Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage a Team Member Who Always Says I Told You So
Transcript
- Lucas: There's a phrase that can quietly poison a team's willingness to take risks, and it's only three words long: 'I told you so.' Luna: Oh, I've been on the receiving end of that. It's infuriating. But as a manager, what do you actually do about it? Lucas: Right. And it's tricky because the person saying it is often technically correct — they did predict the outcome. But the cost to the team's culture can be huge. Before we dig into the fix, a quick thing: if episodes like this help you think through a management challenge, and you've got a couple bucks to spare, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Keeps the show ad-free and coming to you every Monday. Luna: Yeah, we really appreciate that. And honestly, it's a small way to say this content matters to you. Lucas: Okay, so let's get into the dynamics. I want to start with a real case I heard from a product manager at a mid-size SaaS company. She had a senior engineer — let's call him Dan — who was brilliant but had this habit of saying 'I told you so' after any project that hit a snag. Luna: Classic. And I bet the junior engineers stopped bringing ideas to the table pretty quickly. Lucas: Exactly. Within three months, the team's velocity dropped, and the PM noticed that in retrospectives, people were more focused on covering themselves than on learning. So the first step for her was a private conversation with Dan, not in front of the team. Luna: What did she say? I imagine she needed to be really specific. Lucas: She used a script like this: 'Dan, I want to talk about something that's been coming up in our post-mortems. When a project doesn't go as planned, I've noticed you often say things like "I told you so." I know you're trying to highlight that we could have anticipated the issue, but the effect is that other team members feel defensive and less willing to share ideas in the future. Can we talk about a different way to surface those learnings?' Luna: That's direct without being accusatory. How did Dan react? Lucas: He was taken aback at first — he honestly thought he was being helpful. But once she framed it as a team culture issue, he was willing to change. And here's the key: she didn't just tell him to stop. She gave him an alternative. She said, 'Instead of "I told you so," could you say something like "I'm glad we're surfacing this now — here's what I saw coming and why"?' Luna: Ah, so reframing from being right to being a teacher. That's smart. Lucas: Right. And it works because it preserves his expertise while removing the blame. But there's a deeper layer here, which is the team norm. The PM also started a new practice in retrospectives: she would explicitly ask, 'What did we learn that we didn't expect?' That way, everyone — including Dan — is focused on learning, not on who predicted what. Luna: I love that. And there's actually data behind this. I was reading a Harvard Business Review study from 2024 that looked at psychological safety in teams. They found that teams with a high psychological safety score were 67% more likely to surface mistakes early — which is huge for catching problems before they blow up. Lucas: That's a perfect stat to bring in. And 'I told you so' is basically the opposite of psychological safety. It punishes the person who took the risk, even if that risk was reasonable. Over time, people just stop proposing bold ideas. Luna: So what about when the person saying it is genuinely always right? Like, Dan might actually have a better track record than anyone else. Does that change the approach? Lucas: It doesn't change the core intervention, but it does add a nuance. You still need to address the behavior, but you can also acknowledge his accuracy privately. Something like, 'Dan, I really value your foresight — you've saved us from several pitfalls. But I need your help in sharing that insight in a way that builds the team up rather than making people feel small.' Luna: So you're validating his contribution while still setting a boundary. That's a delicate balance. Lucas: Exactly. And you have to be consistent. If you let it slide when he's right, the behavior will continue. The team is watching. Luna: What about the person on the receiving end? As a manager, do you also talk to them? Lucas: Yes, but more to check in. You might say, 'I noticed that comment from Dan in the meeting. How did that land with you?' That gives the employee a chance to vent and also signals that you're aware and you care about the team climate. Luna: And if they're feeling discouraged, you can coach them on how to respond in the moment — maybe something like, 'Thanks, Dan. Let's capture that learning for next time.' Lucas: Right. That's a great way to neutralize it without escalating. But ultimately, the manager has to own the culture. If 'I told you so' becomes a pattern, it's on you to address it. Luna: So let's say you're a first-time manager and this just happened. Walk me through the exact steps you'd take this week. Lucas: Step one: observe. Make sure it's a pattern, not a one-off. Step two: have the private conversation using the specific script we talked about. Step three: offer an alternative phrase. Step four: change the team ritual — like reframing retrospectives to focus on learning. And step five: follow up individually with both the person saying it and the people on the receiving end. Luna: And how long would you expect it to take before you see a shift? Lucas: If you're consistent, you'll usually see a change within two to three weeks. But the team's trust might take longer to rebuild — especially if the behavior went on for months. So patience is key. Luna: That's really practical. I think a lot of managers know this behavior is toxic but don't know how to name it or address it without sounding like they're punishing expertise. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the trap — you don't want to discourage the person from sharing their insights. You just want to change how they share them. The goal is to move from 'I told you so' to 'Here's what I see — let's learn from it together.' Luna: I think that's a great way to put it. One last thing — what about the occasional 'I told you so' that's said jokingly among friends on the team? Is that okay? Lucas: Context matters. If it's a high-trust team and everyone's laughing, it's probably fine. But if there's even a hint of tension, it's better to avoid it altogether. As a manager, you can model the tone you want. Luna: Fair enough. So the takeaway: 'I told you so' is a culture issue, not just a personality quirk. And fixing it starts with a private, specific conversation. Lucas: Exactly. Name it, reframe it, and change the team rituals. Do that consistently, and you'll see a shift in how freely people share ideas — even the risky ones. Luna: Thanks, Lucas. That's a solid game plan for any manager. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And to our listeners — good luck having that conversation this week. It is worth it.