Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Confronting the Assault on the Independence of the Legal Profession and the Judiciary with Hon. Joe Hilberman (Ret.), Patricia M. Corrales, Professor Barry P. McDonald, Stephen F. Rohde
Transcript
- 0:06I'm Belinda McCauley, Executive Director of the
- 0:08Beverly Hills Bar Association and the Beverly
- 0:11Hills Bar Foundation. Today's program is presented
- 0:14by the Beverly Hills Bar Foundation, which is
- 0:16BHBA's charitable arm. As you saw when you registered,
- 0:19the program is free, but the foundation needs
- 0:22funds for programs like today's, its free legal
- 0:26clinic that directs residents of greater LA to
- 0:28legal aid resources, and its signature annual
- 0:31program, the Public Interest Scholarships Program.
- 0:34These annual scholarships, awarded for more than
- 0:3650 years to students at five LA area law schools,
- 0:39support students who have committed to do public
- 0:41interest work, including in some of the spaces
- 0:43you'll hear discussed here today. We'd so appreciate
- 0:47your donation to support the foundation at bhbf
- 0:50.org. And now I'm delighted to introduce the
- 0:54moderator for today's panel, Stephen Rode. Steve
- 0:56is a constitutional scholar, lecturer, writer,
- 0:59political activist, and retired civil rights
- 1:01lawyer. He's a past president of the Beverly
- 1:03Hills Bar Association, a founder and chair of
- 1:06Interfaith Communities United for Justice and
- 1:08Peace, past president of the ACLU of Southern
- 1:11California, a past chair of Ben Biark, a Jewish
- 1:14Partnership for Justice, and is on the board
- 1:17of Death Penalty Focus. He's written extensively
- 1:21in media, including for the LA Times, Huffington
- 1:23Post, Truthout, American Prospect, and Miss Magazine,
- 1:27and is a regular contributor to the Los Angeles
- 1:29Review of Books and Los Angeles Lawyer Magazine.
- 1:32Steve will introduce the panelists and then guide
- 1:34today's discussion. Steve, over to you. Thank
- 1:38you very much, Belinda, and thanks everybody
- 1:40for joining us on a... Monday morning for what
- 1:44I think and we think is a very important topic
- 1:48to address. You know, people are fond of lawyers'
- 1:53jokes and even comments like, first thing, let's
- 1:58kill all the lawyers. Well, that's often misquoted
- 2:03at cocktail parties. Shakespeare wrote it in
- 2:08Henry VI, Part II, but U .S. Supreme Court Justice
- 2:14John Paul Stevens understood why Shakespeare
- 2:20put those words in the mouth of the villainous
- 2:24character Dick the Butcher. Justice Stevens wrote,
- 2:30Shakespeare's insightfully realized that disposing
- 2:35of lawyers is a step in the direction of a totalitarian
- 2:41form of government. He understood that and that
- 2:46is the backdrop for today's program. It is reported
- 2:51that 297 active cases are pending against President
- 2:58Donald Trump and the Trump administration. All
- 3:02of those cases were filed by lawyers and are
- 3:06being heard by judges who are grappling with
- 3:10some of the most unprecedented and serious legal
- 3:15and constitutional issues of our history. It's
- 3:20reported that over 180 rulings have temporarily
- 3:26enjoined or stayed some of the Trump administration's
- 3:32actions. One source indicates that 67 % of all
- 3:38federal injunctions in the last 100 years have
- 3:43been against the Trump administration. To address
- 3:49these issues, and there are so many, but today
- 3:53we are looking seriously at attacks on the rule
- 3:57of law, lawyers, and judges. We've really been
- 4:01able to assemble an extraordinary panel. I will
- 4:05briefly introduce them, but in your materials
- 4:08and online, their full bios are included. Patricia
- 4:14Corrales specializes in criminal defense and
- 4:18immigration law. She began as a deputy district
- 4:22attorney in Denver, Colorado, from 1995 to 2012.
- 4:29She was an attorney at the U .S. Department of
- 4:33Homeland Security and the Immigration and Customs
- 4:38Enforcement Department, ICE as we know it. She
- 4:42is familiar with the issues of immigration law
- 4:46on both sides of the subject. Our second panelist
- 4:52will be Barry McDonald. He has taught constitutional
- 4:57law. First Amendment Law and Comparative Constitutional
- 5:01Law at Pepperdine School of Law since 2000. He
- 5:06graduated cum laude from Northwestern School
- 5:10of Law. He clerked for Chief Justice William
- 5:14Rehnquist, and he worked for the U .S. State
- 5:17Department, the law firm of Gibson, Dun & Crutcher,
- 5:20and as general counsel for two tech companies.
- 5:25Judge Joe Hilberman served on the LA Superior
- 5:30Court from 2001 to 2009. He is now with ADR Services
- 5:40as an arbitrator and mediator. In 2008, and I
- 5:46have known Joe so long that my daughter babysitted
- 5:51for his kids, so I call him Joe with full and
- 5:55honorable respect. Joe was chosen in 2008 as
- 6:02Jurist of the Year. by the LA chapter of the
- 6:06American Board of Trial Advocates. Before becoming
- 6:11a judge, he practiced law for 27 years, specializing
- 6:16in civil litigation and mediation. In 2022, he
- 6:21was a member of the Judicial Independence Committee.
- 6:26of the American Board of Trial Advocates, which
- 6:31issued a revised version of a comprehensive report
- 6:35entitled Preserving a Fair, Impartial, and Independent
- 6:41Judiciary. A copy of that report is among the
- 6:46174 pages of resource materials which All of
- 6:53us have assembled that is available to everyone
- 6:57who is attending and watching this program. I
- 7:02can't urge you enough after the program to go
- 7:06to those materials. Included is a sample of President
- 7:11Trump's executive order against law firms. There's
- 7:16a statement by the California State Bar on this
- 7:20issue. I have included an article on this subject.
- 7:26There's an amicus brief filed by former state
- 7:29and federal judges in support of a motion to
- 7:33dismiss the indictment against Wisconsin state
- 7:37judge Hannah Dugan, which we'll be discussing
- 7:40today. There's a really important 102 page memo
- 7:45opinion dated May 2nd by Judge Beryl Howell in
- 7:50the Perkins -Cooey case, which we will be discussing.
- 7:54All of those materials are substantive in support
- 7:58of the issues that we can only briefly touch
- 8:03on today. I do want to thank Belinda McCauley,
- 8:08Jenna... Klyushnikov, Rin Santiago, all on the
- 8:14staff of the Beverly Hills Bar Association who
- 8:17put in such effort to organize programs like
- 8:20this. And I'd like to also thank Alexander Rufus
- 8:25Isaacs and Ken Petroulis, who played an instrumental
- 8:29role in organizing this program, both of whom
- 8:32are past presidents of the Beverly Hills Bar
- 8:36Association and the Beverly Hills Bar. foundation.
- 8:41I'm going to give a rather substantive opening
- 8:44more than many moderators may because I want
- 8:47to lay the groundwork for all of our speakers
- 8:50so that they can focus on their perspectives
- 8:53and their analysis of these important issues.
- 8:58We now know that nine of America's largest and
- 9:02most powerful law firms have surrendered to Donald
- 9:07Trump's threats through executive orders and
- 9:11other policy issues. They have agreed to provide
- 9:17$940 million in free legal services to causes
- 9:22chosen by Donald Trump and the law firms, while
- 9:27also agreeing to discontinue their diversity,
- 9:31equity, and inclusion policies. Fortunately,
- 9:35several other firms have refused to abide by
- 9:40those orders and are fighting back. To date,
- 9:43three full dress preliminary injunctions have
- 9:47been issued and one TRO in the latest case, which
- 9:52is still under consideration. I want to note
- 9:59that this began in February 25th when Donald
- 10:04Trump issued his first memorandum against Covington
- 10:09and Burling, suspending security clearances because
- 10:15they had advised special counsel Jack Smith.
- 10:22On April 9, emboldened by the law firms that
- 10:31had begun to cave in because previously Latham
- 10:34and Watkins had agreed along with other law firms
- 10:39to provide substantive benefits to the administration.
- 10:50On March 6, Trump issued another executive order
- 10:54suspending security clearances for the law firm
- 10:58of Perkins Coe, criticizing their diversity and
- 11:03inclusion policies. What's very important in
- 11:06this discussion is there's no concealing the
- 11:11stated purpose of these executive orders. President
- 11:15Trump explicitly cited Perkins Coe's representation
- 11:19of Secretary of State Hillary Clinton during
- 11:23her 2016 presidential race. Perkins Coe immediately
- 11:29hired the firm of Williams and Connerly, which
- 11:33filed suit leading to the first of the rulings,
- 11:39which included a May 2nd preliminary injunction
- 11:44by Senior Judge Beryl Howell. which I've alluded
- 11:48to. On March 14, Trump issued an executive order
- 11:53against the New York firm of Paul Weiss. Here,
- 11:58he attacked an attorney, Mark Pomerantz, who
- 12:02had left Paul Weiss to assist the Manhattan district
- 12:05attorney in its probe of Trump's finances. When
- 12:09Pomerantz resigned, he issued a letter stating
- 12:14his belief that Trump was guilty of numerous
- 12:17felony violations. Just days later, in his first
- 12:24victory, Trump rescinded the executive order
- 12:29because Paul Weiss agreed to provide $40 million
- 12:33in pro bono work for causes the administration
- 12:38supports and the firm would end. On March 22nd,
- 12:44Trump named the Elias law firm, and the pattern
- 12:49is similar in terms of the statements made against
- 12:53Mark Elias, I should say, and his representation
- 12:58of Hillary Clinton. The pattern continued, and
- 13:07on March 25th, The president issued an executive
- 13:11order revoking security clearances for Jenner
- 13:15and Block, which immediately fought back. And
- 13:20on March 28, Judge John D. Bates of the U .S.
- 13:24District Court in Columbia issued a temporary
- 13:27restraining order and subsequently on May 1st,
- 13:31a 52 -page opinion granting a preliminary injunction.
- 13:37On March 27, Donald Trump issued an executive
- 13:42order against Wilmer Hale. He revoked their government
- 13:46contracts for engaging in, quote, partisan representation
- 13:50to achieve political ends and efforts to discriminate
- 13:55on the basis of race. That firm had employed
- 14:00Robert Mueller and other attorneys who worked
- 14:03with the Justice Department to investigate ties.
- 14:06with Russia and the Trump campaign. That firm
- 14:11hired Paul Clement, a prominent conservative
- 14:14lawyer and former solicitor general. And on May
- 14:2027, in a 73 -page opinion, Richard Leon of the
- 14:25district court stayed Trump's order. On March
- 14:3128th, despite three injunctions having by then
- 14:35already been issued, Skadden Arps made a deal
- 14:42with Trump even before it was targeted by any
- 14:46executive order or by any memo from the White
- 14:50House promising to provide $100 million in pro
- 14:54bono legal services. And finally, between April
- 14:581st and April 11, seven more law firms, Wilkie
- 15:03Farr and Gallagher, Milbank, Cadwallader, Wickersham
- 15:07and Taft, Kirkland and Ellis, Allen, Overy, Sherman,
- 15:13Sterling, Simpson, Thatcher and Bartlett, and
- 15:17Latham and Watkins agreed collectively to provide
- 15:21$800 million in pro bono. legal services. And
- 15:27finally, finally, on April 9, emboldened by the
- 15:32firms that had caved in, Donald Trump issued
- 15:35an executive order claiming the law firm of Sussman
- 15:39Godfrey was weaponizing the legal system and
- 15:46engaging in dangerous efforts to undermine the
- 15:50US military. Sussman fought back and has so far,
- 15:58through the rulings of Judge Lauren Ali Khan,
- 16:05who granted a stay, a temporary restraining order
- 16:09on April 15, 2025. I've taken the time to recount
- 16:15those all in one place. because it is near impossible
- 16:21for the public, let alone lawyers and judges
- 16:25to keep track of this assault on lawyers and
- 16:30the court system. All of this has been accompanied
- 16:34by attacks on judges, calls for impeachment and
- 16:40other efforts to undermine the rule of law. And
- 16:46that's exactly why we have convened this program
- 16:50today. We'll hear from each of our speakers.
- 16:55We'll engage in some inter -panel conversation.
- 16:59And in the Q &A feature on your Zoom screen,
- 17:04you can put in a question which time permitting
- 17:09we will address before the hour is up. I want
- 17:14to turn to Patricia Corrales to dig deeper into
- 17:20the court rulings, some of the analysis that
- 17:25judges have used to reach these conclusions,
- 17:30and also time permitting to talk about the response
- 17:34of the American Bar Association, the Beverly
- 17:37Hills Bar Association law students. and including
- 17:41an LA Times ad that Patricia was instrumental
- 17:44in publishing, defending the rule of law. Thank
- 17:48you, Patricia. Thank you, Steve, and thank you.
- 17:52Good morning to everyone at the Beverly Hills
- 17:55Bar Association, and thank you for having me.
- 17:58We are in this position because the government
- 18:01The economy and the politics of this country
- 18:05have not been healthy for a long, long time,
- 18:08and we all know that. And now we're facing a
- 18:11very critical time in our history as it relates
- 18:16to the rule of law. As Stephen pointed out, all
- 18:19those executive orders, one of the executive
- 18:22orders or directives that President Donald Trump
- 18:25issued was on March 22nd. And that one's a little
- 18:28different. While it does... talk about a specific
- 18:32law firm. It also authorizes the attorney general
- 18:35to go back eight years and investigate immigration
- 18:40attorneys who may have filed documentation or
- 18:45petitions in the federal court or any applications
- 18:49before any federal agency branch to determine
- 18:52if any of those filings were frivolous or fraudulent.
- 18:57or in any way attacked President Trump's directives
- 19:02or executive orders. So when I read that March
- 19:0822nd directive, I thought to myself, I cannot
- 19:12remain silent. I must not remain silent because
- 19:16if we do remain silent, we are complicit in the
- 19:19attack against our democracy and against the
- 19:22rule of law. I love being a lawyer. something
- 19:27that I'm very passionate about. I never thought
- 19:31myself to be an immigration lawyer. That wasn't
- 19:33what my thought process was when I was in law
- 19:37school. I thought it was going to be joining
- 19:40a big firm. But I ended up with the district
- 19:42attorney's office and then lo and behold, I ended
- 19:45up with the agency. At the time it was called
- 19:47INS and now it's called the Department of Homeland
- 19:50Security. And people think of the Department
- 19:53of Homeland Security as ICE, but the Department
- 19:56of Homeland Security isn't just about ICE. It's
- 19:58about a bigger agency. It's an agency that determines
- 20:03prospective benefits for individuals who come
- 20:06to this country seeking hope, seeking a new life.
- 20:10And some of these individuals are well deserving
- 20:13of this new opportunity. And yet this executive
- 20:17order that the president issued on the 22nd has
- 20:21now taken such a toll on immigration lawyers
- 20:25because lawyers are afraid to file certain benefit
- 20:30applications because they're afraid of being
- 20:33investigated. What we're seeing on a day -to
- 20:35-day basis, and right now immigration is in the
- 20:39forefront of the news with the raids that are
- 20:43happening, the protests that are happening here
- 20:46in Los Angeles. I'm going to talk about that
- 20:51as it relates to that because that's something
- 20:54I'm very familiar with and it's very personal
- 20:56to me. When that directive came out, as I said
- 21:00and I mentioned, we could not remain silent.
- 21:03I had to gather and contact my colleagues, AILA,
- 21:08the American Immigration Lawyers Association,
- 21:11and ask them, we need to speak up. We need to
- 21:14say something. We cannot just let this go by
- 21:18and not say anything. And we can't be bullied
- 21:20by this president. We have to defend our clients.
- 21:24And I was astounded, to be honest, that there
- 21:28was so much reluctance. by many of the lawyers,
- 21:33by many of my colleagues, because they were afraid.
- 21:36They were afraid that if they stood up, they
- 21:39were afraid if they spoke out, that this would
- 21:42affect their clients, that their clients would
- 21:44be targeted. And there was such a resistance.
- 21:48But luckily and fortunately, 30 brave lawyers,
- 21:52I gather 30 brave lawyers to put together a defense
- 21:56to the attack on on being an immigration lawyer,
- 22:01but on the rule of law in particular. And so
- 22:04as Stephen mentioned, we published a op -ed that
- 22:08was openly published in the Los Angeles Times.
- 22:11And we got phenomenal response in relationship
- 22:13to that. And that letter is basically telling
- 22:17the president of the United States that he will
- 22:20not scare us, he will not bully us, that we have
- 22:22every right to defend those who are defenseless,
- 22:25those who have no voice. And I firmly believe
- 22:30that. And I firmly believe that these big firms,
- 22:33and I'm a small firm, These big firms should
- 22:37be taking the same stand. They should be able
- 22:41to stand up against this president and his administration
- 22:45and the tactics that this administration uses
- 22:48to defend those who are defenseless. Not just
- 22:53the big corporations, but those who are really
- 22:55defenseless. I recently was contacted by an attorney
- 23:00in one of these big firms. who advised me that
- 23:04their firm can no longer do pro bono immigration
- 23:08work. And so they're referring out clients. To
- 23:12me, that's incredible. Big firms have the resources,
- 23:16the opportunities, or more opportunities to help
- 23:20those who are seeking asylum. If an individual
- 23:23has a unique asylum claim, big firms have those
- 23:26types of resources to get the investigators,
- 23:28to get the expert witnesses. And now big firms
- 23:31are not taking on these pro bono cases because
- 23:35they've made a promise they've made an agreement
- 23:38with this executive with this administration
- 23:40to not handle any immigration cases i find that
- 23:45to be outrageous i find that uh i find that to
- 23:49be outrageous but i also find it to be a lack
- 23:53of strength and we need to not be weak in this
- 23:57moment um I wanna talk specifically about what
- 24:01we've seen since the executive order on March
- 24:0422nd. We have seen lawyers like myself being
- 24:08prevented from representing our clients in immigration
- 24:12court. For example, during this particular protest,
- 24:17this over the weekend, two of my clients were
- 24:20detained. I was prohibited, prohibited from speaking
- 24:26to my clients. Now, the reason I was given was
- 24:30because it was too dangerous and the situation
- 24:33did not allow for me to talk to my clients. But
- 24:37a lawyer should never be prohibited from talking
- 24:40to their client. And an individual seeking representation
- 24:45should never be prohibited from seeking the assistance
- 24:49of a lawyer. And all the individuals detained
- 24:52over the weekend were prohibited from seeing
- 24:54a lawyer. Lawyers were, and I'm not exaggerating,
- 24:58were pushed, were prevented from talking, even
- 25:01talking to their clients, telephonically. We
- 25:05were given wrong numbers to contact. the false
- 25:08facts numbers too. Facts are notice of entry
- 25:12of appearance. Those are the types of tactics
- 25:15that unfortunately we are seeing on a day -to
- 25:17-day basis, and that's an attack on the legal
- 25:21system. If we allow that, the fundamental principles
- 25:26of our democracy are just going to go away, and
- 25:30we cannot allow that. We're also seeing as a
- 25:35We're also seeing on a day -to -day basis government
- 25:38lawyers and not all government lawyers. Some
- 25:42are courageous, but many are in a very difficult
- 25:45position. They have homes, they have families
- 25:48to feed, and they need the job. But we have government
- 25:52lawyers that are espousing legal arguments. They're
- 25:58not sustained by law if that makes any sense
- 26:02or they're making up legal arguments that have
- 26:05no basis or no merit in the law and that's outrageous
- 26:10because as a lawyer we have a duty to be ethical
- 26:14before the court and yet Department of Justice
- 26:17lawyers are being told that they have to they
- 26:25have to make certain arguments before the court
- 26:28that have no basis factual or legal precedent.
- 26:34And I find that... just absurd and a violation
- 26:39of our ethical obligations. And we're pushing
- 26:42back. Us lawyers are pushing back. We're filing
- 26:44lawsuits against the administration for the denial
- 26:47of due process, the denial of access to our clients,
- 26:50the denial of benefits to our clients when clearly
- 26:54the individual was eligible for that benefit.
- 26:57And in doing so, what we're seeing, and it's
- 27:01not an exaggeration, is I filed a federal lawsuit
- 27:04against the Trump administration. And two days
- 27:07after I filed the lawsuit, four ICE agents raided
- 27:12my client's house and detained him. Why? And
- 27:16I solely believe it's because I filed a lawsuit
- 27:19claiming that the government was acting, you
- 27:24know, without cause and denying my client's naturalization
- 27:28application. So these are the types of scare
- 27:31tactics, the type of bullying tactics that we're
- 27:35seeing. They're investigating immigration lawyers
- 27:38that are filing certain applications. They're
- 27:41investigating attorneys who file H1Bs or VAWA
- 27:46applications. So lawyers in my field are being
- 27:51careful. They're being hesitant to represent.
- 27:55individuals. And that clearly has a negative
- 28:01effect in our rule of law, because we can't be
- 28:05afraid to represent our clients. So this is what
- 28:08we're seeing as a consequence of the executive
- 28:14order that Trump issued on the 22nd. Because
- 28:17many of us are also getting emails from the court
- 28:20saying, back up. back up your legal argument
- 28:25that you made on such and such a day. I haven't
- 28:27received that, thank God. I haven't received
- 28:29one of those emails, but I know a colleague of
- 28:31mine that did receive that. I know that Department
- 28:33of Justice lawyers are also receiving those emails.
- 28:37Why? Because there is a sense of Department of
- 28:41Justice lawyers are being supervised in such
- 28:45a manner that they are expousing legal arguments
- 28:49that just have no foundation in both truth and
- 28:52law. And that to me is, I've never seen that
- 28:56before. And when I get a brief from the government
- 28:58attorney that has arguments that have no basis
- 29:02in the law, I'm flummoxed. I'm like, how is that
- 29:06possible? And so you respond in kind. And we're
- 29:10also seeing on a practical level, judges, immigration
- 29:15judges. They're not Article 3 judges. They're
- 29:18administrative law judges. But they are judges
- 29:20nonetheless. They have to be neutral. They have
- 29:22to be fact -finders. They have to make decisions.
- 29:25And we're seeing judges afraid to make decisions,
- 29:30afraid to take the right course of action because
- 29:34of what it could do to them because these judges
- 29:37are under a quota. That to me is outrageous for
- 29:41a judge to be pressured in that matter because
- 29:44then the judge isn't free to act neutrally. The
- 29:49judge isn't free to act without bias. These are
- 29:54the kinds of day -to -day issues that we're facing
- 29:58as a result of this executive order. It's not
- 30:00just affecting big law, it's affecting lawyers
- 30:03like myself, smaller firms. Thank you, Patricia.
- 30:08I'm so grateful that you have put this in a real
- 30:10-life context, the lawyers and the clients and
- 30:14the judges that are being affected by this. The
- 30:17order that Patricia highlighted, the March 22nd
- 30:21order, is in the materials that I referred to
- 30:25before, and I'm glad she gave it that broader
- 30:28context of the threat to go back. and file Rule
- 30:3211 and other motions alleging frivolous proceedings.
- 30:37I want to turn to Barry MacDonald to give us
- 30:42even a deeper sense of what's at stake here.
- 30:46What are the principles of due process of independent
- 30:50decision makers and the kinds of vigorous advocacy
- 30:55that the American people really expect from their
- 31:00lawyers. We know that these decisions have called,
- 31:05and these are the court decisions themselves,
- 31:09pernicious, unprecedented, cringe -worthy, egregious,
- 31:12and shocking. Barry, take a few minutes to expand
- 31:16on those issues and give us your perspective.
- 31:21First, I'd like to say thanks to Steve and Belinda
- 31:24for putting this panel together and inviting
- 31:27me to speak. As a professor of constitutional
- 31:31law, I told Steve that I thought my 10 minutes
- 31:33might best be spent focusing on the merits of
- 31:36the constitutional claims that are being litigated
- 31:38in these law firm cases. But having now had a
- 31:42chance to review the district court decisions,
- 31:44I've changed my mind. Why? Because the retaliatory
- 31:48actions being taken by the Trump administration
- 31:51against these firms seem so patently unconstitutional
- 31:54that they hardly seem to warrant serious analysis.
- 31:58For starters, it's textbook law under our system
- 32:01as affirmed by the Supreme Court in the seminal
- 32:04Youngstown Sheet and Tube decision that the executive
- 32:08can only exercise power as authorized by Congress
- 32:11or the Constitution. In other words, the executive
- 32:14is under law like every other citizen. And while
- 32:18Congress may have given the executive power to
- 32:21control certain issues with respect to government
- 32:23security clearances, government contracting,
- 32:27and the like, it's still black letter law that
- 32:30such power cannot be exercised in violation of
- 32:34the Constitution. A prime example of this is
- 32:38the Hamdi decision arising out of the September
- 32:4111 attacks, where the Supreme Court held that
- 32:44while even though President Bush had been authorized
- 32:47by Congress to detain suspected enemy combatants,
- 32:51he still acted unlawfully in not respecting their
- 32:54due process rights. And in this case, there is
- 32:58little question that the Trump administration
- 33:00has violated the First Amendment by retaliating
- 33:03against these firms for advocating on behalf
- 33:06of clients or causes viewed as being opposed
- 33:09to Trump's personal or political interests. It
- 33:14is plainly a form of viewpoint discrimination,
- 33:16which is at the core of what the First Amendment
- 33:18prohibits, as well as a violation of rights of
- 33:22political association and related rights. In
- 33:25addition, the Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights
- 33:27to effective counsel of the law firm's clients
- 33:30seem clearly violated by these attempts to quell
- 33:34the vigorous advocacy of their causes. As District
- 33:38Court Judge Richard Leon recently ruled, Trump
- 33:42also seems to be plainly violating the separation
- 33:44of powers by attempting to regulate the behavior
- 33:47of attorneys in cases before the courts, something
- 33:51that clearly lies within the responsibility of
- 33:53the judiciary itself. Perhaps the clear illegality
- 33:58of these executive orders is why the Trump administration
- 34:01has remained silent. about appealing these rulings,
- 34:04something that is in stark contrast to what it
- 34:08usually does when it loses these types of cases.
- 34:12So let me instead spend the rest of my time making
- 34:15some broader points about the subject of this
- 34:17event. It might seem strange to talk about preserving
- 34:21the independence of the legal bar, professionals
- 34:24trained to be anything but independent and impartial
- 34:28and vigorously advocating for causes on behalf
- 34:31of clients. But here we're not talking about
- 34:34the bar's independence from clients or even from
- 34:37courts and codes of professional conduct in order
- 34:41to make whatever claims an attorney wants to.
- 34:44After all, deeply rooted in our history and tradition
- 34:47is the principle that attorneys are officers
- 34:49of the court, having duties to serve not only
- 34:53clients, but also the broader interests of justice.
- 34:57Rather, we're talking about an attorney's independence
- 34:59from the political branches of government in
- 35:02making decisions about who to represent and how
- 35:05best to do that. Without such independence, our
- 35:09historic adversarial system of justice, where
- 35:12courts rely on the robust advocacy of both sides
- 35:15of a legal question to reach its own independent
- 35:18decision about it, would cease to function properly.
- 35:22and particularly in cases involving the government
- 35:24as one of the parties to the dispute. The Supreme
- 35:28Court made this point explicitly in the legal
- 35:31services versus Velasquez case, where it ruled
- 35:34that Congress violated the First Amendment rights
- 35:37of attorneys in conditioning the receipt of government
- 35:39funds on refraining from making certain claims
- 35:42and arguments about welfare laws. As the majority
- 35:46wrote in that case, an informed independent judiciary
- 35:50presumes an informed independent bar. And this
- 35:54is not just pie in the sky idealism. It is how
- 35:58our system is designed to enforce the rule of
- 36:01law instead of the rule of particular politicians.
- 36:04In other words, independent courts, supported
- 36:08by an independent bar, provide the foundation
- 36:11for even -handedly enforcing the rules we ourselves
- 36:15have made via our political representatives.
- 36:19In short, those rules and their impartial enforcement
- 36:22through our adversarial system is the cornerstone
- 36:26of American democracy and what separates us from
- 36:29a more autocratic form of government. And it
- 36:33takes little discernment to realize that in these
- 36:35law firm cases, the political interference seems
- 36:39much more pernicious and harmful to the rule
- 36:41of law than the Vlasquez situation of Congress
- 36:45denying funds in connection with welfare cases.
- 36:49Here we have a president attempting to exact
- 36:52retribution for personal grievances arising from
- 36:55prior effects to have courts adjudge whether
- 36:58he violated the law in various cases. The most
- 37:03serious situation in my mind involves the Trump
- 37:06administration's actions against Covington and
- 37:08Burling for providing legal support to the independent
- 37:11counsel investigating the January 6 events at
- 37:15the Capitol. So here we have a then former president
- 37:19being forced to stand trial for a purported crime
- 37:22of historic proportions. an alleged attempt to
- 37:25hijack a presidential election based on claims
- 37:28of voter fraud uniformly rejected by the courts,
- 37:33who has only spared those proceedings by winning
- 37:35a relatively close second election. And then
- 37:40the Trump administration not only goes after
- 37:42Covington, but also many career government attorneys
- 37:45and law enforcement officers who were just doing
- 37:48their jobs to investigate the matter, accusing
- 37:51them of weaponizing the law. A claim that seems
- 37:55exceedingly perverse and disingenuous in light
- 37:58of how the Trump administration is reacting in
- 38:01these cases. I can't say I know for sure why
- 38:05Covington and other firms like Paul Weiss appear
- 38:07to have capitulated to these efforts, but many
- 38:10kudos to Perkins Cooley and the other firms that
- 38:13decided to fight this out in court. And many
- 38:16kudos as well to Williams and Connolly and other
- 38:19firms who were willing to risk similar retribution.
- 38:22for representing these firms. For in the end,
- 38:26confronting this assault on the independence
- 38:28of the legal bar can only effectively be done
- 38:31by appealing to the courts who in turn rely on
- 38:35the bar's work to function properly. And as Steve
- 38:40noted, as Shakespeare recognized, we need the
- 38:44courts to protect this aspect of the rule of
- 38:46law since it's not likely to be the public's
- 38:50enthusiastic support for lawyers. that does it.
- 38:54Which brings me to confronting the Trump administration
- 38:57attacks on courts that rule against them. As
- 39:01I've said, an impartial and independent judiciary
- 39:03is critical to the rule of law. That is why the
- 39:07founders created Article III courts with protections
- 39:10such as lifetime tenure and compensation guarantees.
- 39:15Even though I'll be the first to admit the courts
- 39:17sometimes abuse these protections to impose their
- 39:20own political preferences on Americans. But that's
- 39:23a subject for another time. But once courts start
- 39:27deciding who wins cases based on the wishes of
- 39:30a political leader, now we're definitely moving
- 39:33from the rule of law to the rule of an autocrat.
- 39:36That is why Trump's attacks on judges who rule
- 39:39against him are so concerning. Many judges are
- 39:43being subjected to death threats after such attacks.
- 39:46And in the past, some judges and their families
- 39:49have been the target of deadly violence. Lately,
- 39:52judges have begun receiving pizza deliveries
- 39:54at their homes in the name of a judge's son who
- 39:57was killed by an extremist a few years ago. Thinly
- 40:02veiled threats telling judges that we know where
- 40:05you live. And you know we've reached a sad point
- 40:08when a conference of federal judges recently
- 40:11discussed creating their own personal security
- 40:14force because they can't be sure that the U .S.
- 40:17Marshals Service, which is under the executive
- 40:19branch, can be fully relied on to do the right
- 40:22thing if judges have ruled against the administration.
- 40:27This is a sad state of affairs and must be addressed
- 40:30to protect our democratic system of government.
- 40:34But how to confront this threat is a stickier
- 40:37problem than the threat to the bar. At least
- 40:40courts exist to protect that bar. But who will
- 40:43protect the courts if the executive and loyalist
- 40:46congressional leaders are reviling them for their
- 40:50rulings? Hopefully, if things remain at the level
- 40:53of ludicrous threats of impeachment or like criticisms,
- 40:58our courts will be able to weather this storm.
- 41:01So far, President Trump has said his administration
- 41:04will comply with court orders, although this
- 41:08pledge is being sorely tested in certain immigration
- 41:11cases. But if we reach the court where the Trump
- 41:14administration is openly defying court orders
- 41:17on a more serious scale, now we will have a constitutional
- 41:21crisis on our hands. It has been suggested that
- 41:25President Trump would never let it come to this
- 41:27due to the chaos such a situation would inflict
- 41:30on our financial and other markets, much more
- 41:33so than the tariff situation is currently causing.
- 41:37Well, I for one hope this is right, because I'd
- 41:40hate to think that Ben Franklin might have been
- 41:43on to something when he suggested to an inquirer
- 41:45outside the Constitutional Convention that the
- 41:48republic the founders gave us might not be easy
- 41:51to keep. particularly in an age when a large
- 41:55portion of our citizenry does not seem sufficiently
- 41:58engaged to recognize and respond to serious threats
- 42:02to our democratic form of government. Thank you.
- 42:07Thank you, Barry. Just an extraordinary and tight
- 42:12examination of the issues that we're confronting.
- 42:17I'm very, very grateful to you for that. Now
- 42:21let's take a view from the bench. We were very
- 42:24grateful that Judge Hilberman joined us for this
- 42:27panel because there is the separate attacks on
- 42:33the judiciary that have been taking place and
- 42:38I for one was impressed by the report that the
- 42:42American Board of Trial Advocates put out. preserving
- 42:46the fair, impartial, and independent judiciary
- 42:49that Joe had a hand in. Please give us your thoughts
- 42:56from the perspective of a judge and the perspective
- 42:59of how you resist outside influences and how
- 43:04you maintain judicial independence. Thank you,
- 43:08Stephen, and thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar
- 43:10Association for inviting me to participate. I'd
- 43:13like to point out that these are my opinions,
- 43:16not the opinions of the court nor of ADR services
- 43:19with whom I currently work. One of the beauties
- 43:22of being the person who goes last on a panel
- 43:24is pretty much everything I wanted to say and
- 43:26covered by everyone else. I did, however, wear
- 43:29my Supreme Court tie. I purchased this when I
- 43:31was visiting the Supreme Court. They have a comment
- 43:36here, a number of things. Habeas corpus, for
- 43:38example, I'm going to find out from Kristi Noem
- 43:40what that means when I have an opportunity. You
- 43:45know, John Adams in 1780 in the Declaration of
- 43:50Rights in the Massachusetts Constitution established
- 43:54the principle of judicial independence. And our
- 43:58Constitution created three equal branches of
- 44:02government. the executive, the legislative, and
- 44:05the judiciary. To ensure that independence, federal
- 44:11judges are appointed for life, so they don't
- 44:13have to be responsive to public whim or to political
- 44:18power or pressures, although it seems as though
- 44:22that is a diminished philosophy among some folks.
- 44:27Although this was established by Alexander Hamilton,
- 44:30in federal's paper number 78. Judges are accountable
- 44:35to the Constitution. They're not accountable
- 44:37to politicians or to the public. They're accountable
- 44:41to the Constitution. Now, that's true, of course,
- 44:43as we know, with the federal judiciary. Here
- 44:46in California... and in many other states, judges
- 44:49are elected. I, for example, was nominated and
- 44:53appointed to the bench by the governor at that
- 44:55time, Gray Davis, and then stood for election
- 44:59as we're required to do in California at the
- 45:02next general election. I was then elected to
- 45:06a full term on the court. They can only be removed
- 45:11for violation or creation of high crimes and
- 45:14misdemeanors. And Chief Justice Roberts brought
- 45:17that to everyone's attention when he commented
- 45:19on President Trump's comment that a certain judge
- 45:23should be impeached. And Justice Roberts correctly
- 45:27pointed out that the constitutional standard
- 45:29is impeachment is based upon the commission of
- 45:33a high crime or misdemeanor. not based upon an
- 45:37opinion with which the president disagrees. Members
- 45:41of the Congress picked up on that, and there
- 45:44were drumbeats to impeach certain judges. Never
- 45:47an action filed, as far as I'm concerned. My
- 45:50constitutional colleagues can address that more
- 45:54accurately, but I don't believe any articles
- 45:56of impeachment has ever been brought against
- 45:58any of the judges who've entered orders in these
- 46:00cases. We've had recall elections in certain
- 46:05jurisdictions based upon disagreements with the
- 46:09order of the court, the finding of the court,
- 46:11not the propriety of the finding, but rather
- 46:14just a disagreement in principle with what the
- 46:17judge ruled rather than an argument about violating
- 46:20established law. The Annenberg School of Public
- 46:26Policy at the University of Pennsylvania, And
- 46:29I think this goes to Professor McDonald's point.
- 46:33They provided a survey in 2018. And at that time,
- 46:38they found that 21 % of those surveyed indicated
- 46:43that if the Supreme Court started making rulings
- 46:46that most Americans disagree with, then they
- 46:49should just disband the Supreme Court. 21 % of
- 46:53those surveyed adopted that policy. I was also
- 46:57taken by the executive memo that was part of
- 46:59your materials, and I just wanted to refer to
- 47:01some of these, because this was a directive from
- 47:04the president's office to the attorney general
- 47:07and the secretary of homeland security, which
- 47:11made reference to misconduct by lawyers and law
- 47:14firms that threaten our national security, homeland
- 47:18security, public safety, and election integrity.
- 47:22And as my colleagues have pointed out, there's
- 47:24no suggestion that any of those things were undertaken.
- 47:27It was rather just a disagreement. The memo goes
- 47:31on to state that the immigration bar, that's
- 47:36you, Patricia, the immigration bar and powerful
- 47:40big law pro bono practices frequently coach clients
- 47:44to conceal their past or lie. about their circumstances
- 47:48when asserting asylum claims, all in an attempt
- 47:52to circumvent immigration policies enacted to
- 47:55protect our national security and deceive the
- 47:59immigration authorities. There are no citations
- 48:02of authority to support that position in this
- 48:05memorandum. It goes on to say, That under the
- 48:10federal rules a lawyer shall not bring or defend
- 48:13a proceeding or assert or con or assert or Controvert
- 48:18and issue therein unless there's a basis in law
- 48:21in fact for doing so and it should not be frivolous
- 48:25And there have to be good faith arguments once
- 48:27again No indication of when this has happened
- 48:31in any proceeding and finally that goes on to
- 48:34state. Unfortunately, this is a quote unfortunately
- 48:38Far too many attorneys and law firms have long
- 48:40ignored these requirements when litigating against
- 48:44the federal government or pursuing baseless partisan
- 48:48attacks. Now, we've all talked about this morning,
- 48:51we've talked about certain law firms that have
- 48:53acquiesced in President Trump's contention that
- 48:57they have crossed the line, and they've given
- 49:01millions and millions of dollars to Trump and
- 49:05his chosen charities or whatever he's going to
- 49:09refer to them as, in order to continue doing
- 49:11business with the United States government, even
- 49:14though every court that's ruled on this has found
- 49:17that this order, this memorandum was unconstitutional.
- 49:22I signed on to a number of these amicus briefs
- 49:27and it's clear that that these orders were just
- 49:32because of a dislike for the attorneys and the
- 49:35clients that they represented, not based on the
- 49:38law. There have been and has been referred to
- 49:41several assaults on the judiciary, both physically
- 49:44and intellectually. Justice Sotomayor recently
- 49:49referred to the relentless attacks, disregard
- 49:52and disparagement of judges on a daily basis
- 49:55in the media and by elected officials. As I mentioned,
- 49:59there's a suggestion that some in the executive
- 50:01and the legislature that they can eliminate the
- 50:04court system by simply defunding it. There was
- 50:07a suggestion that we simply defund the Ninth
- 50:10Circuit, and then we wouldn't have to deal with
- 50:11this anymore. We've read about threats to judges.
- 50:15Justice Kavanaugh had an armed person outside
- 50:18of his home who was apprehended. The professor
- 50:21made reference to the pizza delivery thing, which
- 50:23is really a way of telling the judge, we know
- 50:25where you live. And that's very intimidating.
- 50:31There's the image of the judge being perp walked
- 50:33because she purportedly assisted in one of the
- 50:37parties before her in exiting the court through
- 50:39another exit rather than the public exit of the
- 50:43courthouse. And instead of simply citing her
- 50:45for some violation, they arrested her and had
- 50:49her do the perp walk in front of the media. which
- 50:52was completely unnecessary and another assault
- 50:55on the independence of the judiciary through
- 50:58intimidation. There was a special report published
- 51:02by Reuters in May of this year that highlighted
- 51:06a troubling surge in threats against judges and
- 51:09their families. They analyzed 600 social media
- 51:14and message board posts since February, targeting
- 51:17the families of federal judges who had ruled
- 51:21against the Trump administration. Prominent Trump
- 51:26allies have amplified these by republishing and
- 51:29rebroadcasting, reposting something I don't do,
- 51:33and I don't know how many of you do, reposting
- 51:35these things over 200 million times. The United
- 51:41States Marshals Service has documented 373 substantiated
- 51:47threats against federal judges in the first five
- 51:50months of this year. In 2024, there was a total
- 51:53of 500 such threats in the entire year, and there
- 51:58have been 373 through the first five months of
- 52:02the year. I recently had a conversation with
- 52:05some of my former colleagues, both on the California
- 52:07Court of Appeal and on the Superior Court. And
- 52:12significantly, they, although they have been
- 52:16trained in what to do in either a hostage situation
- 52:20or if there's an assault on the court or the
- 52:22courtroom, there have been no reported cases.
- 52:25of physical assaults or threats directly at Superior
- 52:29Court judges in California or the Court of Appeal
- 52:32that these judges and justices with whom I spoke
- 52:35were aware. So what can we do as lawyers and
- 52:39as judges about the assaults on the judiciary?
- 52:44Years ago, Justice Sandra Day O 'Connor made
- 52:48the comment that there was a tremendous decline
- 52:50in civic education. and the people didn't appreciate
- 52:54the three branches of government. Now we see
- 52:57this decline in civic education going further
- 53:01to the removal of books from our libraries to
- 53:05limit the amount of information, the breadth
- 53:07of knowledge that students and others who utilize
- 53:10the library, even the Library of Congress or
- 53:12the library at the Military Academy, can put
- 53:16out for their consumption of the patrons. 32
- 53:21percent, and this is a recent study. This is
- 53:24really disturbing. Judges worry about this. 32
- 53:28percent of Americans were able to name all three
- 53:32branches of government, and 33 percent could
- 53:36not name the court as one of the three branches
- 53:39of government. Judges think we're pretty important,
- 53:41and when we find out that 33 percent of the surveyed
- 53:45public doesn't know about us, it's a little disappointing.
- 53:49So you as attorneys, You as attorneys can be
- 53:51very influential in educating those with whom
- 53:55you interact on the basics of the Constitution.
- 53:59That includes speaking in schools, in civic meetings
- 54:02with which you're engaged, and supporting organizations
- 54:06like the Bar Association or ABOTA, which encourage
- 54:10the knowledge and understanding of the Constitution
- 54:13and the judicial system. For those of you who
- 54:16aren't litigators, you probably don't know about
- 54:18ABOTA. which stands for the American Board of
- 54:21Trial Advocates. It has three basic principles.
- 54:24One, respect for the judiciary, civility in the
- 54:28practice of law, and the preservation of the
- 54:32right to a civil jury trial. Those are all fundamental
- 54:36to the institutions of justice. Recently, and
- 54:40I believe this was alluded to, Chief Justice
- 54:42Dolly G. was addressing a group of federal judges
- 54:46and noted what she called a full -body challenge
- 54:50to our constitutional order. And she also noted
- 54:54that silence of the bar is acquiescence. And
- 54:59I think all of us agree that we cannot be acquiescent
- 55:02in the attack on the Constitution and the judiciary.
- 55:07So the committee for judicial responsibility
- 55:10here in California has proposed some new rules,
- 55:13which I believe are in the materials as well.
- 55:16But I wanted to address one other thing about
- 55:18people leaving the public service, as some judges
- 55:21have done under pressure. Recently, you may have
- 55:25read about a case in the federal court here in
- 55:28Los Angeles where a hard -fought conviction of
- 55:33felony was found against a police officer. Then
- 55:36a new US attorney came into town and reduced
- 55:39the felony conviction to a misdemeanor. My friend
- 55:43was one of the attorneys who prosecuted that
- 55:46case, and he felt he could no longer be a member
- 55:50of the assistant US attorney's office and has
- 55:54resigned. He's a brilliant lawyer and a terrifically
- 55:57nice person of great moral character. So I suggested
- 56:00to him that he might consider applying for a
- 56:03position on the bench. and he told me that he
- 56:06was concerned about the safety of his family
- 56:09if he took a judicial appointment. It just troubles
- 56:13me so much to think that we have declined into
- 56:16a position where lawyers and judges are afraid
- 56:20to take appropriate moral and ethical positions.
- 56:25With that, I want to remind you that it's your
- 56:27responsibility to stand up for the judiciary,
- 56:30stand up for the rule of law, and One last thing
- 56:35I'll mention, and it was mentioned earlier today,
- 56:37and it's in an article in the Los Angeles Times
- 56:40today, quoting Professor Erwin Chemerinsky, who's
- 56:44a pretty good constitutional scholar like our
- 56:46two other panelists members here. He said that
- 56:50the things that are going on now, particularly
- 56:54in California with the calling out of the troops,
- 56:56creates a chilling effect, and I know Patricia,
- 56:58this has to do with your practice as well, a
- 57:01chilling effect. on lawyers and their clients
- 57:04in expressing their rights. I will personalize
- 57:07that because I was asked, along with 350 other
- 57:10retired judges and justices, to join as an amicus
- 57:14on the briefs that have been referred to. I actually
- 57:18thought about it for a minute before I signed
- 57:20on. The fact that I had to think about it for
- 57:23a minute, I think is a clear example of the chilling
- 57:27effect. So go forth and do justice. Thank you,
- 57:33Joe. I think this may be part one of this discussion
- 57:39because we are verging on running out of time.
- 57:43There are questions in the chat. I want to frame
- 57:47two quick questions and quick answers from you.
- 57:53Barry, it is asked in the chat what you expect
- 57:56from the current U .S. Supreme Court in response
- 58:01to these. rulings if they are appealed by the
- 58:06Trump administration? Well, I suspect the Supreme
- 58:11Court will uphold what the district courts have
- 58:15done. I don't see an alternative course for them.
- 58:19But in terms of the broader array of emergency
- 58:24orders that are coming to the Supreme Court regarding
- 58:28district court and appellate court decisions,
- 58:31respecting the Trump administration, I think
- 58:33the Supreme Court is engaged in a real delicate
- 58:37balancing act. It wants to enforce the rule of
- 58:40law, but at the same time, it does not want to
- 58:42provoke a serious constitutional crisis where
- 58:46it's being defied by the Trump administration.
- 58:49So I think it's going to be really interesting
- 58:52what happens in the future. I did want to disappoint
- 58:57my friend, Joe Hilberman. Six impeachment articles
- 59:02have been filed against federal judges already
- 59:06in the House of Representatives. Those are pending.
- 59:10When you read about them, they are directly focused
- 59:13on the substance of the rulings of these judges
- 59:18in violation of what Chief Justice Roberts spoke
- 59:21about and what you spoke about as well, Joe.
- 59:26Patricia. In addition to everything that has
- 59:29been said, is there a role to be played by the
- 59:32public? We are being watched by an extraordinary
- 59:36number of people today in this webinar, as well
- 59:39as those who will see it. And I am proud of the
- 59:42Beverly Hills Bar because, as Joe said, people
- 59:45are silent and silence betokens support for the
- 59:52status quo and what this government is doing.
- 59:55So it's important that a bar association would
- 59:58hold a program like this. It's important that
- 1:00:01bar associations are speaking out on this. But
- 1:00:05as we direct this program to lawyers and others,
- 1:00:08what can the public do in the face of this and
- 1:00:13why should this matter to the public? It should
- 1:00:17matter to the public because this isn't just
- 1:00:20an immigration issue. I think what we're hearing
- 1:00:23a lot about is the immigration situation and
- 1:00:26how many of these executive orders target the
- 1:00:31immigration aspect of our laws. But this is not
- 1:00:34solely an immigration issue. This is truly a
- 1:00:39quintessential issue of the rule of law. We depend
- 1:00:45on these three branches of government for them
- 1:00:48to do their job independent of each other. And
- 1:00:52if one particular branch of that government,
- 1:00:55the executive, begins to order the other branches
- 1:01:00to do what that executive wants, then we have
- 1:01:03no democracy. And I think as individuals, as
- 1:01:07lawyers, as judges, as just folks, the citizenry,
- 1:01:12yes, learn. about our civics, but speak out.
- 1:01:17And speaking out doesn't mean you have to throw
- 1:01:20mocktails or set the cars on fire. That's not
- 1:01:23what I'm talking about. I'm talking about write
- 1:01:25your congressman. If your congressman isn't doing
- 1:01:28his job or her job, then see if you can flip
- 1:01:31that seat. our congressmen have to respond to
- 1:01:35us we are the people that is what the constitution
- 1:01:38says we the people not we the executive not we
- 1:01:43the congress we the people and if our leaders
- 1:01:46and our elected leaders are not holding the executive
- 1:01:50accountable and to be frank with you i'm just
- 1:01:53astounded at the lack of i'm astounded at the
- 1:02:00silence from the are other than AOC, you know,
- 1:02:05or others, you don't see a lot of Democrats holding
- 1:02:11town halls, Democratic congressmen holding town
- 1:02:14halls. We've got to hold our representatives
- 1:02:17accountable. And that's just my strong belief.
- 1:02:23The other thing I want to say, I want to touch
- 1:02:24upon is many of you may or may not know that
- 1:02:27on June 5th, because of all the ridiculous grounds
- 1:02:33of ridiculous legal arguments that are being
- 1:02:38made in some of these cases. There was an ethical
- 1:02:41complaint filed against the attorney general
- 1:02:43in the state of Florida with the bar. It is important
- 1:02:48for all the bars to talk about this subject,
- 1:02:51but it's also important for us to not allow these
- 1:02:56un... these arguments that have no foundation
- 1:03:01in fact, no foundation in law to perpetuate.
- 1:03:06We have to hold these lawyers accountable. And
- 1:03:10filing a complaint against the attorney general,
- 1:03:12while that might sound unprecedented and a little
- 1:03:17bit frightening because how is it going to affect
- 1:03:19me, we can't think about it as how is this going
- 1:03:22to affect me. are part of this country. We have
- 1:03:27to stand up for the principles and the foundations
- 1:03:30of this great country. So to be frank with you,
- 1:03:34I'm not afraid to stand up, but there are others
- 1:03:36who are afraid, and I can appreciate that. I
- 1:03:39truly can. But I don't think we can remain silent.
- 1:03:43We become complicit. And so I ask everyone to
- 1:03:48talk about it, to hold your representatives accountable,
- 1:03:51to speak up when you can. Thank you, Patricia.
- 1:03:55I'm sure you speak for all of us. The quote from
- 1:03:59Benjamin Franklin that was requested in the chat.
- 1:04:03A woman did approach him in 1787 outside the
- 1:04:07Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia and
- 1:04:11asked, what have you accomplished? What form
- 1:04:16of government have you created? He responded,
- 1:04:18a republic, if you can keep it. if you can keep
- 1:04:24it, and he was talking to a prominent woman,
- 1:04:27not a member of the elected delegates. So this
- 1:04:32question that we leave you with is, can you keep
- 1:04:36it? On June 14, There are going to be nationwide
- 1:04:42no King's rallies. It's estimated that 1 ,600
- 1:04:47rallies are planned across the United States
- 1:04:50on that Saturday, June 14. That's what it means
- 1:04:56to keep it. It means to support those kinds of
- 1:05:01peaceful demonstrations. It means to speak to
- 1:05:04your congresspersons, to come out to those town
- 1:05:07halls, to write letters to the editor, to contact
- 1:05:12and also to speak frankly over the dining room
- 1:05:16table with your family and your friends. to not
- 1:05:21allow a passing remark like kill all the lawyers
- 1:05:24to go by without addressing what's really behind
- 1:05:28that and the role that lawyers and judges play
- 1:05:31in our democratic system. That's what this panel's
- 1:05:35been about. We look forward to your comments
- 1:05:38to the Bar Association and others. We're going
- 1:05:42to spread this. recording free and you'll all
- 1:05:46get links. Please do consult the 174 pages of
- 1:05:51materials. They are accessible, they are readable,
- 1:05:54they are part of the civic education. that Judge
- 1:05:58Hilberman spoke of, which this program today
- 1:06:02is an attempt to advance. Thank you for attending
- 1:06:07this. Thank you for doing something today for
- 1:06:12our republic and our constitutional democracy.
- 1:06:15Thank you very much.