Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Touching Therapists, Butlers, and Immoral Kirk
Transcript
- 0:00So Bob emails what he said, Yeah, anonymous patron, She says,
- 0:04Hello, Kirk and Bob, the way that you both share insights into the
- 0:08process of healing and relational therapy has helped be so much so just chiming in
- 0:14so the way you both share insights into the process of healing and relational therapy
- 0:18has been helpful to me. That's cool. Both Kirk's experience from years of
- 0:22doing this work, and especially Bob's insights into his personal therapy, have helped
- 0:27me to understand that my own experience is not that unusual. You reassured me
- 0:33that feelings I find too shameful to speak about are actually normal or even healthy,
- 0:38and this allowed me to raise them my feelings with my therapist with less
- 0:43fear that she would react badly. Recently, I feel a real shift within
- 0:48me and I wanted to thank you for that. That's lovely, thinks,
- 0:51So just chiming in here, Bob, what do you think that's thank you
- 0:54for writing and telling us. It's really lovely to hear. Thanks. Going
- 0:58on with email. One of my issues in therapy has always been struggling with
- 1:03trust and struggling to believe that my therapist really cares about me. In my
- 1:07worst moments, I thought she actively wanted to harm me. Wow. It
- 1:11was extremely distressing and frustrating. Recently this has improved hugely, and I feel
- 1:19like I can feel that my therapist cares about me and supports me even when
- 1:26I'm not with her. So just chiming in. In her longer email,
- 1:29she's talking about how she would in session achieve trust, but then a few
- 1:34days after the session she would return to my therapist doesn't really care about me,
- 1:41and then a few days later my therapist might be actively trying to get
- 1:45me. Of course, this has to do with schemes developed in a situation
- 1:49in which you had an attachment figure that was actually, at the very least
- 1:53giving you a very reasonable impression that not only is your attachment feel you're not
- 2:00there for you, caring about you, but actually is actively working against you.
- 2:06So that creates this dichotomy within the self of I am in desperate need
- 2:12for attachment security because I've never gotten it, But the closer I get to
- 2:15someone, the more terrified I am. Yeah, and the typical background is
- 2:21severe abuse. It's not just like a general feeling of neglect from a parent.
- 2:24It's actual physical sexual harm that is occurring from the main attestmentheure the person
- 2:32I need is also dangerous. Yeah, so going on, it feels so
- 2:38powerful and unbelievably good to carry that feeling with me that my therapist is a
- 2:43safe person that cares about me. I'm not sure that I would have stuck
- 2:47with it and gotten to this point without hearing again and again from you that
- 2:53healing takes place in safe relationships. So thank you so much for this,
- 2:58Bob. What do you think about that? Thanks telling us. It's lovely
- 3:00to hear. What I think is you're internalizing a good object. This is
- 3:07just a way of saying you feel safe in your attachment to your therapist and
- 3:12the therapist that lives inside you. You're viewing them as safe. That's lovely.
- 3:23That's a fundamental shift. That's a big deal. Yeah, really big
- 3:25deal. Hard to achieve, but agreed, worth striving for. So I
- 3:30have a question about touch and therapy. I do therapy via video call,
- 3:37and my therapist lives several hours from me. However, I have met with
- 3:40her in person for therapy a couple of times. Before I go further,
- 3:46I should say that my therapist has firm boundaries about finishing on time and about
- 3:51out of session contact. She is understanding of how boundaries can feel cold,
- 3:55but she keeps these boundaries firm even if I am upset or I try to
- 4:00challenge them. We discuss boundaries, and she's always saying that they are there.
- 4:08The boundaries are there to keep me safe. We are both female,
- 4:12by the way, and I think she's about twenty years older than me,
- 4:15So any thoughts on that, Bob. This is the caveat before going into
- 4:18the question here. It sounds ideal. Yeah, yeah. For people with
- 4:26disorganized attachments or a personalite sort of a schema of this sort, it is
- 4:33often very important that therapists provide a very firm but loving set of boundaries,
- 4:40because when boundaries are loose, then the client might be confused and or will
- 4:47be hurt when you finally do draw the boundary, you know, like,
- 4:50oh, yeah, if you are opening of a boundary that says, yeah,
- 4:56go ahead and text me whenever and say for a few months, it's
- 5:00a text every three weeks or something, and it's pretty brief. Well,
- 5:03the client goes through a crisis and they start or they get attached to you
- 5:06and they start texting you throughout the day, like maybe it's not immediate,
- 5:11but over time, and it's twenty five texts in a day, and your
- 5:16style of therapy or of your life professionally and personally is not to be constantly
- 5:23on call regarding that, and at some point you have to draw a boundary.
- 5:28Well, that's going to hurt them, that's going to feel very abandoning,
- 5:32and they are inevitably going to think that you're either not really caring about
- 5:38them or that they screwed up somehow, and so it might destroy the therapy
- 5:45or provide a major thorn in the side of the progress of therapy moving forward.
- 5:50So it's important from the beginning from the get go, particularly if the
- 5:55therapist to texts a client that might have issues like this, is to have
- 6:00very firm but loving boundaries. You might even say, look, you can
- 6:04text me for these circumstances, or you can text me once a day.
- 6:10As long as it's with this that you know Stott, that you have to
- 6:13say no texting. It just has to be consistent and you as a therapist
- 6:17have to say so in all contexts with every client. By the way,
- 6:24am I okay with this? That's always the question to ask, Like if
- 6:28a therapist were to say, you know what, maybe it'd be a good
- 6:31idea with this client if I open up the possibility of texting me throughout the
- 6:35day. So the question should be, am I okay with that? In
- 6:41perpetuity with this client? Because if I work with this client for the rest
- 6:44of my life? Is that? Is that okay with me? And two?
- 6:47Am I okay with every client? Because it's harmful to potentially give special
- 6:55treatment to one client. If word gets out, other clients will be like,
- 6:59well, I know that you're doing that. How come you're not doing
- 7:00it with me? Am I a bad person? It's a little bit of
- 7:03a less of a problem because there are justifications for some measures. You know,
- 7:09when I was treating people with eating disorders, I had a lot more
- 7:13contact with those folks, So you can make justification. But if it's not
- 7:17really clear as to what the justification is, then you can harm other clients.
- 7:23You can also give the wrong impression of the client that they're a special
- 7:26person and that they're more than a client, you know, which can be
- 7:30hurtful to a client as well. So you just have to ask yourself,
- 7:34am I okay with this forever because if you're not, then then don't do
- 7:42it. Also, am I okay with my client exploiting the nature of this
- 7:46boundary that I'm setting? You know? You know, because a lot of
- 7:50therapists say, you know, I'll open up the possibility of them texting me
- 7:54whenever they want, because you know what client is going to text me throughout
- 7:58the day. Well, you know, it's not common, but it can
- 8:01occur. So it's just a question that you just have to ask yourself.
- 8:05A lot of therapists have a hard time with this sort of thing because they
- 8:09feel like they're being mean. They got in the field because they wanted to
- 8:11be helpful to people, and they feel like having a boundary is like saying
- 8:16no, and that's kind of a mean thing to do, and so they
- 8:18can get loose. So it's really something we all need to be mindful of
- 8:24and considerate of and as best we can clear with ourselves about what our real
- 8:28limit is. Because ain't nobody sprinting through life. It's all a marathon.
- 8:31So if it's not going to work in ten years, you probably should be
- 8:35very careful about what you do now, right, Yeah, right, And
- 8:41you know, I appreciate the concern or effort to quickly be helpful to a
- 8:48client, but you have to be able to sustain that help over time.
- 8:54So this therapist is really good at it. Right, This therapist has really
- 9:00great boundaries and sounds like there's been a lot of conversations about it. It
- 9:03sounds like this client anonymous patron has really pushed those boundaries and said, hey,
- 9:09you know, at least requested, if not been upset about boundaries being
- 9:15established, and they've had long, helpful, reparative conversations about that. That's
- 9:20probably a significant part of what's been helpful in therapy. Yeah, so,
- 9:24right on, So going on, I do therapy via. Oh sorry,
- 9:33I went by so and just a reminder, she's saying, you know,
- 9:39we're both female and she's about twenty years old of me. Okay. At
- 9:41a previous in person session we had hugged. We discussed it beforehand, and
- 9:48it felt good and safe to me when we hugged. This time this second
- 9:52session in person, I asked if she would also sit next to me for
- 9:58some of the time and if I could hold her hand. So, Bob,
- 10:01if a client asked you to do that, what would you say you're
- 10:07hemming and hawing. Yeah, I'm hemming and hawing. I'm thinking about it.
- 10:13What would I say? I would probably say yes, I would be,
- 10:22well, i'm a man, so cis gender straight straight man, So
- 10:26i'd be if I'm working with a woman and there let's say sis, gender
- 10:33and straight, then I'm going to be mindful of what is the implication here,
- 10:39and I would probably ask about what's needed or wanted. I'm not a
- 10:48I should say this. I would be careful and cautious. I'm not opposed
- 10:52to it off off, just like period, but there's reason to be really
- 11:01mindful about that, and it has to be okay to say no, even
- 11:05if the reason for the no is it doesn't work for me. So if
- 11:09a thirty five year old female client were to ask you this, what would
- 11:16be your tendency. Well, my tendency is to feel like I should say
- 11:22yes because it's been asked. And I am not as good at boundaries as
- 11:31like I think this therapist is. And something like this did happen to me
- 11:37once and I had to go back on it, like I had to say,
- 11:41yeah that actually that's not okay with me, that doesn't work for me,
- 11:45and I think it was not. It was unnecessary to. It would
- 11:54have been better to have avoided from the start, to just said no from
- 11:58the start and just been firm and guilt and you know, my own kind
- 12:03of whatever got in the way of me just being plain and clear. So
- 12:07you had an impulse to say no, but you overrode that impulse because you
- 12:13were worried about displeasing them. Yeah, but that isn't necessarily that's not because
- 12:18I believe that it was therapeutic. I think I was just stuck in my
- 12:22own stuff. Yeah. And to be specific, they requested it like holding
- 12:28hands or what I think they wanted me to if I remember it. They
- 12:33wanted me to sit next to them, and yeah, I think it was
- 12:37hold hands. Yeah, and not a super uncommon request, but not very
- 12:43common and nothing wrong with someone asking no. Yeah, totally totally fine.
- 12:48Yeah and great, And you agreed to it and then did it or agreed
- 12:56to it then rescinded no. I agreed to it and did it, And
- 13:00then I think at the next meeting, what was it like to do it?
- 13:03It made me uncomfortable, Like I was like, is this really okay?
- 13:07Is there some am I sending a message that I don't want to send
- 13:11as the client making a meaning of this that you know will be confusing or
- 13:18difficult in the future, is it getting Am I making it muddy? And
- 13:24I think I did make it muddy? And did you talk about it beforehand
- 13:30regarding like what would happen and what it meant and how long it would happen?
- 13:35I think so. But to be honest with it was a long time
- 13:37ago. Yeah, I don't remember, right. And did you consult about
- 13:41it at all? No? I don't think I did. It seems like
- 13:45you would have. It seemed like I should have. Yeah, yeah,
- 13:48yeah. And if you had consulted, what would have been the result prior
- 13:52to doing it or or agreeing to it? What do you think you would
- 13:56have come up with? To turn it down? Because of just to keep
- 14:01things clear, not because there's anything. The fear is that you know my
- 14:07client will be have some make some meaning of it that you know, you
- 14:11know reinforces the schema of exploitation or danger of that having a boundary is akin
- 14:24to rejection. And so I'm accepted. If you say yes to my request,
- 14:31then I am accepted and acceptable. Whereas if you say no to my
- 14:35request, then that means you're rejecting me. Yeah. One of the things
- 14:39to think about in these situations it's not always the case, is that if
- 14:43you grew up with an attachment figure that exploited you and your boundaries, especially
- 14:50if it's sexually right, you had a parent who would coerce you and cross
- 14:56boundaries physically, and it was it's a semi safe place for the child,
- 15:03right, because some times you'll have maybe a single parent or at least a
- 15:09very challenged attachment matrix, if you will, and the few moments of attachment
- 15:15occur during the act of exploitation and harm, so you're getting abused, but
- 15:22you're also getting some nourishment, some needs bet and it will create a schema
- 15:28of that's what love is is to exploit and cross boundaries, and it can
- 15:33be very confusing to victims. They don't always grow up with the schema and
- 15:39or act on them, but many will, and as they will feel the
- 15:45safety or the urge to attach and to love, it will be associated with
- 15:50us at least somewhat of a dose, if not a strong dose of exploitation
- 15:54and crossing boundaries. They believe, as you were saying, that if I
- 16:00can cross this boundary. If I can push someone beyond their comfort zone,
- 16:06then that proves to me that they are truly with me, because if they
- 16:12say no to me, then that means, you know, black or white
- 16:18way of looking at it, means they don't really care enough about me.
- 16:22Also, I don't want to have to wait six months or six years to
- 16:27have the regular process of attachment and security and trust. I want to I
- 16:34want to fast track this, and a good way to fast track it is
- 16:40to put someone to the test, right, So, I think that can
- 16:44be another thing. I don't know if this patron was doing that. Of
- 16:48course, there's no way to know, but it's just another thing to think
- 16:52about. Because one of the ways of evaluating and assessing what the enactment or
- 16:59recreation might be for the client is to evaluate for yourself as a therapist,
- 17:02how does this feel? As long as you aren't bogged down on a lot
- 17:06of your own weirdness, if you're open and fairly healed around this topic.
- 17:11Is to think how do I feel? So, when I've had clients that
- 17:15have asked me similar things, one of the things that I will consult about
- 17:21and think about is does this feel icky or not because it might not look
- 17:26icky, but it'll feel icky to me. And if it feels icky,
- 17:30then it might be an indication of what I'm talking about. And it doesn't
- 17:34necessarily mean I don't do it, because it could still be a creative experience.
- 17:40If I were to hold the hand of a client and it felt icky,
- 17:44as long as I made sure it didn't become icky, then it could
- 17:48become a corrective experience for them, such that they walk away having recreated something
- 17:56that part of them was worried it would head down that road, but it
- 18:00didn't, you know what I mean, it might yeah, like there the
- 18:06exploitation was not re enacted, or at some point I will know I will
- 18:11have to draw a boundary somewhere because if it's icky now, they might continue
- 18:17to try to impose and coerce and invade. So I'll let this want boundary
- 18:23be crossed to some extent, but I'll make a note that there's a chance
- 18:27that they'll keep pushing, and so maybe even at the outset, I'll say,
- 18:30Okay, here's here's what we'll do, but I won't go beyond this
- 18:34point, you know, so that when it does come up, it's like
- 18:37it had already been disclosed. And this is not like clients are not bad
- 18:42for having no these urges or impulses or wants. No, it's it's it's
- 18:48on therapist to be mindful and careful. Yeah, the vast majority of people
- 18:53who want this are people with disorganized attachment, who have never had closeness.
- 19:00And for people without this kind of trauma, you can get enough of your
- 19:06needs met through talk therapy that will fulfill an individual. But for someone who
- 19:12has literally never had a single human being, including their parents, who they
- 19:18felt secure and safe and loving around, to have that physical contact is human.
- 19:25It's weird to think about a relationship that is as close as a therapist
- 19:32client relationship in this kind of reparative work to not touch at all, because
- 19:38it'd be like having a one year old child and refusing to touch them.
- 19:44Bad for a one year old. Yeah, so now is there a ton
- 19:48of touching going on? No, but there are well understood ethical guidelines and
- 19:52standards of practice around how to have touch of this nature. Sitting next to
- 19:59someone and holding their hand, it's a very common touch in therapy, or
- 20:03having your hand on the therapist puts the hand on the client's back, as
- 20:07they cry or something and you're sitting next to them. You know, there's
- 20:11a set of things. Hugging briefly at the end of session is a normal
- 20:15thing to do. Shaking hands. I like to put my hand on people's
- 20:19back as they're walking out of the office if I have the urge. You
- 20:25know, I don't always, but sometimes it just feels I don't know,
- 20:29it just feels like the right thing to do. And only through that hand
- 20:33on the back briefly can I communicate what I'm trying to communicate. And it
- 20:38communicates a lot, I think. So with hugging, with holding hands and
- 20:45sitting next to each other, you know, I'm trying to think of what
- 20:48else you could do. I mean, when it comes to kids, there's
- 20:52a whole other topic of touch in therapy because with kids, I would say
- 20:57ninety eight percent of them there was touch involved, not initiated by me,
- 21:02but by the kid. Because you know, you got a seven year old
- 21:04kid and you're playing, you know, you're throwing the ball back and forth
- 21:07in session or something, and things get a little rambunctious and fun and he's
- 21:14jumping off of a chair and I'm like, ah, yeah, that was
- 21:18great. You know, and then he wants to crash into me or something.
- 21:22Then that's technically touch and theraptally sweet. Actually yeah, Or I just
- 21:29want to ras a teenager and sort of playfully punch them in the shoulder and
- 21:33be like, oh you big galut or something. Yea, you know,
- 21:37it's it's very normal in that circumstance. There there are a lot of holding
- 21:41of hands and hugging. No, but there can be, you know,
- 21:45if the client asks for it. Especially. I remember this cute seven year
- 21:48old boy at the hospital where I used to work. He was my friend,
- 21:55was sitting in an office chair, you know, a rolling chair,
- 21:57just sitting there doing whatever that they were doing. The kid came up and
- 22:00sort of just stood between his legs and kind of leaned on leaned back on
- 22:03his knee and just just kind of the air looking down and talking and you
- 22:07know whatever. It was just a very sweet interaction. Yeah. I can't
- 22:11tell you the amount of times that happened to me. Young children would be
- 22:15either processing something or recovering from something, and they would get ever closer to
- 22:22me and then they would just want to because you know, if you've been
- 22:26around kids, they have normal urges that have not been beaten down by society,
- 22:33and they at times in a normal way, like every other primate.
- 22:37By the way, they want some physical contact. It's reassuring, it's soothing,
- 22:44it's normal. To the Internet, they'd be like disgusting, boundary violation,
- 22:48call the touch police, and it's like, have you been around children?
- 22:53Four year olds behave like four year olds, and pedophilia or being attracted
- 22:57to children is a rare fucking condition that I do not have big surprise because
- 23:03most people don't. So let it go. And the mom was totally She
- 23:11probably wanted that to happen. The mom probably wanted the daughter to bond with
- 23:15me. Sure it was a warm experience. I had one eye on the
- 23:22client and one eye on the kid client, and I'm thinking, Okay,
- 23:27what do I do? And I'm thinking, well, you know this,
- 23:30this feels, this feels good, it feels reparitive, it feels appropriate.
- 23:36And I thought, can I you know, this is all going on in
- 23:38my head as I'm because I hadn't plan on this happening, of course,
- 23:41and I'm thinking, can I justify this? Can I document it and have
- 23:45it not be something that I'm afraid of scrutiny. That's a good litmus test.
- 23:51Yeah, And I said, yeah, I can. I can justify
- 23:53this completely. I don't know how people would receive it if they heard about
- 23:57it, but fuck them because everything's fine. They're like assholes. Everybody got
- 24:03one. Yeah. So getting back to anonymous patient's email, again, mostly
- 24:11online therapy, but occasionally in person, and they did one where they hugged
- 24:18and they had planned about it beforehand. It's like sounds like maybe the client
- 24:22said, Hey, when we meet up, can you hug me? And
- 24:23this client has what looks to be a version of disorganized attachment, you know,
- 24:27that real severe need that therapy can provide of stable, secure, safe
- 24:34attachment. And so the hug was very helpful. And then the next session
- 24:38she's like, I would it be okay if you sat next to me and
- 24:41held my hand? See, I asked, he if she's sat next to
- 24:45me, She agreed, and we discussed how that will work. So when
- 24:49I met her last time, we hugged and she sat next to me for
- 24:53some of the time and I held her hand a couple of times. The
- 24:57whole experience, include the touch, was incredible. I felt so deeply cared
- 25:03for and totally accepted. What do you think of that? That's just lovely,
- 25:07that's what we want to have happen. I'm really pleased. Yeah,
- 25:11I've heard this a lot from my own clients and otherwise, that it can
- 25:17really provide an experience that talking can maybe never provide or would take years to
- 25:23provide. That if you do it right, with boundaries and with love,
- 25:32then holding someone's hand occasionally in therapy, sitting next to them, it's neurological.
- 25:37You're taking a training on neurological aspects of attachments and therapy and couples,
- 25:44right, And I'm guessing you've already been over some of the literature and research
- 25:49and evidence about the need that we have as humans and how you know,
- 25:57because we're in the Western world. We're so intellectualized and we think of everything
- 26:03as like concepts and philosophy, but we're squishy physical animals with squishy physical neurons
- 26:12that are regulated in part by touch and by attachment. The actual neural chemicals,
- 26:22the connections, the amount of firing of the amygdala, and our sleep
- 26:26and our diet and our emotional regulation, our resilience, our mood are all
- 26:33affected greatly by attachment, security, and partially as a sub category of that
- 26:41touch. You know, me and my wife, we don't love each other
- 26:45exclusively through talking, so we have of course, we have that need.
- 26:51And to have a client that has never had that without it being exploitative and
- 26:59harmful and abuse, and to have that with that kind of love and safety
- 27:04and professionalism really of boundaries of stability. You know, you just know,
- 27:11like if like this therapist, you just you can just count on this therapist
- 27:15knowing how to manage this over time. Just imagine what that would feel like
- 27:18as a client, just like I have total trust in this person and they're
- 27:25going to hold my hand and they're not going to exploit me, they're not
- 27:29going to hurt me, they're not going to shame me. And just to
- 27:32have that feeling, it's profound, it it's neurological, it's deep, it's
- 27:34life changing. So why would we not do that as therapists If we're able
- 27:41to do that, if we're comfortable with it, you know, and if
- 27:45we're uncomfortable with it, are we uncomfortable for the wrong reasons? So yeah,
- 27:49going on afterwards, I told a couple of people about my experience and
- 27:55they reacted very strongly badly. They even reacted strongly to just the hug.
- 28:02I had just had this deeply healing experience, but now I felt I shouldn't
- 28:07even talk about it, or maybe I should even question it to begin with.
- 28:11I discussed this with my therapist, and she said that touch is taboo
- 28:15with a lot of therapists, and that many have a blanket no touch rule.
- 28:22Bob, what do you think about that? I think it's true and
- 28:25ridiculous all at once. Yeah. Yeah, And I'm sorry about the response
- 28:30of the uninformed and uninitiated because it's hard. It's the brain is set up
- 28:37to believe the bad stuff. So when somebody says, oh, that's wrong
- 28:41or icky or whatever, even though you know it's fine in fact, it's
- 28:47healing and reparative, it's hard not to be impacted by ignorance. Yea,
- 28:52And so you know, I feel sad about that. That sucks. Yeah,
- 28:57there are pockets in our country and particularly around the world. But if
- 29:02we were to look at a particular pocket of in an exaggeratory sense of the
- 29:07Deep South in the nineteen twenties or the eighteen forties or something, and you're
- 29:14a white person and you raise the question as to whether or not black people
- 29:18are humans as well, that they deserve rights, or that they should not
- 29:23be slaves, or they should not be suppressed regarding the vote or something.
- 29:29If you are a white person and you're in a social gathering with a bunch
- 29:33of white people and you were to bring up this idea, we understand looking
- 29:37back that you're going to get a lot of frowns and maybe even some major
- 29:41pushback on those ideas well. That's the world we live in regarding touch today.
- 29:48You bring up the topic of touch and therapy, or in a lot
- 29:52of circumstances outside of therapy, if you were to bring up the normal,
- 29:59dare ice say, socially just topic of how touch is important and okay and
- 30:04can be facilitated in an ethical way, even among other therapists, you're gonna
- 30:10get some very fucking weird, regressive answers from people. And that's just the
- 30:18state of our culture right now, and it's not getting any better. In
- 30:21fact, I think it's getting worse, not only as our society becomes more
- 30:26disjointed and less in contact with other humans. Like it's not uncommon to have
- 30:32a human being today who might literally not touch another human being for months,
- 30:37like not touch, not a single touch, especially with the pandemic and everything,
- 30:41you know, no incidental touching at all. And I'm not saying we
- 30:45have to have that, but to have touching other humans being so foreign to
- 30:49people, you know, So it's a it's a weird world. And with
- 30:55the professionalism of our of our profession, which is a good thing, it
- 31:00things become simplified and the idea of like, well, you can't have sex
- 31:04with your clients, okay, and then but people just generalize that to say
- 31:07like any touch is a slippery slope to having sex or is sexual or something,
- 31:14you know, Like it reminds me of this one reality TV show that
- 31:18I watched, Iata Fiance, and there was this guy from Samoa who was
- 31:25in Portland, Oregon, and he was marrying a samo and half Samoan American
- 31:33woman. And the Samoan guy had his family come over to visit and he
- 31:38hadn't seen his mom in a long time. And so they're in Portland downtown
- 31:42and they hug and they they're kissing, and they kissed on the lips.
- 31:48It looked like they briefly kissed on the lips. This Semoan man I don't
- 31:53know, twenty five, thirty years old, is kissed his mom on the
- 31:56lips briefly, and his wife, the you know, someone, an American
- 32:06woman, was shaming him for this and saying like did you did you kiss
- 32:08her? And he's like what, He's like that that's what we do in
- 32:13my culture or something. That's what me and my mom do. And his
- 32:16wife is just like, oh my god, that's so disgusting, Like he
- 32:21was just without any hesitation or any change or nuance to her approach. She's
- 32:27just like, you're disgusting. That's disgusting. What's wrong with you? It's
- 32:30creepy and that really shows you something about our society, right, And I
- 32:37said, no, that's not weird. I kiss my mom on the lips.
- 32:43I don't fucking make out with my mother, but I kiss I kiss
- 32:49her on the lips. When I was a kid, my parents both kissed
- 32:52all of us on the lips, not long, not lingering, but it
- 32:58was, uh, you know, it's a kiss of affection, you know.
- 33:01And you know in other countries, other societies, other cultures, they
- 33:07will kiss on the cheek, right, It's not that different from that.
- 33:10And I got blasted for that people are just like, ew, creepy.
- 33:15I'm just thinking, what is wrong with you that you would think that me
- 33:20Kirk kissing my own mother on the lips when I say hello to her after
- 33:25not seeing her for a while. What is what's wrong with you that you
- 33:30think that there's something creepy about that? Like it'd be like if a mother
- 33:37were to change their child's diaper and wipe them down and look at that as
- 33:43if it's creepy or breastfeeding people will they'll be like, oh, it grows
- 33:47bess what the fuck is wrong with our society? And it should not affect
- 33:54us as clinicians. We should know better. There are lots of things,
- 34:00whether it's racism in history or current, whether it's this taboo regarding touch,
- 34:08whether it's taboo regarding talking about your feelings or about traumas. We should know
- 34:15better. The rest of society, who god fucking knows, they'll they'll figure
- 34:20it out hopefully eventually, I don't know. But we should not be absorbing
- 34:23those ridiculousnesses. Now you're suggesting that we have an ethical duty to be get
- 34:30beyond our own biases. Yeah, that's a good that's a great point.
- 34:35Now, I'm not saying all therapists need to agree to touching. Uh.
- 34:39You know, if someone came to me and said, I understand what you're
- 34:44saying, and at the same time, I don't want to have any touch
- 34:46in my office, I would say, totally fine, good to your own
- 34:51limit. It's not it's not that big of a deal. It's not super
- 34:54critical. There's a lot of prose to having that firm line around those kinds
- 35:00of things. But I imagine there are a lot of therapists that, left
- 35:05to their own devices, would be wanting, you know, to provide that
- 35:09sort of help, like hugging briefly at the end of session, or sitting
- 35:15next to a client while they cry, or holding the hand of a client
- 35:21as they have a panic attack, for example. I imagine there's a lot
- 35:24of therapists that have that impulse to do it, but refrain because of our
- 35:30stupid culture. This is my good. Supervision is a really important, absolutely
- 35:36important aspect of training. So going on with the end of the email,
- 35:45my therapist reassured me that her decision was very considered and her key consideration was
- 35:51what helps me and what is safe for me, And that conversation with my
- 35:53therapist was reassuring. So, what are your views on touch and therapy?
- 35:58Do you have a blanket no touch rule. We've already answered that. Do
- 36:01you think it can be very powerful if used carefully and with clear boundaries?
- 36:05Yes? What role do you think the genders are the client and the therapists
- 36:09play? Bob? Probably just to be plain about it that this is not
- 36:15a sexual thing. This is not about any kind of on the part of
- 36:21the therapists acting out any kind of erotic feeling. Erotic feelings might arise in
- 36:28a client, right, and if they arise in a therapist, then you
- 36:31really gotta that. You got to you gotta get consultation about that. It
- 36:36could happen. And if it happens, it's not like uh oh bad,
- 36:38bad bad. But but to not address it would be a huge mistake,
- 36:45especially because it could leave one blind to what's happening with their client. But
- 36:49if a client had erotic feelings, and occasionally that will happen, they just
- 36:54get to be talked about, just like anything else. Now, are there
- 36:58some therapists that will bloyit their clients. Yeah, I've talked about this for
- 37:02years. I have whole episodes dedicated to this. I think the episodes in
- 37:07question are called a therapist kisses his client or something, and it's a it's
- 37:15a problem. But for the normal therapists like you and me, the idea
- 37:21of erotic feelings even being in the ballpark of these experiences with clients is absurd
- 37:30to me. That times where I have hugged a client or held their hand
- 37:34or sat next to them or put my hand on their back as they're walking
- 37:37out the door, there's not There hasn't been a single out of sexuality or
- 37:42sexual attraction at all. The amount of love and care and warmth and attentiveness
- 37:50and good is just all that I can sense, you know, It's just
- 37:53all that's there, right, And the same way that if I hug or
- 37:58kiss my mom, it's there's no sexuality to it for one of us.
- 38:02It's totally normal. Again, if you have trauma around that, if you've
- 38:07been exploited in that way, yes it does happen, but it doesn't mean
- 38:12we just completely throw all of that away because of our puritanical, Victorian,
- 38:20anti touch, anti creep culture. It's really, it's really a problem.
- 38:27And I guess the final thing I'll say a spatron is don't talk about it
- 38:31with people that you can't trust. It'll just interfere. In the same way
- 38:37that in the eighteen forties, if a white person came to me and said,
- 38:39I want to talk about helping black people to become free of slavery,
- 38:45I would say, you got to be careful about who you talk. You're
- 38:47right, but you have to be careful about who you disclosed that to because
- 38:52you can be harmed. And that's a sad state of affairs. And I
- 38:57think it's I think it's worse now. Does it feel worse now to you?
- 39:00You don't really have a sense of the internet culture like I do.
- 39:04But do you have any sense of it being worse now? Well, I
- 39:08have a sense of the political culture, and it is worse now. We
- 39:13are very divided, we are really suspicious, We in many cases believe all
- 39:21the wrong stuff and just have our heads up our butts when it comes to
- 39:27wisdom and humanity. It's a fucking mass. Yeah, I don't know about
- 39:30the Internet culture, because it's as you say, I don't Well, there's
- 39:34I don't know if I call internet culture. But in my observation, commensurate
- 39:38with the me Too movement, which I've one hundred percent support, of course.
- 39:43Yeah, that's fantastic. There's a commensurate commensurate increase in hyper awareness around
- 39:50creepiness, which I think is half a good thing and half a bad thing.
- 39:54Yeah. Yeah, and I think the bad part is what I'm talking
- 39:58about. But you know, it's like we had a unbusted up vibe regarding
- 40:04touch before all that, so it's just another factor. I think. Yeah,
- 40:09it's like a break get back. More emails, Yep, all right,
- 40:15this thanks emails from patron Morgan. Morgan says Bob. First off,
- 40:19thank you. You are a beacon of kindness and a beacon of warmth for
- 40:23some of us that didn't get to experience those things from our dads. Thanks
- 40:29Morgan. Hows it make you feel, Bob to be other people's warm and
- 40:31kind dad touched in DEII? Thank you for being a parasocial corrective experience for
- 40:38me each and every time I hear you speak. You're hired, Morgan.
- 40:45My question for you is this, do you ever experience a compelling need to
- 40:50freeze when your relational trauma is triggered, like you get stuck in needing something
- 40:57like a hug, love, or care from your partner, but you get
- 41:00stuck in the scared mode. For me, I become paralyzed like I'm overwhelmed
- 41:06with all my personal failures, with all my not good enoughs, and I
- 41:10expect my partner to notice me and help me. And I want this help,
- 41:15but I'm stuck and I'm scared to ask for it. He's never given
- 41:17me a reason not to trust that he will care for me, and he
- 41:21often will without question. And by the way, I grew up with a
- 41:23dad with a personality disorder. I'm now a clinician specializing in personality disorders.
- 41:30I can help others with similar trauma, but I can't seem to shake the
- 41:34visceral feeling of shame, anger, and fright when I'm in this mode.
- 41:38What advice would you give to someone like me? Thank you? Well,
- 41:44the first part of your question is does that ever happen to me all the
- 41:47time? And it's really lonely. I'm sorry it's happening to you. Feel
- 41:52sad for both of us. I have a sense of any I might want
- 42:00is going to be experienced as intrusive or rejectable, and so there are times
- 42:06when I want that I don't ask, and it can lead me to feeling
- 42:09resentful because Colleen can't do anything about what she's not aware of. And it's
- 42:16as you say, your partner hasn't given you any reason to distrust and neither
- 42:21has mine. And I think actually, she would really like it if I
- 42:25reached for her more. Yeah, you don't think that. You know that,
- 42:30You've talked about it a lot. Yeah, she would like that.
- 42:32I do know that. Yeah. And then the other thing that comes to
- 42:37mind is something our couple therapists said to us last week. He said,
- 42:44you know, the thing about being vulnerable is it feels really scary when you're
- 42:49first doing it, But if you do it enough, vulnerable starts feeling good
- 42:53because you have a felt sense that you know. It's like a trustful If
- 42:58you fall, you will be caught, and falling can be thrilling then because
- 43:04I know you're going to catch me, right, So there is that possibility
- 43:09for us. I notice in me a recognition of that fact. And at
- 43:15the same time, man, this fucking wilfulness that just keeps me locked up,
- 43:22And um, what's the sentence that runs to your mind with that wilfulness?
- 43:30The sentence that runs through my mind? I don't think I understand your
- 43:34question. What part of you that is being wilful? That part of you,
- 43:39how would it justify itself? Oh? Well, occasionally angry like,
- 43:46well she should know what I need, right, that'd be one version of
- 43:51it, I told her last month. Or I shouldn't have to ask is
- 44:00a version of it. And you know, yesterday I was I was at
- 44:07this training and part of the training was, you know, they do these
- 44:09role plays, right, So we all break up in the small groups and
- 44:13we do these role plays. And so I'm playing the role of a partner,
- 44:15and I have a partner, and then there's a therapist, right,
- 44:19And I don't do good at acting, so I don't ever act when they
- 44:22do these things. I just use me. So I just will in boy
- 44:25myself. And actually, the feedback I got is, wow, that's a
- 44:29hell of a character you're playing. And I'm like, I ain't playing a
- 44:30character, guys, I'm just I'm just this is how I am, right.
- 44:34And my partner said, that's a cop out. That's a cop out,
- 44:39And it was humiliating to hear her say it. What is a cop
- 44:43out? Something that I I was saying that I'm not willing to talk about
- 44:49something and oh, during the role play. During the role play, oh,
- 44:52okay, yeah, no, no, she was playing, she was
- 44:54playing partner. She said it was a cop out that you said, this
- 44:59is me. No, no, no, no, no, no,
- 45:00I don't. I don't. I don't think anybody know. During the role
- 45:04play, I'm playing a spouse and you said you were saying what I was
- 45:07saying. You know, I don't. I don't want to talk to you.
- 45:10I don't feel safe talking to you. And she's as a partner.
- 45:14As a partner in the role play, she was frustrated with me, and
- 45:17she said to me twice or three times, well, that's a cop out.
- 45:22And that was humiliating, embarrassing to hear her say it. And I
- 45:25actually started thinking about it, you know, after that, and then during
- 45:29the rest of the day yesterday, And there's a part of it. Let
- 45:34me let me start over. I agree with her. I mean, I
- 45:37think cop out's a bit loaded in a bit blame me, blame me.
- 45:42Yeah, but did you get angry at her? Did she notice your feeling?
- 45:46I don't know, I don't know. That would have been interesting to
- 45:50find out. And I got the sense from her that if she and I
- 45:53wanted to talk about that that she would have been totally cool in the gang
- 45:55with you didn't decompress after the role play. We process the therapist experience,
- 46:01not the you gotta process your feelings. Well that's not anyways, So well,
- 46:13cop out might be a judgmental way of putting it. I think what
- 46:17she's saying is you're engaging your own passivity and you're not willing to step beyond
- 46:25yourself, which I think is actually an even handed way of saying it.
- 46:30And I am vulnerable to that, and so it's like an excuse and avoidance
- 46:37and it's you know, it's like you said, I heard you say earlier.
- 46:43Sometimes it just like you know, when you come to your deathbed,
- 46:45you're not going to embrace all the times you were afraid and you know,
- 46:47refuse to step beyond yourself. You know that's really true. So Okay,
- 46:53I'm stuck with it, and I mean to sundagram stuck with it. But
- 46:59each moment I have a choice, Like I have a choice. So this
- 47:04morning, Colleen was waking up, I was waking up, and I sort
- 47:07of cuddled up to her and just chit chat and blah blah blah, and
- 47:12I said, you know, tonight, let's go over to the pub and
- 47:15we'll have dinner over at the pub, this pub that we ridgecrest, this
- 47:19pub we'd like to go to. And yesterday she's been knitting a sweater,
- 47:28and so I I asked her about it, Like I don't think I would
- 47:35have. I muted the TV and paid my attention to, you know,
- 47:39the sweater, and she actually talked about the sweater she's knitting. And so
- 47:44you had the impulse to cop out, yeah, and you decided not to
- 47:50not to How did you do that? Just said, tell me about your
- 47:52sweater? But how do you overcome the fear and the the old tapes playing
- 47:58in your head of avoiding The thought that goes through my head is Colleen is
- 48:04in my care, like we are in each other's care. That's the nature
- 48:07of a relationship in our in hair case of marriage, that's the nature of
- 48:12a partnership. And as such, she is in my care and caring about
- 48:21her is stepping beyond myself. It's not enough to say, golly, I've
- 48:25got this shitty history and I'm really scared. Yeah, and that by itself
- 48:34is it is a disservice to my partner. To just automatically succumb to that
- 48:43and wait for later. So by asking about the sweater, it was like
- 48:47opening up a conversation. Yeah yeah, I'm like saying, shit, I
- 48:52don't know how you do that, and that looks really complicated, and it's
- 48:54really lovely seeing you engage this way, and gosh, you're really proud of
- 48:58it, aren't you. You know some like it's okay to buy more yarn
- 49:02if you need it, because she needed some more yarn, and it's like
- 49:05just a friendly reminder that it's okay to do that, but basically just engaging
- 49:08her around what she's up to, because what she does is she made a
- 49:14she turned her office into her room where she's gonna do a knitting. She
- 49:19got a really nice chair in there, and it's really she did a nice
- 49:22job with it. It's really cozy. And I got the bowling table desk
- 49:27a couple weeks ago. Do you ever see that table bowling table? Yeah,
- 49:30it's like a bowling alley. It's about seven feet long and as wide
- 49:34as a bowling alley because it is a bowling alley, it's a piece of
- 49:36a bowling alley. Well, we had some legs put on the bottom of
- 49:38it. And it's a table, a sizy one as you could imagine.
- 49:43And that was in her room. Her room's a little bit smaller than my
- 49:45room. She's like, you know, do you want the table? Anyways,
- 49:49we swapped desks with my desk very small, so that fits in her
- 49:52room really well. And now she has room for a chair and she's made
- 49:54this den where she sits. She's been sitting there for the last week,
- 50:00knitting, watching her show, watching knitting videos or well, what about your
- 50:06needs? I'm thinking, because that's how this whole thing started, was right,
- 50:16Well okay, so yeah, right, I'm getting a little tangential.
- 50:22Colleen is in my care, and as a person who's in my care,
- 50:25one of the things that I owe her is to be more open about what
- 50:30about your needs? That's what I mean, to be more open about my
- 50:34needs? Oh I see, yeah, So how are you open about your
- 50:37needs? Oh? I haven't done that yet. Okay, but this is
- 50:38the catalyst. This is the catalyst, the connection to facilitate like this and
- 50:44embracing of the fact that we are in each other's care, because it's like,
- 50:50so's that another avoidance to attend to her? It would be an avoidance
- 50:55if it stops there. Otherwise I think it's actually really useful. She might
- 51:00say, how's your sweater going? Yes? Going, okay, okay,
- 51:01great, moving on watching Spider Man right, instead of actually engaging her.
- 51:07You know, but you know what I'm saying, you know the Butler syndrome.
- 51:09Right. Well, what she said to me a couple weeks ago is
- 51:14I know if I turn to you'll be there. And I'm like, yeah,
- 51:16but do you everar the sense that I don't ask enough of our relationship?
- 51:22And she said yeah, so it's not enough that I'm available to her
- 51:27if she needs me, And in fact, I could imagine it feels kind
- 51:30of lonely because it's not a bilateral. It's not a two way street,
- 51:34you know. So look, I'll be honest, I don't want to do
- 51:38any of it. I just recognize that I owe her, and as a
- 51:45result of owing her, I give a I have a shot at doing something
- 51:49useful for myself. You owe her, Yeah, you also are owed.
- 51:55That was harder, Yeah, but okay, I'm listening. Uh it's hard
- 52:04man when I just think that this stuff inside me is bad, so like
- 52:08off ur go just dumb shit like, honey, can you bring me a
- 52:15fork? Just get up and get a fork. You know. I guess
- 52:20it's useful to be self sufficient, but it's really it's it's it's adaptive when
- 52:24you're alone, but it's a bug when you're in a partnership. So but
- 52:31that stuff happens to me all the time, big stuff and little stuff.
- 52:39I mean, just to put a fine for the listeners, is that you
- 52:45started out by saying that you avoid through the mindset that it's doomed or that
- 52:52she's a bad person or a bad partner. The stepping out of that involves
- 52:59being a butler exclusively, which is closer but still avoidant of your needs,
- 53:07maybe indirectly getting your needs met because there's some good will between the two of
- 53:13you, Yeah, which feels probably good to you, better than being at
- 53:15odds or at distance, but not really, not really, And how that
- 53:23felt to you as you were giving the narrative as that's the solution I'm gonna
- 53:30I'll put on this earth to serve her. End of paragraph, end of
- 53:34chapter, end of book. And then I was like, when is this
- 53:37going to get Because this whole thing started with an avoidance of your needs,
- 53:42you know, and so I thought, Okay, we'll eventually. Is he
- 53:44kind of around or is he just going to talk about clever way about how
- 53:46to meet Colleen's needs and avoid right? Yeah, But to you it felt
- 53:50right. It felt like like that's the solution, you know. It felt
- 53:55like yep, job done, that's the good place, you know. But
- 54:00it's still another avoidance, yeah, and still denying of your needs. Yeah,
- 54:06I'm really vulnerable to that. Something really profound happened to me a couple
- 54:13weeks ago. You know, I canceled seeing you because I was doing a
- 54:15plumbing project. Yeah. It took five days, fifty five hours of just
- 54:21all day, all five days to get it done. Yeah, well just
- 54:27to paint a picture for people. You can elaborate. But from what you
- 54:30were telling me, and I told you that I could relate because when I
- 54:35was doing my heavy home remodel project years ago, I would have these moments
- 54:40where one you and I were not professionals in these construction fields. No,
- 54:47but we know enough to be able to muddle our way through it. Yeah,
- 54:52but it's really an efficience. We might not have the right tools.
- 54:55We're pathologically in penance, so we're doing it alone without any secondary hands to
- 55:01help us. The fact we get bogged down. We're doing it on our
- 55:06off time. Like I remember this one just a pain of scene is I
- 55:09was renovating my bathroom and there was in the attic I was going to take
- 55:15down the drywall from the ceiling, and in the attic was all this really
- 55:19horrible insulation from the fifties that is called rock wool. Oh yeah, and
- 55:25it's I think basically the shavings from inside of a coal refinery plant pipe like
- 55:35a smoke stack on the inside will coagulate this material. That is, if
- 55:43you touch it, it turns instantly into dust. But if you are careful
- 55:45with it, it's it's fluffy. It's fluffy coal dust and iron it it
- 55:52has a lot of minerals in it too. And I was trying to deal
- 55:57with it, but it was so hard. And this is before the internet
- 56:00was very good, right, The Internet was kind of good enough for me
- 56:05to learn that it was very toxic to breathe in the dust of this stuff,
- 56:08which makes sense, right, And so I'm trying to do this all
- 56:13myself because I don't have money to pay anyone to do anything. And I
- 56:16just said, I think I'm just going to have to just do it all
- 56:22in one fell swoop. So I got plastic and put it up all around
- 56:25the bathroom, and then I went in there with a respirator, you know,
- 56:29a filter and goggles and just tore down all the dry wall from the
- 56:37ceiling, which in the summer as well. And so I'm hot and I'm
- 56:40sweaty, so as all this rock weeell insulation is coming raining down on top
- 56:45of because that was the plan, I was like, well, this is
- 56:47the only way. And I just remember the sweat and the dust sticking to
- 56:54my head because you know, sweating, and it was getting into every nook
- 57:00and cranny and the respirator is good, but it's not perfect, you know.
- 57:05And I just remember thinking like and this was just one of those times,
- 57:08you know, And it's it's like all weekend long, and I probably
- 57:14screwed things up and got a little frustrated and just started like tearing shit off
- 57:19and breaking stuff along the way. Ah, fix it fucking later, don't
- 57:22you know. And you just you go down this and it's like eleven thirty
- 57:27at night and right, and no one even cares that you're doing it.
- 57:31You just and you're thinking, did I fuck it up? Was there a
- 57:34better way? You know, you just get into your head, you know,
- 57:37and it's it just becomes this deep pit of anger and despair and discomfort
- 57:44and demoralization. Like it can it can get pretty bad. So that's what
- 57:49was happening to you, oh for two days, a couple of weeks ago,
- 57:53Yeah, a couple weeks ago. Because you're under the house. You're
- 57:55doing plumbing, combing under the house, mostly in the garage, but yes,
- 57:59under the house house, crawling around in rat poop and rat pea.
- 58:01And that's what you're saying, just how the rats are getting into my found
- 58:06how they're getting into my cross base under my house a gross place to be.
- 58:09And I mean if it's rat pe that means rats where they're recently.
- 58:13Oh yeah, you can smell. I can smell them easily there and I
- 58:16can smell them and it doesn't matter. They're definitely there and it's you know,
- 58:22two feet tng, so you there's it is literally a cross base.
- 58:28That's the only way to get around. So I'm dragging a bag of tools,
- 58:30including a torch because I got a sweats and pipe and you know,
- 58:35I'm planning out of my head, has going to do and like swearing.
- 58:40Colleen is literally right above me because it's into the living room, you know.
- 58:44And anyways, and that actually went pretty smooth. I was only I
- 58:49was under there for about an hour and a half, and the thing I
- 58:52needed to do I got done pretty quick and relatively quick. But the rest
- 58:57of the weekend, you know, it took me five days, three days
- 59:00to get the water back on and five days to get the hot water going.
- 59:04So it was just like on the ground in my garage, just desperately
- 59:13wanting to scream my head off and needing her to hear me, but not
- 59:19knowing what the hell I needed her to do or what for. Just like,
- 59:22well, looking back, what'd you think you needed? I think some
- 59:30validation and care, yeah, and the appreciation for working hard. Yeah.
- 59:37She came out twice, and one of those times she's like, come on.
- 59:40She just dragged me back into the house and sat down, and I
- 59:45just was just I was describing to her how unbearable, like the shame that
- 59:50comes from me is when I fail, and how I feel this like awful
- 59:57compulsion to get it right. And she's like, you know, we can
- 1:00:00hire somebody which of course is technically true, but you know, like we
- 1:00:07don't have water now, so you know, well, plus it doesn't address
- 1:00:12the emotional oh, not even close. Would it have helped if she said
- 1:00:15maybe she did eventually said I love you even if this, if you fuck
- 1:00:21this up. She did say that, and that was her attitude. She
- 1:00:22put up with five days of of me, you know, these long days
- 1:00:28and you know, moments of it's going okay, and then mostly no,
- 1:00:31it's not, because mostly it wasn't. She said several times like this is
- 1:00:39you. I know you're going to get it done and it's going to be
- 1:00:42good because that's all you do. You get it done and it's okay.
- 1:00:45So I asked her to validate me, and it's like, Yep, you're
- 1:00:50right, Bob. It doesn't work right now. That is a true I
- 1:00:52like, I asked her, It's like what can I do? And I
- 1:00:54said, can you just validate that it's not working? Yep, it's not
- 1:00:58working. It doesn't mean that it's not a word, but it's just not
- 1:01:00working. Now. Let's see, this came up because because oh the reason
- 1:01:07I came to mind was because I absolutely had a need and I couldn't figure
- 1:01:12out what the hell it was and you were melting down. Yeah of days,
- 1:01:22yeah yeah, yeah right, like like during the Husky game, the
- 1:01:28championship game, I was out in my garage just trying to get the water
- 1:01:31back on. Almost got there that night, got it the next day.
- 1:01:36But so I guess the reason it came to mind is because I wonder about
- 1:01:44the needs I have that I just don't even notice. M I mean,
- 1:01:49as normal anyway, is it? Oh? Yeah? Yeah? Really is
- 1:01:54that normal? Like do you have that? Yeah? How does it?
- 1:01:59Like? Can you tell a story? Uh well, a similar but less
- 1:02:06melty downey story recently. I'm sure one's in my brain somewhere. Uh oh
- 1:02:19well. So, Unfortunately, being an H level celebrity on the Internet means
- 1:02:25that you're going to have some people that scare the shit out of you and
- 1:02:30make threats and oh shit, involve the police and the FBI. And I
- 1:02:36told you about all that, Yeah you did, true. And I don't
- 1:02:39have a gun or a bowie knife. I didn't take martial arts like you
- 1:02:45did. So I did take wrestling and football, so I could tackle them
- 1:02:51and sort of pin them to the ground, But that doesn't necessarily help if
- 1:02:54they have an AK forty seven pointed at me. But I worry, and
- 1:03:00my wife worries to probably more than me, and I worry about I mainly
- 1:03:05worry about her being hurt. Honestly, I don't really worry ongoing about me.
- 1:03:09But I have invested a lot of time and effort into a pretty robust
- 1:03:15security system. And the way that these security companies advertise it's to cycliceity fucking
- 1:03:21split and they install it or you install it and everything works fine. It
- 1:03:25never works that way. There's so many annoyances. It's just a constant thorn
- 1:03:31in my side. I'm constantly looking glitches, glitches, looking at Reddit threads
- 1:03:39about how to fix this, or functionalities that don't work quite right or as
- 1:03:44advertised, or there's just so many things. And so I spend you know,
- 1:03:49I don't spend a lot of time, but I do spend time.
- 1:03:52And I think of myself as doing it sixty percent for Stacey and forty percent
- 1:03:57for me, because she was like, we had our house broken into five
- 1:04:02years ago or something, and I was kind of relaxed about the whole experience,
- 1:04:09but Stacey was really rattled by it. Just the one up in shortline,
- 1:04:13yeah, yeah, And I at first was like, well, she'll
- 1:04:18get over it. You know, I've had my house broken into before.
- 1:04:21It's not pleasant, it's a total violation, but it'll pass. But it
- 1:04:28didn't pass for her. And she's not the sort of person to really hit
- 1:04:31the solution hard, do you know what I mean? She is in this
- 1:04:36realm kind of paralyzed in a way. And so I was like, okay,
- 1:04:41well as a favor to her all, And I guess it's sort of
- 1:04:45a man's job if I was to follow my socialization job, that I have
- 1:04:48to do this for us, and you know I would benefit from it too.
- 1:04:55And so for five six years I've been doing this thing that I would
- 1:05:00not probably have done if one I wasn't living with her, and two if
- 1:05:04she hadn't been rattled by that whole experience. And so whenever I'm working on
- 1:05:10it, because it'll take you know, I work too much as it is,
- 1:05:14and then on my days off, I'm spending like seven hours problem solving
- 1:05:17this thing. And it takes a lot of time. Yeah, and it's
- 1:05:21a lot of blood, sweat and tears that you know, I got to
- 1:05:25get outside and I have to start installing things and I have to start wiring
- 1:05:30things, and I have to figure out how to get the signal to work,
- 1:05:33and you know, it's just a lot of things to call the security
- 1:05:38company and like problem solve with them, which is a whole fucking nut area.
- 1:05:42And so every once in a while I'll start to have a meltdown around
- 1:05:45it, especially when i'm doing it, and I'm just like, this is
- 1:05:49the the few four hours this week that I don't have to work, and
- 1:05:55I'm you know, so this is just me, independent of thinking about Stacey.
- 1:05:58I'm just like, and I'm wasting it doing this fucking thing. And
- 1:06:00then this you know, stock creeps in of just like and you know,
- 1:06:04at the end of the day, Stacy won't even she won't even know or
- 1:06:08if I alert her to what I have done, she won't she won't appreciate
- 1:06:11it. And I'm doing this for her, you know, He's just get
- 1:06:14this. She's not even she's not even the in in the realm of what's
- 1:06:19happening. But I'm already angry at her. I get that. So I
- 1:06:25noticed that, and at some point I was able to tell myself, oh,
- 1:06:30you want appreciation, Okay, good for you. And so then I
- 1:06:34at some point, maybe I don't know, a month ago or something.
- 1:06:38We were talking about a bunch of things, and I think I just explicitly
- 1:06:43said to her, so, when I work on this security system, i'm
- 1:06:46doing it. I'm doing it for you. I'm doing it for me,
- 1:06:49but I'm doing it mostly for you because I want you to feel safe,
- 1:06:54and I also want you to be safe. And I think about this.
- 1:06:57I think about it a lot, and I'm pretty obsessive about it, and
- 1:07:00I work really really hard on it, and it can get really frustrating,
- 1:07:03and I'm just looking for some appreciation. I just want to know that it
- 1:07:09matters to you, or that you care or something. And she was nice
- 1:07:13in the moment. But then like a couple of weeks later, I was
- 1:07:17toiling away at it again and I brought it up later in the evening and
- 1:07:25I said, I spent a few hours on the security system again, and
- 1:07:29she like explicitly said, thank you for doing that for me, you know,
- 1:07:32she said that, wow, and yeah, it definitely helped. Yeah,
- 1:07:40So this was a question as to whether or not I would notice my
- 1:07:44feelings. I probably had that feeling that I wasn't acknowledging. Four months before
- 1:07:50that moment a month ago or two, when I finally just really saw it,
- 1:07:58you know, But I'd had probably for years, maybe had moments where
- 1:08:02I would be miffy around her because of this un known kind of resentment that
- 1:08:11is illogical because I haven't told her, but was there and affecting me and
- 1:08:17her. So yeah, it's pretty normal. I would say. I think
- 1:08:21wanting appreciation is a very common, ignored need that adults have. I'll think
- 1:08:29about that. Thanks, good story. Uh, it's take a break.
- 1:08:36One more email. Yep, all right. Question for Bob and Kirk.
- 1:08:45YouTube member Kate from Honolulu. How she says, Hi, Bob and Kirk.
- 1:08:49I'm a young person who went to therapy for about a year. I
- 1:08:54enjoyed therapy as a way to reflect on my actions and thoughts. But my
- 1:08:58therapist, so I'm a young person with the therapy about a year. I
- 1:09:00enjoyed therapy as a way to reflect my actionally myself, but my therapist asked
- 1:09:03me multiple times if I wanted to return. It felt as if she didn't
- 1:09:08think I needed therapy, and sometimes felt I wasn't a priority in the therapist's
- 1:09:14size. I think eventually I stopped going for financial reasons. So just kind
- 1:09:17of shifting through this, what do you think Kate is saying exactly? I
- 1:09:21think Kate's saying at the end of the session, her therapist said, you
- 1:09:25want to come back? And the question itself is a bit off putting because
- 1:09:29it says it sends the message that you know, you don't really need to
- 1:09:33be here, but you know, if you want to come back, And
- 1:09:40that's an off putting message for a client. Right. If I had to
- 1:09:45guess, I'd say the therapist didn't have an attitude of you know, you
- 1:09:48don't really need to be here, but was probably trying too hard to be
- 1:09:54non presumptuous. Right, And do you do that? Yeah? Guilty,
- 1:09:59Yeah, bad way. These days, what I'll say to my people is
- 1:10:04Okay, do I see you next week, you know, at our usual
- 1:10:06whatever. But I never say do you want to come back? Yeah,
- 1:10:14there's different severities of that question. Yeah, And it is interesting. I
- 1:10:19don't know if we've ever talked about this. I don't know if you know
- 1:10:21if I've ever talked out loud about this, but it is a it is
- 1:10:26a very interesting aspect of therapy, this question at the end, you know,
- 1:10:30particularly with clients where you're not exactly sure, you know, because some
- 1:10:33clients you know, because it's explicit that they're in it to win it and
- 1:10:39they want to be in therapy for a long time. But there's a number
- 1:10:43of clients where it's not super explicit, and I never want to assume,
- 1:10:47so I don't want to pressure people, you know, because some people might
- 1:10:51want to take a break for a week or longer or something right, And
- 1:10:57so with some clients yeah into it that it would be safer to say,
- 1:11:02so do you want to schedule? I'll say something, so do you want
- 1:11:04to schedule for next week? And if they say yes, But it does
- 1:11:09run the risk of sending this message of confusion of either I don't want to
- 1:11:15see you, or I don't think you need therapy, or I don't think
- 1:11:19this is going to last very long, which I don't want to send because
- 1:11:23that's really anesthetical to my work. If I were a brief therapist, then
- 1:11:28I would say, yeah, go ahead and ask questions along those lines.
- 1:11:31So it is kind of making me rethink that me too. I do.
- 1:11:36Once I figure out that they're in it to win it, then I stop
- 1:11:42asking it that way, but I probably ask it longer than I need to,
- 1:11:45because I do know some With many clients, I just say, all
- 1:11:49right, let's schedule for next week, you know something like that. It's
- 1:11:54just a cue to get your calendars out. Yeah. Not a question about
- 1:11:59whether you're planning to see one another yeah, or whether or not, or
- 1:12:02about the client's motivation. I guess, if I think about it, the
- 1:12:06best thing to do, given my style, would be when this emerges in
- 1:12:13my head as a topic that needs to be discussed, like the last few
- 1:12:16minutes of the session, I would say, okay, so we're about to
- 1:12:19wrap up. At the end of session, I will ask you if you
- 1:12:25want to schedule an appointment next week. And I just want to be clear
- 1:12:28as to what I'm asking when I'm asked that, because I don't want to
- 1:12:30assume anything, and I want you to know that if you want to take
- 1:12:33a break, you can. I don't want you to take a break.
- 1:12:38If you want to take a break, then yeah. But I like working
- 1:12:42with you and I want to see you next week, and we have a
- 1:12:45lot to work on and I'm excited to work on those things with you.
- 1:12:48And to be honest, i'm sort of therapist that if you stay in there
- 1:12:53with therapy with me for years and years, like I'm your man, and
- 1:12:57there won't be any qualms or thoughts about it at all. Right, It's
- 1:13:00it's completely dependent on what you want. But I also don't want to pressure
- 1:13:04you to see me forever or to even have at the pace you know,
- 1:13:13if you want to start going over the week or something. So it's like
- 1:13:15a high demand situation. So that's that's what that's my position, which I
- 1:13:24don't necessarily tell every client. I don't think I've ever said that, but
- 1:13:28yeah, I think it should. And then I would say at the so,
- 1:13:31so then I might say so when I ask do you want to schedule
- 1:13:35for next week? That's where that question comes from. It's it's not implying
- 1:13:41anything, right, But really, when I think about it now, I
- 1:13:45think if a client wants to take a break, I wouldn't want it to
- 1:13:49be expressed through the you know, it's such a dumb pres it's such a
- 1:13:55dumb premise if it is, so I'm going to ask a client like,
- 1:13:59so, do you to schedule for next week? And they're like no,
- 1:14:01And then that's the only conversation we have. This is how we're going to
- 1:14:05talk about whether or not you know you're dropping, you're going to stop coming
- 1:14:10right, So it's a it requires a bigger caveat to introduce the topics.
- 1:14:20So I guess what I might say is say all that, and then I
- 1:14:25would say so at the end of session, I will say, let's schedule
- 1:14:28for next week. That isn't saying you should be scheduling next week or pressuring
- 1:14:33you. So if I detect something, I'll bring it up. But in
- 1:14:36all likelihood, you will be the one to introduce the topic as to whether
- 1:14:42or not you want to take a break or slow down, or you know,
- 1:14:45do something else in therapy or whatever. If I detect that, we
- 1:14:48might be handing that direction, I might ask, but I might not.
- 1:14:53So when I ask the end of session, let's schedule for next week?
- 1:14:56Or when do you want to see me next week? Or do you want
- 1:14:58to or I'll just see next week, you know, I might just say
- 1:15:00that that would be a more proactive or ptroactive avert And then and then it's
- 1:15:09yeah, chances are well, I was about to say. You know what
- 1:15:13I always say to the folks who write in is you should talk about this
- 1:15:15with the therapist because it's just muddy. That's probably mostly what it is,
- 1:15:19but it's impact sex. Yeah, yeah, because clearly, you know a
- 1:15:25person that wrote in very much enjoying their experience of therapy and founding finding useful,
- 1:15:31and chances are that the therapist has a felt since that that's the case,
- 1:15:35probably really liked working with them. Yeah. Well, I don't know
- 1:15:42what Kate is saying, because Kate saying, my therapist asked me multiple times
- 1:15:45if I wanted to return. So does that mean I've stopped coming? And
- 1:15:48my therapist reached out, well that it felt as if she didn't think I
- 1:15:51needed therapy, and I sometimes felt I wasn't a priority to her. Eventually
- 1:15:56I stopped going for financial reasons. Oh. She goes on to say,
- 1:15:59I like therapy and having someone to talk to, and I'm trying to decide
- 1:16:02if it's worth it to start going again. What are some tips or information
- 1:16:06that is helpful when someone are deciding if therapy is right for them? End
- 1:16:12of email. Well I'm probably the wrong person to ask that, because I
- 1:16:16think everybody can benefit from going to therapy, and you know, like it
- 1:16:23sort of depends on where you are, but I think we're all all of
- 1:16:27us have attachment insecurity to some degree that could benefit from learning about in personal
- 1:16:32counseling. So you know, like do I need it? It depends on
- 1:16:36how you define that word, like what's your goal in life is so so
- 1:16:44I'm I don't think I'm I'm going to be very useful in my response to
- 1:16:49to the right to the person that wrote in except yeah, yeah, I
- 1:16:53think it's a good response. The only thing I'll add is you can go
- 1:16:56to therapy. And I've had clients come to me for this reason to identify
- 1:17:00a reason to go to therapy. Why not you can come to therapy.
- 1:17:03Be like I think I need therapy, but I actually don't know what I
- 1:17:08should be working on. You know, like when you have a motivation to
- 1:17:11go to therapy, Bob, you know why you're going. You know,
- 1:17:15I'm going because of X, Y and Z. I want to change this
- 1:17:21about myself. I want to heal from this. I want to improve this
- 1:17:25relationship. And it's normal for people not to have that at the forefront of
- 1:17:31their mind because we're not in a society that values that kind of exploration,
- 1:17:39and there's still pockets of people that and cultures where you only go to therapy
- 1:17:44if you're quote unquote crazy. So there's that. The other thing is is
- 1:17:49it's important to find the right therapist because if you went to a particular kind
- 1:17:55of therapist and said, I don't know why I'm in therapy, but I
- 1:17:59want to explore that, there's a good percentage I would say at least twenty
- 1:18:02five percent of therapist that would say, well, then you shouldn't be in
- 1:18:05therapy. Yeah. I did that once. The dumbest thing. I discouraged
- 1:18:11somebody from coming because they didn't have a specific goal, and my supervisor said,
- 1:18:15don't do that, and I did it anyways, and I think about
- 1:18:17that person. She was lovely and it was a total bonehead move, and
- 1:18:23she did exactly what you could imagine, she stopped coming. I don't know
- 1:18:26if i'd call a bonehead, because it has its logic to it. If
- 1:18:30someone came into a dentist and said I need you to do something to my
- 1:18:33teeth and they're like, well, what's wrong, They're like nothing or I
- 1:18:38don't know, and then they do an examination and there's nothing going on,
- 1:18:42and the doctor the dentist like, I don't know what you want me to
- 1:18:45do, and the patient's just like, well, I just feel like you
- 1:18:48should be doing something, and the dentist be I'm sorry, I can't proceed
- 1:18:53until I have something to go off of, So until then you're going to
- 1:18:57have to leave. But the good thing about therapy is you can be self
- 1:19:00reflective, like I don't see anything that needs working on. But that doesn't
- 1:19:04mean there isn't something here. Obviously you want something. I'm just saying that
- 1:19:09bonehead is and I would personally say it was a bonehead move if I did
- 1:19:14it too, so, but I just want to say that there's a whole
- 1:19:16section of therapists that that's their bread and butter is to be clear about those
- 1:19:21things, and there's a lot of good to that. The problem is is
- 1:19:25if you have a client like Kate who might benefit from a therapist like you
- 1:19:29and me, they won't know where to find therapists like you and me or
- 1:19:34what keywords, and those keywords might not even exist, So you just have
- 1:19:40to try out a few. So, Kate, if you do that,
- 1:19:44stay with the therapist that says ooh I like it, Yeah, well let's
- 1:19:49start somewhere. How's your life going? Or yeah, that's I love that,
- 1:19:54that's a great time. How are you feeling right now? What's going
- 1:19:58on in your relationships? Yeah, because that's what I would do, because
- 1:20:02there's there's always something yeah. And then I would say, okay, well
- 1:20:06so that's something. Would you like to work on that? And if the
- 1:20:11client's like yeah, no, okay, well keep going, keep exploring,
- 1:20:15right, and I might say, like, look, for as long as
- 1:20:17you want to explore this, I'm here to explore it with you. I'm
- 1:20:20not going to kick you out of the office for not having a goal yet.
- 1:20:25We have a goal of trying to find a goal. And that's okay,
- 1:20:28yeah, that is Yeah. And the therapist that they had might be
- 1:20:30a really good one. They liked going and they found it useful and like
- 1:20:34talking to that person. Maybe that person just needs some orientation. Maybe they're
- 1:20:40workable. M yeah, yeah, yeah, that case says I liked therapy.
- 1:20:44Yeah. Another. The final thing I'll say is that there are schemas
- 1:20:50related to this that I've treated before. I'm sure you have too, Bob,
- 1:20:54where people will have issues that will high affect the way they feel about
- 1:21:02the therapist and the therapy in general, meaning that they have issues but they're
- 1:21:12in a habit of denying their issues and of avoiding, and people outside of
- 1:21:20them may or may not even be able to identify issues in them because they
- 1:21:24might be effective at being able to mask it, but other people might be
- 1:21:27able to see as oh my god, yeah you need therapy, and the
- 1:21:30individual is like, really do you think so? So there's a lot of
- 1:21:33obscuring of one's issues, but you're thinking, well, but I feel like
- 1:21:36maybe there's something there, but you need a lot of help with a therapist
- 1:21:42to even look at yourself. It's not automatic that humans can even begin to
- 1:21:47ask answer the question do I need therapy and what do I need to work
- 1:21:53on? Yeah? Yeah, So that's one issue. The other issue is
- 1:21:58that there's a there's schemas and relational traumas related to sitting down in the client's
- 1:22:03chair in the therapy office, of avoidance and suspicion of the whole process that
- 1:22:12can result in the client sitting there and evading a lot of different you know,
- 1:22:17I've had clients in the first session where they sit down and and they're
- 1:22:23like, I I want to work on I'm trying to think of of an
- 1:22:28example. They might say, well, my life is falling apart and I
- 1:22:33just feel like maybe therapy would be a good idea. So just that opening
- 1:22:36sentence, it's not clear, right, It's like my life is falling apart,
- 1:22:42and I think maybe I need therapy. Right, It's it's not It
- 1:22:45has a hint of something that I'll get to you in a second. And
- 1:22:46then and then I'm okay, So I don't know the landscape. So I'm
- 1:22:50just asking, okay, what you know what's going on? Because usually when
- 1:22:54you ask clients what's going on, they just ramble for the rest of the
- 1:22:57session, you know, because there's there's so much the got to get off
- 1:23:00their chest, you know. I don't have to pull things out of people,
- 1:23:03right, So okay, tell me what's going on. And they're like,
- 1:23:05well, you know, regular life. Pause. I'm like, oh,
- 1:23:12well, yeah, so regular life. And so I'm really caring a
- 1:23:15lot of the weight, you know, in this conversation. Okay, rere
- 1:23:19your life and it gives some people will get nervous or whatever, and so
- 1:23:24I feel it's my duty to carry that weight in the beginning anyway. Sure,
- 1:23:28So, okay, so your life's falling apart? Is that is that
- 1:23:30what you said earlier? Well, no, I don't I wouldn't say my
- 1:23:32life's falling apart. I mean, come on, it's not be dramatic.
- 1:23:38And then oh, okay, well, you know earlier you said that you
- 1:23:44know, life was difficult and and that's why you're here, so uh you
- 1:23:50know what's going on there, right, And they might give some really lackluster
- 1:23:56detail about their life. It's like, oh, well, uh, I
- 1:24:00you know the pandemic has been difficult or something. Okay, you know,
- 1:24:06it just kind of continues to go in that vein, and then I at
- 1:24:11some point will feel like, okay, I feel like I'm fighting with the
- 1:24:15client. So I might say something like, so, okay, I want
- 1:24:21to just write because I have I always have a clipboard in the first session
- 1:24:25side, Okay, I just want to get down on my notes at least
- 1:24:29one goal, just one thing that you want to change about your life or
- 1:24:35your relationships or the way you think, or your emotions or trauma or something.
- 1:24:40I just want to get one thing down on my noteboard, on my
- 1:24:45clipboard here, so that I can have something to go from, you know,
- 1:24:49because until we get that, I don't know where to begin. I
- 1:24:54feel like you've told me some details, which is great, but so if
- 1:24:57there was one thing that you want to work on, one thing you'd like
- 1:25:00to change, what would that be? And I'll never forget this one client
- 1:25:06who was doing this to me. She says, well, I don't know
- 1:25:12what do you mean? So I asked the question again. I'm being very
- 1:25:15polite and very diplomatic, even though I'm like, you know, so I
- 1:25:21do to get And then she says, well, you're the doctor, you
- 1:25:25tell me right, And I'm like, how the fuck did we get here?
- 1:25:30This is nineteen minutes into the session, right, and you're already angry
- 1:25:33at me because I'm asking you what you want to do. Like, the
- 1:25:39implication is that I pulled you in off the street and I'm trying to tell
- 1:25:43you that there's something wrong with you. I don't know. I don't clearly
- 1:25:46there is something wrong with you, but I'm learning all about it. I'm
- 1:25:51seeing it right now. You know, there are personality sorders and schemas that
- 1:25:56can result in this, and so now that's one example. But if a
- 1:26:03friend of mine or someone or to come to me like Kate and say a
- 1:26:08similar kind of presentation. It's pretty brief what Kate's say, but there's a
- 1:26:12chance that even though in your mind you go to a therapist next Kate and
- 1:26:16say I really want to find out what I want to do in therapy,
- 1:26:20you could have something subconscious that's getting in the way of you even giving enough
- 1:26:27material to the client or to the therapist for the therapist to even begin the
- 1:26:33process, you know. And just to conclude this bit here, is that
- 1:26:41for the clients that have come to me with this presentation, of which I
- 1:26:44can, off the top of my head think of a handful, and I
- 1:26:47remember them because it's it's so weird and it's actually kind of rough for me,
- 1:26:53you know, it feels dangerous, and I, given certain professional policies
- 1:27:00that I have, I'll do a lot and I feel like I'm pretty good
- 1:27:02at coming at it from a lot of angles in the first session, you
- 1:27:05know, because I'm pretty adamant about having the therapy goals emerge from the client
- 1:27:11and not from me. Yeah, And I have a you know, supervisor,
- 1:27:15and I teach this and I feel like a lot of therapists don't do
- 1:27:18enough work around this, so I have a lot of ways of getting there.
- 1:27:23And I'm also, you know, pretty good at being diplomatic in the
- 1:27:26first session but for a good number of these clients that will do this to
- 1:27:30me in the first session, I will gently terminate with them and say something
- 1:27:34like, well, so I'm not hearing a firm goal that you want to
- 1:27:41work on, which is normal, that's okay. But what I want you
- 1:27:45to do is I want you to after we conclude, I want you to
- 1:27:47go home, and I won't charge you for today if you don't continue with
- 1:27:51me, but I want you to go home and I want you to think
- 1:27:54about or talk about, or journal about at least one thing that you want
- 1:27:59me to help you with, or just therapy and generally to change about you.
- 1:28:02And if you come up with that, then make an appointment and we'll
- 1:28:06talk. But if you can't come up with something, then I'm sorry,
- 1:28:11but I don't think it's worth your time to come here and have me try
- 1:28:16to coerce you to come up with a goal, you know, so you
- 1:28:19know, give it a shot. And for some people that's all they need.
- 1:28:21They just need like an hour of journaling and they'll figure it out.
- 1:28:25So if you come up with that, I'd love to work with you,
- 1:28:28But if not, then I think it's in your best interest to not come
- 1:28:33until you have that. So they terminate, you know, and they're not
- 1:28:36happy about it. You know, it's weird they get You would think they'd
- 1:28:42be like, oh okay, in this state, you know, they're already
- 1:28:45at odds, you know what I mean, rejected. Yeah, And so
- 1:28:50they don't leave the office happy and I never see him again. There's another
- 1:28:59approach. Know, I could just sort of write it out and say like,
- 1:29:01okay, well let's schedule for next week and continue talking about And I
- 1:29:05will do that sometimes as well. For sure, for sure there are some
- 1:29:08clients, but some clients I just feel like, if we're going to start
- 1:29:12out with you being antagonistic and basically accusing me of trying to pry things out
- 1:29:19of you, like there's there's already an accusation there of that, you know,
- 1:29:24when I am not, you know, then I don't personally want to
- 1:29:29do this. You're not interested in that kind of case. I'm interested if
- 1:29:34I predict that things can work out. Yeah. But if I predict,
- 1:29:40because you know, I think for some of these people, no matter what
- 1:29:43I do, they're going to blow out. So you know, maybe it's
- 1:29:47session three or session seven, but they're going to go like because you know,
- 1:29:53for the clients that are really struggling in therapy, say someone with disorganized
- 1:29:57attachment, for example, they have a stated known wish for recovery or attachment
- 1:30:05or security or safety or you know, they know that and they can we
- 1:30:11can all stand on that. And yet for some of these folks will there
- 1:30:15will be severe transference that will be occurring where they will hate me or think
- 1:30:18I'm rejecting them, or be very hostile towards me. But we always have
- 1:30:25that and the client has that thing to return to they know that they deserve
- 1:30:30or it would be helpful for them to recover from the relational trauma they've been
- 1:30:32there. For these clients, there isn't They don't have a conscious awareness of
- 1:30:36that. No, they're highly defended. Yeah, and so there's not a
- 1:30:42lot bringing them back. You know. For the disorganized or the borderline client,
- 1:30:46they have a tremendous drive to return to the well and to come back
- 1:30:51to therapy, even though they are at times very suspicious that it is not
- 1:30:59only unhelpful, be a danger to people in this category with this schema and
- 1:31:02this person I disorder. They don't even have that. They don't have a
- 1:31:08conscious drive the fact that they even ended up in therapy is kind of weird
- 1:31:12sometimes, and often the circumstances are kind of weird, like their workforce them,
- 1:31:17or they had a suicide attempt that came out of nowhere seemingly to them,
- 1:31:23or they went through a divorce, or their life truly is falling apart,
- 1:31:28they lost their job and their marriage and blah blah blah. And so
- 1:31:30unless there's something that I can point to to say I can work with this,
- 1:31:38then I don't predict it a work well. And at a certain point
- 1:31:41in my career I said, I just you don't want to It's not what
- 1:31:45I wake up in the morning and decide I want to do. You know,
- 1:31:49I'll get into it with someone with borderline who is attacking me and being
- 1:31:57hostile and threatening to sue me. I'll get in, I'll get my hands
- 1:32:00dirty, and I'll get into it and won't be pleasant, but I'll do
- 1:32:02it, and I'll professionally be very satisfied with that. But this sort of
- 1:32:06problem, I just I guess I just don't really predict it would work no
- 1:32:10matter what I did. And to be clear, I don't terminate with them.
- 1:32:15I'm telling them when you come up with a goal, which is a
- 1:32:17pretty small ask, then we will work with each other forever. That's all
- 1:32:23I'm asking is like, when you find a goal, then please make an
- 1:32:28appointment and we will work together. Well, it's an invitation to engage with
- 1:32:31something below defense, and someone with really strong defenses is not going to take
- 1:32:39you up on it. I think it's good feedback and that person probably going
- 1:32:45to have a response inside that's based in the defense, and the defense is
- 1:32:49somewhat hostile and offloading responsibility and putting it on the other. So you know,
- 1:32:58as if I'm doing that, I'm not helpable, right unless there's some
- 1:33:02part of me that's willing to say, oh, yeah, I'm doing that,
- 1:33:05which is unlikely, But if there were, then you got something to
- 1:33:09work with. Well. The thing I guess I would say is that they're
- 1:33:13not likely to have that awareness. No, but a part of them could
- 1:33:17at least say, well, I can come up with something. How about
- 1:33:20self esteem, you know, or I'd like to not be as anxious,
- 1:33:28or I want my marriage to go a little better, or yeah, something.
- 1:33:31You know, it's not hard to have something, even if it's not
- 1:33:34even the thing, right. Yeah, So and if if there's nothing or
- 1:33:41you know, then then it's because the defense is trumping. It's But if
- 1:33:45I don't know that I'm defended, Yeah, that's true. I'm really twisting
- 1:33:50myself in nuts because I I'm bumping up against my policy with always saying that
- 1:33:58people come to therapy with problem like someone comes into therapy with narcissistic personal disorder,
- 1:34:03and a lot of times therapists will reject them because they're pathologically independent and
- 1:34:10will keep the therapist at arm's length. And although they might have a goal,
- 1:34:15unlike the other scheme house talking about, they especially in the beginning of
- 1:34:19therapy, will do everything in their power to keep the therapist powerless and keep
- 1:34:26the therapist in a position of observer and hopeful admirer of the client. And
- 1:34:33for many therapists it can be very challenging. And if the therapists were to
- 1:34:39confront the client like this, it would result in a similar outcome, and
- 1:34:44would I would denigrate that therapist for not realizing what's going on and for rejecting
- 1:34:51a client when they obviously need your help and you don't need every client to
- 1:34:58stroke your ego about it thing. Of course, that's on the one hand,
- 1:35:03yeah, and so it makes me wonder if I just have to raise
- 1:35:06the question as to whether or not the handful of clients I can think about
- 1:35:11over the last fifteen years that I've done this too, if I was actually
- 1:35:15going against my policy. I mean, it certainly is challenging because even with
- 1:35:18the narcissistic people, they often will have something to say about a goal,
- 1:35:24you know, say, well, I just want to explore myself or something.
- 1:35:27Well, you're the doctor, you tell me is a very interesting response.
- 1:35:30Yeah, it's full of thorns. Yeah, but people come to therapy
- 1:35:35with problems. No, no, I get all that. Well, you
- 1:35:42might run into that problem of task alliance. Yeah, well we're already at
- 1:35:48we can't even get to task alliance because we don't have a goal alliance.
- 1:35:51Well, is it ethical to try to treat somebody who fights treatment? I
- 1:36:00think that clients come to therapy because they have problems, and if it's obvious
- 1:36:06that the client's problems are resulting in them having a hard time tolerating a conversation
- 1:36:12about them offering up a goal which is self critical or asking for help or
- 1:36:19any kind of self reflection is obviously a result of something they went through it's
- 1:36:26not normal to have that kind of reaction, right, I mean somebody being
- 1:36:31that defended. It's not hard to pick out, right, Like, for
- 1:36:34example, it's normal for a client to come to me and say I want
- 1:36:40you to help me to quit alcohol or something, and for me to say,
- 1:36:45oh, well, I could help you with that, but there's a
- 1:36:48better treatment professional. You know, it's normal for a client to not know
- 1:36:54what a therapist does or what it's for, but it's that's normal. But
- 1:37:00it's not normal for a client to show up to therapy and have such you
- 1:37:03know, I'm saying it just is an obvious symptom of something. Yeah,
- 1:37:09it is, And so I just I don't like, I have no justification
- 1:37:17for what I did other than I was just annoyed, which I hate it
- 1:37:24when other therapists do that. Well, you don't like working with this kind
- 1:37:29of person I don't mind working with these people. Actually, I with many
- 1:37:33of the clients that have these kinds of scheme as I have worked with them.
- 1:37:38It's a struggle, but it's not as hard as other kind of personality
- 1:37:42disorders. Well, it is interesting because there's something about it that you noticed
- 1:37:45that you really turn off and wish to close the door. You won't be
- 1:37:53an overt dick about it, but you send a message that send someone packing
- 1:37:59and you're not. It's at odds with your ethical and moral Yeah, you
- 1:38:08know, if I was to think about it, going back to that house
- 1:38:11that I renovated, which isn't far from your current house. Oh that's true.
- 1:38:15When I was working there, I remember there was a client this would
- 1:38:18have been twenty years ago, and she came in and you know, when
- 1:38:26you're a full time private practice therapist, you have you know, a fair
- 1:38:29amount of new clients in a month, and just another routine one of those,
- 1:38:31and she came in and I had a session that was very similar to
- 1:38:36the one I kind of role played earlier, and she was the one that
- 1:38:41said, well, you're the doctor, you tell me. And it had
- 1:38:45a vibe of and this could be by counter transference. I'm sure that's part
- 1:38:51of it. So I don't know if this was a recreation on her part,
- 1:38:55a projective idification on her part, and or an issue with me,
- 1:39:00or just complete issue with me. But the way it felt in those escalating
- 1:39:04moments was as if I was walking up to her in a dance club and
- 1:39:09hitting on her and she was annoyed with it. That's interesting, that's the
- 1:39:14way it felt to me. That's fascinating. Yeah, And so that's why
- 1:39:16I think it's kind of relevant to the way that she was presenting physically,
- 1:39:21because it could be a whole syndrome of hers a push pull, yeah,
- 1:39:30histrionics specifically, and a lot of pain and a lot of a lot of
- 1:39:35fear of closeness, a desperation for closeness of course, and a deed for
- 1:39:43attention, whether it's positive or negative, maybe for some sexual attention. And
- 1:39:50I remembered feeling really insulted by the whole vibe, you know, and thinking,
- 1:40:00look, you came to me, uh huh. And I am a
- 1:40:04competent therapist, I'm a professor, I'm a supervisor, so I'm not going
- 1:40:10to beg you you to come up with you know, that kind of anger
- 1:40:15that I would have fascinating. And so I think that affected like maybe one,
- 1:40:24two or three clients after that, Oh that presented similarly similarly, you
- 1:40:30have a similar response. And I had this policy after that one from twenty
- 1:40:35years ago of just like you know, because my policy is if clients don't
- 1:40:40have a goal, I don't reject them. I have a whole system around
- 1:40:44it. But if they if they can't come up with a goal with that
- 1:40:47kind of vibe that she had, that historyonic vibe, then I am I
- 1:40:56felt very safe for vindicated or just a in being very nice and diplomatic and
- 1:41:03saying what I said. I'm just like, well, you know, feel
- 1:41:05free to come up with a goal, and I'm your therapist. But until
- 1:41:11then, I don't know where to go from here. I don't know what
- 1:41:15to assess. I don't know what to work on unless there's something that you
- 1:41:18want to change. But that one from twenty years ago, I terminated a
- 1:41:23session maybe like seventeen minutes in. It was very brief, and she was
- 1:41:28angry about it. Yeah, she wanted to stay and I, you know,
- 1:41:30and I'm like, I don't unless unless there's something to work on.
- 1:41:36You know, Therapy is a service that is professionally provided for people that want
- 1:41:45to change something. It's not just this amorphous activity. You know, there's
- 1:41:49there's a there's at least something to work on, something that you want me
- 1:41:54to help you with. Otherwise I don't know what else to do. I
- 1:41:58think it got caught up in a bridget like a really powerful one. Yeah.
- 1:42:01She wanted me to feel invasive of her. She wanted me to feel
- 1:42:10like I was below her. She wanted me to feel as if I were
- 1:42:15begging her for something. You know. It had that kind of vibe to
- 1:42:20it where I was left in this crumbling mass saying, please, Venus from
- 1:42:28on high, give me something, you know. And I was hurt by
- 1:42:34that. I guess also kind of scared of it too. It's because it's
- 1:42:39like, yeah, what's happening right now? You know, right, you're
- 1:42:43in a play and there's lines and nobody handed you a script. That's a
- 1:42:46good way to put it. It felt that way. It felt like,
- 1:42:48wait, what's happening right now? You're the doctor? So this is fifteen
- 1:42:53minutes into our first session. And again I'm super diplomatic. Sure, you're
- 1:42:57the doctor, you tell me it's what's happening? How is how are you
- 1:43:01already angry at me? How did this? I'm just asking for a goal
- 1:43:06everyone has and some people it takes some a bit of time to figure out
- 1:43:11the goal. That's okay, But what's happy? So? I think,
- 1:43:15you know, I don't know. I don't feel great about not examining this
- 1:43:19twenty years ago, and I don't think you feel great about the fact that
- 1:43:23you don't want to that this is someone you don't want to work with.
- 1:43:27I don't feel great about not wanting to work with them. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:43:30that's what you said, right. No, I do want to work
- 1:43:33with them, and I have worked with plenty of historic people. Yeah,
- 1:43:36but you're but those people, which is the majority. I would say ninety
- 1:43:41five percent of the historic people do have a goal that they can identify.
- 1:43:45It's just a particular kind of brand of histrionic. Yeah, I don't know.
- 1:43:49I don't have any moral or ethical problem with you not wanting to work
- 1:43:54with somebody. I do you think you should want to work with everybody.
- 1:44:00I think it's immoral for me to reject a client for having issues, even
- 1:44:04when they interfere with coming up with a goal. Similar to I think it's
- 1:44:11im moral for me to reject a client for saying something like I think you're
- 1:44:15a worthless therapist. You know, it's not uncommon for a narcissistic or histrionic
- 1:44:20or a borderline client a year and a half in to say, you know,
- 1:44:25they sit down on the couch and there's like, I've been thinking about
- 1:44:28it, and I'm I can't think of a single thing that you've helped me
- 1:44:30with. Yeah, you haven't helped you haven't given me tools. All you've
- 1:44:33done is just avoid and you know, create all these boundaries about things.
- 1:44:40And I just I just don't understand how you and all your type are in
- 1:44:45business. This is just a complete sham. I hear that that is on
- 1:44:48the I hear on the rag that's and I don't turn to that client and
- 1:44:54say, well, you can get the fuck out of my hoves. No,
- 1:44:56no, of course not no. They because they're handing you something to
- 1:44:58work with, right. They're similar to the histrionic person who said you're the
- 1:45:01doctor, you tell me, right, I get it. She's also handing
- 1:45:04you something to work with. Oh now I remember, you might not be
- 1:45:10a good candidate for that kind of person, Like if seventeen minutes in you
- 1:45:14want them to leave, it might be good if they do. Maybe,
- 1:45:19But there's not a lot of therapists out there that in my anecdotal experience,
- 1:45:23I can maybe she would have gelled differently with it at a different therapists.
- 1:45:26Maybe I can't know that, but I'm not reassured that if I were to
- 1:45:30just say, go find out of the therapist, that things would work out.
- 1:45:32I'm not reassured of that, no, because I'm not saying I'm special.
- 1:45:35I'm saying that they would run into the same issues, and it's more
- 1:45:41common for people to draw that boundary. Then. Well, yeah, there's
- 1:45:45degrees of you know, expertise, and there's a lot of folks who aren't
- 1:45:53do not have enough training to or the desire yet. Right, Yeah,
- 1:46:00it's an interesting dilemma. Yeah, I wonder would happen if she could hear
- 1:46:06you with the fight inside you. I wonder what the impact of that would
- 1:46:12be. I can imagine twenty years later, appreciating that she still takes up
- 1:46:18space and that you care. All right, Yeah, that would have been
- 1:46:25the helpful thing to focus on. Your response to it now might be different
- 1:46:29than it was twenty years ago too. Yeah, I don't know. This
- 1:46:31one is harder for me to know where I was with because I wasn't very
- 1:46:39aware of historyonic as much as I was borderline back then. Yeah, so
- 1:46:45I don't and I'm not even sure if the few people I'm thinking of had
- 1:46:49histrionic. But yeah, it was some sort of precise order. It's not
- 1:46:54just a random anxiety, you know. It was some deep relational trauma that
- 1:46:59was being foisted very firmly, you know, and weirdly and dangerous. It
- 1:47:03felt dangerous, you know. Yeah, well that's part of it, as
- 1:47:06you were scared. Yeah, it feels very dangerous. Yeah, it feels
- 1:47:11like I am already in the process of slipping through the thin ice and drowning.
- 1:47:17I could see why you would find an elegant way to back away.
- 1:47:23Yeah, you know, especially you know, when you have a scantily clad
- 1:47:28young woman in your home office and she's already angry at you, you know
- 1:47:32what I mean, and implying that somehow I'm trying to force her into therapy
- 1:47:38or something. You know, it just feels so dangerous, really interesting.
- 1:47:42She's being forced She's being forced by me. Yeah, yeah, no,
- 1:47:47I get by her dad ors like, well, I'm literally the one forcing
- 1:47:51her into therapy, right right, right. But that's that's the projective identification,
- 1:47:57that's the view of self in the world. I mean, it's fine,
- 1:47:59it's it has nothing to do with you. That one She walked in
- 1:48:02the door with that one rotten around inside her, and we don't even have
- 1:48:08the benefit of any kind of context, like she went because you know the
- 1:48:12court ordered, or too, I'm no, not that one. You'd know
- 1:48:14that, but you know because a spouse pushed her into it, or who
- 1:48:18knows what we don't know. Yeah, well live and learn, bob.
- 1:48:24Yeah, and everyone out there please take care of yourself because you deserve it,