Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Minis - Put the brakes on bad journalism
Transcript
- 0:00Oh, it's me. Okay. Again, guys. I shouldn't put you on the spot like this. You know,
- 0:06you know the topics at this point, right? Yeah. But I'm picking for you this one because I made
- 0:13the dealer's choice category and that's what I'm picking from today because I came across something
- 0:18that I really liked and I ought to share. I don't know if this is too mainstream, but it fits into
- 0:23our overall gringiness. Okay. This one's filed under dealer's choice. However, I would also see it
- 0:30fitting under feeling like an update and feeling bad. So I'm going to click on it here just now.
- 0:35And this title is from the New York Post and it is from March 5th, 2004. It is still relevant,
- 0:42just I'll have you know, by Shannon Thaler. And it's an update, you say? Yeah, you'll know why
- 0:47it's an update once I start talking. So this one's titled, Electric Vehicles Release More Toxic
- 0:53Emissions Are Worse For The Environment Than Gas-Powered Cars. Okay. It's the New York Post.
- 0:59It's incredibly conservative. I take a lot of things where they're kind of counterculture at
- 1:04face value. Yeah, I was trying to fit there. I had a topic in mind and this one fit what I wanted
- 1:11to talk about the most. Let's just read it. I'm interested just because of one of the timelines.
- 1:17That's early on with electric cars. 2024. Oh, I'm sorry. I heard 2004. Oh, 2024. You missed the 20.
- 1:24Let's just get into it. And then we maybe it's the discussion you came for today. It's a mini
- 1:28though. We can't talk that much. Electric vehicles release more toxic particles into the atmosphere
- 1:33and are worse for the environment than their gas-powered counterparts, according to a
- 1:37resurface study. The study published by Emissions Data Firm Emissions Analytics was released in
- 1:432022 but has attracted a wave of attention this week after being cited in the Wall Street Journal
- 1:49of Sunday. It found that brakes and tires on EVs released 1850 times more particle pollution
- 1:56compared to moderate tailpipes, chap-efficient exhaust filters, and gas-powered vehicles
- 2:02emissions to new lows. Emissions comes from tire wear. As heavy cars drive on light duty tires,
- 2:08most often made with synthetic rubber made from crude oil and other fillers and additives,
- 2:12they deteriorate and release harmful chemicals into the air according to emissions analytics.
- 2:18Because EVs are on average 30% heavier, brakes and tires on the battery-powered cars wear out
- 2:23faster than on standard cars. Right, we actually talked about this in our week, all the ways we
- 2:29didn't know we're polluting episode. Yeah, the tire wear, right? Yeah. Basically, they're saying,
- 2:34let me continue and then we'll see. Emissions Analytics found that tire wear emissions on
- 2:38half a metric ton of battery weight in the EV are more than 400 times as great as direct
- 2:43exhaust particle emissions. Through reference, half of a metric ton is equivalent roughly
- 2:481,100 pounds. The most popular EV in the US, Tesla's Model Y boasts a lithium-ion battery that weighs
- 2:55in at a hefty 1,836 pounds. Another sought-after electric model, Ford's F-150 Lightning Pickup
- 3:02Truck also has an approximately 1,800 pound battery. Study throws doubt on the practicality
- 3:07of the Biden administration's EV mandates, which tout electric cars as zero-emission vehicles,
- 3:12in a quest to force two-thirds of new cars in America to be all-electric by the year 2032.
- 3:18California lawmakers have similarly referred to EVs as producing zero emissions because they
- 3:23don't have tailpipes per the journal, which added that the label is deceptive. Electric cars still
- 3:28use tires made from petroleum that create particle pollution as they wear. Still, this will not be
- 3:33something that stops electrification. Nick Molden, the founder and CEO of Emissions Analytics
- 3:38Hillpost. I'm going to stop here. Basically, you saw in that last two sentences that my whole
- 3:45complaint about the New York Post. The reason they're doing that is because they found something
- 3:49that goes against the Democrats. Basically, the point that I was just trying to make from this
- 3:54article is that electric vehicles aren't as good for the environment as they're being told. They
- 3:59are. This one comes in the form of tires and how they burn through tires at a much faster rate
- 4:06than other vehicles. And we learned in our previous episode that tires are hugely bad.
- 4:11They're polluting in ways that we don't really contemplate that well. They're terrible for
- 4:15fish. You've got to remember, anytime it rains, every particle that's on that road is going into
- 4:20the rivers. I need everybody to understand me when I say this. I am against electric cars
- 4:25for completely different reasons than the New York Post is in here. It's night and day for the
- 4:31reasons that we would be. I agree. They're not great for the environment. Are they better for
- 4:35the environment than gas-powered vehicles, though? Kind of a little bit. My whole problem with it
- 4:41is that we should be moving away from automobiles as the main form of transportation. I mean,
- 4:46that makes sense. Honestly, when you're looking at a lot of the things that are popping up in
- 4:49cities now, especially electric bikes and scooters, much better ways to go, but we should be on trains.
- 4:54Just going to leave that part there. When they're talking about this polluting the air,
- 4:58they're completely discounting the fact that they're not even talking about carbon dioxide or
- 5:03things that aren't as toxic per se as a pollutant. They're just disregarding that. When they're
- 5:07talking about this from the New York Post point of view, also, they said that, look, our filters are
- 5:11great on the tailpipes. It's a great talking point, but that's still going to end up somewhere.
- 5:16It's just not in the air right there. And I went on the EPA Environmental Protection Agency in the
- 5:22U.S. They kind of have this question posted as myths about electric vehicles. Myth number one,
- 5:28electric vehicles are worse for the climate than gasoline cars because of power plant emissions,
- 5:32which is something they were kind of talking about. EVs have no tailpipe emissions, generating the
- 5:36electricity used to charge EVs, however, may create carbon pollution. The amount varies widely based
- 5:40on how local power is generated. To the extent that more renewable energy sources like wind and
- 5:45solar are used to generate electricity, the total greenhouse gases associated with EVs could be
- 5:49even lower if we change over. That was actually a bad thing to bring up. I don't know why I brought
- 5:53it up. I thought there were more in there. Apparently the New York Post was a bad thing to
- 5:56bring up as well. But really, I just wanted to find an article that was talking about how many
- 6:02tires the test was they're burning through when you say they're burning. Yeah, no. And that's a
- 6:06fair point. And I have used the New York Post before. It's just something that I always preface.
- 6:12It is the New York Post. Overall, they might be saying something right, but it's not for the right
- 6:17reasons that always pisses me off. So yes, I agree. There is a problem with the weight of cars. We
- 6:22should be moving away from cars. And that's where we fundamentally disagree with the New York Post.
- 6:28Again, my message was just they're burning through tires. It's simpler than the New York Post.
- 6:35They just had the first article that agreed with me, kind of, as far as the simple point I wanted
- 6:41to make. And I think it probably has to do with the regenerative braking as well. But I don't
- 6:46know about that. I couldn't tell you either. I don't know. I don't even know if they fundamentally
- 6:49use the same braking system. But I do technically agree with some of the things they're saying in
- 6:54that there are problems with pollution with electric vehicles that we didn't have to deal
- 6:58with before. They discount the standard issues of pollution that gasoline power cars are emitting.
- 7:05They're just completely disregarded for them. That's that. Something to keep in mind when
- 7:09you're looking at that and take it with a grain of salt. So they're that. I think that's a good thing.
- 7:14The main thing to keep in mind is that Chelsea wanted to tell you that Tesla's go through more
- 7:18tires. She sure did. Good work, Chelsea. Remember that for 48 hours. Goodbye.