Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep14: GRD014: Roth IRA vs. Roth 401k
Transcript
- 0:00Intro: Hi, I'm Ed Slott.
- 0:01And I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we are two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the savers, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic with the.
- 0:23Helping you keep more of your hard-earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip
- 0:29a coin winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want
- 0:33to argue, and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respect positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner you, a more
- 0:45informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of each side of the debate
- 0:48to your own personal situation to decide what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:02Jeffrey Levine: All right, everyone.
- 1:02Welcome back to the Great Retirement.
- 1:05I'm here with Ed Slott.
- 1:06Ed, good to be with you as always.
- 1:08Ed Slott: Great to be back with you and a, again, hitting one of my favorite
- 1:12topics, Roths, but what kind of Roth?
- 1:14Which is better?
- 1:15Some people have money.
- 1:16They say, where should I put it?
- 1:17My Roth IRA or Roth 401k.
- 1:20And sometimes you can do both, so we'll see.
- 1:23Uh, which is better.
- 1:24So we have to, uh, flip a coin to see which side of the debate.
- 1:31You will take and then I will take.
- 1:33All right.
- 1:33I have my coin here.
- 1:34Oh, somebody's gotta call it.
- 1:36We'll call whatever.
- 1:37Jeffrey Levine: All right.
- 1:37I'll take tails, Ed.
- 1:39Ed Slott: Tails, what did you call?
- 1:41Jeffrey Levine: I called tails.
- 1:43Ed Slott: All right.
- 1:43That's what it is.
- 1:44All right.
- 1:44What are you taking?
- 1:46The Roth 401k or the Roth IRA?
- 1:48Jeffrey Levine: You know, Ed, we're recording this the
- 1:50Monday after the Super Bowl.
- 1:52It's a, it's been a long, you know...
- 1:54Ed Slott: Well it was a commemorative coin!
- 1:56Jeffrey Levine: Oh, okay.
- 1:57All right.
- 1:57The commemorative coin..
- 1:58Ed Slott: One side, I'll be like, the ref, one side is the Roth 401k and the
- 2:04other side we'll call tails, the Roth IRA.
- 2:06Jeffrey Levine: Well, I am going to take, yeah, I'm gonna take the
- 2:08Roth IRA as the better vehicle here.
- 2:12Uh, I'm gonna, I'm gonna stick it to you the Monday after the Super Bowl.
- 2:15Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 2:16All right.
- 2:16I like..
- 2:17So it's a tough call because I like tax free.
- 2:20All right.
- 2:20So I'm taking the Roth 401k.
- 2:23Jeffrey Levine: Yeah, and I'm gonna take the Roth IRA and boy
- 2:26Ed, I've got a list a mile long.
- 2:28So out of, out of, out of courtesy on this one, I'll let you make the first argument.
- 2:32Ed Slott: All right, all right, the Roth 401k.
- 2:33What's better about it?
- 2:35All right, uh, I'll ask you, Jeff, how much can you put in a
- 2:39contribute to a Roth IRA in a year?
- 2:42Jeffrey Levine: Uh, let's see, $6,500 for this year.
- 2:45$7,500 if I'm 50 or over by the end of the year.
- 2:49Ed Slott: Alright, so would 30,000 be higher than that?
- 2:53Jeffrey Levine: Checks the math.
- 2:54Carry the one, uh, yes, yes, yes it would.
- 2:57Ed Slott: All right.
- 2:57For 2023, those are the limits for the Roth 401k or regular 401k limits,
- 3:0322,500 with the catch up, 7,500 more.
- 3:08It's the first time I believe it's ever hit 30,000, uh, that you can put in with
- 3:13a, Roth 401k, and remember coming up with Secure 2.0, some people might get
- 3:20extra catch ups going in there, that could really pile on in a Roth 401k.
- 3:26So there's another advantage.
- 3:27Higher annual contribution limit.
- 3:30Uh, Jeff, I'll throw you another question.
- 3:32Uh, why is it some people can't contribute to a Roth IRA?
- 3:39Jeffrey Levine: Because they're not aware of the backdoor Roth to get around
- 3:43Ed Slott: Well, that's that's gonna be where, how you answer me back.
- 3:46Jeffrey Levine: That's right.
- 3:47No, because they make too much money.
- 3:48Of course.
- 3:49Yes.
- 3:49Ed Slott: Right.
- 3:49Yes.
- 3:49Uh, and there are no limits, income limits on who can contribute to a Roth 401k.
- 3:57What if you get in trouble?
- 3:58Uh, Roth 401ks, you know, part of a regular 401k.
- 4:02Generally, generally an ERISA plan, which means it's got
- 4:06rock solid creditor protection.
- 4:09Uh, I don't think so.
- 4:10You know, that goes by state law when you have IRAs and Roth IRAs
- 4:14and they may not be as good.
- 4:16Uh, when I'm talking about creditor protection, it's the gold
- 4:19standard in an ERISA plan, employee Retirement Income Security Act, uh,
- 4:25that's the gold standard, both for bankruptcy and other judgements.
- 4:30You get that in a much stronger creditor protection in a Roth 401k.
- 4:36Jeffrey Levine: You know, I, I'll, I'll, I'll pick and knit with you there.
- 4:39Uh, some places you get much stronger creditor protection, but in, in the, as
- 4:43you said, it's a state by state issue.
- 4:45In the overwhelming majority of states, your IRA or your Roth IRA
- 4:49will have roughly an equivalent protection under state law.
- 4:53That the, uh, now in, in, in fairness in some places, including perhaps our most
- 4:58populous state, uh, the, the rules are not nearly as favorable at the IRA level,
- 5:03but in, in most places, most people have about the same protection for their Roth.
- 5:09Of course, if creditor protection is an issue for you, you
- 5:11don't want most, you want all.
- 5:13So I, I will, I will somewhat seed to you there, but I gotta stop you, Ed.
- 5:18You know, one of the big things, one of the big benefits about, uh, a, a Roth
- 5:23IRA is it's tax-free nature, right?
- 5:26And, and, and the ability to invest tax-free for the long run.
- 5:29Would you agree?
- 5:30Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 5:31Jeffrey Levine: Okay.
- 5:31And so that means that you probably wanna put your best or highest
- 5:38appreciating, let's call that your, and I don't wanna say your best,
- 5:40but your, your highest appreciating investments or the things that you
- 5:43believe over time will go up the most.
- 5:46Right.
- 5:47Would you agree with that?
- 5:48Ed Slott: Yep.
- 5:48I'm waiting for the setup.
- 5:49I, I can feel myself getting set up here.
- 5:52Jeffrey Levine: That's it.
- 5:52There's a, there's a aha here coming and the aha is, you know, with the plan.
- 5:57You are stuck in almost all situations.
- 5:59Very, very, very rarely does the plan give you more flexibility,
- 6:04be besides, let's say a, a limited lineup of choices that the plan has
- 6:09chosen for you and with a Roth ira.
- 6:13Really the, the world is your oyster other than perhaps, uh, you
- 6:18know, collectibles, life insurance and s corporation securities.
- 6:24You can own just about anything inside your Roth IRA that you want, which means
- 6:29you can pick the investments that you believe will go up the most from a much
- 6:33wider assortment of, of, of choices.
- 6:36And that's a big deal.
- 6:38That that's a big deal and that's perhaps the biggest benefit of
- 6:41the Roth IRA for for most retirees relative to the Roth 401k.
- 6:46Ed Slott: It's one benefit.
- 6:48Here's another benefit I talked about, uh, higher contributions.
- 6:52Uh, when you have your own Roth IRA, are there other people around
- 6:57that can match your contributions?
- 6:59Like friends?
- 7:01Jeffrey Levine: I mean, I guess it depends how nice your friends are, but, uh, no.
- 7:04In general, you, you, you, you probably would not have matching
- 7:07contributions for your Roth.
- 7:08No.
- 7:08Ed Slott: Which you could have in your Roth 401k and under secure 2.0.
- 7:13Uh, soon those matching contributions can go to the Roth 401k side, beefing up your
- 7:19. Roth 401k contributions, uh, that way.
- 7:22So that's another benefit.
- 7:25For the Roth 401k.
- 7:26Jeffrey Levine: Even so far we've focused on the, the big benefit long term of,
- 7:30of people who are, are using these accounts for, for their intended purpose.
- 7:33But you know, Ed, as we know, life gets in the way and not everyone who puts
- 7:39money into a retirement account is lucky enough to be able to wait until retirement
- 7:42account, a retirement to use it.
- 7:44And while we're certainly not encouraging folks to raid their retirement accounts,
- 7:48we do know that for various reasons people need to access money sooner.
- 7:54If you have a Roth IRA, one of the best things about it for, for young people
- 7:59in particular who are worried about what if I need the money for whatever, right?
- 8:03Uh, for, for anything else with Roth IRAs, whatever I put in, in the
- 8:08form of contributions I can take out immediately without a tax, without
- 8:14a penalty, and without a reason and without age justification for
- 8:18any reason, for any purpose, at any time, I can take what I put in, out.
- 8:24Now if you have a Roth 401K and you've put in money over the years, and
- 8:29you've been fortunate enough to have some earnings in there, so you've got
- 8:32kind of a mix now of the money you've put in plus the earnings, et cetera,
- 8:36are you able to do the same thing?
- 8:38Ed Slott: No, no, you got me on that.
- 8:40There're a different, uh, first of all, ordering rules in a Roth 401k,
- 8:45without getting too technical, it's exactly as you said with a Roth IRA,
- 8:49your original contributions should be withdrawn anytime any reason.
- 8:52Tax and penalty free, cause that's the order they come out.
- 8:55First those, uh, contributions come out, then conversions and you don't
- 8:59hit the earnings till the last layer as opposed to most distributions.
- 9:04There are some exceptions from, uh, Roth 401ks and 401ks in general.
- 9:08You follow what's called a pro rata rule, where each distribution has a
- 9:13piece of the earnings, so it's not as advantageous if you have to, if
- 9:18you, you want to get that money out.
- 9:19Jeffrey Levine: Right.
- 9:20Cause those earnings are what would be subject to tax and a penalty.
- 9:23Ed Slott: That's correct.
- 9:24But another benefit of, uh, Roth 401ks, and by the way, as I said,
- 9:28I'm a big Roth fan either way, and we're gonna get to that in a minute.
- 9:32Uh, one of the things you talked about needing the money, uh, with
- 9:36a Roth 401k, if it's a part of a plan that offers loans, that may
- 9:40be an option you absolutely don't have with IRAs and Roth IRAs.
- 9:45Jeffrey Levine: Well, that, that's true, but if I could take my own
- 9:47money back, I may not need a loan.
- 9:48So I'll, I will argue on that one.
- 9:50And you know what, Ed, I, I think one other thing that's really interesting to
- 9:53note here, i, i, is that the Roth IRA is something that allows you to, uh, to, to
- 10:00be flexible, to choose where you want to hold it, not only for investment purposes,
- 10:05but also for estate tax planning.
- 10:07Ed Slott: That's true.
- 10:08Jeffrey Levine: For if, if you wanna have multiple accounts, you can set that up.
- 10:11If you have, uh, certain beneficiaries that you want to keep separate, you can.
- 10:15So there's a lot more flexibility with the Roth IRA than there is the plan.
- 10:20At the end of the day, the Plan Roth is still a plan account.
- 10:24Ed Slott: All right.
- 10:24Trick question now.
- 10:25Uh, let's talk about RMDs.
- 10:28Roth IRAs have no lifetime RMDs.
- 10:31Jeffrey Levine: Ah, see that's a win for me.
- 10:33Oh, oh, wait.
- 10:34Or, or, or is it.
- 10:36It used to be a win.
- 10:37In fact, if we had recorded this ad just a few months ago,
- 10:40that would've been a big pro.
- 10:42I would've been my, that would've been my, you know, my, my number one argument
- 10:47for you is that Roth IRAs have no RMDs, but as we know, That is now equal under
- 10:53the, at least beginning in 2024, Ed, for..
- 10:56Ed Slott: That would've been your drop the mic.
- 10:58Jeffrey Levine: That's, that's it.
- 11:00I, I got one more year where the Roth IRA remains advantageous and that's in 2023.
- 11:06Roth IRA still have no required minimum distributions, but Plan Roths do.
- 11:10Imagine being 75, 76 years old this year and having to take money
- 11:16out of a Roth 401k account, that's growing tax and penalty free before
- 11:22you actually needed the money.
- 11:24It would be criminal almost to do that.
- 11:26Ed Slott: Right.
- 11:27So that goes away.
- 11:28That's a good change In secure 2.0, no lifetime.
- 11:31I, uh, same thing with the Roth.
- 11:33We're only talking about no lifetime RMDs, the beneficiary issue.
- 11:37That's another issue.
- 11:38They still follows the other, the other general rules for beneficiaries.
- 11:42But here's an interesting thing you know, maybe you can do
- 11:46both, cause we have this debate.
- 11:48We like the Roth.
- 11:49We like the Roth 401k.
- 11:50Jeffrey Levine: That is, that is the show, Ed.
- 11:52That's the whole premise of the show.
- 11:53Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 11:53Yeah.
- 11:54All right.
- 11:54But, uh, can't you do both?
- 11:57You know, a lot of people don't know this.
- 11:59If you have the disposable income and you qualify for a Roth IRA contribution
- 12:05or a backdoor Roth, how you can get money in and you have the money
- 12:09to load up on a Roth 401k at work.
- 12:12You can actually do both.
- 12:13I know some people think you can't, cause it almost sounds too good to be true.
- 12:18Jeffrey Levine: It is.
- 12:18It's a great, uh, it's, it's great when you can do it.
- 12:20Now, it is a little bit limited in the sense that if you have that much
- 12:24disposable income, your income is probably high enough that you don't qualify to
- 12:28go directly into the Roth IRA, but for those where it, it, it, it, you know where
- 12:33you have it, maybe have other savings that you can live off of, you know,
- 12:36someone who's, uh, who's able to do that.
- 12:38That it, it is a home run and Ed, you know, more, this is a
- 12:42case where more is better, right?
- 12:44Like this, this some is getting more is better.
- 12:47Ed Slott: The only reason I bring it up, because we're debating, we almost
- 12:50sounding like, well, do you have to choose between a Roth IRA and a Roth 401k?
- 12:55You can have both.
- 12:56If you have the income.
- 12:57So that's the story.
- 12:59Uh, we both like Roths, however you can get them in there.
- 13:02Roth IRA, or Roth 401k, they both grow tax free for the rest of your
- 13:07life and even beyond, even under the limitations of the Secure Act for
- 13:11another 10 years for most people.
- 13:13Jeffrey Levine: On that, Ed, we agree.
- 13:14And another thing we agree on is that while there are two sides
- 13:17to every coin, your life and your retirement decisions are too
- 13:21important to leave up to a coin flip.
- 13:23And that's why one thing that we continue to agree on, Ed is that if
- 13:27there is a big decision in your life, You wanna make sure you're talking
- 13:31that through with a knowledgeable financial advisor or tax professional
- 13:35so that you can weigh the pros and the cons of different options against your
- 13:39specific set of goals and circumstances.
- 13:41Trying to figure out whether a Roth IRA or Roth 401k is right for you.
- 13:46It's great to have the knowledge that you can get from this podcast, but
- 13:49you need to talk through big decisions like with a knowledgeable professional.
- 13:53Ed, there are lots of benefits to both Roth IRAs and Roth 401ks and you
- 13:59know, maybe we missed something or maybe we've persuaded some listeners.
- 14:03So we'd love to hear from you if, uh, if you'd like to give Ed and I a
- 14:07shout and let us know what we missed or what you thought and whether you
- 14:11think the Roth 401k or the Roth IRA is the better vehicle for you and why?
- 14:15Reach out to us.
- 14:16Let us know.
- 14:16You can hit up Ed on Twitter @TheSlottReport that's
- 14:20@TheSlottReport or myself @CPAPlanner.
- 14:25Again, that's @CPAPlanner.
- 14:27We look forward to hearing from your comments and would love to know what we
- 14:30should debate in an upcoming episode, Ed?
- 14:33Ed Slott: Yep.
- 14:33Plenty more to come on the great retirement debate.
- 14:36See you next time!
- 14:37Outro: Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 14:41This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 14:44not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 14:47Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 14:50which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 14:53Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 14:56completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 14:58The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 15:01and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth partners.