Latest / Automotive State of The Union / China Already Banned the Types of Cars America Is Trying to Ban with John Bozzella
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Thursday, September 24th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. We got John Bozzella on the show today- Yo... with the Alliance of Automotive Innovation. I'm Paul Jay Daly. That's Kyle Montzer.
- 0:10So much to talk about. China's in the house. And- [sighs] That's kind of fun to say. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Fun, eventful. China's in the house. China's in the house today, folks. They're here, baby.
- 0:23And we got John Bozzella on- They've done run up, they've done Run Up on the Hill, and we got some opinions on it. I hope they're not running up on the Hill. [laughs] I hope not.
- 0:30That, that, that's all the wrong imagery in my mind. [laughs] That's true. That's true. Ah. Okay, okay, I said that wrong. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 0:35Well, all right, but either way, we got John Bozzella, who is just, uh, an authority on what's going on in the OEM world. He represents so many of the OEMs.
- 0:42He's given us some time, so we're gonna, uh, have an interview with him here in just a second. We do wanna thank our friends at autohub.io. Today's show is made possible by them.
- 0:51Dealers, uh, helping dealers buy their cars, buy some cars from their own customers in minutes, whether they're in the showroom, the service drive, o- or online. You can visit autohub.io to learn more.
- 1:05Um, also, we need to talk a little bit about ASOTU CON West. We had a webinar yesterday. You can still get a hold of that. We had a webinar yesterday. Yeah. You gotta check out the webinar.
- 1:13You can still do, go to asotu.com, scroll down just a little bit. Uh, and if you're thinking, "Hey, how do I appraise more cars? How do I get more vehicles on trade?
- 1:21How do I make sure that my managers are held to the expectations?" We covered it all yesterday. There we go.
- 1:26Rachel Holloway with Gilchrist Automotive was absolutely sublime, uh, and, and gave some real practical takeaways that any used car operator, uh, can dial in. Uh, so you gotta check it out. There you go.
- 1:37Now, now you can tell them about ASOTU CON West, Paul. I've been waiting. Now you can do that. I've been waiting. ASOTU CON West is coming. And I know it's event season, and there's a lot crammed in.
- 1:44That's why we made ASOTU CON West to be fly in, fly out, one day on the West Coast, a place we've never done a live event before. You... It's on November 18th. Beautiful time to be in West LA.
- 1:56Uh, so you can go to asotuconwest.com and check out the list of speakers and topics. We're talking mobile service. We're talking AI implementation in a very practical way.
- 2:05We're talking affordable used cars by way of used EVs. Hey. We also have Vic Keller and Jack Hollis and Steve Greenfield and Alex Lawrence and so many others. Again, fly in, fly out. Starts at 10:00, ends at 5:00.
- 2:19Get the best piece of swag we've ever created, by the way. The best. asotuconwest.com. But now for the main event- Dude-... of today's show...
- 2:26I'm so jealous because you got the opportunity to hang out with John Bozzella. Uh, we've got that interview primed for you today because today is a day that is really in the eyes of a lot of people.
- 2:38I can't wait to see what happens. Uh, and I'm sure John's got some thoughts, so let's check out that interview. Hope you enjoy it. John Bozzella, it's good to be here with you today. Paul, love being with you.
- 2:49All right, so, um, listen, there's no shortage of things to talk about right now. Whenever the auto industry is a part of public discourse for positive reasons, like, we get super excited around here.
- 3:00And I think this convergence of events between EVs and this, uh, China visit into the White House, this dinner that's happening tonight. Uh, we know that Mary Barra's gonna be there.
- 3:10Still unforeseen whether or not, uh, Farley's gonna be there. But, um, Tesla executives are gonna be there.
- 3:16All of this stuff surrounding the auto industry, all of it around national security, OEM involvement, protecting dealers' interests, protecting the consumer.
- 3:25Um, we haven't, you and I haven't had a chance to talk about this in, in quite some time, so I would love to hear, uh, what your purview is on it and, uh, you know, what your, your members and all are thinking about what's happening right now.
- 3:37Yeah. So first of all, um, such an important, like, sort of point in this whole... You know, this is a big moment. It really is when you think about it, right? So, like, what's happening now?
- 3:49So for some time, um, policymakers have been raising concerns
- 3:55about the national security and surveillance risks associated with connected vehicles made in China or made by Chinese companies that could be controlled or influenced by the government coming into the market.
- 4:08Like, well, why is that? Like, think about, you know, like, your viewers know firsthand what a modern automobile is like, right? It is a rolling computer. It's a surveillance device on wheels.
- 4:23And do you want Chinese vehicles rolling past military installations in the US sending data back to China? I don't think you want that, right? So this is what policymakers are concerned about, right?
- 4:35They're also concerned about the economic security dynamics, right? Um, is the economic competition between the United States and China, is it fair?
- 4:46Like, uh, you know, our, you know, mutual friend, you know, Michael Dunne has talked a lot about this idea that, that China has created this massive automotive bubble, and it's gonna burst, right?
- 4:59And frankly, it is bursting, right? They have too much capacity supported by heavy subsidies in this sort of state, central state economy, driven economy, right?
- 5:10And so they've gotta export these vehicles around the world at cut-rate prices, you know, well under the cost of production in order to survive. This is the dynamic happening around the rest of the world.
- 5:22And so, like, now policymakers are focused on this. So- So you're seeing it on Capitol Hill, and you're seeing it in the White House...
- 5:28the, the last point that you brought up is very interesting because if you, you look at it from that scenario, United States, by far the largest automotive market in the world.
- 5:38So, you know, if, if I'm China, I'm looking at it as a gigantic, the way you put it, like, if they're on life support. This is an oxygen tank, right? Yes.
- 5:45And if they can tap into it, it could be something that can keep the bubble inflated for a while longer. I wanna, I wanna move back to the surveillance comment that you just made.
- 5:53So, um, I've recently learned over the last couple weeks that there are places in China where Teslas are not allowed to drive It seems like for this very same reason. Is, am I, am I reading that right?
- 6:05You are 100% right. So here's the way it works. Not only, they, they, they also, any vehicle that's a, call it a foreign vehicle, in China, ah, cannot send any data outside of China.
- 6:21So anything related to the VIN, any information. So you, like, look, people who are watching this, they know how sort of the back end of a, a, of an auto manufacturer works, right?
- 6:29So data may come off the vehicle for predictive maintenance purposes or what have you to inform the... That can't happen in China, right?
- 6:37So China put these restrictions in place well before the United States ever started contemplating them. So you're 100% right. Do you think that there's, um, a world where they are able to satisfy those requirements?
- 6:49So for instance, restrict the area that Chinese vehicles can drive and perhaps come up with some type of agreement where there is, uh, I mean, it, this seems like a further stretch, non-Chinese software in these vehicles, which doesn't seem feasible, but at least data, the data warehoused so that it cannot leave the United States.
- 7:09Do you see that as a plausible option? Yeah. So this is a great question, right?
- 7:14And, and so, um, and, and, and, and the reason, and it's also a complicated question, and because it's a complicated, complicated question, that's why Senator Bernie Moreno and Senator Elissa Slotkin, Senator Bernie Moreno, a Republican from Ohio, and Senator Elissa Slotkin, a Democrat from Michigan, have introduced legislation.
- 7:33Because even under US connected vehicle security rules, you know, there is a little wiggle room. There could be a loophole.
- 7:42And so I think those senators have said, "Look, we don't want that happening under any circumstances." Mm-hmm. Right? And so they've tried to tighten those loopholes in the legislation that's being considered.
- 7:51And by the way, 51 senators have co-sponsored this legislation, and it's almost equally divided between Republicans and Democrats. So this is a concern that's, that, that is, like, almost universal.
- 8:07I can't think of a single other thing- That brings people together [laughs]... that the Democrats agree on in Washington. I know. Agree on, that's beautiful. I have a tie on.
- 8:14[laughs] So I'm here this morning, I'm gonna go up and do battle on Capitol Hill in my tie and suit. But, like, nobody agrees on anything else. Yeah.
- 8:21Well, leave it to the auto industry to unify some people around some things.
- 8:25So what do you think President Trump's position is on this, on this, um, you know, I don't know if it's rhetoric, I don't know if he's playing 4D chess somehow that we can't pick up, but saying like, "You know, I'd be open to the Chinese maybe having their cars here as long as they build them here and employ Americans."
- 8:43Yeah. What do you think that play might be? No, I, like, I chuckle because this is, this is the, I, I get this question asked and I ask it of my fellow automotive executive colleagues all the time.
- 8:53What do you think is actually happening here? Look, we know a few things.
- 8:58We know the President has said more than once, not just a few weeks ago, um, on a Fox News interview, but also in January in Detroit on the sidelines of the Detroit Auto Show, he has said, "Hey, look, I don't want them importing any Chinese vehicles into the United States."
- 9:14Okay, good, as far as it goes. But he's also said, "Hey, look, if the Chinese companies wanna come here and build here, I might be okay with that." Mm-hmm. All right. That's a major concern. Mm-hmm.
- 9:24So when the president says something, I listen to the president, and I take the president both literally and seriously. Mm-hmm.
- 9:31And so, like, you know, I, I think our job has been to continue to educate the administration and the president on what the risks of that are.
- 9:39I also understand that the president is, you know, among the consummate dealmakers, right? Mm-hmm. And so this, look, it could be a negotiating ploy, it could be some positioning.
- 9:47So look, again, I respect, you know, his right to put the United States in a, in a, in the appropriate negotiating posture or whatever he needs to do, but there is significant risk, not only to auto manufacturers, but to consumers and to dealerships by doing this.
- 10:03This drains the pool. You know, if you're concerned about the blue sky value of, you know, of, of, of dealerships across the country, let them in. Mm-hmm. You know, if you're not concerned. If you are concerned, don't.
- 10:16Right? I think there's some significant business risk in addition to consumer risk in this. I was, uh, at the New Jersey, um, Auto Dealer Association.
- 10:25I was at one of their meetings a couple days ago, and, uh, Glenn Mercer was one of the speakers, and we were talking about, uh, the long tail Chinese strategy to go into EVs.
- 10:33We talked about a number of things, and, you know, one of my points of feedback in that conversation was, he said, "You know, I think..."
- 10:41You know, he's like, "It's probably safe to assume we have some Republicans in the room."
- 10:44He's like, "And if so, you're, you're faced with a bit of a dilemma right now because your free market capitalist side is saying like, we need to have global competition. Hey, the best should win.
- 10:53But the other side of you, the national security side, all these other dynamics at play are at war with one another."
- 10:58And I said, "You know, I, I basically hear two positions from the same dealer, and one is, we need to protect the industry, we need to p- protect our OEMs, we need to stand with them.
- 11:07There are security risks, there are major economic risks. We need to make sure we can innovate and catch up a little bit to get a breath because, uh, the Chinese had an unfair advantage going into it."
- 11:16And then as soon as the mic goes off, they lean over and they say, "But if they are coming here, put me first on the list to sell them [laughs]." Yeah.
- 11:24So look, I, uh, y- I, I th- I think we can satis- to, to, to, to Greg's point of view, I think we could satisfy both wings of the argument. Um, by the way, if you let them in now, it, it's game over.
- 11:35It just destroys the entire automotive ecosystem. So there's, there's absolutely no, no win. Right. Even if they use a dealer network. Right. Which they would have to. Even if they use a dealer network.
- 11:44Which they have to. Because look, we're a pa- we're a mature market. We're 16, 16 and a half million unit market. Mm-hmm. We're not growing the market, so this pie stays the same. We're just robbing from somebody else.
- 11:57And that's where you, that's where you affect the value, you know, the value of these dealerships. But here's the thing to think about over the mid to long term. You gotta take two strategies.
- 12:07You gotta protect- And promote. So you, yet, yes, we can't have unfair competition or surveillance vehicles, so that's the protect part.
- 12:16But we also have to promote US automotive competitiveness against competitors like China. Because look, I can't predict the future. I can't say that this, this, this will hold up forever, right?
- 12:29So we need to be focused also, you know, on making sure that we are globally competitive as an industry. Yes.
- 12:38Now, the, I think one of the final, final things I think about, even, like, let's play the tape to the end for a second, and I would love your thoughts on this.
- 12:45Say the Chinese are allowed to build and manufacture and sell their vehicles here. I think there are a number of other roadblocks in the way.
- 12:52Number one, I don't think that their fac- If you s- put a Chinese factory up against, um, a traditional OEM factory or, you know, like, how many people are we actually employing?
- 13:03I think the Chinese factories will largely be much more automated and will create a lot fewer jobs after they're up and running than people expect. And the second part of that is
- 13:13you look at places where there, that can support an automotive factory, and you look at the zoning and you look at the places they would be located, and I don't know that there would be a whole lot of support from communities saying, like, "I would love a large, ominous Chinese factory in my backyard."
- 13:29So I think that there's some headway there that also- It- If you play it to the end... 100% right. So you're right on the first point, like, I think they're gonna be highly automated plants.
- 13:38The other thing to keep in mind is this is gonna be kit manufacturing. They're gonna, their supply chains are still gonna be Chinese, the, the, the components are still gonna be Chinese.
- 13:45They're gonna box them up, ship them over- Assemble them here... and just assemble them here. But to your point also, this is sorta like the Chinese farmland thing, right? Yes. Like, this is just like that.
- 13:56Oh, yeah, sure, like, like they're buying up all this farmland. Except harder to hide- Yeah, they're-... honestly... commu- communities are like, "What are you doing?" Mm-hmm. Yeah.
- 14:04So, um, John, [laughs] it's gonna be amazing to see. We'll have to follow up and get your thoughts after this dinner, 'cause obviously this week is gonna be more and more unfolding, a lot more in the coming weeks.
- 14:12Thank you so much for the work that you do, and thank you as always for sharing some of your time and insight with us. Thank you, Paul. I love what you guys do. Really appreciate it.
- 14:21Okay, at the e- you, Kyle, you and I had a, a question yesterday. We're like, "How do we get a ticket to the dinner tonight?" [laughs] How do we get a ticket? I asked John after we got done recording.
- 14:30He was just like, "Nah." He just left, you know. He just left. Which is pretty much what you did. [laughs] No ticket to the dinner. Uh, so glad that Mary Barra is gonna be present at this.
- 14:38Um, obviously, hopefully we're gonna hear a lot more about this. We're gonna stay on top of it, so if you wanna get, like, the recaps and all that, you should subscribe to our newsletter.
- 14:47You can go to, uh, daily, D-A-I-L-Y, daily.asotu.com, or just asotu.com and subscribe there. But we're gonna archive and chronicle everything we're doing, keep you on the edge.
- 14:57And again, if you have some comments, some commentary, uh, let us know. And you get the email- Yeah... you can reply to the email. Let us know. We'll answer your questions. Hit us in the comments, man. We'll be there.
- 15:05Yeah. We'll join you. Oh, that's my, I have to- That's your turn... roll the outro mu- That's my turn to roll the outro music. That's how you do it. Extend it.
- 15:10Um, if you can't tell, we're paying attention, we're excited. You know why? 'Cause retail auto, the best industry in the world, in the United States, is at the center of conversation.
- 15:17It's our turn to do something good for the community. [upbeat music]