to say that, but I mean it's delicious. I mean it I mean I would 100% at this stage. I would say it's ⁓ on the list. Perfect. Yeah. I love how well balanced it is. Like that's my biggest takeaway. I loved how well balanced it. Yeah, it's a great zipper. ⁓ low rye bourbon from Old Commonwealth Distillery. Very curious as to where they source this from. ⁓ sure. I have an idea. I'll tell you off camera. Sounds good. Anyway. ⁓ listen, thank you for joining us again for another week, another podcast on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. As always, please leave us some comments. Let us know how you're if you're enjoying it. Leave us a review on Spotify, Apple Music. Definitely we'll we'll hit you back, let you know. And ⁓ if there's suggestions of a bottle you want it to see reviewed in the future, just let us know. We'll see you next time. Cheers. Cheers