Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Retail Credit Performance: Risks for Credit Unions
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, this is Mark Trico with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04This is another short take with our recent discussion on one topic
- 0:08from the OCC risk report, and that topic today is retail credit risks
- 0:15at credit unions and at banks.
- 0:17How that inter relates, and we talk about things like.
- 0:24Student loan payment, resumptions, recurring mixed economic signals,
- 0:28the state of unemployment in all 50 states, and what that
- 0:31means and what the breakdown is.
- 0:33Generational differences, Venmo and more.
- 0:36As always, thanks for listening.
- 0:38Another storyline is the retail credit.
- 0:40Uh, performance remains stable despite headwinds.
- 0:44And that's a little bit, I think, Todd, you might have touched on
- 0:46the headwinds that the report seems to talk about the past and the
- 0:50future a little bit differently.
- 0:51Any thoughts on, on retail credit performance?
- 0:54Gentlemen?
- 0:56Bauer: One, one thing I, I've seen that, that's changed recently is
- 1:00right during the last administration and a lot of student loan debt.
- 1:04You could stop making payments, but I think that with the current
- 1:08administration now that's back on.
- 1:10So it'd be interesting to see, I, I forget how, what the millions of dollars in
- 1:14student loan payments that are in arrears, how that might impact consumer's ability
- 1:19to make other payments depending upon where they prioritize where, where, where
- 1:24they prioritize making loan payments.
- 1:25All right.
- 1:26With inflation, the cost rate, that could be a challenge and that could impact,
- 1:30um, I think credit unions delinquency and potentially charge offs in the future.
- 1:35Um, I mean, I, again, the trend seems to be for credit unions, delinquency and
- 1:40charge offs seem to have leveled off.
- 1:43Um, maybe, maybe even down a little bit for this first quarter, but Right.
- 1:47There's always you know, with that student loan potentially hanging out there, that
- 1:50could be an, that could be a concern.
- 1:52I think that credit unions need to, to address.
- 1:56Treichel: Good point.
- 1:57Good.
- 1:57Miller: Todd?
- 1:59I think the student loan thing is gonna be a huge one in the future.
- 2:02I don't know how that impacts, you know, our accrediting people.
- 2:05It definitely hits your borrowers in those younger age demographics.
- 2:09It's just somewhat interesting.
- 2:11You know, the, you know, they talk about headwinds and, you know,
- 2:15which way is our economy going?
- 2:17And Trump jumps this way then that way with tariffs and this and that.
- 2:22Delinquency levels are really manageable.
- 2:25There definitely seems to be a pullback in consumer spending are in bank credit
- 2:29union lending standards because for both banks and credit unions, auto loan
- 2:33portfolios have shrank a little bit.
- 2:36And I don't know how often that happens.
- 2:38Maybe it was just because there was a huge spike in purchases during COVID,
- 2:42but auto lending numbers did shrink.
- 2:45Um, I tracked unemployment by states and if you look from December to May, 24
- 2:51states had higher unemployment, but 26 of them had lower unemployment levels.
- 2:55You know, so everything is kind of mixed and muddled.
- 2:58And if you look at the FDS quarterly reports, they break
- 3:03things down by their five regions.
- 3:05There's a lot of performance differences across regions.
- 3:08So, you know, there's, there's all these risks that are generic
- 3:12to, you know, our credit unions.
- 3:15But there's certainly different economic zones in different parts of the
- 3:19country are performing very differently than other parts of the country.
- 3:26Treichel: You know, we had the sand states in oh 8, 0 9, right?
- 3:29That's kind of what at NCUA it was, where there was sand, there
- 3:32was a problem, whether that was, uh, Florida Las Vegas, et cetera.
- 3:37Any, when you look at the 24 versus the 26 that had up or down, any, any, anything
- 3:43pop out at you on an individual state?
- 3:46I
- 3:46Miller: didn't
- 3:47Treichel: PO
- 3:48Miller: look at individual states or I didn't look at NCA's
- 3:52performance by region or states.
- 3:54But when you look at the banks, basically your coast, your San Francisco,
- 3:57New York thing are struggling more than the heartland of the interior.
- 4:02You know, last time the sand states I, my first four or five years as a DSA,
- 4:08right through that last recession, it was all spent in Utah and Arizona.
- 4:11And I closed a lot of credit unions in Utah and so did the FDIC.
- 4:17Treichel: Steve Dennis.
- 4:18Any anything to add here?
- 4:20Farrar: The one thing that I kinda observe is there's this big differences in the
- 4:25with all the generations in terms of how they view a borrowing and, and how
- 4:30they're doing their own finances, which will affect future retail loan growth.
- 4:35And to see how, uh, credit unions are able to, uh, adjust their marketing for the,
- 4:41you know, the borrowing type generation.
- 4:43We'll see how that behavior, uh, is in the future, but it's something
- 4:46they definitely should be looking at in the Yeah, that's one of the key.
- 4:49I agree with you.
- 4:50Treichel: That's one of the keys to long-term survival, figuring out, uh,
- 4:53where the borrowers, uh, how they're gonna react so that you can make good loans
- 4:58and, and, uh, add to the bottom line.
- 5:01It's how do
- 5:01Miller: you capture them as depositors too, because Yeah.
- 5:05They move their money around.
- 5:06How do you get them to use your debit card when you know, a lot of 'em use
- 5:11Venmo and PayPal and Apple paid now.
- 5:14So like the whole payment systems are, you know, circumventing the
- 5:17general credit union in banking industry with these third parties.
- 5:22And, you know, it, it'll come up later maybe with fraud because the OCC
- 5:27risk report mentioned some of that.
- 5:30But like Venmo, people under 40, I had a thing the other day I looked it up, how
- 5:35many accounts there were people that are using Venmo, most of them are under 40.
- 5:40If I go through my history here on copilot, I can probably
- 5:44find it again really quickly.
- 5:46So Venmo's transactions are up 80% just over the last three years.
- 5:522025 first quarter here, Venmo did $342 billion in payment
- 5:57transfers between people.
- 6:00Wow.
- 6:00And you think of the industry, that's not a lot.
- 6:03And they're not the biggest one.
- 6:05They're just the fastest growing one.
- 6:07But it says 85% of their users are under 40.
- 6:11Treichel: So I'm one of the, I'm one of the fif, I'm one of the 15% not,
- 6:17Miller: I've used it maybe twice in the last couple years when
- 6:19I've sold stuff to other people and got an account just for that.
- 6:23So it's like, how do Fred gather up and get these people to become members
- 6:30for their transaction services, for those checking accounts and for
- 6:33those deposits, it's gonna be kind of somewhat of a, a challenge, I think.
- 6:39Treichel: And by the way, here's my Venmo tip.
- 6:41If you are on Venmo and you don't know that you have to set some privacy
- 6:46things up so that you can't, so that your friends or contacts don't see.
- 6:51Every time you send a Venmo, you might wanna look at your privacy 'cause,
- 6:55because my kids tip me off to that.
- 6:57And then there are some other connections I have that are constantly, um, or
- 7:02frequently having payments to or from.
- 7:04And it, uh, it's something that you wanna make sure is not toggled in the wrong way.