Latest / Pop Culture Junkie® / PCJ Book Club: 'Sunrise on the Reaping' by Suzanne Collins
Transcript
- 0:00♪ Entertain me, entertain me right now ♪
- 0:03Welcome to the Pop Culture Junkie podcast.
- 0:06I'm Olivia and I'm here with Shauna.
- 0:10And we are so excited to go into the world of Pan M today
- 0:15with another episode of our Pop Culture Junkie Book Club.
- 0:19This time we're gonna be looking at sunrise
- 0:21on the reaping by Suzanne Collins,
- 0:23which came out in the last month or so.
- 0:27And before we really had deep into the book
- 0:32of sunrise on the reaping itself,
- 0:35we wanna do a little bit of a spoiler-free discussion
- 0:39of the Hunger Games world in general.
- 0:41What we knew kind of heading into this book,
- 0:45things that we were kind of thinking and knew
- 0:47about Hamich Abernathy who is--
- 0:50- That he was hot.
- 0:51- Yeah, well, Woody Harrelson's hot.
- 0:53So, you know. - Yeah.
- 0:54- In my head then, Hamich is hot.
- 0:57- Not a little rascal.
- 0:58- Yes, exactly.
- 0:59And so before we dive into our spoiler version
- 1:03of sunrise on the reaping,
- 1:05if you haven't heard yet,
- 1:06here's really kind of a quick rundown of the book.
- 1:10The Hunger Games prequel centers on Hamich,
- 1:13who you will probably know as Katniss's mentor.
- 1:16It's focused on the 50th Hunger Games,
- 1:19which is also known as the second quarter quell.
- 1:23If that sounds familiar to you,
- 1:25it's actually the reaping where they put in
- 1:29double the amount of contestants or tributes.
- 1:33So rather than 24 people going in from the districts,
- 1:37they actually had 48.
- 1:39- Do we know what they did in the first quarter quell?
- 1:42Because for Katniss's quarter quell,
- 1:44they reaped from the pool of existing victors.
- 1:49And then yeah, Hamich's was double the tributes.
- 1:51I wonder what they did for the first one.
- 1:54- So the first quarter quell was the Hunger Games
- 1:58where they made the districts of vote
- 2:01who would go into the reaping.
- 2:04- Oh, that's a mess.
- 2:05- Can you imagine winning the Hunger Games
- 2:08and then coming back and be like,
- 2:09"Oh, have you voted me yet?"
- 2:11- Yeah, so you all hate me is what you're saying.
- 2:14So you hate me.
- 2:16Stacy, I saw you vote for me.
- 2:18I saw you fucking vote for me, bitch.
- 2:20- Exactly.
- 2:21- Yeah, so the first quarter quell,
- 2:23you had to vote in people from your district.
- 2:26The second was Hamich's.
- 2:28It was double the tributes
- 2:30and then the last Hunger Games of the Hunger Games
- 2:34is the 75th quarter quell.
- 2:35And that is reaping of tributes.
- 2:39And so they do them every 25 years
- 2:42and they're meant to be audacious
- 2:44over consumption of a Hunger Games.
- 2:48- Yeah, the over the top.
- 2:49Even more fancy and ridiculous
- 2:51than the usual Hunger Games,
- 2:53which is always ridiculous and over the top
- 2:55and lots of children dying.
- 2:57- Yeah, trigger warning for children dying.
- 3:00- Yeah, lots of trigger warnings.
- 3:01Just war, you know, hunger, all the things
- 3:05that you can imagine, of course, kids dying.
- 3:09And, you know, the Hunger Games takes place
- 3:11in this dystopian future.
- 3:13It's in a place called Pan M,
- 3:16which is the ruins of North America
- 3:19after like a governmental collapse and war.
- 3:22So Pan M is kind of,
- 3:26the districts are set up into these 12 colonies,
- 3:29formerly 13.
- 3:32So kind of think back to when the United States
- 3:34first started, we had the 13 colonies
- 3:37and those things.
- 3:37So it's a bit of a nod back to that.
- 3:40But the Hunger Games is--
- 3:42- It reminds me kind of like handmade stale
- 3:44where it used to be the United States,
- 3:46but now it's gillian, gillian.
- 3:47- Gillian, yeah.
- 3:49- And so yeah, like imagine the United States,
- 3:50but yeah, it's broken up into 12.
- 3:52I saw a map the other day on social media
- 3:55that was like what the districts actually are
- 3:58like what they're broken up into,
- 4:00but I'm not sure how accurate it was,
- 4:02but it was interesting to see it.
- 4:03- So it is, it actually came out of a promo
- 4:08for the Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes movie.
- 4:11Is where there-- - Oh, so it was a legit one.
- 4:13- Yeah, so it's from the movie specifically.
- 4:16And actually, if you just Google like Pan M,
- 4:19US overlay, like map, you'll be able to see like,
- 4:24District 10 is mainly Texas, like Arizona.
- 4:27- Where way in Arizona?
- 4:29- Arizona in New Mexico are District 5, California is
- 4:33District 4, the District 12, which are where Hamage
- 4:38and Katniss are from is known as Appalachia.
- 4:42And ultimately, it is--
- 4:44- Mountains and trees and forests.
- 4:47- Very much that.
- 4:48And Pan M is like a futuristic America
- 4:53and they've kind of broken it into this,
- 4:57but really the Hunger Games gets started
- 5:00after what's known as the Dark Days.
- 5:02They ultimately reap these young girls and young boys
- 5:07to kind of put a remembrance of why
- 5:12that they shouldn't rebel against the Capitol.
- 5:15- Yeah, it's--
- 5:16- It's their ongoing punishment year after year.
- 5:19And if you rise up again, then it's just gonna get worse.
- 5:22It's toe the line.
- 5:23(laughs)
- 5:24- Yeah, absolutely.
- 5:25And we get introduced really into the Hunger Games world
- 5:29during the 74th Hunger Games with Katniss and PETA.
- 5:34But really, it was such an interesting way to go back
- 5:38and really see these characters 25 years in the future
- 5:41and how these people started
- 5:44and how they got there ultimately.
- 5:46- Yeah, I liked that portion of the book.
- 5:48I'm sure that we'll get to it a little deeper
- 5:50in our conversation, but I remember texting you
- 5:53because you finished it before me, of course.
- 5:55Shocker, of course you did.
- 5:56Shocked, but I was like, I don't know how I feel
- 5:59about all of these characters.
- 6:02It kind of just felt like member berries.
- 6:04Like, oh, that character is here.
- 6:06Oh, yeah, that character is here.
- 6:07But by the end of the book, I was like, okay,
- 6:10I get it and I like that.
- 6:11And it explains why they are the way that they are
- 6:13when we run into the Katniss' books.
- 6:16Oh, that's why she's like this now
- 6:18and that explains her backstory.
- 6:20So yeah, I agree, it was interesting.
- 6:22- If you haven't finished the book yet,
- 6:24or you haven't started it yet,
- 6:25hopefully we can kind of convince you
- 6:27to read the book from our spoiler free version
- 6:30here, familiar names, but not overwhelming.
- 6:33- Yes, yes, exactly.
- 6:35And I think that the Hunger Games has,
- 6:38I mean, when I was younger,
- 6:39I, I think I was in high school
- 6:41when the original books came out
- 6:43and it hit me at such a point in my life.
- 6:47Like, the Hunger Games are a YA novel.
- 6:49They're very dark YA novel, ultimately.
- 6:51- Yeah, they are.
- 6:52- Because, you know, children are getting murdered,
- 6:54but it has such an important message.
- 6:58And so, Suzanne Collins, the writer of the Hunger Games,
- 7:02she's known in kind of the book talk world
- 7:05and just overall social media world
- 7:07as Suzanne Collins does not write a book
- 7:10unless she has something to say.
- 7:12And I think that is.
- 7:13- Absolutely, yep.
- 7:14- And it's very profound.
- 7:16- It's in a coincidence.
- 7:17- Yeah, that this book came out in the time
- 7:20that it did and what we're facing in the United States.
- 7:23There are so many little nods where it's not overt,
- 7:28but if you know, you know.
- 7:30- Yeah, absolutely.
- 7:31And, you know, when she first wrote the initial book,
- 7:35she's been quoted to say,
- 7:37you know, I was channel surfing
- 7:39between reality TV and an actual war coverage
- 7:43when Katna's story came to me.
- 7:46One night I was sitting around
- 7:47just flipping channels of young people competing for money.
- 7:50I don't know, maybe.
- 7:51And onto the next, there was a group of young people
- 7:53fighting in an actual war.
- 7:55And I was tired.
- 7:56- Yeah.
- 7:56- And the lines began to blur in this very unsealing way.
- 7:59And I thought of this story.
- 8:02- That's fascinating.
- 8:03I mean, you think about how you watch the war,
- 8:05you watch one tragedy, you all get sad.
- 8:07And then it's, okay, we forget about that
- 8:09and move on right to the next one.
- 8:11And then that fast tragedy becomes a distant memory
- 8:13and how it just kind of becomes, I don't know,
- 8:16oversaturated of this 24/7 news cycle.
- 8:19Let's all watch the news all night and just get sad
- 8:22and riled up and then not do anything about it
- 8:25where tragedy can become entertainment, absolutely.
- 8:28- Well, the Vietnam War was the first war
- 8:30that we ever had brought into our homes, right?
- 8:33But I think of the Iraq War as, you know,
- 8:36just constant coverage where people could tune into it
- 8:39at any given time and it was always there.
- 8:41And so it was really, really interesting.
- 8:43She had a father who served in Vietnam
- 8:45so she kind of had that background in it.
- 8:47But the original trilogy was inspired by Greek mythology
- 8:52and particularly the myth of theses and the Minotaur
- 8:57in which Athens was forced to sacrifice seven boys
- 9:00and seven girls to the Minotaur as punishment,
- 9:04which is a very clear parallel there and bringing that in.
- 9:08- I feel like a lot of mythologies have that sacrifice
- 9:12your youth to God.
- 9:13It's like even God commanded Abraham to sacrifice his son,
- 9:19Isaac, to prove his loyalty to him and in the end,
- 9:22God pulled a, "Gachah, oh, you were gonna do it,
- 9:25"she'll, you don't have to anymore."
- 9:26But like, definitely a running theme
- 9:30throughout a religion of mythology.
- 9:32- Yes, ultimately, and we've been retelling
- 9:36Greek mythology stories, stories of religion
- 9:38over and over throughout it and just finding new ways
- 9:42to resonate with it.
- 9:43Now, after the initial Hunger Games trilogy,
- 9:47I think that Suzanne Collins was like perfect.
- 9:49I wrote my little story, everything's gonna go well
- 9:52in the world.
- 9:52But as we mentioned earlier, Suzanne Collins
- 9:56really doesn't write anything by mistake.
- 9:59And I think that we first saw that she really had
- 10:02something to say with the ballad of songbirds and snakes.
- 10:06- Oh, gosh, which I still haven't read.
- 10:08- Yes.
- 10:09Did you watch the movie yet?
- 10:11- You know, I haven't and everyone keeps telling me
- 10:13how good it is.
- 10:14I think I will.
- 10:15My gut reaction of why it's taking me so long
- 10:17is that I really don't, I mean, I don't like snow, obviously.
- 10:21And so I'm like, why the fuck would I want to watch
- 10:23an entire movie dedicated to,
- 10:25like in this guy's sob story?
- 10:28- Yeah, like I don't hear you.
- 10:30- But I don't hear you. - But I don't hear you.
- 10:31- You're so hot. - Yeah.
- 10:33I know, but I'm like, oh, oh, what was me?
- 10:35You had a sad story and now you're gonna be like a dictator
- 10:38and a fascist.
- 10:40I don't know.
- 10:40But I've heard that it's more than that.
- 10:43So I'll give it a whirl.
- 10:45- Yes, I think that the movie, I mean, a lot,
- 10:49and we'll talk a little bit about the movie,
- 10:51or the book to the movie adaptations, I think, a lot.
- 10:54- Yeah.
- 10:55- What is said in ballad of songbirds and snakes?
- 10:57So in the book of ballad and songbirds and snakes,
- 11:00you're through snow's mind, right?
- 11:03So you hear his internal monologue
- 11:05and you hear that he is deep down like a bad person,
- 11:10even before he becomes like evil snow.
- 11:14And so-- - Okay.
- 11:15- So it's always been there.
- 11:16See, I wanted that too.
- 11:17I'm sick of all these.
- 11:18- Yeah.
- 11:20- I like a complex villain and I like a tragic backstory,
- 11:23but sometimes I want a villain who's just a dick.
- 11:26I want him just to be a bad person.
- 11:29I don't need some sob story.
- 11:31I don't know.
- 11:32- Yeah, and I think, you know,
- 11:34she is exploring these really popular themes
- 11:36in all of her books, right?
- 11:38So she's been on record to say
- 11:41the ballad of songbirds and snakes is looking at human nature
- 11:45through the philosophical arguments of Hob's,
- 11:49Locke and Russo.
- 11:51And ultimately, like, is someone born bad
- 11:55or is it something that happens to them?
- 11:57Is it a series of things that occur
- 12:00that lead them to this path
- 12:01and make them ultimately bad?
- 12:03And so I think it is a very interesting look
- 12:06into how does someone become like a fascist dictator?
- 12:10- Or they are terrible.
- 12:12- And all of a sudden.
- 12:13- Who broke Donald Trump's heart.
- 12:14- Yeah, right?
- 12:15And she came out with that.
- 12:17I mean, when did it come out like in 2021?
- 12:19So she was writing it around the time of, you know,
- 12:23the Trump presidency and things like that.
- 12:26And so four sunrise on the reaping.
- 12:30Ultimately, she has been said to draw inspiration
- 12:34from the Scottish philosopher, David Hume.
- 12:38Oh, yes, my favorite.
- 12:39Oh, yes, of course.
- 12:41It's a-- - Yeah, undoubtedly.
- 12:42(laughs)
- 12:45Hume, Hume's philosophy explores the easiness
- 12:50in which the many are governed by the few.
- 12:54- Oh, shit.
- 12:55- Yes.
- 12:56- So his whole kind of philosophy explores that
- 13:00and why are we willing to do that?
- 13:02And it also kind of lends itself into propaganda
- 13:07and how we find ourselves believing that
- 13:09and accepting that.
- 13:10Even when we do know that things are bad
- 13:13and people don't have our best interest in heart.
- 13:15- Yeah, and like the diffusion of responsibility
- 13:19at a certain point, like we all see that something bad
- 13:22is happening, but we all think,
- 13:24oh, somebody else will take care of it.
- 13:26Somebody else will take care of it.
- 13:27And at a certain point, everybody just kind of sits back
- 13:30and lets it happen because they think,
- 13:33at a certain point, oh, it's too hard to do anything
- 13:34about it now.
- 13:35Like no one did anything, so now none of us can.
- 13:38And then that's how people get away with continued evil shit.
- 13:42- Yes, exactly.
- 13:43And before we head into our spoiler version,
- 13:48give the listeners who maybe read slower than you,
- 13:52a spoiler free review of the sunrise on the Reaping Game.
- 13:57- First of all, it is April
- 13:59and I've already finished seven books this year.
- 14:02And I know you've probably finished like 35,
- 14:04but that's pretty good for me.
- 14:07- That is good.
- 14:08- I loved this book.
- 14:10I have not read song of--
- 14:13- That was some words in this guy.
- 14:15(laughs)
- 14:17I haven't read that yet or seen the movie,
- 14:19but I am a huge Hunger Games fan.
- 14:22I have watched those movies way more times
- 14:25than I think is probably healthy.
- 14:26(laughs)
- 14:27And read all of the books immediately when they came out.
- 14:31And this book was,
- 14:33you hear Hamich's voice in your head.
- 14:37It's written in such a perfect tone of voice.
- 14:40Almost where I had to reread certain lines like twice
- 14:43because they weren't quite grammatically correct
- 14:46because it's the way that he speaks, right?
- 14:49Do you know what I'm trying to say?
- 14:50- Yes.
- 14:51- And he'll say something and I'm like,
- 14:52"Wait, what is he trying to--
- 14:53- He speaks like someone from Appalachia, you know?
- 14:56- Exactly.
- 14:57And so I really liked that detail.
- 15:00And yeah, without saying any spoilers,
- 15:03I haven't cried in a book in a long time.
- 15:07And I went to the end of this book.
- 15:11And my husband was in his office playing video games
- 15:13and I walked in and I was like,
- 15:14"You don't even understand."
- 15:17And he's like, "No, I don't."
- 15:19I write down.
- 15:20- He's still reading two years later.
- 15:24He's like, "Yeah, I don't get it."
- 15:26- He's never gonna finish, dude.
- 15:28- Yeah, I couldn't agree more.
- 15:32I definitely rated this five stars on Goodreads.
- 15:35It was great.
- 15:37I think it had the right amount of fan service.
- 15:40It really explored a deep meeting, a deep theme
- 15:44and dark as hell.
- 15:47And I think for a story, you think you know so much about
- 15:52because you met this character within the Hunger Games.
- 15:56I mean, there was still so much that shocked me throughout
- 16:00and even though you know what's coming at the end
- 16:03because you meet Hamich later down the road,
- 16:06you know what's not gonna be good.
- 16:08Like, I knew even those final couple pages,
- 16:11I was reading it like, "Oh, like you turned the page
- 16:14"because you're like, "Oh, something bad's gonna happen."
- 16:18- Yeah.
- 16:19- Oh, lo and behold, it's Hunger Games.
- 16:19So it lots of bad things happen.
- 16:22But it all makes so much sense to explain
- 16:25why Hamich is the way he's now.
- 16:27- Yeah, absolutely.
- 16:28(dramatic music)
- 16:31- Before we head into our spoiler sunrise
- 16:37on the reaping discussion,
- 16:39we wanna remind you that we do have a Patreon
- 16:43wanna shout out full access to our new PCJ pops,
- 16:47a sneak peek into the uncensored video of our episodes
- 16:50before anyone else gets to see them.
- 16:52(imitates music)
- 16:53- You also get, you also get,
- 16:55you also get, you also get,
- 16:56- It might not sound sexual at all.
- 16:57- Oh, yeah. - Sorry guys.
- 16:58(imitates music)
- 17:00- You also get, like, a mut from the Hunger Games
- 17:02like you know.
- 17:04- A mutation.
- 17:05You also get to support our show,
- 17:07which brings us to you the best of the pop culture
- 17:10on a weekly basis.
- 17:12- That's a bad shirt.
- 17:13- That in itself is a reward.
- 17:15You get to hear us do lovely animal noises,
- 17:19like Shawna just did.
- 17:20(laughing)
- 17:23So to access our Patreon, go to patreon.com/popculturejunkiepodcast
- 17:29and subscribe.
- 17:30- Okay, so now that the fairies of the world
- 17:35are out and not listening.
- 17:37- Hey, hey, she learned how to read eventually.
- 17:41- Yeah, you're slowly becoming literate.
- 17:43No, I'm just kidding.
- 17:43- She figured it out.
- 17:45- We wanted to do this book,
- 17:47but we wanted to give our listeners enough time
- 17:49to be able to get through it and read it.
- 17:51And ultimately, we are aware that people have lives
- 17:54unlike myself.
- 17:56And so, you know, sometimes it's hard to get through a whole book
- 17:59unless you have high perfectations.
- 18:03And so, you know, I think that this book in itself
- 18:06was so well done mainly because we kind of alluded to it
- 18:10in the beginning, hey, Mitch is a character
- 18:12that we know survives the Hunger Games, right?
- 18:15We meet him with Katniss and 25 years from now.
- 18:19We know that he is a very sad alcoholic
- 18:23who has no family, no friends.
- 18:27At a certain point, they ask him, well, do you have any tips for us?
- 18:30And he goes, accept the inevitability of your,
- 18:34like, imminent demise.
- 18:36- Of your imminent demise, basically.
- 18:38- Except the fact that you're gonna die
- 18:40and there's nothing you can do about it.
- 18:42And they were both like, aren't you supposed to be armant
- 18:45or like, so that is the first introduction we get to him.
- 18:49- Yeah, and ultimately, if you never read
- 18:52the Hunger Games books, but you did watch the movies,
- 18:55hey, Mitch is very much changed within the book to movie, right?
- 19:00So within the movie, he is kind of there
- 19:03as the silly alcoholic.
- 19:05He's there for comedic relief.
- 19:07I mean, it's really hard not to--
- 19:09- But just sad because I tragic alcoholism is not funny.
- 19:13- Yeah, well, it's the Hunger Games.
- 19:15So it's murder.
- 19:17- Hey, you lived and now you just drunk all the time.
- 19:20- Yeah.
- 19:21- I mean, to be fair, that would be absolutely being--
- 19:23- Yeah, I mean, that's me and I'm not going into the Hunger Games.
- 19:26- That's me right now. - Yeah, and ultimately, the book itself,
- 19:35it changes a lot of things about Heymich.
- 19:37So we have the iconic Woody Harrelson playing Heymich,
- 19:42but within the books, Heymich is actually described
- 19:46as having dark hair and gray eyes.
- 19:49He is much more--
- 19:50he's not blonde hair blue-eyed within it.
- 19:53And a lot of the people within District 12 fit that.
- 19:56So Katniss has more olive skin tone.
- 19:59She is very dark hair.
- 20:00And so, you know, kind of keep that in mind
- 20:02whenever they originally casted it,
- 20:05where, you know, he doesn't necessarily fit the book description.
- 20:09Woody Harrelson?
- 20:11Woody Harrelson is just so good, though.
- 20:13And that has to be it.
- 20:14It's just like, he captures it so well,
- 20:17just that like tragic nuance,
- 20:21do you know there's something else there?
- 20:23You don't really get to find out, you know,
- 20:25in those first couple books or even movies,
- 20:28but you know something went down, right?
- 20:30- Yes. - To make him the way he is.
- 20:32And Woody Harrelson is just such an amazing actor.
- 20:35It's like, I'm thinking PETA's character, too,
- 20:38is also kind of that like blonde kid,
- 20:41but I don't remember if he has described that way in the book.
- 20:42- He is just blonde in the books.
- 20:45- Okay.
- 20:46Yeah, but he's just, he nailed it.
- 20:49So, you know, no stink from me with a different hair color.
- 20:53- Yes, and in the books, Hey Matches is seen
- 20:56as much more strategic and helping Katniss and PETA
- 21:01kind of navigate the capital itself and understanding,
- 21:05like what are they gonna look for?
- 21:06He definitely like pushes Katniss and PETA
- 21:09into their romance and their interview presentations
- 21:14and doing those things.
- 21:15And so, I think it, you lose a little bit of the depth
- 21:19to Hey Match within the movies that you would have had
- 21:23if you had read the original Hunger Games trilogy.
- 21:27- I agree with that.
- 21:28You do see like spots of it in the movie
- 21:30where he looks over and sees like the kids playing
- 21:34with the toys and you can, you know, in the capital
- 21:36and they're playing with like swords,
- 21:38wow, Katniss and PETA are in the games.
- 21:40And you could see that like sadness in his eyes
- 21:42where he's like, oh, these kids are playing murder
- 21:45and when he starts hustling the room
- 21:47and trying to get them some sponsors, you know,
- 21:51especially once the, once catching fire is over
- 21:55and the plot is revealed with Plutarch,
- 21:58then we really get to see him kind of become more
- 22:00of that strategic player.
- 22:02But I agree it was definitely like a lot of things
- 22:06between these movies and the books were more nuanced
- 22:08or they cut them out for the sake of film
- 22:11or even for violence is sake in some of them, I think.
- 22:14- Yeah, yeah, and that's, he's like, yeah, right.
- 22:19So I love that you just said like, you know,
- 22:22the plot to overthrow the capital
- 22:25become with District 13.
- 22:26Like, so you know that Hamish has involved in that
- 22:29within the original trilogy, but you don't know
- 22:32when they met, how they met,
- 22:34you have a friendship spell.
- 22:36And ultimately that's really what you get
- 22:38within this book, right?
- 22:39So him and Plutarch, you mean?
- 22:41Him and Plutarch, him and Beatie, him and,
- 22:45- Mags and mags. - Mags and mags.
- 22:47Yes.
- 22:48So we talked about it a little bit in the beginning
- 22:50where you see these characters from catching fire,
- 22:54which are virus, Beatie and mags.
- 22:57And ultimately, Hamish was originally supposed to be
- 23:02briefed within those games.
- 23:05So he was supposed to go in, but PETA actually
- 23:08volunteers as tribute, so me, Mitch gets taken out.
- 23:12But you meet these characters,
- 23:14Mag is actually Hamish's mentor
- 23:17and virus as well is involved within the mentorship,
- 23:22because again, they have 48 mentor,
- 23:25are they 48 tributes?
- 23:27So they have two mentors. - Remember that little line
- 23:31in catching fire where Katniss is like,
- 23:35oh, there's no way she's gonna survive talking about mags.
- 23:39And then Hamish says, well, I hope when she goes,
- 23:42she goes fast, she's actually a really nice lady.
- 23:44- Yeah.
- 23:45- And it just brings so much more depth to that now
- 23:49that you know, like, yeah, she was so there for him.
- 23:53It makes sense why,
- 23:55why risks is, what's the good word for this?
- 24:00Talks to herself in his kind of strange, right?
- 24:05- Yes, it's alluded that they were tortured
- 24:07at the end of this book, but we don't really know how.
- 24:10Same with mags doesn't even speak anymore, right?
- 24:13Like, virus is kind of like,
- 24:15loses a mind a little bit, but mags is just silent,
- 24:18isn't she, in catching fire?
- 24:20She's just mute.
- 24:21- Yeah, she doesn't really speak, but at the same time,
- 24:25she's also Annie's mentor, I think at some point within it.
- 24:29So I don't know if she's just like old,
- 24:31within catching fire.
- 24:32I know that it impacts her quite a bit,
- 24:34but I don't know if she's like,
- 24:36I don't think she has a single line in that entire movie
- 24:39from watching it, and she kind of like signs to catness.
- 24:43I don't know, it's just, to me,
- 24:44both of their characters speak trauma,
- 24:46something happened, and then we see in sunrise
- 24:49on the reaping that they were tortured
- 24:51after "Hammages Games."
- 24:53So like, that explains why they're the way they are now.
- 24:56- Yeah, ultimately, and so you start to see these connections.
- 25:00We also meet Beatie, who actually, as a result of his,
- 25:05so Beatie is known to be one of the smartest people
- 25:11within Pennam, not just the districts,
- 25:13not just the capital, and he's very in control
- 25:17of their electrical grid and their power grid.
- 25:20And so they cannot kill him as a result of his rebellion.
- 25:25So what they end up doing is they send in his son
- 25:29into the Hunger Games.
- 25:32His 12 year old son goes in, so the first year,
- 25:35and ultimately, like, Beatie goes into it,
- 25:38knowing that his son is going to die,
- 25:41and they hatch this plan of how do we destroy the arena itself
- 25:46and go through this kind of large plot to destroy it
- 25:53with Ampert Beatie's son, and then ultimately,
- 25:57Hamich as well, and so Hamich is involved in it.
- 26:00- How did you feel about that plot?
- 26:02It was so frustrating, and purposefully so,
- 26:05I think it's supposed to be frustrating,
- 26:07in that he keeps getting, he goes through the plan, right?
- 26:12He floods the system, and it doesn't really do anything.
- 26:16And it leads to Ampert's, like you said, Beatie and him,
- 26:20already knew he was gonna die.
- 26:22It was punishment for Beatie to have to watch his son die in TV.
- 26:25And he was like, I want it to just be as quick and painless
- 26:27as possible, and it ended up being the most gruesome death
- 26:30of the games. - Oh, yeah.
- 26:31- Oh my God.
- 26:33Oh, never looking at a squirrel the same.
- 26:36- Literally, squirrel.
- 26:38But, and then, so he gets through this whole plot,
- 26:42and Hamich beats himself up throughout the book too.
- 26:45His internal monologue is just, I'm useless.
- 26:48Why did I do this?
- 26:48I should have just not done anything.
- 26:50It would have been better to not do anything,
- 26:52which is that diffusion of responsibility, right?
- 26:54He's kicking himself or doing something
- 26:56because it didn't really work out.
- 26:58And I know he has another plan in the end,
- 27:00but it's frustrating to see him go through that, right?
- 27:05- Yeah, well, I think that's kind of like the argument
- 27:07of the whole book, right?
- 27:10Like of, you know, I think that Hamich's actions
- 27:15do cause the capital to lose control of the narrative
- 27:20within the game.
- 27:21They wrestle it back in the end, ultimately,
- 27:24with the replays and what they let people kind of see
- 27:28on the second go around.
- 27:29- Propaganda, and that's what the news,
- 27:31like, you know, that's propaganda now,
- 27:33just tweaking things to your liking.
- 27:36And like, in the United States,
- 27:38has it any country as propaganda,
- 27:39but you think of North Korea, right?
- 27:41Or they only show you the certain things
- 27:43that make them look real good.
- 27:45And so people don't know the actual truth.
- 27:47But, yeah, it's so frustrating.
- 27:49And you just want to scream and throw the book across the room.
- 27:53- Yeah, and I think, you know, at the end of the book,
- 27:56they had this line where, you know,
- 27:59there's gonna be another victor later,
- 28:02who's luckier than you are, but has catches fire
- 28:06and that rebellion goes into it.
- 28:08And you see that, you know, there are so many people involved.
- 28:13We haven't really talked about Plutarch yet,
- 28:14because I want to spend some time on him,
- 28:16but you see so many people from the district
- 28:19who have Plutarch involved in this story as well.
- 28:22And then Hamich, who was courageous enough to do it,
- 28:25he was courageous, he had the plan,
- 28:27but he didn't have the luck, and he didn't have, you know,
- 28:30the right kind of factors working for him at that moment in time.
- 28:35- He had people who had his back,
- 28:39but not to the degree that Katnist did.
- 28:42So I do think, thinking back, you know, in the moment,
- 28:45he probably thought, oh, this was useless, this didn't do anything,
- 28:48but no, absolutely did.
- 28:50You have to try and fail.
- 28:51Like, revolutions aren't just easy.
- 28:53It's not something you just try once,
- 28:55and then you overthrow the government and everything's hunky-dory.
- 28:58It's like, people will try and fail and fuck up and fall down,
- 29:02and you will vote somebody out of office,
- 29:04and then four years later they'll come back,
- 29:06and it doesn't mean that you just stop, you keep trying.
- 29:10So I think that's, you know, kind of like the epilogue
- 29:13at the end of the book, he's like, yeah,
- 29:14I did meet somebody who had more luck than I do.
- 29:18And did destroy not only the arena, but the entire system.
- 29:23So yeah, in that moment, it just,
- 29:24it was so heartbreaking to see him be like,
- 29:25why am I even doing this?
- 29:27I keep fucking up, I keep failing, and you're like,
- 29:29no, man, this is necessary, this is necessary,
- 29:32the failure is necessary.
- 29:34- Yeah, and ultimately, you know,
- 29:36there's so many beautiful like callbacks within it.
- 29:40Whenever I think, whenever I realize that,
- 29:45you know, there's the scene with Lenore Dove and Hamich,
- 29:48where he talks about wanting to be the last person
- 29:52ever reaped, and to be fair, he technically was,
- 29:56but it was 25 years later, because Hamich was the last name
- 30:00pulled, and then Peter, you know, volunteers distribute,
- 30:04but then that's the last hundred things.
- 30:06- Yeah, so there's blue my mind,
- 30:08you can blue my mind a little bit.
- 30:10- Oh, so there's so many beautiful things
- 30:13within this story, but, you know, one of the characters
- 30:16that I think was the most interesting that we got to me
- 30:19and get to know as a younger person
- 30:22was definitely Plutarch Heavensby, who it--
- 30:26- Did you picture him as--
- 30:28- Phillips Seymour Hoffman.
- 30:29- William H.
- 30:30- I almost said it, William H. Macy.
- 30:32- Why?
- 30:35- I did picture him as William H. Macy.
- 30:37I pictured him as film, like,
- 30:38Phillips Seymour Hoffman the entire day.
- 30:40- Yeah.
- 30:40- May he rest in peace.
- 30:41- Just like a young Phillips Seymour Hoffman,
- 30:43yeah, absolutely.
- 30:44- Absolutely, let me tell you.
- 30:45- Hey, Mitch, it was just a young, what do you hear?
- 30:47I'll say that in my mind.
- 30:48- 100%.
- 30:49But, yeah, I mean, I think that meeting Plutarch
- 30:53as a younger person, as such a younger privileged person
- 30:57who also kind of could see through it.
- 31:00So you see these early seedlings of us,
- 31:05no, hating Plutarch.
- 31:08Now Plutarch is younger than him,
- 31:11but Plutarch really kind of plays this angle
- 31:13of getting what he needs out of the capital,
- 31:16but also having this kind of like secret rebellion.
- 31:19And you see that-- - Yeah.
- 31:20- That the resources of the capital,
- 31:22I mean, sometimes you need someone on the inside like that.
- 31:25- Or an over their trust, get the money in the resources,
- 31:28get on the inside.
- 31:29- Yes, and one of the most interesting things to me
- 31:32that I think I saw within this book that I took away
- 31:35was the Heavensby family are even among the district
- 31:39and the capital.
- 31:40Some of the few people who still have access to books
- 31:44and books that we would know today in North America.
- 31:47So I don't think I ever really like grasp the level of like,
- 31:52book burning, information control that the capital had
- 31:57on books like the Raven by Edgar Allan Poe
- 32:01is within this book quite a bit.
- 32:03And no one-- - Yeah, exactly.
- 32:05I know I caught that and it took me a minute too.
- 32:07I didn't mean to cut you off,
- 32:08but like when he first started quoting the Raven,
- 32:11I was like, oh, yeah, you're like,
- 32:13I forgot that this, yeah, I forgot that this took place
- 32:16in what used to be the United States.
- 32:18So yeah, this literature did exist in this world.
- 32:22It's just people don't have access to it anymore.
- 32:24So now it's just passed down through song
- 32:27and through tale and spoken word, yeah.
- 32:29But yeah, a lot of song, especially in the same.
- 32:33- Yes, exactly.
- 32:34And so, you know, it, how does the Heavensby's
- 32:38because the Heavensby's are one of the richest families
- 32:40within the capital.
- 32:41They're richer than the snow family
- 32:43and you see that within valid a song, birds and snakes.
- 32:47And that is ultimately like why snow
- 32:49so deeply despises the Heavensby family as well.
- 32:53But they're keeping up with the genders a little bit.
- 32:56Their ability to retain information and retain text
- 33:00is actually what gives them that sets of humanity
- 33:03in empathy and wanting to overthrow it.
- 33:07Now, Plutarch I think is very self-serving within himself
- 33:11because he's not like overtly putting his money there.
- 33:15He's kind of behind the curtain tinkerer,
- 33:18which might be what people need.
- 33:19- Yeah, I mean, he's not gonna put his name in face to it.
- 33:22Yeah, which, you know, for better or worse
- 33:24could be something that any revolution needs
- 33:26and I'm sure it is, but even when the book started
- 33:29and he kind of started exposing himself to Hamich
- 33:33as being on his side, I know how it ends
- 33:37and I know who Plutarch ends up being.
- 33:39But even I was like, wait, is he bad?
- 33:41Is he bad?
- 33:43Like even you aren't sure if he's kind of like playing Hamich.
- 33:48- Yeah, I think he's meant to be very self-serving
- 33:52where he thinks that's gonna be best.
- 33:55Like does he do it because snow hates his family
- 33:59and he knows that snow has to be overthrown
- 34:02or is he doing it for the good of goodness, you know?
- 34:06And so I think he gets results, so that's good.
- 34:09I think that he's a very interesting character.
- 34:12He's a very complex character.
- 34:14And so one thing I didn't mention about Susan Collins
- 34:17is she was originally a screenwriter
- 34:20and so she likes to write within trilogies
- 34:25and all of the books are written within a three-act structure
- 34:29as well.
- 34:30- So do you think is gonna be the next,
- 34:32it's gonna be Plutarch?
- 34:34Because I think she is going within a story of snow,
- 34:39Hamich, someone deeply impacted but becomes,
- 34:43like who is hurt but becomes a part of a rebellion
- 34:46and then someone who is, you know, on the outsides
- 34:49of that society and decides to join
- 34:52because they don't have everything they want.
- 34:55- If she writes a book about Plutarch,
- 34:56it'll be interesting too.
- 34:58Because it'll be the first book that she's written
- 35:00if somebody who wasn't a tribute.
- 35:02So it'll be definitely kind of a snow isn't a tribute.
- 35:06- Well, that's true, but somebody,
- 35:08he's like training a tribute or he's,
- 35:11he's a mentor in the beginning.
- 35:13- Yes, I guess that's true,
- 35:15but it's somebody who's not like either a mentor
- 35:17or a tribute, like.
- 35:18- Yeah, well, I mean, Plutarch is like the video,
- 35:23the propaganda person who like follows them around.
- 35:26So he's involved in the games,
- 35:27but probably still like get through the plot
- 35:30of A Hunger Games within the book.
- 35:32- Yeah, well, because Plutarch becomes a game maker, right?
- 35:36And so he starts as the film person
- 35:40who's like following around the district.
- 35:41I think it'd be really interesting to see how he moves up
- 35:45within that and like what does that do?
- 35:46- Yeah, we're gonna see like that a,
- 35:48like what promotion, what bad did he have to do
- 35:52to get there to eventually do good?
- 35:54I think that's a really interesting philosophical.
- 35:56Like the needs, the many overcome the needs of one.
- 36:00Like I think I could really see her making that argument
- 36:04and saying, hey, is this even a good person?
- 36:06Is this someone that you should support?
- 36:08Because they did all this bad even though it led to
- 36:12an overall much greater good.
- 36:14Like I can see-- - He's gonna have to do something bad
- 36:16to earn Snow's trust, right?
- 36:18He's not just gonna let this guy move from being like
- 36:21a propaganda journalist, if you know,
- 36:24journalists very loosely there to be a game maker.
- 36:28You gotta do something, shoot that toddler in the head
- 36:30or something, I don't know.
- 36:31- Yes, yeah, ultimately.
- 36:32And I think that'd be a really interesting philosophical argument,
- 36:36right?
- 36:37There's so much philosophy around the needs of the greater good,
- 36:42makeup for bad actions, negative action to one person.
- 36:47I do think that it's gonna be a Plutarch
- 36:50if she does end a third book.
- 36:51She goes inside for sure she is.
- 36:53But just-- - Oh, these are making so much money though.
- 36:56- Yeah, but what I really do want to see
- 37:00is a Finic Odare, a Hunger Games.
- 37:04- Yeah.
- 37:05- And if they could just age down some--
- 37:07- Daddy. - At a Catholic.
- 37:08- He's so hot.
- 37:10He's so hot and touching fire.
- 37:11- He's so hot.
- 37:13Oh my God, just in a sugar cube.
- 37:15- Yes, that was like when he pops that sugar cube in.
- 37:18Oh, baby.
- 37:19- I'll be your sugar cube, daddy.
- 37:21- Yes.
- 37:21- Yes, so hot, and he's amazing.
- 37:24- Also really hot and dainty Joe's in the sixth.
- 37:27- Squirrel.
- 37:28- And also hot in that movie where he is a paraplegic
- 37:32with me before you--
- 37:34- With Daenerys Targaryen.
- 37:35- Yeah, yeah, very hot.
- 37:37Sorry, see this is why we need a Squirrel.
- 37:39- Squirrel.
- 37:40- So I'm eating squirrels.
- 37:42- No but-- - He's a track.
- 37:43- Yeah, but one of the funniest things,
- 37:46I think about this book coming out
- 37:50is the internet reaction to it.
- 37:53So whenever the movie came out,
- 37:56they had Tom Blithe play, Snow.
- 37:58Tom Blithe is a very attractive man.
- 38:01And so the--
- 38:02- You mean in "Balad Assam Burns" and "Snakes."
- 38:05- The ditty of the snakes and the birdies.
- 38:07- Yes, yeah.
- 38:08And so there were all these fan edits of Tom Blithe as Snow.
- 38:13- Oh my God, so--
- 38:14- No people thirsting over snow.
- 38:16- Yes, and the internet said that this book was
- 38:19our consequence of that.
- 38:21And that's why she ultimately ripped our freaking heart out.
- 38:25I mean, there were so many good characters.
- 38:27- Oh, he's handsome.
- 38:28- Oh, yeah.
- 38:29Did you see him as Snow?
- 38:30Type, type.
- 38:31- Yeah, I'm looking at him right now.
- 38:33- Yeah. - But also, we've said this before,
- 38:36never trust a blonde man.
- 38:37- Yeah, never trust a blonde man.
- 38:39But you know, these characters within this book
- 38:43were so amazing.
- 38:44I mean, like, mazily Donner, so good.
- 38:47You see nods of her throughout.
- 38:49- I love her.
- 38:50- Oh, we love a best.
- 38:52- She bests me, girl.
- 38:53She reminds me of Cordelia Chase, right?
- 38:57- Yes.
- 38:57- A bitch with a heart of gold.
- 39:00- A bitch with a heart of gold.
- 39:01- Yeah, that's perfect.
- 39:02- She will look at your outfit and be like,
- 39:03what the fuck are you wearing?
- 39:05And then also offer to redress you
- 39:08unless you get on her bad side.
- 39:09And then she's just gonna make little jabs
- 39:11at you every time you see her.
- 39:13- I don't know if you ever caught this,
- 39:15but the mocking J-Pan, that cat-ness guess--
- 39:17- Yes, it's mazily's.
- 39:19- Yeah, so--
- 39:20- Yes, 'cause she thought it was ugly, right?
- 39:21(laughing)
- 39:23- Yeah, so--
- 39:24- She's like, what is that?
- 39:26- We had a mazily who is an amazing character.
- 39:29Lulu, who, oh my god,
- 39:31- Oh my god.
- 39:32- Oh my god, just so sad.
- 39:33- Rip my heart out with Lulu and Lulu.
- 39:38What's Lulu's actual name, I forgot.
- 39:40- Loyella?
- 39:42- Loyella, yes.
- 39:43- Loyella and Lulu,
- 39:44both equally tragic characters.
- 39:48Poor Wyatt, who doesn't get much to do in this book,
- 39:51but he's there.
- 39:52And Ampurt, who has, like I said, a horrifying death.
- 39:57All of the deaths in this book are horrifying.
- 40:01- Yeah, never gonna look at a squirrel the same.
- 40:04- No, eaten by squirrels, blown up, heads cut off.
- 40:09- The killer head chug.
- 40:10- The killer head chug.
- 40:11- Yeah. - Yeah.
- 40:12- This one had a lot of crazy mutations.
- 40:16I also think the arena, as itself,
- 40:19was really, really interesting.
- 40:20It's known to be this beautiful scenery,
- 40:23but everything is poisonous.
- 40:24So it's like, what looks beautiful on the outside
- 40:27and can kill you or the illusion of beauty.
- 40:30- Like a red rose with sorens.
- 40:32- Yeah, the illusion of beauty.
- 40:35So honestly, if you can't tell,
- 40:37we could go on and on and on about this.
- 40:39But I think that this book has so many deep themes within it
- 40:44and ultimately of how power structures
- 40:48try to maintain control and how individuals
- 40:50can resist oppression even when that victory
- 40:54seems impossible.
- 40:55Again, Suzanne Collins, just an amazing person
- 40:58to come in and create a story.
- 41:00- Incredible. - They'll live.
- 41:01- Yeah, ultimately.
- 41:03And I think even if she wrote like a joke book,
- 41:08it would still be amazing and have deep themes
- 41:10and meaning within it.
- 41:12- I'd still cry.
- 41:13- Yeah, absolutely.
- 41:14So she's just amazing at really telling a story
- 41:18that makes us think.
- 41:20And so we're gonna take a quick break
- 41:23and we're gonna talk a little bit about the film adaptation.
- 41:26(dramatic music)
- 41:29- Okay, so if you haven't heard yet,
- 41:34the Sunrise on the Reeping book was immediately picked up
- 41:38for a movie, Go Figure, just like the Ballad of Songbirds
- 41:43and Snakes, they kind of immediately,
- 41:44like I think as soon as Suzanne Collins finished the book,
- 41:47they started to write the script.
- 41:49And so it was so close afterwards, yeah.
- 41:51- Yeah, and she writes in a really good way
- 41:53because again, she was a screenwriter
- 41:56to be adapted into a movie.
- 41:59- Well, we don't have any official casting announcements.
- 42:04They have started to release a little bit of buzz,
- 42:08a little bit of rumors within it.
- 42:10- And rumor mill buzzing.
- 42:13- Yeah. - Love it.
- 42:14- And I think most of these sound legit.
- 42:18- Yes, they do.
- 42:19So for our leading man here,
- 42:23we have Charlie Plummer as Hamich Abernathy.
- 42:26So I had originally wanted this person to be
- 42:30Keeper Sutherland because obviously it's Donald Sutherland's
- 42:33son, but I actually do really, really like this casting.
- 42:38- Keeper Sutherland as old girl.
- 42:41- So is President Snow.
- 42:43- He's pretty. - Yeah, but you mean for Snow,
- 42:46I thought you meant for Hamich.
- 42:48And I was like, "Bad, you are so pretty."
- 42:54- E.K. Lying really am, aren't you?
- 42:56And now I'm just gonna picture Keeper Sutherland
- 42:59trying to play a 16 year old.
- 43:02And he's like, "Yeah, I'm big."
- 43:04- So we have 24 hours to be in to destroy the arena.
- 43:08- I would watch that though.
- 43:11I would definitely watch that.
- 43:12- Oh, absolutely.
- 43:13- No, that key would be great for Snow.
- 43:15- Yes, Keeper Sutherland for President Snow
- 43:18because his dad was the older snow.
- 43:20But unfortunately they're not doing that.
- 43:23The rumored casting for this is actually
- 43:26rafes finds so not only-- - So old the more?
- 43:29- Yeah. - Literally old the more.
- 43:31- So not only is he going to play Voldemort,
- 43:34he will play Snow.
- 43:36- The girl has come to die.
- 43:39- So literally Voldemort.
- 43:41So Voldemort. - Literally Voldemort.
- 43:43- So the girl has got fire.
- 43:46- Has come to die.
- 43:49- Literally.
- 43:51I don't hate it.
- 43:54I think you could do a good job in it.
- 43:56- It's a good actor.
- 43:57- Yes, he is.
- 43:58Even if he has a confusing name to pronounce.
- 44:01(laughing)
- 44:02- It's too much his name ever.
- 44:04- Okay, how old is Snow supposed to be in his 50s, right?
- 44:07- Yes, yeah.
- 44:08- So it-- - Okay, it's--
- 44:09- It's fine as 62.
- 44:11So-- - Yeah, yeah.
- 44:12- It's close.
- 44:13Same with Keeper Sutherland.
- 44:15I was going straight.
- 44:17I just want NEPO baby casting.
- 44:19Same thing with Plutarch.
- 44:22I wanted it to be Philipsy More Hoffman's son.
- 44:26- But-- - Was he an actor?
- 44:27- Yeah, he is.
- 44:29But they're saying that it will most likely be Jesse Plemons.
- 44:34- Which-- - Jesse Plemons would be--
- 44:36- Perfect.
- 44:37- He looks so much like him.
- 44:38- Yeah, he looks, he's spot on,
- 44:40and he's a very good actor.
- 44:42- Yeah, he looks so much like Philipsy More Hoffman.
- 44:45Now, I love this one the most.
- 44:47Out of all the rumored fan casting.
- 44:49- Yeah, I love that.
- 44:50- I don't know.
- 44:51- We have Kirin Colken as a Caesar flickerman.
- 44:55I don't know.
- 44:56I mean, I would have to see it.
- 44:57- Kirin Colken again. - Cool act.
- 44:58- A wonderful actor.
- 45:00But I'm not sure if he looks like--
- 45:03- Stanley Tucci.
- 45:04- Yeah, I don't know if I can,
- 45:06I see that him growing into Stanley Tucci.
- 45:09- Oh my God, no, I see it so much.
- 45:11- It's essentially-- - And it's a very young
- 45:13Caesar flickerman too.
- 45:15And they're gonna have, like Caesar flickerman,
- 45:17wears all those colors and like literal drag
- 45:19all the time. - That's true.
- 45:21- I see it for him. - He is a gay icon.
- 45:24- Literally Kirin Colken is so funny.
- 45:26I think that he's probably my favorite
- 45:28out of all the rumored fan casting released so far.
- 45:30I think he would-- - Yeah, he's wonderful.
- 45:32- And do a really good job.
- 45:34And then-- - Oh no, he would do amazing.
- 45:36I just, I need to see the full makeup effects maybe.
- 45:40- Yeah. - I need to see a purple booth font
- 45:41on him. - Yeah, right.
- 45:43- Exactly.
- 45:44And the last one that we've had come out of this.
- 45:48Now, they've been rumored to be playing two people.
- 45:52I'm gonna say the one that I want them to play the most.
- 45:56But I'll tell you the second laughter.
- 45:58So L-fanning is rumored to be a young,
- 46:02effie trinket.
- 46:03I totally forgot to mention.
- 46:05We meet effie within the book.
- 46:07How effie in the industry-- - Oh my God, I love effie trinket.
- 46:10I love that she had, Hey, Mitch is back.
- 46:13Like, throughout, I mean, she's still effie
- 46:16and she's still gonna be a capital darling.
- 46:19But we see that little bits of humanity
- 46:21where she knows that this isn't right.
- 46:23- Yes. - You know, she--
- 46:25- Yeah, I mean, as much as she wants to say,
- 46:27well, this is for the greater goods.
- 46:29And the games really are for the greater goods.
- 46:31Like, you know, there's that doubt in her mind
- 46:32where she's like, this is also gonna mess up.
- 46:34- Yeah.
- 46:35And so, L-fanning, I think, just like the red carpet looks,
- 46:40we would get leading up to this movie as her
- 46:43in "Math Addressing." - Oh my God.
- 46:44I would love it. - Yes.
- 46:45I think she would make a great effie trinket.
- 46:48I also saw a fan cast of Lily Rinehart.
- 46:52- Yeah. - Yeah.
- 46:54I think she's too, like, sweet looking for that.
- 46:56- Mm. - Vienna.
- 46:57- Okay, I could see that.
- 46:59I want her to get some more roles.
- 47:00I like her. - I see.
- 47:01- I like her too. - I think she's good.
- 47:03- Lily Rinehart's hilarious.
- 47:05Al-fanning has also been said to be rumored
- 47:08for Mazzle Lee Donner.
- 47:10But I think that needs to be like a mega bitch.
- 47:12Someone who looks bitchy right out the gate.
- 47:14- Yeah, I need a Burnett.
- 47:17I don't know. - Well, she's blonde.
- 47:18- She's blonde in the middle of it.
- 47:19- Is she blonde? - Yeah.
- 47:20- In my head, I picture her as a sassy Burnett.
- 47:23Maybe it's just I pictured her just as charisma carpenter
- 47:26in the entire movie. - Yeah, I'm fair, probably.
- 47:27- Or the entire book.
- 47:28- Yeah, charisma gets some blonde highlights.
- 47:31- Yeah, let's get charisma in there.
- 47:32(laughing)
- 47:34- And so those are the main speculations of characters
- 47:39we've seen so far.
- 47:40Again, no one is confirmed yet.
- 47:43I think the movies are kind of stuck to what
- 47:46the other movies did, where they can't stray too far
- 47:51from those original castings,
- 47:53but I think they do have some wiggle room within it.
- 47:56If they were to cast Hamage as someone with dark hair,
- 47:59they'd be in trouble for continuity sake,
- 48:01but-- - Yeah, it just wouldn't make sense.
- 48:03But I mean, yeah, it doesn't.
- 48:04You're never gonna get somebody who looks exactly
- 48:07like somebody else because humans have faces.
- 48:10- Yes, I also think they could do.
- 48:12- That's for Chessie Plymans.
- 48:13That one's-- - Yeah, that's--
- 48:14- Those two might be related, I don't know.
- 48:16- That's Philipsy Morehoff, a little spot on.
- 48:19(laughing)
- 48:20- Or they just get, I almost like Kristen Stewart.
- 48:24- No.
- 48:25- Kristen Dunst to play Fee would like that too.
- 48:28She's a little too old though.
- 48:29- Oh, I would love that.
- 48:31I just watched Hidden Figures for the first time
- 48:34over the weekend, and Kirsten Dunst is delightful in it.
- 48:37I mean, she's a bitch, but she's good.
- 48:39- I've seen that movie, but I don't remember her in it.
- 48:42- I love that. - She plays, yeah,
- 48:43like one of the higher ups in NASA,
- 48:45who at first is like kind of trying to hold
- 48:48the other ladies down, and then eventually she's like,
- 48:50"Yeah, you could do this."
- 48:52So.
- 48:53- Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 48:54Now it's coming back to me.
- 48:56- I don't know, I haven't really been able to place
- 48:58Lenore Dove in my mind.
- 49:00I almost want it to be someone who has like a Rachel
- 49:05Zegler look within her because it's like,
- 49:09that Rachel Zegler within that story, right?
- 49:12- Oh, Lucy Gray. - Yeah, Lucy Gray.
- 49:15Lucy Gray is her aunt.
- 49:17Lenore Dove is a redhead, right?
- 49:20- I can't remember.
- 49:21I think she does have a strawberry blonde or red hair.
- 49:24Ooh, the redhead from Riverdale.
- 49:26I could see her in it.
- 49:27I don't know if she could sing, no.
- 49:29- I mean, she's singing Riversdale,
- 49:30but they all kind of were forced to sing in Riverdale.
- 49:33- Yeah, right, exactly.
- 49:35No, but I really, really love the book.
- 49:37I mean, I think that so many good things to say,
- 49:41even if you loved it. - Yeah, me too.
- 49:43- If you went into it and you're like,
- 49:44well, why would I read that?
- 49:45I already know what's gonna happen.
- 49:46Oh, boy.
- 49:48- You don't though.
- 49:48You think you know, but you don't.
- 49:51- The buckle.
- 49:52- This is the true life of HeyMitch.
- 49:54- HeyMitch, have a happy nothing.
- 49:56- And the stories that get told around it.
- 49:58Why did I go to a studio?
- 49:59- This is behind the music of HeyMitch.
- 50:01(laughing)
- 50:03I was doing behind the music, but I was doing S.V.
- 50:07Oh my God.
- 50:08(laughing)
- 50:10- Man.
- 50:11Behind the music is you think you know, but you don't.
- 50:16This is the true story of Britney Spears.
- 50:19- Then it's all like a breakdown.
- 50:21Anyway, aging myself VH1, where you at?
- 50:24- Well, in Vanabout, we'll go ahead and close out
- 50:28our analysis of a sunrise on the reaping.
- 50:31- Yeah.
- 50:32- And we could talk about this forever.
- 50:34We wanna talk about this forever.
- 50:36Slide into the DMs.
- 50:39Let us know your thoughts.
- 50:40If we didn't cover something you think we should,
- 50:42or you think we even missed a big theme of the book,
- 50:45we would love to chat through it.
- 50:47Honestly, we could talk about the Hunger Games
- 50:49and Susan Collins forever.
- 50:50Want actually the day that Sean broke her foot
- 50:53when we were in Newport.
- 50:54We finished all of the Hunger Games movies.
- 50:59- We laid on the couch.
- 51:00- And I had, I sent my foot,
- 51:03and we were drinking white claws in order to pizza.
- 51:05And that was one of my favorite parts of the trip,
- 51:07even though I would have broken foot.
- 51:10- But if you already had the broken foot.
- 51:12- But my foot was already broken at that point.
- 51:14I just didn't know it.
- 51:15- Yes.
- 51:16- And we watched Hunger Games on the couch and ate pizza,
- 51:17and it was simply lovely.
- 51:18- You know, and we had the door open
- 51:20to the ocean sounds, it was amazing.
- 51:22- Yeah, I'm glad.
- 51:23- You know, the Hunger Games universe itself
- 51:26has taken us through so many stages of life.
- 51:28So we're so happy to talk about it with you guys here.
- 51:31As you know, you can find us on the line on our website
- 51:35at popculturejunkie.com.
- 51:37From there, you can find our podcast on all platforms,
- 51:40as well as social media links, blog posts, and more.
- 51:44Please rate, subscribe, review the show.
- 51:47Obviously it helps us so much.
- 51:49Get discovered, give riveting analysis
- 51:53like we have this time.
- 51:54Actually, the time we sounded pretty smart.
- 51:56- I was gonna say, we were pretty riveting this time.
- 51:58We sound like we read a book, and that we know where.
- 52:01- We have the best words.
- 52:03- I have the best words, the greatest of words.
- 52:05- I know all the words.
- 52:06I have the best words.
- 52:08- And as we mentioned at the top of the episode,
- 52:10join our Patreon because every subscription
- 52:12really helps us bring you more great episodes like this.
- 52:16Find us at patreon.com/popculturejunkiepodcast,
- 52:20sign up for a sneak peek,
- 52:21or get a super special shout out from us.
- 52:24God, I'm so glad I said that fine.
- 52:26Super special shout out.
- 52:28- Super special, I've been slurring through this whole thing.
- 52:31So not because I'm drunk, just 'cause I'm stupid.
- 52:34- But I'm gonna put a bow.
- 52:36- Shauna, where can I find you?
- 52:39- I am also drunk and stupid.
- 52:43You can find me @shaunatrinidad,
- 52:45S-H-A-U-N-A-T-R-I-N-I-D-A-D on Instagram and threads.
- 52:50- And you can find me, Olivia, on Instagram
- 52:55@livimariez L-I-V-I-M-A-R-I-E-Z,
- 53:00and an honor of this episode,
- 53:04I'm gonna drop the Goodreads as well.
- 53:09- Oh yeah, I'm gonna do that too.
- 53:11Follow us on Goodreads.
- 53:12I have three friends on there,
- 53:14and I'm pretty sure it's just Olivia three times.
- 53:16(laughs)
- 53:18You can find me, Olivia, R-O-D-I on Goodreads
- 53:23and then Shauna Trinidad as well.
- 53:26Follow us, we have some great reads.
- 53:29- And judge all of the books that we've been reading
- 53:32and just be like, why did you read that?
- 53:34Shauna, that's disgusting.
- 53:35- Shauna, you are not reading, disgusting books.
- 53:39- You're reading like, I got some good stuff on there.
- 53:42- Yeah, you're reading like, the basics of smut, you know?
- 53:46Like, they're not so dark.
- 53:49I'm honestly, I've been in like a very wholesome read mood lately,
- 53:54but you know, that could change.
- 53:55- I've read a lot of like, I have autobiographies
- 53:58and a lot of like feminist to like, fight the power stuff
- 54:01on there too, so nothing to.
- 54:02- I love that. - We pray.
- 54:03- So yeah, thank you.
- 54:05- Right, subscribe, follow.
- 54:07We'd love to hear your thoughts on the sunrise
- 54:10on the reapingness episode and come back next week
- 54:13for another hit of pop culture.
- 54:15(upbeat music)
- 54:17- The Pop Culture Junkie podcast is produced by Jeff Markin
- 54:22and Cheryl Lightfoot for the Pop Culture Entertainment Network.
- 54:27So entertain me, entertain me right now
- 54:29I need it bad, I need it bad
- 54:32Cause I need it bad, I need it bad
- 54:38[Music]