Latest / The Vegan Report / Vegans Respond to Jordan Peterson. With John Sanbonmatsu | Ep. 91
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report. My name is Ryan
- 0:03and today we respond to an episode from the Jordan
- 0:07B. Peterson podcast posted on April 17 and titled,
- 0:12The Best Argument Against Veganism. For that
- 0:16episode, Dr. Peterson interviews Joel Salatin,
- 0:21co -owner of Polyface Farm and an outspoken proponent
- 0:25of regenerative animal farming. Joel Saliton
- 0:30happens to be featured in Chapter 8 of The Omnivore's
- 0:34Dilemma, the bestseller of author Michael Pollan.
- 0:38Both of them, Saliton and Pollan, have been instrumental
- 0:43in popularizing the idea that animal exploitation
- 0:48can be humane and ecological. To debunk this
- 0:52Jordan Peterson interview and set the record
- 0:56straight, I have with me the perfect guest, John
- 1:00Sanbonmatsu. John has written The Omnivore's
- 1:04Deception, which completely obliterates the Michael
- 1:08Pollan's Omnivore's Dilemma. The Omnivore Deception
- 1:12is a true animal rights classic, and I highly
- 1:16recommend it. I did a whole episode on it. Get
- 1:19a copy of the book, link in the episode's notes.
- 1:24And please share this episode everywhere. John
- 1:27called me an optimist. I don't know if one day
- 1:32we could hope to see Jordan become vegan, but
- 1:36at the very least I hope that his supporters
- 1:40and listeners get exposed to what is really veganism
- 1:45about. So spread the word. Every gesture of support
- 1:49is appreciated. Thank you so much. Let's start
- 1:54with talking about Bill. Let's talk about our
- 1:59fond memories of Bill. I remember the first time
- 2:02Bill Gates called me and told me, hey, Ryan,
- 2:07me and the other globalists feel strongly that
- 2:10you should start a podcast about veganism. And
- 2:14I'm sure he also called you to write your latest
- 2:18book. Yeah, Bill. Yeah, I was on the call with
- 2:21George Soros at the time, and I had to put George
- 2:25on hold in order to take the call from Bill.
- 2:29And he had left his his golf clubs at my Chateau.
- 2:33So we had to talk about that, too. Yeah, no,
- 2:35it's it's great to feel like we're part of the
- 2:38global conspiracy. I don't know how you feel
- 2:41about it, but I am gives me a sense of purpose.
- 2:46Yeah, I mean, When he when Jordan Peterson says
- 2:51that veganism and this whole push to reduce or
- 2:56stop eating animal products comes from a cabal
- 3:02of globalist elites So, you know we hear all
- 3:06this nonsense at high levels among the globalists
- 3:09about the fact that agriculture is a net pollutant
- 3:13and that we have to radically cut back, for example,
- 3:16on our meat consumption, which is something that's
- 3:18like, oh, I see. So everybody's going to have
- 3:20a little brain because they eat nothing but plants.
- 3:22That's your damn theory, right? And so, you know,
- 3:25you hear about these. Well, if we're all if we're
- 3:27all eating beans, that might solve the gas problem.
- 3:30Well, apparently Bill Gates has a solution to
- 3:33that. I just feel he's he doesn't know any vegan.
- 3:38in his life. As I do, he doesn't understand how
- 3:43much of a grassroots movement this is. And as
- 3:47someone who works in fundraising, I can tell
- 3:50you, I can attest to the fact that animal charities
- 3:54are struggling to get funding from the wealthiest,
- 3:59from foundations. This idea that reducing meat
- 4:03is popular and well -funded and part of a global
- 4:08agenda of some sort, it feels ridiculous when
- 4:11you're part of this community. Well, absolutely.
- 4:14But I mean, this idea of conspiracy of a small
- 4:19number of people is, of course, grounded ultimately
- 4:21in anti -Semitic tropes going back centuries,
- 4:26right? the propaganda around the so -called Protocols
- 4:32of the Elders of Zion, which is this document
- 4:35that supposedly showed that Jews met secretly
- 4:38to control everything. And I joked about George
- 4:40Soros because of course he's a Jewish billionaire
- 4:42philanthropist who gives money through the Open
- 4:45Society Foundation to liberal charities and stuff
- 4:49and parties. But in reality, as you point out,
- 4:56I mean, vegans are, first of all, a powerless
- 4:58minority. I'm sorry to give a spoiler alert to
- 5:02your audience. But it's important to understand
- 5:08or to acknowledge that the kinds of discourses
- 5:11that Jordan Peterson pervades have a long history.
- 5:17you know, of demonizing a small group and saying
- 5:20it's a conspiracy of elites and so forth. And
- 5:24it's quite striking in this right -wing environment
- 5:26where we see fascism rising in many different
- 5:29contexts around the world, particularly Europe
- 5:31and the United States, although not just there,
- 5:34that the demonization of anyone who descends
- 5:40from the status quo is accelerating, that demonization
- 5:46is accelerating. And it's interesting that veganism
- 5:48and animal rights has become a focal point. Governor
- 5:52DeSantis in Florida, for example, issued a proclamation
- 5:56talking about the global conspiracy, globalists
- 6:00want to take away people's meat and so on. So
- 6:03it's all tied up with all this other bad political
- 6:06stuff about domination of men over women and
- 6:09so on. It's a lot to unravel. And also the fact
- 6:12that veganism has been around for decades now.
- 6:16The vegan society, I think, was born just after
- 6:20World War II. And even before that, you had the
- 6:27vegetarian society, you had movements of communities
- 6:31of vegetarian people. And you can, you know,
- 6:35go back to the Middle Ages with characters like
- 6:39Al -Ma 'ri who was arguing for abstaining from
- 6:44animal products. He's a Syrian poet, again, from
- 6:48the Dark Ages. Yeah, so this feeling that you
- 6:53should abstain, that it is immoral to exploit
- 6:58animals has been with humanity since the beginning
- 7:02of time, like since hundreds, if not thousands
- 7:05of years. Well, thousands of years. I mean, the
- 7:08first person to call himself a philosopher or
- 7:11lover of wisdom, philosophia was Pythagoras,
- 7:14from whom we get the Pythagorean theorem. And
- 7:17the kind of cults that developed after his death
- 7:21were vegetarian. And part of that seems to have
- 7:25been an ethical critique of our violence against
- 7:27animals, because Ovid talks about it in the Metamorphoses
- 7:31centuries later. Plutarch and Porphyry or some
- 7:35other ancient thinkers who were talking about
- 7:38analytics. And also then from the eastern side
- 7:42in Hinduism and Buddhism and Jainism, we find
- 7:45critiques of our violence against animals and
- 7:48eating of animals literally for 2000 years. So
- 7:54yeah, this idea that it's some kind of conspiracy
- 7:57of PETA, for example, right? PETA is the kind
- 8:00of whipping boy or a lot of this stuff. or that
- 8:04it's a fad. No, it's not. It's been rooted in
- 8:08civilization for many, many years as an idea.
- 8:12But I think it's significant that it's become,
- 8:15as they say, so important in right -wing discourse.
- 8:20And I think it's precisely because it's kind
- 8:23of the linchpin that holds together the most
- 8:27destructive features of our civilization. Our
- 8:30domination over other animals becomes the basis
- 8:33for dominating other human groups. To vilify
- 8:40a group of people as animals or animal -like
- 8:43is to prepare the way for violence against them,
- 8:46including genocide. One of the first things that
- 8:48happened after the October 7th attacks is that
- 8:52Yoav Galant, the defense minister in Israel,
- 8:55referred to the people in Gaza as as human animals,
- 8:59you know, that's who they were fighting. And
- 9:00so you treat, because we treat non human animals
- 9:03as things to be destroyed, then you apply that
- 9:07to a social group or ethnic group, and that justifies
- 9:10the violence. So again, I don't think I mean,
- 9:13people think that the issues that we talk about,
- 9:16about animals is somehow trivial, but I really
- 9:19don't agree with that. I think that it's It's
- 9:22central to the whole apparatus of capitalist
- 9:25production and patriarchy and all these these
- 9:29things that are keeping humans in a kind of perpetual
- 9:32bondage of violence and misunderstanding and
- 9:36suffering Yes, and one last point about this
- 9:40idea of a conspiracy If vegans were that powerful
- 9:45with, you know, the global elites and all of
- 9:49the billionaires, and we had all of them as allies,
- 9:52then how come Big Ag is thriving right now? Yeah.
- 9:58No, I mean, it's just so absurd. And yet, as
- 10:04the saying goes, a lie will travel halfway around
- 10:07the world while the truth is still pulling on
- 10:09its trousers. I mean, it's It's a topsy -turvy
- 10:15environment. We're going to be talking about
- 10:17Jordan Peterson, but one thing that struck me
- 10:20not for the first time was just how wacko his
- 10:24views are about climate change. He's a conspiracy
- 10:28theorist. He says that arguably some of the carbon
- 10:36emissions warming the planet are human produced.
- 10:39Arguably, there's no argument But because he's
- 10:43very glib and very, you know, he has a PhD and
- 10:47he's very confident in his own skin, it's amazing
- 10:51how easy it is to fool people who want to be
- 10:55fooled. I think that's really important. It's
- 10:56not just that he's glib and he's a good propagandist
- 10:59and ideologue. He's speaking to the worst parts
- 11:03of the human personality and people who want
- 11:05to believe the lies, really lies that he's purveying.
- 11:11Yes, let's talk about climate change. He does
- 11:15bring some interesting points about climate change.
- 11:21And I want to start with this. You don't need
- 11:25to be a climatologist to understand the impact,
- 11:30the negative impact of animal farming on the
- 11:33environment. If you just, you know, go and visit
- 11:37rural areas and pay attention or have this discussions
- 11:41with people living in those areas about the impact
- 11:46of livestock farming on the ecosystem, you would
- 11:51realize quite quickly, that it is a very negative
- 11:56impact. So, yeah, there've been studies about
- 11:58this that, for example, grazing animals, however,
- 12:04wisely, that's quote stewardship is the results
- 12:07in something like a 75 % biodiversity loss. Now
- 12:12all for to be sure all forms of agriculture are
- 12:17ecologically damaging one way or the other. I
- 12:19mean, but the lowest impact is vegan farming
- 12:23without any animal inputs. As soon as you have
- 12:27animal inputs in there, in addition to committing
- 12:30injustices against the animals, you've just created
- 12:33new inefficiencies that simply weren't there
- 12:36before and are not required. So one of the things
- 12:40that was interesting about the Peterson interview
- 12:43with Saliton is this claim that Well, there have
- 12:48always been ruminants who have been producing
- 12:50gases and why aren't all of these animal rights
- 12:56people and environmentalists concerned about
- 12:59the wild bison? We hear a lot of noise about...
- 13:04how cows are contributing to global warming,
- 13:07which, you know, is an idea that's really struck
- 13:09me as rather specious right from the beginning.
- 13:11Because, like, the buffalo did that, too? Like,
- 13:14I see, so huge herds of grazing animals are bad
- 13:18for the planet. That strikes me as highly unlikely.
- 13:21So, and I know they talk about methane, but,
- 13:23you know, people talk about a lot of things.
- 13:26Now, it wasn't clear whether they were only talking
- 13:29about the past or today, but I looked up the
- 13:31number of... these animals today. There are only
- 13:34six to nine million feral pigs, for example,
- 13:37wild pigs in the United States, and I think 20
- 13:40,000 or 30 ,000 wild bison. So we're talking
- 13:44about an order of magnitude, more than an order
- 13:47of magnitude of cows and sheep and pigs and so
- 13:50forth. I think 130 million pigs are killed every
- 13:53year in the United States and over 30 million
- 13:56cows. millions of sheep, and then the billions
- 13:59of chickens. In addition to their suffering,
- 14:03we have to look at the enormous ecological impact,
- 14:05which I read somewhere is something like 400
- 14:08pounds of carbon emissions per capita in the
- 14:10United States. Humans eating chickens causes
- 14:13that. So again, it's like this Orwellian inversion
- 14:17of the facts. But as I explained in my book,
- 14:21it's really about bad faith. It's like people
- 14:24wanting to believe that they can by embracing
- 14:28regenerative animal agriculture or smaller scale
- 14:32farming, that's somehow going to solve the ecological
- 14:36calamities that get produced. And as you say,
- 14:41if you live near a farm, maybe in your observant,
- 14:43maybe you notice this. But I'll tell you this,
- 14:46here in Massachusetts, there are You almost never
- 14:49see wild animals anymore. It's incredible. They've
- 14:52just been decimated by a whole variety of things
- 14:55and people just don't notice. So I think that
- 14:59most people seeing a denuded landscape or you'd
- 15:05have to... grown up in nature to really appreciate
- 15:10what's lost. And I think more and more people
- 15:12are growing up in completely synthetic and indeed,
- 15:14digital and virtual worlds where they don't even
- 15:18notice the losses that are piling up at our feet.
- 15:22Yes, and you go into that in the beginning of
- 15:25your book, actually, which, you know, it was
- 15:28a touching passage of the book. because we all
- 15:34had that experience at some level. It's environmental
- 15:38destruction is a trend, and it's kind of exponential.
- 15:45So yeah, we've all been affected with that. And
- 15:50let me add to what you said about those wild
- 15:55herbivores, big herbivores. Those creatures are
- 16:02part of an ecosystem that, you know, balances
- 16:06itself. This is not the case for the cows that
- 16:11we're farming, that we're exploiting. So add
- 16:15to this, you know, the the layer of how he's
- 16:19like ignoring the the ecosystem and the environment
- 16:23and the complexity of that whole question. Yeah,
- 16:26it's, you know, people talk about humans as being
- 16:31at the top of the food chain. And that's a very
- 16:34common way of understanding our place in nature.
- 16:37And it's completely not true. First of all, if
- 16:39you or I go into a swamp with an alligator or
- 16:42a crocodile, we're going to realize pretty quickly
- 16:44we're not at the top of any food chain. But beyond
- 16:48that, there's really, there's not that idea of
- 16:51a food chain. It's this vertical model of a hierarchy,
- 16:56but actually it's a food web. There are all these
- 16:59interconnected organisms, plants and animals,
- 17:03a kind of harmony that developed over the course
- 17:05of millions and millions of years, a billion
- 17:07years of evolution. And as you point out, the
- 17:10animal agriculture system is not part of that.
- 17:14It's this artificial thing that was just thrust
- 17:17into the terrestrial sphere, and it's destroying
- 17:21the web of life. It's consuming the web of life.
- 17:24It's the most ecologically destructive force
- 17:26on the earth, which people don't realize. That
- 17:28really drives me nuts. People think, well, global
- 17:30warming is the worst environmental disaster.
- 17:33First of all, that's not true. It's the mass
- 17:35species extinction crisis, which is even worse,
- 17:38which is partly caused by global warming. But
- 17:42animal agriculture and the fishing industry,
- 17:45put those together, they are the most destructive
- 17:47force on the earth, along with the capitalist
- 17:50system for sure, which is intertwined with it.
- 17:54But getting back to a point you made earlier,
- 17:57it's like the meat industry, the animal industry
- 18:00in general is so incredibly powerful that it
- 18:04papers over and occludes or covers over what
- 18:08are simply undeniable facts about the disappearance
- 18:13of species across the earth. depletion of topsoil,
- 18:23the dumping of nitrogen runoff into the oceans,
- 18:26which is causing algal blooms and killing fish.
- 18:30I mean, it just goes on and on. It's a cascade
- 18:32of catastrophes. And then along comes Joel Saliton,
- 18:37Michael Pollan, and these other critics and farmers
- 18:40who tell us, oh, there's a better way to do this.
- 18:44There's a way that we can have our meat and eat
- 18:47it too. even have our conscience and keep going
- 18:50along with the system. And it's just a kind of
- 18:53elaborate set of lies really and half truths,
- 18:57a mythology to reassure the consumer that things
- 19:00aren't as bad as you think and we're moving to
- 19:03a brighter future. And there isn't any future
- 19:07for life on this planet given this trajectory.
- 19:11There just isn't and people don't They won't
- 19:14realize it until there's no freshwater. All the
- 19:16freshwater aquifers in the United States are
- 19:19almost depleted, mostly due to animal agriculture.
- 19:23Even the American cities are sinking into the
- 19:25ground because the water has been taken up. Well,
- 19:29that water took God knows how many thousands,
- 19:31hundreds of thousands of years to get there,
- 19:33and it can't just be replenished. But it's like
- 19:37a dream world that we're all living in and not
- 19:40Not understanding that we're like, it's like,
- 19:43you know, use the metaphor of thin ice. We're
- 19:45skating along without understanding that there's
- 19:47just nothing beneath us, you know, as we begin
- 19:51falling. Yeah, that was a weird tension in the
- 19:55conversation or kind of a contradiction because
- 19:59here is Jordan Peterson making the point that
- 20:04we're not in a dire situation, ecological situation,
- 20:08but that the same time that you know, it was
- 20:12preferable to do sustainable farming, Allah,
- 20:19John Saliton. And then you think, which is it?
- 20:24Are we in an environmental crisis? And is, you
- 20:26know, the exploitation of animal causing destruction
- 20:30and havoc all around us? Or is, you know, the
- 20:34climate crisis a myth and we're not in a dire
- 20:38situation. But then, you know, what's the point
- 20:42of doing the kind of farming that John Salton
- 20:47is defending? Joel Salton, sorry. Yeah, thank
- 20:52you. No, that's really that's a great point.
- 20:57It's true. Like they want to have it both ways
- 21:00that they're trivializing. the environmental
- 21:03crisis, denying the basic facts of global warming,
- 21:06and yet at the same time, appealing to a broad
- 21:10swath of consumers, including a lot of liberal
- 21:13consumers, I would point out, who think that
- 21:16they are environmentalist and care about the
- 21:19earth and vaguely concerned about animal welfare,
- 21:22whatever, making these arguments at the same
- 21:23time that say, well, this is better for everybody.
- 21:28So it's an implicit acknowledgement, as you've
- 21:30said, of of a problem that needs to be fixed.
- 21:35And animal agriculture is a problem that needs
- 21:36to be fixed. It just can't be fixed. That's the
- 21:40issue. If you're going to have eight to 10 billion
- 21:42human beings on the earth, and you're going to
- 21:44try to provide them with literally trillions
- 21:47of dead animals, including sea life, without
- 21:54tearing up what I described as the web of life.
- 21:58without causing enormous suffering to the beings
- 22:01through this mass violence. It simply can't be
- 22:04done. I mean, just prima facie. As I say, at
- 22:07the first glance, it can't be done. And on examination,
- 22:10it can't be done. Nor should it be done. I mean,
- 22:14even if there was a way to, as Salvaton claims,
- 22:17to have forms of animal agriculture where the
- 22:20animals thrive for a brief period of time, There's
- 22:25a contradiction involved in saying that you care
- 22:28about the quality of the lives of the animals,
- 22:31and then you're going to inflict extreme violence
- 22:33against them. You're going to kill them. Well,
- 22:36if their lives are meaningful or worthwhile,
- 22:40then how can you kill them like that? How can
- 22:43you kill them when they're juveniles also? They're
- 22:44young animals. They're not like a chicken in
- 22:47the wild can live, I think, up to 15 years or
- 22:49more. not the bioengineered ones that Saladin
- 22:54uses, but, you know, in their natural habitat.
- 22:58And correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that
- 23:00many chickens are killed in like six weeks, but
- 23:03certainly within months. So yeah, again, I keep
- 23:08coming back to the word Orwellian because it's
- 23:10the way that these folks use language and manipulate
- 23:14the information, the facts to suit their arguments.
- 23:22It reminds me of totalitarianism, honestly. And
- 23:26in a way, we live in a totalitarian culture vis
- 23:29-a -vis other species. It's just taken for granted
- 23:32that doing these things to other animals is natural
- 23:35and right. And so everyone goes along with it.
- 23:40Yeah, I found it so revealing that Soliton kept
- 23:46making the point that the best skill you could
- 23:51develop in your life is communication and the
- 23:54mastery of language. And he said the secret of
- 23:57his success and the success of his farm, I think
- 24:01it's called polyface. Polyface. What a funny
- 24:06name. When you think of the hypocrisy of his
- 24:10arguments and his words, but Yeah, the secret
- 24:17of that success was marketing and the relationship
- 24:22he was developing with his clients. I have moms
- 24:27come up to me with their little 10 -year -old
- 24:29in tow. My son wants to be a farmer or daughter
- 24:32wants to be a farmer. What would you suggest
- 24:34to them? the amateur theater group, enroll them.
- 24:39Right, right, right, right. Get them, get them.
- 24:42So counterintuitive, Dave. Yes, and they look
- 24:44at me like, yeah, become a storyteller. Storytellers
- 24:49are what change the world. Yeah, right, that's
- 24:51exactly right. And so, obviously, 82, this is
- 24:55before computers, before internet, any of this
- 24:58stuff, and so we basically did a three -prong
- 25:00approach. I put together a slide program. you
- 25:05know, the old Kodak carousel, you know, a slide
- 25:08projector. And at that time, every city had a
- 25:11very vibrant kind of, you know, philanthropy,
- 25:15you know, Rotary Club, Ruritan, Kiwanis, Elks,
- 25:20Toastmasters, Elks, Moose, right. And they do,
- 25:23you know, weekly or monthly dinner meetings.
- 25:26And they're always looking for an interesting
- 25:27program. And so I put together a carousel program,
- 25:31how we can heal the planet with pastor -based
- 25:33livestock. And so, yes, it very much, you know,
- 25:37echoes the point you're making. Call it marketing.
- 25:42I'll call it lies. Yeah, it's interesting. I'm
- 25:47forgetting the name of the fellow who created
- 25:49the very term public relations, but he had been
- 25:54originally to help during the first or second
- 26:00World War. I'm so, so bad with this at the moment.
- 26:02I can't remember. But what is that difference?
- 26:06Propaganda is simply mass psychological manipulation.
- 26:09Well, that's what marketing is. You get people
- 26:13to think that they want something. You get people
- 26:16to think they need something, and then they buy
- 26:19it. So Saliton brags about the fact that he spent
- 26:23his life committing acts of violence against
- 26:26animals and then basically manipulating people
- 26:28into thinking that it's okay and it's just, it's
- 26:33good for the environment. I mean, it's just ludicrous.
- 26:36You can't even, I mean, you couldn't scale up
- 26:38Saliton's farm anyway. I mean, it's a big enough
- 26:41operation where they're killing hundreds, thousands
- 26:43of animals every year. But even so, they're just,
- 26:47first of all, there isn't enough land on the
- 26:48earth to do the kinds of things he's talking
- 26:50about. And second of all, the way that capitalism
- 26:55works as a system, and he's a libertarian, so
- 26:58he's not critical of the system, right? Is that
- 27:01as Marx pointed out 200 years ago, It's built
- 27:05to create monopolies. Because the system is based
- 27:09on competition, the bigger the company has the
- 27:14advantage and it gobbles up the smaller company
- 27:16and so on. And you can look at every sphere of
- 27:18society and see every industry, whether the military
- 27:21industrial complex or the media industry or the
- 27:25meat industry. And you see companies getting
- 27:28bigger and bigger and bigger over the last, especially
- 27:30the last 30 years. This notion that we're going
- 27:33to go back to small -scale animal farming, the
- 27:36small family farm, it's ridiculous because the
- 27:41economic pressures are going in the exact opposite
- 27:44direction. Look at Nyman Ranch. Bill and Nicole
- 27:47Nyman ran this enterprise of selling so -called
- 27:52pasture -raised organic animal products. and
- 28:00they were the toast to the liberal intelligentsia
- 28:02in the United States, given a lot of real estate
- 28:04in the op -ed pages of the New York Times. Well,
- 28:07they sold that, I think, to Coleman beef, and
- 28:09then that was bought by, eventually, the chicken
- 28:12operation, maybe the beef operation, too, were
- 28:15bought by Purdue. Now, Purdue, of course, is
- 28:17one of the largest killers of chickens in the
- 28:22world, as well as a huge corporate polluter.
- 28:26They employ child labor. immigrant child laborers
- 28:30who would get injured or killed on the assembly
- 28:33line, this assembly line and slaughterhouses.
- 28:37So, well, that's not an accident. I mean, you
- 28:40know, that's simply the free market, right? So
- 28:45again, like if you accept all of these premises
- 28:49about natural hierarchy, about God having created
- 28:53a capitalism really to help us out, I mean, then
- 28:57there's a certain logic to the arguments. But
- 28:59if you don't accept these flawed premises, then
- 29:02the whole thing, the conclusions fall apart.
- 29:06So I haven't looked into the mind of salt. And
- 29:10I'm pretty sure he understands that he, you know,
- 29:14he's a smart guy. I think he knows that his model
- 29:18cannot be reproduced at scale. And capitalism
- 29:23is smart in that way, you know, It identified
- 29:26the demand for animal products and it conceived
- 29:30a way to Respond to that demand in the most efficient
- 29:35way and that's how we have factory farming I
- 29:38think they've already you know questioned themselves
- 29:41Can we can we adopt a soliton model and the answer
- 29:45was obviously? No, and the fact that you preach
- 29:50to people, you know go into rural areas and invest
- 29:55in homesteading and you can have your backyard
- 29:58chickens and so on. Well, most people cannot
- 30:01even afford a house. How do you want them to
- 30:05be able to afford that lifestyle? And let's not
- 30:11even talk about the lifestyle. Let's just talk
- 30:13about the products that he sells. I did not look
- 30:17into the price tag, but I'm pretty sure those
- 30:21are not, you know, the cheap products you find
- 30:23in your local grocery shop. You know, it's interesting.
- 30:27I had a, I was part of a debate on Earth Day
- 30:30a couple of years ago at Boston College here
- 30:33in Massachusetts. And I was debating a farmer
- 30:38and an academic at Tufts University who has this
- 30:43large medium -sized animal farm here in Massachusetts
- 30:47and has this whole glib presentation about regenerative
- 30:53agriculture and all these buzzwords. And even
- 30:58she acknowledged that this is not necessary,
- 31:00that the animal inputs are there because she
- 31:03likes to eat meat and her consumers, her clients
- 31:05like to eat meat and it has this exorbitant price
- 31:09tag. And what she said is, I believe as I recall,
- 31:12is something that I've heard before, which is
- 31:14that, well, the fact that only rich people or
- 31:17whatever upper middle class people can afford
- 31:20these products and who seek out these products.
- 31:24Well, the price tag helps us reduce our meat
- 31:28consumption, you see, because the problem is,
- 31:32you know, Michael Pollan makes this argument,
- 31:34you know, we should we should eat less meat,
- 31:36but higher quality. But of course, it doesn't
- 31:39reduce demand at all. I mean, all it does is
- 31:42create a new niche market of a boutique meat
- 31:48and boutique animal products for wealthy people.
- 31:51So yeah, it comes with a high price tag. And
- 31:53so it can't compete with lower priced products
- 32:00turned out by JBS or Purdue or. any of these
- 32:05other mega companies. But again, it's not really
- 32:07meant to. It's simply, it's in parallel, right?
- 32:12And this, by the way, I'd say this is also a
- 32:14problem with some vegan, consumer -oriented vegan.
- 32:20Yeah, there's this kind of naiveté even among
- 32:24some vegans that the capitalist market will somehow
- 32:29create vegan alternatives that will convince
- 32:32people to change their diets and so on. But if
- 32:35you look at what's been happening over the last
- 32:3820 years, there are more vegan products than
- 32:41ever, specialty products, vegan cheeses and meats
- 32:46and so forth, and yet per capita meat consumption
- 32:49is up. More animals being killed than before.
- 32:52And in fact, some of the very companies like
- 32:55Maple Leaf Foods in Canada, the largest meat
- 33:00packing company in Canada, they've taken over
- 33:02the vegan product line of field roast. So we
- 33:09have to take a system -wide view, a systemic
- 33:11view of the problem and understand the forces
- 33:15that are pushing calamitous forms of animal agriculture.
- 33:22So again, all this is to say that Joel Soliton's
- 33:26polyphase farm, apart from the problems of the
- 33:30farm, the violence at the farm, the suffering
- 33:32of the animals and degradation of the animals
- 33:34on his farm, apart from Joel Saliton's lies or
- 33:39his mythologies about what happens, even that
- 33:43is all to the side and inconsequential next to
- 33:46monopoly capitalism and the juggernaut of these
- 33:51immensely powerful billion -dollar companies
- 33:53that are keeping humans addicted to these products
- 33:58that are disastrous for animals and for the earth
- 34:01and for human health. But I think the thing is
- 34:05that someone like Soliton and also Michael Pollan,
- 34:08who are criticized in my book, or Temple Grandin,
- 34:11these figures are enormously important for the
- 34:16kind of ideological reinforcement that's necessary
- 34:19to keep people from questioning the system. As
- 34:22long as in the back of the consumer's mind, they
- 34:24can think, oh, well, if I had the money or the
- 34:27time, I'd go and buy humanely raised pasture
- 34:30-based whatever, cage -free, et cetera. But you
- 34:34know, I'm in a hurry and I'm gonna take the kids
- 34:36to McDonald's. So we're just gonna eat there.
- 34:39So it kind of gets them off because they think
- 34:41that deep inside, they're a good person who would
- 34:43choose this other realm. And in fact, it doesn't
- 34:46matter. I mean, there's been plenty of investigations
- 34:48as you know of Chipotle and other companies that
- 34:53have been supposedly sourcing humane, humanely
- 34:57raised chickens and so on. And it's a scam. I
- 35:02mean, the animals are putting gas chambers in
- 35:05some cases on organic farms and the direct action
- 35:09everywhere and others have looked at the supply
- 35:12chain. found, you know, animals, terribly abused
- 35:17and suffering. So the it's just it's interesting
- 35:22that this one idea that we should just not harm
- 35:26our other fellow creatures is so radical, just
- 35:30the idea so radical that it has to be stamped
- 35:34down as quickly and as aggressively as possible.
- 35:38Right? Yes. You mentioned how some vegans have
- 35:45decided to bet on the capitalist market to, you
- 35:51know, advance the cause. And, you know, this
- 35:55is just a window into how diverse the vegan movement
- 36:01is, how there are people like you, John, and
- 36:05then there are others who, you know, support,
- 36:09you know, free market. models. There are conservative
- 36:15vegans, believe it or not, Jordan. There are
- 36:17plenty of conservative vegans out there. I had
- 36:20one of them, Liam Gray, who founded the Wilberforce
- 36:24Institute. You have vegans of all religion. There
- 36:30are plenty of Christian vegans. I invited Daniel
- 36:34Mascarenas, who's studying to become a Catholic
- 36:37priest. Just like we have Hindu vegans and Buddhist
- 36:42Vegans, you know, I'm one of them here and you
- 36:46know the fact that they love to Just generalize
- 36:52and make us into this monolith Is just so frustrating
- 36:58Yeah, they're missing out and You know coming
- 37:04back to global warming You mentioned how the
- 37:10negative impacts of fishing, I should say, most
- 37:14plastic in the ocean is a byproduct of those
- 37:18fishing operations. That is a fact that most
- 37:22people don't know about. They think it's straws,
- 37:25Starbucks straws. It's not. We also mentioned
- 37:29farming and how not all farming is livestock
- 37:34farming, of course, but also Most crops go to
- 37:40livestock, so most of the non -livestock farming
- 37:45that we do, the growing of crops, is not for
- 37:48human consumption, even though there is famine
- 37:52on earth. We send that to fatten the cows instead
- 37:58of our fellow human beings. And I guess I don't
- 38:04want to overlook one particular point that Jordan
- 38:08Peterson makes, which is that plants love CO2,
- 38:13and whatever CO2 emitted by humans will be counterbalanced
- 38:19by kind of a growth spur of plants. Well, one
- 38:22of the things that's really struck me as incomprehensible
- 38:26about the carbon debate is, so I know, for example,
- 38:30that over the last 30 years, something like that,
- 38:33the planet has greened quite radically, especially
- 38:37in semi -arid areas. And that seems to be a consequence
- 38:41of increased atmospheric carbon dioxide, some
- 38:45of which is arguably human -made. But the net
- 38:48consequence of that, it's so interesting to see,
- 38:51is immense green. It's something like 20 % of
- 38:54the Earth's area, which is like, that's a lot.
- 38:57And the fact that it's in semi -arid areas means
- 39:00that exactly the desert -like areas that we're
- 39:03supposed to expand, according to the climate
- 39:06doomsayers have actually shrunk. And then, and
- 39:09I've been thinking that through. Again, more
- 39:12recently, I talked to Patrick Moore, for example,
- 39:15and he was one of the founders of Greenpeace.
- 39:18And Moore has produced these, he's not the only
- 39:19one, but he's produced these graphs of carbon
- 39:21dioxide levels across like 500 million years
- 39:25instead of 250. And we're definitely at a carbon
- 39:28dioxide low. And so if we tap it up even a little
- 39:31bit, it makes a big difference. But that's all
- 39:33to say that plants like carbon dioxide a lot.
- 39:38And then when there's more of it, They grow and
- 39:41sequester it. You know, this was the most replayed
- 39:45part of his video and podcast episode. I guess
- 39:51people felt compelled by that argument. What
- 39:56do you make of it, John? Again, you know, the
- 39:58problem with these kinds of arguments and these
- 40:01kinds of platforms and podcasters is that they
- 40:05it's just it's spreading lies by algorithm. at
- 40:10the speed of light. I mean, there's a lot of
- 40:12literature on this by media studies people and
- 40:15sociologists and political scientists and others
- 40:18looking at the way these lies are just inundating
- 40:23people's media environments. So it's certainly
- 40:28true. I mean, there's some evidence that the
- 40:32more CO2 develops that that of course encourages
- 40:36plants who thrive in a CO2 rich environment,
- 40:40but there's a study in Nature in 2021 that looked
- 40:43into this. And so that's true, but it's also
- 40:45the case. And during the same period that they
- 40:47studied, like a 20 year period, I think, carbon
- 40:51emissions increased and the amount of carbon
- 40:55in the environment increased. So it's true that
- 40:59plants do sequester some carbon, but remember
- 41:01that animal agriculture is the greatest destroyer
- 41:04of of habitat and biodiversity on the earth.
- 41:10The rainforest in the Amazon is being burned
- 41:13down in order to graze cattle for JBS suppliers.
- 41:18So when people eat a hamburger in North America
- 41:22or Europe, it's possible it came from the Amazon
- 41:27and that's destroying the basis of life for mammals
- 41:31and reptiles and also in birds and so on. So
- 41:38the fact that plants absorb carbon dioxide and
- 41:41that they're absorbing more doesn't offset the
- 41:46overall problem, which is that the gases are
- 41:51building up in the atmosphere. Methane is something
- 41:53like 1 ,000 times more potent. I can't remember.
- 41:57I don't want to get misquoted. I'll just say
- 41:59it's many times more potent. a greenhouse gas
- 42:03than carbon dioxide, but it doesn't stay in the
- 42:05atmosphere for, you know, as long, not nearly
- 42:07as long. You know, carbon dioxide can be up there
- 42:09for centuries. So, again, it's Orwellian. I mean,
- 42:17my friend Troy Vitezi, the environmental historian,
- 42:20he and Drew Pendergrass have looked at the, done
- 42:23the math on this, and Troy had an article called
- 42:27to freeze the Thames River. which I highly recommend,
- 42:32and he pointed out that animal agriculture has
- 42:37basically deforested the earth. And if we got
- 42:41rid of animal agriculture and we got rid of the
- 42:43monocrops that are being fed to the animals so
- 42:46that we can then eat the animals, right, we could
- 42:49reforest the earth and sequester, you know, I
- 42:52think he said 215 gigatons of carbon that way.
- 42:55So it would be a natural way to geoengineer our
- 43:00way at least partly out of the global warming
- 43:02crisis. So, but you can't get there by turning
- 43:07over more land to pasture. I mean, the reason
- 43:10that we have quote factory farms and feed lots
- 43:14and so forth is simply for capitalist efficiencies.
- 43:19And ironically, animals raised on feed lots produce
- 43:23fewer carbon emissions than ones who are grazed
- 43:27on land. So there's not enough land for the pasture
- 43:33stuff. It takes enormous amounts of water and
- 43:38resources, other resources. So it's ridiculous
- 43:44to think that the plants, by absorbing more carbon,
- 43:47are going to get us out of this crisis. It's
- 43:49simply not true. you have eyes. Again, look around
- 43:58you, look at your neighborhood. The few green
- 44:03spaces that existed have most likely been built
- 44:09into condos or some kind of commercial building.
- 44:16We've seen that in Canada. I've had that conversation
- 44:18with Liz White, the leader of the Animal Protection
- 44:21Party of Canada, on how we're losing all of our
- 44:26wetlands across Canada because we are in this,
- 44:31you know, home crisis. So we need to build more
- 44:37apartments and so on. And yet, I mean, if there
- 44:42are no plants, then how are we going to sequester
- 44:46all of that CO2? If it's asphalt everywhere,
- 44:52then you know, how are we going to go about this?
- 44:56Well, yeah, if I may, I just want to say that
- 44:58the nature of capitalism is to turn all of nature
- 45:01into a commodity. You know, the caps production
- 45:05is organized not around meeting human need, let
- 45:08alone non human need, right, but about producing
- 45:11profit for private companies and individuals.
- 45:14That's simply a fact. That's not, you know, shouldn't
- 45:18seem controversial to anyone. So the only reason
- 45:20that meat is produced or milk is exploited, taken
- 45:26from cows, is to produce profit for the companies
- 45:29that own them. That's the only reason. And the
- 45:32longer this continues, the more ecologically
- 45:35devastating it is. And the people are so wedded
- 45:40to these kinds of myths about natural human domination,
- 45:44the inferiority of other species, you know, we
- 45:47treat them as kind of between slaves and things.
- 45:51They're not quite things. We recognize they have
- 45:54something that's not like a thing, but we see
- 45:59them as, quote, subhuman. And so we've organized
- 46:02the whole global economy around that. But all
- 46:08that is to say, sorry, I got off my own track
- 46:11here that If you are going to be a free market
- 46:17advocate, then you have to understand that that
- 46:19comes with total ecological ruin of the planet.
- 46:24I mean, that's what's happening. All the animals
- 46:27on the earth are dying, reptiles, amphibians,
- 46:30birds, mammals, insects, all the conscious life
- 46:36in the oceans being removed, killed. killed off
- 46:41and that's because of the profit motive and not
- 46:43just the profit motive but the very dynamics
- 46:45of the capitalist system which require through
- 46:48competition of a racist cannibalization of the
- 46:53earth's resources. So the idea of sustainable
- 46:56capitalism that is an oxymoron. It's just, we
- 47:00have the facts. People talk about regulating
- 47:02capitalism. What are they talking about? We've
- 47:04had 500 years of efforts to regulate capitalism,
- 47:07actually, in one way or another, and it hasn't
- 47:10worked, can't work. So, but it's so bizarre.
- 47:15I mean, people will go down with this ship. They
- 47:17really will, clinging to some, like Peterson,
- 47:21great example, clinging to some reactionary conception
- 47:26of masculinity. He'll go down with that ship,
- 47:29you know, you can show him that it's, it's bad
- 47:32in a million ways, but no, and I got to have
- 47:36my meat and that's part of my masculinity. And,
- 47:38you know, so the earth dies, it's the earth is
- 47:41being swept with droughts and floods and fires
- 47:44and category five storms and typhoons. And, you
- 47:48know, but the propaganda system is so intense
- 47:54and intensive and growing that people can't see
- 47:58outside it. I find it really frightening. And
- 48:01here in the US, of course, we find the growth
- 48:02of this fascist populist right -wing authoritarian
- 48:06movement that is part and parcel of domination
- 48:10of all vulnerable groups, from non -human animals
- 48:13to immigrants to trans people to women. And it's
- 48:17all of a whole cloth. All of these threads come
- 48:20together in one web of domination. And the space
- 48:26for dissent like this conversation, the space
- 48:29for dissent at the university is shrinking, it's
- 48:32narrowing constantly. So yeah, I mean, Jordan
- 48:37Peterson found fame because of his defense of
- 48:42free speech. Now, animal rights activists are
- 48:47persecuted in Canada. We have ag -gag laws passing
- 48:51at a provincial and federal level to just, you
- 48:55know, shut us up forever. And you know, I did
- 49:00not see him bravely taking the defense of animal
- 49:05rights activists, talking about how this is such
- 49:09a blatant violation of free speech and of democratic
- 49:14values in Canada. Yet it is and there's nothing
- 49:18equating that I mean if you apply the same standards
- 49:25to let's say investigative journalists the world
- 49:28would be in in fire fire of outrage and It's
- 49:34not you know, because we're talking about vegans
- 49:37vegans who want to share images of what's happening
- 49:40inside slaughterhouses and they can't they can't
- 49:44and they risk like heavy prison sentences because
- 49:50of that and Yeah, here he is talking about pronouns
- 49:55and how there are laws, you know compelling Canadians
- 49:58to use pronouns. Well What about that other part?
- 50:02What about that other infringement on free speech?
- 50:05Are we not going to address it? But I after watching
- 50:11that conversation I I really felt like Well,
- 50:15first of all, Joel Saliton makes the point that
- 50:19his one goal as a businessman is to please his
- 50:26clientele. No sale is an end to itself. Every
- 50:29sale is a springboard for the next sale. Right,
- 50:32of course. You cannot stay in business finding
- 50:35new customers. The only way you stay in business
- 50:39is to please the customers you have. enough that
- 50:43they buzz and tell people about it and bring
- 50:45them back to you. And that's a long -term relationship.
- 50:47That's akin to a friendship relationship. You
- 50:49don't want to play with someone once. Which is
- 50:51why you don't want to irritate somebody at your
- 50:54lectures or your presentations. Yeah, because
- 50:56they're already in the camp. They're the last
- 50:58people you want to irritate. Exactly, exactly.
- 51:01They've done all the work coming to you. You
- 51:03need to do backflips to make them happy. And
- 51:05so how can you trust someone who has been captured
- 51:09by, you know, monetary interests like that. That's
- 51:14my first point. He's not an independent voice.
- 51:18And then I want to know if this was an advertisement
- 51:22for polyphase form. I think it's most likely
- 51:29the case that he had a deal with Daily Wire or
- 51:37the Jordan Peterson podcast to appear and promote
- 51:41his farm through a conversation. I feel strongly
- 51:48that it might be the case. You know, I don't
- 51:51know enough about Peterson. I know as much as
- 51:54I want to know. But I didn't realize that he'd
- 51:56gotten his start supposedly defending free speech.
- 51:59But it is interesting the way that that discourse
- 52:04is being used by the far right, Charlie Kirk
- 52:08being another example. And basically under the
- 52:10banner of free speech, what they're doing is
- 52:13what Kirk was doing and what Peterson is still
- 52:16doing is making room for hate speech. So when
- 52:19Elon Musk talks about free speech, that's what
- 52:21it means. Because originally the idea of free
- 52:23speech was actually to create a space for dissent
- 52:27against absolutist monarchs or repressive states.
- 52:34But now, what when people hear the word or say
- 52:38the word, the term free speech, what they really
- 52:40mean is, we want to be able to use speech as
- 52:45a weapon as part of a project of denying civil
- 52:48and human rights to, you know, vulnerable groups
- 52:51of people. That's what they mean by free speech.
- 52:55It's not about freeing speech, it's about freeing
- 52:58hate, misogyny, racism, And there are certain
- 53:03forms of speech that we should not engage in.
- 53:06I'm not talking about state laws, necessarily.
- 53:09That's a different issue, whether the state had
- 53:12interest in censoring or monitoring speech. I'm
- 53:17saying that I should not engage in speech that's
- 53:20hurtful to others, whether it's my kid or some
- 53:23group. But that falls out. I just wanted to stay
- 53:26of the picture completely. Yeah, so I guess the
- 53:32question is, what do we do about all of this?
- 53:35And now I'm going to turn the tables on my interviewer
- 53:38and ask, what's the solution to this? I don't
- 53:43have the solution to this. I'm a simple podcaster,
- 53:47but, you know, I think having this conversation
- 53:51already, you know, and discussing this publicly
- 53:56for the sake of free speech, you know, and I
- 54:00I invite Jordan Peterson or his people to invite
- 54:03you or invite Liam Gray if you want someone who's
- 54:08more conservative but shares our ideal of a vegan
- 54:12world on your podcast. Expose yourself to different
- 54:20opposing views. What's the harm in that? And
- 54:25so I challenge him to do that. I want to end
- 54:32this conversation with an important point. You
- 54:36mentioned how, you know, there is animals are
- 54:40treated often as slaves and perceived as such,
- 54:44you know, as objects by those people, those farmers.
- 54:50Now, Jordan and Joel Saliton agreed in that conversation,
- 55:00that animals are smart and are sensitive. A few
- 55:04examples, Joel mentions how rotating electric
- 55:08fences, so he uses that to replace herding. How
- 55:15cows are shocked by those electric fences and
- 55:20hate that and learn from that experience that
- 55:24they should not approach the fences. Okay, so
- 55:28now the problem comes down to essentially how
- 55:30do you move the cattle, right? That's okay. Yeah,
- 55:32so so we move the so We move the cows every day
- 55:38around four o 'clock We like the afternoon move
- 55:40best for a number of reasons, but it's electric
- 55:44fence one strand of electric fence cows are very
- 55:46smart They they don't want to get shocked and
- 55:49so we just go out and and open open a cross fence
- 55:54So imagine a ladder with rungs And so our permanent
- 55:59wires, our permanent fence, is the stringers
- 56:02on the outside. Our portables are the rungs on
- 56:06the inside. And we can expand and contract those
- 56:09based on how big the herd is, how much grass
- 56:11there is. Then later Joel and Jordan agree that
- 56:15animals learn quickly and love keeping a routine.
- 56:19And then they make the point that it's just like
- 56:23any other human being out there. The beauty is
- 56:27that in no time, the cows respond to you coming.
- 56:31I mean, think about your dog or your cat. When
- 56:34you bang the dish, they come running. They know
- 56:38what that is. Well, the cows, when we go out
- 56:41to move them, roughly, you know, we try to do
- 56:43it as close to four as possible. You know, if
- 56:47you got called every day at four o 'clock for
- 56:49a bowl of ice cream, about 3 .45, you know, your
- 56:52tail would wag and your ears would wiggle too.
- 56:55And so the cows are ready, and we go out, and
- 56:58we just call them, come on, cows! And they just
- 57:01come running through. We close behind them. Why
- 57:03do they? Because they know the food will be better?
- 57:05Because, yes, because they've got a new salad
- 57:08bar. OK, so they've learned that. They've got
- 57:09a new salad bar. They've learned that. It doesn't
- 57:11take them long to learn that. They learn that
- 57:13very, very quickly. And so you don't have to
- 57:16herd them. Another advantage to doing it the
- 57:18same time every day because you establish a habit
- 57:20with the cows. Animals love routine. Animals
- 57:21love routine. So do people as it turns out. Yes.
- 57:24Even though they think they don't. Yeah. Oh no,
- 57:28we are creatures of routines. And then again,
- 57:31Jordan discusses the experiments of BF Skinner.
- 57:35Now they're talking about marketing and how their
- 57:38marketing meets to people. And he explains how
- 57:41those experiments that Skinner did on animals,
- 57:47the same conclusions apply with humans. There's
- 57:51a famous psychologist, B .F. Skinner, and B .F.
- 57:54Skinner was the father of reinforcement learning
- 57:57theory, and that's a big deal. These large language
- 58:01models, these new AI systems, they're trained
- 58:04with reinforcement theory. So like this was a
- 58:06major deal, and B .F. Skinner was a master of
- 58:08this, and he could... He, in World War II, he
- 58:13trained pigeons to guide missiles by pecking
- 58:15on photographs as they were flying across the
- 58:18sky, right? So Skinner could train animals to
- 58:21do anything. Now, he noted that you could use
- 58:24threat and punishment to shape an animal's behavior,
- 58:26but the best thing to use was targeted reward.
- 58:29And so what he would do is his animals were hungry,
- 58:32because they had to be motivated to work for
- 58:35food pellets. And so he'd have a hungry animal,
- 58:38Maybe you're trying, so imagine there's a rat
- 58:40in a cage and there's a little ladder and you
- 58:43want the rat to go up on the ladder and then
- 58:46walk across and go down the other side. It's
- 58:48pretty complicated behavior. So here's how Skinner
- 58:51would do it. He would just watch that rat and
- 58:53as soon as it got near, as soon as it made a
- 58:56move near the ladder, he'd give it a food pellet.
- 58:58Then it would start hanging around the ladder.
- 59:00And when it was hanging around close to the bottom
- 59:02of the ladder, now and then it would put a paw
- 59:04up. and he'd give it a food pellet. And then
- 59:06now the rat was doing this quite a bit, and then
- 59:08now and then it would do this, food pellet. But
- 59:12the key issue was that he was observing, and
- 59:16then when he got an increment of behavior in
- 59:19the direction he wanted, he signified that. Well,
- 59:22that's what you're doing with your customers,
- 59:24is you're paying very careful attention, and
- 59:27then one of your customers does something that
- 59:29you'd really like them to do more of. You notice
- 59:32yeah, you tell them you reward them for it and
- 59:36then now this and so Why is there such disconnect?
- 59:40How can they accept that animals are sentient
- 59:43and intelligent? But then they will eat them
- 59:47exploit them kill them. Well, thank you Yeah,
- 59:50I think first of all, you know I begin with the
- 59:52last thing you mentioned which is the reference
- 59:54to BF Skinner is quite telling because BF Skinner
- 59:58I mean, that's almost a sense that Joel Salatin
- 1:00:00and Jordan Peterson are ignorant men, ignorant
- 1:00:05people who have no real understanding of the
- 1:00:09science of cognitive ethology or what we now
- 1:00:13know about animal cognition and complexity of
- 1:00:16feeling. So they make these gestures towards
- 1:00:21acknowledging a continuity between humans and
- 1:00:24non -human beings. But it's superficial, because
- 1:00:27if they were to really sit with that, and if
- 1:00:29they were to understand the research, then they
- 1:00:33would know, going back to Darwin in Descent of
- 1:00:35Man in 1871, that we are fundamentally like the
- 1:00:42other beings. So their psychologies are much
- 1:00:46more complex than they understand. They just
- 1:00:49understand it in terms of being clever, smart.
- 1:00:52And then as you say, there's this really sinister
- 1:00:56thing going on where they acknowledge that these
- 1:00:58are beings with consciousness of some kind, and
- 1:01:02yet they're using torture devices against them.
- 1:01:05They're committing acts of extreme violence and
- 1:01:07aggression against them. They see them as worthless.
- 1:01:11and don't let anyone who participates in the
- 1:01:14meat economy tell you otherwise because if you're
- 1:01:16going to advocate the killing of trillions and
- 1:01:20trillions of animals forever not even just like
- 1:01:23anything about soliton is apart from the thousands
- 1:01:26of animals he personally kills he's advocating
- 1:01:29a system that will supposedly be in pit place
- 1:01:32i suppose to the second coming since he's a born
- 1:01:34-again christian evangelical you know he's he
- 1:01:38wants us to be doing engaging in these practices
- 1:01:43of violence for time and memorials. So trillions,
- 1:01:47what, quadrillions of animals are to die for
- 1:01:49what? For profit, for his own sense of himself
- 1:01:55as a white man with a commitment to reactionary
- 1:02:03and anachronistic ideals of natural hierarchy.
- 1:02:07That's really what it's about. And so underlying
- 1:02:10this whole thing that these two guys massaging
- 1:02:15each other's egos, you have a fundamental contempt
- 1:02:18for other life forms. You can't love what you
- 1:02:23seek to destroy. And what I argue in my book
- 1:02:25and what you believe and other people believe
- 1:02:27who've looked at this issue is that other animals
- 1:02:30are worthy of our love. Now that may sound like
- 1:02:35sentimental or something, but You know the people
- 1:02:38in this country millions of whom have cats and
- 1:02:41dogs Those folks who aren't vegetarians or vegans
- 1:02:45the vast majority of cats and dogs dog people,
- 1:02:47right? They understand that their cat or dog
- 1:02:50is a being worthy of life worthy of their experiences
- 1:02:53and interests and needs and that we they They're
- 1:02:59very being calls upon us for empathy compassion
- 1:03:03and help like like in building a life together
- 1:03:06That insight is completely absent from the kinds
- 1:03:10of ridiculous conversations we just saw between
- 1:03:14Peterson and Soliton. They're intellectually
- 1:03:18dishonest and they're immoral. They are literally
- 1:03:22advocating mass violence against completely defenseless,
- 1:03:26lovely beings who do not deserve it. They're
- 1:03:31not worthless beings. That completely drops out.
- 1:03:35of the conversation, and that's what we need
- 1:03:37to keep going to the public about. It's not about
- 1:03:42sustainability. Even if it was the case that
- 1:03:44you could say that regenerative animal agriculture
- 1:03:47was not ecologically damaging, so what? It's
- 1:03:51still not right. It's still fundamentally evil,
- 1:03:57and especially in the face of nonviolent alternatives
- 1:04:00like vegan farming. And go to the vegan agriculture
- 1:04:06network. People can go to there and see the resources
- 1:04:09that vegan farmers are sharing with one another.
- 1:04:12It's perfectly possible to have farming without
- 1:04:15pesticides, without artificial fertilizers, without
- 1:04:19animal inputs of any kind. And if you doubt it,
- 1:04:24go into your backyard garden and look what you're
- 1:04:26doing. You can actually grow things in the ground.
- 1:04:29Without any of these things without synthetic
- 1:04:31fertilizer and without animal inputs, you know
- 1:04:34Yeah, I said one last point but can I just ask
- 1:04:38it one more question? Sure. I don't want to you
- 1:04:42know, take too much of your time. I know we scheduled
- 1:04:45for one hour You mentioned Purdue I think when
- 1:04:51Purdue looks at Salatin they think Hey, he doesn't
- 1:04:56know it but he's actually one of our best advertisers
- 1:05:01because he will give an appetite to people for
- 1:05:07animal products and then we will be the one responding
- 1:05:12to that demand because again it's not scalable
- 1:05:15his business model and also we can do our own
- 1:05:21marketing. and use the same arguments that he's
- 1:05:25using and tell people our lies about how humane
- 1:05:30are treated, you know, our chickens and so on.
- 1:05:34So do you agree with that? Absolutely, absolutely.
- 1:05:38This whole, you know, my book is partly about
- 1:05:40this new discourse of omnivorism, the enlightened
- 1:05:44omnivore, or the locovore, the carnal locovore.
- 1:05:48all of that stuff, which poses itself as a so
- 1:05:52-called alternative to the main animal economy.
- 1:05:56It's an appendage of the animal economy. And
- 1:05:59what it does is, exactly as you say it, wets
- 1:06:02the appetite of consumers. It makes them feel
- 1:06:05good about eating animals and animal products.
- 1:06:09It papers over the fundamental violence and inequality
- 1:06:12and suffering at the basis of it. It strengthens,
- 1:06:16therefore strengthens the chain of the larger
- 1:06:19animal economy by legitimating the system by
- 1:06:23saying in every advertisement, the implied argument
- 1:06:28is animal agriculture has been done in ways that
- 1:06:34aren't great. So we're going to make it great
- 1:06:36again, make agriculture great again. There's
- 1:06:40your MAGA moment. And it was never great. So
- 1:06:46that's such an important insight, what you just
- 1:06:48said, and it's completely, completely true. And
- 1:06:52there have actually been studies that have shown
- 1:06:53that people who seek out or consume, quote, high
- 1:06:56welfare meat are less likely than other consumers
- 1:07:01to become vegetarian or vegan. It makes sense.
- 1:07:06You know you care maybe you care enough about
- 1:07:08the environment you care enough about quote animal
- 1:07:11welfare That you are willing to pay a few dollars
- 1:07:14more for the product But what you don't want
- 1:07:16to do is to question the system You don't want
- 1:07:19to question your complicity in an injustice and
- 1:07:22this gets you off the hook again I think that
- 1:07:25the true significance even though this is you
- 1:07:26know hundred there were hundreds of millions
- 1:07:29of dollars Bound up with you know, the whole
- 1:07:33foods organic meat market and so forth. That's
- 1:07:36like a piddling amount with the real strategic
- 1:07:40function of all this is to stabilize the wider
- 1:07:43global meat economy, whether people know it or
- 1:07:46not, the ones like Temple Grandin. Grandin is
- 1:07:49a great example because she's the ligature that
- 1:07:53brings together the smaller farming and organic
- 1:07:56farming operations with the big factory farming
- 1:07:58operations. She consults to everybody. She doesn't
- 1:08:00care, really. She certainly doesn't care about
- 1:08:03the animals. But as long as people like Temple
- 1:08:07Grand and Michael Pollan and Joel Soliton exist,
- 1:08:09people will think that everything is more or
- 1:08:12less okay, or we're on the right track. But there
- 1:08:14is no good track for exploiting and killing other
- 1:08:18beings. Simply simply isn't. So yeah, Jordan
- 1:08:23Peterson, you said that eating plants shrinks
- 1:08:28your brain. I think John's is the proof that
- 1:08:31it's not true. And also, Einstein was vegetarian.
- 1:08:37Da Vinci was vegetarian. I mean, you could go
- 1:08:39on and on about how many smart geniuses were
- 1:08:45eating plants and not eating meat. I don't know
- 1:08:48where this is coming from, the brain shrinking
- 1:08:50thing. I get that sometime in the comments of
- 1:08:53social media. Honestly, yeah again, it's just
- 1:08:58an outright lie. It's a bald -faced lie and I've
- 1:09:02been a vegan for 40 years and that and certainly
- 1:09:06I Don't know. Maybe my brain is smaller than
- 1:09:09I know and my mind is Stupider than it thinks
- 1:09:12I'm willing to grant that but as you say Leonardo
- 1:09:15da Vinci great example, right is considered one
- 1:09:18of the you know I don't know, top two or three
- 1:09:22brightest humans that ever lived. And yes, as
- 1:09:24you point out, he was an ethical vegetarian.
- 1:09:27And there are, and similarly in terms of the
- 1:09:29health stuff, as you know, there are all these
- 1:09:30high performance athletes like Venus Williams
- 1:09:33or Honal the free solo rock climber and just
- 1:09:41all these high performance athletes, some of
- 1:09:43the best in the world, Djokovic, the best male
- 1:09:45tennis player perhaps in history, whether we
- 1:09:47like him or not. who have tremendous athleticism.
- 1:09:52Science is all on our side about nutrition, as
- 1:09:55you know. I mean, that vegans have lower rates
- 1:09:57of heart disease, stroke, cardiovascular diseases
- 1:10:00in general, type 2 diabetes. And in fact, as
- 1:10:04an article, I think in JAMA, Journal of the American
- 1:10:07Medical Association just a few years ago, recently
- 1:10:10that vegans live longer than so -called omnivores.
- 1:10:17Now, you know, as an ethicist, I would argue
- 1:10:19that even if it was the reverse, even if there
- 1:10:21were slightly better health outcomes from eating
- 1:10:23animal products, no, it doesn't justify mass
- 1:10:27violence against trillions of beings, you know,
- 1:10:31just so I can get my omega threes or whatever.
- 1:10:35It's just absurd. But luckily, as I say, the
- 1:10:38science is actually in the other direction that
- 1:10:41people who eat a balanced vegan diet Do better
- 1:10:46in all of these all these things. So Yeah, topsy
- 1:10:51-turvy world. That's the bottom line here folks
- 1:10:54is that we live in an Orwellian world and it's
- 1:10:57it's up to us to break through it and and try
- 1:10:59to bring people to to their senses Yes, I'm nicely
- 1:11:05push and to go back to your question. What do
- 1:11:08we do? Well, I've been thinking, you know I believe
- 1:11:13there is I believe more and more there's a division
- 1:11:16in society of people who believe the end justifies
- 1:11:21the means and those who have moral principles.
- 1:11:26And I'm not in the camp of those who believe
- 1:11:30that the end justified the means. I'm really
- 1:11:32not. Um, and so whatever you decide to do, do
- 1:11:36it in a ethical way. If you want to protest,
- 1:11:39protest peacefully. If you want to, you know,
- 1:11:43oppose their views, do it with intelligence and
- 1:11:47thoughtfulness and in line with your principles.
- 1:11:51Yeah. Well, thank you for having me. I, when
- 1:11:53I see these things or hear about these things
- 1:11:55like the Jordan Peterson thing, I get so upset.
- 1:11:57I can't even deal with it. So it's good. Do you
- 1:12:00do something productive with that, you know?
- 1:12:02But I was gonna say that if you decided you wanted
- 1:12:04to do another episode on this thing, I would
- 1:12:08ask Vasily Stanescu onto the show because he's
- 1:12:12the world authority, vegan authority on regenerative
- 1:12:15animal agriculture and piercing these myths.
- 1:12:17And he's got the facts at his fingertips. Of
- 1:12:20course, I would love to have Vasily since having
- 1:12:25watched that. famous infamous debate about cultivated
- 1:12:28meat, you know, I've been exposed to him. So
- 1:12:32I absolutely do not do not know him. No, no,
- 1:12:35I don't know him. I'm happy to make introductions
- 1:12:38if that would be helpful. Thank you so much,
- 1:12:40John. Thank you. Well, best of luck. And we will
- 1:12:43we will meet again. But in the meantime, thank
- 1:12:45you so much again. And just hope we can make
- 1:12:49a little progress here and there, I guess. Of
- 1:12:52course, let's be optimistic and positive. I'll
- 1:12:55let you hold the hope in this relationship. I
- 1:12:58have enough to share. Good, good. Thank you everyone
- 1:13:03for listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 1:13:06podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 1:13:09more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 1:13:13so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday
- 1:13:16for a new episode.