Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E016: Assessing Custodial Threat Vectors with Guy Swann
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of money? Does is it creates?
- 0:27A single network which can do a microtransaction to a giga
- 0:33transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 0:38of the major forces for reducing.
- 0:41The role of gun. The one thing that's missing
- 0:44that that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51Welcome back to Final Settlement everyone.
- 0:54This is episode 16 great show for you guys today we have the
- 0:59great guy Swan, prolific Bitcoin educator and and host of Bitcoin
- 1:06audible, which I'm sure many of you are familiar with.
- 1:10We have lots to get to today, but it is a a, you know,
- 1:12somewhat of an important day. It's Election Day here in the
- 1:15United States and so. Twitter social is going to be so
- 1:20unfun today. Just.
- 1:21A lot of doom scrolling today. Imagine.
- 1:25All the numbers are so good. We're totally winning.
- 1:27There's no market charge. Too many of these people have
- 1:30voted. I mean, it's been a crazy just
- 1:33few weeks, few weeks. It's like you can't, you can't
- 1:36look at anything objectively and say like this means anything.
- 1:42So yeah, it's been a whirlwind of a few weeks leading up to
- 1:45this. But yeah, welcome to the show,
- 1:49guy. Happy to happy.
- 1:51To have you and thank you. This will be a great
- 1:53conversation, but on the on the topic of the election, I
- 1:58mentioned before we hit record, I wrote a a piece for on ramp
- 2:02about a year ago today and it was called a political money and
- 2:06it was really looking at Bitcoin, you know, from its
- 2:09foundational level. The, the core protocol itself
- 2:12is, is in my mind a political in many ways just in terms of, you
- 2:18know, at the core of it, you know, you're trusting math
- 2:22instead of fallible humans, right?
- 2:24And part of what I also wrote about is, is looking at the
- 2:28trajectory of traditional assets, you know, most
- 2:31importantly the dollar, that have become increasingly
- 2:34politicized over the past several decades.
- 2:37And Bitcoin stands in contrast to that in that, you know, at
- 2:41its core, it's harder to politicize.
- 2:46But the interesting paradox that I called out was that, you know,
- 2:49and and I wrote this about 12 months ago, but it was really,
- 2:52you know, really past 12 to 24 months where I started to see
- 2:56Bitcoin become politicized in the sense of certain politicians
- 3:02understanding what it represented to a certain cohort
- 3:05of voters. And that being really, you know,
- 3:06freedom money at its core. And so, you know, those
- 3:10politicians latching onto it as a, you know, a talking point,
- 3:13something that they would be willing to vouch for if they
- 3:16think that they could win those votes.
- 3:17So guy, I'm, I'm very curious to get your thoughts on on this
- 3:20concept of Bitcoin being a political.
- 3:22But then the, the very clear trajectory that we've seen of,
- 3:26you know, the past year or two where it's really, you know,
- 3:30Bitcoin has has shifted the Overton window in some sense
- 3:33where politicians are talking about this regularly now.
- 3:35Like I think if we just rewind 4 years, like that seems kind of
- 3:38insane that that's where we're at today.
- 3:42But yeah, would love your thoughts on any of that.
- 3:44Yeah, so I've, I think I've probably had posts and maybe
- 3:49even episodes on the show where I talked about like Bitcoin as a
- 3:52political money because like from a purely like practical
- 3:57sense or I guess technical sense from just like pure like what is
- 4:03Bitcoin? There's no politics, right,
- 4:06Right. It is it is genuinely a
- 4:08political money. It does not and cannot care
- 4:10about anything. Whereas you talk about like the
- 4:13dollar being politicized. Think it's a great example
- 4:16because you can see like the dollar is literally being used
- 4:19as a political weapon against people because it is
- 4:22permissioned and because it is controlled, it can be
- 4:26selectively manipulated for a certain cohort.
- 4:30Like so that someone who has the wrong political opinion or lives
- 4:34in the wrong director, a jurisdiction literally does not
- 4:38use the same money. It doesn't work the same.
- 4:41And in that sense, like Bitcoin is pure a political money.
- 4:45But the the thing that gets me about this, and I kind of go
- 4:48back and forth between whether or not it's an accurate
- 4:51description, because a lot of politics is about controlling
- 4:55other people. A lot of political ideology is
- 5:02about everyone should do this and if they don't, the state
- 5:05should force them. And in that sense, Bitcoin can't
- 5:10be a political in that environment.
- 5:12It's like saying a gun is a political Sure, from a technical
- 5:16sense, there is no politics in a gun.
- 5:18But between a socialist and an individualist, somebody who
- 5:21actually believes in freedom, a gun is a very political tool,
- 5:24you know, like, so when it's kind of boots on the ground,
- 5:29which political ideology does it actually defend or enforce?
- 5:35Like from an individual perspective, it's totally
- 5:37apolitical. Like whether you are a socialist
- 5:40or whether you are a, you know, freedom loving, whatever you're
- 5:44crazy right wing, the white supremacist or Nazi or a Russian
- 5:52or kid in China doesn't matter. It is perfectly apolitical
- 5:57according to the individual. But according to the group,
- 6:01there are very different ideologies that can be either
- 6:04defended like a socialist can defend themselves and do
- 6:07everything like a politically with Bitcoin.
- 6:10But the socialist ideology cannot sustain itself using
- 6:15Bitcoin because it literally negates one of their fundamental
- 6:19tools of collective control, one of the most important tools of
- 6:23collective control. So it's weird because like an
- 6:26add an individual technical, like just purely what is it
- 6:31level? Of course it's apolitical.
- 6:33It doesn't do anything. It doesn't have a notion of who
- 6:37is, who is using it. That's why we say, you know,
- 6:39Bitcoin is for everyone, right? Can't persecute you for your
- 6:43religion or your sexual orientation or anything like
- 6:46that. But from a collective sense,
- 6:50when many people are using Bitcoin, there are certain
- 6:53political ideologies that just won't work.
- 6:56And that's a really interesting dynamic.
- 7:00And it makes it hard for me to say like I completely understand
- 7:05the argument on both sides, you know, like whether it is a
- 7:08political money or very, very political money in a certain
- 7:11regard. So I guess maybe it's like the
- 7:14scale or where in kind of like the layers of politics you're
- 7:19talking about and and how because.
- 7:22Yeah, is, is sort of what you're getting at.
- 7:25And correct me if I'm wrong, but like for the individual, like
- 7:27you're saying like Bitcoin as a tool is a political.
- 7:31But if you Fast forward, I guess Bitcoin adoption to it being
- 7:37more of a ubiquitous tool and in an entire community or say
- 7:42country is using Bitcoin, then there are some parameters within
- 7:47which it made. It's not that it's political the
- 7:50tool, but it's there's certain political realms where that
- 7:53could go in a, in a fully bitcoinized world.
- 7:55Is that kind of what you're getting at?
- 7:58Yes, yes. And I have some better way to
- 8:01say it maybe. Maybe the way to say it is from
- 8:04the individual perspective, Bitcoin is completely and
- 8:08completely apolitical. But the, and that's like Bitcoin
- 8:13the thing or the money. But Bitcoin as a network is
- 8:16actually a set, is actually a political structure.
- 8:20It's actually a set of rules. You know, all politics says is a
- 8:23set of rules. Bitcoin is the network is a set
- 8:28of rules. That is inherently political
- 8:31because it is in that environment.
- 8:32It's rules about who owns what, how you determine ownership and
- 8:37who has the rights to do what in the network.
- 8:40That's a political institution. It's just one that doesn't have
- 8:44goals. Ideology then that Bitcoin
- 8:46represents is a meritocracy, right guys?
- 8:49It's not a system which if your system that you're supporting is
- 8:541 based on, you know, socialism or communism or is some, you
- 8:59know, the, you know, the 5th pillar of the Communist
- 9:03manifesto is central banking. So if those are some of the core
- 9:05tenets of your group or like what you style as an individual
- 9:08level, this Bitcoin system and network is not going to work for
- 9:12you and doesn't align with the way that you want to, you know,
- 9:16try to better the world or whatever your aims are, whether
- 9:18they're nefarious or in your mind, good.
- 9:21Because you can't do things such as redistribute wealth at will.
- 9:24Yeah. You don't have that
- 9:25centralization of control that allows you to redistribute
- 9:29resources and in whatever way you see fit.
- 9:31Again, whether you perceive that to be for for better, for worse,
- 9:35Bitcoin doesn't allow that for better, for worse, and we would
- 9:38say for far better. But the playing field is equal
- 9:41in level and the rules are fixed and the money is fixed.
- 9:44Yeah. And it's kind of like a everyone
- 9:47is equal before the network or everyone is equal before the
- 9:51cryptography. Like outside of that, you know,
- 9:54it's your obligation, it's your responsibility to deal with
- 9:56that. But in the context of Bitcoin,
- 9:58it doesn't matter if you can sign for it, it's yours because
- 10:01the rules are independent of the like we, it's, it is, it is a
- 10:07completely unique and completely independent set of property
- 10:11rights, a system of property rights in the digital realm, in
- 10:15my opinion. And I think that inherently
- 10:17can't be a political from that top down view, but from a
- 10:25personal perspective, like from the individual using Bitcoin,
- 10:29there is no politics in Bitcoin, you know.
- 10:32And so it's, it's a very, very interesting thread to pull on.
- 10:38I've done it for for many times, many times a long time.
- 10:43Yeah. And, and it's, it's also been
- 10:44interesting that I think, you know, something that supports
- 10:49everything that we just walk through is that there's, you
- 10:54know, it's hard to estimate the, the size of this cohort, but
- 10:57there's a cohort now in America where Bitcoin support for
- 11:01Bitcoin is, you know, these people are single issue voters.
- 11:06And so is that political? Like if, if, you know, if this
- 11:11is the only thing a certain a growing cohort of the country
- 11:14cares about, then it's entered the political realm in the sense
- 11:19of the existing parties, the existing political
- 11:22infrastructure needs to now consider this thing.
- 11:26And so that's, that's just been a fascinating thing to watch
- 11:29play out. Certainly makes it politically
- 11:31important, yes, you know, it certainly puts it on the
- 11:34political playing field. It's it's a ball in play.
- 11:38That's for sure. And it's funny to me, I was
- 11:39thinking about this this morning.
- 11:41Like I would say over the summer, you know, after after
- 11:44Nashville, I think there was sort of the expectation that the
- 11:51game theory we all like to talk about would play out and ensue.
- 11:56And I don't think we really saw that to the extent that maybe
- 11:59people expected to back then in terms of the Democrats, you
- 12:04know, trying to match Trump's favor and excitement about the,
- 12:09you know, the Bitcoin community and, and reaching that that now
- 12:13single issue voting bloc. I would say, I would say there's
- 12:15a couple comments did play out. I would say the game theory did
- 12:18play out, but it played out with them shutting down their attacks
- 12:23of it like they're just like shut up, stop talking about it
- 12:26right because. We.
- 12:28Look like the opposite of this. It is it is the game theory
- 12:32playing out, but it's not the game theory that, you know, many
- 12:36assumed of them like, Oh well, we're just going to try to go
- 12:38harder. They're not trying to out
- 12:40compete Trump. They're just trying to not look
- 12:42like the thing that makes Trump look good.
- 12:45Yes. So that's fair.
- 12:46They don't like it and they don't want to like it, but they
- 12:49can't say anything bad about it because now they know what that
- 12:52means and what that's going to look like when you're holding it
- 12:55up. You know which which one of
- 12:57these pictures you know. You know when you're making that
- 13:00comparison. No, that's, that's a great
- 13:02point. Are you ready to secure your
- 13:04future with Bitcoin? At Onramp, we're revolutionizing
- 13:07how you can save for retirement. Onramp has just launched the
- 13:10industry's first Bitcoin IRA product with multi institution
- 13:14custody, designed to give you unparalleled security,
- 13:17transparency, and Peace of Mind. With Onramp, you can verify your
- 13:20assets on chain and protect them with the support of three
- 13:23independent institutions, reducing risks and enhancing
- 13:27security. At Onramp, we believe that
- 13:29Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 13:32The hard part is securing it right.
- 13:34There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 13:36exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 13:39arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 13:41concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 13:44solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 13:48ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 13:50possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 13:53your family is protected as well.
- 13:56On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 13:58whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a complement
- 14:01to your existing self custody setup.
- 14:03For more information about our services as well as our new
- 14:06Bitcoin IRA product, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 14:10But another sort of a transition to you know, you mentioned this
- 14:17there are very you know, there are many very unique attributes
- 14:20of Bitcoin. I think one of them that is
- 14:23worth talking about is you know it's this is a digital bearer
- 14:27instrument and that just really hasn't existed ever in human
- 14:31history. And so I think as a species we
- 14:34are still grappling with and learning to understand what we
- 14:39do with that type of asset, right.
- 14:41It's been 1516 years. We have hardware devices, we
- 14:46have third party custodians. Oh wow, we 16 years, didn't we?
- 14:50Yeah, yeah. Well, since the White Paper 16
- 14:52on January 3rd. But that's I mean that's a
- 14:56relatively short period of time in terms of technical.
- 14:59Learning to drive. Technical, technological
- 15:02adoption like that's a, that's a blip in terms of monetary
- 15:05history and absolute blip, right.
- 15:06So I guess where I'm going with this is what are your thoughts
- 15:13on Bitcoin's unique nature in this way of, of how it needs to
- 15:17be secured and stored and how you've thought about that over
- 15:21the years? And maybe how you're thinking
- 15:23has evolved from when you first got into Bitcoin to now and how
- 15:27you think about securing, you know, your Bitcoin well into the
- 15:30future, handing it off to your kids, their kids.
- 15:34Like how, how do you think about that generally and, and really
- 15:37compare and contrast it to, you know, anything else anyone could
- 15:41ever hold? It's very different.
- 15:43And I think that there's, yeah, there's there's a learning curve
- 15:47obviously associated with it, but I think it's it's on us as
- 15:51Bitcoiners and as a Bitcoin community to not only educate on
- 15:56best practices, but also think of new ways and innovate to make
- 16:00it easier to store this asset in a secured way.
- 16:04Yeah, so my feelings have been in the same direction, but they
- 16:12have gotten far. The conviction on it has gotten
- 16:16much, much deeper the more time has gone on.
- 16:19I don't do anything that's not multi sig anymore.
- 16:21Almost like anything on chain like the only thing that's not
- 16:25multi sig, which is actually funny it's it is multi sig is
- 16:27lightning. Multi lightning is multi sig
- 16:29too. So I don't I don't do anything
- 16:31that's not multi sig basically, except for like my hottest of
- 16:34hot wallets. It's just like a single key for
- 16:37you know, little day-to-day stuff.
- 16:39But for the things that I am doing, spending out of that, I
- 16:43move from a multi sig in chunks when I need it and then back,
- 16:48back and forth from it. And having, you know, a lot of
- 16:54people like it's so easy to do the mantra of not your keys, not
- 16:58coins. And, and I think it's important
- 17:01to remember that those tag lines and the the kind of mottos of
- 17:08the space are guidelines. Like you have to consider the
- 17:14situation, You have to consider the person you're talking to.
- 17:17And I have on boarded a lot of people into Bitcoin over the
- 17:20years a lot. And it is not easy.
- 17:24It is not easy. So many people are confused, So
- 17:27many people need help and that journey from like knowing
- 17:32nothing and never having any Bitcoin to genuinely holding
- 17:35your keys in a way that matters is not sit down with them for 10
- 17:39minutes, You know, like that's a typically very long journey to
- 17:45the point that like to the point that like I worry about some
- 17:49people that I've gotten into Bitcoin, like I don't like it
- 17:53stresses me out that I feel like I could have, I've put them at
- 17:57risk. And I mean, of course, it's not
- 18:02like, you know, my obligation to fix their whole setup and do
- 18:07everything for them and, you know, keep their seed because
- 18:10that defeats the whole purpose of the seed.
- 18:13But it does feel that way, you know, it doesn't.
- 18:17It doesn't help that like, I know the risk and I know what
- 18:20they could do and what they're likely to do.
- 18:22Like my contractor or whatever I've been slowly working my way
- 18:27towards getting him in a real setup.
- 18:31He's more of a buy on Coinbase and then accidentally buy some
- 18:35shit coin that Coinbase told him to and then lose it all because
- 18:39they delisted the shit coin. And just like real true story I
- 18:44was. I'm so mad at Coinbase but God
- 18:49what a shitty service. Anyway, so I've been trying to
- 18:54figure out how to assist and how to set up somebody's multi sig
- 19:02to negate lost keys. Because I think since we've
- 19:08started this this whole thing, he's lost his phone twice, just
- 19:13like in construction stuff, dropped it somewhere, crushed it
- 19:16with, you know, like like that sort of thing.
- 19:20So having a key on the phone as the only thing that secures
- 19:26this, you know, mobile keys not going to work.
- 19:29Got to have a backup. And also, you know, if I know
- 19:34people who are extremely messy, totally unorganized, they're
- 19:37going to write it down a piece of paper, that piece of paper is
- 19:39gone. You know, like they don't have
- 19:42AI know people who live out of their car basically like when
- 19:44they're working, you know, for weeks at a time.
- 19:48And that person is not going to have a safe place to store a
- 19:51seed. And multi sig is literally the
- 19:54best possible thing for splitting that up for for salt,
- 20:01getting around all of those limitations.
- 20:03Lost your phone? OK, get the new phone, set up a
- 20:06new just start a new key. You don't have to put down the
- 20:08seed. Put it do a one out of a three
- 20:11or five or something. And your phone is just the key.
- 20:14And if you lose it, OK, swap it to a new one.
- 20:16And you have just enough help to get someone over that hump to be
- 20:21able to recover the key, to be able to like.
- 20:23Just how do I move this again? How do I, how do I do this?
- 20:26Like, oh, don't worry, It's just this click, click, click and
- 20:28move it to this new key sent. And, and I've also because of
- 20:33that have gotten really dependent.
- 20:40That's not the word, Jessica. I really, really like the tap
- 20:45signer and I know it's not in the most secure key device in
- 20:48the world. You can't see what you're
- 20:50signing, you know, So if like your software is malicious, but
- 20:54I mean, if if you know what you're doing with your software,
- 20:56you check your signature and you install it, you know, the idea
- 20:58that it's been edited later or something is just extremely
- 21:01unlikely. But so you don't see the address
- 21:08with the tap signer like you do with a cold card or treasure or
- 21:13bit box or anything like that. That's that's the beauty of the
- 21:16ones with the screen. I think you should always have
- 21:17one with a screen in your setup and try to use it whenever you
- 21:20can't for that security reason. But tab signer is just something
- 21:25you can stick in your pocket like you used to have it in your
- 21:28wallet. And people are used to the
- 21:31process. They're used to the mind frame
- 21:35of keeping up with some cards. You know, everybody treats their
- 21:39wallet like people who have bad habits in every other regard
- 21:43know where their wallet is, you know, like, and that's hard to
- 21:47beat. If you can get a hardware wallet
- 21:50in that wallet, you don't have to change their habits.
- 21:53You don't have to make them understand.
- 21:55They know this is the thing that lets me pay.
- 21:58They know all of the setups. They have all of the right
- 22:01mental frame, all of the habits that are important to keep up
- 22:04with that. And if you do that with multi
- 22:08sig, keep this one in the one spot at home where you keep
- 22:11something important. Keep this one in your wallet.
- 22:16This one's on your phone. You can negate so many problems.
- 22:21You can negate so many possibilities of theft, of
- 22:27losing a device, of having your house burned down and not having
- 22:31your start losing those keys. Like it's extremely useful.
- 22:36And the really crazy thing about it is that it's something that
- 22:40you can't do with anything else. There is nothing, There is no
- 22:45financial instrument or tool of any sort that actually has that
- 22:50property except for Bitcoin, which is mind boggling.
- 22:55And it is one of the most underutilized tools in the
- 23:00toolbox. And increasingly, I think it's
- 23:01one of the most important. And we totally we totally agree
- 23:05I. Would have assumed you guys did.
- 23:09Yeah, not an unintentional advertisement for on ramp or
- 23:12anything. But no, you said a few things,
- 23:14really important things in there.
- 23:17The first being there's not like A1 size fits all for Bitcoin
- 23:21custody, right? Like there are different use
- 23:24cases, there's different risk tolerances.
- 23:28And you know, you can, there's a, there's merit to saying I'm
- 23:32going to diversify my custody setups.
- 23:34You know, I have a different wallet for different use cases,
- 23:37different setup for different use cases.
- 23:40And much of what we're trying to do it on ramp is say to your
- 23:43another one of your points like multi multi sig is the best.
- 23:46So let's, let's open up the accessibility of this thing
- 23:50called multi sig in a way that hasn't been done previously in
- 23:53the sense that, yes, Coinbase, you know, may use multi, say for
- 23:57their cold storage, but they hold all the keys.
- 23:59So it's, it's kind of irrelevant in, in terms of the actual risk
- 24:03mitigation of, of, you know, reducing that counterpart.
- 24:07And so our whole idea is let's distribute the keys to to
- 24:09multiple institutions and and reduce that barrier to entry to
- 24:15someone, to, you know, an individual or an institution
- 24:18getting the best foreign custody, IE multi sig.
- 24:21Let's reduce that barrier to entry meaningfully.
- 24:24And, and Cam, I'm, I'm curious your thoughts on this, because
- 24:27another thing guy said in there was that, you know, sometimes he
- 24:31worries about the people that he's on board.
- 24:32And I, and I know I've heard that from you in the past of
- 24:35because you've on boarded, you know, billions of dollars to
- 24:38multi sig in particular, other flavors of multi sig.
- 24:42But curious your thoughts on on any of that in terms of, you
- 24:46know, the evolution of custody, you know, different models,
- 24:49different use cases, all that? It's certainly still a difficult
- 24:54problem that we're grappling with, right guy?
- 24:55Because I've been using multi sig actually since I met you in
- 24:582019. And I got some great advice from
- 25:01Matt and Marty, who was listening to TFTC and started
- 25:05using Casa at the time and then later work for Unchained and now
- 25:08with Honor. And of course, I've been focused
- 25:10on it for a long time. And like, you know, I'm
- 25:12fascinated by it because it's never existed before.
- 25:15It is so powerful. You can have multiple keys that
- 25:19secure this asset. You can sign asynchronously
- 25:22different parts of the planet with different people signing.
- 25:24It's, it's so cool. It's like a James Bond
- 25:26technology you developed in the lab that's in the real world and
- 25:29we get to use it now. But then so one thing you
- 25:33touched on guy that I've been struggling with too a little bit
- 25:36is you're when someone either is starting to hold a material
- 25:40amount of Bitcoin that you want them in multi sig and you didn't
- 25:44you started to call it some of the reasons.
- 25:46But what I think you're driving at is redundancy, right, like
- 25:50having eliminating that single point of failure.
- 25:52That's a core tenant of Bitcoin security.
- 25:56But then the right we see the crossroads is what you're asking
- 26:01someone to do is then just use new technology and use multiple
- 26:06devices and form factors, whatever those might be, whether
- 26:09it's a mobile key in conjunction with hardware walls or a tap
- 26:12signer. Like there's multiple new piece
- 26:14of technology and you're asking people to change their pattern
- 26:19of behavior or like change the way that they they normally go
- 26:23about their day-to-day life as you were referencing.
- 26:25So that's where sometimes like then that cause for concern
- 26:29starts to creep in because you know, I'd go back and talk to my
- 26:31clients and like, OK, did you separate the devices?
- 26:33No, they're in the dust store. Did you when was the last time
- 26:36you did a key check? Remember what the wall
- 26:38configuration file is? You know, the essentially the
- 26:40backup for your multi sig right. So how do you think about that
- 26:44in terms of like trying to help people in the best practices?
- 26:47We we couldn't believe more strongly in multi sig because
- 26:51when you have a digital finite bare asset, you have to have
- 26:54redundancy because if you don't have redundancy and it's lost
- 26:58and it's gone forever. So multi sig is just a tool that
- 27:01provides a redundancy. But how do you kind of square
- 27:03the idea of the increased complexity of multi sig can
- 27:06bring with how human nature almost like more of a
- 27:10philosophical thing or like the the way that humans, you know,
- 27:14kind of manage their daily lives?
- 27:16Yeah, well, the multi sig backup is the big thing for the wallet
- 27:23configuration because, you know, you use the exact same keys.
- 27:28You can technically, I mean, not going to like if depending on
- 27:32like what wallet you're using, a lot of times it will just
- 27:35generate the exact same one because it's got like a default
- 27:37configuration. But you can technically create
- 27:41an infinite number of wallets and you can lose it just by
- 27:43losing your wallet configuration.
- 27:46So it, it is essentially a or at least in certain regards, it has
- 27:52the risk of being another single point of failure because that
- 27:57can be lost. But the big thing is that that
- 28:00is not is also not a major security risk.
- 28:05So it's easier to distribute and anybody that I on board or
- 28:12whatever, I have a couple of different wallets or excuse me,
- 28:16a big fan of ProtonMail. I use ProtonMail all the time
- 28:19and I have multiple different e-mail accounts and stuff.
- 28:23And one of the things I often do, I explain to them what the
- 28:28potential risk is, is that, you know, like I could technically
- 28:31pull this information and I could see what was in your
- 28:33wallet if I wanted to. I don't want to and I don't
- 28:36care. But if you want me to have a
- 28:38backup, you can e-mail it to me and you should e-mail it to
- 28:42yourself or to your wife or to anybody that you know.
- 28:45Just have this and label it in all big letters backup of
- 28:50whatever your app is. So that if you ever search
- 28:56whatever you think first when you think about this wallet,
- 29:00what's and you wanted to search that.
- 29:02If you want to search that in your e-mail, what would you
- 29:04find? Make sure that that comes up in
- 29:06that search result and then just have multiple copies of it.
- 29:11It's easy to mitigate and it's not a huge it's not a massive
- 29:16security risk. And if you know who you're
- 29:18giving it to, it's easy to just trust a friend or a family
- 29:23member or something with a backup of the wallet.
- 29:29In the context of keys is I specifically try to be sure one,
- 29:36one thing that I actually do for a number of people, especially
- 29:39family members and distant family members that I've gotten
- 29:42into Bitcoin is I just kind of make a habit of like every
- 29:46month, like shooting out a text, just like, you know where your
- 29:49keys are, Are they safe? I got just kind of do it
- 29:54regularly and everyone's like, oh, it's so good to hear from
- 29:56you and yeah, everything's great, you know?
- 30:00So just keep the conversation fresh, you know, because I think
- 30:05it's important just to remind people and you do that once a
- 30:09month for six months. It's hard for people to forget.
- 30:13You know, it's all, it's always about just a little bit of
- 30:15repetition. Like that's not hard to do.
- 30:17That is not hard to give up with.
- 30:19Set yourself a freaking reminder on the calendar.
- 30:22Text these 10 people or whatever to make sure that they know
- 30:25where their keys are. They will never forget where
- 30:28they are if you do that for half a year, you know, like they'll.
- 30:32You're a good man, guy. It will.
- 30:33Be in their mind have. Trouble setting birthday cards
- 30:36on the right date and the right date.
- 30:37I can't. I don't.
- 30:38I won't send a birthday card. I will send.
- 30:41I can send a text to help where your keys are.
- 30:46But then in addition to is I'll always like to do a setup that
- 30:51kind of forces me to have keys in multiple places like.
- 30:55So just as an example is if I'm using so I always try to use a
- 31:00wallet with a hardware wallet with a screen at some point in
- 31:05my setup. So it cold card dip box Trezor.
- 31:09I don't use my Trezor as much as I do is use typically typically
- 31:13a cold car these days, but one that I can verify and I can see
- 31:20you know what I can look at that address on the screen.
- 31:24But then I almost universally have a tap signer in my set up
- 31:28now because that one goes in my wallet and that one travels with
- 31:32me. My cold card isn't going to be
- 31:34in my wallet. It's never going to be in the
- 31:35same place. A tap signer is always going to
- 31:37be in my wallet. And then I typically like to
- 31:39have a mobile key and I can actually keep a backup of that
- 31:44in my secure non online password manager or something.
- 31:48So I can treat that key a little bit looser and more easily
- 31:55recover that. And I can put that in an
- 31:58encrypted BLOB on a storage service or something just as a
- 32:05backup drive for for those things.
- 32:07And I can recover that if I lose my computer or my phone or
- 32:10something like that. And again, it's one of three.
- 32:12So like if I think that's been compromised, easy to swap out
- 32:18and I also don't have to keep up with paper backup for that one
- 32:22if I don't want to. One thing I really wish was more
- 32:26standard though, because I would love this option is for mini
- 32:33script to be like far more ubiquitous or easy to work with
- 32:40I guess. And I think there's a, it's not,
- 32:44I keep thinking, I always think it's Poseidon.
- 32:47There's a wallet that Anchor wallet Anchor I think is one of
- 32:51the few that has started to implement this.
- 32:54But I love the idea of cascading keys.
- 32:57I would love to have a six month time lock where if I don't have
- 33:03any of the keys, my cold card can just sign.
- 33:06But I have to wait six months for the transaction to go
- 33:09through so that I can always just boot up the wallet.
- 33:12Look. And if somehow one of those keys
- 33:14got compromised and somebody sent a transaction.
- 33:17And in that time I can still use 2 keys and be like do what the
- 33:20fuck or do somebody hacked in my phone or whatever and I can
- 33:23react to it. But in the case where I do lose
- 33:28my tap signer and my phone and I don't know, I lose a whole bunch
- 33:33of things at once, The the way the setup is for like my I mean,
- 33:37this is like my day-to-day wallet that I do like a a setup
- 33:40like this. So I feel pretty secure in it.
- 33:45But if I did lose it, I would love to have that.
- 33:48I only need the cold card. It's just going to take me 6
- 33:50months to get my phones as a backup.
- 33:53That would be that would be a wonderful setup.
- 33:55Another thing that specifically Bitcoin can do that you cannot
- 33:59do with any other asset in the world.
- 34:02And I would love to be able to take more advantage of that.
- 34:07The only problem with doing that for other people, I mean, I
- 34:11guess unless you just keep it as dirt simple as possible, like
- 34:14one key will unlock this in six months, you know, is it becomes
- 34:18a little bit difficult to intuitively understand, you
- 34:21know, the, the risk and what to look for.
- 34:24And if they saw a transaction, Oh my God, what's happening?
- 34:27You know, like if if one of their keys got stolen, granted
- 34:30they have six months to sort it out.
- 34:32So they they would probably just call me, but I might not be
- 34:37there, you know, I might not be accessible, I might not be
- 34:40around, who knows. So.
- 34:41Not every, not not everybody has a guy.
- 34:44Not everybody has a guy, but. But you know, part of the part
- 34:50of the reason we wanted to have this conversation is is you put
- 34:53out a tweet a few days ago, you're in Lugano for the Plan B
- 34:56conference. And you said, you know, we face
- 34:58the truth. Many Bitcoiners overlook being a
- 35:00target is real. A man broke into our hotel room,
- 35:03likely seeking valuable assets Bitcoiners often carry.
- 35:06This is more than a story of vigilance.
- 35:08It's a call for every Bitcoiner to recognize the stakes.
- 35:11So you know, in as few or as many details as as you are
- 35:15willing to share, like would love to hear what happened and
- 35:19Lugano and and what were some learnings and takeaways and and
- 35:23things that the audience should should recognize about what
- 35:25occurred. Yeah, well, if you want the
- 35:27really long version, I did a guy's take on it, so.
- 35:31We'll we'll link to that in the show notes.
- 35:32Yeah, that'd be, that'd be great.
- 35:34Thank you. And I tried to do it while I was
- 35:39fresh, like right when I got home to just try to get out as
- 35:42many details as possible. Like I was thinking about it
- 35:45like a police report or something right now, because I
- 35:47didn't I didn't file in yet. I probably should.
- 35:52But we couldn't figure, couldn't find that we were so rushed to
- 35:55get to the train station. Like, I mean, we were like
- 35:58back-to-back to back that that morning getting out of there.
- 36:02And honestly, I don't feel like it's going to do any good, but I
- 36:06don't know if it's important to have that record.
- 36:07I can't, I can't convince myself why it's like super important to
- 36:10have a police record right now. But I feel like it would be
- 36:13stupid to run into a situation where I needed it and not have
- 36:16it. But anyway, that's, that's
- 36:20beside the point. So that was the night of the
- 36:24first day of the conference. So we've been there for two
- 36:28nights and did the first day conference and we were supposed
- 36:33to have a speakers dinner that night.
- 36:35So my brother and I were supposed to be there and it was
- 36:38supposed to be like from I think it's like 9:00 to 10:30 or
- 36:41something like that at night. And we went with a mechanic and
- 36:49I don't know somebody else. We were hanging out with friends
- 36:52and got there and then we were like, and they were still doing
- 36:55the drone show and we're like, you know, we're going to skip
- 36:57this. We're just going to do the drone
- 36:58show and then call it for the night.
- 37:00I'm a dad, I'm lazy. I just I just want to kick it
- 37:04easy and like go back and like watch some bullshit for a little
- 37:07while and go to sleep right and especially I was MC ING the next
- 37:12day. So I was going to be on my feet
- 37:13all day and go over watch the drone shows.
- 37:17Great. We come back and as we come up,
- 37:22it takes about two minutes to get from the front door up to
- 37:27our room. We're at the very, very end of
- 37:29the hall on the second floor, and as we come up, we're just
- 37:34walking, solving all the world's problems as we're strolling down
- 37:37the hall and we get about maybe 1015 feet away from the door,
- 37:45and at the end of the hall, there's like 3 doors right
- 37:47close. There's door right in front of
- 37:49you, door just to the right, and then a door right beside that.
- 37:53And so there was reasonable, reasonable excuse to say that
- 37:59maybe I misremembered, maybe I wasn't sure which door he came
- 38:03out of, but I've gone over in my head, there's no way it he came
- 38:07out of our door. And so we're like 10 to 15 feet
- 38:11away and he just comes barreling out.
- 38:14And the, the thing that stood out in my mind that like when
- 38:18the the manager was like, Are you sure?
- 38:20Like we don't have any record of this like somebody you know when
- 38:24in this door because there's no log.
- 38:25The there's a log on the door like when you scan a card and it
- 38:29stays on the door like it's stored inside the little
- 38:32mechanism. There's no log at all to anybody
- 38:34in the room between the last time that we did at 7:00 when we
- 38:37left and at nine O 7 when we got back.
- 38:41So whatever he did, it should just be a completely mechanical
- 38:45way of opening the door. But I've specifically remembered
- 38:49the way the door closed, like the fact that it closed behind.
- 38:53I mean, I, I remember seeing him walking out of the door, but
- 38:56regardless, I knew because I was looking through at the wall in
- 39:00the room and the door closed this direction and every other
- 39:04door was the opposite, like in in the in the area.
- 39:09And but it was totally took me off guard because like it took
- 39:12me like half a second to be like, wait a second, what the
- 39:15fuck? What is he doing in our room?
- 39:16And then he basically just comes barreling like like power
- 39:19walking past me and I kind of like half stop him.
- 39:23I was like, dude, what are you doing?
- 39:24And he's in plain clothes. He's in all black at a with a
- 39:29jacket. I didn't remember this, but when
- 39:32we saw it on the footage, both when he was coming in and going
- 39:34out, he had a small shoulder bag and so he had that with him.
- 39:40I don't know what I assume maybe it's the device to get into the
- 39:43door. I'm not 100% sure.
- 39:47I still could not find anything that was missing.
- 39:50But he came up and said, what are you doing?
- 39:53He's just, he's good. He's good.
- 39:56And I was like, what the what are you doing in my room that
- 40:00doesn't what are you talking about this?
- 40:01Like you got to speak some English here, right?
- 40:04Like what are you doing in my room?
- 40:06And he's like water, water. It's fine, It's fine, It's fine.
- 40:08He's like just pushing past me and we turn around and start
- 40:11walking. My brother didn't see him.
- 40:14Exit the room, but he's like, why is this guy so weird?
- 40:17Like, and I'm saying, you know, why did you enter our room?
- 40:22And so we walk him behind him down the hall about halfway and
- 40:25he turns around. He's just like dismissive,
- 40:28trying to pretend he doesn't speak English or maybe he didn't
- 40:30speak English, I don't know, but I assume it's just a defensive
- 40:33mechanism and he's sweating bullets.
- 40:35He's so awkward, he's weird. He's a little bit shorter than
- 40:39me and he's just just trying so hard to get out of there.
- 40:43And everything about it was so weird and uncomfortable.
- 40:45Like it was so clear that he was not supposed to be there or that
- 40:50he was scared to death that he was there for some reason.
- 40:55And he just kept saying the water, the water, the water, and
- 40:59then our immediate so stupid. I just, I still just can't
- 41:04believe that I didn't just follow him down, but it was
- 41:07still registering that someone had broke into our room, you
- 41:10know, and like when you're, I really wish I had prepared, you
- 41:17know, I there was, there was this era and I talked to Shakimo
- 41:20about this is this kind of era of Bitcoin at the very beginning
- 41:23where everybody was like crazy paranoid and everybody was going
- 41:27overboard. And then we've just kind of
- 41:28gotten complacent because like not much has happened, you know,
- 41:33during the, the years and like 2 hype cycles since the 2013, but
- 41:38like the 2013 fourteen era with conferences and stuff like
- 41:41people like everybody's like wearing masks, everybody,
- 41:45nobody's bringing, nobody's connecting to Wi-Fi.
- 41:47They're like you set up Wi-Fi, you're just trying to, you're
- 41:50just trying to get into everybody's devices.
- 41:52Like it was like everybody was crazy paranoid, like Satoshi
- 41:56level paranoid back then. And all that went away.
- 42:00Everybody just got complacent. It's just a fun nerdy thing.
- 42:03And I think it's really important to remember what level
- 42:09of attack and what level of like this is cash, man.
- 42:14Yeah, like this is literal cash. And one of the one of the things
- 42:21that's gotten me super rethinking my security and
- 42:27everything. Like I just recently got my
- 42:29concealed carry and I've been doing like a, a pistol class
- 42:33every month and stuff because I, I feel like I've really let that
- 42:39not be, not get the attention that it deserves for just like
- 42:44personal protection and stuff at home.
- 42:47And I've done like some low hanging fruit, you know,
- 42:49security system sort of stuff. We got, we got dogs, loud dogs.
- 42:52You probably already heard them and but there was a lot talks
- 42:59about this a lot and he was actually very conveniently there
- 43:02and we had a long conversation a couple times about this.
- 43:06But talks about there was a mafia literally a gang out of
- 43:13Florida that was traveling around traveling around the
- 43:15country finding people who had large amounts of just any crypto
- 43:22on then exchange. 11 old elderly couple got hit twice, twice by
- 43:30the same group. And I was regularly reading the
- 43:35reports of this and they straight up there's one of them
- 43:39kidnapping a guy and beating him and torturing him and sending
- 43:46messages to his family members to, you know, text messages and
- 43:50phone photos. Tell him to send, you know,
- 43:54Bitcoin or crypto to the address.
- 43:56There's one of the more common one because it basically time
- 44:03sensitive. You know, you don't, you don't
- 44:04want exposure and you want as few people to know about it as
- 44:08possible. But the most common is home
- 44:13invasion, beat up family members, threaten to kill kids,
- 44:18threaten to rape wives until you give us your keys.
- 44:23And that happens in the town I read the town that I live in
- 44:30twice in these articles. And I was like, now you know,
- 44:40there's, there's a lot of things that you can do to protect
- 44:42yourself. Not using KYC as a huge benefit,
- 44:46but also not having stuff sitting in balances is really
- 44:50important because when that information leaks, you know,
- 44:54it's hard for them to know like they're always going to go for
- 44:57low hanging fruit, you know, like somebody who does that as a
- 45:00coward, like like they're not, they are looking for easy money.
- 45:04That's the whole point of it. If they, if they wanted hard
- 45:07money, they just work, you know? Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 45:12keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 45:14sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 45:17Or maybe you've set up your own self custody, but don't feel
- 45:19safe with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 45:22device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with Onramp
- 45:26and our Multi Institution custody solution.
- 45:29Here's how it works. Onramp creates a dedicated multi
- 45:32sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 45:36a key, Onramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 45:40unilaterally. Instead, only you have control
- 45:44over your coins with Onramp's multi institution custody.
- 45:48You'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is stored
- 45:50with best in class security on chain with fault tolerant multi
- 45:54sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 45:56going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 46:00exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 46:04in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 46:07you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 46:10custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 46:13eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 46:17attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 46:20financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 46:23Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 46:27warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading
- 46:30and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 46:33asset. Secure it right.
- 46:35Learn more at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 46:39Going back to the situation because like this is this is
- 46:43slowly been my framing and this event was kind of like the wake
- 46:47up call. But I, I still had not gotten
- 46:51into that mentality of like thinking about my hotel room as
- 46:54a strictly adversarial scenario and that I should be basically
- 47:00on the warpath for setting up and how I like, I always have
- 47:05backups, you know, like I keep another phone just in case.
- 47:09But I had not been thinking about this like I'm kind of
- 47:12entering a I'm entering a bit of a battlefield, you know, like,
- 47:18and I need to be thinking about this as as my remote castle, so
- 47:23to speak. And so we followed him about
- 47:28halfway down the hall. And then for some reason, my
- 47:30thought was check to make sure he didn't take anything and we
- 47:35turned back around and went back to the room and we looked over
- 47:39everything. Is my laptop still there?
- 47:42Is does it look like anything has been touched?
- 47:44Is the cash still there like you, like I just, we just went
- 47:47and looked through everything and we let him leave and he left
- 47:52the building during that, you know, minute span.
- 47:54And when we when you see it on the security footage, he came in
- 47:58at 854 and he left at 9:10. So the entirety of the time that
- 48:03he was there was 16 minutes. We came in at nine O 7.
- 48:08So basically the largest span of time possible if he went beeline
- 48:15up to my room because he saw guy Swan on the list or got
- 48:19information from an employee or something like that.
- 48:22So if I was specifically targeted, which doesn't still
- 48:26doesn't make a lot of sense to me, like I have a hard time and
- 48:29I don't want to think that I'm just excusing it and being like,
- 48:32oh, he wouldn't target me. I'm safe.
- 48:35He was in my freaking room, you know, but that hotel room had a
- 48:40lot more important people than the guy who does the audio
- 48:42books, you know? And like Marty Malmy was there.
- 48:49I mean, it's like basically three of the top 7, four of the
- 48:55top seven of who might Satoshi be.
- 48:58We're in the hotel, you know, So I suspect it was just a
- 49:06opportunistic attack. Like just random.
- 49:09He he knew that like he was. Just the one.
- 49:11Bitcoiners there for the conference.
- 49:13Because this was the Bitcoiner conference, right?
- 49:15And specifically, they're all at the speaker's dinner and this is
- 49:19the hotel where they stay. So I I highly that that seems
- 49:24like the most logical explanation.
- 49:28And if I was specifically targeted, I also just don't
- 49:32know. That's a little harder to deal
- 49:37with too. Like I don't I don't know what
- 49:38that means, you know, going forward or what they think they
- 49:43have on me for how many Bitcoin guy has or whatever the I don't
- 49:48know. But anyway, so after a couple of
- 49:56minutes realizing that nothing was gone, nothing appeared moved
- 50:00like maybe he was only in the room for a couple of minutes.
- 50:03I don't know. We realized that or it just like
- 50:10kind of popped in our heads and we're like, wait a second.
- 50:12He said the water and we had actually had the the spigot on
- 50:18the bottom was super hard to cut off.
- 50:22And while it was wet, it was actually hard to get completely
- 50:24off and it would start leaking. And we know the maids had come
- 50:28in and clean the place or whatever.
- 50:30And twice we'd come back and the spigot was leaking.
- 50:36And so we're like, well, hold on a second, Maybe the maid saw
- 50:40this and this was like a maintenance guy just checking
- 50:43before he left at night or something.
- 50:46And so we kind of had this like real dumb, not very good excuse
- 50:49for it and shrugged it off for much for a lot too long.
- 50:57We shrugged it off for too long and we sat and just kind of
- 51:00pretended nothing happened and just we're going about our
- 51:04normal night. And then my brother took a
- 51:08shower and I was sitting there and apparently both of us were
- 51:11separately thinking about it being like, and that shit don't
- 51:14make sense, that none of that makes sense.
- 51:18It was 910. He is in plainclothes.
- 51:21This hotel would fire somebody for going into plainclothes in
- 51:25somebody's room. You know, like, this is a nice
- 51:29hotel. This is the nicest hotel I've
- 51:31ever been in. And then he got out and he's
- 51:34like, dude, I think we should, we should go tell somebody.
- 51:36I was like, yeah, we totally should go tell somebody.
- 51:38I don't know what the fuck we're doing.
- 51:39Like, why? Why would this took us this long
- 51:41to figure this out? And so we go downstairs, report,
- 51:46talked to the manager, and we ended up meeting them again the
- 51:48next morning. They looked at maintenance
- 51:52records, nobody was on. Everybody left at 6:00,
- 51:57definitely not a maintenance guy.
- 51:59And then that's when they checked the log for the door and
- 52:05there's no indication that anybody open the door.
- 52:08And he was like, you sure it wasn't the right, you know, the
- 52:11wrong door. You misremembered when I was
- 52:13like, no, no, that's not that. That's, that's not what it is.
- 52:17I, I get that you're confident about your doors, but that's,
- 52:21that's just not what happened. And I ended up talking to
- 52:25somebody randomly in the bathroom.
- 52:27There's two guys talking about Defcon and like all these like
- 52:31crazy security things. And I can't remember exactly
- 52:33what was said. You know, you hear somebody
- 52:35talking about something in the bathroom, you know, you don't
- 52:37know if they don't know what they're talking about.
- 52:39But I do know enough to know whether to be able to spot
- 52:44whether or not somebody else is full of crap.
- 52:46Most of the time. I've read a few things and
- 52:52something about something that one of the guys said.
- 52:56I was like, oh, OK, yeah, so he knows what he's talking about.
- 52:59And I actually stopped them coming out of the bathroom.
- 53:02And I was like, let me give you a scenario.
- 53:04And I gave him the rundown. And he was like, well, it all
- 53:08depends on your actor, like like who is who is the threat?
- 53:13Is this a state? Is this, you know, CIA?
- 53:17So it's just a opportunistic thief.
- 53:21But I would consider I would be rolling every key that I have,
- 53:26every every single one of them. I would just be assuming no
- 53:29matter what that you're screwed and you just need to change
- 53:33everything. And, and I was like, well, he
- 53:40was in a hurry and there was no indication that he touched my
- 53:44laptop. And then he was like, wait, this
- 53:45was real. He thought, he literally thought
- 53:48I was just coming up with a scenario.
- 53:50And so the conversation got more interesting after, right.
- 53:53And, and you know, that's, that's what I've been doing.
- 53:57But Oh my God, that's a job. And I had to do this recently
- 54:01with the LastPass hack, which I know like a really secure
- 54:05password, but if that's out there, I have to assume it's
- 54:08somebody at some point somebody's going to break it.
- 54:10That's, yeah, two months to swap out all this stupid crap.
- 54:16Yeah. You know, I guess there's like
- 54:1750 that are important, like that are really critical.
- 54:20But I don't, I don't like it leaving anything exposed because
- 54:25there's a lot of roundabout ways that somebody can get back to
- 54:28something. But yeah, so we got him on video
- 54:34coming up at 854, got him on video leaving.
- 54:38I could not, I'm really the only thing, you know, I was talking
- 54:44to a couple people and they were like, well, I'm not, that's
- 54:46unacceptable. I'm not going to stay at that
- 54:47hotel again. And I'm like, you know, there's
- 54:52it's a hotel, it's a hotel. Like it was really nice.
- 54:57And as far as like basic security goes, there's not a lot
- 55:02you can do. Hotel room doors are just not
- 55:06cryptographic lock boxes. You know, like the guy I was,
- 55:10the guy from DEFCON was like, man, I actually like hotel room
- 55:13doors are just crap and doesn't matter what what they have.
- 55:16Like you can just get into him like you just can't if you know
- 55:20what you're doing. He even said that he usually
- 55:23takes a device to Defcon or whatever just to show it off
- 55:27that can just get into doors. And then we also looked and we
- 55:31tested a bunch of things. One of the things that we did
- 55:33and which I will do because somebody actually had an
- 55:36interesting point, is maybe he was picking something up.
- 55:39Maybe he had a Wi-Fi device in there and he was getting it
- 55:45because that was his opportunity to see, you know, who connected
- 55:48to it because, you know, he had a small bag.
- 55:51But we looked for something that was planted and we looked like,
- 55:54OK, like, and we tore that whole place apart, looked under
- 55:58mattresses, looked in the weird little cubbies behind drawers
- 56:02and the little desk thing. Look behind the the wall piece
- 56:06that the TV was hanging on. Because my thinking is, you
- 56:11know, low hanging fruit, easy to like, very easy to implement
- 56:16because like I know how to do it and high likelihood of just a
- 56:24lot of optionality is drop a man in the middle Wi-Fi, like get a
- 56:29signal there and see if you can get anybody's info and hope
- 56:32they're not on a VPN because that'll foil most of those
- 56:37plans. Like like a VPN is basically a
- 56:40set protection or a default protection against the majority
- 56:44of man in the middle attacks. If you trust your VPN but could
- 56:52not find anything, again, could not.
- 56:56There was no visual indication that he had touched my laptop
- 57:00and it was over in the corner on the floor next to the bed.
- 57:03So it makes more sense that he was probably going through all
- 57:06of my brother's stuff first if he was making his way around the
- 57:09room. And in the context of how long
- 57:12he had been in the room, maybe he was just on the 2nd floor and
- 57:14he went to the end of the hall because that was the one that
- 57:16nobody was going to have traffic.
- 57:18You know, like literally just go to the end of the hall and
- 57:20start, you know, maybe we were the second door because we're
- 57:23the Second World on the hall. Maybe he had just gotten into
- 57:26our room, clearly caught him in the middle.
- 57:29You know, the other thing that stood out to me is that he
- 57:32didn't have a lookout. He wasn't working.
- 57:35Like as far as sophistication goes, sure it could have been
- 57:40Mossad or CIA or whatever, but then they just hired a dummy on
- 57:44fiver, you know, to to break into the room.
- 57:48And they certainly weren't helping him because they would
- 57:50have known way before we would have just passed him on the
- 57:53stairs. You know, like I said, it's like
- 57:55a 2 minute trip to get up to the end of that hall.
- 57:58He left the room because he hurt us.
- 58:01Like either that or he was doing something that took two minutes
- 58:04to clean up and you know, be done with which that seems less
- 58:08likely. You wouldn't even want to get
- 58:09into something that involved. I feel like this sort of an
- 58:12attack, it just makes a lot more sense that he was just working
- 58:17alone. You know, he came up by himself
- 58:20on the security tapes. Going back to the hotel though,
- 58:24I don't I don't really fault the hotel that much.
- 58:28The one thing that I really wish they had done is think about
- 58:32their security camera positioning.
- 58:35Everything was super far away and they did not have a single
- 58:39like on the door, just .1 at the door, just .1 right at the door.
- 58:43So you could see the hall. So we can see a door.
- 58:44Specifically. There was nothing inside, like
- 58:49for the sake of privacy, they don't have anything on the
- 58:51hallways, but they have the entries and exits and lobby and
- 58:54reception and that sort of thing.
- 58:56And so, and they were pointing at both the, the sidewalks and
- 59:03stuff outside, really big high cameras pointing down so you can
- 59:08see him. And I recognized him because
- 59:11the, the manager was like, we didn't see anybody who fit the
- 59:13description or whatever. I was like, can I look at it
- 59:15please? Can I look at it?
- 59:17And, and he was like, he fought with me a little bit, but he was
- 59:21like, yeah, you can see it. And we found him really quickly.
- 59:25Like I was immediately like, that is the guy.
- 59:27And he specifically was running away when he left.
- 59:31Like he was like, he was like, like he's doing this like little
- 59:35hop thing. So he was not, he was running
- 59:39away. He got caught, you know, and but
- 59:44we looked through everything and then I started doing tests on my
- 59:48computer, like looking up kernel logs, like just like system
- 59:52logs. And so my computer was not off,
- 59:57it was not powered off, but it was closed and asleep.
- 1:00:03So it was like the basic lock, like you had to have a password
- 1:00:07to get back into it. But my question is, you know, do
- 1:00:12logs, do logs take one, it's asleep.
- 1:00:18How does that work? I honestly didn't know.
- 1:00:22So I started doing tests like can I plug something into this
- 1:00:25computer without triggering system logs and while it was
- 1:00:32asleep? While it's asleep enclosed it
- 1:00:34produces nothing, like no logs whatsoever.
- 1:00:38I did it for like 10 minutes on the train and for the entire 10
- 1:00:43minute span there's 00 entries. I plugged in a did it again, put
- 1:00:50it to sleep, plugged in a USB extension like adapter thing
- 1:00:59with a bunch of ports on it hub and like 18,000 system logs,
- 1:01:06like just a crap ton of system logs while it was asleep.
- 1:01:11And then I was like, OK, what's the dumbest thing I have?
- 1:01:13And I have a very, very crappy USB cable.
- 1:01:20I'm like so one that doesn't have like a full computer and
- 1:01:23I'm sure it's got like a little chips and stuff in the head or
- 1:01:24whatever, but it's a very, very basic charge cable.
- 1:01:28Plug that in like like that. There's like 1000 logs like port
- 1:01:32IO boot logs, kernel logs, like you name it, even like a
- 1:01:37notifications log like you plug anything even slightly into this
- 1:01:43computer while it's asleep and it is doing a million things.
- 1:01:47So checked the log for the 16 minutes between him on the
- 1:01:51camera entering and leaving, nothing, nothing at all.
- 1:01:57And I also specifically went around like spent a long time
- 1:02:00trying to figure out how to delete logs.
- 1:02:03And you cannot do it without a root password, at least in a
- 1:02:06very naive sense on the computer.
- 1:02:08So it seems unlikely unless I got Pegasus and, you know, like
- 1:02:15the freaking CIA is after my Bitcoin or my computer or
- 1:02:19everybody, you're probably all infected.
- 1:02:21You're all screwed now. But unless I got hit with that,
- 1:02:27there is just no indication that he got to my computer.
- 1:02:30I am still treating it as if he did, because I don't know deeply
- 1:02:37enough about the topic to really say confidently, but there's at
- 1:02:46least no evidence that I can find in the basic knowledge that
- 1:02:54I have of that level of communication.
- 1:02:58But then I think, you know, if it was Pegasus or something, why
- 1:03:02do you have to send a guy to my room?
- 1:03:05You know, all you need is my phone number and my Apple ID,
- 1:03:09you know, like like if you've got a back door to the Apple
- 1:03:11servers, you got all my crap, you know, you don't need my
- 1:03:14hotel room. Why do you need to go to
- 1:03:15Switzerland or pay somebody to do it?
- 1:03:17You know, so but yeah, it was basically 2 days of just trying
- 1:03:24to like explain the situation. I wish so bad and I will never,
- 1:03:30I will have this forever every time I am in a hotel room,
- 1:03:35especially at a Bitcoin conference.
- 1:03:37I may very well have a travel computer now with me.
- 1:03:41I'm probably won't bring this thing and I'm still even
- 1:03:44considering just buying a new one and trading this in and just
- 1:03:48wiping it just for the hell of it.
- 1:03:51I literally took I bought up a kit kit and the first thing I
- 1:03:54did when I got home was I took it apart, open it up, make sure
- 1:03:57there wasn't anything planted in like he's in a simple little
- 1:04:00microphone could do a key logger, just listen to the keys.
- 1:04:05Nothing, no indication there either.
- 1:04:08And he could have opened it and only actually took me about like
- 1:04:11a minute and 1/2 after I knew exactly what I was doing because
- 1:04:14you have to like do like a funny thing to get the the bass off.
- 1:04:18But if you had practiced, if I had practiced it, I easily could
- 1:04:21have gotten in in like a minute, minute and a half tops.
- 1:04:26But I'm going to have a camera in my hotel room, one that is
- 1:04:32inconspicuous and remotely accessible, saving information
- 1:04:38somewhere. In fact, I may, I may develop my
- 1:04:44own app that runs on pair, the pair stack or whatever.
- 1:04:47So it will just record back home or something by default and just
- 1:04:51like cycle it over for like the last five minutes worth of
- 1:04:55footage until there's motion or something.
- 1:04:57And there's a couple of simple little open source things for
- 1:04:59motion detection on a camera that you can do with a
- 1:05:01smartphone these days. I think even Edward Snowden,
- 1:05:05they built a app called like or Los maybe, I don't know, I think
- 1:05:11maybe it's an app, but it's like called like Haven or something.
- 1:05:14I could be wrong in that it's been a long time since I'd
- 1:05:16thought about it until very recently.
- 1:05:19But it's basically Snowden talked about, you know, this
- 1:05:23device is a crazy spying device. They use it to, they can record
- 1:05:27you. They can turn on the camera.
- 1:05:30They have this has a proximity sensor.
- 1:05:33I mean, this thing's got like 20 sensors on it.
- 1:05:36It's battery powered. You can turn it off and it's
- 1:05:39still technically not off. It's still doing stuff.
- 1:05:42And he's like, you know, this is a powerful weapon that the
- 1:05:46government has and the the intelligence agencies has
- 1:05:49against us. We can use it too.
- 1:05:52Why wouldn't we use it? You know, like we can use this
- 1:05:56as a security device. We can use this as a watch your
- 1:05:59room and is the best security camera you're ever going to be
- 1:06:03able to ever going to be able to buy, You know so that's kind of
- 1:06:07the the idea of that app, but I'll probably use something like
- 1:06:12that. But for the next time I travel,
- 1:06:14I'm going to have something I'm going to be absolutely thinking
- 1:06:19about a lot more seriously about my devices and keys.
- 1:06:24And then there's every day that I felt like better having
- 1:06:29everything set up on multi sig right, because I got at least
- 1:06:34knew that even with total access to my computer, they'd have to
- 1:06:39be playing the long game. Nothing is immediately
- 1:06:42vulnerable, you know, But I just wish I, I just wish I could know
- 1:06:50what the hell he did in my room. Yeah, that's a tough, that's
- 1:06:54tough to tough to stomach that you don't have like full closure
- 1:06:58on it in in some sense. Yeah, I was.
- 1:07:01I was. I was legit sick on my stomach
- 1:07:03for a little while. I'm sure, but I appreciate you
- 1:07:06walking through all of that because I think it's, it's very
- 1:07:09helpful context for folks who, you know, you mentioned, you
- 1:07:14think there's an element of complacency that's sort of has
- 1:07:17occurred over the past few years.
- 1:07:19I would argue like the, you know, the scarier or more
- 1:07:24concerning aspect to me is less the complacency, it's more the
- 1:07:31the attackers are only going to become more sophisticated and
- 1:07:33advanced over time because 5-10 years ago Bitcoin was this
- 1:07:38plaything. Well, now it's now it's more
- 1:07:41broadly recognized as an asset where people store material
- 1:07:44wealth. And we think, you know,
- 1:07:47knowledge about Bitcoin is not widely dispersed, right?
- 1:07:51Like, so if that is to be true, most people don't understand
- 1:07:54Bitcoin as an investment asset. You know, the same number, if
- 1:07:58not less understand that people store material wealth in this
- 1:08:01thing. And Oh yeah, it's a bear
- 1:08:03instrument that they might have on their person.
- 1:08:07So I think we're, you know, I think it would be, we would be
- 1:08:09remiss not to assume that these attacks are only going to become
- 1:08:13more sophisticated and more prevalent as people more deeply
- 1:08:18understand what Bitcoin is and how it's stored.
- 1:08:22And so I think it's just important to highlight stories
- 1:08:25like this because, you know, it's not to be clear, it's, you
- 1:08:29know, it's, it's certainly not to fear monger in any sense.
- 1:08:32It's to give people context and you'll have them thinking
- 1:08:37critically about how they store their Bitcoin, you know,
- 1:08:42particularly when they're traveling or, or on the road,
- 1:08:45particularly at Bitcoin conferences, but also just
- 1:08:48recognizing that there's, there's different models and
- 1:08:51there's different use cases and, and threat vectors to consider.
- 1:08:55And so, yeah, we just just really appreciate you walking
- 1:08:58through all of that because I think it's something that people
- 1:09:01do need to to think more critically about.
- 1:09:03And I feel like it doesn't do any good.
- 1:09:08Yeah, I guess I'm, I'm an extrovert too, so I'm more
- 1:09:12likely to just blab about it anyway.
- 1:09:14But it also seems like it's of no value for that to happen and
- 1:09:19then not tell people about it because like, what do you, what
- 1:09:24do you learn from it? Like, and in, in the context of,
- 1:09:27you know, oh, is he fear mongering?
- 1:09:30It's like, no, just like that should have 100% happened.
- 1:09:35You know, like it's not a fear monger.
- 1:09:36I'm just telling you what happened.
- 1:09:38Like you can be afraid or not based on how likely you feel
- 1:09:44like you're going to be attacked.
- 1:09:46I'm, I'm a very prominent person in this space or like outward
- 1:09:51person in the space. Like, you know, people could
- 1:09:53listen to my show and probably be like, all right, well, his
- 1:09:55house has a, doesn't have a garage and it's got this and
- 1:09:59this and this is how many hardware wallets he has.
- 1:10:01That's actually somebody, somebody was posting that on a
- 1:10:04oh, is UTXOUTXO posted on Noster.
- 1:10:07They said the the burglar listening, listening to Kai
- 1:10:11son's episode as he lists all of his hardware wallets and it's
- 1:10:15the picture of Mark Cuban, like, oh, OK, let me write that down
- 1:10:18here. But I was like, ah, yeah, yeah,
- 1:10:22good luck. If he wants to wants to break in
- 1:10:24and find all my hardware wallets I have there's there's a
- 1:10:27security through obscurity, but then there's also security
- 1:10:33through sheer number. You know, like that's less the
- 1:10:35cryptography trick, right? Is that if your number is too
- 1:10:37big to guess, well, if they come in and get all of my hardware
- 1:10:41wallets, it will take them six months to figure out what
- 1:10:44combination of what hardware wallets actually make something
- 1:10:49that might have some Bitcoin on it.
- 1:10:52Because I have way too many hardware wallets.
- 1:10:55Like I have a lot of hardware wallets.
- 1:10:57I have drawers with hardware wallets and people have sent me
- 1:11:01hardware wallets that I've used just to test and play around
- 1:11:05with and stuff. I do not envy the person who has
- 1:11:08to just look and I do not envy myself having to go back through
- 1:11:13and clear things out and just make sure that I can take note
- 1:11:17of the setups that I have. But Jesus Christ, somebody just
- 1:11:20like getting all of my hardware wallets and then being like, all
- 1:11:23right, let's get into all these things and get some Bitcoin off
- 1:11:25of this. Like that guy's got a fucking
- 1:11:27job. Yeah, that would be an
- 1:11:32unenviable task. Well, we're, we're a little over
- 1:11:36an hour here. I want to be respectful of your
- 1:11:38time, Guy. This was super helpful.
- 1:11:41Cam, did you have any other thoughts you wanted to get out
- 1:11:44or any other questions for guy before we wrap?
- 1:11:47No, just a general thanks guy. I appreciate you sharing that
- 1:11:49story, as uncomfortable as that is, because it is a good call to
- 1:11:54us all to re evaluate how we're securing our own Bitcoin.
- 1:11:58And I agree that multi sig should be the premise that
- 1:12:00there's multiple different forms that can take.
- 1:12:03But when you think about defending your own Bitcoin, your
- 1:12:06own castle, so to speak, in the place you are most of the time,
- 1:12:10whether it's at home or traveling, think about how you
- 1:12:13can use multi sig to keep yourself and your family and
- 1:12:16you're well safe in those scenarios.
- 1:12:18So I appreciate you highlighting that.
- 1:12:20Yeah, 100%. Especially when you're
- 1:12:22traveling. It's too easy to set it up these
- 1:12:25days so there's services that make it easy on ramp, you know
- 1:12:28obviously, but like nunchuck is super easy too if you just want
- 1:12:33to do it yourself, you know like you have so many options now and
- 1:12:36two years ago that was not the case.
- 1:12:38Yeah You know none of the great .2 years ago.
- 1:12:40It was awful, confusing, risky. Two years ago yeah today, not at
- 1:12:45all, not at all. Have multi sig set up just in
- 1:12:49case your bag gets stolen at the airport, like have a multi sig
- 1:12:54so that you can go home, break out your hardware wallet or you
- 1:12:58know, whatever it is that you're using and recover your funds.
- 1:13:02That is that is the easiest as as I specifically said a little
- 1:13:08bit ago is the most comforting thing through this entire
- 1:13:11process was just knowing that my Bitcoin was not behind a single
- 1:13:14key that was potentially at risk because of my computer.
- 1:13:20That was the only thing I was never really concerned about.
- 1:13:22Like it even took me a day or two to open up my multi sig
- 1:13:25wallet just to look, you know, because I just wasn't concerned.
- 1:13:29I just knew that there was no feasible way that that was being
- 1:13:33that was at risk because of my setup.
- 1:13:37You know, and the only tap signer that was even involved
- 1:13:40with it was on my person the whole time it came with me did
- 1:13:43not stay in the hotel. So yeah, that's, that's just
- 1:13:47something to think about. And if there is any simple
- 1:13:50mitigation, I feel like that's, that's definitely, it's one
- 1:13:57that's easy to do and it, it is a massive, massively valuable
- 1:14:01tool in my opinion. So.
- 1:14:04Absolutely. Well said.
- 1:14:05Well, thanks again, guy. This has been great and.
- 1:14:09Good to meet you, Brian. Yeah, great to meet you as well.
- 1:14:12Been a fan for a long time and and you you provide an immense
- 1:14:16amount of important Bitcoin education, which is, you know
- 1:14:19something that at on ramp. We're very focused.
- 1:14:21On as well, since day one. You know you can't.
- 1:14:24You can't run a Bitcoin company without.
- 1:14:25Y'all got a really good first I was gonna say y'all got like a
- 1:14:28really good like Bitcoin intro thing that that I've been
- 1:14:31through. Don't y'all?
- 1:14:32Where is? Where is that one?
- 1:14:33Yeah, we have a fundamental series, yeah, which goes through
- 1:14:37some, you know, basic core concepts in a in a pretty
- 1:14:39concise I. Should I should link to that
- 1:14:42one? Yeah, please do and we will.
- 1:14:45We will link to all of your stuff as well in the share
- 1:14:47notes. But thanks again.
- 1:14:50And Cam, thanks for subbing in for Michael today.
- 1:14:53Much appreciated. OK.
- 1:14:54How you doing, Bob? Guy So this has been a pleasure.
- 1:14:58It's so fun. Oh man, we need to catch up.
- 1:15:01What's When's the next conference you're going to?
- 1:15:05I'm going to the one here in Dallas coming up in a couple
- 1:15:07weeks that Lee Bratcher and the Texas blockchain.
- 1:15:09Console. Yeah, no, I'm not going to that
- 1:15:11one. Blockchain Summit.
- 1:15:12Well, hit me up. We'll we'll coordinate.
- 1:15:14We need to hang out again. It's been too long.
- 1:15:17Hell yeah. All right.
- 1:15:19All right, guys. Thanks, boys.
- 1:15:19Thank you. Yeah, you guys.
- 1:15:21Appreciate it later. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:15:24week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:15:27valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:15:29rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:15:31All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:15:33notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:15:36reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:15:39entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:15:42investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:15:45your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:15:47Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:15:51one of our private Client Advisors.