Latest / The Philanthropists / What Grief Reveals About Giving | One More Thing with Quanda and Meredith
Transcript
- Quanda: Welcome to The Philanthropist Personal Journeys of Giving with Purpose. I'm Quanda Allen. Today's episode is a little different. After some of our guest conversations, we'll come back together for a reflection episode, a space where Meredith and I can unpack some of the ideas, tensions, and questions that stayed with us long after the interview ended. Because these conversations are about much more than charitable giving. They're about identity, responsibility, grief, family, systems, joy. And what actually moves people to stay engaged in the lives of others. And our conversation with Norman Ornsteen and Judy Harris gave us a lot to sit with. Through the Matthew Harris Ornstein Memorial Foundation, they built a model of philanthropy that is deeply personal, highly engaged, and remarkably honest about complexity, particularly around mental health advocacy, documentary storytelling, crisis intervention, and educational opportunity. meredith: This simply wasn't a conversation about generosity. It was a conversation about what happens when a personal tragedy forces you to contend with systems that you never knew you needed before, and how that motivates one to change the way these systems operate. So in this reflection episode, we want to spend some time exploring a few of the themes underneath the conversation faith, advocacy, grief, responsibility, and the idea that philanthropy is something less about check writing. and more about staying engaged long enough to help build something together. And if this conversation resonates with you, we'd also encourage you to go back and listen to the full interview with Norman Judy at episode one. Their story, their honesty, and their perspective are incredibly powerful. This is the Philanthropist. So Quanda, what do you think this conversation was really about underneath? What it what resonated? Quanda: You know, for me, it was really about love. Like at the end of the day, as a parent, you love your children. And Norman and Judy Oranstein's story was really anchored in the love that they had for their child. And and then by extension, the love that they have for their community and for humanity. And it's funny, right? Because that's the actual definition of philanthropy. meredith: Right. Quanda: And I think their story for me illustrated that expansion so beautifully. meredith: Yeah, dude. I also thought maybe there was a little bit of they were frustrated, angry, and and it they didn't look angry but I can imagine if I put myself in their shoes when they were trying when they were going through this and when they lost their son, Matthew, that they were angry about the systems and and what they had to deal with and confused. I mean, I thought it was so interesting as These are two people who are incredibly smart, right? The top of their fields. Quanda: Right. meredith: And one's in policy and one's in the legal world. And they had a really Quanda: Right. meredith: hard time figuring out the systems and and then decided to do something about it. I I I thought so it was like frustration. I guess I've talked about passion before. Quanda: Yeah, I agree. I mean, you have two people who have complete and total access to the best of everything. And meredith: Right. Quanda: even with that access, they weren't able to ensure a good outcome for their child. I know we're gonna get into some of that a little bit more throughout our conversation, but meredith: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Quanda: f for me like that was what it was really, you know, all about that, you know, y you your your children, you love your family and you'll do any and everything that you can to meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: make life better for them. But there are truly so many things that are outside of your control. And some of those things are systemic and and really, really big and unwieldy and difficult to overcome, especially if you have an immediate acute need. So it was it was such a powerful conversation and I know I personally learned so much. meredith: Yeah, I wanted to be in the living room with them. Quanda: I know. We could probably ask like to come over for coffee. I think they're the kinds of people who would welcome us. Yes. meredith: I who would a la Yes, I think so. They were so generous. Quanda: They were awesome. Meredith, what do you think people often misunderstand about philanthropy when they hear stories like this? meredith: You know, I think philanthropy's not always gl glamorous. It's not always It's not always positive, right? You're trying to address a need. Sometimes it's like lifting people up and sometimes it's like getting underneath the hood and trying to figure out what's wrong and then doing something about it. often it begins with a crisis and it's it's terrible. It's ho it's un tragic, I think, is is not even a powerful enough word for what that family went through. And and I said earlier, like passion, I remember Once I was talking to a nonprofit consultant and he said, you know, people give, not necessarily because not always because they're excited about something or they're inspired, but because they're angry, they're passionate about w solving a pub a problem. And I don't I didn't get anger coming from from the from the Orns deens, but they needed to solve a problem. And it began with you know, somewhere on the continuum, grief is probably closer to anger than happiness. I don't know. and they had a lived experience and they were trying, because it was so deeply personal and so and they lived it, they were trying to help solve that for others. And so they didn't they didn't the so others wouldn't have to be affected in such a way. And then there is Quanda: Right. meredith: a really happy side to their story too, where they decided with their philanthropy to spread joy that Matthew had. with his debate experience and and give that joy, bring that joy to others and lift others up with that. So I loved that there were celebrating Matthew and then trying to solve, solve a problem for others that they dealt with. Quanda: And so what stayed with you most? Was it that they were able to pursue these kind of parallel paths or, you know, the impact that they made? I mean, what what did you think about once that episode was over in kind of the following days and weeks? meredith: So three things. One, I was I loved how Judy talked about her faith and Jewish traditions and customs and cultures and how they were living their faith with their with their philanthropy and bringing elements of that and and she talked about that like they lived that and how they were living that through their journey with Matthew when he was sick and they were trying to figure out how to help him. And then how they brought that Seduka, I think is how she I may am probably pronouncing it incorrectly, but how they brought that into the their philanthropic work. So emotional honesty around that was really powerful to me and stayed with me. The other part I thought was really interesting was, you know, I know Norm and from from my life in Think Tank Land. And, you know, he's a staunch conservative in the traditional sense. And it was really touched by all of the exp by all of the stories they told about these like legendary progressives that that touched them. So, you know, Bill Clinton and Joe Biden and the Rob Reiner story, it was it was really powerful to me that that they that they shared that and that those were so meaningful to them. And it and in today's like polarized world, I was really impressed by that they didn't see someone as like in a black and white sort of way. And then the last thing that stayed with me Is that navigating the complexity of the mental health system and like what it means as a parent to not be able, like you said before, to help your child and you're trying to help your child, but like these systems are working against you. And how you as a parent sort of walk that fine line between enabling and then also like helping solve the problem because your kid's suffering. And mental health and is something that strikes a deep chord with me because I have a a grandmother who suffered from schizophrenia and an uncle who was bipolar and and unfortunately committed suicide. And I I I put their story put put me in my mom's shoes and put me in my grandfather's shoes and and in my grandmother's shoes. I I just tragic. And really what they went through was pretty and anyway, that that stayed with me and and upset me a you know, a of a great deal. Quanda: So it's so interesting too how you identified with that story as well, you know, and how so many people have this shared experience around mental health issues, but nobody meredith: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Quanda: wants to talk about it. that I I really reflected on that a lot, that they're like so open meredith: Did you? Right. Quanda: about their journey and all that they, you know, try to do to help Matthew and they've been like so transparent about his his illness that meredith: Yeah. Quanda: I think it's gonna help other people share their stories and and possibly even get the help they need. meredith: Right, totally. Yeah, yeah. oftentimes after like a a tragedy like that, people like shut down, they don't want to talk about it anymore. Right. And then that Quanda: Right, right. meredith: so a question for you, before I start crying here. what did their story reveal to you about you talk in you talk often about proximity and and how that changes Quanda: Yeah. meredith: people. So what do you think about that? Quanda: Well, to me, the proximity to mental illness is what created one, the understanding and two, the desire to do something about it. Like before Matthew got sick, Norman Judy had no meaningful exposure to mental illness. So they may meredith: Hm. Quanda: have a general appreciation of, you know, the challenges that people with mental health issues might face. But they didn't truly understand all of the challenges related to the stigma, to di getting diagnosed, to medication, meredith: Mm. Quanda: to having a family member or friend who has a mental health issue but doesn't recognize that. So we talk a l a lot about that too. meredith: Right, that was shocking. Quanda: Completely shocking. And so there's no way for anyone to have the depth of understanding. About the issue and possibly what could be done about it if you have zero proximity. and so I I I I walked away from that feeling like, wow, you know, if we can try to help children, for example, have empathy and a level of understanding about some of the many societal challenges, you know, that we have. you know, t from from mental health to the environment to homelessness, you know, the earlier we can do that, the better. There is no proxy for having lived experience, but you can see the dramatic difference it makes when you have that lived experience. You know, you're able to mobilize people and resources and ideas to get to the heart of the issue. And you have motivation, right? You have, you know, in this case a the the love of a of a of two parents for their son as motivation to try to figure this out. So for me it was all about proximity being the understanding that they ultimately needed to make change. meredith: That was you're always incredibly poignant. I love that You really are have an amazing way with words. I What did you think about their choice to set up an operating foundation as opposed to just giving away to somebody else? Quanda: I think that their choice around moving forward with an operating foundation versus making a charitable contribution to another organization was so intentional and strategic. There are really kind of two reasons. Like, first and foremost, Judy shared with us her early experience as a young professional. When she was the managing partner for a law firm. And instead of making direct contributions to nonprofit organizations, she started building out partnerships with nonprofit organizations where their firm would make a contribution, but they would also get the lawyers who work there involved in volunteering. And she loved that model and she saw the impact that that model could ultimately have. And it was twofold, right? It was It was beneficial for the lawyers and it was also beneficial for the organizations and the people that they helped. So, you know, I think that Judy's early experience with this more hands-on approach really laid the paved the way for them to ultimately choose an operating foundation. The second part of this for me is that what what Judy and Norm wanted to do was very specific. And I can tell you. As a former director of development myself from meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: you know 20 years ago, sometimes you can accommodate the interests of donors within the scope of your organization, and sometimes you cannot. And the idea that they could take this very specific vision of creating a debate institute and find another organization who shared that vision is meredith: Right. Quanda: Is relatively small. You know, meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: they may find one potential partner, but if you have the program underneath another organization, you you lose a lot of control and meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: you could possibly lose some level of impact. So they had the time, they had the resources to devote, you know, to an operating foundation because what they wanted to achieve. Required a laser sharp focus. And it's difficult to ask a nonprofit organization if this is not already their exact mission to take on meredith: Right. Quanda: your project. And sometimes when nonprofits do that, they require a multi-year financial commitment. You know, they may require some additional resources. They are not necessarily committed to continuing that program. you know, when funding changes, you know, there's just a lot of things that could impact their ability, Norman Judy's ability to achieve their philanthropic goals if they're doing it through another organization versus if they're, you know, doing it through an operating foundation. meredith: Building it themselves. Quanda: Right. Now Judy did mention there's a risk inherent in here too. You build meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: out an operating foundation. And so now you have to manage that organization and hopefully, you know, you have time to create some infrastructure so that then the legacy and impact of the organization can continue when you're gone. And she talked a little bit about succession and, you know, I think they're in their 80s. Like at what point will someone else kind of step in that gap? They do have paid staff, but You know, what what does it look like twenty or thirty years when, you know, they're no longer actively managing the the foundation? meredith: Right. A and and do they want it to continue in perpetuity? You know, sometimes Quanda: Right. meredith: it's it's okay to sun down something, you know, to say we've ma achieved an enormous impact in these many people's lives and and now we're gonna spend down Quanda: Yeah, absolutely. and I I wanted to make sure to get your take too on, you know, kind of the two parallel areas of focus that the Ornsteins have pursued. So, you know, they they have the debate can or they have the debate camp and that is incredibly successful. And then they also have the mental health work. kind of going at the same time. I mean, what were your thoughts about meredith: Yeah. Quanda: their approach and the debate institute conversation, as you mentioned earlier, it just sparked so much joy from both of them. And and that part of the conversation seemed to matter so much. I mean, what what's your take on these kind of two parallel paths and and the role of like the debate camp in their overall philanthropy. meredith: I I think it I think it's important that they needed to have they needed to have joy and and something positive to think about and to focus on when they're honoring their son, right? If you only focused on trying to fix a broken system that brought you so much heartache, you might actually dissolve under the crush of that a negative emotion, but to have something wonderful to and and like you said, joyful and positive to focus on, you can Honor your son's legacy and live in that. And with that, it it's more buoyant, I guess you would say, with your feelings. and the the sc they describe, you see how Judy's and and Norm's face lights up when they talk about Matthew and his friends and writing this this screenplay or s show for Hollywood and how he was the life of the party and he was so you know how he He's he spoke with such confidence and he had all these wonderful leadership qualities so that they can so that this particular endeavor, the debate institute, helped them carry on the joyful parts of their son and cultivate that in others is lovely. And again, I I love this concept of proximity that you you started off with and we I feel like we keep coming back to it like giving students an experience, like experiential learning, proximity to an experience that they never would have had before or they never would have had someone really invest in them to cultivate that experience o opens up a whole bunch of wonderful doors. So I I love that there's like hope alongside the grief. Otherwise I think they would have as a parent, you would just get crushed underneath the enormity of that weight. I So I I I loved that part of them. I loved watching their faces light up. And Quanda: Yeah. meredith: I I have actually a donor whose son also passed away. Very different experiences. And they they chose to invest their philanthropy in a a study abroad program that honored the best of their their son. They and brother he he loved travel and loved studying. And They get so much joy from developing a relationship with the students that are awarded this this gift every year. And they have a chance to create a connection with others that remind them of their of their son and brother and and help his legacy live on in others, like the best part of him. And it it's just wonderful. To watch that joy spread on their faces. It's you can see it, you can feel it emanating. Quanda: And they had so many good stories too. I mean, it's meredith: Yeah. Quanda: clear that they are not just sitting on the sidelines watching all this happen. I mean, they are meredith: Right. Quanda: like at debate camp. They're, you know, bonding with meredith: Right. Quanda: the kids. so it really it really has been a meaningful outlet for them. And I'm so happy that they have it too. so let's s shift gears a little bit. I mean, what what like uncomfortable truth? Do you think this conversation is gonna force people to confront when they hear it? meredith: Yeah, I I'm a big fan of Brene Brown and her talking about shame being this concept that we all deal with and we don't talk about. I think she's normalized that as along with you know many other wonderful psychologists who talk about it. But mental illness is a stigma and there's an enormous amount of shame that goes along with it. And and then when you're confronted with these broken systems. You're you can't help but think to yourself, like that am I the only one that's ever going through this? Like, how can I be the only one that's going through this? There's gotta be other people out there that are dealing with this, but I don't wanna talk about it because this is so personal and so shameful or so hard, or they I mean, I I my mom can't my mom can't talk about her brother. Like this is not a thing she is emotionally capable of talking about. So you avoid the conversations. And I think, you know, kind of writ large, you bring it up to a societal level, society avoids these conversations. So and they're unc because they I mean, to your point, they are uncomfortable. But the more that you do talk about it and normalize it, you create compassion, you create awareness. but even today, I mean, I think it it's a lot more socially palatable and and normalized to talk about. Going to see your therapist and you know, taking these anxiety medications and whatnot. And every kid in my daughter's sixth grade class has a therapist, right? It's like totally fine to have them. And it's like not in a there's not a stigma with having anxiety or depression or something like that so as much as there used to be. But it still exists. It's still out there. Quanda: It does. meredith: And you know, the systems are still broken. I mean, I think Judy Mm-hmm. Quanda: It it's funny, Meredith, when when you mentioned like the systems are broken, to me, the other like uncomfortable part of this conversation is that the systems are broken in so many areas of like modern day society. I mean, meredith: I know. Quanda: you can look at edu like education. There are some meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: places where public school education is phenomenal, but there are too meredith: Right, right. Quanda: many places, just too many places where public school education is inadequate. And the one of the drivers for that gap is systemic. You know, it's there's not like a one school problem or one person problem. I mean, it is just wide sweeping and and systemic. And so it it th that's one of the things I walked away with too was like, wow, you know. when you really step back and think about how big some of these problems are, it can be truly overwhelming. And that's one of the reasons why, you know, I mean, I'm so impressed by Norman Judy's desire to impact change and meredith: Right. Quanda: their belief, right? Like their belief that they can do something that's gonna address this issue and and make life better for people. meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: Like they weren't totally overwhelmed with the broken system to such an extent that they didn't believe that they had agency. meredith: Right. And I I this actually is really this you I think you're hitting on a good point too about what when you're thinking about in your philanthropy of there's a sea, you know, you can't boil the ocean, right? Like there's so much when you're talking about systemic that you could feel overwhelming, like you said, we're not gonna have an impact. We only have this much money or this much time. How do we do this? And I think they obviously went through the the paces, you know, to figure out where they could have the greatest impact. And I like that they talked about, you know, we found this judge in Florida who is making a difference. And so that is where, you know, they zeroed in on supporting him and his work. rather than trying to cast the net so wide that they diluted the impact they were gonna have. They they they found, you know, something more targeted that then they could create case studies on. And then they did this documentary. And so I I wanted to ask you, you know. Storytelling is such an important part of philanthropy. I loved I mean, what did you think about their their focus on on the on the documentary? I I don't know, I thought that was fascinating. Quanda: I mean, we keep going back to the proximity theme, right? And meredith: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Quanda: I actually think there's a thread through the documentary work as well. It's like if people can't experience it themselves, show them, right? meredith: Mm. Quanda: Show them the challenge, show them the opportunity, show them the people. Like hear from the people who have been impacted. by, you know, in this case, you know, mental health and and and young people who ha who did not have access to debate. So I really think it's a way of humanizing the challenges that are being faced by people who are impacted by like mental health issues and young people who don't have an equal access to some of the programs like debate that that Matthew has. So I think it's just a way, you know, of providing people with, you know, as as close to a firsthand experience as as most people can have, you know, so they can see and hear and feel for themselves, you know, what what makes the work so so special and so impactful. So I I think storytelling and and video, documentaries and and even people leveraging social media, it just goes like a really long way in helping to connect. meredith: Connect emotionally, like Quanda: Right. meredith: not just intellectually, but emotionally is really where, you know, when they say pull heart strings, right? That's or Quanda: absolutely. meredith: changing hearts and minds. Like it starts with hearts. They don't people don't say changing minds and hearts, they say changing hearts and minds. Like you want to touch them emotionally through the story. I love it. I love it. I love it. all right, let's shift a little bit here and and talk about what what would you want people to walk away from this conversation? when it comes to being more intentional about their giving. Quanda: Yeah, you know, we we talk about this a lot in our conversations with philanthropists and that is, you know, start your giving from lived experience. So I think one of the big takeaways is, you know, if you wanna make an impact in the community, if you wanna impact a specific cause, just start from where you are. And meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: I think that's really starting from From a place of strength. and and then I think the other part of it is be curious, you know, don't walk into in an a philanthropic effort feeling as if you have all of the answers. You know, invest meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: time in talking to people, invest time in getting to know multiple organizations, do some research and meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: and allow yourself to evolve and iterate your ultimate approach. And then I think finally. meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: Is that engagement matters? It's really important. I think, you know, from the very beginning of our conversation with the Ornsteins, you know, they weren't just check writers. I mean, there's we we need the check writers too, right? But from the very beginning, from you know, having peanut butter and jelly sandwiches made at Matthew's Bramitzbah to all the way to, you know, Judy's engagement of other lawyers in her law firms, philanthropy to the debate institute, right? The meredith: Right. Quanda: the theme throughout their philanthropy has been hands-on engagement and not everyone has the capacity to maybe do that at the same level. But you know that's one of the big takeaways is you know you get more a lot of times out of giving than the organizations or the individuals who are the beneficiaries of it. And so give meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: yourself an opportunity to positively benefit from learning from others, experiencing others, and and gaining more and more firsthand knowledge of whatever the issue is that you care about and certainly the people who you care about. Emeritus meredith: Wells. Mm-hmm. Quanda: So to kind of wrap us up, I would love to hear your perspective on what do you think this conversation says about the future of philanthropy? meredith: I I think you said it very well about being more engaged, being thoughtful about if you're trying to tackle systems issues, that you need to have cross-sector thinking about that. You need to do your research. And if it comes from, you know, humans at the center, that is the best. Or whatever your, you know, your target audience is, whether it's cats or dogs or or something, you know, public education, that Quanda: Bunnies. I I heard recently meredith: Bunnies. Quanda: there's a not the nonprofit organization devoted to bunnies. Yeah, it's amazing. meredith: Bunnies. That's awesome. I mean, one of my favorite philanthropist Craig Newmark has a thing for pigeons. Like he does pigeon rescue. Quanda: Pigeons. Well, I used to live in the Bloomingdale neighborhood of DC and meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: learned that there is an association that has a program for alley cats. meredith: wow. Wow. Quanda: Yep, there's a whole Alley Cat nonprofit organization. So I love it. meredith: I I love that. I love it. I think we're in a really interesting time for philanthropy. We're at this moment, where there'll be a huge, like the biggest generational shift in wealth, transfer of wealth, that people are going to be thinking about how do I direct my philanthropy and what's the future of my philanthropy, and grappling with what to do with what they've built, right? you hear about, you know, the biggest philanthropists, Melinda French Gates and Bill Gates and Others, those are the two that come to mind, thinking about, you know, what do they do with their work? Charles Feeney, Atlantic Philanthropies, he he was like, it's it's not going on in perpetuity. It's I'm going to sundown this. how do you, you know, spending down your wealth or spending down or or recognizing that not everything needs to live forever, that you can have a wonderful impact with the funds that you have in your philanthropy at this moment or in the within this certain amount of time. I think a lot of people are going to be grappling with. How d how do we sustain? Do we want to sustain? Their son, their other son is is is from what they're saying, is maybe not as keen to to continue the work in the way that they want to, right? So sometimes things evolve. Like, is there an opportunity Quanda: Right, right. Yes. meredith: to take a portion of the work and and stick with that while while making, you know, letting other things fall away? So I think a lot of people are gonna be talking about. that in the future of philanthropy, I think there's probably gonna be a lot more writing about that. I hope there is. not everything needs to live forever. and if you do, you have to be really thoughtful about about how you execute for that. Quanda: Wow. Thank you, Meredith, for closing us with such powerful words. Appreciate meredith: What stays with me after this conversation is the idea that some of the most meaningful philanthropy doesn't begin with expertise or strategy. It begins with proximity, with loving someone, with seeing something up close that you can no longer unsee. And I think Norman Judy showed us that philanthropy can become a way of transforming pain into structure, into advocacy, into opportunity for others and dignity for other people. Quanda: And I think they also reminded us that generosity is not always soft or simple. Like sometimes it asks us to stay engaged with hard systems, uncomfortable realities, and problems that don't have clean solutions. But there was also just so much hope in this conversation, especially in the debate institute and the way they're helping young people find confidence, voice, belonging, and possibility. meredith: If this reflection resonated with you, we'd really encourage you to go back and listen to our full conversation with Norman Ornstein and Judy Harris in episode one. Their honesty, wisdom, and vulnerability are extraordinary and inspiring. Quanda: Thank you for joining us for this episode of The Philanthropist Personal Journeys of Giving with Purpose. If this conversation stayed with you, we hope you'll share it with someone in your own life who is thinking deeply about generosity, legacy, impact, or what it means to truly show up for others. You can also watch full episodes and exclusive content on our YouTube channel and follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram for behind-the-scenes reflections and upcoming conversations. And if this podcast is meaningful to you, please subscribe, review, and share. It really does help us grow this community. We would like to extend a special thanks to Lumina Foundation for their support and our good friends Jack Pompey and Connor Ellis of Goodpoint NYC for producing this episode. Meredith Hanley: To continue the conversation with us directly, email us at hello at the philanthropistpodcast.org. We generally want to hear what these stories are stirring in you. You can also watch full episodes and exclusive content on our YouTube channel and follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram for behind the scenes reflections and upcoming conversations. Quanda: And if this podcast is meaningful to you, please subscribe, review, and share. It really does help us to grow this community. I'm Quanda Allen. Meredith Hanley: And I'm Meredith Hanley. Until next time, give with purpose, give with joy, and give in a way that changes you too.