Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 12: Buying a Dental Practice in Canada: Asset Purchase vs. Share Purchase Tax Breakdown
Transcript
- Vishal Gill, CFP: Hey everyone, welcome to another episode of Portfolio Talks. Today we're gonna be talking to you dentists who are looking to buy a clinic. So perhaps this is your first clinic, or perhaps you're buying your second, third, fourth, and becoming you know the warm buffet of the dental world. So there's a lot of considerations you want to look at when it comes into buying a dental practice. We're gonna go through and break down some of the nuances, demystify some of the numbers, and just simplify everything so you have a good framework. of a thought process to enter into clinic ownership for dentists. And as always, if you appreciate the podcast, if you learn from the podcast, do us a favor and subscribe and share so your colleagues can also learn and benefit from this as well. And with that said, let's jump into it. Another episode of Portfolio Talks. All right, episode 12 portfolio talks. Today, dentists, we are talking to you guys about buying a clinic. And this is going to be one of the most important decisions of your career if you're transitioning from an associate dentist to being a full-fledged practice owner. We want to make sure that you have a good general idea of, you know, not all the complicated stuff. Like here's a 45-page document with 17 checklists for you to do. It's just very simply, what are you looking for? And how do you start to get an idea of Is this clinic good? What things should I start to put in place? And then you can lean on your professionals like your lawyer, you know, the banks and things like that to make sure that you are getting you know, the information that you need to be able to vet a good deal and turn a profit quickly and then perhaps move on to your next one or just start to use that money to build your own personal wealth and retire and enjoy, you know, the rest of your life because a lot of you will have high income earning years, but you want to enjoy that money as well. So making sure that you enter the right deal. Is the big difference between buying a landline or buying a jackpot and a gold mine, is what I meant to say. So you know, those two things can be very different. And the thing to understand is you guys are private practice, so it's not like you're physicians where you can open up anywhere and your clinics can be good to go, and there's a backlog of 70,000 people waiting for a family doctor. You are competing against every other dental clinic or specialist that's gonna be in your area. so know what do you do and how do you try to profit on that one. So as always we have myself and you have Tyson here as your hosts. And as a reminder, we have a closed Facebook group for those of you doctors across Canada. So if you want to know learn if you want to learn more about these topics, you can feel free to join that. As always is going to be in the show notes and you can ask your questions and we'll start to do mailbags as well. You know, this last episode we want to go a bit more into the numbers. this episode we're gonna go on more of our overarching advice and then we'll probably switch back in the numbers next episode. So we want to do a couple different styles. So depending what type of listener you are, you have an episode that fits your flavor. So for this one, we're gonna keep it pretty high level and not go too much into graphs and charts and all that kind fun stuff. but we're gonna we're gonna talk about valuations for dental practices, asset for share sales, which one's better, which one you want to look at. we're talking about bank financing and how you can get financing to buy your practice. potential conflicts of interest that brokers have and should you use a one stop shop or should you you know break it apart and and have different professionals that are working separately and in silos to make sure you remove the conflict of interest. we're talking about patient retention and then we'll wrap it with some general stuff. But Tyson, I just talked a lot. You know, what do you want to share before we jump into it? I know you were golfing this weekend you almost did a master's thing. I you golf what, two days? Three days? Tyson Nagasaka: I I did two days last week. yeah, it was good. it's summertime, so we're trying to get out and golf as much as possible. you know, I got in two rounds last week. went and played with one of our business partners. We played Northview. It was beautiful. Man, what a difference when you play like a super nice course and the tea boxes and the fairways and the greens are just premium feeling. So nice. They were fast. Right. So if you miss a putt, it's running for a while. but I I shot a personal best and so that was awesome. And it was casual because I didn't I didn't realize I was trending towards that until we're on the second or last hole. It's like, man, I'm doing a lot better than I thought because we were talking most of the time. And then on Friday, played a charity golf tournament and we played a Westview Plateau. It was run really well. Great great turnout, tons Tons of people. good golf. even at the beginning, we had thunder and lightning, but we weren't sure if we were gonna get called off, push back, like what was going on. That was kind of weird weather. but I think it actually helped us with the greens and the fairways, keeping them a little damp and so you didn't get as much runoff. Because if you're not accurate on that course, you're gonna lose some balls. And we did. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, it's crazy the difference. I think the last round I shot was at Vancouver Club, the Vancouver Golf Club, and it was like lightning quick. If you miss your putt, if you miss your line by like an inch, that thing is gone. Then you have to chip back onto the green. And it's it's brutal. Like it's it's it's tough, it's frustrating. But I do remember the days when I first started golfing and I was on these pitch and putts where it's just mud, like you're shining in mud, and you're like, this is nice, and you start learning to golf, and then you go to the nice courses, you're like, I would never go backwards. So it's it's one of those things that's you know, you take take the difficulty and and you're happy with it. But it's a patient game and you know, congrats on the personal best. That's that's unreal. I had my personal best Tyson Nagasaka: Thank you. Vishal Gill, CFP: all by one of my worst rounds earlier in the year. So it's hopefully you don't get that. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: awesome. Okay, so let's jump into it. So one of the first things that you know we want to tackle is the acronym that everybody hears about that most people don't even know what it is. EBITDA. What is the myth of EBITDA? What is that? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, EBITDA is something that accountants use. it gives you an idea of value of your business without relying on top line revenue. Because some companies have really, really high top line revenue. And then you look at their next number which is expenses, and their expenses are equally as high. So they're not making any money, they're not profitable. So the acronym of EBITDA. earnings before interest, tax, depreciation, amortization. so they're looking at a lot of stuff. Essentially one we pull out all of the noise and all of the fluff from the numbers, what is the actual profit? Like what is your company actually doing? The reason EBITDA is a nice number to know is some industries will value your business on multiples of EBITDA and not multiples of revenue. so it's good to know which industry you're in. How does that work? Is it working for you? Is it working against you? without you having to have an accounting degree or background. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, and it I like that explanation. It's really just the true profit of the business. and you know, when it looks at like interest, tax, depreciation, advertisation, those are really the big expenses besides you know, for for for most businesses. So it's actually looking at what the true profit is. I think that's a simplest way instead of ebita, ebida, ebida, when you hear it, just think what's the true profit of this practice? Because revenue is an easy thing to drive up, but oftentimes it takes more money to make more money. So you want to see what the profit margins are. And those are going to be really what dictates a really truly well-run practice. And that's what we want to be buying into as a well-run practice. and if it's not, if you look at why it's not so profitable and you can solve those problems, you have experience solving those problems, then you can buy it at a discount and turn that profit even quicker. So sometimes, you know, lower EBITDA or or you know, things that don't seem ideal, they're distressed assets. those are sometimes, if you have the specialty to fix it, And the appetite to fix it, because obviously it's gonna be more work, or you have your own staff from clinic one, they can bring in in clinic two, then those are things that perhaps you want to be looking at as well. So either you can look for the best or you can also look for the worst. one thing I would find interesting, because we've been helping clients with their acquisitions over several years now, but comps. Comps are always an interesting thing to talk about because usually, if you're listening to this, you when you think of comps, you probably think of real estate like. you're looking to buy your first hole. okay, your realtor will tell you, okay, comparables in this area or comps in this area, or this price, this price, this price. It's not always the same thing. So not all comps are truly fair comps. And what I mean by that is Dental Corp. Dental Corp is something that had a big change fairly recently. So, you know, people know about Dental Corp, they recognize the name. we had one client who was looking to buy a practice and the seller was giving multiples. That Dental Corp use as the comps, like, well, yeah, like, you know, Dental Corp's the biggest one. And obviously they have the their argument was Dental Corp has the most you know resources to vet the right deal. So they should truly be the benchmark of what you should be valuing my practice at. and you know, who could value better than Dental Corp? But that's not very true at all. So, you know, why would Dental Corp have higher multiples than you know a mom and paw dentist looking to buy in practice? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: So Dental Corp's business was buying up practices and creating a fl workflow that is more profitable for everybody that falls under their umbrella. And I think they can value at higher multiples because of their economies of scale, so they can get the deal, pay the dental practice very handsomely, but also have them stay on because there's you don't want to take over a practice in that structure. Or you're trying to build an umbrella of essentially franchisees. you want the dentist to stay on, you want to maintain business, you want it to stay business as usual with improvements. And so Dental Corp was offering higher multiples in that sense. And they had a system. And side note, side story, in one of the companies that we work with, they had Dental Corp in their private in their Canadian equity sleeve. And it actually went private last year. it was bought by private equity. So it left the public TSX market and was bought by private equity. We got a very, very handsome exit on that. You usually get a 25-30% exit on the premium. So if the stock price is trading at $100 a share, you're gonna exit $125 or $130, which is very nice for shareholders. so side note, people who are in that portfolio, that was part of the Canadian equity returns last year, which were really, really good. Vishal Gill, CFP: Okay. Tyson Nagasaka: But I think that that like that is their playbook. So their multiples are higher. It sounds more attractive, but is it realistic for a one to one? So in the sin in the it's in the instance that we are gonna change hands. So if you had a practice and I was gonna buy it, I'm not managing three, four, five hundred practices. I don't have economies of scale, it's a one to one transfer. We have to be more reasonable with the numbers. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep, absolutely. And I think another thing of why those do so well is it it is a franchisee models is a great reference. And and that's kind of what you see and we see this often, whether it be you know, FYI adopters, whether it be chorus in the orth orthodontic space. there there's a bunch of different examples across different industries, but they can also attract a lot more associates because you can be more competitive, you have more money, you have more scale, you have a bigger market so whether you're an associate that's wanting to work in BC and then eventually relocate over there. whether you want to look at your career trajectory and like, okay, well if I work here I can get buyout options and then buy a clinic that's you know going to be financed through the parent company and then you know all these things are more favorable. So it's quite smart and I I don't see that really going anywhere. If anything it's happening more that's kind of like the world nowadays is private equity and is leading into everything really. But To Tyson's point, is not a fair comp. So I think the blended rate was like six and a half to seven and a half, you know, roughly for dental court when they're buying their clinics and they had like almost 600 locations. So like that's insane. so you know, that multiple isn't always going to be the same of what you're looking at. Could be higher, could be lower, but you really want be looking at what are the comps in your area. because every you know, small town, are you rural, are you urban? you know, what's the Specialty treatments that are being provided at the clinic, what can you add on to the clinic? All those things go into the factor that you wanna be looking at when you're in the baggage clinic and just working with a you know, good realtor to look at comps, to see what was sold recently, what are the details of that purchase, and your lawyers can help you with that as well. And we're gonna come back to dental core because when we talk a little bit later, we'll be talking about shareholder agreements, associate agreements, staff agreements, all that kind of stuff and why that's important. So Remember Dental Corp. We'll come back to it as an example of the importance of getting those agreements in place. awesome. So when you get to that point, let's say you find a clinic and you're okay, cool. I like this Tyson Dagasaka Dental Corp. That's perfect. it fits what I'm looking at. I want to buy it, you want to sell it. Awesome. There's two different ways we can do that: asset sale, share sale. And they're two kind of different, but kind of the same things. So to simplify it, when you're looking to do a transaction on a business, as a seller and as a buyer, you're gonna make an offer. So the buyer would most likely want an asset sale. Reason being is they protect liability. They're buying the assets in the dental corp in this example. So you know, goodwill, dental chairs, delivery units, imaging equipment, sterilization tools, precision instruments, all that kind of stuff is gonna be part of the asset. So I'm gonna be buying all of your assets and then I'm gonna start. Using those assets to generate revenue. It's clean. On the flip side, the sellers would usually prefer a share sale because they can use lifetime capital gains exemption, which will allow them to knock out a big chunk of the money tax-free with a caveat, and we'll get to that in a second. But the risk for the buyer is you are buying the shares of that corpse. So any, you know, pending litigation issues or skeletons in the closet are also coming with that share sale. There's ways to mitigate that as much as possible by using a good lawyer, doing due diligence, things of that type. But that's generally the two different ways that people will do a transaction is either an asset sale or a share sale. One thing to keep in mind is generally the numbers end up being very, very similar. no matter which way you offer it, if you're doing it correctly. but Tyson, I'll let you jump in here before before I go into more details about it. But asset sale, share sale. You know, how does that break down? Tyson Nagasaka: yeah, I mean I think Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: the one that we see the most the most common across some of our different pockets that we work in is a share purchase or a share sale. for the reason that you talked about is the the mature seasoned professional they're trying to exit their business and access lifetime capital gains exemption. And we haven't been involved in a heavily confrontational Buy where the purchaser wants an asset purchase and the seller wants a share sale and they're at stalemate. I I don't think we've been part of one of those yet. I can see where that comes in though, in that you know, if you're following the advice of your tax team and your legal team and you want to sell your practice, they're gonna advise you to do a share sale. it just makes sense. You want to use as many advantages as you can getting in and out of a business. but yeah, I agree with what you said is like the the only downside to the purchaser is potential liability and buying the shares. And that's where due diligence, good legal team comes in. Like let's let's go through it before you write a check. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep, absolutely. And yeah, thankfully we haven't been in any messy ones. But one thing I want to talk about is when you get ready to sell your business, it isn't something that should be a you know, knee-jerk reaction where it's like, okay, cool, an offer came in and okay, I'm gonna sell it. Which way should I should I use asset sale or share sale? only time that's ever and we have seen that, the only time we've ever seen that is when it's something like a private equity fund or dental court that comes up with a crazy multiplier where it's like, wow, this is nuts. Like I gotta kind of take this while it's here. and whatever, it's fine. It's it's a little bit messier, it's a little bit more hectic, but attached treatment isn't ideal. We can make it work. But to make to take advantage of Both of these as the seller, you really need to be preparing for your sale many years before it happens, or massaging your finances to have that happen. And one thing that we see as not ideal when people do, let's just say, asset sales, for example. CCA recapture is one thing that happens quite often on that side because of the dental corp, you have so many assets in the dental corp, as I mentioned before. dental equipment, specialty equipment, precision equipment, computers, all these kind of things. To simplify CCA is really a each each item that you buy is going into a bucket that the CRA allows you to depreciate over several years. What they won't allow you to do is hey CRA, I bought $50,000 of equipment, I'm gonna take a $50,000 deduction year one and wipe out all my taxes. They don't like that. They like to Give you stuff in buckets or in tranches. That's essentially what CCA is, it allows you to depreciate over several years that piece of equipment. So a $20,000 piece of equipment, let's just say 5 to 10% depreciation every single year, and that happens. However, if you sell it and you sell that for more than what's remaining on your deduction, so it's $20,000, it's been going down over time because you've been depreciating every single year. And there's only 5,000 left, but you sell it for 10,000. Now the CRA is gonna you know blow the whistle essentially and be like, well, we actually gave you too much of a deduction, you need to add that back. So CCA recapture, hopefully that made sense. But CCA recapture is a consideration when you're doing an asset sale from a tax perspective as a seller. So making sure that you have things available for you to offset that potential tax bill, such as your CDA room. that is very important. And we talk about this with clients all the time. So if you're looking to sell your practice over several years, you want to make sure you start, you know, realizing some unrealized gains within your portfolio and start to open up CTA room in your corp, because then that can allow you to mitigate the CCA recapture when that happens. And that can also be true for your share sale. And we've seen this as well, where there's a share sale and they use lifetime capital gains exemption, which is great, but there's something called AMT, which we won't. Go into in this episode, but it's essentially like a backup tax that Syria has. So if you are not going to pay tax, such as a lifetime capital gains exemption, and you're trying to swing all that money onto the personal side, the Syria is also always calculating AMT tax on an annual basis. Generally, your AMT tax is lower than what your actual tax bill is. So you never see it, you never hear about it, it never impacts you. However, in years where you wipe out your tax, like the lifetime capital gains exemption, the AMT tax is actually going to be the higher one. So you would actually have to pay AMT tax and it's like an account that you get back similar to the CCA over several years. So I know this sounds really complicated because it is, but there's a lot of different moving Tyson Nagasaka: Ha ha ha Vishal Gill, CFP: parts on it. but essentially what you want to do is if you're getting ready to sell in like, I don't know, 2030, for example, start preparing your finances now. See if you can start opening up CDA room now, because that can allow you to remove some of these task traps that are sitting there for you. I don't know. I I feel like that was complicated, Tyson. Is there a better way to explain that? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, let's do it. Let's do a quick let's do a quick recap. And I'm Vishal Gill, CFP: Yes. Tyson Nagasaka: only gonna cover the acronyms. CCA, Vishal Gill, CFP: Perfect. Tyson Nagasaka: capital cost allowance, right? So that's what that's what that stands for. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yes. Tyson Nagasaka: it's just it's just the cost, deductibility of of goods that you've bought in your business. C D A room is capital dividend account. This is a way for you to flow tax-free money out of your corporation, C D A. AMT, this is alternative minimum tax. It's always running in the background. Your tax software, your tax prep team, they're always running an AMT number in the background. You just don't normally see it unless things are going to be very favorable for you. Then CRA would say, you don't get what your tax prep preparation team has done. You actually have to pay the alternate minimum tax, which is AMT. what was the other one? HST, GST. We didn't cover that one. but Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: that's a h acronym heavy segment. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, very heavy acronym segment. But you know, when it comes to the way that you're gonna be selling your business, your CDA room can really help you on the asset sale side. and then when it comes to the share sale side, you get the left-hand capital gains exemption, which is great. but you basically need to show income to be able to get all that money tax-free, basically. So oversimplification, we'll go through that part on a few future episodes. We can share some charts and some numbers and some examples that'll help you know clarify that a little bit. but the point being, there's usually what we see is there's two offers that are given on the table. One of them is gonna be for an asset sale for the buyer, and one of them will be for a share sale as a buyer with two different numbers, and usually ends up being net almost the same for both parties, which is what it should be. And it really is beneficial for the seller of like, hey, if you haven't had, and we saw this actually just recently with a private equity buying one of our clients' clinics. but the good thing about it is it it benefits the buyer. Sorry, it benefits the seller because the buyer's like in that example. I know it's quick, so you may not have purged your corporation to be able to use a left-hand capital gains exemption. So here's another offer, and you work with your team and pick which one makes the most sense, which is really awesome to see. but more or less your net net should be roughly the same. But just prepare your finances because to use some of these. Tax avenues at the Sierra allows you to make it more as profitable as possible. It can't be a last-minute tweak or last-minute thing. You got to have it over several years. So lots of acronyms, super heavy, but that's it for that side. Generally speaking, asset sale benefits the buyer and a share sale benefits the seller. and there's ways to mitigate as much as possible. Having a good lawyer is of the utmost importance when it comes to that kind of business transaction. All right, go to the more simple one of that transaction. So now we started off with at a at a quick high level, how do you evaluate your potential clinic you want to buy? So you know another dentist that's gonna be looking to sell, you'll probably have to do an NDA or sorry, another acronym, a non disclosure agreement, and and probably a commitment letter to buy the clinic. They'll share the financials with you. You get a rough idea of what the EBITDA is, which is the true profit of the clinic. you can see the things that are dragging it down. If you have the specialty or the experience or the appetite to fix that and make it more profitable, that's great. Now goes into step two, which is I'm gonna make an offer. Am I gonna do a share sale or an asset sale? Talk to your team, work with a lawyer, all that's great. Now it's going into the financing. So how do you get the money to buy the practice? Banks love you. That's the good news. You're a dentist, banks love you. So you'll you'll get pretty much 100% loads value from. anyone you really talk to. what we mostly see is Scotia Bank and CIBC have been very heavy in the last few transactions with our clients. But roughly they'll do 100% loan to value, pretty straightforward. They'll also give you line of credits for operating. So if you need to do any kind of renovations, buy some equipment, things like that. You can do interest only options for the first, you know, year. Sometimes we've seen two years, or you can just start paying out principal right away. And that it really depends on what your strategy is. But So maybe the strategy is the important part that we should talk about here. So banks are banks, they you, Zentis, they'll give you the money, that's not a problem. Do you do hundred percent loan to value? Do you do eighty? Do you do ninety? What is your strategy? So Tyson, if we want tackle that one. Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I mean I think if you are buying a practice that is extremely profitable and it's set up, doing a hundred percent loan to value, it may seem a little bit less risky than if you're buying one that you have to rebuild and you have to rebuild the clientele or you have an aging clientele, where you'd have to you'd have to, you know, essentially market and get replacement clients for your aging clientele who may no longer be seeking dental treatment with you. So 100% loan to value. It sounds really good. It's risky. You might take a lot longer to hit that break-even point or or start really like paying down your outstanding loans to the point where you feel profitable and you can start breathing. going into the going into the deal with some money as a large down payment is ideal. it's a lot like buying a home. I still like the recommendation of going into a home. with twenty to thirty percent down. Otherwise, you're considered like a high ratio borrower. And on the on the home side is we have high ratio insurance on these mortgages, default insurance. But on the business practice side, I mean you you assign life insurance to the lender essentially. It's it's I'm more conservative. I'm a little more traditional. I like buyers to go in with some money to the deal and have skin in the game. And you know, there may be some there may be some unique numbers as to why you wouldn't want to do that. Like you might get a extremely low interest rate because the banks do love this sector. and so I think again, is doing a little bit of due diligence, don't fall in love with any one particular lender. You can talk to three of them. It doesn't cost you anything to talk to them. It costs you time. and see who's gonna give you a good deal because exactly like you said, they're gonna give you a purchase loan, which is huge. I have heard some of them say they'll do a million dollars without doing much underwriting. lines of credits, operating lines of credits, credit cards with like essentially no limits. And then some of these institutions will offer you access to their private banking, some other things. I mean Coming from coming from a banking background is they want you to have as many product lines with them as possible because it's impossible for you to change down the road. and they love, love, love dentists. So so you got some choices. Use that to your advantage. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, everybody loves you, which is a nice thing, right? I'd rather have everyone love me than everybody hate me. So that's always nice. and yeah, so really it comes from my perspective, it comes to whatever your next step is, is dependent on what you're putting into the deal. I see the school of thought for having skin in the game. At the end of the day, you're working in the clinic, so you have skin in the game because you're reliable, you're the guaranteor for for the the loan. so when it comes to how much you're putting into it, it depends what your strategy is. So if it is your know first clinic and you're looking to buy into another clinic then perhaps you know putting some money down to be able to turn profit you know quicker is is going to be great so we've done that for some clinic owners where we'll say okay well what's you know the planning is pretty easy you're gonna buy a clinic banks are gonna give you the money that's not really a huge concern what's step number two do you want to buy another one do you want to just let this pay itself off and then start catching up afterwards And we start doing the numbers for what is your retirement number that you need to get to for you to be able to retire, you know, in your late 40s, early 50s. for the most part, you can still work a little bit if you want to, but what is that number? So, in order to hit that number, when do we need when do we need to unlock the revenue from this clinic to be able to start investing to get to that number? And that's going to be one indicator of how much money you should put down because it's just a simple math equation at that point. The other thing is what is your money doing? So if your money is, you know, getting 20, 30% returns. Does it make sense to take that money out and put that into your clinic? or do you just use the bank's money and then buy yourself some time, do interest only payments, and then start to do some changes? So it really depends on your experience, it depends on your timeline, it depends on your retirement number. And that, I guess, deal of are you putting 100% loaded value, 90, 80, 70? It all is gonna change for each and every person. So if you hear someone saying, hundred percent, you're good to go. That's not always the right number. what I mostly see is most people don't like doing the hundred percent because they don't that's obviously in the bank's interest to have all the debt because your interest payments are are way higher to them. so of course they're gonna love to do hundred percent loan to value. it may not always make sense for you, but it really just depends on the cash flow strategy of what you're trying to do. okay, moving along. Yeah, go ahead. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. I think one little like extra extra side point to that is we've seen a couple people that come from a business family that they're they're starting like business acumen intelligence way higher than the average person. And so for the for those few individuals, I would call them outliers to go in 100% finance and be able to turn the business around, understand business principles, really like shrink cost, increase profits. Th we've got a few of those people that we've come across super, super high intelligence when it comes to business. it might make more sense for them to borrow all that money and and and grow the practice quickly. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep. True points. okay, we're running a little bit over time that we wanted. So we got three other things to tackle. One of them I'll tackle real quick for you all is is really when it comes to the broker side of it. So okay, cool. Now you the basin give you money, who's brokering the deal? Really have two decisions to make. and neither one of them is right or wrong. It's just as long as you go into eyes open, you can make your decision. So one approach is the one stop shop person. So this person's like your your mortgage broker, your financial planner, your know they have their own introductions for you for the accountant, the lawyer. It's it's a one-stop shop, which is easy and and that's nice is a premium to be paid for convenience. but just know that it's not really regulated and tracked. So there is no disclosure requirements for them to be getting kickbacks from other people. generally speaking the one that's making the sale is paying most of the people's fees. so it's oftentimes in the best interest to pump up that number is what we've seen sometimes as well of according to this person. Well that seems little bit higher than what a comp would would you know dictate you you paying for. but at the same time some people are okay with the convenience I'm paying the premium for, you know, just buying me my time back. This one person can do it. Sure, I'm paying more money than I probably otherwise would, but I don't have to talk to all these other people. So just make your decision because there's two approaches is the one stop shop. That is most likely going to cost you more for the transaction because there's a potential or strong potential for conflict of interest. And there's referral kickbacks probably happening there as well. So that's one thing. or the other side is you break it apart and you work with you know a separate lawyer, separate workers' person, separate bank, and you kind of have your own connections. that's why everyone's working in your best interest and they're not connected at all. Not to say one is better than the other, just be aware of what the potential conflicts of interest are. And as long as you're okay with that, we have some people that really like the latter, and we have some people that like to get the time back and do the former as well. So just real quick on that one. okay, cool. Last two things, Tyson, is you know, patient retention as evaluation, tool, and variable, and then finishing off with agreements. and and we'll tie that back into dental corp in the beginning. So when it comes to patient retention, you know. That is probably one of the most important things for you to be looking at. you looked at the EBITDA, the revenue looks great, and the true profit looks great. But a couple considerations is you want to look at who's actually working in that clinic. So if you have one dentist, let's say Tyson is the dentist that's working at the clinic, and he's really doing like 90% of the billings and and and seeing the patients and then doing the production, you want to assume anywhere from a 10 to 25%. drop off and there's a little bit potentially more risk if it's a rural community maybe it's like a real big family vibe with that person and then it's a new shop in town again because they're private so competition is everything. so you want to be aware of like what's recently opened up around the area but there's always an inherent risk if there's one dentist that's doing the vast majority of the production because always assume 10 to 25% drop off of of of patients and that is not ideal if it's one person who's a rainmaker. As opposed to if you have associate or associates, you know, doing 30 to 50 percent of the production, that's great because your patients are conditioned to be able to come in and to see different people. and if your clinic is running that way, it's a lot more feasible for you to have a lot lower end of the drop-off or the patient drop-off because they're used to Dr. So-and-so is here, Dr. So-and-so's here this day. and it's just a different vibe on that. So that's one thing you always want to look at is who is producing the revenue. And that is extremely important for you to look at. As much as you may feel confident that, like, you know, I'm the man, people are gonna love me and they're gonna they're gonna, you know, wanna stay with me. You don't always know that. So assume a big drop-off, especially if it's one rate maker that does it. especially if it's a second generation dentist. We've seen that as well with a couple of years back. We had a client that was looking at that. It was a second generation dentist. So lots of family legacy there. And that was no longer happening. So you would assume we put a higher risk on the retention rate than what the industry standard was. Other thing to look at is active patients. I think what do we look at? 18 months, I think Dyson is trailing 18 months. Is trillion Tyson Nagasaka: Trailing eighteen months. Yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: 18? Okay, perfect. Yeah, trailing trailing 18 months is a good number for an active patient. Honestly, I don't know if I'd be considering an active patient. I remember last time I went to the dentist. I get the reminders, but my schedule's all crazy. So I I I apologize to my dentist if you listen to this. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. It's so true. How many people follow their six month recall schedule or their nine month recall schedule? I mean, it just doesn't happen. and so trailing eighteen months, I think it's fair, Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. I'm a horrible patient. Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: to give them like something that's reasonable. And also, like remember, when you're looking at these numbers, this is this is all recorded history. It has happened. It's no indicator that it's exactly as it's going to happen in the future. The good news is, I think we were talking offline, is dentists and our other niche that we work with is optometrists. It it can't be done virtually. You can't convert to like telehealth or teledental, teleoptical. they don't have that. So you clients have to come in. You get foot traffic in in your clinic, in your dental office. they have to come and see you. And so that is a huge, huge benefit for you. Vishal Gill, CFP: Absolutely. and yeah, so you know, that's one of the things that's that's good to keep in mind. So an active patient is trailing eighteen months. And then from that number you can also see what is the symptom of that. So if you're out of that 18 months, you want to look at your like the healthy hygiene recall rates. are those high? What's the process of there? And that can kind of tell you that story as well. But those are probably the two biggest numbers that we look at. goodwill is one thing that you always wanna be cautious of because that's such a hard thing to quantify. but you know your active patient and your provider concentration risk are are two things you always definitely want to look at. All right. Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I know in in in sorry, just to add one more point, just because you know, why not why not talk some more? Vishal Gill, CFP: Why not? Tyson Nagasaka: In our industry, when we buy a book of business, we typically use a format that's called an earnout, which would exactly line up with this is like you're looking at client base, how many of those clients are you gonna r retain? How many are gonna do repeat business with you? And if there's a significant drop off that could adjust the the payout model. over a period of time. So if you're buying at a three, five or a six X multiple, are you paying that out in one lump sum or are you paying that out over three years? So that's also tax advantage to the seller. So that they don't have a balloon payment with a huge tax bill is they might get phased payouts and you're spreading it over different calendar tax years. So something to consider maybe with your creative tax and finance team on both ends. Vishal Gill, CFP: That was actually perfect segue to go into our last point for a couple of minutes here is we'll talk about agreements and the importance of a lawyer. So lawyers are very valuable, extremely valuable in these types of transactions. and and part of that is going to be the agreements that come into it. So the associate agreements, the lease agreements, the purchase agreements, all these shareholder agreements. I I think. I said enough agreements. I I can't remember on the top man if I missed one there, but there's a lot of agreements that have to be redone when this transaction happens because a lot of times it's a it's a big material change and sometimes there's assignment things that happen on the the landlords, there's some great landlords. We just did transaction which was probably the worst landlord I've ever experienced. It took so long, it was so difficult to work with them. but we got it done, which is great. So when it comes to agreements and lawyers, what are some some important things you want to leave the audience with? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I think Vishal Gill, CFP: Okay. Tyson Nagasaka: depending on which which point we want to look at. So let's talk first about shareholders' agreement. So shareholders' agreement is really important if there's more than one partner in your business. what happens if you get sick? What happens if you pass away? What happens if you want a business divorce? What is the agreed upon method, valuation, and separation of these of these individuals? also I mean, this is something that we're starting to see a little bit more of, but I think when you do your shareholders agreement, what happens if you're approached by private equity? Now we're talking about dental practices, but I have a lot of guys that are in the trades and the trades are being approached by private equity. So you started out, you're a plumber, you're a electrician, you're a framer, and you never thought that you're gonna get a 10x multiple from a private equity fund to sell. Well, your dental shareholder agreement should say. If we're approached by one of these funds, this is our thinking, this is our methodology, this is the terms that we would accept in order to exit. Because the last thing that you want to do is you have two or three dentists running a corp. Two of them say, I'd like to take this this once-in-a-lifetime payout, sell to private equity, exit early. and then one of them says, No way, Jose, I want to work for another 25 years. Now you're at an impasse. Now do you do? So shareholders agreement. It gives some rules to the game of like how you should deal with some of these forks in the road. Associate agreement, I think, is one that you you brought up is really good. It's like an employment contract, but you're self employed working for that individual. What are the expectations of the clinic? How are you supposed to operate? How does payout work? if they if they sell their practice, are you expected to stay? I mean, it's a It's your clients too. You're the associate dentist. You're gonna have your own book and your own following of clients that like you and wanna deal with you. so these are things that should be talked about with your legal team. And it doesn't have to be a ton of of work, but you should put some thought into it and understand like what this means. And you can always revise these agreements and documents as you evolve as a practitioner. what were some of the other ones that we talked about? Vishal Gill, CFP: lease agreements. Tyson Nagasaka: Lease agreements. Interesting. So, like we're in Vancouver, Vancouver lease agreements with Triple Net and with all the other things that are involved. You don't own the property, but you pay like you own the property. you want to make sure you're protected from the risk of sudden development syndrome, right? If your if your property owner, the person that you're leasing from, says, I want to sell and they want to build a high rise on this property. And you're out in six months. Do are you protected against that in your agreement? do you want to uproot your clinic and find another clinic in the same neighborhood that's comparable, that's not older, or needs a lot of work? I mean, you really want to take these agreements to protect yourself because we do see that in the Vancouver area. I'm sure it happens in Toronto too. Landlord sells all of their holdings to a development company and then it doesn't get developed for like 10 years. So did you have to leave and like uproot your c your practice, move somewhere, pay all this start up cost again when you could have just stayed because you had a solid agreement? something definitely to consider. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, and I think DMC actually put out a good article maybe maybe a few months back. I can't remember exactly when, but it was a case study about a demolition clause that the landlord tried to put into a lease agreement upon the sale of it. So dentist one sold the dentist two, and they try to use that opportunity to add a demolition clause. and then disputed it and ended up being like a big litigation thing. So, you know, really what I would say is if you listen to and you're a potential seller in the next little bit. it is worthwhile to spend the money to make your clinic more attractive in regards to the ease of trans transition. So having a good assignment clause built around a reasonable assignment for the next one. That was part of why our transaction that we just did was so difficult is the assignment clause wasn't super advantaged. So we got a discount because of that and then we had to deal with that whole process. But that was fine, it ended up working out. But making sure an assignment clause is reasonable and it's easy Making sure your associate agreements are written away to give as much favorability of the incoming dentist to be able to take over that practice, have some type of retention or a sweetheart bonus, make sure that your shareholder agreements are done. That doesn't really help you as a seller, really, but unless you're selling to a big bigger conglomerate or you have someone that may be a potential dispute. And all things are really good to do when everyone gets along. So all those things are really important to do because. Again, I keep saying the same thing. You are private. So, you know, if someone doesn't want to buy your clinic and someone else has made their clinic a lot more attractive, even it's a higher sale price, that is gonna be better deal for you know us as buyers potentially coming in and looking at it. Is okay, this one's more expensive, but it has way more favorability. It's it's gonna be a way quicker, cleaner transaction. So we would definitely pay more money on that. you have you know, better balance of who's doing what billings. We have good agreements that those people are going to stay on and good commitments that they're going to stay on. All these things are really important to make sure that your clinic is attractive. So that was a lot. What we will do is I'm sure we'll we'll answer some questions. If you have questions, drop them in the comment section, whatever platform you're watching. Also another reminder for our closed Facebook group for doctors across Canada. I know a lot of you are dentists that have come through are dine and talks and things of that type that are gonna be that group. So this will be really advantageous for you. And I I'm sure we'll probably do a follow-up episode on this one with the lawyer to go some more details because as we kind of thought through this, I think it's definitely worthwhile to to have a lawyer chat about the importance of some of these things and give some perhaps case studies for you guys to learn off of. So a little bit heavier episode. Actually it wasn't that bad. It was like 50 minutes. So it felt longer than than I thought it was, but maybe because that acronym Heavy segment I did kind of threw me through a loop. But That's why we're a team. Tyson simplified that, which is great. so all that being said, we want to leave you with the thought of as a dentist, you are a private clinic. Buying this clinic that you're going to be looking into is going to be the difference of you buying a landmine or a gold mine. You want to make sure you're looking at the true profit of the clinic, you want to look at the potential risks of the retention, you want to have a strong argument of how do you quantify the goodwill, you want to make sure that. You're looking at your options of offering as a share sale, an asset sale. Take a look and seeing what brokerage you're gonna be using. Are you gonna be using a one-stop shop and potentially paying a premium? Or are you gonna you know break it apart and have no conflict of interest because you have separate parties doing it? The basic will give you money regardless. But do you want to do 100% load to value, 90%, 80? make sure you're really talking to your team to get an idea and a roadmap of what this plan is and then. The transaction is kind of the easy part. It's really about what's the next step? Are you looking to buy another practice? are you looking to just use the practice to be a conduit to retire you? What is the strategy? And I think if you know that and you work backwards, all these other decisions become a lot easier. So we'll leave you on that note. Tyson, any last thoughts? Tyson Nagasaka: No, that was a heavy episode. Vishal Gill, CFP: Don't Tyson Nagasaka: I mean, it's a lot. It's a lot. So it is it Vishal Gill, CFP: I like how we started the episode by saying this is not gonna be a heavy episode and then ended up being a heavy episode anyways. Tyson Nagasaka: It ended up being a heavy episode. Yeah. With all of that complication, all of those layers of stuff that we've said, it's still likely easier to buy a practice than to build one from scratch. Like a cold start is that's a big Vishal Gill, CFP: Yes. The hardest. Tyson Nagasaka: uphill battle. so buying if you're young and you're buying a practice and you can modernize it and add social media and add marketing and really grow the practice that way because the more mature doctors they don't like. to use technology, computers, social media, all those things, you can have a real advantage and you can use that to your advantage to really grow business. so purchasing is the easier road to having a big business. Vishal Gill, CFP: Amazing. Thank you so much, everyone. We'll see you on the next episode of Portfolio Talks.