Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How 30-Year Treasury Yields Above 5% Reshape the Deficit Forever
Transcript
- Lucas: So the 30-year Treasury yield is sitting at 5.15 percent as of this morning. That's up about a percent over the last five days. And I think we need to have a real conversation about what that means for the federal deficit, not in some abstract future, but right now. Luna: It's funny — five percent used to feel like a ceiling, and now we're talking about holding above it like it's the new normal. What changed? Lucas: A few things, but the biggest is that the market is starting to price in a structural shift in how much the US government will need to borrow. We're looking at a federal debt load of about $39 trillion. debt to gdp is at 122.6 percent. And the deficit for fiscal 2025 was just under $1.8 trillion. Luna: And that's with relatively low unemployment and a growing economy. It's not like we're in a recession where deficits are supposed to blow out. Lucas: Exactly. That's the scary part. When the next recession hits, tax revenues will fall, spending will rise, and the deficit will blow out from an already elevated base. But the immediate story is about the cost of servicing all that debt. Luna: Walk me through the math. How much does a 1 percent move in yields actually cost? Lucas: Rough ballpark: the average maturity of outstanding Treasury debt is about six to seven years. So a 1 percent rise in yields across the curve, all else equal, adds about $390 billion in annual interest expense over time as debt rolls over. That's not a small number. Luna: And we've seen yields on the 10-year go from around 4 percent in early 2024 to 4.63 percent now. The 30-year hit 5 percent earlier this year and hasn't come back down. Lucas: Right. So the interest expense is already climbing. In fiscal 2025, net interest on the federal debt was about $1.1 trillion. That's more than spending on Medicare. It's more than defense. It's the fastest-growing category in the budget. Luna: And the CBO projections from earlier this year had interest costs hitting $1.6 trillion by 2030. But those projections were based on lower yield assumptions. If yields stay where they are, or go higher, that number is conservative. Lucas: That's the thing about these long-term projections — they're very sensitive to interest rates. The CBO's baseline assumed the 10-year would average about 4 percent over the next decade. We're already above that. So the fiscal hole is deeper than the official numbers suggest. Luna: There's also the question of who's buying all this debt. Foreign holdings have been relatively stable, but we've seen some rebalancing. China's share has been declining. Japan is still a big holder, but they have their own yield curve control issues. Lucas: And the Fed is still shrinking its balance sheet, albeit slowly. So the private market has to absorb a lot of supply. That means higher yields to attract buyers. It's a feedback loop. Luna: A quick honest thing — we do this show ad-free, and it's because a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's literally what funds making this many of these. Lucas: Yeah, if walking through the economy with us has made something click, that's the way to keep it going. No ads, no sponsors, just listener support. Luna: And it makes a real difference. So back to the yield curve — the 10-year minus 2-year spread is at 36 basis points. That's positive, which is what you'd expect in a normal economy, but it's narrowing again. Lucas: The narrowing suggests the market is a bit nervous about the near-term outlook. The 2-year is at 4.26 percent, the 10-year at 4.63. That's a relatively flat curve. It's not screaming recession, but it's not pricing in strong growth either. Luna: And the Fed is sitting at 3.63 percent on the effective fed funds rate. They've been on hold for months. But the market is starting to price in some easing next year, which seems at odds with the long-end yields staying elevated. Lucas: That's the tension. The front end is driven by expectations for Fed policy. The long end is driven by fiscal risk, term premium, and supply. And right now, the long end is winning the tug of war. Luna: I saw Kevin Warsh gave a speech yesterday. He's been one of the more hawkish voices. He apparently homed in on three key phrases that Fed watchers are parsing. Any read on that? Lucas: From what I've read, he stressed that the neutral rate may be higher than pre-pandemic, that fiscal policy is adding to demand pressures, and that the Fed shouldn't rush to cut. That all points to rates staying higher for longer, which is consistent with what the bond market is pricing. Luna: So if the Fed doesn't cut much, and the long end stays high, the interest expense problem compounds. Every year we delay fiscal consolidation, the debt grows faster. Lucas: Exactly. And there's no political appetite for austerity. Both parties have been running large deficits. The pandemic stimulus was necessary, but we never really tightened afterward. So we're left with this structural deficit that becomes self-reinforcing. Luna: There was a headline about import prices from China hitting their highest since 2008. That's a cost pressure that feeds into inflation, which keeps yields higher. It's all connected. Lucas: And the proposed tariffs on generic drugs from 2028 — that's a long lead time, but it signals that trade policy is still a factor. If tariffs push up prices, the Fed may have to keep rates higher, which again feeds the debt spiral. Luna: So what's the endgame? Do we just keep rolling over debt at higher rates until something breaks? Lucas: Something could break, but it's more likely a slow grind. The US has a lot of advantages — the dollar is the reserve currency, markets are deep, institutions are strong. But those advantages aren't infinite. If investors start demanding a higher term premium just to hold US debt, that's the canary. Luna: And we're already seeing that. The 30-year yield at 5.15 percent is a statement. The market is saying, 'We need more compensation for the risk of holding long-term US government debt.' Lucas: Right. And that's the key point for today. It's not about a crisis tomorrow. It's about the slow, compounding effect of higher borrowing costs on a massive debt stock. Every basis point matters when your debt is $39 trillion. Luna: I think that's a good place to leave it. The math is the math, and it's not going away. Lucas: Thanks for listening, everyone. We'll keep watching the yield curve.