Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 471. THE Cancer Episode you must Hear! Thyroid Cancer and Hashimoto's Connection with Dr. Nasha Winters
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to the Thyroid Fixer podcast, where I'm all about helping you lose that stubborn weight that won't come off no matter what you do. Get off your couch at 2 p.m. and get through your day with energy and stop counting the hairs that come out of your head.
- 0:18I'm your host, Dr. Amy, and I'm here to help you get optimized with your thyroid and your hormones. It's all part of living our mantra, better thyroid, better hormones equals a better life. So let's get you back to being the badass human that you're meant to be. Let's approach it from a thyroid and hormone optimization standpoint, better hormone,
- 0:40Between myself and my guests, you will be loaded down with information to take control of your health and get back to being you. So let's get started. My podcast guest for today, number one, is much needed. I can't believe that we have made it to 460 plus episodes and we haven't talked about cancer yet. Not to this level, to this depth. Yeah.
- 1:09And number two, because Dr. Nisha Winters and I are like each other's fans. Like every time we see each other anywhere, we're like, oh my God. And we really need more time to just like sit down and pick each other's brains. But I think that's why we sometimes schedule podcasts with guests is so that we can just get them on for like our own selfish knowledge.
- 1:28But then, you know, we decided to share it with y'all too, just to be nice. So Dr. Naysha, thank you so much for coming on today. I'm just, like I was saying beforehand, I'm loaded down with questions in my mind. So I cannot wait for this.
- 1:42I'm so excited. And as you said, I mean, it feels like we've had this sort of fangirling thing going for a while. And for such a long time in tiny podunk Durango, Colorado, I was the only endocrinologist in a four state region for 10 years. And I am like, I know about this much of the endocrine space. There's so much here. So it's really fun to get together with someone who geeks out on this and only this. And so I think we're going to have a really interesting conversation with your guests and of course, with each other today. So thanks for having me.
- 2:11Absolutely. So, oh my God, we have to start with your story because it is just so powerful. So like you just shared, you started just as endocrinology practice and now you have totally transitioned. And, you know, a lot of times we transition in this space, in this health space because of something that happened to us. Yeah.
- 2:33So I'm going to hand this over and please tell us your story. Sure, sure. So as you alluded to, we are often, you know, the pain to purpose story plays out again and again and again. And crazy for me, my story started well before I even finished, went into medicine and went into medical school. But I never thought what I'm doing today would land me where I am today. The story is really crazy. And that was 19. I was diagnosed with stage four end stage ovarian cancer.
- 3:03It had been missed for many, many months. I'd only known weird health conditions my entire young life leading up to that moment. So just to give your listeners a little background, I'd had a lovely diagnosis of thyroid dysfunction. We later learned was Hashimoto's. We learned later on I had celiac disease. We're going to talk about these connections today. We're even going to talk about the connections of thyroid dysfunction with ovarian cancer, by the way, and other cancer types in general.
- 3:30But I also had IBS, which there's some relationships here, a lot of PCOS, which is a metabolic endocrine disrupting process, which also ties into this whole thyroid dance. So I kind of had this unbelievably wonky endocrine system for so long. And so when my symptoms got worse and worse, they just thought it was accumulated effects of
- 3:49all my other diseases that had led up to that point until I landed in the ER on the brink of death. And unfortunately, there was nothing standard of care could offer. I was in end-stage organ failure. I had a complete bowel blockage. I had a grapefruit-sized mass on my right ovary. I had...
- 4:06lesions throughout my whole peritoneal cavity, throughout my whole abdomen, on my liver. I had fluid in my lungs. I had fluid built up around my heart. I had lesions throughout my whole abdomen, blocking on important structures. I was in trouble, to put it mildly. And so cancer was the last thing I ever thought I'd want to do in medicine because it almost took my life. And it was...
- 4:30A crazy story as to why I just even kept that so secret. That's a whole nother podcast you and I can do, but it was a really, really traumatizing time for me. Fast forward in private practice, I wanted to do anything but oncology. So I really wanted to focus in whole family medicine. And of course, the endocrine world lands very nicely in that.
- 4:52And as I mentioned before, I was the only person in the whole Four Corners region of the United States that was really focused in that area. And I'd studied with a lot of really amazing people like Dr. Datis Karazian, Dr. Isabella Wentz, not directly, but more indirectly, you know, Dr. Alan Christensen. A lot of the folks in the kind of functional endocrinology world were my teachers as well. So I gleaned a lot of it. And so I'm really drawn to folks like you, because you guys are systems thinkers.
- 5:18And you have to be thinking about the thyroid, not in a silo, but in relation to the rest of this beautiful symphony of our hormones and our endocrine receptors and chemical messengers. Yeah. Yeah. So wait, what did you do? I mean, my God, you got the cancer down. Like you're leaving me hanging here, girl. I'm like waiting for the end of the movie. I know, I know.
- 5:40You know, it's still, it's here it is this month. I hit 33 years out of a terminal diagnosis, which is always just surreal that I could even be that, that old number one. Because terminal means you're going to die. So they gave me three months. They gave me three months. They didn't expect me to see 1992, much less 2024. I had just turned 20. At the time I was in the hospital, I was 19. By the time full diagnosis came through, I had just turned 20 and,
- 6:09And they didn't expect me to see the end of my 20th year, right? That was, they didn't expect me to see into the year 1992. So for me, a couple of weird things happened. And just really briefly, one of them is because of that bowel blockage, I had to fast.
- 6:23No one was talking about fasting in 1991, guys. In fact, they were pushing the opposite, just like they still do today. No matter what, don't lose weight. No matter what, that was already too far gone for me. I was already severely cachectic. I was already very sarcopenic. I was already fluid buildup in parts of my body where it shouldn't be. And the bowel blockage didn't allow me to eat. So the very fact that I had real estate taken up by fluid and blockages of tumors probably saved my life.
- 6:48on one level. We know that now in retrospect because of studies that have come on since. So fasting was very integral. Another component of this, which I know you speak to in volumes, was stress. I came from an incredibly stressful, traumatic childhood. If your listeners know anything about the adverse childhood event score, this is exposures to traumatic events before the age of 18. And it's a score of zero to 10. And basically for every yes you have on those 10
- 7:18an exponential increase in chronic illness, including cancer at a younger and younger age. So just to give you and your listeners a sense, I was a 10 out of 10. So of course, I was going to be met with extreme health crises and experiences. All of that also led to just a body that was wired in a way to be in chronic stress and duress. And so that
- 7:39weakened my immune system, that messed with my endocrine system, that messed with my microbiome and my neurotransmitters and my hormone regulatory pathways and my blood sugar pathways. So I started to learn early on in my medical training, undergrad and on into med school and beyond, the interconnectedness of it all.
- 7:59So I did have some understanding of that. And I was studying psychology and biology to understand psychoneuroimmunology. That was my self-constructed major after my cancer diagnosis. I wanted to understand because I had a sense of the psychology of my experience, but
- 8:16But I also knew that there was physiology and biochemistry in this experience. And so I played in both realms. I played in the psychosocial spiritual realm, including even plant medicines were probably integral in saving my life. Really powerful therapy, really powerful EMDR work in trauma resolution. Those were just as integral as the accidental fasting and some of the herbal therapeutic interventions I use, like acupuncture for my pain management therapy.
- 8:41They don't respond well to pharmaceuticals. We learned that early on. And then things like Pau Darko tea, for instance, Tababwea is its Latin name. This was an accidental finding in the literature in the early 90s that showed it induced apoptosis in ovarian cancer cells. So I was drinking gallons of this, you know, a week in hopes of whatever I could find. 1991, guys, there was no Dr. Google. Yeah.
- 9:04There were no beautiful podcasts with people like Dr. Amy sharing this wisdom. I was really out there alone figuring this out. And to this day, still figuring it out. My gosh, girl. Oh, my gosh. You went through so much. That is crazy. So, all right, let's start with what triggers cancer. You know, we hear a lot about genetics. And then, of course, we have epigenetics. And I know you dive into that in your practice, really looking.
- 9:34treatments people should do based on their genetic profile. So, you know, I feel like just even in mainstream media and in our worldly thinking, we always think, oh, cancer. Yeah, that's genetics because my mom had it and her grandma had it. And so I'm just predisposed to having cancer. But it's it's that. And and there's so much more I want you to unpack.
- 9:59First, I love that you bring it up in that particular way, because that is how we've looked at cancer since 1914, thanks to the work of Dr. Theodore Bovary. This is the man who basically coined the concept of somatic mutation or genetic causation of cancer. And we've put all of our energy and all of our eggs in that one basket.
- 10:19ever since. And that's where we've kind of gone off track is instead of being open and asking questions and continuing the scientific method of, okay, this wall, we've hit a wall, what else, what else, what else? We just have just driven that train even harder in the genetics. And let me just let you and your listeners know, if this was truly a genetic disease,
- 10:41we would be able to remove from a healthy cell the nuclei, which is basically the genetic storage unit of our cells, and replace the nuclei of a cancer cell. And if this was a genetic disorder, we should be able to turn that cancer cell into a healthy cell. Just like if we took that nuclei out of a cancer cell and replace the nuclei of a healthy cell, if this was a genetic disease, it should make that cell now cancerous.
- 11:08That does not happen. And we've repeated these types of nuclear cell transfer studies many times over for many decades, and they all fall short. Where we now are considering, and the research, thank God, is going, is this more of this concept of the terrain, the milieu, the extracellular matrix, or basically the swimming pool in which those organelles within our cells are hanging out in, is where the magic's really happening, where dis-ease is created or health is created. Right.
- 11:36And so specifically, that cytoplasm, that extracellular matrix, what the cell's swimming in, what's inside the cell and the organelles are swimming in, have more impact on our cancering process than our genetics. And those little swimming pools inside the cells and the swimming pools outside of our cells are very sensitive to information.
- 11:56that we're taking in from the environment in, on, and around us. That means that our food, our exposures to light, water, toxins, body care products, pharmaceuticals, nutraceuticals, thoughts, exercise too much, too little, just stressors in general, all of these things impact that environment, which then sets the stage where,
- 12:21for signaling pathways, which may have oncogene potential, meaning it can flip on certain gene behaviors. But to your point, we can act above the gene and impact it with our daily dietary and lifestyle modifications, which is what cancer is. 95% of the time, it is something that we have impact to change. Whereas less than 5% of cancers are truly of genetic
- 12:50dysfunction. And yet all of our resources in the research world and the treatment world are focused on this genetic problem. We're really missing an opportunity for folks. And I think that's the piece that I want everyone to understand and why something like a really honed endocrine system and thyroid functioning system play a massive role in your body's ability to ward off disease or treat disease once it's on board.
- 13:14Absolutely. And you talk a lot about the metabolic approach to cancer. And I feel like we've been hearing more and more about that over the last just few years, maybe five, maybe a little bit longer. But I don't think people know exactly what that means. And the reason why I really want to dive into that with you is because, like I shared off camera, my audience is obviously filled with women with thyroid problems and hormone dysfunction. And I'm going to talk
- 13:44And in my practice, I see, I would say 95% of my patients are insulin resistant. Now that could be because of their lifestyle. They're just eating garbage. And I don't even mean, you know, you're hitting McDonald's and eating donuts every day. I just mean that you are consuming things that you think are good for you. You know, you're getting the gluten-free pasta, but that still is jacking up your blood sugar. And you're getting the...
- 14:11The sugar-free snack wells, but it's still loaded with carbs. So, and we can go on and on. Or stress, which also affects your glucose and insulin regulation. But really 95% of all my patients, they have that thyroid dysfunction, which I want to get into. They have the hormone imbalance, which I want to get into because like you shared, both of those impact our cancer risk and cancer expression. But what about that insulin resistant component? How important is it?
- 14:40First of all, I love that in the last few years, every conference I go to, whether it's a general medicine conference or an oncology conference, the theme is metabolic health, which I love that you brought this up. And when we look at studies that show that less than...
- 14:566.8% of Americans are considered metabolically healthy. We should be taking note of that and doing something about it. So when you say 95% of your patient population is insulin resistance or metabolically disabled in some form or fashion, it might even be more than that really, you know, for your patient population. And to your point, the, the role just so people have an understanding from 1850 to,
- 15:22to today, we have gone from about five pounds of sugar per person per year to upwards of 175 pounds of sugar per person per year in a relatively short period of human evolution. Okay.
- 15:38it has overwhelmed our little powerhouses in our cells known as the mitochondria. And we've mentioned earlier about the extra, you know, the organelles and the within our cells and the swimming pool that they're in. Well, one of the most important organelles within our cells is the mitochondria. It is that sensing organ.
- 15:58It is taking in all the information, especially from food, thought, water, pollution, toxins, medications, etc. And it translates that information, sends out signals to the rest of the system, especially things like our endocrine system, to respond to the input.
- 16:16And so what has happened is we've gone, as you said, a lot of people are thinking they're doing great. We went into our fear of fat phase for the past 50 years. And when you take the fat out of food, you put in more sugar. So it's palatable. So that's where big changes happened. We also really pushed a very, very grain and legume dense dietary recommendation in.
- 16:39and very fruit forward dietary recommendation because it's what our palates naturally want. We gravitate to sweet. When we're uncomfortable, when we're under stress, we gravitate to sweet, looking for sweetness in our life. So we tend to default to sweet things, to carbohydrates, to simple sugars when we need fast energy or fast soothing.
- 17:00And so that has led to a population of increasingly, increasingly more metabolically deranged individuals, which less than 7% of us are actually metabolically healthy today. So with that, the things like I'm eating my low-fat yogurt, well, if you look at the sugar content, loaded with carbohydrate.
- 17:18Right. Or, hey, I'm a vegetarian. That's great. I was a vegetarian for 20 years. I was a vegan for seven of those years. But when I looked at my daily carbohydrate intake with my epigenetic profile, so basically what I evolved from, my ancestry, I was eating an average of three to four hundred grams of carbohydrate per day to get my protein needs met as a vegetarian.
- 17:42Crazy in that the amount of sugar dysregulation, the level of insulin, the level of C-peptide and insulin growth factor, all the drivers, by the way, the signaling pathways to all of our cancer processes.
- 17:57all of our cancers have some driver of insulin fueling more cancer progression. 90% of cancers are very almost predominantly glucose hogs. The other 10%
- 18:12can vary. Maybe they might be more preferential towards certain proteins or certain fats at different times, but those are more advanced bulkier cancers. But even those cancers still need to work on diminishing the insulin levels to turn off some of the growth factors. And so when we look at a time of high stress,
- 18:30endocrine disruptions of our world in, on, and around us, and high carbohydrate intake, more than ever before, we are in a constant grow, baby, grow state in ourselves. And that is very difficult to get in front of unless you take very specific, thoughtful steps to avoid or reverse that.
- 18:51Yeah. And in this day and age, I mean, everything that you were just saying, it sparked in my mind. OK, wait a minute. We also know that covid cases, covid deaths increase with poor metabolic health.
- 19:07Alzheimer's, dementia is called now type three diabetes because of its relationship to more metabolic health. So if we just start there, I mean, could it even be argued that if we just start with improving our metabolic health, really controlling our blood sugar and our insulin response,
- 19:26Yes, it might mean that you need to change your diet and lifestyle, get your stress under control or fix your thyroid, which has a direct impact on your insulin signaling. That is move number one for prevention and longevity and really prevention of all cause mortality and all disease states.
- 19:43Nailed it. I mean, that's where some of the famous researchers in longevity show that even just simple caloric restriction in my in, you know, in in spotted times, not like ongoing caloric restriction, but our feast and famine are we evolved from having resources available and having resources not available. And our bodies could calibrate and create resilience.
- 20:05But now we have access 24 seven every day of the year for, you know, years and years on end. And you can even get like a papaya in the dead of winter in Colorado, or a pumpkin in the dead of summer in Mexico. You know, it's like, these are the weird things that we have access to our bodies don't know what to do with all of that increased input, but also
- 20:30or output. We do not burn enough energy to meet the energy we consume. We do not burn off what we consume anymore. And we did that for millennia. We evolved from that. So even in the environments that are still heavily plant forward or heavily, like I think about my community in India or the communities in Indonesia, we're,
- 20:53These are also some of the highest exploding rates of cancer and diabetes in the world because the diets that served them for generations are now contributing because they're not meeting their energy input and energy output in the same way. And they're...
- 21:10mucking up the works with all of the extra things in our environment that we're being exposed to on a regular basis. And just the access to that much sugar all the time has changed us for generations to come. So now we even have to talk about, yep, you've eaten this way for 10,000 years, but you have to think about it differently today because it didn't have glyphosate.
- 21:33You weren't getting 175 pounds of that sugar a year. You were getting five pounds of that. And you were working very physically hard to plant, grow, harvest, and manipulate that food to make it ingestible. We don't have to do that anymore.
- 21:50Right, right, 100%. So, okay, now let's tie this back to having a non-optimized thyroid. So whether you have Hashimoto's, hypothyroidism, you're being treated, you're not being treated, you're on T4 only, it's not quite right. We'll just, we'll categorize that as just thyroid dysfunction or non-optimized thyroid. How does that contribute to that?
- 22:15an increased risk of thyroid cancer or hormonal cancers make that connection for me? I mean, many of my listeners have already gone through thyroid cancer. So does that mean that they're already just even having gone through it and maybe having been treated for it, does that now increase the risk of endometrial cancer and ovarian cancer and uterine cancer? Yeah.
- 22:36This is such a good question because piecemealing all of this together over 30 years, you will never find what I'm going to speak to you about next in one place. This is piecemealed from multiple resources and multiple research over decades to understand these processes because of my own medical history, as well as the tens of thousands of patients I've been able to serve on this journey. I've learned things along the way.
- 23:02All of them are referenceable. So none of this is just hokey pokey made up information. Okay. But let me give a little context. So you and your listeners probably are already aware of that thyroid dysfunction. So 90% of folks dealing with a thyroid disorder actually have autoimmune thyroiditis, right? So I know you speak to this in volumes. And so that's one component of this. And then when we break down that autoimmune thyroiditis a little bit further, it's
- 23:31The three slash four major thyroid cancer types, the number one, 80 to 85% of thyroid cancer cases are papillary thyroid carcinoma. And the crazy thing about papillary thyroid carcinoma, they frankly, I've yet to see it not correlate, but I would use the language carefully to say most of them started out as Hashimoto's thyroiditis.
- 23:55But I've yet to see in my practice of all the folks with thyroid cancer, papillary thyroid cancer, all of them had Hashimoto's thyroiditis. They just hadn't been tested for it until they came along to see somebody like you or I. So that's the most common. And that one is super slow growing and really not typical to metastasize except for one particular genetic variant, which we can talk about here in a moment, which is also thanks to changes in our environment over the last few years, not our true genetics, but how we're altering.
- 24:24our genetics with other information. The next, some of these are clumped together, medullary and follicular thyroid carcinoma is about 10% of the population. They are, follicular is more slow growing, medullary more quickly growing. Both of them have a tendency to metastasize. They like to go to the long-term.
- 24:43in particular, and some of the lymphatics around. And they are just a little more deranged. They're a little more aggressive. The most aggressive is only about 1% to 3% of thyroid cancer types. And this is an anaplastic. And it's often kicked off by a major radiation event or some major hit to the DNA that's very destructive. Even things like Cowden syndrome or Lynch syndrome or particular familial genetics that make...
- 25:12This cancer type can show up very, like it's super rare, super aggressive, but all of these I just described, all of them are not responsive to chemotherapy. Okay. Right. So I want to plant that crazy seed.
- 25:27What they do offer this is surgery. They'll often just remove the full thyroid, which then patients are, and I'm sure Amy, Dr. Amy, you probably see a ton of these folks who are just a mess because you cannot quite calibrate their system. The medications are never as good as our bodies. Right. Right. And what's really tough is that thyroid medication, we try and give them like, here's your dose. Right.
- 25:51But we are a dynamic individuals. They should perturbate with seasonally and times of day and times of our cycles and life cycles. And so the fact we try to put somebody on a medication and keep them on that dose is also...
- 26:04Very weird for our bodies. It's not normal, right? It's not based on anything except for here's a standard dose for pharmacology. But here's the crazy thing I want your listeners to understand. The main treatment we give folks with a cancer diagnosis of the thyroid is RAI, radiation uptake of iodine. It's a radioactive iodine that gets taken up into the cancer cells. Here's the craziest thing.
- 26:31This is where I will freak out a lot of colleagues in the endocrinology world, is the very treatment that we give folks actually causes cancer.
- 26:41And the weirdest thing is I've never had any thyroid cancer patient I've ever had who've come to me early in their diagnosis, who's never had that treatment of RAI therapy, zero. We're talking hundreds of cases, zero have ever metastasized, zero have ever died from their condition. The only patients I've had that had any kind of excessive behavior of their cancer type of their thyroid were those who had undergone RAI. Mm-hmm.
- 27:09And very specific, the mechanism with, we mentioned the Hashimoto's connection. We mentioned that papillary thyroid carcinoma is the most common cancer type. The relationship between papillary and Hashimoto's is well documented. And there are two main drivers of Hashimoto's.
- 27:26iodine issues and gluten issues that kick up reactive oxygen species, that kick up inflammation, that kick up that insulin response you talked about. When we have a body that's taken on iodine, we will then release more estrogen to deal with that excess iodine. So then we have estrogen driving the train as well of causing cancer cell proliferation. And so we just create this crazy whack-a-mole storm
- 27:55And we bring on, and the iodine itself stimulates the thyroid peroxidase antibodies that are the hallmarks of Hashimoto's autoimmune thyroiditis. So it leaves the body in this precarious immune dysfunction. It creates more inflammation. Then we give it radiation, a known carcinogen.
- 28:16which makes thyroid cells are even more vulnerable to radiation than any other cells in our body. And so it's just something interesting to think about that we treat this cancer with therapies that cause this cancer to worsen. And we often have women who've had maybe a history of pneumonia or history of breast cancer where they've had radiation to the chest wall, whether it was through x-rays or through radiation for their breast cancer treatment. Thyroid is also within that field.
- 28:45and very vulnerable. So oftentimes when I see women who've had breast cancer and radiation treatment for breast cancer, I'm watching them very closely to make sure it does not progress into thyroid cancer as well, which is very, very common as well. So I want to unpack a lot of that though. I'm not sure where to start. Let's start with iodine because I'm with you. So if a patient comes to me and says, okay, I have to have my thyroid removed due to cancer.
- 29:14And they're giving you the option of thyroidectomy surgery or radioactive iodine treatment. I always say go the surgery route because you don't want that RAI in there. Right. Just for everything that you just said. But then there's over here, we have iodine use. We have supplemental...
- 29:34iodine so i don't want people to get all freaked out about oh my god i'm taking iodine and it's going to cause cancer no no so can you clarify that like are you okay with someone supplementing with iodine to keep their iodine levels up to help lower the reverse t3 antiviral blah blah all of that detoxification versus the radioactive iodine treatment
- 29:57So I used to be in the pro iodine supplement camp for many years until I started learning that supplemental iodine over about one milligram a day starts to create this estrogen dominance pattern, starts to create this chronic ROS reactive oxygen species pattern, starts to increase more autoimmune thyroiditis patterns.
- 30:18which then makes the terrain more vulnerable to a cancering process. So I pulled people off of anything that contains supplemental iodine and just said, please just eat your high quality salts. Please eat your seafood. Please eat your occasional seaweed and get it from that. You will get enough because most of our patients, what they're missing out on are various forms of the other minerals because of the over processing of our soils, which,
- 30:45We've got this imbalance that's happened. And so that's why I love the mineral combinations of like our beam friends and, you know, because that just brings this harmony back and lets the body be wise about what it needs and what it doesn't need. And it can figure it out on its own because we were getting that from our food for all those years. Now we have to supplement it because our soils are so depleted. So I typically find that patients who are coming across thinking they're actually iodine deficient, they're actually selenium deficient.
- 31:12And that is what's very interesting. We've learned that selenium specifically is basically like birth control to the thyroid peroxidase antibody. So it helps stop that proliferation of those antibodies that can further damage the thyroid tissue. But we've also learned that we have these TPO, these thyroid peroxidase receptors on other tissues and organs of our body, not just in our thyroid gland.
- 31:37We very specifically have them in our hippocampus and our hypothalamus. We very specifically have them in our gonads and our ovaries and our testes. And so when we, even if we've had that thyroidectomy and now we're taking iodine, we could still be kicking up Hashimoto's and other parts of the body.
- 31:54If we're taking iodine supplementally, we could be throwing that mineral balance off even further. That's one of the things I've really liked about some of your supplements is you are very careful about not to give the additional iodine. I think there's only one or two of your products that contain it. But I think for the most part, your thyroid support is without additional iodine.
- 32:14Oh yeah, actually, none of my products contain iodine. We carry an iodine that we don't actually even make. It's a cellar and iodine. We carry that on the store because, gosh, when I dove into the research of Brownstein, Dr. David Brownstein. That's who I was part of that camp for many years, yeah. Oh man, it's just so right there in your face. And then I have dosed iodine anywhere between six...
- 32:39And like 25 milligrams for patients, especially those like my listeners who are on T4 only. And that's, I want to touch on that next. T4 only, the reverse is through the roof. Iodine brings that down. And a lot of them experience a betterment and improvement of their symptoms when they started on iodine that they wouldn't have gotten otherwise. So, oh man. Yeah.
- 33:02I don't know. But I think like, first, I always screen everybody for Hashimoto's. If they already have Hashimoto's, we just keep iodine out of the, just keep it out. It's just really important to keep it out because of what we do know very specifically about its impact on the TPO antibodies. For those who don't have, you know, if they just have primary hypothyroidism, not autoimmune hypothyroidism, I think that...
- 33:24Pulsing and occasional dosing can be absolutely appropriate, especially if they live in the goiter belt, like heading through the Midwest where we don't have as much of that in our soil or our food processes. So keeping that in mind, those would be places that I like to use it more like a paint.
- 33:41Instead of an oral, I like to bypass and use the dermal application and see how quickly it goes in. Then I know the body will use exactly what it needs and discard anything it doesn't. One of the coolest things I have when I was in private practice is we would occasionally paint the cervix with Lugol's solution to change breast density. And it would be literally on manual exam before, paint the cervix, manual exam on the breast after, and you'd feel the softening of those hard nodules in the breast tissue. So we get in, get out. It can be...
- 34:09very, very powerful, a time and a place. But I think what happens is, and what happened with my practice, I had to write a letter to 2,500 patients explaining what I learned and basically say, if I killed, if I screwed any of you up, I will pay the medical bills because of what I started seeing.
- 34:26I started seeing massive skew of labs because I test very prolifically. Everybody gets labs almost monthly. Thyroid labs every three months. So I'm watching every, and beyond TSH, which I know you're a fan of as well, going way beyond that. We can watch that pendulum change and you can watch where it goes through the place of kind of going to the happy place and then the problem place. You can overshoot it. And so it's easy to see those. I'm really militant about watching the thyroid antibodies closely for someone who is taking on.
- 34:55some treatment with exogenous iodine. For folks, like you mentioned, like the differentiation, if you're getting a radioactive bolus of it, holy hell, that plays up pretty hard. That's like hitting you with a sledgehammer instead of a feather. Yeah. That's-
- 35:10really has deleterious effects and can really throw people for a loop. We try and give our patients like have them go suck on lemons afterwards to really help excrete, create a massive pumping out of their salivary glands to try and excrete that iodine as quickly as possible. We have them take binders and sauna.
- 35:28We can do the best we can if they are going that route. I, like you, really strongly suggest people don't do it, but I still have folks who do. So looking at that, we go by case by case, Dr. Amy. It's just like, you know, if they've already got known Hashimoto's, I avoid that. If there's a family tendency or, you know, propensity towards that, I avoid that. Because papillary is the most common, I tend to avoid it there. But I have seen some pretty cool things on like breast, you know, lesions when it's painted onto the cervix.
- 35:55or occasional painting of the forearm to like give them a little bolus if they are experiencing some issues where we could use a little bit of like, especially like I said, the goiter belt zone of where the mineral imbalance might even be worse. But what you'll find is you deal with people's metabolic health, you get their minerals balanced, you make hydrate that you're dealing with their stress response that they're got their oxytocin on because they're dealing with great connection and community and support.
- 36:25all of that beautiful access repairs. Like when we just take out the garbage and put in the support mechanisms, the body regulates pretty miraculously. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And then going back to what you said, I wanna get your take on this. So post-virodectomy or even post-RAI, standard of care and endocrinology, as you know, is to give T4 and T4 only, and then check the TSH. And if the TSH is within normal limits,
- 36:54then just leave them on that T4 dose or adjust it up or down or whatever. And the problem is, and my argument for this is, is we just took out your thyroid gland that produced T4 and T3. The thyroid gland in and of itself is a main conversion location. I know we have the liver, we have the gut, we have peripheral tissues, but the thyroid gland does play a role in T4 to T3 conversion. So to give T4 only to me,
- 37:19is really in the realm of medical malpractice. Because you are, and this is where I want to really get your input on. I want you to speak on what I just said, but also...
- 37:30There have been some studies, albeit not many, but some saying, oh, look, we're seeing a connection between T4 use and cancer. So, you know, my patients are coming to me like, oh, my God, I'm on 25 micrograms of T4. Am I going to get cancer? I'm like, no, because, you know, we have you on, you know, NDT medication. We have you on a little bit of T4 and a little bit of T3 and you're optimized and you're good. So can you expand on all of that?
- 37:59First of all, you are a unicorn in a chronology field. I really want people to hear that because when I even would talk to conventional endocrinologist colleagues around the country, when I was consulting on a patient, it was like pulling teeth to beg for something beyond a TSH.
- 38:17and something beyond it, just a T4. Most never, ever run a reverse T3, a T3 uptake, any of the thyroid antibodies for your total T3 itself, like nothing. It was like that was just left off and ignored because they were just looking at a number that they could medicate. And even then, how many of your patients had perfect labs and still felt like shit?
- 38:39Most of them. Yep. They were optimized. So Dr. Amy, you guys, is a unicorn in that she understands the evaluation of and the systemic nature of and the interrelationships with as well as the metrics in which to actually gauge the
- 38:56besides the subjective of the patient, but the objective of their data to say, do we have your medications dialed in? Do we have you titrated at the right time? Do we need to cycle you? Do you need to change it with seasons? Do you need to change it from pre-menopause to perimenopause to post-menopause? What are your needs there? This is the woman who knows what I'm talking about. And most people would never even consider this. So first of all, I'm so grateful to you for that.
- 39:22Second of all, the studies, when they started coming out a couple of years ago about, you know, synthetic T4 causing increased rates of cancer, like you, everyone started flipping their lid. People who come to somebody like you or I, we are never just giving synthetic T4. It's just never going to happen in our world. However, 99.9% of patients aren't seeing somebody like you or I, and they may just be on that.
- 39:44And the concerns, there's a couple of things. So first there's, there is some good data, especially interestingly enough in breast cancer of a correlation with that. The mechanism is still not quite understood, but there seem to be, you know, causation correlation. We're not sure, but there's some trends. The other thing that was very interesting is we used to, in the thyroid cancer world, aggressively, um,
- 40:07suppress thyroid function with extreme high dosing of exogenous thyroid hormone, because that's what we're taught to like, that's how you suppress the cancer from coming back. We actually realized, oops, that was a mistake. Not only does it make for more because hyper thyroid increases proliferation of cell turnover. That's not a good idea in cancer, but also it strongly depletes one of our largest endocrine organs, which is our bone.
- 40:36And that interrelationship between there's that mineral discussion in our calcium, magnesium, vitamin D, vitamin K, selenium, potassium, like all of those minerals get thrown off because we break down the bone very, very quickly with being more in a hyperthyroid state.
- 40:53whether it was intended through medication to help women lose weight or intended to suppress post-thyroidectomy, you know, for cancer, or just somebody put on a dose and stayed there. And no one ever figured out if that dose was just right or too much or too little along the way, which is the vast majority of the patients out there. So the point is somebody like you
- 41:14you're looking relatively routinely as to how they're responding and you make those adjustments accordingly. You know, and we used to just teach our patients like, especially because we would play with these little kind of compounded micro dosing places and give the patient sort of a sense of you're going to wake up every day and know what you need.
- 41:34Here's some of the symptoms you're going to be looking for. Here's how you're going to turn up the volume or turn down the volume based on how you're feeling. And that was after we established a few baseline labs so that the patient really got to correlate what they were feeling in their body and what was showing up on their lab values to know, oof, I'm a little hyper now. I need to cut this back. Oof, I'm a little sluggish. I need to kick this up.
- 41:54And they'd start to learn trends and patterns, kind of like our continuous glucose monitor. I would really love, Amy, have you got something like that in the works? Like some type of continuous thyroid monitor to give us a sense of our circadian patterns. Is there some way to do that today? Oh, that'd be money. I'll work on that. Okay. Work on it. You got it.
- 42:12Because I'm imagining, and especially for someone like you who watches it so closely, that it's not a flat line. It's very dynamic. So how do you, like you're asking me the question, but I'm flipping it around. Like how do you educate your patients to really tune in and feel what they feel in between their lab tests?
- 42:35Yeah, it's exactly that. It is tuning into your body. And, you know, I think we all have a dial that we can turn up or turn down in terms of getting tuned in. So, you know, you had mentioned stress earlier and stress is such a huge driver of cancer cells metastasizing and even expressing itself.
- 42:57Well, okay, let's add on another layer. Stress completely turns down your dial of being able to listen to your body because I will have patients that are like, oh my gosh, I'm anxious. And like, I'm like, my heart's racing. And I go, okay, well, is there any stress? And you're like, yeah, my mother-in-law just moved in. I'm like, okay, so you're not over-medicated.
- 43:16You are just really, really stressed out. And you have to kind of differentiate. But then I teach my patients, if you're sitting there and, you know, you're working at your desk and you look at your Apple Watch and your heart rate is that of you doing cardio or a brisk walk.
- 43:33then you're probably over-medicated. If you can't sleep at night, if you're sweating, if you're, you know, just all of those signs that our bodies give us that, hey, we need to adjust things down. So I do really try to educate my patients so that they can make these little tweaks. Because as you know, so many people out there, and this is, I would attribute this more to conventional medicine dogma,
- 43:57You listen to the doctor. You do what they say. You take that medication every day. I don't care how you feel. That was prescribed to you and you take it no matter what. And that's really not the case when we're tuning into our body. We do have the power to adjust up and down according to how we feel. So, yeah, I mean, that's my answer is just education, education, and really teaching people how to tune into their bodies.
- 44:22I love it. Well, there's, I mean, the whole word doctor in Latin, docere means teacher. And so we're teaching as clinicians, we should be teaching more than just prescribing. And then we should teach our patients to be docere, to doctor themselves, to understand and listen in and tune in and communicate what they're experiencing with their healthcare provider to help watch that and to be believed when they say something's weird. And then what's beautiful is you and I have metrics. We can go and test.
- 44:51We can take a look at their insulin. We can take a look at their thyroid function. We can take a look at their cortisol levels. We can take a look at a lot of things and see what's driving the train and deal with it. Because sometimes, like here's the crazy thing. Like for instance, bipolar disorder is actually often autoimmune thyroiditis, the ups and downs, right? It's like our mental highs and lows.
- 45:12It's like, golly, like pieces of that. Or when we think we're fatigued, well, it's actually maybe more of a blood sugar issue or a cortisol issue versus a thyroid issue. Or maybe your weight gain is not that your thyroid's not working. It's that everything else has stopped working and your thyroid's working its ass off to catch up. And this is what I think is so extraordinary. Why endocrinologists are my favorite because of the systems thinking process.
- 45:37at least those who are trained beyond just the prescription pad of here's your insulin and here's your T and your synthetic T4. Right. Because unfortunately there's a lot of endocrinologists that only know that realm, but the more functionally thoughtful and functionally trained endocrinologists, you guys understand the relationship and
- 45:53I call it the three S's, you know, the sugar, stress, and sex impact on any of our hormonal expressions, whether it's from your ovaries, your gonads, your thyroid, or your pituitary, or your adrenals, even your pancreas and your bone health is going to be responsive to your stress response, to your insulin response.
- 46:15And to your safety, security, and connection in the world, which is more about our oxytocin levels versus some of the other hormones that we give a lot more lip service to. And so if we can calibrate their cortisol, calibrate their insulin, calibrate their oxytocin, oftentimes our need for even exogenous hormone replacement is mitigated, modified, or at very least microdosed as the only thing required to create some balance in the system.
- 46:45Right, right. Absolutely. I love that you said that. Okay. I want to, since we're talking about removal of body parts, I want to ask you a personal question that I did not preload you with this, but so it's a little bit of a story and I want to get your opinion. So I just recently did a podcast telling everybody about my experience with possible
- 47:09uterine cancer. So what happened? I'll be very brief. I was on the Wiley Protocol of Hormones. I was not bleeding. They did a biopsy. They found...
- 47:21atypical, complex atypical hyperplasia. So based on that, the gynecological oncologist said hysterectomy. I said, I'm not really comfortable with that. So why don't we do a DNC? I said, you know, get up in there, see what else is in there, scrape it out. Let's have some fun. And that also came back.
- 47:42no cancer anywhere, no cancer in my ovaries, nothing in the abdomen. I had the CT scan as well, blah, blah, blah. I did all of that. And their answer was still, but I think you should get a hysterectomy. And I said, well, yeah, but I'm not that comfortable with that. And they said, well, that's a
- 47:58you know, 20 to 30 or 30 to 40% increased risk of cancer when you have these atypical cells. And I say, okay, well, number one, I'm on progesterone. I'm on bioidentical progesterone that will provide some protection to my uterus.
- 48:14And, and then number two, I said, why don't you just do a biopsy every couple of months and check to see if cancer pops up. And then that can be a different conversation at that point in time. So based on that, what is your opinion of that practice? And then of my decision to keep my uterus? Yeah.
- 48:33Well, a few things I would look at as someone coming to me with a diagnosis of probable or high risk for uterine or endometrial cancer is I would look at the main drivers, which is low D3. So I'd make sure your D3 levels are optimized between 80 and 120. That's my happy place.
- 48:48And of course, K2 to make sure you keep the calcium in the right places and out of the wrong places. So that combination, I look at your insulin and your insulin growth factor, very big drivers of uterine hyperplasia. And so again, stress, sugar, sex. So perhaps you came through your own window of high stress that might've kicked up some things.
- 49:08to look to see if that impacted your insulin levels. I ideally for just general prevention, I like an insulin under five. And if someone's already cancering, I like an insulin under three because if someone's been practicing more of a low carbohydrate diet, I might look at a C-peptide in addition because it's more sensitive than just an insulin or an A1C.
- 49:26And I would like to make sure that's under two and an A1C is under five. So that's kind of my parameters. Insulin growth factor, that's another one that can be kicked up by estrogen, by sugar, by stress that can really drive that insulin growth factor component. I want to make sure that's as low as possible around 100, 120, so that we're not growing other things. Yeah.
- 49:47The other piece here is I would look at exposures, like what's in your drinking water, what's in your endocrine disrupting chemicals in the environment in, on, and around you. Because those are really big players. There's tons of these metalloestrogens. So arsenic, cadmium, mercury, those are things that can actually kick up malformed estrogen metabolism.
- 50:09Even if you're doing all the other things right, that you may be in your drinking water, your soil, et cetera. So I'd explore that. And then I would also look at from kind of more of an esoteric, like what, you know, what are you carrying in your womb? You know, what grief, what loss, what betrayals, what abuses have happened there that women, we store everything.
- 50:28Our bodies are amazing. We create life there, but we also carry a lot there. And so exploring that as well, when we go there, those are the places that I'm looking at. Specifically, we can look at a vaginal ultrasound for you, far less invasive than a biopsy because I don't really want to poke sticks at sleeping tigers, but you could do a vaginal ultrasound annually. You could get a baseline CEA, CA-125 and HE-4 biopsy.
- 50:53which are the main tumor markers of uterine or ovarian cancer, just to make sure things look good there. And then just be looking at, maybe do a Dutch hormone test, look at your single nucleotide polymorphisms, make sure you're not turning your progesterone into 4-hydroxyestrone.
- 51:09which a lot of women do if they've got a SIP1B1 or a SIP1A1 SNP, meaning that you're putting in all that good, but it's getting turned right into something not so good, which is adding to that hyperplasia. So those are just some kind of pieces that I have more questions than answers, but you certainly have a lot less invasive options and options that also say, well, let's figure out why you went hyperplastic.
- 51:32And so just removing it because your body's trying to tell us something. She's so dang wise. And the fact that you did a thorough clean out and things look good. Well, you've probably given yourself a runway to then explore a little bit what else is going on in the building and be more thoughtful about your approach.
- 51:49Now, that would be kind of my general caveat. But if you have an instinct, like I have had women just say, I just feel like it's time to have a surgery. Well, I would do a lot to prepare that patient. I would have a ceremony around this. I would be more intentional in preparing as well as grieving.
- 52:08So I want women to know that there is a time and a place for a surgical intervention as well, especially if something did come back out there. Sometimes the best treatment for many cancers is a surgical intervention if there is something very in situ in the spot, but it still always warrants a deeper dive into the terrain to understand why that cancer expressed to begin with, or those dysplastic cells expressed to begin with.
- 52:34So what's interesting to me is as you're talking, and this is my question, so can I or other people, obviously my listeners, but mainly me, consult with you? Because I have all of these. It's interesting as you're talking, like I have a genetic test over here. I have a Dutch test over here.
- 52:53I have a vibrant wellness talks panel over here, all ordered by different practitioners. I need you to take all of that and let's sit down because I want, I'm as much about cancer prevention. I think we all should be as it's cancer treatment. If it ever occurred, God forbid. So we can do that, right? We can sit down with you and map out a plan of cancer prevention as well.
- 53:18Which is my, this would be my dream job is on the prevention. Most people come to me when it's the Hail Mary. I'd love to see y'all before you get to that point. Now, I no longer work directly with patients, but I train clinicians to do all the things I just explained to you. So now we have over 650 clinicians and allied health providers in 43 countries that I've trained through this methodology.
- 53:40So a lot of them work telemed, a lot of them work virtually, a lot of them consult virtually. So you don't have to physically be in the same town. I've got a really great gal just up the road from you where you are that I'll definitely, I was just mentioning before we started recording, would know exactly how to evaluate all of that because you're right. What happens a lot, even in the well-meaning functional medicine space is we still silo.
- 53:59Yeah, we've got this test over here. We have this test over here. We have this test over here. You got your female hormone expert. You got your thyroid expert. You got your polycystic kidney expert. You've got your, I'm a terrain expert. And so I am the systems thinker. I like to see it all come together. And that's how I train the clinicians and the patient advocates into seeing it from that realm, which I think you would really dig because you already have a systems thinking brain. So we can certainly, you already got so much good information to come through and be like, what are we missing?
- 54:26What are the clues here? And then how do we tweak it? Because you are very thoughtful about how you take care of your body, but you probably have just a couple of blind spots, just like all of us do. And to have someone outside of you, like I don't doctor myself. We are the worst, by the way.
- 54:42horrible idea exactly exactly thank you exactly and so but having somebody from a bird's eye view coming in and looking over it really fascinating and we might just find that oh you have this one thing you just need to do this one thing because you do all the things so we're going to find out from you doing a little detective work what might have just led to that hyperplastic process and nip it in the bud yeah
- 55:06Yeah, absolutely. Okay, well, before I let you go, I need to ask this one other question. Hormones. So, you know, we heard from the Women's Health Initiative all those years ago that hormones, progesterone, estrogen, testosterone, specifically progestin and estrogen, specifically conjugated equine estrogen and progestins that they use in the Women's Health Initiative study cause cancer.
- 55:32Now, in our practice, we use bioidentical hormone replacement therapy. Can you speak on the connection to increasing or decreasing the risk of cancer when we replace those hormones that start to decline as we age?
- 55:49Perfect. So a few things. First of all, what you described, all those very synthetic, high, high estrogen metabolite and the progestin synthetic, very, very known carcinogenic aspects. So I don't think anyone is questioning that reality any longer. I think we've kind of put that in a bucket, like here we are. Where it's a little more gray is in the bioidentical world.
- 56:10And I do want to just say that bioidentical does not mean natural. We kind of put it in the camp as that. It's that it's so similar to mimicking your own endogenous hormones that it binds a little more assertively and a little more aggressively to our receptor sites than our endogenous inside hormones do. So it can be a powerful tool. And I think one that is sometimes overused and not properly chosen for the individual at the given time. And again, what I find, like I just had a patient...
- 56:36Last week, endometrial cancer, 72 years old, has been on the same dose of her fucking hormones for the past 20 years. That is malpractice. And it was all bio, bio identical, right? That is like, talk about different animals. Yeah. Right. And it's like, they're right in a wrong way.
- 56:51because of what I see and what I do in my practice, that I'm not a fan of exogenous hormone replacement therapy, bioidentical or otherwise, because I think it's because the world I function in, the filter I see is through a cancer filter. I do not think that the exogenous supplementation is the cause of cancer, but I do think it can aggravate an already vulnerable system.
- 57:14So to give some examples, because I do SNPs on everybody, the single nucleotide polymorbidins, because I have all of the tissue or blood biopsy data of somebody's tissue type, so where it was breast, uterine, pancreatic, whatever, I know the flavor of that tumor and I know its hormonal vulnerabilities, etc.,
- 57:32I have the SNPs. I have the labs. I have the patient's medical history, pharmaceutical history, family history. I take all of that in, just like we were talking about for you in a moment, and I assess sort of the risk to benefit. And I will tell you about 70% of the population should probably be very thoughtful and careful to avoid exogenous hormone replacement because they have a particular set of variables within themselves.
- 57:54that make them take what's seemingly good and turn it into something not so good in the wrong environment. So what I like to do is if I have somebody coming to me who's already on them, we do a deep dive. We assess what's going on. We assess everything. Be like, are you safe to stay here? Do we need to tweak it? Do we need to take you off of it?
- 58:11You know, if they're cancering, we take people off anyway, because hormones in a cancering environment are growth factors period. While you're cancering, the debate is still around. Do you get them back onto something down the road after the cancer crisis is over? That's also debatable in some circles. But my practice, I had 17 years as a family healthcare provider and mostly women in my practice from everything from PCOS, hormone issues, perimenopause, postmenopause, cancers, you name it. I saw it all.
- 58:38I never had to use exogenous hormone replacement therapy. I would get their insulin normalized or cortisol normalized or oxytocin normalized. And all of those things would align, get them off the gluten, get them off the iodine, their thyroid would normalize, get their vagal nerve retuned up. Everything would normalize their digestion and all the things. So I didn't need that tool.
- 58:58But I do appreciate that there are some women and men practitioners out there who are very savvy at knowing exactly how to observe their pain, like you, with how you evaluate your whole thyroidal picture for your patients. You then know how to tweak their medicines. I would like to see much more of that happening in the hormone replacement space as well.
- 59:21And so that's where my hope is that the conversations continue and that we find ways to create a roadmap for our patients to know what's best for them at any given time. Because again, what we need in our fertile years, what we need in our perimenopausal years, in our postmenopausal years, our needs will change.
- 59:41And that's still based on the rest of the endocrine system response as well, and the mitochondrial health response as well. So we need to be thinking more globally in this arena. So I know that was a very...
- 59:53diplomatic and long-winded place to say, please just be thoughtful, mindful, get information before you just get on something and stay on something. Just like I have the same gripe with people who get put on a thyroid hormone and stay on it for 20 years, never titrating or changing it when you need, I mean, it probably drives you crazy to see how mismanaged that is. So there's good doctors and bad doctors in every field. You want to work with someone who's very hyper aware of you, your individual self.
- 1:00:20and are able to titrate and tweak and personalize every step of the way. Right. Right. Absolutely. Well, that's what you guys do. So can you let the audience know where they can find you, your team, and if they're interested like I am in working with you on cancer prevention, or unfortunately, if you are in the
- 1:00:43cancering space and you're dealing with it right now. It's not too late. So Dr. Nisha, can you please tell everybody where they can find you? Absolutely. Please take a look. Go find me at drnasha.com. That's where you'll also see my book, The Metabolic Approach to Cancer and my other book, Mistletoe and the Future of Integrative Oncology. Also just tons of amazing interviews like I'm getting to do with Dr. Amy today. You can listen to some of these discussions in other ways.
- 1:01:11Also, we have our own podcast, Metabolic Matters. Dr. Amy is going to be on that soon. I'm very excited about it. We can unpack even further. And that's really talking about metabolic health in general and bringing all these pieces together. And then mtih.org. That's metabolicterraininstituteofhealth.org. That's where you'll see our directory that shows you our advocates that are like our allied healthcare providers that can also screen and help you sort this through.
- 1:01:38as well as our clinicians who've come through the training and information about the training. If you are a patient advocate, if you are a clinician and you're interested in learning how to do what I just described with Dr. Amy's case and kind of how I described the hormone or not hormone case, then that's what we teach in this and help people understand all the different ways we can evaluate for and support people on their healthcare journey.
- 1:02:00amazing amazing well i have just absolutely loved this discussion i i i do believe we need to bring you back for part two i want to deep dive more into the female cancers specifically breast cancer because that's a big one but for now this has been amazing i love you very much thank you so much for your time today and we'll definitely have dr nation back on thanks everybody