Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP210: Nancy's Grave
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi Tanya, Hi Talia. Welcome back
- 0:38everybody to this episode of Crimes in Consequences. Thank you so much for listening
- 0:43to us or watching us on True Crime Daily. We'd like to ask you
- 0:49to hit the subscribe or follow or like button or whatever whatever positive thing you
- 0:54can do. Right, Yep, yep, how are you I'm doing?
- 1:00Okay? You are? I am am I getting you stressed out, getting
- 1:03stressed out, running a little fantastic. I'm always good, that fantastic and
- 1:10always good. Are you ready for some true crime? Yes? Okay.
- 1:15So this case actually it's from Michigan and you've heard about it. It happened
- 1:23not far from my home, and it's a really tragic case. I'm not
- 1:30going to say the last names of the victim or the perpetrator to respect the
- 1:37family, okay, but it's a very interesting case. And with that,
- 1:44are you ready? Yes? Okay, So let me tell you a little
- 1:47bit about it. It's about March thirteenth of twenty sixteen, and the parents
- 1:53of Stephen, we're gonna call them Stephen Christopher. They walked into the police
- 1:57station to file a missing peron since report. Stephen was nineteen, and it
- 2:02had been three days since they last saw him. He wasn't answering his cell
- 2:08phone and he'd never been gone that long without talking to them, Susanne and
- 2:16Michael, his parents. They reached out to all his friends and where do
- 2:22you know, what's going on? Have you seen Stephen? And nobody seemed
- 2:27to see him since March tenth. Oh, yes, it's been a few
- 2:30days. It's been three days. Yeah, So the evening of March tenth
- 2:36seemed a very normal evening to Steven's parents. There was nothing unusual. Stephen
- 2:43was at home, his sister was there. His dad worked the day shift
- 2:50and so he would get home. Well, i'm sorry, it's the afternoon
- 2:54shift. So he didn't get home until like one o'clock at night, and
- 3:00Stephen was there when his dad got home, and they're talking. When Stephen
- 3:06was in bed, he was actually laying on the couch and he was just
- 3:10on his phone, just like a nineteen year old does or a fifty two
- 3:15year old or scrolling my phone. Suzanne woke up in the morning and it's
- 3:24about six o'clock and when she did, there's no Stephen, according to records,
- 3:32And we got the records for this case. We did a four year
- 3:38request and we got the court transcripts and all the documents for this case.
- 3:46So a lot of what I'm going to tell you is based on actual court
- 3:53records or testimony or evidence. The testimony evidence exactly. So I know that
- 4:00some people dispute some of the information, but this was all from the court.
- 4:06Okay, that's all. We know what we go backs. We're going
- 4:12with the According to records, the last time Stephen had contact with somebody was
- 4:17at two thirty am on I guess it would be the March the eleventh,
- 4:25and he'd facetimed his friend Andrew. Andrew and him were best friends. And
- 4:30then mom wakes up at six am and he's gone. It appeared as if
- 4:36he willingly left the house. But he didn't take any clothes with him,
- 4:41he didn't take any belongings, nothing that demonstrated he's going to be gone.
- 4:46He just wasn't there. So he said, there's records at show. At
- 4:53two thirty, he facetimed his friend Andrew. The next day, his phone
- 5:00was pinged in Detroit, and this is about forty minutes from where they lived.
- 5:08They lived in a suburb of Detroit. You know this, Yes,
- 5:12not in Detroit, right, but his phone pinged in Detroit. And then
- 5:16after that, through the records, we know that it peinged in a place
- 5:20called Strolling Heights, which is where we're located right now. Yes, yeah,
- 5:26I was just gonna say, we're in Sterling Heights, yes, right
- 5:28now. And that was about twenty minutes after that, and then there was
- 5:32just nothing, No, we're pinging nothing. Desperate to find their son because
- 5:42time is going on, Susanne and Michael, they contacted the news and the
- 5:46newspapers ran the story locally and I saw it. I saw ended up doing
- 5:54posters of him missing, and they were really concerned. Is he doubted or
- 6:00alive? And I'll explain why in a little bit. Then they reached out
- 6:05during the news and they were like, please come home, Stephen. Everybody
- 6:11wants to see you, everybody misses you. Please come home again. They
- 6:16reached out to friends. Nobody knows they did crime Stoppers and offered a reward
- 6:23for information on his disappearance. The police ended up becoming so concerned that they
- 6:30interviewed his friends and even acquaintances, and nobody had any information as to where
- 6:39he was. And then the trail went cold. This is a nineteen year
- 6:43old. Yeah, maybe he ran away, maybe he committed suicide. That's
- 6:50where some people were thinking. But I'm gonna tell you a little bit about
- 6:54Steven. In many ways, he was your typical nineteen year old. He
- 7:00was six feet tall, he was thin, he was an attractive young man.
- 7:05He was great at art, and he loved to play the drums.
- 7:11He collected vinyl records, you know people that, oh, my daughter does.
- 7:15And he hung out with his friends, just like a normal nineteen year
- 7:18old. But there are other things that made Stephen different. He was diagnosed
- 7:25at a young age with Asperger's syndrome and bipolar, So he had these mood
- 7:32swings. And as you know, oftentimes when people have are diagnosed with mental
- 7:40illness, compliance is a problem. Right, you have compliance with they're not
- 7:44taking their medication. Yeah, And so sometimes he wouldn't, and when he
- 7:48didn't, he could allegedly become violent. The police were called to Stephen's family's
- 7:59home sometimes when these episodes happened. Allegedly. For example, in twenty fourteen,
- 8:09the police were dispatched to Stephen's house because he was being very aggressive.
- 8:18Now again these are from police reports, and some family members and people might
- 8:28dispute the accuracy of the police reports, but they were called because he was
- 8:33refusing to go to school and he'd got in his dad's face and they were
- 8:39hit. Stephen and his dad were wrestling on the floor. His mom explained
- 8:45to the police that he hadn't taken his medicine and that was why he was
- 8:48acting out. Prior to that, though his mental illness seemed to be somewhat
- 8:54under control, he had been involuntarily committed to a psychiatric ward of a hospital
- 9:03just to get his medicine adjusted. And I don't want to make it look
- 9:11like I am blaming the victim, because I am not. I am just
- 9:13going through some of Stevens past. In twenty fifteen, he was arrested along
- 9:20with a friend named Kyle, for larceny. They had been suspected of breaking
- 9:26into cars, which a lot of kids, a lot of kids do.
- 9:30That just happened in your neighborhood. Right, Oh yeah, absolutely, in
- 9:33my neighborhood, some kids were caught on camera and broke into my husband's truck.
- 9:39And I mean, not that I'm condoning it, but it happens.
- 9:43It happens. It happens teenagers, you know, I fucked up. Yeah,
- 9:48I get it, I get it. I'm not judging it. I'm
- 9:50not judging. I'm not. But yeah, not that it's right, it's
- 9:56definitely, it's definitely, but it happens, it's definitely wrong. It's definitely
- 10:01teenage inks. So on another incident, it was July twenty second, and
- 10:05this is twenty fifteen. Stephen is out with his best friend Andrew, and
- 10:11they're sitting in an Andrew's jeep and the lights are off. They're on the
- 10:15side of the road. They were all dressed in black and they had with
- 10:22medical gloves like rubber gloves. Yeah, okay, yeah, and the police
- 10:28were trying to figure out, like what are you doing and they told the
- 10:30police, We're gonna get some ice cream and say or something in the morning.
- 10:37Yes. I also want to know that his Stephen's best friend Andrew had
- 10:43mental health issues too, which we'll get into. One of them. Was
- 10:50Asperger syndrome, so they both were HM. They both were on the spectrum
- 10:56of eyes and they actually met at a special at a school for children with
- 11:01things with issues in elementary so they'd been friends for ten years and they were
- 11:11very close. They did end up that day getting arrested for larcenia vehicle and
- 11:20when the police looked into the jeep, they discovered that there was a black
- 11:24knife and there were some skulls. I don't know what they weren't human skulls.
- 11:31I don't they weren't human skulls. I don't know what they were.
- 11:33Police ended up releasing Stephen into the costume of his parents and he was forbidden
- 11:39from hanging out with Andrew for a little bit. He stayed with his uncle
- 11:46because his mom thought that his uncle might be a positive influence on him.
- 11:56Now this is disputed. This is again only from the court records that while
- 12:01Stephen was staying with his uncle in New Jersey, he ran away and they
- 12:09found some marijuana pipes and eventually, long story short, Stephen comes back.
- 12:18His uncle ended up personally driving him back to Michigan because he couldn't control Steven.
- 12:28Stephen was not a bad kid, it's just the medicine trying to you
- 12:31know, trying to tweak it, trying to get it the way it's supposed
- 12:35to be. And it's a guessing game when you're dealing with medications sometimes,
- 12:41and I mean I've personally gone through it too, you know what i mean.
- 12:46So, especially with children, how they grow up and go through their
- 12:50teens and all of that. So it's really sad. But in general,
- 12:54he was a very nice kid. When he got back home, he plays
- 13:00stickers all over his mom's mirror, and he threw some coats out and clothing,
- 13:07and he emptied some of her drawers, and he wrote bitch and weed
- 13:11on his mom's wall and pat on the door. But again, he wasn't
- 13:16taking his medicine. These aren't violent, anisis he? Well, he did
- 13:20punch a hole in the wall. Oh okay, I'm sorry, excuse me,
- 13:24and knocked over the television. The police ended up arresting him for that,
- 13:31And it's just very sad for me because the mom and the dad,
- 13:37they tried really hard to help him. According to a police report, Susanne
- 13:46told the police that she had enrolled Stephen in in every in every program she
- 13:52could think of I mean, she did everything to help, and I believe
- 13:56she was a nurse. I could be wrong, but I believe she was
- 13:58a nurse. And he was just out of control, and at one point
- 14:03he said he wanted to fucking die. They take me to the hospital,
- 14:07and he was put in the back of the police car and he was rocking
- 14:11back and forth and shaking, he was screaming, he was hyperventilating. So
- 14:18they ended up calling EMS and he was taken to the hospital, and eventually,
- 14:22of course, they got his medicine tweaked, and there were more incidences
- 14:30of him having outburst when he wasn't on his medicine. And I'm not going
- 14:37to go through all of the things, but there were multiple attempts or threats
- 14:43of suicide. They found fifteen of his pills missing one time, and he
- 14:52was mumbling incoherently, slurring his words on the floor. The MS had to
- 14:58come. He was very agitated and he had to be held down and then
- 15:03he was taken to the hospital. Well, with this background, I mean,
- 15:05I understand now the extreme concern his parents felt when he's missing. When
- 15:11he's missing, absolutely so now Steven's an adult, his parents end up getting
- 15:18awarded guardianship over him. You know how that works. Adult guardianship, adult
- 15:24guardianship, and that gave him more control over Stephen and more avenues that they
- 15:31could see, you know, use to help him. And guardianships are for
- 15:35medical decisions. Yeah. So now we're back to March tenth is less time
- 15:43he's seen. By March thirteenth, his family is just beyond consolable. They
- 15:50know something, something bad has happened. They go to crime stoppers. I
- 15:56told you, they went to the news. They registered Stephen on the name
- 16:02US okay, right, National Registry of I don't know Missing Persons. I
- 16:08don't know. I name it. It's a great place to go if you
- 16:12have someone you love that's missing. And he was put there. There was
- 16:18a reward. They had a go fundme page. They did everything, and
- 16:22they put out thousands of missing Persons posters. I saw them in stores,
- 16:30grocery stores, everywhere. And that's why this this case really touched me.
- 16:37They did everything they could do, but I said it grew cold, and
- 16:45it wasn't until thirteen months after he was gone that they got their first The
- 16:52police got their first tip thirteen months. Thirteen months, agonizing, agonizing,
- 17:00everybody who knew him and loved him, because I can't even imagine as a
- 17:03parent. You remember me talking about Oh, yes, yeah, I remember
- 17:08this case. Yeah. It was a tip from an eighteen year old girl
- 17:14named Ceci. She was a young woman and she'd been talking to get to
- 17:19follow me. There's Cec. She's talking to her friend, a VET,
- 17:25and an a VET confided in her that she knew Stephen was dead. Oh
- 17:33boy, and where he was and how he got there. Let me tell
- 17:41you a little bit about a vet. At the time of Stephen's disappearance,
- 17:45she was seventeen years old. She was a tenth grader. She did online
- 17:51high school classes, and she lived with her boyfriend at her parents' house.
- 17:57Her boyfriend was Andrew, Stephen's best friend. She met Stephen maybe ten times
- 18:07through her boyfriend Andrew. So Cec goes to the police and I'll tell you
- 18:15what Cec I mean says she has some more details, but it was actually
- 18:21Cec talked to a VET and then Cec told her dad, and her dad
- 18:27made her go with him to the police. And this is a very disturbing.
- 18:37Yay, let me give you some background more on a vet. She'd
- 18:42been dating Andrew for two years. He seemed very jealous of Stephen, and
- 18:51on multiple occasions he would accuse a Vet of sleeping with Stephen, which was
- 18:57completely unfounded. I mean not even mildly accurate. Andrew became very jealous.
- 19:06One time, he even drove to a Vett's house. Wait, scratch that,
- 19:11he drove to Steven's parents' house and he made a Vet go up to
- 19:17the door and ask some of Stephen's family members if they recognognized a vet.
- 19:23Are you kidding? He wanted to see if a vet had been there.
- 19:27It's like if there's a secretly something, secretly something going on. Yeah,
- 19:33like she's going to Stephen's house and hanging out and and I don't know exactly
- 19:37how the family reacted, but I know the answer was no, we don't
- 19:41know who a Vet is. So on the night of March tenth, that's
- 19:48the last time Stephen seen Andrew and Vett. Andrew and Novette got into a
- 19:55fight over two things. One was about whether a Vet sleeping with Stephen again,
- 20:00this is an argument, And the other was about her going on this
- 20:04vacation to Florida to visit a friend because he's getting controlling right. That stated
- 20:15she went to bed about nine o'clock. She seems awfully early for a teenager.
- 20:22And when she went to bed, Andrew was laying beside her. She
- 20:26woke up at three am and there's no way Andrew, It's like hmm.
- 20:33She went back to sleep. When she woke up in the morning, Andrew
- 20:37was back at the house. She asked him where were you? Where were
- 20:42you at at three in the morning? Like, this is weird, right,
- 20:47and he told her that he picked up Stephen and they hung out of
- 20:49the gas station and then he dropped Stephen off back at Stephen's house and then
- 20:55he came home. And then that next day event that went to Florida.
- 21:03When she was when she got back that she learned that Stephen was missing.
- 21:07It was there was a conversation maybe a week or two after that got back.
- 21:14Andrew asked that how would you feel if Stephen was dead? What the
- 21:21fuck? I know? That's what is that supposed to do? What the
- 21:25does that mean? Right? Great? Yeah, yeah, I'd be so
- 21:27happy. No, why what kind of answer is? She's like, what
- 21:32are you asking me this for? Why? Why would you ask me that?
- 21:36He told Andrew told her that he was a tech guy for the mafia.
- 21:45That Andrew was the tech guy from the for the mafia. He worked
- 21:48for the mafia mafia. He helped them with computers, surveillance, technical things,
- 21:53and you guys do that funny face. And he's nineteen, okay,
- 22:00And that Stephen saw things on the computer that he shouldn't have seen, and
- 22:07Andrew was ordered to kill him by the mafia. Okay, of that,
- 22:15I mean, she's late. Are you for real? Are you for real?
- 22:18Come on? Come on. He told her that on March tenth,
- 22:25Stephen face timed him, which we know is true, and that the last
- 22:30time was three seventeen am, when Stephen asked him to come pick him up
- 22:37at around three point thirty so they could check out a place called Nancy's Grave.
- 22:41Let me tell you a little bit about Nancy's Grave. You have to
- 22:45understand this area. It's rural, you know, yep, I've lived there.
- 22:52And Nancy's Grave is this area in the woods that's considered haunted. There's
- 23:00not actually a grave there, it's just called Nancy's Grave. And so you
- 23:08have Andrew telling a vet that they went to Nancy's Great Yeah, and so
- 23:15it's out in the country and then you have to go through the woods to
- 23:22this area. And teens went their urban legend whatever Nancy's great it's not that
- 23:29far from Andrew's home. It's maybe five miles because he lived out in the
- 23:36country. When they went there, that's when Andrew found this opportunity to kill
- 23:44his best friend. Apparently, Andrew parked his car and it's suggested to Stephen
- 23:56leave your vape and yourself phone in the car, and Stephen did. Steven
- 24:04didn't know that Andrew had a twenty two caliber gun with a Russian revolver and
- 24:12a whole oyster Ulster Holster holster. And they began walking through this wooded field.
- 24:23They're looking for Nancy's great There is no Nancy's great ry, but they're
- 24:27looking. It's about they're about two hundred yards in or so, and it's
- 24:34about a ten minute walk because it's dark. We're talking the middle of the
- 24:37night. You're walking through the woods. I mean, it's just about ten
- 24:45minutes and they're walking and then Andrew ends up stating that he shot Stephen once
- 24:52in the stomach and twice in the back. That's his best friend, I
- 24:59know, for no reason, like no reason no reason. They don't understand
- 25:03he's jealous. Yeah, a vet didn't believe him because number one, the
- 25:08mafia story is it's stupid. It's stupid, it's ridiculous. And then she
- 25:14didn't think Andrew was capable of killing anybody and their best friend, right like,
- 25:19this is your best friend, this is your best friend. Andrew told
- 25:25a that I can prove to you this is true. So it's may It's
- 25:32less than two months after Stephen disappeared, and Andrew drove yvet to the location
- 25:37out in the country, and according to a vet, Andrew had his brother's
- 25:44gun in his hand and he forced her to walk with him into the woods.
- 25:49She said it took about ten to fifteen minutes and then laying on his
- 25:56back was the decomposing body of Stephen. And she described it as a grizzly
- 26:04site. This is going to be graphic. His jaw was missing and his
- 26:11skin had turned black. They looked at the body for a little while and
- 26:17then they left the woods. But that wasn't the last time they went and
- 26:23saw Steven's body. In fact, what happens only gets worse, only gets
- 26:33more and more. It's it's horrible, it's it's it's it's her parents.
- 26:38It's shitty. About a month after the first time of that one out there,
- 26:44they went back to the woods where Steven's body laid, only this time
- 26:48they brought with them a duffel bag and an axe. But it's one of
- 26:53the acts that have like what is it a pick axe? Like there's a
- 26:57okay, like a sharp end. Get the pick at the one end.
- 27:02Why would you bring that? Well, seriously that I'll tell you why,
- 27:07Okay, Larry, I mean, it's not funny, but I'm gonna tell
- 27:12you why. He wanted. Andrew wanted to be able to move Stephen's body,
- 27:21but he knew it was still too heavy, so it was easier to
- 27:27do it if the body was in pieces, so dismembered him with a pick
- 27:32axe. Well, he wanted to cut it in two. So it's an
- 27:36axe. Yeah, there's one end. That's the axe. But first he
- 27:41took Stevens watch off his wrist and he kept it for himself, like a
- 27:47souvenir, right, a souvenir. Andrew gave the acts to a vet and
- 27:53he tells her to swing at Steven's helvic region she misses. I'm sure she's
- 28:03all shades fucked off right right? What the hell? I mean, what's
- 28:10going through your mind? Standing there? I would just be I need their
- 28:14place, I needed what I needed to pay out of here, and I've
- 28:15never seen my boyfriend again exactly. So she misses, and it takes her
- 28:26a couple of times. She misses. Andrew takes the axe from her and
- 28:30he swings it about ten times. Now the body is in two pieces.
- 28:37He grabs Steven's out loop out loop, and a that grabs Stephen's pant leg
- 28:44and they place his the lower half of his body in the Duffel bag.
- 28:48Okay, that says. She remembers seeing Stephen's skull in the Duffel bag,
- 28:56but she doesn't remember seeing Andrew chop it off. Okay, but he did,
- 29:04Okay. Andrew also threw in a few loose bones because time had gone
- 29:11by, into the bag, and he did break down for a minute.
- 29:17He was telling a that this is my best friend. I can't do this,
- 29:22I can't do this, and to a Vet he seemed generally sad.
- 29:27But it didn't stand. He still did it. He still did it.
- 29:33They ended up carrying the Duffel bag and placed it into Andrew's trunk. And
- 29:37now remember this is about a ten minute walk. The whole process, according
- 29:42to a VET, took about forty five minutes. Okay. And then the
- 29:47couple take this stuffle bag with the body out of Andrew's car and they ended
- 29:53up putting it into the trunk of a vet's car because a VET did didn't
- 30:00have a license or a license plate, so they weren't able to drive her
- 30:03car. They had wait, hold on, sorry, because if I didn't
- 30:15have a license or license, but they weren't able to drive a car,
- 30:21let's scratch that. Okay, the we're gonna go back to the whole process
- 30:27took about forty five minutes. They put the devil bag into the trunk of
- 30:32a car, and they end up realizing, Okay, this is a really
- 30:37bad idea to keep a body in the trunk of a car. You think,
- 30:44you think, and it's been but it ends up being in the trunk
- 30:48for a couple of days. What, Yeah, a couple of days.
- 30:53They don't do They don't know what to do. They don't know what to
- 30:57do. Oh my god, why they put him in the bag in the
- 31:00first place. I mean maybe they were afraid. I think I had here.
- 31:06You thought I had enough to bring a bag put him in, right,
- 31:08But Jesus, oh my god. They went back to Andrew's house and
- 31:17there when a that was there. There was Stephen's vape and also the watch
- 31:23he had taken a month early, and an alarm would go off once a
- 31:27day. And Andrew had said it for the time that Stephen died. Oh
- 31:33geez, are you kidding me? The couple went back to the scene for
- 31:38the third time, but this time a vet says she stayed in the car.
- 31:42And Andrew went to the rest of the body, because I didn't take
- 31:45all the bodies. Remember, God, they didn't take Oh my god,
- 31:48they remember part of him. Yes, because it's a double bay. It
- 31:56was a month or two when a vet's trunk, because they put an event
- 32:00a vet's trunk. She was when they got it back home. Yes,
- 32:06she wasn't. Yeah, she wasn't driving. Her car didn't have a license
- 32:10plate. So they noticed the smell. And Andrew and a Vet weren't getting
- 32:16along. Oh no, he kicked her out of the house. That's but
- 32:22if that wasn't gonna leave with his body in her trunk? Uh uh?
- 32:28So that and Andrew decided it was time to bury part of Stephen's lower Torso
- 32:37they went to home depot. They bought a bucket and they bought some quick
- 32:45drives. Meant that is, I guess cementing. Yeah, you make it
- 32:51and yeah. During the day, while Andrew's parents were working, Andrew decided
- 32:58to bury parts of Stephen's body and his parents' backyard. Oh my god,
- 33:02this house is out in the country, so there's not any close neighbors by,
- 33:09and it has a very long front yard with a kind of a long
- 33:15driveway, and so it's a brick house. It's actually four acres of land,
- 33:22so they have four they have four acres of land. And I know
- 33:24because everything else I live while I live right down the road. Don't forget
- 33:31that. Andrew Grahams shovels and together with a vet, they lowered They took
- 33:39Stephen's lower body and they put it into a children's wagon like the little the
- 33:45little the writer. The writer, Yes, like the little red wagon.
- 33:51And a vet was crying as they're digging this hole. She says that Andrew
- 33:57made her do it. And I mean, I'm going to give her the
- 34:00doubt because I really don't see why she would want to be any of that.
- 34:06Yeah, she's, yeah, she's she's kind of stuck. Now.
- 34:10They opened up the Duffel bag and rolled out part of Stephen into the hole,
- 34:15and then they poured cement on it and they covered it with dirt.
- 34:22Stephen's skull. They filled it with cements. Oh why? And then they
- 34:29buried it in a different area of the property along the fence line. This
- 34:35is so horrible. It's I feel bad for Stephen's family, and I feel
- 34:42bad for Andrews. I mean, what the what the hell? I know,
- 34:47like Andrews started a fire and they ended up throwing the duffel bag and
- 34:53some of the gloves they used into this fire. And it wasn't long after
- 34:59that that the couple broke up. Wasn't good for their relationship, A murder
- 35:04probably would? Do we have a little bit of a strain on someone's relationship,
- 35:07good lord? Yeah, And if you can do that to your best
- 35:12friend, I know, what could you do to me? Exactly? So
- 35:15they broke up. She didn't go to the police because she was afraid of
- 35:20Andrew and he'd taken her ID and he threatened to frame her for the murder.
- 35:25I mean, I sort of can't blame her. I mean, what
- 35:28is she like, seventeen eighteen years old? Yeah, plus part of her
- 35:31started to believe he might actually be part of the mafia. At first it
- 35:36seems stupid, but then I guess it's things happen. You start and you
- 35:39hear it enough you start to believe. It was only when she ended up
- 35:45telling CC that his body, Stephen's body was found. That had been interviewed
- 35:54before, because remember I told you the police interviewed acquaintances friends. And Andrew
- 36:00had been interviewed many times. That's his best friend. So of course they're
- 36:04gonna they're gonna interview Andrew. But nothing, you know, nothing led them
- 36:10to actually believe that Andrew would do it. After they broke up, Andrew
- 36:16would send a vet threats reminding her about the mafia. She ended up blocking
- 36:23him on her social media, which is a big deal when you're blacked,
- 36:29when you're ghosted. That made him very unhappy. So now she's went forward.
- 36:34She's told cec Cecy's told her dad. His dad, her dad brought
- 36:39him her to the police. We're at April twenty seventh of twenty sixteen,
- 36:45so it's been it's been thirty. It's been like thirteen months. Yeah,
- 36:53that is when the police first arrested him. He'd spoken with them before,
- 37:02said I know nothing about it. But they ended up issuing the warrant for
- 37:07his arrest and they picked him up by at four am. And at that
- 37:10point he was at a rehab center because Andrew was having psychiatric problems too.
- 37:17It's really important to understand Andrew's background to really get an idea of how he
- 37:25got to the point we're at. Andrew parched. Andrew was put into foster
- 37:37care at the age of twenty two months. Twenty two months months, okay.
- 37:42It was a result of abuse and neglected by his biological mother. His
- 37:47mother already had an older son that had been taken away and adopted through the
- 37:52foster care system. The state reached out to Andrew's biological brother, and because
- 38:01he'd been adopted, they reached out to his adoptive parents and they agreed to
- 38:07take Andrew too. So now you have these two brothers that are being raised
- 38:14by the same adoptive parents. And his mother was a special education teacher assistant,
- 38:22so she was perfect for him because, as you know, he had,
- 38:27he had a lot of issues. I mean, he was abused,
- 38:29neglected, and has Aspergers. He attended regular elementary school, but then he
- 38:36took classes at the learning centers called and that's where he met Steven. So
- 38:42they put them in regular school, but they also sent them away a couple
- 38:46hours a day to this learning center, and that's when they met. Andrew
- 38:52was a lot like Stephen, as they said. They both had Aspergers.
- 38:57Andrew had fetal alcohol syndrome, and he'd been h He'd been institutionalized seven or
- 39:05eight times for psychiatric reasons. Throughout his childhood and teens. He attended therapy
- 39:13sessions, I mean his just like Steven's parents. They did everything they could
- 39:19to try to get give their kids the best life they could give with the
- 39:23issues that were going on with them. Every opportunity to help these boys was
- 39:32given. They end up the So Steven gets arrested. I'm sorry, Andrew
- 39:39gets arrested. They do a search warrant and that's when they find Steven's watch.
- 39:45It was on this at that point. It was on the center council
- 39:47of Andrew's car. Why, I don't know why why were reminded of I
- 39:58don't know, I don't know. You got no Nope, I have nothing
- 40:01about that one. That's a weird. Why would you want to be reminded
- 40:05of what you did? That's what i'm That's what I mean, Like like
- 40:09serial killers and stuff. Okay, fine, they get off on it or
- 40:12whatever whatever with the with their souvenirs and stuff. But I'm I don't think
- 40:15that's the case here. I don't like, maybe maybe he wanted to remind
- 40:21himself because he he did, you have what he did, like like I'm
- 40:24such a bad person kind of like you know how sometimes you do that to
- 40:27yourself, like you torture yourself over the bad things you've done. I mean,
- 40:30this is really bad. But I mean, like maybe I don't know.
- 40:35That's that's my armchair psychology. I don't know. That's the only thing
- 40:39I don't think of. I don't know. Uh. So police and uh
- 40:45finding the gun that was used to kill Stephen in Andrew's brother's room. He
- 40:52had put it there, not not Andrew's brother, Andrew. I'd put it
- 40:58there, right, I got it. They searched the property and he ends
- 41:04up showing them where the different body parts are. They found Stephen's lowered torso
- 41:12with his legs on the border of the family's for acre property. They had
- 41:16to break through that thin layer of cement. He had his jeans on and
- 41:22there was a key chain with a key on it in his pocket and his
- 41:28wallet was there. They found Stephen's skull behind the garage. It's not an
- 41:37attached garage like a carriage house, old barn or something. It was in
- 41:44case in cement and buried along with some of the other bones. It was
- 41:57in case and cemented, buried along with some other bones that were connected to
- 42:02this skull, so the spinal yeah, and some ribs. There were some
- 42:09ribs. To this day, it hasn't been explained how his head was completely
- 42:15separated from his body, because he didn't explain it and a vet set.
- 42:20She didn't see him actually do that. His upper torso, including his vertebrae,
- 42:25and some of his ribs and arms were found at Nancy's grave, so
- 42:30they had whenever he never moved, no, so that was one of the
- 42:34things is they had left. His body was scattered in different spots. It
- 42:38is anyway of that said, she doesn't really know how. Her mind can't
- 42:50remember every detail, but she did point out when she was with the police
- 42:55that there was an axe hanging in that bulbarn, and that was the one
- 43:00that they had used to you, Yeah, and then the little red rider
- 43:07wagon. So this is what an autopsy determined. It's different than what Andrew
- 43:16had said to a vet. Stephen was shot in the face at close range,
- 43:22through the eye, yeah, and then the back of the head.
- 43:29Both wounds would have caused instant death. Death. Both they never I'm sorry,
- 43:40I make mistakes. Sometimes they could never determine if he was actually shot
- 43:45in the stomach because of decomposite decomposition, thank you. And as I said,
- 43:52warrant was in Andrew's rust. He picked him up. In the rehab,
- 43:55he ended up confessing to the crime, and we have some of that
- 43:59confess that we can play for you guys. It's very sad. It's over
- 44:07an hour long, so there's no way to play at all. But his
- 44:12confession is different than what a vet had said. He said that Stephen face
- 44:20timed him to get some weed, that's why he picked him up, and
- 44:23that he went to the woods to sell some weed. That he was afraid
- 44:29of Stephen because of his mood swings. Okay, there was a scuffle and
- 44:36so he shot him in the stomach, and then he did the last two
- 44:39shots to make sure his best friend was dead. Police believe there was a
- 44:47scuffle, but they believe it was Stephen realizing that Andrew was pulling out a
- 44:55gun, and he tried to protect himself. I mean it was dark.
- 45:00I don't know everything. But after the murder, Andrew did drive around for
- 45:06a while, which is why Stephen's phone, if you remember, was pained
- 45:10in Detroit, and then it was pained in Sterling Heights. Eventually he ended
- 45:15up throwing it in the dumps in a dumpster. In his confession, he
- 45:21makes no mention of wanting to visit Nancy's grave, only that they were gonna
- 45:24sell Pat. Like, why are you selling Pat to your best friend at
- 45:30three in the morning at Nancy's grave. Yeah, here's a little snippet of
- 45:35his confession. So I try, I thought I thought it was I can't
- 45:52leave him here, but I don't know what else I can't move? Why
- 46:00about myself? And so me and her woman and we cut from the lace,
- 46:08trust me, that o her. She she swung at it with the
- 46:14hats she got at And yeah, I couldn't. I couldn't do it.
- 46:22Ill, why would she do it because I couldn't do it? What was
- 46:29hers when she she's wanted to help? Are you going? So? Yeah,
- 46:38that's the such flies living in the trump in the worst of my house.
- 46:47And then we moved them over to her trump and that's where they saved.
- 46:52Tont myself lived in that yard. It was so you heard of the
- 46:59time? Okay, did you just throw the trust? You put the lads
- 47:05in the in the b and then we're kind of back hockey okay. And
- 47:14then he said at one point he had her her for a while and then
- 47:17he said the mast where she said down in your house? What what do
- 47:25you? What are you were initially there? Let's beat a little bit now,
- 47:30But where you went to get the lower strmies like that? What is
- 47:34that happened? What took those guys all went into the woods? Okay?
- 47:37How did you? How did you? How did you do it? He
- 47:39said? He went back by off the black and then what happened from there?
- 47:47She said, saying okay, and it completely s his his legs or
- 47:55so she had how many? How many fists that she's wanted a couple in
- 48:01both of his lace No, so his baselines were shipped. Okay, and
- 48:08then completely separated is over from the summer. And then then where he said,
- 48:15we have shipping back? How that go out? Where did you use
- 48:19for cover? Expensive the bag? I asked, I used to ask to
- 48:24put it around his belt and lifted up the top cheer around the head and
- 48:30the flags and put it in the back. You be sure you can't have
- 48:38nothing to do with the child because I can't release sho I straw it up
- 48:43or shot up to be read at it and did not. Okay, So
- 48:47so sifted up and google carried it back the baggers chick hands like, there's
- 48:54a long shot. I have the one set shot. And then where where
- 49:00did you place to the trunk of your of your future? So then you
- 49:06got to also how did you got to have transfer this into her car?
- 49:10Why did why did you do that? Most your license? Your car was
- 49:15just staying there. And he's like, okay, so we see here in
- 49:17here since it's not anywhere and I have my car every yet, okay,
- 49:22all right? And did you did you have plays on very at your house
- 49:29during time? What were your thoughts? We're gonna do what you said the
- 49:34boy to strutting your house, and what was your thought bosses were over there.
- 49:39Did you get the intention of bringing his body back to your house and
- 49:46you have something that could Yeah, I didn't want to. Just why did
- 49:51you deserve the chop? Why? Why didn't you decide this a whole lot?
- 49:55I figured you can't move all bout okay. A trial was held eventually,
- 50:01and a that testified against Andrew. Andrew's defense tried to claim diminished capacity,
- 50:10but in Michigan it's not allowed as a defense. They were still trying
- 50:16to argue that, and they were trying to argue self defense because he's claiming
- 50:22that he was afraid of Stephen, even though Stephen wasn't armed. I was
- 50:28gonna say, and if you have a self defense, if that's your defense,
- 50:31you have to be threatened with some yeah, saying that when your life
- 50:37is yeah, life's danger and Stephen's unarmed, and I mean Andrew has the
- 50:45gun, so really that self defense doesn't hold water with me. Well,
- 50:51in the end, he was not found guilty of premeditative murder. He was
- 50:55found guilty of second degree murder, and he was sentenced two a minimum of
- 51:00fifty two years in prison, which so you know, so you know,
- 51:05was beyond the sentencing guidelines. Oh it was it was wow. The judge
- 51:10whom we know stated, quote, you destroyed not only Stephen's life, his
- 51:15family and friends. You destroyed your family's life as well as your own.
- 51:22And the judge said, for thirteen months you let everyone wallow in fear and
- 51:30in distress, and that there was hope that he might be Well, that's
- 51:34the worst part of it. Even after they found Stephen, you still showed
- 51:37no remorse for killing your friend. And didn't he post like on social media
- 51:43and stuff like ye, I miss you so much, Oh where is my
- 51:46friend? Right? We helped distribute posters for his friend. At sentencing Andrew
- 51:54spoke. He was crying and he said, I have nightmares. I take
- 52:00responsibilities Stephen was. I miss him so much. I'm just so sorry,
- 52:07such a waste, such a senseless crime. Yeah, it's just so sad.
- 52:13Well, that ended up doing well for herself, and she went to
- 52:19college and I believe she got probation or something like that, and she ended
- 52:28up recovering from this and making something of her life. Last I knew when
- 52:32I looked her up. But the pain that the family, both families feel
- 52:39is so strong still in this local area, and it's just so shocking that
- 52:47it still affects me right now. This is a terrible story. I do
- 52:51remember when it happened as well, but just for thirteen months, they didn't
- 52:55know where I was at. And the whole time his best friend, I
- 53:05know, knew his body was out there. I mean, like I said,
- 53:13maybe he his parents, maybe he just wanted to be reminded of what
- 53:16he did. I don't know, but I know there. I mean I
- 53:21feel bad for everyone. Yeah, this is this is just so like I
- 53:23said, it's just senseless and it makes it's not that you know, crimes,
- 53:29A lot of crimes have a reason why people do crazy stuff, right,
- 53:32I mean, this was this is just nothing like just because I don't
- 53:37know, like how terrible and the betrayal Stephen had to have felt the last
- 53:43minute of his life, right, it's terrible anyway. Anyway, Well,
- 53:47thanks to Lea. You're welcome for that one, and thank you everyone for
- 53:52watching. We appreciate you guys watching and listening. And again I'm Tlea and
- 54:00I'm Tanya Lovely co host. If you guys wanna you're more, we have
- 54:05a Patreon It's called Patriot. You go to Patreon dot com, slash t
- 54:08and T crimes, and you can get audio. We have what how many
- 54:14one billion, two billion? Yeah, there's about two billion extra episodes,
- 54:17extra episodes and they're all commercial free. Plus you get episodes like this early
- 54:24release with no commercials and lots of amazing things. Yeah, we have a
- 54:32Facebook group, so check it out. Yeah, you get to be part
- 54:36of the Facebook group. We also you can subscribe through Apple to our podcasts
- 54:40and get the same ad free early releases and unreleased to the public episodes.
- 54:49We have a website, Crimesconsequences dot com. We have some good merchandise.
- 54:52H. One says I hate people. Yeah, that's my favorite. One
- 54:55says dead inside h. There's just all kinds of check it out, shut
- 55:04it out. Just check it out on our website. Check it out.
- 55:06You're so cute. Thank you again for listening. Again, don't write some
- 55:13nancy comments because we will get back to you on that. You know it
- 55:16happens. Comment on the commenters coming on people love it. But whatever,
- 55:21whatever, it's not going to stop us from doing our podcast. No,
- 55:23so keep on keeping on with that. But for all you guys that have
- 55:28posted really nice comments, we want to thank you for taking the time to
- 55:34help us out and for any new people, thank you for checking us out
- 55:37and giving us a chance. We appreciate it. Yeah, we love you
- 55:38guys until our next episode, don't kill each other. Bye,