Latest / Viewpoint Alabama / Earwitness: The Toforest Johnson Story
Transcript
- 0:14Johns the comedy plays Officers Shot the back of our ability he is that movie
- 0:20is one of us. They have got one down. It happened in Birmingham
- 0:26almost thirty years ago, But what really happened? Hello, I'm John Mounds
- 0:31and this is Viewpoint Alabama on the Alabama Radio Network. A new podcast hosted
- 0:36by award winning journalist Beth Jolborne called Your Witness explores the story of DeForrest Johnson.
- 0:42He has been on death row for twenty five years for a crime he
- 0:46said he didn't commit. And there's a lot of evidence that would confirm this.
- 0:49But what really happened. Let's go to the expert, Beth. Welcome
- 0:52to the show. Thank you so much for having me. Absolutely so take
- 0:56me back. I guess we're talking like thirty years What happened in I guess
- 1:00it was in Homewood. Yeah, it's now in Embassy Suites, but at
- 1:07the time the hotel was called the Crown Sterling Suites and it's right at the
- 1:12border of the city of Birmingham and the city of Homewood. If people know
- 1:17Birmingham, it's where the Red Mountain Expressway cuts from Birmingham into Homewood and there's
- 1:23a big hotel with the roofs Christ Steakhouse, right, I know right where
- 1:26it is. I stayed there before. I know right where that is.
- 1:30Yeah, most people do. It's kind of a special occasion place. And
- 1:34that's where the crime happened in nineteen ninety five, July nineteenth, at about
- 1:40twelve forty five twelve fifty am behind the hotel, Deputy Bill Hardy was shot
- 1:46and killed. And unfortunately there were no eyewitnesses to the crime, and so
- 1:52of course police went to work. Was this the Birmingham Police or the Homewood
- 1:55Police? So Deputy hard was with Jefferson County Sheriff's Office, and of course
- 2:02when a law enforcement officer is shot, you can imagine there was a huge
- 2:07police response to the crime scene. I believe there were four agencies, including
- 2:14Birmingham Police and Homewood Police, but ultimately it was the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office
- 2:19that ended up taking the lead in the investigation. And the investigation I guess
- 2:24did they immediately How did Johnson get indicate? Was he this wrong guy at
- 2:30the wrong wrong place at the wrong time, or was there extenuating circumstances?
- 2:35How did it become that they decided he was the guy. Yeah, there's
- 2:38so many twists and turns in this investigation, especially in the first couple of
- 2:45weeks. It's one of the reasons why I wanted to unpack it in a
- 2:47podcast, because I felt like it needed time to breathe and for people to
- 2:53absorb everything that happened. But to Forrest Johnson has always maintained the same alibi.
- 3:00He was four miles away from the Crown Sterling Suites at a downtown Birmingham
- 3:05nightclub called T's Place when the crime happened. There's at least ten people who
- 3:12have either signed affidavits or testified under oath that they remember seeing him during that
- 3:16time frame. So he had a followed alibi and has always had the same
- 3:23alibi and the same story about that night. How he was implicated, along
- 3:29with three other young black men who were also charged with capital murder, was
- 3:34through a fifteen year old witness who came forward saying she had information about the
- 3:42crime and her mother called police and let them know and then hired an attorney.
- 3:49Pursuing the reward money that was attached to the case. It was a
- 3:53twenty thousand dollars reward at the time, which is a lot of money that's
- 3:59forty today. But this fifteen year old witness was the initial tip that came
- 4:05in that named to Forrest his co defendant, a man named Ardragus Ford,
- 4:13who was also charged and tried. Ardragus was acquitted, and then two other
- 4:17men who were charged stayed in jail for eighteen months, and then when this
- 4:24young fifteen year old witness changed her story over and over again, she finally
- 4:30told police that these other two suspects didn't have anything to do with it,
- 4:33and the charges against them were dropped and to Forrest and his co defendant were
- 4:38the ones that were tried. This is a Viewpoint Alabama on the Alabama Radio
- 4:42Network. I'm talking with best Year ill Born about her new podcast is coming
- 4:46out called ear Witness. It covers the case against a top fust Johnson.
- 4:50And let's go back to this fifteen year old witness you mentioned. Now,
- 4:56obviously at the time they don't they wouldn't. She's a so they wouldn't let
- 5:00her name out there. And I guess because she came forward to is does
- 5:03she go into some sort of witness protection? I notice you don't give her
- 5:06name does anyone know her name? Oh, actually we do get her name.
- 5:12And you know it's interesting, John. At the time, her name
- 5:15was all over the news. One of the things that I did in investigating
- 5:21this case and preparing for this podcast as I did a full audit of all
- 5:27of the media coverage, and that's one thing that really jumped out at me
- 5:30is you know how many different miners names were just out in the media.
- 5:39This was nineteen ninety five, so I think there wasn't as much awareness about
- 5:45the risks of child witnesses or child suspects. I don't think that her name
- 5:50would have been released now, at least initially when she was fifteen years old,
- 5:57but her name was in the news. It was Yollo the Chambers And
- 6:01yeah, we cover the extraordinary ordeal that she went through in becoming a key
- 6:10witness and having detective interview her over twenty five times about the case, which
- 6:15is really extraordinary. And you said her story changed a little bit each time
- 6:19they talked to her. It changed hundreds of times. She changed details of
- 6:26the story. And one thing we were able to do for listeners is we
- 6:30got access to the interrogation tapes. The many hours I think over fifty hours
- 6:40of police conversations with suspects, with witnesses. We had personally nowhere ever needs.
- 6:46We had the word of a fifteen year old who told lives a lot
- 6:54of lives. So what she says she was there and I was there,
- 7:00that's that's a shame. And with Yalanda Chambers, that's fifteen year old witness.
- 7:04We hear over and over again detectives stopping the tape and then they come
- 7:11back and some aspect of the case has changed when they come back and go
- 7:15back on the record. What's really extraordinary is I was able to sit down
- 7:19with the lead detective. He agreed to speak to me on the record,
- 7:24and so we're able to talk through with him, what was going on,
- 7:30why did they turn the tape off, what his take is and was on
- 7:36this fifteen year old witness, and how he feels about it twenty five years
- 7:41later. So it's not one of those podcasts where we're chasing down the key
- 7:46people who don't want to talk about the case. We actually got them to
- 7:49the microphone and they sit down with us for hours of on the record interviews.
- 7:55So I think it makes this podcast really substantive and unique. So in
- 8:01your witness you kind of you kind of go through each one of these aspects
- 8:05of the case and sort of unpack it for the listener. Do you talk
- 8:09to to Forrest Johnson? Are you able to talk with him on your podcast?
- 8:15Unfortunately no, The Alabama Department of Corrections has in their administrative regulations that
- 8:22death row inmates are not allowed to speak to journalists. And so the closest
- 8:28I was able to get to to Forrest is through his family members, and
- 8:33he has a very close extended family. He has five children, he has
- 8:37fifteen grandchildren. He's very close with his mother. So I was in regular
- 8:43contact with his family and also interviewed his legal team for the podcast. Had
- 8:48to Forest been in any sort of legal trouble in the past or was this
- 8:52kind of out of the blue to Forrest had a pretty harrowing upbringing. He
- 9:01grew up in Pratt City and Ensley, and the neighborhood in Birmingham's Insley community
- 9:09used to be called the Brickyard. It's the Tuxedo Projects, but back in
- 9:13the mid nineties, early to mid nineties it was like an open air drug
- 9:18market. It was extremely violent and to Forrest's family was low income. They
- 9:26were really fractured through substance use and different issues. But he had seven friends
- 9:37that were shot and killed during his teens. He was shot and survived.
- 9:43It was just a harrowing, unbelievable upbringing. He had gotten into trouble on
- 9:52relatively minor cases, some misdemeanor, driving without a license, disorderly conduct,
- 10:01things like that. He had been to prison once on a drug possession charge,
- 10:11and he pleaded guilty and did almost a year in prison. You know,
- 10:16you wouldn't do a year in prison now on simple drug possession at least,
- 10:22you know, theoretically people are shouldn't be going to prison for a year
- 10:28for that in Alabama. But at the time, you know, they were
- 10:30really sending people away. So that was the extent of his record was one
- 10:33drug possession conviction that he pleaded guilty too. You know, he had no
- 10:41history of violence, no gun charges, no weapons charges, nothing like that.
- 10:48What we learned about to Forest is that at the time that he got
- 10:52swept into this, he was really somewhat addrissed, trying to figure out what
- 10:58he wanted to do with his life, and dating a lot of different women.
- 11:01He was a ladies man, so that was really, you know,
- 11:03the thing that was going on in his life more than anything. It wasn't
- 11:09you know, anything any kind of big drug conspiracy or anything violent. So
- 11:15did this history, this past, did it play into the DA's willingness to
- 11:20charge him or was it a situation of Yolanda had an ax to grind against
- 11:26him? How how did he get to be the one that Yolanda fingered for
- 11:31having, you know, initially testifying against him. Yeah, it's a good
- 11:35question. Yolanda Chambers was essentially a runaway. She was on the street at
- 11:43the time and she and one of her friends were going to nightclubs and they
- 11:50met to Forrest Johnson and ardreguts Ford at a different nightclub than the one to
- 11:56Forrest and ardre Gets went to the night of the murder, but they ended
- 12:01up picking up Yolanda and a friend of hers after they left the nightclub,
- 12:07and they were all together that night. They were looking for a hotel room,
- 12:13you know, they were out partying and they ended up getting stopped by
- 12:16police at the Super eight motel in Homewood because police were pulling over cars in
- 12:24the vicinity of the crime scene, and the cops told them they were investigating
- 12:28the murder of a deputy. They padded down to Forrest and Ardregus. They
- 12:33looked in the car, they decided that there wasn't anything suspicious, so they
- 12:39let them all go to Forrest. Actually had an outstanding warrant for driving without
- 12:43a license, a misdemeanor, and they took him to the city jail that
- 12:48night and then he was released a few hours later. But when Yolanda Chambers
- 12:52talked to her mother the next day, her mom told her about the murder
- 12:58and they knew Pete Bill Hardy. He was a family friend. And when
- 13:03Yolanda's mother told her Bill was killed at the Crown Sterling Suites last night.
- 13:09He was moonlighting as a security guard and somebody shot him, Yolanda said to
- 13:13her mother, oh, I might know something about that. So her mother
- 13:18then contacted police and said, my daughter has information about the crime. Police
- 13:24brought Yolanda in without her mother, without a lawyer. There was no social
- 13:30worker there. It was just this fifteen year old girl and police, and
- 13:33that's kind of how it went. So initially Yolanda told police, no,
- 13:37I don't know anything about it. Then she said some people in Bessemer committed
- 13:43the murder. Then she said, in the third interview, Okay, these
- 13:48guys that I was with that night talked about smoking a cop, and she
- 13:54claimed that she overheard them talking about the murder. Then her story changed again
- 14:01and she said, oh, she was actually there and she witnessed it,
- 14:03and so on and so forth. It just changed and evolved every time she
- 14:09was brought into the interrogation room with police, and that's how to forrest was
- 14:15initially implicated. Yolanda Chambers, by the way, eventually recanted her entire story
- 14:22under oath in a court hearing that we'd bring to life in the podcast,
- 14:26and she said she made the whole thing up because she was scared police were
- 14:31threatening to put her in jail, and she recanted everything, but the judge
- 14:37still allowed the case to go forward despite her recantation. In addition to was
- 14:43there anything other than her testimony which implicated to force was their circumstantial evidence,
- 14:50were their secondary witnesses or said I saw a guy who met the description anything
- 14:54like that, or was it just based on Yolanda's testimony. Yolanda's testimony was
- 15:05the only thing that led to the arrest of the initial four suspects, including
- 15:11to Forrest Johnson. There was no forensic evidence connecting them to the crime,
- 15:16no physical evidence, no other eyewitnesses, no other person on the planet put
- 15:22them at the scene other than Yolanda Chambers. What we unpack in the podcast
- 15:28is she eventually falls apart as a witness, and so in the case against
- 15:33to Forrest Johnson, the state ends up going with another witness who is the
- 15:41so called ear witness that becomes the key testimony in the case against to Forrest
- 15:46Johnson. But no, these cases were built exclusively on the circumstantial evidence of
- 15:56two different witnesses making these claims, and these two witnesses were also pursuing the
- 16:03twenty thousand dollars in reward money. This is dew Point, Alabama on the
- 16:07Alabama Radio Network. My name is John Mounts, and I'm talking with Beth
- 16:11Shelbourne. She is a I guess, the host of the podcast Earwitness.
- 16:17You mentioned the word ear witness there, So why do you call this thing
- 16:21earwitness? What is an ear witness? Exactly? Yeah, an ear witness
- 16:26is like an eyewitness, except that someone who hears something. This case is
- 16:33all about alternative worlds that are in conflict with each other. And in conflict
- 16:40with truth and in conflict with what our justice system stands for. We had
- 16:45a week case. It's based on test twenty and one witness. The only
- 16:48evidence supposedly they had against was this ear witness who had never heard him speak
- 16:53before, who had no idea who he was. So in the case of
- 16:59the Forrest Johnson, the state's star witness is this ear witness. Once Yolanda
- 17:06Chambers began to fall apart as a witness, the state ended up going with
- 17:11the testimony of another person who had come forward in the weeks after the murder,
- 17:18and it was a woman named Violet Ellison who claimed she eaves dropped on
- 17:22a three way song call and overheard to Force Johnson talking about the murder of
- 17:27Bill Hardy. So that's what an ear witness is. And we called the
- 17:33series Ear Witness because this ear witness testimony is the only thing connecting to force
- 17:40Johnson to this murder. And we're also asking listeners to be an ear witness,
- 17:45to really sit back and listen and listen substantively to what we found as
- 17:52we unpack this terrible case of injustice. When you mentioned sheaves on the phone
- 18:00call, was that she was listening. She happened to me in the same
- 18:03room listening, or she actually had like a connection into the phone glass.
- 18:07You heard both sides of the conversation. Yeah, the choreography on these earwitness
- 18:11phone calls is a little tricky, but it went like this. Violet Ellison
- 18:18was a fifty three year old woman who lived in Birmingham and she had a
- 18:22sixteen year old daughter at the time named Katrina. Katrina Ellison had a friend
- 18:29who was in the Jefferson County jail, and at the time, the jail
- 18:36didn't have a sophisticated phone system like they have now, where inmates have to
- 18:41have an account with money on it and the phone is digitized and recorded.
- 18:47At the time, it was literally a payphone, and jail inmates could keep
- 18:51quarters on them and that's how they would make calls out from the jail.
- 18:55Well, three way calling had just become a thing on landlines in nineteen ninety
- 19:02five, and so this friend of Katrina Ellison's realized he could call her and
- 19:07use one quarter and then she could dial other people on three way and he
- 19:12wouldn't have to keep feeding quarters into the pay phone. So Katrina was doing
- 19:17a favor for her friend in the jail, just making three way calls for
- 19:22him. She was like, she was like the operator. She was kind
- 19:26of like a switchboard operator for him. Yeah, and some guys in the
- 19:30jail heard about it, and so more people started calling her and asking her
- 19:34to make three way calls. And that is how her mother, Violet Ellison
- 19:41came to pick up the phone and eavesdrop on this phone call involving to Forrest
- 19:48Johnson and a young woman named Daisy Williams, who was a younger sister of
- 19:55some of his friends. And that was the incriminating call that Violet Ellison claimed
- 20:03to overhear him say make incriminating statements about the murder. It was to a
- 20:07young woman named Daisy. It's interesting Violet Ellison testified that she could hear Daisy's
- 20:17voice, but she didn't listen to what she was saying, because she said
- 20:21she was only interested in hearing what to Forrest Johnson said. So one thing
- 20:26that his attorneys at trial reiterated to the jury is this was really a misunderstanding.
- 20:33She was listening to one side of a conversation in which to Forrest wasn't
- 20:38talking about what he did. He was telling Daisy what he was accused of
- 20:45doing. She asked him why he was in the jail, and he told
- 20:48her, I've been accused of shooting the sheriff's deputy. This is what they're
- 20:51saying I did. And so, you know, you really kind of see
- 20:57through looking at these different claims, through different witnesses, how these things can
- 21:03so easily get turned around and be made into something that they're not the best
- 21:08thing that a person probably can do for them says that's suspected over crame is
- 21:15do not talk to the bouties period. Now that's really interesting coming from a
- 21:19retired detective, but that's the truth. It's like when it's like that game
- 21:22of telephone, you know you used to play when you're kids. You know,
- 21:26I think I heard this person. You say something to somebody to somebody,
- 21:29and eventually the message completely changes. It's what the original message was after
- 21:33it's passed between person and person and person. It's absolutely like that, except
- 21:40you know, the telephone exchange is really just Violet Ellison herself reviewing over and
- 21:47over again what she claimed she overheard, and what we're able to unpack is
- 21:52how her statements changed over time. We got access to I mentioned the investigative
- 22:02file with the interrogation tapes and interviews of witnesses, over fifty hours of police
- 22:07interviews, and in Violet Ellison's original statement to police she said one thing.
- 22:15Two years later, when she took the stand as the key witness, she
- 22:18said something completely different and extremely inflammatory. So we're able to show how these
- 22:26statements really evolved and changed and became something extremely damaging to Forest in the jury's
- 22:37mind. But we're not what Violet Ellison originally claimed to overhear, Beth,
- 22:45you hear stories all the time. People on death row and Alabama who have
- 22:48been there for a very long time like to force and usually they get appeal
- 22:52after peal after appeal. I gather he's appealed a few times, right,
- 22:57Yes, he has. He has a very competent legal team right now.
- 23:03But you know, it's interesting. I think there's this myth where people assume
- 23:08folks on death row have all these resources and they get all these chances to
- 23:12appeal. And you know, there's been a movement to sort of speed up
- 23:18executions because people think folks on death row have too many opportunities to appeal.
- 23:25When to forrest first was sent to death row the attorney. First of all,
- 23:30he's never been able to afford to pay for an attorney. He had
- 23:33appointed attorneys at the time of trial that were paid twenty dollars an hour for
- 23:37out of court work with a thousand dollars cap So obviously you know you're going
- 23:44to get what you pay for. Their attorneys can't work for free, and
- 23:47when they're paid such a low amount, that's going to really, you know,
- 23:55not help them do a thorough job in defending him. But once he
- 23:59got sent to death row, he was appointed another attorney to help him post
- 24:03conviction, and that attorney was disbarred. At one point he was on death
- 24:08row with no legal representation and several key dates were missed. Then there's an
- 24:15organization called the Southern Center for Human Rights and they heard about his case and
- 24:21were able to place some attorneys with him who are still with him today and
- 24:26had been litigating his case for him. And he's lucky in that regard that
- 24:32he has a very capable legal team. Because the majority of people on death
- 24:34row are poor. Almost everyone on death row had appointed attorney. There's very
- 24:41few that had hired their own legal team that end up on death row.
- 24:49But the problem is when you are convicted, the burden is really placed on
- 24:56you to prove your innocence after that, and you can't claim an innocence as
- 25:00a legal claim. That's literally not a valid legal claim. You have to
- 25:03litigate all these sometimes granular issues of your case. And that's where he still
- 25:11is trying to overturn his case on some of these specific issues, like the
- 25:15earwitness who was paid an undisclosed reward that the jury never knew about. Interesting,
- 25:23now, let's go back briefly to Deputy Sheriff Warren G. Hardy,
- 25:29because he regardless, we know for sure somebody killed the guy, so has
- 25:33there been any I guess once they convicted to first, they didn't look any
- 25:37further into what else might have what did lead to his death. Well,
- 25:41it's interesting to Forrest and his co defendant, ardregus Ford, were both charged,
- 25:47and they were the two people that the state ended up putting on trial.
- 25:51They tried them separately. The first two trials ended in mistrials. The
- 25:56juries were not able to reach a unit on this verdict, so then the
- 26:02state tried to Forrest a second time, got a conviction and death sentence,
- 26:07and one of the most appalling things about this case is after the state secured
- 26:12the conviction against to Forrest and sent him to death row, eight months later,
- 26:18they tried his co defendant again, arguing a completely separate theory about who
- 26:26pulled the trigger and fired the fatal shots. And the jury in that case
- 26:30deliberated less than an hour and dregus Ford was acquitted. But that's one of
- 26:36the things that we see in this case is the state has this ability to
- 26:41pursue different theories about what happened in front of different juries, as if they're
- 26:48staging a Broadway play. And I think that most people that listen to this
- 26:53will be shocked to know that the state can do that and does do it,
- 26:59and they did it in this case. To your question about were any
- 27:03other leads pursued, I think the answer is no. Once detectives charged these
- 27:11four young men with capital murder, that became the case, and any other
- 27:18leads that existed at the time fell away and were not pursued. Because it
- 27:22does seem Beth that there's essentially two things of miss justice here to force a
- 27:27conviction, I suppose, but also the death of Deputy Hardy because he died
- 27:33and they never found I guess they really didn't find as killer if it wasn't
- 27:36to force. So there's some guys still out there or woman still out there
- 27:40who's responsible for that. At this point to Forrest is still on death row.
- 27:45Hey, he hasn't. Has he ran out of I know they always
- 27:48talked about you've ran out of appeals? Is he quote out of appeals or
- 27:52are they still working on the case actively? Oh? No, they're still
- 27:56working on the case. The Supreme Court decide today to not review his case,
- 28:03which you know, is not good news when you've got somebody who's so
- 28:07clearly innocent, who the current disc attorney and the original prosecutor both have said
- 28:15publicly deserves a new trial, and the United States Supreme Court refuses to hear
- 28:21the case. It's disheartening. But his legal team is still pursuing other appeals
- 28:26in state and federal court, and so this isn't the end of the road.
- 28:30I think they're going to keep fighting as hard as they possibly can to
- 28:34set him free, and so I guess to find it. So the bottom
- 28:38line is the story is not over yet. For people who want to find
- 28:41out all the details about this hear more about it. You have that podcast
- 28:45out there, Earwitnesses, available on the iHeartRadio app in other platforms as well.
- 28:49Right, it's available wherever you hear podcasts. Even my eighty year old
- 28:53mother was able to find it and listen, and she's been into it.
- 28:57We've released three episodes so far. Episode four is coming out tomorrow, and
- 29:04there's eight episodes total, and we hope there'll be a future one where we
- 29:10get to sit sound with to Forest after the state does the right thing and
- 29:15grant him a new trial and he's found not guilty. Best job, we're
- 29:19the I keep saying author, but it's not author. I guess you're the
- 29:22host of the podcast, Your Witness. Thank you so much for joining us
- 29:26this week on Viewpoint Alabama. Thank you John for having me. I appreciate
- 29:30it very much. You've been listening to Viewpoint Alabama, a public affairs program
- 29:33from the Alabama Radio Network. The opinions expressed on Viewpoint Alabama are not necessarily
- 29:38those of the staff, management, or advertisers of this station.