Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 5 - Do you know what you are buying? (Brand, trust and the supply chain you never see)
Transcript
- Dan Culverhouse: Welcome. This is Under the Pallet Wrap, a supply chain podcast with Keith Dupres and myself, Culverhouse. We're all about real conversations about subjects that are important to but mostly industry and business. And today we're to ask one question. And that question is, how much do you really know about where your products come from, the things you buy? Where do they come from? Keith, how much do you know? And I know you know more than most, but how much do you think about it? Keith: Yeah, that's a good question, isn't it? ⁓ because I think we like to think, as supply chain experts, that we probably know a little bit more than the average person. ⁓ and maybe we yeah, we probably do. We know where waste is in the industry, but absolutely. I found myself in this position buying a new TV a couple of weeks ago. ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: think we do know. We have less excuses than others. Keith: I must admit my my influencer was ⁓ I did look at the origin but my main driver was when can I get this by? I wanted it before the World Cup and my thoughts sort of ended with the movement from South London depot to to the local Argos. That was it. But it was only after I ordered it I started thinking about actually where was it made? It's made in Japan. I trust it's met all the safety requirements, all the ⁓ environmental standards. but is it truly manufactured in Japan? Probably not. I mean you if you go further down the line you've got all the component parts that might be made in China or Taiwan and then even the raw materials from the likes of Congo and I didn't think about that at all when I bought this T V. I just bought it based on trust and it got me thinking with all of the climate net zero discussions on our on our doorstep. I don't think anyone can pretend that there isn't a climate issue. Where is the responsibility? Is it on us the consumer or is it on the brand? And as someone who works deeply in compliance and also in sustainability, I thought as a consumer, you know, I'm driven to make a convenient choice here. How much research could I possibly be expected to do at that moment? I don't know what your thoughts are on that, but I didn't think the information was particularly clear at time I bought it. Dan Culverhouse: I think it is. And I think that's degree purposeful. ⁓ don't think people really want you to think about that. ⁓ think the fashion industry is, it's had issue for a long time. ⁓ mean, you know, think when people buy, you know, clothing, the of people, again, you know, value is always going to be important. And when we say value, quite often it's literally purchase price. ⁓ How much is going to cost me to buy it? You know, but also some people want quality. And when people think about, want a good quality shirt, they think about brand. ⁓ They think about, where was this source from? Where did the raw materials come from? Where was it made? They go to a brand that they trust. And why do they trust it? Because they probably have a good marketing campaign. ⁓ You they ⁓ put out there, their adverts show them like the nice green fields and things like this. But, you know, Do people really think about, well, if I buy this shirt, it was probably sewn together in Bangladesh. I don't think people really pay ⁓ much attention to the products or whether they're overproduced. You know, I want to buy this t-shirt it's really cheap. ⁓ But ⁓ what they don't realize is they make millions of them and maybe 20 percent of end in landfill. Having said that, I will say from a generational perspective, It is starting to change. I do think, you know, younger generations, the Gen Z's are more aware of it. I would still say it's it's pretty a minority. You know, people, people only really, you know, if you want to do research, you've got to work pretty hard to really understand it. So I guess it kind of asks the question is, you know, what are we actually buying when we buy something? how much of it really is we're just buying a story that brands are telling us? You know? You just bought the story that Sony told you, Keith: ⁓ yeah. Yeah, ⁓ I actually think that we're probably in the best position due to what we do to make responsible choices, but I still don't necessarily think that's the case. So as a consumer who knows a little bit more about the background, what is it that prohibits you? I mean, are you solely driven by sustainability? ⁓ do you research every product that that you're buying? And what is it that stops you doing that? and with the procedures and policies coming such as DPP, a digital product passport, do you think that's going to help consumers make their choices? Or do you think it's just another layer, compliance layer that gets the brands off the hook a little? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, it's a difficult one. mean, you know, personally, you know, do I want to buy ethically? Do I want to buy products that are sourced? Yeah, I do. I do. And I think when I buy food in our family, I think we are very conscious of it. You know, we work hard to make sure that the ingredients in our food are not bad. And we do buy a lot as local as possible. To make that supply chain as short as possible. So you understand I know the fields where our vegetables are grown and things like that in the main not always we do still buy from the supermarkets at times, but wherever possible we try to buy from local farm and shops, etc. But I'm lucky I live in the country, right? It's not hard for me. Our farm shops just up the road from where I live. So, you know, so it's kind of it's easy for me to stand here and be all look at me. I'm very I'm very ethical, but it's easy for me to do that from a food perspective. When you start getting into into into other products, it becomes a lot harder and you really have to be very passionate and and and determined and have time. I mean, it's very difficult to have the time. Do I think things like the product digital product passport will help? I think they all help. I think the problem. The problem with it is. How much time is going to be spent by the authorities validating what people, you know, because. If you have digital pass and what the digital passport will mean that you can click on a barcode and you can see a lot of detail about this product, the raw materials, where they were sourced from, blah, blah, blah, where it was made, where it was assembled, all this stuff. There'll be a whole reap of information. But of course, no brand is going to put anything in there that's going to make them look bad. And you could say, well, they have to be honest about it. And therefore they have to change their supply chains to fit what people would see as an ethical supply chain. But will they? You who's going to check that this stuff is correct? Really? And I mean, who is really going to go through and, you you could say, ⁓ well, governments will. They haven't got the money or the resources to do that. So they'll set up an authority, right? A let's say a fashion industry authority that will be monitoring fashions, ethical you know, how honest they're being. But who will pay for that? It's easy. The fashion industry will pay for it. And when they're paying for their own authority to manage them, come on. It's naive to believe that that will, you know, that will deliver a independent view. Maybe I'm cynical. That's my perspective on it anyway. I think it's a good thing and it's a step in the right direction. But will it really change anything? Keith: Well, everything has to begin somewhere, in my view. And traceability is the first step. there was a time before there was HS classification was paper based. It's a lot easier now than it used to be and things are in force. I think that you have to start somewhere. the industry has already put some forward very strong ⁓ policies on plastic and recycled materials and plastic tax is very real. I am so glad that that was taken from the consumer. how can you monitor a consumer? You can monitor much more easily a manufacturer. And to leave it down to consumers in their millions to all have a uniform approach to disposing of packaging materials. It's incredibly, incredibly difficult. You can get refused from a dump, you can get refused from a recycling centre, but what you're gonna do, you probably end up chucking it in the bin. ⁓ and then someone has to deal with it anyway, down the line. If you deal with it further upstream with the manufacturers, at least then the onus is more on someone who can control their input. ⁓ And you make sustainability the norm. It becomes a lot easier for the consumer. If they have no choice but to buy sustainable, you know, we talk a lot about convenience. That's what the supply chain has been based on for so many years. As we both know, getting things to customers quicker, giving them more choice, cheaper. It's easy now to receive your products next day or the day after ne at very low cost. Sustainability probably has to be the same way. It has to be made easier. And in order to do so, we have to shift the data. We have to make the data available in order to make the authorities ⁓ make decisions. If it's presented in front of them, it's easier for them to make the declarations. It won't be seamless from the beginning. People will ask questions, there'll be lots of ⁓ oversight, but I think it's a it's a great start. Policy is the f is a great start. And framework comes from policy. There will be loopholes, there will be w ways around it. Bottom line will always drive. You're gonna have to make allowances. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, get me wrong. Do I think the the DPP is good thing? Yeah, absolutely. It is a step in the right direction. ⁓ I do worry it's just another level of bureaucracy, ⁓ just muddies the even more. ⁓ And the other worry I have not just this, but this general ⁓ approach is it some degree lets the consumer off. It kind of says, ⁓ You know, look, you know, we put all these things in place so you can know that your products are good. So the consumer disassociates and say, well, I don't need to worry because my government and all these authorities are sorting it out for me so I can just buy what I like and because they wouldn't be allowed to sell it if it was bad. Well, I'm sorry. Even, you know, look at Tmoo, look at Shein, stuff you can get on there. If you're buying on that platform, I don't care that as a DPP, you're buying crap, really. and you are not taking responsibility yourself. I don't think it's solely the consumer's responsibility, but the consumer has the ultimate choice to either buy it or not. And if you don't know, you can choose not to buy it. And you can say, oh, well, but I need that shirt. It's like, do you? it's not simple, right? You can't just say it's not the government, it's not the authorities, it's not the brands, it's all on the consumer. It's not all on the consumer. It's all on all of them. you're in my view, but the consumer, you can't abdicate responsibility. there's this there is a little bit of the culture today is that, I rely on my government to tell me or, you know, the brand said they were good. You know, this is one of the things I really love about independent journalism podcasts and independent journalists who are not accountable to anybody who can say what they damn well like. Now, of course, they can still be talking a load of crap, but they're not. bought out by mainstream ⁓ industries to stop not being not allowed to talk about certain things because their sponsors will pull their money. And I do think that people can get a lot of good insight from watching people who are knowledgeable about this stuff, but are not beholden to anybody. And I think that people can do more to understand. Can you really always know? No, of course you can't. But you can do more than most people do, I think. And this is a horse I've got on before about the whole e-commerce, buying patterns of buying three colors and two sizes of everything and then sending 60 % of them back. Whose fault is that? Yeah, well, it is partly the consumers fault. They've kind of demanded that's what they want. So the brands fault for giving into it, you know, that all the brands complain about the cost of running e-commerce in returns and, you know, and the ethical side of us says, ⁓ my God, you know, it's not sustainable, but we still do it. And ultimately, the consumer shouldn't be doing that. Now, they also need a viable solution to it. And it's easy for us to say, oh, that's not good. That's not good. But you also need a viable solution. And maybe brands could start offering, you buy this without the option of being able to return everything, you can get it a discount. Because the reality is, we're all paying for those returns. You might think it's free returns, but it's not. It's just built into the margin of the product. Keith: I think root cause is very important. We provide choice. it's a competitive world. Were customers asking for it or were they turning away because other companies were providing options? It's chicken and egg type situation sometimes. it's not all on the brand. isn't education key? People make short term decisions on health, on purchasing, because they don't really have any other option but to do so. ⁓ easy to make decisions when you have time and knowledge. But not when you don't. So if you have no choice but to shop ⁓ at Primark, what true consumer choice do you have? we talk about fast food, but isn't that a poverty divide? it's too easy to buy fast food rather than healthy food. Why is that? It's because of overheads, economy of scale. So many things. But it becomes easier to buy fast fashion if you you have less money. We have to examine the causes of this and and why it happens before we can say it's truly a consumer choice. it's not It's not a consumer choice necessarily to buy a shirt that's going to last five years. It's it's a desire. I think everyone would like to do that in the ideal world, but not at the expense of food or warmth. It's it's the hierarchy of needs. We have an industry that serves the audience, but the industry also drives that audience. So I think anything that puts an onus on sustainability is a good thing. I think that consumer choice comes with education and visibility. While there is none, it becomes very difficult. It was even difficult for me looking at this T V, I of course I looked at the energy outputs, how sustainable it was for ⁓ p it was very hard to get something at an affordable price but below a D rating. Which made me think at the time. It's like, well, what do I need to do to get the most ⁓ environmentally friendly ⁓ TV from an energy perspective? ⁓ ultimately I didn't want something that was going to break in two years, so I did think about that. Well, what's a false economy? What is or isn't? I decided a certain price point was good enough. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: yes, it is probably more expensive to make a truly ethical item at every step of the way, and someone has to pay for it, but we have to focus on the technology. and making that sort of thing simpler and more visible in order to make it mainstream and the norm. Otherwise, ⁓ everyone's always going to turn to to cheapness and cut out the middleman, speed and speed and and cost. Dan Culverhouse: Sure. It's only when something goes horribly wrong that suddenly everyone's up in arms about it. Why does it take a crisis? Keith: Absolutely. Dan Culverhouse: to make everyone aware? Or is that the best way to make it clear to people? Keith: Well, I think it goes back to my point about upstream coordination. And why does it take a scandal? It's a good question. Because finally the government is forced to act. Dan Culverhouse: or the brands forced to act or the consumers forced to act. All of us are forced to act in that way. Keith: It's a domino effect, but the consumer is ultimately purchasing what is available ⁓ within their means. The brand is trying to survive and ⁓ you know, most brands I've worked with are doing their absolute best to be profitable, sustainable, whilst also making a profit and dealing with a very difficult geopolitical situation at the moment and high oil prices and everything else. Governments, as we know, are less coordinated than than they ever have been. It's very, very hard to coordinate everybody. We came very close to a global village. that's been disrupted in the last few years. But It takes a unified ⁓ approach to the environment. We've got a lot of conflicting views on the environment from different governments at the moment, whereas what's that driven by? It's probably driven by short term thinking, money, ⁓ the inputs that ⁓ matter to these people at the moment, rather than the long term stability of the of the world. Dan Culverhouse: Who were the biggest contributors to that? Who were the biggest contributors to that? I think I'd love to think that people like the G7 are really helping, just think governments are funded by industry. They get into government by being supported by industries. And why do industries give them all that money to get into government? So they'll get their policies in. that support their business. So I'm afraid I don't buy that the governments truly are there to look after us. You know, I think it's horrible because I think we're in a place where actually it's almost impossible to unravel the situation that we've created over the last 50 years. know, things have developed and, you know, kind of, guess, personal ambitions and we've created this complex world which is very difficult to navigate your way through. know, it's like if you want, you know, and we're getting a little bit off topic. If you want to be a truly ethical politician and stand by your values, I think you'll never make it. You'll never get there because you'll be destroyed. You know, because, you know, so you almost need to sell yourself to get to that level, to then hope that you can still retain your values and try to deliver them when you get there. But I don't see that that's the way it happens. And I think it's similar for brands that they I don't think they ought to they go down there saying we don't care about people. We're happy to poison people. I think they want to do the best thing, but it's so difficult. And to do the best thing is so expensive that it would put them out of business. know, I, yes, gee, you know, I'm a big advocate for sustainability. I think we should live in this live on this planet and treat it like it is the, you know. It won't be there forever if we don't look after it. But I don't believe that's what ESG is doing. I think ESG is a political tool to drive people to spend ridiculous amounts of money on reporting and supporting industries that have been created because of the ESG scenario. Don't mix that up with thinking that I don't believe that we should be ethical, sustainable, and we should to have proper ways of governing people etc. I do, I just don't believe that the ESG engine, the kind of huge body that it's become, really tackles the problem. I think it satisfies people's political ambitions and it makes everything appear correct but I actually don't think it addresses the real problems. know, for me the biggest way of becoming sustainable was to be more bloody efficient. That's the best way of doing it. I think we've made everything so complicated We have so much information now, we're drowning in it, we can't sift through and work out what's real. Keith: I do think it needs to be part of the bigger consideration when you're a business and when you're a government. What are we trying to achieve? Yes, sustainability is indeed supported by efficiency, but visibility is also a key driver in knowing how inefficient you are. So knowing your carbon footprint, ⁓ knowing your waste is the is the first start, visibility. And that's where DPP really helps, tracking the movement. And from there you reduce it. I've worked on some very successful sustainability projects. The first step was always understanding where the waste was or where the usage was. ⁓ simple things. Like escalators being on all day. What's the need? Is there any value in that? sprinklers being on all day. There's always a starting point. ⁓ ⁓ cooperation comes through visibility. We can talk about win win situations when you understand what it means to the manufacturer, what it means to the brand, what it means to the consumer, and what it means to the environment. So I think reporting is a very good thing in that. when you start doing it, you know what you're working with. If it's all speculation and you know, ⁓ smoke and mirrors, which it often is in the press, it's very hard to find clear guidance. I think you have to start with the truth and the facts, and they're only going to come with a simple means of measuring the supply chain and the impact of it. The carbon footprint, the miles travelled. the cost any impact at each manufacturing point, each processing point. So I think it's a very good place to start. It's not going to be an immediate win because these things will take time, they will improve. ⁓ And the the consumer's educated and the more we understand how to make sustainability more affordable, the more their choices will be more straightforward. ⁓ you take a look at something, here's a good example. We now take it for absolute granted when we pick up a item of food in the supermarket and we see the salt, sugar, the red, amber, green ⁓ structure for understanding how healthy it doesn't tell the full picture, but we understand at a glance whether something's healthy or not healthy. You look at a packet of sweets, or maybe this isn't for me right now because it's got red all over it. You look at low fat hummus and you think, ⁓ there's a orange and green. That's a more healthy snack. It's very simple education and influence at a consumer level. And the consumer is making a more important choice. We take it for granted now because it was made policy. you have to provide for calorie content. You always have had to in the US. ⁓ And ⁓ I think it makes consumer choice simple. If we had a similar visual on clothing, you know, carbon, whatever we want to include, child labour, ethic ethics, whatever we want to include, and we could see at a glance, a bit like the ⁓ energy efficiency of the TV, I was trying to get as close to A as possible. Maybe that would help the consumer choice. But to get there we need to make it present. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. No, I agree that all these things are things that can help. I don't know if you could see on my face when you were talking about the labeling of food, because, you know, I think it's one of the biggest crimes out there when people say this food is low fat or low sugar, therefore it's healthy. Because when you do look at the bloody ingredients, it's full of chemicals instead. You know, and again, this is where I go back and I know I sound a little conspiratorial and a little bit cynical, but that food labeling is designed by the food industry, supported, you know, funded by the food industry. And they're telling you that if this says it's low fat, we're to put green on it. But what it actually is, you know, Keith: the first checkpoint allows you to look twice. Eventually policy will determine that ingredients have to be clearer. They have to you know, there has to be a a more true rating, but at least it gets people talking and at least it gets people questioning further. Dan Culverhouse: How does that happen? By consumers standing up and saying, this is not good enough. And through consumer groups or through independent journalism. But don't get me wrong, it's not easy. And I do think that the clothing industry needs better regulation. think that digital product password will help to provide people with better information so they can make more informed choices. Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: But I will also put a caveat to that and saying, don't be fooled by thinking it's, you know, that's just it. Because it just means it's another level of information that you have that you can then, you know, utilize. But you should further scrutinize it. Don't just believe everything you see, because there's so much marketing and, you know, in this world that it's easy to be think you're doing the right thing and realize actually you're still not. Keith: Absolutely. But that in itself does drive the need for industry based policy ⁓ responsible brand ownership and also Dan Culverhouse: And I'm not saying it's easy. Keith: regulations. It drives the need for transparency, continued improvement, continued monitoring, and also linking to things like health statistics. One thing has to drive another. One thing has to another. It's very hard, I think I agree with all your points about this is one of the hardest times to to actually link government and industry. ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: What is the truth? Keith: Industry drives government, government drives industry, of course. But in relation to things like climate, where there's conflicting information, we have to I think industry and government need to take a particular stance. I don't think it will happen in our lifetime, to be honest, but there has to be some cohesion. And you have to like anything in supply chain in our world, yeah, we have to link with the buying decisions, we have to link with customer service. Climate policy has to link with economic policy, etc., etc., health stats, to understand carbon stats, to understand how it all affects each other. Otherwise, it's just separate, disparate lobbying factors that aren't really working as a whole. And as long as the air industry can falsify information or at least blur the edges. It's not serving its true purpose. I do agree with you there. But leave it down to the consumer whose main driver is is cheapness and if and ease. It's probably gonna take a lot longer than if you leave it to the industry itself, ⁓ and government input within that. But it's very exciting times for sustainability. There's ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: Certainly lots to keep me occupied and I'll be invested in in improving this type of stuff for brands and ⁓ trying to make decisions easier for brands around sustainability. At least we're having a conversation. Dan Culverhouse: And it's good to be talking about it. Yeah, I do think that, you know, it is important that people are having the conversation and we might not all agree, right? I don't think we entirely agree on where the responsibility sits. think we broadly agree that responsibility sits actually all across the supply chain and everybody has a responsibility. But it's important, I think, to really keep banging on that everybody also has a, you know, as consumer, have a responsibility and you do have the ability to not buy. power of that is, you know, it's strong. I just want to give one example with all the conflict that's going on in the world. And I've worked in the Middle East for a number of years in my past. And Starbucks is like an institution, you know, across the Middle East. They're big coffee drinkers. And on every corner there is a Starbucks. Since You know, the conflict that because obviously Starbucks is American, has Israeli connections. The people in that in the Middle East are marching with their feet and not going. the business Starbucks business is falling apart. You know, they are struggling like mad because people will not buy their coffee because of their links to, you know, to those countries that are doing things in their region. that they don't agree with. I'm not saying what's right or wrong. This is not a place for us to have that political decision, but it does says the power of a consumer. know what they've got is people on social media saying this company is funded by, is owned by this and this is its beliefs and relations. Why are you buying their product and by the millions, they're not buying it in the Middle East at the moment. And Starbucks is having a really rough time because of it. So. it is possible to enact change or to drive, make a point as a consumer, not individually, granted. And we do need, you know, these people that are standing up and willing to, you know, to make it aware, make people aware of certain things. Keith: Well I think almost to wrap up, I think you're right, with social media and consumer influence there's never been a better time for brands to take responsibility. ⁓ And is everything. So having this information available and making responsible decisions that serve your customer. Never has there been a better time. So are we in agreement that everyone holds a bit of responsibility? I think my opinion leans more towards the industry to start with. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I think I Yeah, I think I think everybody does have a responsibility, but my my final point would be as a consumer, do not believe that you can advocate. You have to stand by what you believe in when you know. And it's not always easy to know. And I, you know, we're to buy things that are probably not ethically sourced and not ethically made. But if you do know and you do see it, you should stop buying it. And then that will help to drive change. So it's It is the responsibility of governments, is the responsibility of brands and companies, but it also is the responsibility of the consumer. They have the ultimate choice. Keith: Yep. If you don't offer it, people won't buy it. On that note, we've had a great discussion. I've enjoyed it a lot. And I hope you join us for our next episode, which will be out in a week. Dan Culverhouse: That was fun. Wonderful. Nice one. See you soon.