Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Margin of Safety: Seth Klarman's Value Investing Philosophy
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. We're the show where we take a
- 0:02whole stack of sources, articles, research our own
- 0:05analysis and really boil it down to get you the key insights
- 0:08fast. To get you up to speed.
- 0:10Exactly. And today we're looking at an
- 0:13investor whose path seems almost predestined.
- 0:16You know, long before he probably knew what a stock was.
- 0:20Can you actually picture a four year old arranging his bedroom
- 0:23like a tiny shop? Price tags on toys.
- 0:26No way. Yeah, or picture this. 10 years
- 0:31old buys his first stock, Johnson and Johnson by 12.
- 0:34He's apparently calling his broker all the time.
- 0:37Wow, OK, that's not typical kids stuff.
- 0:39Not at all. It's not just a cute story,
- 0:40right? This is Seth Karman.
- 0:42And these little anecdotes, they kind of paint a picture of
- 0:44someone just born with this feel for commerce, for value.
- 0:47In an innate sense, almost definitely.
- 0:50So today our deep dive is all about him, the sort of enigmatic
- 0:54value investor Seth Klarman, and his, well, almost mythical book,
- 0:57Margin of Safety. Right, the one everyone talks
- 0:59about but can't easily get. Precisely.
- 1:01We're going to unpack his philosophy, dig into the kind of
- 1:04surprising story of the book itself, and then see how these
- 1:07ideas actually play out. Today at his firm, the Bob Post
- 1:10Group. We'll even peek at their latest
- 1:11public portfolio from Q 1/20/25. That's good.
- 1:16Our mission here is really to pull out the most crucial
- 1:19insights from all this material to help you understand what it
- 1:22really means to invest thoughtfully with real
- 1:24discipline. Yeah.
- 1:25Get to the core of it. But, and this is really
- 1:28important upfront, this whole deep dive, it's strictly for
- 1:30educational purposes. We're analyzing A philosophy, a
- 1:33really powerful 1, sure, but it is absolutely not financial
- 1:36advice. Any decisions you make about
- 1:37investing, they've got to be based on your own research, your
- 1:40own due diligence. Always.
- 1:41And just to add, all the analysis we talk about, it's
- 1:43based on publicly available info, could be interpreted
- 1:46differently. Things change.
- 1:47Good point. OK, let's dive in.
- 1:49You mentioned that innate sense. Yeah, it's fascinating, isn't
- 1:52it? How his story seems to prove his
- 1:53own point that value investing isn't just learned rules, it's
- 1:58more like an ingrained temperament.
- 2:01Something in your blood, as he apparently says.
- 2:03Exactly. He grew up in Baltimore Jewish
- 2:06family. His dad was a public health
- 2:08economist, his mom a psychiatric social worker.
- 2:11OK. So you see that blend analytical
- 2:13rigor from the dad. All right.
- 2:16And from the mom, maybe a deep understanding of human behavior
- 2:20psychology, which is. Pretty crucial for markets,
- 2:22wouldn't you say? Absolutely crucial.
- 2:24And those early stories where the bedroom store, the J&J stock
- 2:29and apparently he had a paper route, even a snow cone stand.
- 2:34A serial entrepreneur at age 10. Kind of seems like it.
- 2:37They really suggest this natural interest in business in value
- 2:42way before any formal training. Oh.
- 2:44Yeah, It makes you wonder, are some people just wired for this?
- 2:46He had the inclination, but then he obviously built on it.
- 2:49Education. Oh yeah, definitely hound it.
- 2:50He went to Cornell initially thought about math but switched
- 2:53to economics. Graduated Magna cum laude.
- 2:55Smart moves, probably. Good foundation.
- 2:57But even before Harvard Business School, he did something really
- 2:59pivotal, spent about 18 months working at the mutual shares
- 3:02fund. Under who?
- 3:04Undervalue investing legends Max Hein and Michael Price.
- 3:07Wow, talk about learning from the Masters.
- 3:10How important was that? Absolutely foundational.
- 3:12I mean working directly with guys steeped in the original
- 3:15Graham and Dodd thinking that grounds you in the real deal.
- 3:18Practical application, not just theory.
- 3:21Exactly. It solidifies everything which
- 3:23kind of reinforces his point about temperament, right?
- 3:25You can learn the rules, sure, but applying them consistently
- 3:28with that patients that risk aversion he has.
- 3:30Especially when the markets going crazy.
- 3:32Right. That's tough without that sort
- 3:34of innate disposition. Then, after mutual shares, he
- 3:37went to Harvard Business School, graduated as a Baker Scholar Top
- 3:40tier. And almost straight out of HBS
- 3:42in 82, the Bow post group starts up.
- 3:45The founding story there is pretty unique too, isn't it?
- 3:47It really is. He didn't just hang out his own
- 3:49shingle. He was recruited by one of his
- 3:51HBS professors, William Porvu. OK Porvu and some partners had
- 3:55pulled about $27 million from 4 founding families.
- 3:59They needed someone to manage it.
- 4:01And the name Bow Post, it's actually an acronym of those
- 4:03founders names. Didn't know that.
- 4:07And his starting salary? That tells the story, too.
- 4:09It really does. Reportedly just $35,000 a year,
- 4:13which was way less than other offers he had.
- 4:15So he wasn't chasing the quick buck?
- 4:17Nope. Betting on himself, clearly
- 4:19betting he could generate the returns, and maybe even more
- 4:22important, the firm's mandate right from the start was
- 4:25perfectly suited to him. How so?
- 4:27The goal was to, and I think this is a quote, thoughtfully
- 4:30invest, protect, and compound their wealth over multiple
- 4:33generations. Multiple generations, OK, that's
- 4:35patient capital. Extremely patient family
- 4:37capital, long term term focus, capital preservation baked in.
- 4:41It created the perfect incubator for his very risk averse style.
- 4:45Not your typical hedge fund chasing quarterly numbers.
- 4:48Build for the long haul. That structure seems key.
- 4:50Almost like an anti Wall Street setup.
- 4:52He seems pretty critical of the usual way things are done.
- 4:54Oh. Deeply critical.
- 4:55He talks about the obsession with short term performance.
- 4:58You know how it compares to the index this quarter?
- 5:00Right, the relative game. Yeah, and career risk managers
- 5:03just following the herd so they don't look bad.
- 5:05Plus the focus on marketing hype over actual business value.
- 5:08Yeah, Bowpost was intentionally built to avoid all that.
- 5:11How did that structure give him freedom?
- 5:14Well, fundamentally he wasn't judged against quarterly
- 5:16benchmarks. That meant he could hold huge
- 5:19amounts of cash, sometimes over half the portfolio if he didn't
- 5:21see good opportunities. Which most fund managers just
- 5:24can't do. They get fired.
- 5:25Exactly. He was willing to lag in a bull
- 5:28market. He famously called that the
- 5:30price to pay for protecting capital when things turn South.
- 5:33And it seems to have worked out. Those long term returns are
- 5:35pretty staggering. Yeah, averaging around what, 9,
- 5:381820% annually since they started.
- 5:41It's that structural freedom that patients that's a massive
- 5:44competitive edge. OK, so you've got this deeply
- 5:46ingrained philosophy, this perfectly aligned structure, and
- 5:50then he takes these ideas and puts them down in a book, Margin
- 5:53of Safety. Published in 1991.
- 5:54He was only 34. And the history of the book
- 5:56itself is almost like a value investment lesson, isn't it?
- 5:59It really is. You wouldn't believe it, but
- 6:01commercially it was a total flop initially.
- 6:03How? Bad A flop.
- 6:04Sold maybe 5000 copies at $25 bucks a pop.
- 6:08The publisher basically wrote it off.
- 6:10And now, decades later, it's like the Holy Grail.
- 6:13Completely reversed, long out of print first editions are
- 6:16collector's items. People pay thousands.
- 6:18I saw numbers like $2250 up to over $7800.
- 6:23Yeah, crazy prices. And apparently it's one of the
- 6:25most stolen books from libraries.
- 6:27That's hilarious. And yet, despite all that
- 6:29demand, Clarman will reissue it. Nope.
- 6:32Shows 0 interest. It's like the book itself
- 6:34followed his philosophy Overlooked Bargain becomes a
- 6:36sought after classic, the. Refusal to republish is almost a
- 6:39statement in itself, not driven by popularity or market noise.
- 6:42Exactly. It's a perfect metaphor.
- 6:44The book was this unpopular kind of out of favor asset.
- 6:47It's real value wasn't seen by the market.
- 6:50Until the thoughtful investors found it.
- 6:51Right over time the people who got it recognized it's worth and
- 6:54the prowl shot up because it's useful and scarce.
- 6:56His refusal just underlines his whole approach.
- 6:58Substance over hype. OK.
- 7:00Let's unpack that substance then the core idea, margin of safety.
- 7:04He got this from Ben. Graham.
- 7:05Directly from Graham. Yeah, the basic idea is simple.
- 7:08Buy something for significantly less than what you think it's
- 7:11truly worth. The old by a dollar for $0.50.
- 7:14That's the tagline, but Klarman takes it deeper.
- 7:18It's not just about finding bargains, it's the absolute
- 7:21bedrock of being risk averse. Why is it so essential in his
- 7:25view? Because, he argues, you're
- 7:27always facing three big hazards you can't avoid.
- 7:29One, you're human. You'll make mistakes in your
- 7:32analysis. OK, unavoidable. 2 Just plain
- 7:35bad luck can hit you. Stuff happens, right?
- 7:37And three, markets can go completely haywire.
- 7:40Extreme volatility. So the margin of safety is your
- 7:43buffer against all that. Precisely.
- 7:44And he really emphasizes that valuing a business isn't a
- 7:47science. He calls it an imprecise art.
- 7:50He even said any attempt to value businesses with precision
- 7:54will yield values that are precisely inaccurate.
- 7:56That's a great line. It basically builds in the
- 7:58assumption that you will be wrong sometimes.
- 8:00Exactly. It flips the script.
- 8:02Most strategies kind of assume you'll get the future right.
- 8:05Klarman assumes you'll often be wrong.
- 8:07So it's about intellectual humility, really admitting you
- 8:10don't know everything. Totally.
- 8:11The margin of safety let's an investment work out OK.
- 8:14Even if your forecast were too rosy or management messes up, or
- 8:17the market panics, it builds resilience right into the
- 8:20process. Very different from Wall
- 8:22Street's usual confidence. And he builds his whole
- 8:25philosophy around this using three main pillars, right?
- 8:28The first one is the bottom up approach.
- 8:30Yeah. This means you start and end
- 8:32with analyzing individual companies.
- 8:35Forget trying to predict the whole economy, which he thinks
- 8:37is basically impossible anyway. Focus on what you can know.
- 8:39Right, ask 2 questions. What's the specific business
- 8:42actually worth and can I buy it way cheaper than that?
- 8:45Keeps you away from the hype and the noise.
- 8:47Exactly. Shields you from market
- 8:48narratives. OK, that naturally leads to the
- 8:50second pillar. Absolute, not relative
- 8:53performance. This sounds like a direct shot
- 8:57at how most funds are run. It absolutely is.
- 9:00The goal isn't to beat the S&P 500 this quarter or this year.
- 9:03The goal is to make good returns positive returns over the long
- 9:08run period. Measured against your own goals,
- 9:10not some index. Precisely.
- 9:12It frees you up mentally. You don't have to worry about
- 9:14lagging the market in the short term if you're protecting
- 9:16capital, he said. Lagging a bull market is the
- 9:19price to pay for safety later. And as he says, you can't spend
- 9:22relative performance. Great quote, sums it up.
- 9:25It's about your money, not winning a race against an index.
- 9:29And the third pillar tying it all together, A deeply risk
- 9:33averse approach. This feels like the foundation.
- 9:36It is the core avoiding permanent loss of capital.
- 9:38That's priority number one. Everything else follows from
- 9:41that. So good steady returns with less
- 9:43downside are better than huge swings up and down.
- 9:46Mathematically, yes, over the long term and for him, risk
- 9:48isn't volatility. It's not beta like Wall Street
- 9:50uses. Risk is simply the chance you'll
- 9:52lose money permanently. And that risk is highest when
- 9:55prices are high. Exactly.
- 9:57Highest when you pay a high price, lowest when you pay a low
- 10:00price. Simple but profound.
- 10:03These three pillars, bottom up, absolute return, risk aversion.
- 10:07They work together. Like a system.
- 10:09Yeah, a self reinforcing system. It helps you stay patient, hold
- 10:13cash, wait for the right pitch, and avoid getting caught up in
- 10:16greed or fear or just following the crowd.
- 10:18OK, so that's the philosophy. How does he actually find these
- 10:20opportunities? What tools does he use for
- 10:22valuation? Well, first he avoids simple
- 10:24stuff like reported earnings per share.
- 10:26Too easy to manipulate. He prefers to triangulate using
- 10:30three main methods. OK, what are they?
- 10:32One is net present value or NPV analysis.
- 10:35Basically estimating future free cash flows conservatively and
- 10:39then discounting them back to see what they're worth today.
- 10:41Got it. Standard, but requires careful
- 10:43assumptions. Very conservative assumptions in
- 10:46his case. Second is liquidation value.
- 10:48What could you get for the assets if the company was broken
- 10:50up and sold off? He looks at a fire sale price
- 10:53really to find a floor. A worst case scenario value.
- 10:56Kind of, yeah. And 3rd is stock market value or
- 10:59sometimes called private market value.
- 11:02What would a smart business person, an industrialist, pay to
- 11:06buy the whole company outright? So different angles to get a
- 11:10range of what it might be worth. And where does he look for
- 11:13stocks that fit this? Not the usual popular names I
- 11:16guess. Definitely not.
- 11:17Opportunities pop up where other people aren't looking or maybe
- 11:20can't look because of fun rules, or where people are being forced
- 11:23to sell for reasons that have nothing to do with the company's
- 11:25value. Like institutional constraints
- 11:27or panic selling? Exactly.
- 11:28So it's inherently contrarian. He often finds fertile ground in
- 11:32complex situations. Distressed companies, maybe
- 11:34things going through bankruptcy, corporate spin offs, thrift
- 11:37conversions, stuff that needs deep digging and patience.
- 11:41Stuff others might avoid because it looks messy.
- 11:43Precisely places with perceived hair on them.
- 11:46Now, is it just about buying cheap and waiting, or is there
- 11:49something more active, something that pushes the value to be
- 11:52recognized? I'm thinking of the idea of a
- 11:55catalyst. Ah, yes, the catalyst that's
- 11:58absolutely key to his approach. It's not passive buy and hold
- 12:01forever. He actively looks for
- 12:03investments that have some kind of specific foreseeable event
- 12:06coming up, like what could be a restructuring, a company selling
- 12:09off assets, A merger, a big share buyback plan, something
- 12:12that will likely force the market to wake up and see the
- 12:15value. So it reduces the risk of owning
- 12:17a value trap, something that's cheap but just stays cheap.
- 12:20Exactly. It adds a win to the what It
- 12:22introduces a potential timeframe, time for the value to
- 12:25be realized. So he's not just asking is it
- 12:27cheap, he's asking why and when will the market recognize this
- 12:31value. That event driven focus makes
- 12:33Bow post very dynamic. OK, let's connect all this to
- 12:36bow post today. It's been going for over 40
- 12:38years. Manages what, 2629 billion
- 12:40dollars? And it seems like it still
- 12:42embodies these core ideas. Absolutely.
- 12:45The firm today is the living expression of the philosophy and
- 12:48margin of safety. They have this broad, flexible
- 12:50mandate. Meaning they can invest pretty
- 12:52much anywhere. Yeah, across public stocks,
- 12:54private equity, real estate, distressed debt globally, they
- 12:57call themselves opportunistic, value oriented, doing deep
- 13:01bottom up work to find mispricings wherever they occur.
- 13:04That flexibility must be huge. They can go where the bargains
- 13:07are regardless of asset class. It's a massive advantage.
- 13:10Capital flows to where the margin of safety looks greatest
- 13:12at that moment truly embodies that absolute return mindset.
- 13:15So if we look at the public stock portfolio, the part
- 13:18disclosed in the Q 1202513 F filing, which is about $3.5
- 13:23billion, does it reflect this? Oh, definitely.
- 13:26First thing you notice is concentration.
- 13:28The top 10 holdings make up nearly 80% of that public
- 13:30portfolio. Wow 79.29% that's high
- 13:33conviction they're putting big money by their best ideas.
- 13:36You bet. And looking at the major changes
- 13:37in Q1 gives us a good sense of where they were seeing value or
- 13:41maybe where value is fading. OK, let's hit some highlights.
- 13:43A big new position, Fidelity National Information Services,
- 13:46FIS jumped right into the top five, 7.46% weight.
- 13:51What's the likely story there? This looks like a classic
- 13:53Klarman play driven by a catalyst.
- 13:56FIS announced they're spinning off their Merchant Solutions
- 13:59business. The corporate Action Catalyst.
- 14:01Textbook. It creates a clear path to
- 14:03unlocking value. The market might be undervaluing
- 14:06the core banking tech business, which is pretty stable and
- 14:09recurring. The spin off should highlight
- 14:11that value, the sum of the parts.
- 14:12It's complex, but with a potential resolution.
- 14:15Makes sense. They also started a new position
- 14:17in elevance Health ELV healthcare always seems
- 14:21complicated. Lots of political noise feels
- 14:24contrarian you. Definitely feels contrarian.
- 14:26Healthcare is complex, always under regulatory scrutiny, which
- 14:29scares away many investors and often creates discounts.
- 14:32So perfect hunting ground for Klarman.
- 14:34Exactly, The bet is likely that Elevance is a solid cash
- 14:37generating business, but it's trading cheap because of those
- 14:40fears and complexities. I'll post probably figures the
- 14:43risks are overblown or the price more than makes up for them.
- 14:46An asymmetric bet more upside than downside.
- 14:49OK, on the sell side they cut back significantly on Liberty
- 14:52Global LBTYK down 37.5%. What is a big trim like that
- 14:57usually signal for a long term holder?
- 14:59It's just as informative as the buys.
- 15:01Liberty Global is a complex international cable media
- 15:04company. Maybe the original thesis played
- 15:06out partly or the discount narrowed.
- 15:08Or maybe the competitive landscape changed.
- 15:10Could be, or very likely Klarman simply found better
- 15:14opportunities elsewhere like FIS and Elevant offering a wider
- 15:17margin of safety right now, so they reallocated the capital.
- 15:20It shows it's active management, not just buy and forget.
- 15:23Right, constantly reassessing. Lastly, Willis Towers Watson.
- 15:27WTW they trimmed it about 17%, but it's still their largest
- 15:30public holding at nearly 15%. That signals real long term
- 15:34belief. Huge conviction still.
- 15:35Yeah, WTW is a global advisory and broking firm.
- 15:38Likely attractive because it's got a strong Moat.
- 15:40Stable business, lots of recurring revenue throws off
- 15:43good cash flow. Unknowable business.
- 15:45Very knowable, seems like not dependent on some crazy tech
- 15:49leap, even if some accounting numbers look weird due to past
- 15:52charges. Klarman's probably focused on
- 15:54the future earnings power and cash flow.
- 15:56Seeing a discount there, it's a classic case of owning a quality
- 16:00business long term as long as the price is right.
- 16:02It really paints such a consistent picture, doesn't it?
- 16:05From that kid with price tags on his toys, through the ideas and
- 16:08margin of safety, right up to Bellpo's portfolio today.
- 16:12It's just this unwavering line. Totally consistent.
- 16:15The risk aversion, the deep research, absolute returns,
- 16:19margin safety, they're not just concepts, they're how they
- 16:21operate day-to-day. It's the foundation of that
- 16:23incredible track record. Yeah, and looking at the
- 16:25holdings, it busts the myth that he's just some old guy buying
- 16:29statistically cheap stocks. Right.
- 16:30His idea of value is much more sophisticated, dynamic.
- 16:34He finds it in spin offs like FIS, in complex sectors like
- 16:37healthcare with elements. He's really applied Graham score
- 16:40principles smartly to today's market.
- 16:41Someone called it bringing a modern intellect to Graham's
- 16:44principles. That fits, and ultimately the
- 16:47real power seems to be how it all sits together.
- 16:49The temperament, patients. Discipline, Humility.
- 16:52Aligned with the philosophy in the book.
- 16:54And supported by the structure at bow post that long term
- 16:57flexible mandate, it's the whole system.
- 16:59Exactly. Person, principal and practice
- 17:01all working together. That's the defense against
- 17:04market craziness and the engine for compounding.
- 17:07For the thoughtful investor he wrote for, that's the lesson.
- 17:11It's disciplined, lifelong application of an honest, risk
- 17:14aware view. And that Klarman quote seems to
- 17:17sum it up. The single greatest edge an
- 17:19investor can have is a long term orientation.
- 17:23Powerful idea. So what does this mean for you?
- 17:25Listening. Think about that idea.
- 17:26Long term orientation. How does it apply beyond just
- 17:29stocks? Maybe to learning something new?
- 17:31Building your career? Any place where patience and
- 17:34sticking to principles pays off over time.
- 17:36Yeah. Where could you apply a margin
- 17:38of safety in your own life, maybe outside of finance?
- 17:40Interesting thought. Definitely something to chew on.
- 17:42We really hope this deep dive give you some solid insights
- 17:44into Clarkman's thinking. And just a reminder, this was
- 17:47all for educational purposes, it's not investment advice.
- 17:50Definitely do your own homework before making any investment
- 17:53decisions. Please do.
- 17:54And hey, if you found this useful, you can like and
- 17:56subscribe or on Apple, Spotify Podcasts and our YouTube channel
- 18:00Deep Value Investing. And don't forget, we've got a
- 18:02value investing book list on our main page if you want more
- 18:05resources. Great stuff.
- 18:07Thanks for joining us on this deep dive into Seth Klarman and
- 18:09the margin of safety. We'll get you next time.