Latest / Bloomberg Law / Best of Bloomberg Law: Intellectual Property
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law.
- 0:04Speaker 2: Are plaintiff's leries involved in a kind of competition in Congress?
- 0:08Speaker 2: Force a judicial code on the justices?
- 0:10Speaker 1: Interviews with prominent attorneys in Bloomberg Legal Experts.
- 0:13Speaker 2: My guest is former federal prosecutor Robert min Joining me
- 0:16Speaker 2: is Bloomberg Law reporter Kyle Janner, and.
- 0:18Speaker 1: Analysis of important legal issues, cases and headlines.
- 0:22Speaker 2: Is it unusual a grand jury like this to suspect
- 0:25Speaker 2: people aren't telling the truth? One of the first times
- 0:27Speaker 2: the Justice Department has called for the breakup of a
- 0:30Speaker 2: major company.
- 0:31Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:38Speaker 2: Welcome to the best of Bloomberg Law. Tonight, we'll look
- 0:41Speaker 2: back at some high profile intellectual property cases. Will ed
- 0:46Speaker 2: Shearon's copyright win help other songwriters? The Supreme Court will
- 0:50Speaker 2: decide a trademark clash involving a chewable dog toy that
- 0:55Speaker 2: mimics the Jack Daniels whiskey bottle, and Ermez wins the
- 0:59Speaker 2: first FT trademark trial.
- 1:07Speaker 3: Wow, cool a bag?
- 1:09Speaker 2: Do you like it?
- 1:10Speaker 4: Hello? I'm a girl. It's a purse, not just a purse,
- 1:12Speaker 4: It's a burken bag. I went to school a guy
- 1:15Speaker 4: named brickin. I don't think this is the same burkin.
- 1:17Speaker 2: Oh Rory Gilmour may not have known about the ultimate
- 1:21Speaker 2: status symbol, but her grandmother did.
- 1:24Speaker 4: Oh my god, a Burken bag. You've heard of it.
- 1:28Speaker 4: Of course, that's a very nice purse. Oh maybe I
- 1:32Speaker 4: shouldn't use it. Oh No, a Birken bag is meant
- 1:35Speaker 4: to be used and seen.
- 1:37Speaker 2: The iconic Burken bags range in price from twelve thousand
- 1:40Speaker 2: to more than three hundred thousand dollars, and there's a
- 1:43Speaker 2: six year waiting list to purchase one. So luxury brand
- 1:47Speaker 2: Hermes went to trial to protect its valuable rights to
- 1:50Speaker 2: the Burken trademark, suing an artist for selling Metaburken NFTs
- 1:56Speaker 2: digital images depicting the burkeen but covered in colorful, cartoon
- 2:00Speaker 2: unish fur. The artist Mason Rothschild claimed the meta burkins
- 2:04Speaker 2: were works of art and protected speech under the First Amendment,
- 2:08Speaker 2: but the jury disagreed, finding the NFTs were more like
- 2:11Speaker 2: consumer products subject to strict trademark laws with no First
- 2:16Speaker 2: Amendment protections. My guest this hour is intellectual property litigator
- 2:20Speaker 2: Terrence Ross a partner Katin Euchen Rosenman Terry. The jury
- 2:25Speaker 2: found Wrothschild guilty of trademark infringement, dilution and cyber squatting.
- 2:31Speaker 2: Do we know what tests they used to come to
- 2:34Speaker 2: that decision.
- 2:35Speaker 3: Well, the judge specifically asked the jury to determine whether
- 2:40Speaker 3: or not the meta burkins produced by mister Rothschild or
- 2:45Speaker 3: artistic works or consumer products, and they answered that question
- 2:49Speaker 3: saying that they did not view them as artwork. They
- 2:52Speaker 3: viewed them as consumer products. And so we have to
- 2:55Speaker 3: assume that they at least considered the Rogers test, because
- 2:58Speaker 3: one of the requirements of the Rogers test is that
- 3:01Speaker 3: it be an expressive work, you know, artistic works. It
- 3:04Speaker 3: would have been rejected out of hand.
- 3:05Speaker 2: There's this blurry line between art and commercial products. So
- 3:09Speaker 2: the jury determined that NFTs are more akin to commercial products.
- 3:13Speaker 2: Does that have any impact on future cases?
- 3:17Speaker 3: Not? Really. The finding of the jury is a fact finding.
- 3:22Speaker 3: Legal findings are left to the judge of the court.
- 3:24Speaker 3: The jury only makes fact findings, and the factual circumstances
- 3:28Speaker 3: changed from case to case. This is particularly true in
- 3:31Speaker 3: trademark law, where you have widely different facts producing widely
- 3:36Speaker 3: different results, so that finding by the jury is limited
- 3:40Speaker 3: to this specific case against mister Rothschild.
- 3:43Speaker 2: So people have been looking at this as a case
- 3:47Speaker 2: that has the potential to clarify how trademark law applies
- 3:51Speaker 2: to NFTs. Does it do that well?
- 3:54Speaker 3: I don't think a single case, unless it happens to
- 3:57Speaker 3: be in front of the Supreme Court, is going to
- 4:00Speaker 3: clarify the law in this area. What this case does
- 4:03Speaker 3: do is lay down a marker on behalf of trademark owners.
- 4:09Speaker 3: It points in the direction of findings that the metaverse
- 4:15Speaker 3: is subject to the landmark the US trademark Lause, and
- 4:18Speaker 3: it will encourage other trademark owners to now bring to
- 4:23Speaker 3: enforce their rights in the metaverse. I am aware to
- 4:27Speaker 3: clients of ours who have been thinking it was bringing
- 4:29Speaker 3: law suits waiting to see how this came out, and
- 4:32Speaker 3: this will encourage them. Now. The other thing this case
- 4:35Speaker 3: does is that lays the foundation for appellate decisions. So
- 4:40Speaker 3: now there is a concrete verdict in a case that
- 4:44Speaker 3: can go up on appeal and we can see what
- 4:47Speaker 3: the appellate courts think of the application trademark lause to NFTs.
- 4:52Speaker 5: Yeah.
- 4:52Speaker 2: So Rothschild's attorneys said that they'll take every legal avenue
- 4:57Speaker 2: that they have. What are the legal avenues that they have.
- 5:00Speaker 3: So the very first option that the defense has here
- 5:05Speaker 3: is to file emotion with Judge Raykoff, asking him to
- 5:11Speaker 3: set aside the jury verdict and to grant judgment to
- 5:15Speaker 3: the defense on the legal theories that are presented in
- 5:19Speaker 3: the case. This is going to be challenging for the defense.
- 5:23Speaker 3: It's something they will do, they have to do. But
- 5:25Speaker 3: Judge ray Coff basically said at the motion to this
- 5:28Speaker 3: miss stage that he was uncertain as to whether or
- 5:34Speaker 3: not there was sufficient factual predicate here for the defendant
- 5:38Speaker 3: to take advantage of the so called Rogers test, and
- 5:41Speaker 3: he wanted the jury to give him some advice on that,
- 5:45Speaker 3: and the jury gave him advice. They said, yes, there's
- 5:47Speaker 3: not a factual predicate here. This is not an expressive work.
- 5:50Speaker 3: It's not art, it's a consumer product, and the Rogers
- 5:54Speaker 3: test does not apply to consumer products at least, so
- 5:57Speaker 3: we think the Rogers test, which was from out this
- 6:00Speaker 3: court the Second Circuit, expressly says that a First Amendment
- 6:03Speaker 3: protection extends to the use of celebrity names in expressive
- 6:07Speaker 3: works where the use of the name is relevant to
- 6:10Speaker 3: the work and it's not intentionally misleading. And here that
- 6:15Speaker 3: key element that the jury says is missing is whether
- 6:17Speaker 3: or not this is an artistic work. So I think
- 6:20Speaker 3: they will lose the post trial motion unless he wants
- 6:23Speaker 3: to simply disregard the jury and they'll take it up
- 6:26Speaker 3: then on appeal to the Second Circuit. And this becomes
- 6:29Speaker 3: pretty important is the Second Circuit is the author of
- 6:32Speaker 3: the Rogers test, which the defense heavily relies upon here.
- 6:36Speaker 3: It is also one of the most important appellate courts
- 6:39Speaker 3: in the nation with respect to trademark claw and that's
- 6:42Speaker 3: where we will really get some guidance going forward into
- 6:45Speaker 3: the future. The Second Circuit affirms the verdict here and says, yes,
- 6:49Speaker 3: there's always trademark infringement. That's going to really be very
- 6:53Speaker 3: influential across the rest of the United States, even though
- 6:56Speaker 3: the Second Circuits perview is limited to the New York
- 6:59Speaker 3: and Connecticut.
- 7:00Speaker 2: The Supreme Court is hearing a case involving a Squeaky
- 7:03Speaker 2: dog toy and the Jack Daniels trademark. Could that decision
- 7:08Speaker 2: affect this case?
- 7:09Speaker 3: So in my view, that has always been the eight
- 7:12Speaker 3: hundred pound gorilla in the room that people that tend
- 7:15Speaker 3: to tag more here, particularly the judge in that case,
- 7:18Speaker 3: the Rogers test is squarely presented to the Supreme Court
- 7:22Speaker 3: as to whether it is a legitimate test, whether it
- 7:25Speaker 3: really exists, because remember Second Circuit made that up out
- 7:28Speaker 3: a whole clock. It's not in the trademark laws, it's
- 7:30Speaker 3: not statutory, it's judge made laws. And the Supreme Court
- 7:34Speaker 3: might say, well, there is no such thing in the
- 7:35Speaker 3: trademark lass. Or the Supreme Court could say, yes, we
- 7:39Speaker 3: have to have such tests as the Rogers test in
- 7:41Speaker 3: order to protect First Amendment interests in the trademark field,
- 7:45Speaker 3: but we don't like the way the Second Circuit works.
- 7:48Speaker 3: The test, our test will be and then they'll explain
- 7:50Speaker 3: what it is, or they could simply say, you know,
- 7:53Speaker 3: Rogers test is a great idea. It really protects First
- 7:55Speaker 3: Amendment interests. It works partly fine. We are narrowly cabinet
- 7:59Speaker 3: to protection of celebrity names used in artistic works or
- 8:03Speaker 3: toy expand it say, with greg expanded to expressive works
- 8:06Speaker 3: more generally. But so with all those question marks hanging
- 8:09Speaker 3: over this case, it really made no sense to try
- 8:11Speaker 3: it in mind you, other than say you're moving your
- 8:14Speaker 3: docket of cases down the road, because the whole thing
- 8:17Speaker 3: could be tossed out by a decision the Supreme Court,
- 8:21Speaker 3: and there might have to be a do over.
- 8:23Speaker 2: I don't think Ermez was in this for the money,
- 8:26Speaker 2: but the jury only awarded one hundred and thirty three
- 8:30Speaker 2: thousand dollars in damages. That's less than some Birkenbag's cost.
- 8:35Speaker 3: The point is Hermes only asked for about two hundred
- 8:38Speaker 3: and fifty thousand dollars, so the jury gave them a
- 8:41Speaker 3: portion of that. Trademark infringement cases don't typically result in
- 8:46Speaker 3: significant damage awards. Now, part of the specific reason here
- 8:50Speaker 3: is that miss Rothschild just didn't sell that many. I
- 8:53Speaker 3: think the evidence of trial was he sold fifty five
- 8:56Speaker 3: point two of these NFTs, and so he just didn't
- 8:59Speaker 3: generate that much profit. And the key in the trademark
- 9:02Speaker 3: area is what the plaintiff, the trademark owner gets is
- 9:05Speaker 3: a disgorgement of the ill gotten gains from the infringer.
- 9:10Speaker 3: So there's a cap on it to start with. Now,
- 9:13Speaker 3: what we are going to see here is a post
- 9:16Speaker 3: trial motion for attorney's fees, and those could be substantial
- 9:20Speaker 3: and I don't know whether the court will grant them,
- 9:22Speaker 3: but that is where the real hit on mister Rothschawk
- 9:26Speaker 3: could come from. But I think when you look at
- 9:28Speaker 3: this holistically, this case was never about recovering damages. This
- 9:32Speaker 3: case was about protecting the brand. The Birken trademark. Ermanes
- 9:37Speaker 3: apparently has specific plans in the metaverse, as many fashion
- 9:41Speaker 3: houses do, to start introducing their own NFTs, and it
- 9:45Speaker 3: needed this sort of trademark protection to extend to the metaverse.
- 9:49Speaker 3: And so this was a case about setting a precedent,
- 9:52Speaker 3: and I think they've been very successful in doing that.
- 9:56Speaker 2: I understand that fashion brands like Louis Vauton are now
- 10:00Speaker 2: filing applications for trademarks for design marks covering digital content,
- 10:05Speaker 2: including NFTs. Will that help them pursue these kinds of
- 10:09Speaker 2: claims in the future.
- 10:10Speaker 3: Yes, A registered trademark provides a brand owner with certain
- 10:16Speaker 3: procedural advantages, as well as the right to obtain attorney's
- 10:21Speaker 3: fees in a lawsuit, So there are advantages of that.
- 10:25Speaker 3: It is theoretically possible for a trademark owner to proceed
- 10:29Speaker 3: without a registration under a theory of unfair competition, but
- 10:33Speaker 3: I think the advantage here is to get the registration.
- 10:38Speaker 3: It should not be a difficult thing to do and
- 10:40Speaker 3: to have the full pana play then of trademark claims
- 10:44Speaker 3: and remedies available.
- 10:46Speaker 2: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Launch Show, Jerry Ross
- 10:49Speaker 2: and I will discuss the Supreme Court oral arguments in
- 10:51Speaker 2: that trademark clash involving the chewable dog toy that mimics
- 10:56Speaker 2: the Jack Daniels whiskey bottle. You're listening to Bloomberg.
- 11:02Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 11:09Speaker 2: At the center of a trademark dispute at the Supreme
- 11:12Speaker 2: Court was a chewable dog toy mimicking the iconic Jack
- 11:16Speaker 2: Daniels bottle, but with poop jokes. So perhaps it was
- 11:20Speaker 2: inevitable that there would be quips, laughter and confusion. Here's
- 11:25Speaker 2: Justice Samuel Alito asking the attorney for Jack Daniels, Lisa Blatt,
- 11:30Speaker 2: whether any reasonable person would think the whiskey company had
- 11:33Speaker 2: approved the use of its trademark on the dog toy.
- 11:37Speaker 3: A reasonable person would not think that Jack Daniels had.
- 11:40Speaker 1: To prove this. I think if you're selling urine, you're
- 11:42Speaker 1: probably gonna win on a motion to I mean, on
- 11:44Speaker 1: a twelve by six, but you're probably also violating some
- 11:47Speaker 1: state law.
- 11:48Speaker 4: But sure, oh, no, thought, you're not selling urine.
- 11:51Speaker 1: It's exactly this toy. I thought it.
- 11:54Speaker 3: Now, it's exactly this toy I'm sorry, which purportedly contains
- 11:59Speaker 3: some sort of dog I'm sorry.
- 12:01Speaker 1: L Okay, my bad, Justice Alito.
- 12:04Speaker 3: I don't know how old you are.
- 12:05Speaker 4: But you went to law school.
- 12:07Speaker 5: You're very smart, you're analytical, you have hindsight bias, and well, I.
- 12:10Speaker 1: Went to a law school where I didn't learn any laws.
- 12:12Speaker 2: So okay, but by the way, that was a diss
- 12:15Speaker 2: of Yale law school. Jokes aside, The issue was whether
- 12:19Speaker 2: the don toy, which includes references to old number two
- 12:23Speaker 2: and forty three percent Pooh by volume, is entitled to
- 12:27Speaker 2: First Amendment protection as a parody of the whiskey. But
- 12:31Speaker 2: just as Elena Kagan didn't get it.
- 12:34Speaker 1: In this case, what is there to it?
- 12:35Speaker 4: What is the parody here?
- 12:37Speaker 3: The parody?
- 12:38Speaker 1: Yeah, parody, because.
- 12:40Speaker 4: Maybe I just have no sense of humor. But what's
- 12:45Speaker 4: the parody?
- 12:46Speaker 2: My guest this hour is intellectual property litigator Terrence Ross
- 12:49Speaker 2: a partner Katin Euchen Rosenman Terry. So many of the
- 12:53Speaker 2: Supreme Court arguments are so weighty, so heavy, but not
- 12:57Speaker 2: this one. I mean, the humor at times seemed to
- 13:00Speaker 2: sync to the level of the doctor here. And this
- 13:03Speaker 2: is a case we've been waiting for, so Terry, did
- 13:06Speaker 2: it meet your expectations.
- 13:08Speaker 3: I thought the actual argument, particularly from the Solicitor General's Office,
- 13:12Speaker 3: was particularly good and cut through a lot of the
- 13:16Speaker 3: murkiness and went straight to the heart of the issue.
- 13:18Speaker 3: I thought the tone of the questioning did, as you
- 13:22Speaker 3: describe it, descend a little bit into the gutter for
- 13:25Speaker 3: reasons I can't explain. Over about a year year and
- 13:28Speaker 3: a half, now, this court, with its new makeup, seems
- 13:31Speaker 3: to be unable to approach intellectual property cases without using
- 13:36Speaker 3: a raft of examples, many of which are sort of
- 13:39Speaker 3: ludicrous and really don't advance the ball much. But that
- 13:43Speaker 3: has been the name of the game in intellectual property cases.
- 13:45Speaker 3: You know, you go to the Supreme Court, argue one
- 13:47Speaker 3: of those, and you better be prepared for a bunch
- 13:49Speaker 3: of rather silly examples being tossed at you. And that's
- 13:52Speaker 3: how this hypothetical works. Now that hypothetical.
- 13:55Speaker 2: Works, does a parody have to be good? Because just
- 13:59Speaker 2: as Elena Ca said, she didn't get it.
- 14:01Speaker 3: Yeah, when I heard Justice Kagan asked that question and
- 14:04Speaker 3: say she didn't get it. I think the way she
- 14:06Speaker 3: phrased it is something like maybe I'm the only one
- 14:09Speaker 3: here who doesn't get it. And I felt like jumping
- 14:11Speaker 3: up and saying, no, I don't get it too. I
- 14:13Speaker 3: don't see where the parody is. I mean, I would
- 14:15Speaker 3: go so far as to describe this as merely sophomoreic humor,
- 14:19Speaker 3: and as Groucho Marx would say, that's even an insult
- 14:21Speaker 3: to sophomores. I don't see what the parody is. And
- 14:26Speaker 3: mister Cooper, who was representing VIP Products that produced this
- 14:30Speaker 3: dog toy, kept saying, you know it was a parody
- 14:33Speaker 3: in trying to explain why and it wasn't just justice cake,
- 14:36Speaker 3: And at one point Justice Jackson scheimed in said she
- 14:39Speaker 3: didn't get it either. So this is one of the
- 14:41Speaker 3: whole problems with the Rogers test. I mean, what the
- 14:45Speaker 3: Rogers test says in its pure form is that the
- 14:49Speaker 3: name of a celebrity used in the title of an
- 14:53Speaker 3: expressive work does not constitute trademark infringement if it is
- 14:57Speaker 3: artistically relevant and not explicitly misleading. And various justice attack
- 15:03Speaker 3: what does it mean to be artistically relevant. Other justices
- 15:06Speaker 3: attacked what's an expressive work is everything that has a
- 15:09Speaker 3: statement on a T shirt and expressive work automatically. And
- 15:13Speaker 3: yet one other justice, i believe it was Justice Court
- 15:16Speaker 3: such attack this concept of what does it mean to
- 15:19Speaker 3: be explicitly misleading? Since the standard under the landamac the
- 15:23Speaker 3: trademark laws is confusion not misleading that one. And so
- 15:27Speaker 3: there seemed to be this consensus on the Court that
- 15:30Speaker 3: the test was very difficult to understand or apply. And frankly,
- 15:37Speaker 3: mister Cooper, representing the IP products didn't do much to
- 15:41Speaker 3: out it. Indeed, he came up with his own tests.
- 15:44Speaker 2: Well, I would say, confusion, misleading, welcome to intellectual property law.
- 15:50Speaker 2: Would they ever be able to come up with a
- 15:52Speaker 2: test that's easier to follow than the Rogers test.
- 15:57Speaker 3: I'm not sure that the Rogers test is easy to follow.
- 16:00Speaker 3: I'm not sure that there's an alternative. And this was
- 16:04Speaker 3: an issue that was explicitly posed by Justice Jackson, who
- 16:09Speaker 3: essentially said, Okay, well, what do we replace it with?
- 16:12Speaker 3: I agree with you though that there seems to be
- 16:15Speaker 3: a lot of confusion at the Court on this, and
- 16:18Speaker 3: I think it reflects the new makeup of the Court
- 16:20Speaker 3: and I've said this before and your show June. The
- 16:22Speaker 3: loss of Justice Ginsberg the loss of Justice Bryer were
- 16:25Speaker 3: body blows to the Supreme Court with respect to intellectual
- 16:28Speaker 3: property jurisprudence. They were the two justices who had experience
- 16:33Speaker 3: academic experience and judicial experience in copyright and trademarks. None
- 16:38Speaker 3: of the current sitting justices do. And it was reflected
- 16:41Speaker 3: in the argument. There seemed to be a really poor
- 16:45Speaker 3: grasp of how the Landham Act, which sets out the
- 16:47Speaker 3: US trademark laws works, questions that to trademark lawyers didn't
- 16:51Speaker 3: make any sense. And as Black, the Council for Jack
- 16:55Speaker 3: Daniels did a very nice job of respectfully trying to
- 16:58Speaker 3: correct their misunderstanding a fundamental trademark law. But it was
- 17:02Speaker 3: a steep mountain the climate. I'm not sure she got there.
- 17:05Speaker 2: The Rogers Test is not very popular in some quarters,
- 17:08Speaker 2: is it?
- 17:09Speaker 3: The trademark owners desperately want to get rid of the
- 17:12Speaker 3: Rogers Test. There is an element within the academic community
- 17:15Speaker 3: that wants to get rid of the Rogers Test, and
- 17:17Speaker 3: the Biden administration, to their credit, in a very simple,
- 17:20Speaker 3: plain spoken, but effective argument, said outright that the Rogers
- 17:26Speaker 3: Test was made up by the Second Circuit, It has
- 17:28Speaker 3: no statutory basis and it should be discarded. That's what's
- 17:33Speaker 3: that issue here. And the arguments in favor of eliminating
- 17:37Speaker 3: the Rogers Test in Toto are pretty daring strong. As
- 17:40Speaker 3: Justice Commas has, what's the textual support for that? And
- 17:44Speaker 3: all three councils said there is not. Justice Alito chime did, well,
- 17:49Speaker 3: what about the First Amendment and the trademark law that
- 17:52Speaker 3: we now have. The land of mak has been held
- 17:55Speaker 3: consistent with First Amendment no less than four times, and
- 17:58Speaker 3: so it's sort of an odd question. But Justice Alito
- 18:01Speaker 3: was the one justice who seemed desperate to hang on
- 18:04Speaker 3: to the Rogers Test. Three justices by Mike count did
- 18:08Speaker 3: not ask a single question, and that was Justice Barrett,
- 18:11Speaker 3: Justice Kavanaugh and the Chief Justice. They are all textualists.
- 18:15Speaker 3: They are probably looking at this appeal from the point
- 18:18Speaker 3: of view that Justice Thomas expressed and may have expressed
- 18:21Speaker 3: on the part of all of them. That's making it
- 18:23Speaker 3: unnecessary for them to talk what is the textual support
- 18:26Speaker 3: for the Rogers Test? And as the government said, there
- 18:28Speaker 3: is no. The Rogers Test is an exception to illegal
- 18:32Speaker 3: activity and it does not have any textual basis, and
- 18:35Speaker 3: therefore I think it's very much at risk, particularly if
- 18:38Speaker 3: this click of justices who did not engage in debate,
- 18:41Speaker 3: although to remove.
- 18:43Speaker 2: It despite all the confusion, what's your take on whether
- 18:46Speaker 2: Jack Daniels will win here?
- 18:48Speaker 5: It lost at the Ninth Circuit.
- 18:49Speaker 3: So the overarching sentiment seemed to be that the Ninth
- 18:54Speaker 3: Circuit got this raw and that should be reversed and
- 18:57Speaker 3: that would be technically a win or Jack Daniels. The
- 19:01Speaker 3: Ninth Circuit decision indeed took the Rogers test and maximalized it,
- 19:05Speaker 3: creating a lot of problems. So I think where the
- 19:08Speaker 3: Court's going to go with this is to say the
- 19:10Speaker 3: Ninth Circuit got it raw, it's got to go back
- 19:13Speaker 3: to the district court, and they've got to consider parody.
- 19:15Speaker 3: And then the next part is the question mark. Do
- 19:18Speaker 3: they say, we're not going to decide the Rogers question
- 19:21Speaker 3: now because this case isn't right. We're going to send
- 19:23Speaker 3: it back and let it come back up the chain again,
- 19:26Speaker 3: so three years from now we'll be right here again.
- 19:28Speaker 3: So that's one option, and it's a favorite option of
- 19:31Speaker 3: this Supreme Court. The second option is that Justice Thomas
- 19:34Speaker 3: cobbles together five votes to do what the Biden administration
- 19:36Speaker 3: wants to get rid of the Rogers test. The third
- 19:38Speaker 3: option is that somebody cobbles together are enough votes to
- 19:43Speaker 3: change the Rogers test. I think that's the least likely
- 19:47Speaker 3: outcome here. Indeed, I could see this being one of
- 19:51Speaker 3: these decisions where you get five six votes to reverse
- 19:55Speaker 3: and send it back to the district court, and you
- 19:57Speaker 3: don't get enough votes on any of the right, so
- 20:00Speaker 3: that remains undecided. So I think that's probably what I
- 20:04Speaker 3: would bet on if I had to bet here, that
- 20:06Speaker 3: the case we'll go back to the discord, which is
- 20:08Speaker 3: a win for Jack Daniels, but without any guidance on
- 20:12Speaker 3: the Rogers staff, which would be a.
- 20:13Speaker 2: Shape coming up next. Ed Sheeran wins over the jury.
- 20:17Speaker 2: This is Bloomberg.
- 20:21Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law, with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 20:27Speaker 6: I'm obviously very happy with the outcome of the case,
- 20:30Speaker 6: and it looks like I'm not having to retire from
- 20:32Speaker 6: my day job after all. But at the same time,
- 20:34Speaker 6: I'm unbelievably frustrated that basis claims like this are allowed
- 20:37Speaker 6: to go to court at all.
- 20:39Speaker 2: It's the second copyright infringement trial ed Shearon has had
- 20:42Speaker 2: to go through in a year, and he made a
- 20:44Speaker 2: dramatic vow from the witness stand that he would quit
- 20:48Speaker 2: music if he was found guilty of infringing Marvin Gaye's
- 20:51Speaker 2: nineteen seventy three classic Let's Get It On. But after
- 20:55Speaker 2: a two week trial, it took a jury only two
- 20:57Speaker 2: hours to come out with a verdict clearing Shearing and
- 21:00Speaker 2: finding that he and his co writer had created his
- 21:03Speaker 2: Grammy winning hit Thinking Out Loud independently, which is an
- 21:07Speaker 2: absolute defense against copyright infringement. Sharon had defended himself with
- 21:12Speaker 2: his guitar, demonstrating for the jury how similar chord progressions
- 21:17Speaker 2: are commonplace musical elements found in numerous songs that no
- 21:21Speaker 2: songwriter can own. He did a similar demonstration on The
- 21:24Speaker 2: Howard Stern Show on Sirius XM.
- 21:28Speaker 7: So my one is when your legs a work like
- 21:31Speaker 7: they used to before, and then there's ever told, do
- 21:35Speaker 7: you likely that I loved you?
- 21:37Speaker 2: And then.
- 21:39Speaker 7: People get ready, there's a chain of coming and then
- 21:45Speaker 7: what was the looks like we made it? Look how
- 21:49Speaker 7: far we've come? A baby and she breaks sty I
- 21:54Speaker 7: mean there was there was one hundred and one songs.
- 21:57Speaker 2: Despite the win, Sharon expressed frustration at the current litigation
- 22:01Speaker 2: frenzy that threatens songwriters.
- 22:04Speaker 6: It's devastating to be accused of seeing someone else's song
- 22:07Speaker 6: when we put so much work into our livelihoods. I'm
- 22:10Speaker 6: just a guy with a guitar who loves writing music
- 22:12Speaker 6: for people to enjoy.
- 22:14Speaker 2: Joining me is intellectual property litigator Terrence Ross, a partner
- 22:17Speaker 2: Katon Newchen, Rosenman Terry. The music industry was watching this
- 22:21Speaker 2: lawsuit with trepidation. Does the verdict alleviate the fears?
- 22:26Speaker 3: You know?
- 22:26Speaker 2: Will it discourage frivolous copyright lawsuits?
- 22:29Speaker 3: You would hope.
- 22:30Speaker 2: So.
- 22:31Speaker 3: It is certainly significant in that regard, and seems to
- 22:34Speaker 3: indicate that the pendulum in these copyright in song cases
- 22:39Speaker 3: has swung back in favor of the singer songwriters and
- 22:44Speaker 3: away from the plaintiffs. You know. This all started with
- 22:46Speaker 3: a twenty fifteen lawsuit against Pharrell Williams and Robin Thick
- 22:51Speaker 3: for their Blurred Lines song, which purportedly infringed Marvin Gay's
- 22:55Speaker 3: nineteen seventy seven Got to give it up, and an
- 22:57Speaker 3: enormous jury verdict that got reduced to a little bit
- 23:00Speaker 3: on appeal, but that's sort of created this target for
- 23:04Speaker 3: plaintiffs to aim at and encourage them to bring more lawsuits.
- 23:09Speaker 3: And now looking back, we've had multiple wins for defendants,
- 23:14Speaker 3: and it seems like that case involving Robin Thick and
- 23:18Speaker 3: Perrel Williams was actually an outlier and that we may
- 23:21Speaker 3: have made too much of it. And keep in mind
- 23:23Speaker 3: there was a unique situation going there and that robins
- 23:25Speaker 3: Thick had given just a dreadful deposition which you later
- 23:28Speaker 3: claimed he'd been high giving it, and they played that
- 23:31Speaker 3: to the jury and it was so bad, you know,
- 23:34Speaker 3: the videotape that it may have influenced the jury in
- 23:37Speaker 3: ways that we didn't fully comprehend at the time. Now,
- 23:40Speaker 3: with a fantastic performance and I can't call it anything
- 23:43Speaker 3: less than performance, but a Sharon on the stand in
- 23:45Speaker 3: his case, we see how these cases really do favor
- 23:49Speaker 3: the defendant if the defendant is a credible person who
- 23:52Speaker 3: gives a good test pony and can explain the basis
- 23:54Speaker 3: of his song.
- 23:55Speaker 2: Yeah. I believe that it was the defense attorney in
- 23:58Speaker 2: the Blurred Lines case that said that Shearon made all
- 24:01Speaker 2: the difference here. He was so committed he was in
- 24:04Speaker 2: the court every day he was on stand from multiple days.
- 24:08Speaker 2: He's this nice guy, but also he took on the
- 24:12Speaker 2: defense now and again and even called the musicologist for
- 24:16Speaker 2: the other side.
- 24:17Speaker 5: So what he was doing was criminal.
- 24:19Speaker 3: You're exactly right, June. And he had made the mistake
- 24:22Speaker 3: early in his career of caving in and settling a
- 24:25Speaker 3: couple copyright lawsuits. The reality is that it's often cheaper
- 24:30Speaker 3: to settle some of these copyright suits than to spend
- 24:33Speaker 3: the money to defend against them. The problem is, if
- 24:35Speaker 3: you get that reputation, people just put you at the
- 24:38Speaker 3: top of their list of targets to go after for
- 24:41Speaker 3: copyright infringement, even though you've not been held libel for
- 24:44Speaker 3: copyright infringement and you don't think you did it. And
- 24:47Speaker 3: a couple of years ago, and Sharon apparently sent to
- 24:49Speaker 3: himself enough is enough. He defended aggressively a copyright lawsuit
- 24:53Speaker 3: in the UK, which he won. It was last year.
- 24:56Speaker 3: This case has been going on since before the pandemic
- 25:00Speaker 3: was brought and he's been aggressively defending in and I
- 25:03Speaker 3: think with this win, two wins in two years, sending
- 25:06Speaker 3: a very strong message that if you come after him
- 25:09Speaker 3: for copyright infringement. You better be prepared to go the distance,
- 25:12Speaker 3: and you better be prepared to get your rear end kicked,
- 25:14Speaker 3: because he is not giving in anymore, not settling these lawsuits,
- 25:18Speaker 3: and that's going to make all the difference going forward
- 25:21Speaker 3: for him.
- 25:21Speaker 2: The jury found that Seran had created Thinking out Loud independently.
- 25:27Speaker 2: That's an absolute defense against copyright infringement. Even if it's
- 25:31Speaker 2: a song you've heard and it might have influenced you, it.
- 25:34Speaker 3: Is an absolute defense. So you could say that two
- 25:38Speaker 3: songs have some substantial similarity, which is the test for
- 25:41Speaker 3: copyright infringement, but if the song was independently created, it
- 25:45Speaker 3: just doesn't matter that they're substantially similar. That's an absolute defense.
- 25:49Speaker 3: And the key I think here at this trial was
- 25:52Speaker 3: and sure in getting up on the stand, as you
- 25:54Speaker 3: said multiple times, and explaining the songwriting process in such detail,
- 25:58Speaker 3: even explaining he was to take a break, take a shower,
- 26:02Speaker 3: came back, his co writer was working on some chords.
- 26:05Speaker 3: The detail is what brought it home to the jury
- 26:08Speaker 3: that this wasn't in any sense of copying, that there
- 26:11Speaker 3: was a true creative process here, that he was able
- 26:14Speaker 3: to relate to them and explain an enormous specific factual
- 26:19Speaker 3: detail and then was backed up by his co writer
- 26:22Speaker 3: on this particular song, Gamy wadge.
- 26:24Speaker 2: Do you think the musicologists played a part in this?
- 26:27Speaker 2: I mean, whether one was better than the other, whether
- 26:29Speaker 2: the jury liked one more than the other.
- 26:31Speaker 3: So musicologists testify as expert witnesses. The only difference between
- 26:36Speaker 3: expert witness and the other witnesses that an expert witness
- 26:39Speaker 3: is allowed to offer his or her opinion based on
- 26:42Speaker 3: their expertise, whereas a lay witness can only testify to
- 26:46Speaker 3: facts that they actually saw witness experienced. And as a result,
- 26:50Speaker 3: sometimes jurors, because there's this process of qualifying an expert
- 26:55Speaker 3: making them seem to be great juris, say well, they
- 26:57Speaker 3: must know something more than we do because the judge
- 26:59Speaker 3: has been so. Like I said, they're an expert in
- 27:01Speaker 3: the field, and we may want to defer to them.
- 27:03Speaker 3: My experience of that in these sorts of cases where
- 27:05Speaker 3: you have a very articulate defendant who can explain the
- 27:09Speaker 3: songwriting process, that the musicologists sort of flip into the
- 27:13Speaker 3: background a little bit and are less important. Now that's
- 27:16Speaker 3: set here in this so called battle the experts between
- 27:19Speaker 3: the two musicologists It's clear that Edsurance god got the
- 27:22Speaker 3: better of the argument and got helped in that respect
- 27:25Speaker 3: enormously by Ed Shuron's own testimony. In his testimony during
- 27:29Speaker 3: his defense part of the case, Ed Sheeran specifically when
- 27:32Speaker 3: after the plain tests musicologists and explained how this particular
- 27:37Speaker 3: chord progression, or at least the second chord in the
- 27:39Speaker 3: chord progression, was not substitutable, and how it really made
- 27:42Speaker 3: a significant difference in how a pop song came out,
- 27:45Speaker 3: and he played and explained to the jury almost as
- 27:47Speaker 3: if he was his own musicologist expert. And I think
- 27:50Speaker 3: that's really was a turning point. His musicologist then picked
- 27:53Speaker 3: up on that theme and supported it and sort of
- 27:55Speaker 3: gave legal credence to it. But again, I think this
- 27:58Speaker 3: was ed Shurance testimony that won the.
- 27:59Speaker 2: Day jury verdict doesn't set any legal precedent, But the
- 28:03Speaker 2: way that Sharon testified about chord progressions he used that
- 28:07Speaker 2: are common among songwriters and.
- 28:10Speaker 5: Building blocks of music.
- 28:12Speaker 2: Do you think this provides a blueprint for other songwriters
- 28:16Speaker 2: accused of copyright infringement.
- 28:18Speaker 3: Well, the defense here certainly wrote a script on how
- 28:22Speaker 3: to handle this sort of copyright infringement lawsuit and if followed,
- 28:28Speaker 3: should yield simple results. The interesting thing about this whole
- 28:31Speaker 3: case is that the judge studiously avoided writing any decisions
- 28:34Speaker 3: that might have served in any way as presidential. It
- 28:38Speaker 3: was very curious. It makes it very difficult to challenge
- 28:41Speaker 3: on a Biele as well. But you have here as
- 28:43Speaker 3: a straight up jury verdict with a juried finding, and
- 28:46Speaker 3: appellate courts say that apps them some sort of corruptions,
- 28:49Speaker 3: some sort of broad committments. They got proper instructions which
- 28:52Speaker 3: they did that you don't overturn jury verdict. What's interesting
- 28:55Speaker 3: in that respect because I think it's less the presidential
- 28:58Speaker 3: value this case that matters going forward extent sort of
- 29:01Speaker 3: the notions that defendants are no longer going to roll
- 29:04Speaker 3: over and settled just because of an accusation of copyright
- 29:07Speaker 3: revengement that Gore vigorously defend, and that this is not
- 29:10Speaker 3: going to be easy picking, which is how it's been
- 29:12Speaker 3: viewed for the last five, six, seven years.
- 29:15Speaker 2: Despite all we've said about the defense here, there are
- 29:18Speaker 2: two more lawsuits against Sheer and over the same song,
- 29:23Speaker 2: brought by investment banker and musician David Pullman and structured
- 29:28Speaker 2: asset Sales, which bought a portion of ed Towns in
- 29:31Speaker 2: the state, and after the verdict, Pullman said that he
- 29:34Speaker 2: and his lawyers had learned from the trial, we know
- 29:37Speaker 2: what to expect. Why another trial about the same song.
- 29:42Speaker 3: It's a great question, and it's a real problem in
- 29:45Speaker 3: this field. My understanding of the situation is that a
- 29:50Speaker 3: third party funder obtained rights the portion of the copyright
- 29:55Speaker 3: owned by ed Townsend's estate, which gave them independent standing
- 30:00Speaker 3: to sue for infringement. I think there's going to be
- 30:02Speaker 3: a real question whether or not the verdict here, which
- 30:06Speaker 3: was specific verdict of independent creation, is what's known as
- 30:09Speaker 3: raised ju dakata. In other words, it decides the issue
- 30:11Speaker 3: once and for all. That motion will have to be
- 30:13Speaker 3: brought by the defense, and it's a pretty strong motion,
- 30:16Speaker 3: so they may not get to a trial in that
- 30:20Speaker 3: second lawsuit.
- 30:21Speaker 2: Coming up next, I'll continue this conversation with Terry Ross.
- 30:24Speaker 2: We'll talk about that quick verdict. This is Bloomberg.
- 30:30Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 30:36Speaker 2: After a two week trial, it took a jury only
- 30:39Speaker 2: two hours to come out with a verdict clearing pop
- 30:42Speaker 2: star Ed Sheeran of copying Marvin Gay's Let's Get It On.
- 30:46Speaker 2: I've been talking to intellectual property litigator Terrence Ross of
- 30:49Speaker 2: Katain Euchen Rosenman, So Terry. As far as the similar
- 30:53Speaker 2: lawsuits pending against Sharon over the same song brought by
- 30:58Speaker 2: investment banker and musician David Pullman, Pullman said one of
- 31:03Speaker 2: his lawsuits would be different because it involved a copyright
- 31:06Speaker 2: on the recording of Let's Get It On, rather than
- 31:09Speaker 2: just the sheet music. I know we've discussed it before,
- 31:12Speaker 2: the sheet music versus the recording, whether that does make
- 31:15Speaker 2: a difference.
- 31:16Speaker 3: So it's one of the anomalies of twentieth century US
- 31:21Speaker 3: music that we did not have copyright protection for recorded
- 31:26Speaker 3: sound until very late in twenty century nineteen seventy eight. Well, correctly,
- 31:31Speaker 3: the law that was the copyright law for most twentieth century,
- 31:35Speaker 3: the Copyright Act of nineteen oh nine, did not allow
- 31:39Speaker 3: for copyright and recorded sound because it was in its infancy.
- 31:43Speaker 3: It did allow in copyright lonias that's going well back
- 31:46Speaker 3: into the nineteenth century, allowed for copyright in sheet music,
- 31:50Speaker 3: and so at the time that What's Getting On was
- 31:53Speaker 3: published and recorded, there was only copyright available in sheet music.
- 31:58Speaker 3: Now there is one sort of variant on that. There
- 32:01Speaker 3: are states, individual states that have allowed copyright and recorded
- 32:06Speaker 3: sound earlier than the United States Congress did, and apparently
- 32:09Speaker 3: they were going to make some sort of claim under
- 32:12Speaker 3: state law. You remember a couple of years ago the
- 32:14Speaker 3: old pop group The Turtles, who recorded all of their
- 32:17Speaker 3: music prior to the Copyright Act of nineteen seventy six
- 32:21Speaker 3: coming into effect and allowing for copyright recorders, that they
- 32:24Speaker 3: brought a series of lawsuits across the country under very
- 32:26Speaker 3: state laws accusing the streaming services of infringing their copyright
- 32:31Speaker 3: purported copyright, and ultimately settled when they got a favorable
- 32:34Speaker 3: decision out of one of those states, I think Florida maybe.
- 32:37Speaker 3: So there's this issue that has always been hanging out
- 32:39Speaker 3: there and has never been decided by the Supreme Court.
- 32:43Speaker 3: The Copyright Act, both the nineteen oh nine Act the
- 32:45Speaker 3: nineteen zventy six Act preempted all other laws. But because
- 32:49Speaker 3: record it sound wasn't covered by the nineteen oh nine Act,
- 32:52Speaker 3: it wasn't in theory preemptive of recorded sound copyright because
- 32:56Speaker 3: there was none. The states preferred to do what they
- 32:59Speaker 3: wanted to do, and that's what the reference here is
- 33:01Speaker 3: with respect to this other lawsuit.
- 33:03Speaker 2: In the sharing case with a computerized version of Let's
- 33:07Speaker 2: Get It On based on the sheet music. If the
- 33:10Speaker 2: plaintiffs in the next case can actually play the song,
- 33:13Speaker 2: do you think that would make a difference, even if
- 33:16Speaker 2: Sharon testifies as he did here so.
- 33:19Speaker 3: Clearly made a difference in the Blurred Lines case. I
- 33:22Speaker 3: was not in the courtroom when that happened. A lot
- 33:24Speaker 3: of people said that the playing of those two when
- 33:26Speaker 3: listened to by the jury, seemed to have an impact
- 33:28Speaker 3: upon the jury, So it is possible that it would
- 33:31Speaker 3: have that pack here. I've listened to both songs. You
- 33:33Speaker 3: know a little bit about music, but I'm not some
- 33:35Speaker 3: sort of musicologist expert, and I'm not sure that it
- 33:38Speaker 3: would make a difference to me. But you know, every
- 33:40Speaker 3: jury's different, and I have to wait and see what happens.
- 33:44Speaker 3: But again, I think it's important to note that the
- 33:46Speaker 3: jury made a really important factual finding here that this
- 33:49Speaker 3: was an independent creation that should really my view control.
- 33:54Speaker 2: The deliberation time here is also not the norm.
- 33:58Speaker 3: That he already took on. He's like two hours to
- 34:00Speaker 3: do this. I mean, you can think about this too. Yeah,
- 34:02Speaker 3: the jury gets back there and it's takes a half
- 34:05Speaker 3: an hour to get organized, get a cup of coffee, whatever.
- 34:08Speaker 3: And that's assuming that it's not the lunch breaker ready,
- 34:10Speaker 3: in which case they kill an hour. Then they spend
- 34:13Speaker 3: fifteen to twenty minutes arguing about four person because you
- 34:15Speaker 3: got big four person first, and the bailiff brings in
- 34:18Speaker 3: the forums and they go, Okay, well, what is it
- 34:20Speaker 3: that we're supposed to say that sort of thing? You know,
- 34:22Speaker 3: So that two plus hours is probably only an hour
- 34:25Speaker 3: of deliberation time.
- 34:27Speaker 2: It'll be interesting to see if those other cases get
- 34:30Speaker 2: to trial. Because Ed Sheeran, now it's his second time testifying,
- 34:35Speaker 2: second time winning. I think he knows what to do now,
- 34:38Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Terry. That's intellectual property litigator Terrence Ross,
- 34:42Speaker 2: a partner at Katin Yuchen Rosenman.
- 34:45Speaker 5: And that's it for this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show.
- 34:47Speaker 2: Remember you can always get the latest legal news on
- 34:50Speaker 2: our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 34:54Speaker 2: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, Slash Law,
- 35:00Speaker 2: and remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 35:02Speaker 2: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street time. I'm June Grosso
- 35:06Speaker 2: and you're listening to Bloomberg