Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Recidivism & Correctional Psychology: Why Offenders Reoffend and What Actually Stops It
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Psychology Undergrad. I am so
- 0:02pumped you are joining us today as, you know,
- 0:04a fellow study buddy. Today we are doing a deep
- 0:07dive into Chapter 12 of our Forensic Psychology
- 0:10textbook. And honestly, it is some incredibly
- 0:13fascinating but really heavy stuff. Yeah, it
- 0:15really is. We are jumping right into the world
- 0:17of Correctional Psychology in Canada today. Right.
- 0:20Our mission for this deep dive is to explore
- 0:22how psychology is actually applied to the correctional
- 0:25system. Like how does the system decide who gets
- 0:27locked up? How do psychologists predict if an
- 0:30offender is going to strike again? And how do
- 0:33they even attempt to rehabilitate them? Exactly.
- 0:36And the thing is, this isn't just dry statistics
- 0:39and legal codes. It forces us to grapple with
- 0:41some really deep moral questions about human
- 0:44nature, about punishment, and about redemption.
- 0:47For sure. And to help you remember the core tension
- 0:50of this entire chapter, there's a framework you
- 0:52need to keep in your head. Just think of it as
- 0:54the ethic of control versus the ethic of care.
- 0:57Right. So the ethic of control is heavily focused
- 0:59on safety, punishment, and, you know, strict
- 1:02rules. It is almost like an Old Testament view
- 1:05of justice. Like, you do the crime, you pay the
- 1:08toll, public safety is the absolute priority.
- 1:11And then on the flip side, you have the ethic
- 1:12of care. This philosophy leans way more into
- 1:16rehabilitation. It is about providing services
- 1:18and understanding the root causes of behavior.
- 1:21It is a much more grace -based, redemptive approach
- 1:24to morality. Yeah, and to really understand how
- 1:27complex that tension is, the textbook starts
- 1:29with a real -world case study that just completely
- 1:32challenges your basic moral compass. Oh man,
- 1:35you mean the Robert Latimer case? Yeah, from
- 1:361993 in Saskatchewan. So Robert Latimer's daughter
- 1:39Tracy had severe cerebral palsy. She functioned
- 1:43at basically an incense level, had daily seizures,
- 1:46and was in excruciating constant pain. And she
- 1:48was facing even more painful surgeries. Exactly.
- 1:50So Robert put her in his truck and killed her
- 1:53via carbon monoxide poisoning to end her suffering.
- 1:55It is just so tragic. It really is. And legally,
- 1:59the Supreme Court found him guilty of second
- 2:01degree murder. which carried a mandatory minimum
- 2:04of life imprisonment with 10 years of no parole.
- 2:07Wow. Ten years minimum. Yeah. And the court explicitly
- 2:11stated that the sole function of his sentence
- 2:13was denunciation, not rehabilitation, not public
- 2:17safety, just denunciation. Which basically means
- 2:20public condemnation, right? Like society saying,
- 2:22regardless of the context, this act crosses a
- 2:25moral line. Exactly. And I should note here,
- 2:27the textbook makes it very clear that there are
- 2:30fierce proponents on both sides of the euthanasia
- 2:32debate. Oh. We're strictly examining the legal
- 2:35and psychological facts presented in the source
- 2:37material today. We are definitely not taking
- 2:40a political or moral side on this. Oh, absolutely.
- 2:42We are just the undergrads reporting the facts.
- 2:44But the psychology side of this case is where
- 2:45it gets really wild. Because when Latimer was
- 2:48up for parole, a CSC psychologist, Dr. Bruce
- 2:51Monkhouse, assessed him. Right. And he gave Latimer
- 2:53only a 10 % chance of reoffending in 10 years.
- 2:56Which is practically zero. Actuarially speaking,
- 2:59he was completely safe. But the National Parole
- 3:02Board denied him initially anyway. Because he
- 3:05wouldn't express remorse. He refused to repent.
- 3:08I mean, reading that was so frustrating. Isn't
- 3:10the Parole Board acting way more like a religious
- 3:12confessional here than a legal body? That is
- 3:15exactly the point. It perfectly highlights that
- 3:17clash. The system required an expression of moral
- 3:21repentance, even though the objective statistical
- 3:25risk of him reoffending was practically nonexistent.
- 3:28It is wild. He eventually won an appeal, right,
- 3:30with the help of the B .C. Civil Liberties Association.
- 3:32He did, yeah. But his case really shows how one
- 3:35unique individual navigates a very rigid system.
- 3:38to really grasp correctional psychology, we have
- 3:41to zoom out and look at the macro level. Right,
- 3:43like who actually goes to prison and how did
- 3:45this whole system even start? Well, prior to
- 3:471835, punishments in Canada were super harsh.
- 3:51Very much that ethic of control. We are talking
- 3:53whipping, pillories, very swift physical justice.
- 3:56Whip? Yeah. The first actual prison opened in
- 3:59Kingston in 1835. But it wasn't until the Archibald
- 4:02report in 1938 that the focus actually shifted
- 4:05toward rehabilitation. Wait, what prompted that
- 4:08report? Massive prison riots. And the commission
- 4:11found out that basically 70 % of the inmates
- 4:14were repeat offenders. The pure punishment model
- 4:17just wasn't working. That is what set the stage
- 4:20for modern correctional psychology. That makes
- 4:22sense. And to help you guys study the modern
- 4:25layout of the system, I use a little mnemonic
- 4:27for the jurisdiction stuff. Just remember, pro
- 4:30equals probation and petty. I like that. Yeah.
- 4:34So provincial and territorial systems handle
- 4:36sentences under two years, remand and probation.
- 4:39And then fed equals felonies. So federal penitentiaries
- 4:42handle the big sentences of two years or more.
- 4:44That is a great way to remember it. And looking
- 4:46at the demographics, Canada incarcerates about
- 4:48117 people per 100 ,000, which is way lower than
- 4:53the US, which sits around 730. But it is still
- 4:56higher than a lot of other countries, right?
- 4:58It is, yeah. But interestingly, 80 % of offenders
- 5:02are actually supervised in the community, like
- 5:06on bail, probation, or parole. But the textbook
- 5:09highlights a really massive crisis within the
- 5:12people actually locked up. Indigenous people
- 5:15make up only 4 percent of the Canadian population,
- 5:17but they account for 21 .4 percent of the federal
- 5:21incarcerated population. And those rates are
- 5:23rising. Yeah. And then you look at mental health,
- 5:2545 percent of the total prison population receives
- 5:28mental health services. And for women, it is
- 5:3169 percent. It is staggering. It really is. And
- 5:34I was reading the cost breakdown. It costs over
- 5:38were $113 ,000 a year to keep an inmate locked
- 5:41up compared to just under $30 ,000 to keep them
- 5:43in the community. Right. It is kind of like an
- 5:46emergency room analogy. It sounds like prisons
- 5:48have basically become the most expensive, least
- 5:51effective mental health wards in the country.
- 5:54Like, are we just using the justice system to
- 5:56treat a massive health care failure? That is
- 5:59the exact debate happening in the field right
- 6:01now. And since keeping people in prison is so
- 6:03expensive and disproportionately affects certain
- 6:06groups, how does the system decide who is actually
- 6:09safe to release? Right. Which brings us to the
- 6:12core job of a correctional psychologist. Offender
- 6:17risk assessment. Exactly. And the thing you have
- 6:19to understand is that risk isn't some objective
- 6:22physical trait. You can't put it under a microscope.
- 6:25It is a highly subjective forecast. based on
- 6:28risk factors. Okay. To help you guys remember
- 6:31the three types of risk factors for the exam,
- 6:33I like to use a simple house analogy. I love
- 6:36this one. So think of an offender's background
- 6:38as a house. First, you have the foundation. These
- 6:41are your fixed risk markers. They literally cannot
- 6:44change. Right. Like the age they committed their
- 6:46first violent act, you can't go back in time
- 6:48and undo that. Exactly. The foundation is poured.
- 6:50Next, you have the weather outside the house.
- 6:52These are variable risk markers. They change,
- 6:55but they don't necessarily cause the house to
- 6:57fall down on their own, like maybe a personality
- 6:59disorder or substance misuse. It fluctuates.
- 7:02Some days it rains, some days it is sunny. Yeah.
- 7:05And finally, you have a leaky pipe inside the
- 7:08walls. These are the causal risk factors. They
- 7:11fluctuate over time, but they directly cause
- 7:13the damage, like an attitude that actively condones
- 7:16violence. If you don't fix the leak, the house
- 7:17is going to sustain damage. That is a perfect
- 7:19way to break it down. And the way psychologists
- 7:22assess those factors has evolved a ton. We used
- 7:25to rely on unstructured clinical judgment. Which
- 7:27is basically just a doctor's gut feeling, right?
- 7:29Exactly. Highly subjective, terrible accuracy.
- 7:32So the field swung hard to actuarial procedures.
- 7:36These are strict mechanical algorithms based
- 7:39purely on data Like the static 99 tool used for
- 7:43sexual offenses, but I have to push back on that
- 7:45a bit I mean human beings aren't car insurance
- 7:47policies if I am the offender I do not want to
- 7:50be denied parole just because a spreadsheet says
- 7:52people who look like me or have my background
- 7:54reoffend Oh totally. How does an actuarial model
- 7:57account for a person's individual moral growth?
- 8:00It doesn't And that is exactly why Canadian psychologists
- 8:03developed the current gold standard, which is
- 8:06the level of Service Case Management Inventory,
- 8:09or the LS -CMI. Okay, so how does that fix the
- 8:13spreadsheet problem? It is what we call Structured
- 8:16Professional Judgment. It generates that baseline
- 8:20actuarial score, but it gives the psychologist
- 8:22the professional discretion to override the math
- 8:25if there are highly unusual circumstances. Oh,
- 8:28I see. So it brings the human element back into
- 8:30the strict math. Precisely. It tries to get the
- 8:33best of both worlds. OK, so once we've assessed
- 8:35the risk, what do we actually do about it? Because
- 8:38knowing the pipe is leaking doesn't stop the
- 8:40house from flooding. Exactly. That shifts us
- 8:42from predicting the future to trying to change
- 8:44it. Risk management. And there are four main
- 8:47strategies here. Let me guess. Throwing them
- 8:49in a cell and throwing away the key. Huh. Well,
- 8:52close. First is monitoring, which is basically
- 8:55surveillance. Then there is supervision, which
- 8:58actively restricts their freedom. Like ankle
- 9:00monitors or curfews? Right. Then you have victim
- 9:03safety planning, which is target hardening to
- 9:06protect specific people. And finally, you have
- 9:08treatment, which is the actual rehabilitation
- 9:10part. And for treatment, the textbook says the
- 9:12dominant framework is the RNR model. Risk. need
- 9:16and responsivity. Yep. It is super straightforward,
- 9:19but incredibly important. The risk principle
- 9:22says you have to match the intensity of the treatment
- 9:24to the level of risk. Right. So you don't put
- 9:27a low level shoplifter in an intense daily group
- 9:30therapy session with high risk violent offenders.
- 9:33You are basically just sending them to a networking
- 9:35event for crime. Exactly. Then the need principle
- 9:38says you only target criminogenic needs, the
- 9:41actual leaky pipes causing the crime. So no generic
- 9:45self -esteem workshops if the actual problem
- 9:47is a severe drug addiction. You got it. And lastly,
- 9:51responsivity means tailoring the delivery to
- 9:53that specific offender's learning style and cognitive
- 9:55abilities. And does it actually work? It really
- 9:57does. The data shows that programs following
- 10:00all three RNR principles saw a 35 % reduction
- 10:04in recidivism. Wow. Yeah. And programs that ignored
- 10:07them sometimes actually increased recidivism.
- 10:10A good example of RNR is the Reasoning and Rehabilitation
- 10:12Revised program. It is a cognitive behavioral
- 10:15treatment that teaches offenders to literally
- 10:17think before they act. It drops reconviction
- 10:20rates from 60 % down to 48%. That is a huge drop.
- 10:23But still, a nearly 50 % failure rate is tough.
- 10:26And I think part of the problem is that R &R
- 10:29is heavily rooted in that ethic of control we
- 10:31talked about earlier. How so? Well, it is all
- 10:34about stopping bad behavior. It is totally deficit
- 10:37-focused. Ah. Right. And that brings us to the
- 10:41alternative approach, the good lives model or
- 10:44the GL model. This one leans all the way into
- 10:46the ethic of care. Yeah, because the good lives
- 10:48model argues that just telling people not to
- 10:51commit crimes isn't motivating at all. Exactly.
- 10:53You have to help them fulfill basic human needs
- 10:56like autonomy, relatedness to other people, and
- 10:59mastery of a skill. Give them a positive reason
- 11:02to live a good life rather than just telling
- 11:05them to avoid a bad one. Okay, I have one last
- 11:07analogy to cement this for you guys before the
- 11:09exam. Think of R &R like taking a driver who
- 11:13keeps crashing and just slapping speed limiters
- 11:15and heavy bumpers on their car. Keeping society
- 11:18safe from them. Right. But the Good Lives model
- 11:20is like asking that driver where they actually
- 11:23want to go in life and teaching them how to read
- 11:25a map so they don't even want to drive off a
- 11:27cliff in the first place. Don't we inherently
- 11:29need both? We absolutely do. You need the control
- 11:32to keep people safe right now, but you need the
- 11:34care to actually change the future. Man, this
- 11:37has been such a dense study session. We went
- 11:39from the deep moral complexities of the Latimer
- 11:42case to the incredibly harsh demographic realities
- 11:46of who actually gets incarcerated. We really
- 11:48covered a lot. Yeah. And we looked at the psychological
- 11:50tools from the LSCMI to the R &R model that try
- 11:54to balance keeping society safe with actually
- 11:57helping offenders rebuild their lives. Now I
- 11:59want to leave you guys with one final thought
- 12:01to mull over. We learned today that the system
- 12:04shifted over the last century from pure physical
- 12:07punishment to a real focus on rehabilitation.
- 12:10Right. The Archambault report. Exactly. Yeah.
- 12:13But with rising costs, mandatory minimums, and
- 12:16this massive over -representation of marginalized
- 12:19groups, we have to ask ourselves, are we actually
- 12:22rehabilitating people? Or are we just relying
- 12:25on correctional psychologists to put a scientific
- 12:27band -aid on much deeper societal failures? Oof.
- 12:30That is the question. Next time you read about
- 12:32a crime in the news, ask yourself... what would
- 12:34it actually take to fix the root cause rather
- 12:36than just locking away the symptom? Thank you
- 12:38guys so much for joining us for this deep dive
- 12:40into the text. Keep questioning the why behind
- 12:43human behavior and we will catch you next time
- 12:44on The Psychology Undergrad.