Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Arrowsmith (1931)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And I've got a fever that
- 0:22can only be cured with this podcast. Or having
- 0:26your tooth pulled out with a string. Oh, yeah,
- 0:28that happens, too. This is great. Dude, these
- 0:32movies, they are tossing kids around left and
- 0:35right. They don't care about these children.
- 0:38There's a couple scenes in this, actually, that
- 0:40evident. I guess ultimately he's trying to take
- 0:42care of them, but evidently it's just the Michael
- 0:44Jordan meme of like, you know, I'm not going
- 0:48to say that word, but forget these kids. Yeah,
- 0:50that's kind of this movie. This generation, really.
- 0:53I'm glad that's where you went with the Michael
- 0:55Jordan thing, because he's been in the news,
- 0:56and I was like, what are we talking about? I'm
- 0:59specifically talking about the still image meme
- 1:01of his face in black and white and nothing more.
- 1:04I like that, yeah. We'll keep it there. We're
- 1:06good there. Slam dunk. Everybody get up. It's
- 1:10time to slam because we're talking about Aerosmith.
- 1:12We are. Not that Aerosmith. No. Which my mother
- 1:15was very disappointed when she watched this with
- 1:17me last night. She's like, wait a minute. She
- 1:21finishes the movie. She's like, who was Steven
- 1:24Tyler? It would be so funny if throughout the
- 1:27movie your mom's throwing references when she's
- 1:28like, dude looks like a lady. Yeah. This guy's
- 1:32real jaded. Was there ever an elevator? No. What?
- 1:36There what? No. I think that was a different
- 1:39elevator. That was bad. No. Wasn't there? There
- 1:41was. There may have been. Because remember, they
- 1:44walk in, and at one point, she doesn't go in
- 1:47the elevator, but he does. Right. So I would
- 1:49say there was no love in the elevator. There
- 1:51wasn't. I would say that Leora was definitely
- 1:54living on the edge, though. That's true. And
- 1:57by the end, Dr. Aerosmith was back in the saddle.
- 2:00Yes, he was. Well, we've done this to death.
- 2:05We've done it. This is Aerosmith, A -R -R -O
- 2:09-W Smith, released in 1931. This had four nominations.
- 2:14This was for Best Picture on behalf of Samuel
- 2:18Goldwyn Films, Best Writing Adapted by Sidney
- 2:22Howard, originally by Sinclair Lewis, Best Art
- 2:24Direction, Richard Day, and Best Cinematography
- 2:27for Ray June. Yep, and this was directed by John
- 2:30Ford, starred Ronald Coleman as Dr. Martin Aerosmith,
- 2:34Helen Hayes as Leora Aerosmith, Richard Bennett
- 2:38as Gustav Sondelius, and Myrna Loy, who's, she's
- 2:42listed on, like, the poster and everything as
- 2:45top billing. She's in this movie for about two
- 2:47and a half minutes. And it's not until, like,
- 2:49the last 25 % of the movie? Yeah, and she, maybe,
- 2:54like, seven words. Total, she doesn't say much.
- 2:58It's almost teased that she's going to be a bit
- 3:00bigger of a role, and we'll kind of get to why
- 3:02that might be. But yeah, that was a little surprising.
- 3:05I also had Claude King as Dr. Tubbs, A .E. Ansem
- 3:08as Professor Gottlieb, and Clarence Brooks as
- 3:10Dr. Oliver Marchand. We'll get to a lot of them
- 3:14in a minute. What was the synopsis for Aerosmith?
- 3:18So, Aerosmith is about a up -and -coming... researcher,
- 3:22a medical researcher, who's very, very interested
- 3:25in finding a cure for something. He just wants
- 3:29to make a difference in the world. And it's kind
- 3:32of like a really rapid telling of his life and
- 3:36how he went from a medical doctor to a researcher
- 3:40who eventually makes a very big difference in
- 3:43the world, but all of the little struggles and
- 3:46issues in his life in between. But it's like
- 3:49super fast pace. Extremely. I mean, honestly,
- 3:53this movie almost seems like a two and a half,
- 3:56three hour biopic of like an important figure.
- 3:59Yeah. But it like runs by like an hour 40 maybe?
- 4:03Yeah, like an hour 40 minutes. And I think like
- 4:06I first started watching this two nights ago
- 4:09and I watched maybe the first 10 minutes before
- 4:11I was like, I'm tired. I'm going to bed. But
- 4:13I was so confused as to what's going on because
- 4:16it starts with this. random woman riding a carriage
- 4:20like a a wagon yes through the the american prairie
- 4:24and this man is like why don't we just go stay
- 4:28with your your uncle and she's like nope i'm
- 4:30gonna make a name for myself and then it cuts
- 4:33to a little kid who's like studying in school
- 4:36and they're like you study hard and you'll do
- 4:39great and then it cuts to like a kid in college
- 4:41and i'm just like am i gonna have to remember
- 4:43all of these nameless people But it really was
- 4:47just like this rapid, condensed version of how
- 4:50the Aerosmith name came to be. Which is funny
- 4:53because we'll get to why that might be ultimately.
- 4:57But just in speaking of how the film works and
- 5:00how that comes across, I completely forgot that
- 5:03that opening happened that you're talking about.
- 5:05And the prairie on the wagon. I forgot all about
- 5:08that because the first thing I think of is what
- 5:10helps the story. And the story really does kind
- 5:13of start right where you're mentioning where
- 5:15a young Aerosmith is talking to Professor Gottlieb
- 5:18about wanting to intern with him specifically.
- 5:21And he tells him, get your feet wet, get out
- 5:24there, do your thing, like do something with
- 5:27yourself and then come back and maybe tell me
- 5:29you're like ready to do this. Right. And the
- 5:31way he does it is interesting because it's almost
- 5:32like it's not like a, hey, do some work and come
- 5:35back and we'll see if you're qualified. It was
- 5:37almost like you're not going to survive. Like
- 5:39go out there and do the work and realize how
- 5:41much work that's going to be and then come back
- 5:43and you're going to tell me you don't want to
- 5:45do it. It's kind of the way Gottlieb talks to
- 5:46him about it. And then imagine his surprise when
- 5:48Aerosmith makes an extremely big impression and
- 5:52becomes a very large name because of the work
- 5:55that he does. And he is like a doctor and he
- 5:57does take care of these things. But specifically,
- 5:59the thing that he starts like working towards
- 6:01is like essentially solving plagues. Right. And
- 6:04this movie, I mean, I'll go ahead and go off
- 6:08the bat. I really enjoyed Aerosmith. This is
- 6:10the first movie I've watched of the fifth Academy
- 6:13year. I watched them almost alphabetically. And
- 6:16then I realized we weren't doing alphabetically.
- 6:17Right. That's right. I forgot. So then I had
- 6:21to go and watch some other things in different
- 6:22orders. But Aerosmith was the first one I watched.
- 6:24And this is a really refreshing movie to watch
- 6:27for the Oscars because this kind of fits in that,
- 6:30you know. theory of everything, a beautiful mind
- 6:33type movie where it really is just about like
- 6:35one person and like their journey. And it tends
- 6:38to be a bit scientific, but it doesn't bog you
- 6:41down in the science itself. I really liked the
- 6:44performance specifically of Ronald Coleman as
- 6:47Martin Aerosmith. I thought this was really strong.
- 6:50I thought he was really captivating. Like it
- 6:52didn't come across as like In Cimarron. I thought
- 6:56the lead in Cimarron was like, this guy's a little
- 6:58too much bravado for me. I can't really get behind
- 7:00him. That's why, to me, it was refreshing to
- 7:02watch Ronald Coleman and be like, this man is
- 7:04riveting. And not just the character, but I really
- 7:07liked Ronald Coleman in this specifically. Do
- 7:09you like his voice? I have some notes on his
- 7:12voice. Oh, really? I actually, we'll skip to
- 7:15this. I like the writing in this. We're continuing
- 7:18the trend where we talk about the writing and
- 7:20some of the lines and deliveries in this. Earlier
- 7:23on, he has a scene with his wife, played by Helen
- 7:26Hayes, his wife Leora. And they just got married.
- 7:30They're walking out of the courthouse. And he's
- 7:33like, where should we go? You already know. I
- 7:34see that smile on your face. You know where I'm
- 7:36going. He's like, where should we go? And she
- 7:37was like, well, you know, Dakota. I can't remember
- 7:40if it was north or south. South Dakota. South
- 7:42Dakota. My family lived there, and there's a
- 7:45really great opportunity for us to go out there.
- 7:47And he says, Dakota, yeah! Real man's country.
- 7:53Frontier. Opportunity. I was like, it's South
- 7:56Dakota, man. We can calm down a little bit with
- 8:00that. I mean, what else are you going to do to
- 8:02get excited for South Dakota? Well, it was just
- 8:05the fact that there was like one too many exclamations
- 8:07there. Sure. Dakota. Yeah. Fine. But then real
- 8:10man's country. Frontier. Opportunity. One of
- 8:14those things is true. And there is opportunity
- 8:16out there. I like that line. I like that delivery.
- 8:18But his voice was definitely the whole, it was
- 8:21kind of like, I know you're not copying Clark
- 8:23Gable because he's not here yet, but you're copying
- 8:25Clark Gable a little bit. Sure. And maybe the
- 8:27mustache wasn't helping that. But no, I really
- 8:30liked Ronald Coleman. The voice is a little cute,
- 8:32but I mean, that's of the time, right? Yeah.
- 8:34Well, I had read that a big reason for his success.
- 8:38He was a silent film actor, and then because
- 8:40his voice was so beloved, that was a big reason
- 8:43he found success moving forward. I was kind of
- 8:46lukewarm on him throughout most of this movie,
- 8:48I think until the end, when he has kind of a
- 8:51personality shift. I've noticed that I'm less
- 8:54intrigued by the male stars a lot of time, because
- 8:58they're written very, I don't know, kind of prim
- 9:01and proper and polished, and they all kind of
- 9:04feel one note to me. Oh, sure. And that's not
- 9:07necessarily true because, like, we've seen the
- 9:10kind of the, what's the term? Like in Bad Girl,
- 9:15the guy in that or the guys in Front Page, they're
- 9:19all kind of like, hey, man, what's up? Blah,
- 9:21blah. See? What's the, I can't think of a proper
- 9:24term. I'm going to throw some words out there.
- 9:25You let me know where I'm right. Wiry? Linear?
- 9:29Like, just, you know, they're not men of. Class.
- 9:35I just T -posed, if anybody wants to. Oh, you
- 9:37did T -pose. I was wondering what that was. But
- 9:40you capital T -posed, so you had the arms down.
- 9:43I did, yeah. Yeah, the forearms down. Sylvania.
- 9:47This is going well. I think I know what you're
- 9:49saying. So it's not like they're the, I mean,
- 9:53I don't want to say that, lower class. It's almost
- 9:55like blue collar. Blue collar. That's the way
- 9:57to put it. Yeah, for sure. But yeah, I don't
- 10:00know what that is. But I feel like women are
- 10:03written more interestingly, especially during
- 10:05this pre -code era. I like Helen Hayes in this
- 10:09a lot more than I like Ronald Coleman. What a
- 10:12long roundabout way to just say, I like Helen
- 10:15Hayes more. I prefer Helen Hayes. Yeah, I mean,
- 10:17you're right. There's a little bit more kind
- 10:20of one note to some characters. Aerosmith, I
- 10:24think, in this kind of movie, you can anticipate
- 10:26that... Martin Aerosmith is going to be kind
- 10:29of, like, plagued by his own genius. And there's
- 10:32no cure for that. There's no cure for that. So
- 10:34he is specifically, like, through the majority
- 10:36of the movie, just solving these things scientifically
- 10:40or, like, getting fights with his wife because
- 10:42he's just coming at things way too scientifically.
- 10:44Right. I... I enjoyed this side of it. And I
- 10:47think there's some dynamics to other male actors
- 10:49that we've seen. But you're right as a whole
- 10:51that we're seeing more dynamics in the female
- 10:54characters, not just in this movie, but across
- 10:57the board. Yeah. And I wonder if that's like
- 10:59they are meant to be written in a way that kind
- 11:03of in I don't want to say entices, entices men.
- 11:07And I'm just like, hey, I'm I am a man. This
- 11:11is working, you know, but I don't know. I feel
- 11:13like Helen Hayes in this or her. sauciness when
- 11:16she's a nurse when you first meet her and she's
- 11:18scrubbing the floor yeah and Aerosmith is like
- 11:21hey doing doing your job and she's like this
- 11:24isn't my job I got caught smoking a cigarette
- 11:26and I'm just like yeah girl get him yeah and
- 11:31I think that's what I mean though is that like
- 11:32he he's he's one note but he sees that and he's
- 11:35like well I need that in my life like I need
- 11:36someone who can bring that spice into my life
- 11:40so they do get together and they do get married
- 11:42ultimately he meets her as a nurse yeah at the
- 11:44hospital and she calls him pig -headed and self
- 11:47-centered that's my husband and i was like yeah
- 11:50girl get him every doctor deserves here that
- 11:54once or twice yeah a week so they end up getting
- 11:58married and uh traveling to dakota the land of
- 12:02what was his words Real man's country. Real man's
- 12:06country. Real man's country out there in South
- 12:07Dakota. And they set up shop. And specifically,
- 12:10he finds some success in the opportunity of creating
- 12:14some kind of cure for a horse disease. Cows.
- 12:19Cows. Thank you, not horses. It was cow serum.
- 12:21It was cow serum. You're right. So he introduces
- 12:24his idea. And I thought this was, I really liked
- 12:26this aspect being like 15 minutes of this movie.
- 12:28The idea of like, we're going to have to sacrifice.
- 12:32some things in order to get progress in life
- 12:35yeah and when he tells this to someone they're
- 12:38like what and then he explains it again to someone
- 12:40else and they're like what yeah and that was
- 12:43that was so clearly like a big portion of this
- 12:45movie was that that idea of we have to sacrifice
- 12:48some things in order to get progress in other
- 12:51things yeah i i love this part too because it
- 12:54is kind of the like when my mom says Hey, I know
- 12:58you hate the job you have right now, but it's
- 13:00just your stepping stone. Use that job, you know.
- 13:04They work for you. And that's what he says to
- 13:06the cows. And it works for him because he finds
- 13:09this cure. Or he makes the serum that helps the
- 13:14cows. And then he receives such notoriety that
- 13:17he finds work as a researcher at that point,
- 13:21right? He does. But the thing that happens between
- 13:23that, though. Oh, yeah, very important. Another
- 13:26vet. is like, what are you doing, man? Like,
- 13:29the things we're doing are working, and it's
- 13:31fine. Like, stop rocking the boat. What's your
- 13:33problem? And the things that you're doing are
- 13:35resulting in more cows dying. So like, why would
- 13:37you try this? And he's seen as kind of like a
- 13:40quack in that sense of like, at least the vet
- 13:42is trying to make people think, this guy's a
- 13:45quack. He's not even a veterinarian. Like, what
- 13:47are we doing with this? But instead, he stands
- 13:49his ground. And he's like, this is how we make
- 13:51progress. And this is what we need in order to
- 13:53do this. And I thought, this is, you know, this
- 13:55is fine. This is like a Dr. Dolittle type movie.
- 13:57Like, he's just doing these things, and he ends
- 14:00up creating cow serum. Good for him. But ultimately,
- 14:03that's the stepping stone, like your mom said,
- 14:05she's right, to the next thing. Thanks, man.
- 14:07And he ends up getting that research grant to
- 14:10go and reunite with his old mentor, Professor
- 14:12Gottlieb, in New York City? New York City. New
- 14:15York. The real man's country. Yeah. For real.
- 14:18Ends up moving to New York City. I want to talk
- 14:20a little bit about this institute. The McGurk
- 14:22Institute that he starts working at. We talked
- 14:25in last year when we covered, oh, what was it?
- 14:30Was it the big house that had that really haunting
- 14:33German expressionist beginning? The McGurk Institute.
- 14:39I was like, is this a horror movie? Like the
- 14:42McGurk Institute is huge, massively built out,
- 14:46built for this movie specifically. Yeah. And
- 14:49it is haunting looking. Like, I was like, something
- 14:51bad is going to happen to this place. Yeah. It
- 14:53doesn't. Like, it's ultimately just the setting
- 14:56of the story. But watching it, I was like, this
- 14:59is beautiful. And I'm very happy. But don't go
- 15:02in there, Earl Smith. Also, nobody else works
- 15:04there. Right. He's like the only one wandering
- 15:06the halls at any given moment. Well, okay. In
- 15:08the halls, you're right. As soon as he goes into
- 15:10the actual, like, medical center of this McGurk
- 15:14Institute, then he sees Gottlieb. He sees...
- 15:18What's his name? Sondelius? Yes, Sondelius. Sondelius
- 15:22is working there, too. And he's meeting a few
- 15:24other people. And Lior even kind of sneaks in
- 15:26at one point later on. We'll talk about that.
- 15:29But this institute is so gorgeous looking that
- 15:32any kind of art direction, to me, this made the
- 15:36most sense. Sure. Everything before with them
- 15:39being in South Dakota, fine. Sure, it looked
- 15:43kind of like Cimarron building out these smaller
- 15:45homes and shacks. But it wasn't until they got
- 15:47to New York where I was like, oh, yeah, art direction,
- 15:50I'm totally behind. Right. Now, I will say the
- 15:53thing that interested me prior to this as far
- 15:57as art decor, art, what is it? Direction. Art
- 16:00direction. I almost said art decoration and,
- 16:03you know, art deco. Of course. No, before New
- 16:08York, I thought it was very interesting how this
- 16:10film spans. almost this man's entire life. So
- 16:14you see him living and working in so many different
- 16:17environments and just points of memory and experience
- 16:22in his life. And I think the set design for each
- 16:25of these brief moments is so well done at showing
- 16:29like, hey, this is the lifestyle he's living
- 16:32right now. This is how much money he's making.
- 16:34I mean, you see, I forget Leora's. maiden name
- 16:38but when they go to her parents house you can
- 16:40see like this is how she was raised this is the
- 16:43lifestyle that she was brought up in and then
- 16:45two minutes later Aerosmith gets his own house
- 16:48with Leora and you see like oh they don't have
- 16:51very much when it comes to furniture. He's just
- 16:53now putting his name on the fence outside. And
- 16:56then every time he receives a new position or
- 16:59a new job, his house expands and it's more well
- 17:02furnished and there's more beauty and design.
- 17:05And you can tell that Leora is out there, you
- 17:09know, going to home goods and getting everything
- 17:11that makes a great home greater. Right. And I
- 17:15like all of that when it comes to the art direction
- 17:17as well. That New York building though is insane.
- 17:21It's crazy. It's ridiculous. It's so pretty.
- 17:24And, you know, there's a couple of things that
- 17:25go with this. And I mentioned the big house because
- 17:28the German expressionism that we mentioned there,
- 17:30this is not a movie of German expressionism,
- 17:33but the McGurk Institute specifically. Am I saying
- 17:37that right? I am. Good. Want to make sure I wasn't
- 17:39like five minutes into saying McGurk. No, you're
- 17:41great. I called it the New York building. You
- 17:43know, the one. Yeah. It's the McGurk Institute
- 17:47building. And there's a shot that happens at
- 17:50one point. I think that Martin is so plagued
- 17:54by something that he has to go and take a walk.
- 17:56And he does. And I think, oh, that's what happened.
- 17:59Leora's like, do you want to go for a walk? He's
- 18:01like, yeah, I do. And she's like, great. And
- 18:02she grabs a jacket and he's like a half a mile
- 18:04down the road. And she's like, I'm coming too.
- 18:07And joins him. And by the time that he gets there
- 18:11to the Institute. There's a shot. It's snowing.
- 18:15He's standing in front of the building. But then
- 18:17Leora appears in the reflection of the door behind
- 18:22him. And this was another haunting shot where
- 18:25I was like, wow, that's beautiful. But there's
- 18:27also something sinister about that shot specifically.
- 18:29And maybe that's just the reflection that I put
- 18:31on to the McGurk Institute. But he kind of has
- 18:34the realization. You see him seeing her reflection
- 18:36and then turning around like, what are you doing
- 18:38here? I loved that shot specifically of her appearing
- 18:41in the window or the reflection of the door.
- 18:45Oh, I thought that was great. So everything with
- 18:48McGurk Institute is where I kind of started like
- 18:49turning around with like, oh, what is this movie?
- 18:51Like I was enjoying it fine, but like then I
- 18:54kind of saw to your point, oh, this is a wide
- 18:56ranging, like this is his life in totality. Right.
- 19:00In that sense, it felt very like Frank Capra
- 19:02-esque. But I did enjoy this a good bit. It's
- 19:05not like it's a wonderful life or anything. But
- 19:07in the sense of him scaling his life, I thought
- 19:10that was interesting. The aspect that we haven't
- 19:12talked about was him being plagued by his genius
- 19:14results in him not being able to be as present
- 19:17as he wants to be. You can kind of see Leora
- 19:19in the beginning suggesting Dakota because that's
- 19:22been home for her before. She's familiar with
- 19:25this and she wants to build a life at that point.
- 19:28And he wants to do the same thing. And I think
- 19:30you kind of hear him in that like, you know.
- 19:32Real man's land. Real man's country. Opportunity.
- 19:35Frontier. And this is where I start making the
- 19:39comparisons to Cimarron. In the sense that he
- 19:41really does start seeming kind of like, I gotta
- 19:44get out there and do the next big thing. And
- 19:46I gotta keep going and keep moving. And this
- 19:48is a man plagued by a vision that can't keep
- 19:50him down in one specific, not just location,
- 19:54but even room. Like, he can't be with his wife
- 19:56in the way that she wants him to be. To a point
- 19:59where she's following him to a lab. Right. She's
- 20:01like, I don't care. Let's go. Are you traveling
- 20:03by boat to a different country? Me too. Like
- 20:06she will put herself in that situation because
- 20:08she just wants to be around him. Yeah. This is
- 20:10like Marty Supreme light. Oh my God. Let me change
- 20:14my double feature real quick. It is. It is because
- 20:17you see this like, not desperation, but just
- 20:20like this real eager eagerness to be around this
- 20:23person. You're referring to the Odessa Zion character
- 20:26in Marty Supreme. Right. To Marty. That's kind
- 20:29of what Leora is doing here to Martin. So that's
- 20:32a great call out. His name's Martin? Martin Supreme?
- 20:35No, Martin Aerosmith. Yeah, sorry. For a second,
- 20:38I was like... Yeah, I mean Martin. I was like,
- 20:39have I been saying that wrong too? Marty Aerosmith.
- 20:41Marty Aerosmith. Martin... This is Marty Supreme.
- 20:45It is. That's so funny. Yeah, what did you think
- 20:47about the whole storyline of Leora wanting more
- 20:51out of her husband than she was going to get?
- 20:52I think that's the driving force of this movie.
- 20:55think that as exciting as certain points in this
- 20:58movie are namely like when he first discovers
- 21:01that he might have a bacteria that will kill
- 21:04the plague or whatever a microbe I don't know
- 21:08the terms but like that was super exciting however
- 21:11nothing was more interesting to me than the way
- 21:15that his his wife was so supportive of him no
- 21:19matter what was going on. Even when she was frustrated
- 21:22that he was cooking cow serum on the stove, even
- 21:26when he was leaving her in the dust and going
- 21:28for a walk on his own, she's so supportive. And
- 21:31I really enjoyed her acting so much that it helped
- 21:34drive the movie for me. So to me, that's like
- 21:38the main storyline. And I think it kind of leads
- 21:42up to the culmination of like... tragedy that
- 21:45takes place at the end of this movie yeah not
- 21:47to jump ahead but like that's that's the big
- 21:50beat you know yeah it is and i i think that there's
- 21:54some smaller beats around that specifically you
- 21:56know i i do love the scene where he comes back
- 21:59and he's almost like livid that his test tubes
- 22:02that he's been testing there's one that's clear
- 22:04he's like well who cleaned this out like how
- 22:06could this have happened and it's the realization
- 22:08that any microbes or bacteria that the test he
- 22:14ran. Right. And now he has created this serum
- 22:17that can essentially solve the plague. And when
- 22:22he's doing this, you're like, wow, so this is
- 22:25the story. This is like how he solved the plague
- 22:27and everything. This is a great story. But then
- 22:29you start seeing like the bumps in the road here.
- 22:31And the bump is that the man who's running the
- 22:33McGurk Institute, Sundelius, he actually leaks
- 22:36to the public that this is happening to the publications.
- 22:39And they release a headline about this way before
- 22:42it's been like, Tried, tested, completed, ready
- 22:45for the public. Yeah. And this just completely
- 22:48sideswipes all the progress that Aerosmith has
- 22:51made, because now, when that doesn't go through,
- 22:54Aerosmith is seen as a fraud in that sense. Right.
- 22:57And if he isn't, and it goes through, then he's
- 23:00seen as some egomaniac who thinks of himself
- 23:03so highly that he's going to release this before
- 23:05it's ready. So it's really a lose -lose scenario
- 23:08in that sense, and you see him kind of losing
- 23:10his character here. I really enjoyed this arc
- 23:13for him. And don't get me wrong, this is definitely
- 23:15the play genius. He does not really care about
- 23:18his wife. He does, and he loves her, but he has
- 23:21sidelined her severely throughout this movie
- 23:24to a point where she's almost a sidekick and
- 23:26not a partner. She's trying to be a partner for
- 23:28him, but he won't let her. Or if anything, he's
- 23:30taking advantage of that is probably what I want
- 23:31to say. But two things I want to bring up here,
- 23:34and it seems that stand out for me. And for one,
- 23:36we got to go way back. When he's in Dakota and
- 23:38he's making a name for himself as a doctor, we
- 23:41alluded to this earlier. He sees children. He's
- 23:44trying to help them throughout. You know, he
- 23:46really wants to help one child specifically,
- 23:48but tragically, and I think this is his first
- 23:50patient, he loses them. His first patient with
- 23:53the plague? Correct. The child. Okay, yeah. I
- 23:57thought you meant his first patient in general.
- 23:59No, no, back in Dakota. Okay. Yeah. Was it a
- 24:01baby? No, that was a child. Oh, it was a baby.
- 24:02He delivered a baby. You're right. It was his
- 24:04first, like, medical thing. That's correct. But
- 24:06then the child who was, like, sick, and they
- 24:07were like, you should have called someone much
- 24:09sooner than this. Yeah, I guess it was a child.
- 24:12They never really showed. I don't know why I
- 24:13assumed it was, like, a grandmother. Oh, no,
- 24:15it was definitely a child. Oh, okay. Because
- 24:17he was like, it's tragic, like, you know, the
- 24:18loss, we shouldn't have had that. That explains
- 24:20why the arm was so small. I was like, that's
- 24:23a small grandma. start showing your child actors
- 24:27everyone maybe we start treating them better
- 24:29too because the next scene that is shown is a
- 24:33kid being like hey doc my tooth hurts can you
- 24:36help right and these kids almost like gang up
- 24:39on him like yeah you would see everyone being
- 24:42like uh hey let me give the doctor a call i gotta
- 24:44check out with this guy real quick but then these
- 24:46kids are like let's just go to his window like
- 24:48what about 10 of us just go into his window and
- 24:50just be like his tooth hurts And he's like, fine,
- 24:52come on in, whatever. You should see a dentist,
- 24:54but come on in. What I love about this scene
- 24:56is that he diagnoses, he's like, yeah, that tooth's
- 24:59got to come out, man. And he's like, you really
- 25:01should see a dentist. I was like, that's a great
- 25:03idea, doc. He's like, so we're going to get that
- 25:05tooth out. Yeah. I was like, go to the dentist,
- 25:07man. Like, don't do this. I mean, you know, he
- 25:10did the same thing that a dentist would have
- 25:12done. Did he? Well, you just. With a different
- 25:16style. Right. A little pizzazz. You're so right,
- 25:18because a dentist would maybe, you know, put
- 25:20some anesthesia. Novocaine? Novocaine, thank
- 25:23you. Some Novocaine on the area, like numb them
- 25:26up a bit, and then surgically remove the tooth
- 25:28in a safe and, you know, cautious way. Other
- 25:31doctors, like Aerosmith, would say, hey, sit
- 25:33in this chair. I'm going to hold a string. We're
- 25:36going to tie that around your tooth, and I'm
- 25:38just going to pull. Even better than that. He
- 25:41says... Hey, did you see the movie that came
- 25:44out just a few months ago where they chase the
- 25:47big monster with a torch like this? And he waves
- 25:51a piece of newspaper on fire at the kid who like
- 25:53flips back in the chair in fear and yanks his
- 25:57tooth out. Yeah. So technically, Martin can say,
- 26:01I didn't yank the tooth out. I was just holding
- 26:04the rope and the kid fell. I was just holding
- 26:07the rope and the torch and the kid fell. And
- 26:10the burning paper. Yeah. See? And he's obviously
- 26:14talking about, like, Frankenstein. Something
- 26:15like that, right? Well, he didn't say that. I
- 26:17said that. That was my joke. Don't give it to
- 26:19Marty. Did he not? No. That's right. He did just
- 26:21hold... See, your context makes way more sense
- 26:24than what happens in the movie. Because he really
- 26:26does just, like, hold the flaming, like, newspaper
- 26:28in front of the kid. Yeah. This reminded me of
- 26:31Gremlins. Because there's that scene in the bar
- 26:33when Phoebe Cates is lighting the match. And
- 26:36she holds it to go light the cigarette in the
- 26:38mouth of a gremlin. And the gremlin's just like...
- 26:40immediately like rejects like what the what is
- 26:42that and that's what the kid does because as
- 26:45soon as he puts the line in front of me he's
- 26:46like what in the world and falls over tooth gone
- 26:49tooth gone so i i'll say this i did enjoy this
- 26:53movie a lot and we'll talk about our ratings
- 26:54at the end but this movie has some scenes in
- 26:56it where you're just like what's going on like
- 26:59we the tone is all over the place i can't get
- 27:02a read on like this is a patch adams friendly
- 27:04doctor story is this like a beautiful mind where
- 27:07like your genius makes you not be able to like
- 27:10communicate with the world around you. Like,
- 27:12what exactly is this movie? And that's, I think,
- 27:16evident towards the end. And the second scene
- 27:18I wanted to mention was specifically when he
- 27:20finds that he's kind of building the cure for
- 27:22this is when Leora follows him into the McGurk
- 27:25Institute. And they have this scene where they're
- 27:28in the lab. And I love the look of the New York
- 27:31lab. There's like a window at the top of the
- 27:34room that you can see the rest of New York. And
- 27:36it's snowing. And I thought this was a beautiful
- 27:38shot of him in the lab and all this beauty around
- 27:41him, not just outside, but Leora specifically.
- 27:44And he is just hyper focused on these results
- 27:47and lab tests in front of him. Yeah. And I thought
- 27:49that was a perfect like, you know, that's the
- 27:51poster of the movie is like you're surrounded
- 27:53by all of this. And yet you're just so secluded
- 27:55into this one thing. I thought that was a great
- 27:57shot. And I really liked the symbolism of that.
- 28:00Intentional or not. But. I think it was intentional.
- 28:03I think that's a huge praise of the art direction
- 28:05to not only be like, hey, doesn't this look cool?
- 28:07It also serves the story. Correct. And I was
- 28:10hoping that was the case because I did really
- 28:11appreciate that. So this then leads to the idea
- 28:17of him traveling to solve this specific, like
- 28:21he presents this to a board. Is this something
- 28:23that I can do? Like I want to help with the,
- 28:25you know, spreading this or stopping the spread
- 28:28of these diseases in this plague. with this serum.
- 28:31But it's so early in the stages that the majority
- 28:33of the board is like, we can't approve that.
- 28:35This is insane. We're not doing that. And the
- 28:37majority of them leave. And this is where we
- 28:39enter with Dr. Oliver Marchand, who walks in.
- 28:43And I want to take a second and talk about Oliver
- 28:46Marchand, who's played by Clarence Brooks. Yeah.
- 28:49In a time where we talked about something like
- 28:51the problematic nature of movies like Traitor,
- 28:54Horn, and Cimarron, where we had problematic,
- 28:57and it's not just those two movies, but those
- 28:59were the most, I would say, heinous depictions
- 29:01of characters, of anyone with darker skin, but
- 29:05black individuals specifically. A movie like
- 29:08Aerosmith is such a breath of fresh air because
- 29:10this was one of the first, if not the first,
- 29:12for my research, examples on film where an African
- 29:16-American actor was portraying a character that
- 29:20did not meet those stereotypes. Specifically,
- 29:23like a doctor who spoke perfect English and was
- 29:27just as smart as everyone else in the room. Right.
- 29:30And this was incredible. I really liked the work
- 29:33that Clarence Brooks did here. It's also notable
- 29:35that Clarence Brooks did a lot of work offscreen
- 29:38as well for the further development of individuals
- 29:42of color. That's the best way to put it. I'm
- 29:45trying to find the best way to do it. He put
- 29:47the work forward to help other individuals of
- 29:49color to have these kinds of careers, have these
- 29:53opportunities for these kinds of characters.
- 29:55Because otherwise, the only opportunities that
- 29:58existed were ones that demeaned their character.
- 30:01Right. And I thought this was not just an incredible
- 30:04feat for them to do in the movie, but it didn't
- 30:07feel like tacked on. Right. It felt like it served
- 30:10the story perfectly. And that's another testament,
- 30:14too, to where it's not just, oh, we did it to
- 30:16do it. No. He's a huge part of that movie, because
- 30:19he is the reason, I should say, specifically,
- 30:22Marchand is the reason that Aerosmith even travels
- 30:25to a different country. So, had you known about
- 30:28this before watching Aerosmith, or is this after
- 30:31your research? No, I had no idea. I didn't know
- 30:33anything about this movie going into it. Neither
- 30:35did I. Is that something you found in your research,
- 30:39that this is the first example of this? Correct.
- 30:42Oh, wow, okay. I didn't even know. It is. Fascinating.
- 30:46It is specifically, and the thing for me was,
- 30:49and this is what sucks about this stuff, man,
- 30:52is that I watched this scene, and I saw that,
- 30:54and because of the quality, I didn't watch a
- 30:56DVD or a Blu -ray of this, because of the quality,
- 30:59I had to stop and be like, I gotta make sure
- 31:01this isn't blackface. Because that's another
- 31:03thing of like, okay, well, is this... We're trying
- 31:06to do the right thing, but we're doing it the
- 31:07wrong way, which we'll see a lot of examples
- 31:09of that. Absolutely. Especially way further in
- 31:12the future of trying to course correct some things.
- 31:14But no, this is true that Clarence Brooks was
- 31:18specifically a pioneer for the research of other
- 31:21individuals of color to get these roles, and
- 31:24that this was the first recorded example on film
- 31:27of an individual of color who was not playing
- 31:31a role of stereotypes. And I thought this was...
- 31:35a high spot. Yeah, that's awesome. This was great.
- 31:38But talk to us about that scene specifically
- 31:40and how that leads us to the back half of this
- 31:43movie. Or I should say the back quarter. Right.
- 31:46Dr. Marshawn shows up and he's basically, I believe
- 31:48it's India that Aerosmith goes to, but he says,
- 31:52listen, we've got great opportunity in this village
- 31:57specifically because the whole board is like,
- 31:59hey man, what you're doing, what you want to
- 32:02do to find a cure for these people, it is unethical.
- 32:06And basically, he's going to give half of the
- 32:08population the cure or the, what would you call
- 32:12it? The shot? I'd say cure is fine. The cure
- 32:14for the plague. Serum, if anything. And the other
- 32:18half will get a placebo. And that's his way of
- 32:21testing to see, hey, this is working on this
- 32:23half. Clearly, it's working, you know. But the
- 32:26problem with that is that means the 50 % who
- 32:28don't get the shot, they're left to... Whatever
- 32:31fate determines. Right. The board says no, but
- 32:35Dr. Merchant shows up and says, listen, I've
- 32:38got a little village that, come test it. Come
- 32:41do what you want to do. So he goes to this village
- 32:43and he does exactly that. And this is where Leora
- 32:47goes along with him. They are living out in a
- 32:51really beautiful house, but they are like in
- 32:54the midst of this plague in this village. And
- 32:57this is where there's a... tonal shift because
- 33:02it feels like there is a constant foreboding
- 33:06of this plague approaching their life and i think
- 33:09it's one of the best shot things we've seen in
- 33:12any of these movies thus far it is and you know
- 33:15i i want to go back real quick to that reflection
- 33:17of leora in the glass door of the entrance of
- 33:20the mccurk institute and i think that that kind
- 33:23of like starts that foreboding of what you're
- 33:25talking about i mean the mccurk institute itself
- 33:27does that a little bit with its uh huge stature
- 33:31but him looking at work and him looking at his
- 33:34career and then seeing a reflection of his wife
- 33:36i think is very indicative of his focus and that
- 33:40lends itself to their travels to india the fact
- 33:42that she like pretty much forces herself onto
- 33:44the boat with him to go and he's like fine okay
- 33:47i guess and again this feels like a sidekick
- 33:51thing where she's begging for attention But his
- 33:53focus is certainly like 100 % on this because
- 33:55this is what he's been working towards. The idea
- 33:57of talking about the cows, how half of them get
- 34:00the treatment and the other half don't. So you
- 34:01can see the testing between, I mean, it's essentially
- 34:04the first captured idea of split testing, right?
- 34:09We're going to see what happens to group A and
- 34:11group B with different results and different
- 34:13treatments. When this happens, we start seeing
- 34:16him being more buried in his work than we had
- 34:19seen before. And not only that, but while he's
- 34:21focused on this, he meets another individual.
- 34:24And this is the actress that you're talking about
- 34:26specifically, who is Billed on the poster. Is
- 34:29she third Billed? I think she's fourth Billed.
- 34:32She's after Richard Bennett. Okay. Myrna Loy.
- 34:35Sundelius? That's interesting. I'd like to go
- 34:38back at some point and look at why the people
- 34:39who were billed were billed that way. Because
- 34:41to me, Gottlieb had way bigger of a part than
- 34:43Sundelius did. Maybe it was the actor at the
- 34:45time. Sure, yeah. That's probably what it is.
- 34:47So she appears, and she's part of the expedition
- 34:51and the group research here. But from the get
- 34:54-go, you can see her really eyeing Aerosmith
- 34:57up and down. there's a very large hint that there
- 35:02could be some kind of romance between the two
- 35:04of them. Hated that. Thought it was not in a
- 35:07bad movie way, but I was like, Aerosmith, don't
- 35:10do it, man. Don't do it. Leora's waiting for
- 35:13you. And you could see, well, she's as much into
- 35:16the research as I am, so if I'm going to find
- 35:18any kind of companionship in this, it's going
- 35:21to be in this person. And that's kind of what
- 35:23you're led to believe for the majority of this
- 35:24movie. Or not majority, for the majority of the
- 35:26storyline of India. And the testing there goes
- 35:29off pretty well. Everything goes about the way
- 35:32he wants it to, except with Leora. What happens
- 35:35with Leora? There's such a good moment. It's
- 35:38like an Alfred Hitchcock level of suspense that
- 35:41gets built. While they're in their home, she
- 35:44is, for some reason, transporting these very
- 35:48open... We got to talk about safety in this place.
- 35:51Of the plague, yeah. I don't know what's going
- 35:53on. But she's carrying them over to a position
- 35:56on a table or something. And she's like, what's
- 35:58this, Aerosmith? And he's like, that's the plague.
- 36:01She's like, that sounds dangerous. I'm going
- 36:03to put it down. And she does. And when she does,
- 36:06there's such beautiful camera work here. Yeah,
- 36:09the lingering shot. Yeah, where it focuses on
- 36:12one vial that has shifted. to a tilt, just slightly,
- 36:15just enough for a little bit of a drip to come
- 36:18off of the vial itself. And it happens to land
- 36:22on the end of a cigarette. And I love the setup
- 36:25there because it's like an hour ago when we first
- 36:29go to Leora's parents' house that she reveals
- 36:31she's taken up smoking. Yep. Which is also another
- 36:34moment of her being like, just, yeah, I smoke,
- 36:38what of it? Just super cool. Not that smoking
- 36:41is cool, but you know what I mean. Smoking looks
- 36:44cool. I was just about to say, smoking's pretty
- 36:46cool, guys. Yeah, you're right. I always hate
- 36:49that because I don't want to be that guy, but
- 36:51man, it looks cool. Especially in the 30s. The
- 36:54coolest thing you could look, or the coolest
- 36:58you could look in the 1930s, smoking cigarettes.
- 37:02When a new movie comes out and it's set in the
- 37:0460s or something and I see someone light up a
- 37:06cigarette, I'm like, we're back. The problem
- 37:09is that that doesn't go for me because the minute
- 37:12that I pull out a cigarette and light it and
- 37:14try to smoke it, you're going to immediately
- 37:15hear me hacking up a lung. Sure. The second that
- 37:18nicotine hits me. Yeah. If I'm walking down the
- 37:21street and I smell a cigarette, I'm like, what?
- 37:24Yeah. What are we doing? Have we not learned?
- 37:26That can't be true for me because I walk into
- 37:28Harrah's Casinos all the time. And when I walk
- 37:31in, I'm the Han Solo Force Awakens where I'm
- 37:33like, chewy. We're home. And then you start hacking
- 37:37up a lung. Perfect timing. Just right then. Nailed
- 37:41it. Yeah, perfect. So the shots, though, of the
- 37:44cigarette, and it just lingers on the cigarette,
- 37:48coated in this plague, I guess. The plague. Not
- 37:54this plague. Right. It's the plague. The plague.
- 37:56That one. But not even just that shot alone,
- 38:00but I mentioned this constant foreboding feeling.
- 38:04There there's this beautiful shot. And I want
- 38:06to talk more about John Ford in general. Yes.
- 38:08Kind of his his his style and some of his tropes.
- 38:12I don't know if tropes is the best word. I want
- 38:14to talk about struggles, too. So let's do it
- 38:16all. He he very famously has this shot of someone
- 38:20standing on a door like just outside a door frame
- 38:23and then looking through that door frame out
- 38:25at what's going on. And you see a perfect example
- 38:28of that here where Aerosmith is leaning up against
- 38:31the door in his house. And you look out and you
- 38:34see all of the villagers transporting their dead.
- 38:37And the way that there's like a constant fog
- 38:39rolling across the ground, it feels like the
- 38:44plague itself is just kind of encroaching on
- 38:48them and their lives. And all of that set up
- 38:51leading to this moment of, like I said, very
- 38:54Hitchcockian of, hey, here's the bomb. You know
- 38:59it exists. Carry on. And you just sit with that
- 39:03suspense of like, when is that going to come
- 39:05into play? Who's going to smoke it? It's such
- 39:08good filmmaking. And ultimately, as Aerosmith
- 39:12is out curing these villagers and doing his tests
- 39:15of 50 -50 and all of that, people start to succumb
- 39:18to the plague. We first lose Sindelius. He passes
- 39:23away and he has a very dramatic farewell scene,
- 39:26which also is shot incredibly well. And then
- 39:29we lose Dr. Marchand. And this is a great moment,
- 39:33too, because he calls over the phone to get in
- 39:35touch with Aerosmith. And I think he gets, like,
- 39:38one word in where he's just like, hey, we need
- 39:40to talk about something. Cuts to Aerosmith. He's
- 39:43like, what is it, Marshawn? And then it cuts
- 39:45to just a phone with nobody using it, nobody
- 39:49operating it. And you're like, whose phone is
- 39:51that? It almost doesn't register right away.
- 39:53And then you see the talking piece. I don't know
- 39:58how a phone works. Just dangling there. And you
- 40:00know, oh, no. This is it. He's lost his life.
- 40:03And of course, he was staying with Leora. Right.
- 40:06So now it becomes a race for Aerosmith to get
- 40:10back to his wife. And this as well, the shot
- 40:13where you see Leora succumbing to this plague.
- 40:17I just love the composition of this shot. There's
- 40:20like a chair very forward. Yes. In the shot.
- 40:23And she kind of stumbles with the door. Is the
- 40:26door open? The door is partially open. He opens
- 40:30it more. This is like a noir shot. It is. Yeah,
- 40:33it's gorgeous. And she kind of stumbles just
- 40:36behind that chair in the foreground. So I don't
- 40:39know. I don't know how to interpret shot composition
- 40:42to be like, wow, that's why this worked on me.
- 40:45I just know that it worked on me really well.
- 40:47Focus is a big part of it, right? Like what's
- 40:50in the focus? What's in the foreground? What's
- 40:51in the background? And there's a shot specifically
- 40:53not of, it's more when Aerosmith discovers Leora.
- 40:58When he discovers her, he walks in and the shot
- 41:01is kind of in the corner of the room. And on
- 41:03the far right, you can see her on the ground.
- 41:05And on the far left, you can see the door opening.
- 41:08And the light that that door lets in as he opens
- 41:11it is very like noir. Yes. Sense. And then it
- 41:14cuts to a shot of just her arm. Yeah. Reaching
- 41:17out towards the door in a way. Yeah. All of this
- 41:20reminded me of when Barbara first shows up at
- 41:25the farmhouse in Night of the Living Dead. Oh,
- 41:29sure. There's a lot of like interesting, like
- 41:32canted angles. And there's not canted angles
- 41:34here, but there's very intentional setups for
- 41:38all of these shots. I would say you're right.
- 41:40It's not the angles. It's the placement. yes
- 41:42the placement it does feel very intentional and
- 41:45it feels like it's not just higher up and then
- 41:47we'll look down it's more well let's go lower
- 41:49and then we can look up from there yeah yeah
- 41:51yeah that's everything about it was so well done
- 41:54i really liked that i mean it was tragic but
- 41:57i really liked the the build to that and you
- 42:00know it you you want to say That you don't, this
- 42:04hit me specifically because then it kind of opens
- 42:07the door to, and I'm completely spacing on the
- 42:10actress's name or the character's name of the
- 42:13fourth build actress who's the scientist. Myrna
- 42:16Loy played Mrs. Lanyon. Lanyon. Okay. So this
- 42:22opens the door for Mrs. Lanyon, specifically,
- 42:24right? Because now you're like, okay, well, his
- 42:26wife's gone. And now there's this opportunity,
- 42:28him sitting in his room alone. And like, she's
- 42:30knocking on the door. She's right outside of
- 42:31the door. What does this mean? And this kind
- 42:34of is a testament to the quick cutting that you're
- 42:36talking about, where maybe something happened,
- 42:38maybe it didn't. But the way that it quick cuts,
- 42:40it doesn't show you anything of like, did she
- 42:42go in? Did he answer the door? Did something
- 42:44happen? It just quick cuts to the next day. Yeah.
- 42:50solving this and great yeah we've treated these
- 42:52people but look at the people that we've lost
- 42:54and what's the cost of that and he ends up going
- 42:55back home and then this kind of lends to the
- 42:58idea of what do you do with the McGurk Institute
- 43:01now like what do you do moving forward do you
- 43:04be the person who solved this plague and you
- 43:06just continue to like you know you retire on
- 43:09that and live on your morals like you're okay
- 43:11or do you keep pushing the envelope and with
- 43:15Mrs. Lanyon still being a part of that Do you
- 43:17then like pursue a life with her? Like, well,
- 43:19what does that look like for you? And I thought
- 43:21this ending was really profound too, because
- 43:23there's another individual and I'm, I'm blanking
- 43:25on who it is, but it's someone he's worked with
- 43:27at the McGurk Institute. Is this Dr. Tubbs? Oh,
- 43:29I want to say his name's Tyler something. I'm
- 43:33going to pull it up. Cause he is kind of, could
- 43:34it be Tyler Tubbs? It could in fact be Tyler
- 43:37Tubbs. If not, that's my new moniker. It is Terry
- 43:42Wicket. That's his name. It's like his old partner.
- 43:46It's not Tubbs. Is Terry Wicket not one of the
- 43:48Ewoks in Return of the Jedi? Wicket certainly
- 43:51is. That's the main Ewok. His child. Your child.
- 43:55Terry Wicket. Can you imagine? All right, Terry,
- 43:59let's go solve the world plague. Yeah. Great.
- 44:03So anyways, no, not that. He has the opportunity
- 44:07to follow like Terry Wicket out. And Terry Wicket
- 44:10says, hey. I'm leaving. We don't need the McGregor
- 44:12Institute. The work that we want to do, we can
- 44:14do wherever we want. And you should follow me.
- 44:16But if not, you can stay here and follow whatever
- 44:18path you want. And he leaves. And there's this
- 44:21great shot of Martin making his decision of what
- 44:25he wants to do. And the only thing he takes out
- 44:27of his giant lab is the one tool that he brought
- 44:29with him, which is this, it's a microscope, I
- 44:34think. And he takes the microscope, or not microscope,
- 44:38what is that called? Where you look at the Petri
- 44:40dish underneath. It's a microscope. I guess that's
- 44:42true. I was thinking like a, nevermind. My brain's
- 44:45not working. So it was a microscope and he, he
- 44:47takes it with him and he leaves. And as he's
- 44:50walking out, he emerges from a bunch of reporters,
- 44:53people who are trying to get his attention, trying
- 44:55to get a story on the news that has broken about
- 44:58the plague and him solving it. And he says like,
- 45:00I've made my decision. I forget the final line
- 45:03that he says, but he's made his decision and
- 45:05he's coming. He's following Wicket. And he walks
- 45:08past the camera. And that's the final shot of
- 45:10the movie is him walking past the crowd and past
- 45:12the camera. And we just end there. He has that
- 45:14great line. I believe he says like, Terry, I'm
- 45:18coming with you and I'm bringing Leora. Oh, that's
- 45:21right. Which is huge because that's the decision
- 45:24maker right there that he is certainly not going
- 45:26to go with. Lanyon. Yes. Yeah. Myrna Loy's character.
- 45:31Character. Character. character and you know
- 45:35he's he's now very dedicated to uh his his late
- 45:38wife yeah but also to the cause um so he can
- 45:43have it all yeah which is kind of weird that
- 45:45he's like yeah now i'll dedicate my time to my
- 45:48wife yeah i i can see uh i can see lorna being
- 45:51up there being like Looking down and be like,
- 45:54oh, now you choose me. Yeah, she's the meme with
- 45:56the guy with the hand on the hips. She's just
- 45:57like, really? This is what it took? Yeah, it
- 46:00only took me to die for you to choose me. Right.
- 46:02Appreciate that. Yeah, I... So I'll briefly just
- 46:06say that the ending, I thought, went on just
- 46:09a little too long. Yeah. I wish it would have
- 46:10cut just a little earlier. The movie's about
- 46:12five, two minutes, ten minutes too long. Yeah,
- 46:14I agree. Beyond that, though, I think the most
- 46:17exciting elements of this movie, like, I did
- 46:20enjoy the story. I loved seeing John Ford in
- 46:23one of his first major films. Yeah. It's so exciting.
- 46:27Did you see The Fablemans? I did. Okay, we got
- 46:31to talk about that. Dude, so the second this
- 46:34movie started, I was like, all right, I'm looking
- 46:36for horizons. And I will say that first shot
- 46:39going across the prairie, the horizon is dead
- 46:42center. And I was just like. Oh, okay. This is
- 46:45like really early John Ford because he has not
- 46:47learned his Lynchian lesson. He has not, no.
- 46:51What we're referring to for those unfamiliar
- 46:52is that David Lynch portrays, he really is a
- 46:56cameo at the end of Steven Spielberg's The Fablemans.
- 46:58Yeah. portraying the role of john ford and john
- 47:01ford uh rather david lynch's john ford preaches
- 47:05the idea of how boring it is to film the horizon
- 47:07dead center yeah you want to put it at the top
- 47:10it's interesting bottom it's interesting right
- 47:12left it's interesting but you put it right in
- 47:13the center it's boring while he's eating cheetos
- 47:16putting the horizon right or left is very interesting
- 47:20to me well i mean i guess if you're laying down
- 47:23yeah You're laying down, you put it there. Sure,
- 47:25why not? But, you know, he goes on to do things
- 47:27like stagecoach, you know, How Green Was My Valley,
- 47:30The Grapes of Wrath. So much. A prolific director.
- 47:33So many movies we're going to cover as well.
- 47:34Yeah, so it's very interesting to be talking
- 47:36about this. And it's awesome to see the first
- 47:39example. This wasn't like he built into his creativity.
- 47:43Sure, with The Horizon and everything, he's learned
- 47:45his lesson with that afterwards. He has such
- 47:48great direction here specifically. And I want
- 47:50to talk a little bit about behind the scenes
- 47:51with John Ford. He was told by Samuel Goldwyn
- 47:55that the exception to this rule of you're going
- 47:58to make this movie and it's going to be great.
- 48:00However, you have to lay off the booze. Yeah.
- 48:03When you're filming this movie, you cannot be
- 48:06drinking. And John Ford, which maybe this is
- 48:08why David Lynch played him because it sounds
- 48:10very David Lynch. John Ford said that is not
- 48:13going to be a problem. I will not drink while
- 48:15I film this. I will, however, expedite the filming.
- 48:18So I do not have to be going that long without
- 48:21drinking. And this resulted in a lot of the movie
- 48:24being cut that was supposed to be shot. Helen
- 48:27Hayes, who portrays Leora, is in shock to find
- 48:30that she actually wasn't filming some of the
- 48:32scenes that she was supposed to be filming. Because
- 48:35John Ford has decided to cut those. So I think
- 48:38this is hysterical. I think it is so funny to
- 48:41hear this from your boss and be like, hey, man.
- 48:43Head of the studio, you can't be drinking while
- 48:45you do that. Not a problem. I won't. You didn't
- 48:48say that I couldn't expedite the filming, though,
- 48:50and make this six -month shoot an actual two
- 48:53-month shoot, and we're going to get out of here
- 48:54as quickly as possible. I'm making those numbers
- 48:57up, but that did happen. Sure. That alone, though,
- 49:00to say this shoot is going to take X amount of
- 49:04time, and for whatever reason, you decide, I'm
- 49:08going to make this take less time. Yeah. So impressive
- 49:11to get something of this quality. in an expedited
- 49:14shoot time. It does. It does make me wonder about
- 49:17the alternate reality thing where you're like,
- 49:19well, I wonder if they didn't tell you you had
- 49:21to lay off the booze while you were filming this,
- 49:22what you would have made. Because to your point,
- 49:25there's some shots in the beginning and towards
- 49:27the end with like, you know, the scene of, I
- 49:30do like that scene of Clarence when he isn't
- 49:33answering the phone and it's hanging down. But
- 49:36that in the beginning, there's just so many shots
- 49:38that feel rushed that... It's not that the shot
- 49:41feels rushed. It feels like the editing was almost
- 49:43rushed. It's probably because they didn't have
- 49:45the scenes to fill in the gaps on that. So it
- 49:48makes you wonder, what would this movie have
- 49:49looked like if you did have all the resources
- 49:51that you needed and the time you needed to get
- 49:54that done? But I don't think that stops it from
- 49:56a grating for me. It's still very much, I don't
- 50:02want to say a classic. I did very, very, very
- 50:05much enjoy this movie. Yeah, I think that the
- 50:08story itself is something that I'm like, yeah,
- 50:12that was entertaining enough. But it really is
- 50:14the direction and the art direction and the cinematography
- 50:18that really sold it. And just being able to see
- 50:20John Ford put together such an interesting movie.
- 50:24I mean, there are shots and even like editing
- 50:28transitions that we didn't bring up when they
- 50:31first moved to South Dakota, I believe. I don't
- 50:36know the term, but when the screen itself shrinks
- 50:39down into a circle. Oh, sure. And it does that
- 50:43into a train moving to the right side of the
- 50:47screen very quickly. And as the train passes,
- 50:50the camera does like a whip pan, but like a really
- 50:53long whip pan, almost like it's 270 degree rotation
- 50:56into Aerosmith's new, no, into Leora's home.
- 51:02And it... It's cool because you see the camera
- 51:05keep up pace with the train. And that's such
- 51:08a unique use of the camera in a way that we've
- 51:11certainly not seen yet. Even just the framing,
- 51:14there's the cowboy angle. When you line up the
- 51:17shot, you get not the actors at like the torso.
- 51:22You lower it down a little bit to just below
- 51:25the hip to where you could see a gun on their
- 51:27belt. Oh, okay. John Ford, of course, is a big
- 51:31Western guy. He did tons of Westerns. Right.
- 51:34And that is kind of the standard in a Western
- 51:36because you want to show off the weapon. They
- 51:39do that a lot in this film as well, which of
- 51:41course is not a Western, but I think that's kind
- 51:42of like a John Ford trademark. I've almost said
- 51:45John Wayne like seven times and it's driving
- 51:47me nuts. You're doing great, sweetie. Keep it
- 51:50up. There's so many cool shots in this movie
- 51:53and just the composition of so many of these.
- 51:57What is your favorite shot sequence? In this?
- 52:02Yeah. I mean, I think easily it's Leora in the
- 52:05reflection in the door. Yeah. Because you're
- 52:07right. I mean, there's a lot of technical achievements
- 52:09there, but I think that when you have the meaning
- 52:12behind it of him looking at work and then seeing
- 52:15a reflection of his wife, I think that's exactly
- 52:17what I was looking for. It's very cool. And I
- 52:19think it's just that sequence in general where
- 52:21they then go up to the lab and then, like I mentioned,
- 52:23you see the New York skyline with snow and everything
- 52:25in the background, but he's too locked in on
- 52:28his lab. I think that whole sequence to me was
- 52:31like... There's actual storytelling in the framing
- 52:34of this and not just in the characters and what
- 52:36they're saying. Yeah, there was like there was
- 52:39a moment where Leora is sitting on the bed and
- 52:42she's very upset about something. But her back
- 52:45is to the camera and Aerosmith comes in and is
- 52:47talking to her. And I was like, why are we shooting
- 52:50this from behind? This doesn't make any sense
- 52:52to me. And that's when the kids roll up to the
- 52:55window that is also in the frame. And I was like,
- 52:57OK, there's purpose in this setup. I thought
- 53:01that was cool. Well, it makes you think too,
- 53:03if he had more time, maybe that's like, okay,
- 53:04well now we're going to do the shot where we're
- 53:06facing Leora and now we can get like the reactions
- 53:09of her face. And then we'll use the other camera
- 53:11angle to show the kids come in. But because we're
- 53:14trying to like get this as quickly as possible,
- 53:16I think that limits where the camera can be,
- 53:18which ultimately could lead to a movie feeling
- 53:21rushed. And there's parts of this that do feel
- 53:23rushed, but it's hard to use that word rush when
- 53:26you have some of the scenes like you do and some
- 53:28of the camera placements that you do here. where
- 53:30it feels extremely intentional. And that helps
- 53:33the narrative. So it's a very strange movie in
- 53:36that sense, to where it's not perfect. And it's
- 53:39definitely not what John Ford is known for, right?
- 53:42You mentioned his Westerns and all the movies
- 53:44that are to come that we'll cover. Really excited
- 53:45to get to Stagecoach. But when this happens,
- 53:49it feels like this, you can't ask for a better
- 53:52example of like, with John Ford, where did he
- 53:55start? Because you could expect, like, oh, his
- 53:57first feature, it's probably just some, like,
- 53:58nothing burger movie. This isn't that. This is
- 54:01something really interesting. This certainly
- 54:04wasn't his first feature. Oh, correct. His first
- 54:07time to show up at the Academy is just like,
- 54:09wow, so well done. Extremely. Real quick, and
- 54:12then we'll get into the ratings. I just want
- 54:14to highlight Ronald Coleman. At this point in
- 54:16his career, he had already been nominated for
- 54:18Best Actor at the third Academy Awards for Bulldog,
- 54:22Drummond, and Condemned back when they were still
- 54:24doing multiple films. But Helen Hayes, how much
- 54:28did you read about her? Not a ton. Her name is
- 54:31the only person in this movie. As far as acting
- 54:34goes, that I was like, I'm familiar with that
- 54:36name. I don't know that I've seen her in much.
- 54:37I did see her in Airport, which we will be covering
- 54:41in 1970. She was nominated for Best Supporting
- 54:44Actress. So roughly 2040. Yes, right around there.
- 54:48Insane. But beyond that, she was a huge theater
- 54:52contributor and actress. So much so that she
- 54:56was considered the first lady of American theater.
- 55:00She was the second person ever and the first
- 55:02woman to win an EGOT. She was awarded the Presidential
- 55:07Medal of Freedom and the National Medal of Arts.
- 55:11She's like a huge philanthropist that has built
- 55:14hospitals and research facilities for like wildlife,
- 55:18wildflower rehabilitation. There are theaters
- 55:21named after her. She's just this monument of
- 55:24a woman. So she's Aerosmith. Yeah, she like left
- 55:28him in the dust. I think recently, maybe like
- 55:32the past 10 years, she showed up on a stamp,
- 55:35which is a, you know, a huge indicator of importance
- 55:37in this country. Yeah. But her debut on film
- 55:41was also this year. She was nominated for The
- 55:44Sin of Madeline Claudette, which she won the
- 55:48Academy Award for Best Actor, Actress, excuse
- 55:51me. I think she's like the coolest person to
- 55:54come out of this movie. I mean, easily. Outside
- 55:57of John Ford, like 100%. Ronald Coleman, we haven't
- 56:01heard a ton from since then. Not to say he disappeared,
- 56:03but I mean, how can you beat that legacy with
- 56:06Helen Hayes? Insane. Yeah. It's so huge. But
- 56:09yeah, that's what I've got so far. What do you...
- 56:11So far, that's what I've got. What do you have
- 56:14for ratings? So for ratings, you and I are actually
- 56:17matched. Spoiler. Well, I didn't say yours and
- 56:20I didn't say mine. So we are matched. We both
- 56:23gave this three and a half stars. Yeah, we did.
- 56:25Spoiler. So here's the thing. I talked about
- 56:30how much I really like this movie and the direction
- 56:32is a large part of that. I don't want to say
- 56:34that the story bogs it down, but I feel like
- 56:36it feels so disconnected by the end because we
- 56:40have rushed through this man's essentially life
- 56:42and parts of it feel like that went on a little
- 56:44bit longer than it should have. It feels like
- 56:47some scenes are kind of teased. Hey, this is
- 56:49going to happen. No, it's not. This is the lanyard
- 56:52of it all. It feels just disconnected to me to
- 56:55where it doesn't feel like a coherent story all
- 56:58the way around. But there are so many incredible
- 57:00moments of this movie that are lent by the direction
- 57:03and the art style that I thought was like almost
- 57:07breathtaking in the moment. So I want to give
- 57:10this like this is an easy 3 .75 for me. Like
- 57:13it's just right below a four. But because Letterboxd
- 57:16has not responded to our emails just yet, I'm
- 57:19going to keep it my three and a half. Yeah. And
- 57:21three and a half, I think, is where it sits for
- 57:23me just solidly. Just to talk about the Lanyon
- 57:26hinting of an affair. I think that what I'm starting
- 57:30to do is in these early films, if something is
- 57:34even mildly implied, it happened. That's just
- 57:37what I'm going to do, because obviously they
- 57:39couldn't show an affair. Sure. Due to the production
- 57:41code and everything. So I'm just going to say.
- 57:44That is their intention there. Anytime that happens.
- 57:47I mean, that makes more sense. I hate you, Martin
- 57:50Aerosmith, if that's the case. Yeah. Because
- 57:53that just feels like, okay, I mean, what's the
- 57:54worst thing that can happen other than having
- 57:57an affair on your wife? I don't know. She dies
- 57:58of the plague. Yeah. Like, come on, man. She
- 58:02has a miscarriage in this movie. She does. We
- 58:04completely glazed over that. Well, I mean, look,
- 58:06when so many other things happen. I mean, that's
- 58:08just to show, like. They're really rushing through
- 58:11some of this stuff. Correct. Also, I would like
- 58:13to point out that the tagline of this movie,
- 58:15at least listed on the Letterboxd account, is
- 58:17he fought for man and lost a woman! Exclamation
- 58:20point. Spoiler! These movies love to spoil themselves
- 58:24in the poster. Yeah, they do. There's so many
- 58:26things like that. So let's talk about Double
- 58:28Feature. Do it to it. What do you got? So I went
- 58:31with a film that I have not seen in a long, long
- 58:33time. Okay. So this might be a mess. But this
- 58:36is a film starring Edward Norton and Naomi Watts,
- 58:40The Painted Veil. And this is going off memory.
- 58:43I believe he is a doctor that goes to some other
- 58:48country to fight or help an outbreak of cholera.
- 58:53Okay. And while he is dealing with that, he is
- 58:57also struggling with a... An unfaithful wife.
- 59:01There you go. That's the word, yes. I was going
- 59:03to say, fidelity. Yeah. So very similar. A doctor
- 59:07going out to do things and having kind of other
- 59:11issues in his life influence his work a little
- 59:13bit. The Painted Veil kind of paints the woman
- 59:17in a bad light, whereas I think Aerosmith is
- 59:20the opposite. Aerosmith is kind of the problem
- 59:23here, or majorly the problem, as we get to the
- 59:26Myrna Loy point. So not a one -to -one comparison,
- 59:30but halfway through watching this movie, I was
- 59:32like, you know, this reminds me of The Painted
- 59:33Veil. And then I saw it was listed as a similar
- 59:36movie on Letterboxd. And everyone said, we agree.
- 59:38Yeah. And I said, thanks, guys. How about your
- 59:41double feature? That means it's effective. You
- 59:42said this earlier, like it's a bad thing. I think
- 59:44that just means it's effective. It'd be one thing
- 59:46if you saw it and you're like, yeah, I agree.
- 59:48And you wrote it down. But you thought of it
- 59:49beforehand. Also listed in similar films was
- 59:52The Creature Walks Among Us. We're still trying
- 59:54to figure that one out. Yeah, we got some questions,
- 59:56but maybe it's the John Ford of it all. Who's
- 59:57to say? I went in a very different direction.
- 1:00:00I thought about a couple movies with doctors
- 1:00:03and the idea of medication and the practice of
- 1:00:06that and how that can weigh you down. And then
- 1:00:08I kind of thought about the back half of this
- 1:00:09movie, or really the back quarter. I'm going
- 1:00:12to say it's a long movie. It's not. There's a
- 1:00:14lot that happens in this movie. The last quarter
- 1:00:16of this movie is him traveling to India and the
- 1:00:18idea of him kind of immersing himself in the
- 1:00:20culture and trying to bring the betterment to
- 1:00:23them. But also the idea of romance playing a
- 1:00:26large part of this, whether it be his failed
- 1:00:29connection with Leora or this possible definitely
- 1:00:33did happen infidelity with Lanyon. Right. And
- 1:00:37that reminded me a bit of the 2011 film Salmon
- 1:00:42Fishing in the Yemen from director Lasse Hallström.
- 1:00:45You just said a thousand words I've never heard
- 1:00:47before. Salmon. That's one. Okay. Fishing. I
- 1:00:50think you know about that one. That's two. That's
- 1:00:52how you get the salmon. In. Are you familiar
- 1:00:54with that word? Depends on the context, but sure.
- 1:00:57Go ahead. It is in the Yemen. So it's salmon
- 1:01:00fishing in the Yemen. In the Yemen. Friends reference
- 1:01:04there. Chandler goes to Yemen. That's what this
- 1:01:07is. No, it stars Emily Blunt and Ewan McGregor.
- 1:01:12So specifically. He's a fisheries expert about
- 1:01:16the idea of bringing the sport of fly fishing
- 1:01:20to the desert. And there's a whole thing about
- 1:01:22that. And the romance between Emily Blunt and
- 1:01:25Ewan McGregor reminded me of this a little bit.
- 1:01:27But the idea of someone bringing their expertise
- 1:01:30to this knowledge to this location and then finding
- 1:01:34more than they bargained for in that location.
- 1:01:36This is like a feel -good rom -com kind of thing.
- 1:01:39So this is a very different style of movie. But
- 1:01:41that idea. kind of felt like, okay, what this
- 1:01:44movie is missing is this sense of romance, not
- 1:01:48adventure, but what we can bring to ourselves
- 1:01:51in this kind of scenario. It just reminded me
- 1:01:54of something like Salmon Fishing in the Yemen.
- 1:01:56I want to go ahead and go on the record and say
- 1:01:58that Aerosmith is probably exponentially a better
- 1:02:01movie than Salmon Fishing in the Yemen, and there
- 1:02:03are very different styles of movies, but I feel
- 1:02:06like the amount of time that they spend in the
- 1:02:08Yemen in Salmon Fishing in the Yemen is... counterintuitive
- 1:02:14to, or is good counterprogram is what I mean,
- 1:02:16to something like Aerosmith where it's like maybe
- 1:02:1920 minutes of the movie. Right. You get the tooth
- 1:02:22pulling and... There's so many scenes that happen
- 1:02:24in this movie where we're like, couldn't we spend
- 1:02:25more time in India? But sure. Okay. But no, Salmon
- 1:02:29Fishing in the Yemen. This was a movie that I
- 1:02:31reviewed earlier on as a critic and was like,
- 1:02:34that's going to stay with me for a while. Interesting.
- 1:02:36I love you, McGregor. That's pretty much what
- 1:02:37it is. Sure. Yeah. Emily Blunt. Solid, too. Yeah,
- 1:02:40I like Emily Blunt. I like her as well. She's
- 1:02:42pretty great. Yeah. I just looked it up as far
- 1:02:45as physical releases go for Aerosmith. Yeah.
- 1:02:47April 28th, 2026, there will be a Blu -ray released.
- 1:02:53No ray. I just did the opposite. That's white.
- 1:02:57No way. There's a Blu -ray. Yeah. Okay, that's
- 1:02:59so cool. In three weeks. Because I do really
- 1:03:01want to own this. Yeah, yeah. For sure. I'm very
- 1:03:03excited about that. Did you see who's releasing
- 1:03:06it? It is Warner Archive Collection. Another
- 1:03:09huge Warner Archive dub. Man, they put out a
- 1:03:12lot of stuff. They do. So thank you again for
- 1:03:15Warner Archive for being a leading voice in the
- 1:03:20preservation of film through physical media.
- 1:03:22Yeah, thanks, Warner. So that's Aerosmith. Appreciate
- 1:03:25you guys hanging out for us. If you have thoughts
- 1:03:27on Aerosmith or a good double feature that involves
- 1:03:30salmon fishing. I think I gave the best one.
- 1:03:33Probably. That features salmon fishing. What
- 1:03:34if there is a better one and someone comes to
- 1:03:36us with it and we watch it and we're like, wow.
- 1:03:38Bryce, I'm awaiting you to let me know. I think
- 1:03:40that's a Victoria job. She's always coming out
- 1:03:43with just crazy double features. Victoria, let
- 1:03:45us know when there's a better movie that features
- 1:03:47salmon fishing. Yeah. It can or cannot include
- 1:03:50the Yemen. Yes. Has to include the plague. Good
- 1:03:53luck. She's like, it's just Aerosmith. Right.
- 1:03:57If you do want to shoot your thoughts to us,
- 1:03:59they will be read on the ceremony episode coming
- 1:04:01out on April 29th. Reach us via email, OUTAOPodcast
- 1:04:06at gmail .com. We'll also be doing a watch party
- 1:04:09on the 29th. You can... Find more info on that
- 1:04:13via our Patreon. That's patreon .com slash O
- 1:04:16-U -T -A -O podcast. And next episode, we will
- 1:04:20be talking about Shanghai Express. So look forward
- 1:04:24to that. Anything else you want to add? I don't
- 1:04:27know why I said that through gritted teeth. What
- 1:04:29else do you want to talk about? Like I was pounding
- 1:04:31my fist. Isn't the next episode the champ? That's
- 1:04:33the previous episode. We recorded these. Why
- 1:04:36did we record these backwards? Because I wanted
- 1:04:38you to get Aerosmith like. I appreciate that.
- 1:04:40It is older in your mind. Nope, that's it for
- 1:04:42me. Perfect. Thanks for listening, guys. As always,
- 1:04:46I'm your host, Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see
- 1:04:49you at the movies.