Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E016: The Steady March Towards Institutional Adoption with Loren Asmus
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of doubtless 1974?
- 0:15198792972000 whatever we want to call this, it's all just the
- 0:19same. Thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves, I say when we sell.
- 0:26Hey, I say when we sell. And we're live, gentlemen, big
- 0:34week in Bitcoin. We got some Fazbe guidance.
- 0:37The public companies are are very happy about.
- 0:39We've got some grid instability down here in Texas and the
- 0:43Bitcoin miners are playing a big role in that narrative.
- 0:47And we're joined by Lauren Asmus from Canterbury Consulting.
- 0:51Lauren, welcome to the show. Thanks, Marty.
- 0:53Thanks for having me on. Thanks for coming on.
- 0:57I guess before we jump into. Of the topics we have allocated
- 1:00to discuss today, let me just jump into a brief introduction
- 1:06about yourself, what you're doing your VP of Investment
- 1:09Research at Canterbury, what does Canterbury do?
- 1:12What do you do within Canterbury?
- 1:14And then why are you here to talk about Bitcoin?
- 1:17Yeah, all great questions. So Canterbury, we're an
- 1:21investment advisor, effectively A consultant based on Newport
- 1:24Beach, CA. And so we advise clients which
- 1:27are small to mid size endowments and foundations as well as
- 1:30family offices and it worth individuals on their investment
- 1:33portfolio. So everything from stocks,
- 1:35bonds, alternative assets and and digital assets, Bitcoin it
- 1:41is starting to become a part of that.
- 1:44And so the the clients we work with in aggregate it's a little
- 1:48over 20 billion in assets that we advise on.
- 1:51Most of our clients are on the West Coast, but we work with
- 1:53groups all across the country. I myself am based in Nashville,
- 1:58so I work remote and got connected with with Michael and
- 2:02Jesse, you know several months back.
- 2:05And yeah, I thought it'd be great to come on the pod and
- 2:09talk a little bit about the the institutional investor
- 2:12perspective on Bitcoin and individual assets and and what
- 2:15folks are thinking about within that regard.
- 2:20Yeah, we appreciate you coming on.
- 2:23It's been great to build a relationship and I think what
- 2:26I'm personally excited is this, this world of in my mind is
- 2:31probably like the best nomenclature you can correct me.
- 2:33But like I think of in, in the intermediary between, you know,
- 2:36asset allocators and the form of pensions, endowments and then
- 2:40asset managers and really providing the guidance and
- 2:43research is such an important aspect of the market structure
- 2:47and how they're looking for guidance to navigate this ever
- 2:50changing world. And so it's something that we're
- 2:53excited to be exploring and working with on the onramp side.
- 2:56But then also I think for the market to understand a little
- 2:59bit of that world that I think is a little bit of Gray or fuzzy
- 3:02at best and maybe not even completely known to exist as
- 3:08well. Yeah.
- 3:09And when you when you bring up consulting, people think
- 3:12management consulting, right, and it's always investment
- 3:15consulting, what is advisory. And so you're right, Michael.
- 3:18You know where we sit in between the the money managers, asset
- 3:23managers that that invest specific strategies where that's
- 3:26an equity strategy or bond strategy or Bitcoin strategy and
- 3:31then the total asset allocation of the of that client's
- 3:33portfolio. And so my job, I sit on the
- 3:36research team. My job is to.
- 3:38Investigate and to really diligence all these different
- 3:42money managers and make sure that they fit the parameters
- 3:44that our clients are looking for.
- 3:46Then also putting the whole portfolio together, making sure
- 3:50that the asset allocation makes sense for a given client.
- 3:54And so yeah, it's this world where really.
- 3:58I guess you can kind of think of us as gatekeepers of a way of
- 4:01client assets, right, where money managers would like to
- 4:03partner with us and work with us and start a job to vet and make
- 4:06sure that we're working with good groups.
- 4:08Out there, Yeah. What I find exciting about this
- 4:13to have you on the show is in the Bitcoin space.
- 4:17People are constantly talking about like institutional
- 4:20investors are coming. You know, they're they're just
- 4:24around the corner. They're on their way, They're
- 4:25making, you know, they're learning about Bitcoin now.
- 4:27I talk about that sometimes and you are really living that of.
- 4:33You interface with both sides, the institutional allocators and
- 4:38and the managers with different strategies.
- 4:43And so you are kind of you have your finger on the pulse of this
- 4:47big unknown question that we always wonder about.
- 4:50And so I'm excited to get your insights about all of everything
- 4:54about you know that topic and how it's been shifting overtime.
- 4:58Yeah. And I think a good jumping off
- 5:00off point before we get into the individual mindset of these
- 5:04asset allocators is to properly define them and what they're
- 5:08looking to get out of an allocation.
- 5:10So whether it's an endowment, a foundation.
- 5:12A pension or a family office across those four archetypes,
- 5:16how are they approaching their allocation strategies?
- 5:20I imagine they each have different goals and
- 5:23perspectives. So what's going on?
- 5:24So how do you sort of get to understand those goals and then
- 5:28work with the managers on the other side to make sure that
- 5:31you're you're reaching those goals for your clients?
- 5:34Yeah. And to your point, Marty, you
- 5:36know every client whether it's an ENF or a or a family or or
- 5:40high net with individual, they all have individual goals within
- 5:43that. And cus, you know, really what
- 5:44they're trying to achieve is very different from one to the
- 5:47other. But you know, I'd say in
- 5:48general, you know starting with endowments and foundations, at
- 5:52the end of the day they're they're thinking in terms of
- 5:54perpetuity, right. You know, having a portfolio
- 5:57that's going to last multiple lifetimes in the last multiple
- 6:00generations. And so they want to make sure
- 6:03that first and foremost their portfolios are secure and their
- 6:07principal is largely secure. On top of that, they're trying
- 6:11to achieve some sort of annualized return that can meet
- 6:15their spend rate, usually that's around 5% plus CPI or plus
- 6:19inflation. So you know, 5% real returns is
- 6:23what they're trying to on average achieve on an annualized
- 6:26basis. And so historically how that's
- 6:29worked is with within the consulting space, our, our team
- 6:33is tasked with going out there making sure the clients are
- 6:36diversified across a lot of different segments, you know
- 6:38across equities, fixed income alternatives.
- 6:41But even within that if you dive into just say equities that
- 6:44could be large cap growth, large cap value, Small cap growth,
- 6:50Small Cap Value, international, Small cap international.
- 6:53So it gets a very, very. Granular even within those asset
- 6:57classes. And so really you know if you
- 7:00just take a step back and look at it at a portfolio, it's
- 7:04highly diversified not only just within you know stocks or bonds
- 7:09or or you know private capital alternatives but also within
- 7:13those individual segments. And so you know I would say if
- 7:16you look at the ENF side, they're highly diversified.
- 7:18If you go to the family side, they're also diversified.
- 7:21But you typically find more willingness and ability to take
- 7:24a little bit more risk. And I think a lot of that is, is
- 7:27down to the fact that people view and this is not always the
- 7:32case, but this is typically what we see.
- 7:34People view their own money separately or differently than
- 7:37how they may view a foundation or endowments money because when
- 7:42you're a board member or trustee, that is a very
- 7:44different role than if you're just managing your own personal
- 7:47wealth. And so we tend to see a little
- 7:50bit different. Ask allocation models between
- 7:52families and and and institutions.
- 7:57But again, it like it really depends on kind of where along
- 8:00the life cycle these different groups are in terms of how you
- 8:04you put their portfolio together or curate their portfolio.
- 8:08Yeah. And I guess with that in mind,
- 8:11obviously Jesse mentioned there's this always been this
- 8:14mean. This means been around since
- 8:162014 in the Winkle Vie. We're saying the institutions
- 8:19are coming. We applied for our ETF.
- 8:21It's gonna get approved. The institutions are gonna come
- 8:23after that. Happens.
- 8:26Hasn't happened yet, still waiting almost 10 years later.
- 8:29But what are you seeing internally at Canterbury
- 8:32interacting with your clients and how they're viewing Bitcoin?
- 8:39As a single siloed asset, how are they viewing Bitcoin versus
- 8:42crypto? And then across the different
- 8:44types of clients you have, how are they viewing the risk
- 8:47profile of Bitcoin? Yeah, no, it's interesting,
- 8:51right. You always hear that mean that
- 8:53the institutions are coming or they're here and then it's kind
- 8:56of a head fake, right? Yeah, I would say we've we in
- 9:00terms of just taking digital assets first and then we can
- 9:03kind of get down into you know how, how clients view Bitcoin.
- 9:10Really we're seeing it on the family side the the most
- 9:12interest. And I think that goes back to my
- 9:15comment on when you're a fiduciary for a larger
- 9:20institution or you're on the board, you're going to view risk
- 9:23return much differently than your own personal wealth.
- 9:25And so we actually haven't seen at least yet much of any
- 9:30interest in terms of allocating on the institutional ENF side.
- 9:35And so maybe that's partly because there's this thinking of
- 9:39it's highly risky, it's, you know, venture like risk.
- 9:48You know, I think there's a lot of reasons for that.
- 9:50I also think that it takes a lot of time to really understand one
- 9:54Bitcoin, but then two, when you're hearing about other types
- 9:57of digital assets and and you're getting mixed messages across.
- 10:02The ecosystem, it it gets really difficult to kind of hone in and
- 10:06figure out kind of what the signal is across
- 10:10cryptocurrencies. So I think for a lot of people
- 10:12they've said, hey, I'm just going to be pencils down, I'm
- 10:15going to wait and see how things shake out and then you know, if
- 10:19we're not early adopters, so be it.
- 10:22But I think the one thing that folks want to stay away from is,
- 10:25is that uncertainty. On the family side, though, you
- 10:29know that there has been interest.
- 10:32And digital assets, that's been a mix of VC type allocations as
- 10:40well as kind of diversified allocations across digital
- 10:43assets. And I think that goes back to
- 10:46the model that institutions and consultants, investment
- 10:50consultants have made is. Is you want to be diversified
- 10:55and so you take diversification to the next level.
- 10:57I want to be diversified in in crypto, right, or earn digital
- 11:00assets that means having access or having exposure to
- 11:03everything. There still is a lot of
- 11:08education to be done on just Bitcoin only and why Bitcoin is
- 11:12a signal and you know why that is the important piece of all
- 11:16this. And so that's something that
- 11:18we're kind of trying to figure out as well internally is you
- 11:21know how do you kind of get that message across and.
- 11:23And how do you think about that? So I know it was a long winded
- 11:26response, but I have to kind of dive into any one of those
- 11:29aspects. Well, a couple things.
- 11:31Or? Go ahead, go for it Michael.
- 11:34I was just going to say one of the things that came up about
- 11:37the institutions coming is I think because of the cycles
- 11:41we've heard this and that happened in 2021 were Ras and
- 11:45other institutional investors were very interested in the
- 11:48asset class. But then as the market corrected
- 11:51in the the fallout of FTX, Block 5 and the rest, it kind of
- 11:56pulled back. And so they're sitting there,
- 11:58you know, pencils down looking at the market.
- 12:00But I think this continues to happen because of the
- 12:02cyclicality that Lauren referenced that the institutions
- 12:07might be here in the sense of the personal accounts of the CIO
- 12:11or the CEO have exposure to Bitcoin.
- 12:13But to go via a board and the proper governance takes time.
- 12:17And by the time that time gets close enough, the market has
- 12:20already turned and it's like hey, do we not like what's they
- 12:22probably didn't go deep enough to really understand the
- 12:24fundamental other than maybe an allocation.
- 12:27So I think there's some some aspect there in the cyclicality
- 12:29and that we know as the price appreciates in BlackRock coming
- 12:33in is a is a big aspect of this. But then I think just one other
- 12:39like touch point is that the intermediary, it feels like such
- 12:42an important position based on what you said Lauren, in the
- 12:46sense of like well crypto diversification and what we've
- 12:50seen in the market with and I can't remember the names, but it
- 12:52feels like they just keep getting rugged in Canada with
- 12:56these. Ontario teachers pension, yeah,
- 13:02And I think they got rugged like three times.
- 12:57I think it was a couple. It's not funny, but it's like
- 13:05Celsius maybe Block 5, but that there was somebody there more
- 13:10than likely guiding them on why this was a good investment and
- 13:14this reality of like giving them the exposure to what's happening
- 13:18in the ecosystem. And obviously they're going to
- 13:20make, they're going to do their due diligence as well.
- 13:21But it it feels very important for that intermediary to really
- 13:24support in the guidance of what's the, what are the
- 13:27fundamentals happening in the digital asset space versus like
- 13:31here it's crypto and then we've seen kind of the fallout.
- 13:37Yeah, No, I would agree with that and and you know that's a
- 13:40very sophisticated investor too, right.
- 13:42They've they've done you know in in in aggregate very well over a
- 13:46long period of time investing that money in that capital.
- 13:50And so I think it's getting back to to your point Michael of you
- 13:54know having the right information and making sure
- 13:57you're doing your, your, your actual due diligence, not just
- 14:00trusting. You know, leading following the
- 14:04herd and trusting, you know, because larger V C's are doing
- 14:07this, it must be safe, right? I think people got burned by not
- 14:11doing their diligence and this this goes across other asset
- 14:13classes too. This isn't just digital assets
- 14:16or Bitcoin. It's, you know, it's part of my
- 14:17job is to make sure that I'm unbiased and not getting
- 14:20persuaded by investor relations, marketing, people pitching a
- 14:24good story or you know, colleagues and other firms
- 14:27thinking that's a good investment or good strategy.
- 14:29You know I need to be doing my own work.
- 14:32You know, it's it's the whole notion of don't trust, verify.
- 14:35It goes across the board and it's especially important in
- 14:38this space, so. It seems it's very interesting
- 14:44that there's like some structural friction or or
- 14:50barriers to for you know, institutional capital allocators
- 14:55to get on board with Bitcoin and Bitcoin only and.
- 15:00You know, I think that that beating heart mantra of if we
- 15:06miss out on being early adopters, that's okay.
- 15:09It is kind of at the core of capital preservation and and how
- 15:13these strategies play out, right of you're there to protect
- 15:17capital, you're there to not take risks, you're there to be
- 15:20diversified and have exposure to everything so that you're
- 15:24preserving capital into the future and that.
- 15:29Prevents you from prevents these types of capital allocators from
- 15:35taking that leap on Bitcoin. But then when they do, they're
- 15:41sort of caught up in in another mantra that leads them astray,
- 15:47which typically serves them well.
- 15:49Of diversification is good. If your mandate is capital
- 15:54preservation, you want diversification.
- 15:57In your across asset classes. And then when you bring that to
- 16:00crypto you you end up with some Bitcoin and a lot of junk.
- 16:06And I think it's it's such a tricky marsh to navigate, you
- 16:14know, to not to make a misstep if you're a capital allocator
- 16:18coming from the old world with a certain conservatism and style
- 16:23of thinking that has served. Capital allocators well and and
- 16:28and you know capital preservation has been the name
- 16:30of the game and that is how you stay alive and here Bitcoin kind
- 16:36of asks the these same people to slightly modify how they're
- 16:42doing things. I think it's such a such a
- 16:44difficult thing to to get over and or navigate and and I and I
- 16:50guess it comes back to like how has that been how is that tone.
- 16:55That you've noticed been shifting over time.
- 16:58You know, in 2020 we had Paul Tudor Jones come out and say,
- 17:02you know, actually I've taken a a close look at Bitcoin and I
- 17:05think it's going to be the fastest horse this decade.
- 17:08And then you know Bill Miller and Paul and Stan Druckenmiller
- 17:14getting on board. And then now, most recently,
- 17:16Larry Fink at BlackRock saying some of the same stuff that Paul
- 17:20Tudor Jones has been saying and and and Michael Saylor has been
- 17:24saying. Do you notice that?
- 17:27That is, that these data points are starting to establish a
- 17:30precedent or or turn the ship a little bit over time about
- 17:36capital allocators, openness to Bitcoin, and Bitcoin
- 17:40specifically. I think so.
- 17:43And I I think back to 2017, right during during that bull
- 17:48run, you know, me and a few other colleagues were getting,
- 17:52you know, more into Bitcoin. And you know regrettably I guess
- 17:56other other cryptocurrencies at the time and you know everyone
- 18:00has their own journey of kind of what they go through and what
- 18:02they learn for for their own personal opinion and and and
- 18:05benefit. But you know, if I, if I were to
- 18:07think at during 2017, if I were to bring up a Bitcoin allocation
- 18:12to or, ICI would have been locked out of the, out of the
- 18:16conference room. It it, it would not have been
- 18:21even entertained, went one bit. You know, Fast forward to you
- 18:26know five years later, six years later, you know can have
- 18:31constructive conversations with, you know senior leadership, you
- 18:35know at our firm about Bitcoin and the value proposition.
- 18:38And you know, a few months ago, you know I had breakfast with
- 18:43one of our senior consultants who who was who's been at the
- 18:47firm for 30 plus years and we spent 45 minutes just talking
- 18:52about Bitcoin when? Prior to that he wouldn't have
- 18:55even entertained it to have that discussion.
- 18:58So the the narrative is definitely evolving and
- 19:03changing. I think there there's it's still
- 19:04early days of understanding why Bitcoin is the signal and and
- 19:10kind of how to kind of think about the ecosystem more
- 19:14narrowly in that regard. I love hearing that that.
- 19:18So tell me a little tell us a little bit more if if you, if
- 19:22you will, about like what was what was he interested in now
- 19:26that like you know, why was that a 45 minute conversation?
- 19:30What was he trying to find out more about?
- 19:32And and you know, yeah, if you could share any color there.
- 19:37Sure. No, I mean, frankly, he was just
- 19:38trying to to understand the value proposition of Bitcoin.
- 19:45How he's trying to understand how it works.
- 19:47He's trying to understand why is it considered to store a value.
- 19:52You know, why would you choose Bitcoin over gold when gold has
- 19:57the track record in history that it has?
- 20:03It was definitely a, you know, he's, you know, I consider him
- 20:07to be part of the the boomer generation.
- 20:09I consider myself to be part of the millennial generation.
- 20:12And he was just trying to figure out, you know why would the
- 20:14younger generations want to invest in this when gold is a
- 20:17perfectly viable option. And so, you know it's talking
- 20:22about the the ability to transact at much quicker pace,
- 20:24the fact that you you are purely decentralized you you you can
- 20:29hold the asset directly without any intermediary third party and
- 20:36and this was yeah 7-8 months ago and and for him it was just, you
- 20:42know, I don't know if we kind of fully got to him being a full on
- 20:46Bitcoin or by the end of the conversation, but you know just
- 20:50the fact that we had the conversation I thought was a
- 20:52big. Function forward, Everybody
- 20:55needs their three touch points. And it sounds like he got one of
- 20:58his touch points at that lunch or whatever it was.
- 21:02And and that's just like such a perfect microcosm to me of the
- 21:07viral, the virality, the viral coefficient of Bitcoin.
- 21:11Where, you know, those of us who get into it and see the value of
- 21:16it, we tell more than one person about it, right?
- 21:18And so it's a positive viral coefficient over time.
- 21:21And yeah, I just love that little microcosm.
- 21:27Yeah. And I want to take a step back
- 21:30to just to focus on because I'm really fascinated about this
- 21:34particular subject. You brought it up earlier,
- 21:37Lauren, but like just due diligence more broadly?
- 21:40That's what you guys do at Canterbury on behalf of your
- 21:42clients. And I guess you could say that's
- 21:44your fiduciary responsibility is to make sure that you're doing
- 21:47that. And as we saw over the last
- 21:51three years particularly, I mean, yet Sequoia, their due
- 21:54diligence that they wrote publicly in the blog post was
- 21:57that SBF was playing League of Legends during their call.
- 22:01And that like said that he was a Wonderkin, Like that's the utter
- 22:04state or that was the utter state of due diligence at that
- 22:08point. In the market cycle and I think
- 22:11the zero interest rate environment that we experienced
- 22:13over the last 15 years or the 15 years proceeding last year, the
- 22:17year before 1314, whatever it is really led to this sort of
- 22:23environment of complacency when it comes to due diligence.
- 22:26So just on the topic of due diligence alone, like how do you
- 22:32at Canterbury or you individually within Canterbury
- 22:35try to sort of? Zone out all the noise that is
- 22:39out there and sort of buck the trend that existed in the zero
- 22:43interest rate environment. Yeah, I mean it's it's a good
- 22:47question because it's, you know, just even thinking about time,
- 22:52it it feels feels so long ago and in a weird way, even though
- 22:56it's just what a few years ago, how hyped up everybody was, It
- 23:01was all Web three, it was the future.
- 23:04It's about the blockchain, right?
- 23:07And it's so easy just to follow the herd in that time period and
- 23:14say okay, well, Sequoia, they're highly successful.
- 23:17They made a lot of money for clients, for their investors.
- 23:21You give them the benefit of the doubt, right?
- 23:23And I think it was a stark reminder to everybody in our
- 23:26industry that you need to do your own work and your own
- 23:29research. And you take all the factors,
- 23:32you take all, you try to take as much information out there that
- 23:34you can get. But the end of the day, it's
- 23:37asking me the questions that they're not giving you right.
- 23:41Whenever you're getting pitched on the new fund or new strategy,
- 23:45they're putting their best foot forward, right?
- 23:47They're only gonna tell you the good news.
- 23:48They're gonna tell you the good investments.
- 23:49They're gonna tell you why their experience beats everybody else.
- 23:54But you gotta actually look at the investments, look at the
- 23:57structuring, look at the portfolio as in aggregate look
- 24:02for potential weak points. But then also it's it's really
- 24:04trying to understand people at the end of the day this is a
- 24:09relationship business and the second you lose trust with
- 24:13somebody it it's over. And so I think trying to
- 24:19understand the people aspect of it is almost as important as as
- 24:22trying to understand the, the the quantitative aspect of
- 24:25looking at the various characteristics of an
- 24:27investment. And some of those things are you
- 24:30know how not how you know someone ACIO or a PM will speak
- 24:37to you on a on a call. But you know how do they
- 24:39interact with their colleagues, with their employees that are
- 24:43under them, that are reporting up to them?
- 24:45How do they treat them? You know what do they, you know,
- 24:49what do they do to kind of spur on a certain culture at the
- 24:52firm? Does that, is that culture
- 24:54additive or subtractive to the the firm as a whole.
- 24:58And so I I think, you know, really trying to understand the
- 25:02cultural aspect and the people aspect and the incentives behind
- 25:05that is almost as important. And so, yeah, I think as of the
- 25:10day, it's in a way you're kind of a psychiatrist or
- 25:14psychologist in a way, trying to figure out kind of the mental
- 25:17side of it. But it's important in this area
- 25:23to get that aspect of it. Yeah, and I think.
- 25:29This it's such an important aspect to under score.
- 25:32Maybe Lauren, you can speak to this, but it's where the focus
- 25:36from an on ramp perspective and also just in general where we
- 25:39support and various other aspects of our, you know,
- 25:41business or professional lives across the folks on this podcast
- 25:46in the Bitcoin only thesis when it comes to let's let's forget
- 25:50about, you know, crypto digital assets in the sense of should
- 25:53they exist, what's their value. But when we look at like the
- 25:57conservative nature, when an asset allocator, somebody's
- 25:59looking at the asset class, there's certain components to
- 26:02Bitcoin that are just very like clean.
- 26:04And and when you think about it, a security versus the commodity
- 26:08and where the CFCC has come down or custody and how there is a
- 26:13landscape of really battle hard and tested custody frameworks
- 26:17versus what you see with like of the long tail of crypto assets
- 26:20and how they're supported in the in the associated hacks or bugs.
- 26:25Around it or defy and thinking about the opportunity to lose
- 26:29all your funds or ventures, venture funds going heavy into
- 26:34crypto and effectively going to zero or the assets being you
- 26:37know the counterparty risks associated with leaving with
- 26:39like you know unscrupulous actors And so we've seen this So
- 26:43this has always been a it's not a it's there's not only a thesis
- 26:46around the Bitcoin only from a. Conservative nature.
- 26:50There's also the the technical debt, the human aspect and being
- 26:53able to speak, you know, very intelligently across, you know
- 26:56these different crypto assets. But then also when it comes to
- 27:01all the things that have happened in this space and we're
- 27:03seeing this in real time. We've had some really great
- 27:05conversations the past couple weeks and months where to to
- 27:09Lawrence point like some of the institutions or entities are
- 27:12looking at this and and doing diligence, but others are really
- 27:15looking in and realizing that this thing isn't going away.
- 27:18But how do we get ahead of what just happened the past two years
- 27:21and how do we sidestep all of those big traps that are just
- 27:25laid out and will continue to be laid out?
- 27:27Because the reality is that this is it's not like tack in the
- 27:32sense that you make a wrong bet and now you just maybe goes to
- 27:350, but you just have something in a venture portfolio that
- 27:38could potentially. You know, not pick up traction
- 27:42or there's another winner, but you were right on the sector and
- 27:45now you have exposure to a like an area, it's like it can
- 27:47actually go directly to zero. And we've seen this.
- 27:49There was a slide that we previously had with Martin 1031
- 27:54on the, I think it was like 7 or 8 companies back in 2021 that
- 27:58had $100 billion in enterprise value and it was like the
- 28:02Genesis, the FTX's of the world and it's it was effectively 0
- 28:06looking at it and it still is 0 today.
- 28:08And that just doesn't exist in any other asset class where it
- 28:12goes from you know in a year 100 billion and this investment is
- 28:15getting marked up to a 0. And so anyway I think it just
- 28:18speaks to why the the Bitcoin ethos or Bitcoin only at least
- 28:22to start is such a great place for folks to come in because it
- 28:25kind of de risks it and then they can start to learn a little
- 28:28more. So anyway, I'm curious to learn,
- 28:31is that like how do you feel about that and like how you
- 28:34think of the market outside of Canterbury, but just like
- 28:36consultants and institutions? If you think that will help in
- 28:40letting them get access to a market like this or a sector
- 28:43like this, or it's not really gonna matter.
- 28:45They're just gonna come whole hog in across the sector, Yeah.
- 28:50No, I think it will be gradual. And it's interesting, right?
- 28:57Because it goes back to that comment on diversification,
- 29:00right? If you're diversified across a
- 29:01bunch of different cryptocurrencies and tokens and
- 29:04VC projects, like in the grand scheme of things, like, you're
- 29:07gonna get something, right? Even if there's a lot of zeros.
- 29:10You just need a few things. It's the trip, typical VC model,
- 29:12right? You just need a few things to
- 29:13work out and you're gonna do well.
- 29:17And I think there's a lot of noise around that.
- 29:20And I think because of that people view Bitcoin, and this is
- 29:27not everybody, but I think some people view Bitcoin is just
- 29:29something that's boring and not worth the time to dig into.
- 29:33Which is insane, right. But I've heard that from
- 29:36multiple people that it's just not exciting enough to do the
- 29:44deep dive work on it and and part of it is is I can I can
- 29:48understand that because you have you have different groups that
- 29:51are pitching you different ideas that sound great, the stories
- 29:54sound awesome and then at the end of the day you're
- 29:57diversified across all these different types of stories And
- 30:00so from your perspective it's all good.
- 30:03But you know I I do think there needs to be this kind of first
- 30:06principles back to basics of you know why Bitcoin is is is the
- 30:13signal from all this. I also think that in a way, you
- 30:20know, if you're running a Bitcoin only company or you know
- 30:24like like in terms of your strategy, your product, right.
- 30:26It's a very low time preference business and it's it takes a
- 30:32long time to gain credibility and trust and for you know,
- 30:35people to reach out to you. And then you know because it's
- 30:39Bitcoin only, you don't have all the other stories and all the
- 30:42other exciting things that you can report to people.
- 30:46And so I think it's just that it's just a matter of time.
- 30:50It's just going to take longer than people, I think think to to
- 30:53kind of come full circle. But yeah, I mean, that's kind of
- 30:58what I see at least from, you know, speaking with colleagues
- 31:00and others out there. Yeah, I agree.
- 31:05Like historically, up to this point that's been the case where
- 31:07it's like it's boring. But I do think we've talked
- 31:10about this, particularly last week's episode with Max Webster.
- 31:12I do think something. It is becoming a tailwind for
- 31:16Bitcoin and it's a narrative. Is the development happening at
- 31:202nd layers, particularly the lightning Network.
- 31:22Like it's finally gotten to a point of maturity where you can
- 31:26have web three like functionality on top of Bitcoin.
- 31:29Point to things like podcasting 2.0, the intersection of
- 31:32lightning and AI, monetizing music via podcasting 2.0
- 31:38functionalities L 402 as a protocol to sort of embed.
- 31:43The payments protocol into the Internet stack, and I think that
- 31:49I mean it. We always knew as bitcoiners
- 31:51that this was going to come fruition and just took some
- 31:54time. And I feel like we're finally at
- 31:56a point where those narratives that crypto has sort of taken
- 32:00and run with historically are beginning to come to Bitcoin.
- 32:03You do have that sort of flashy, high tech play within Bitcoin
- 32:09coming to the market from a narrative perspective, but
- 32:12another thing? I wanted to touch on to get your
- 32:17view on this is that I think this is a line that many
- 32:20Bitcoiners have run with for some time.
- 32:22And I do think it's true, which is the idea viewing Bitcoin from
- 32:28like a risk profile and sort of flipping the table on asset
- 32:32allocators and saying, hey, it's actually probably riskier not to
- 32:35have an allocation of the Bitcoin that than it is to have
- 32:38an allocation of Bitcoin, especially if it's a small
- 32:40allocation like you could. Miss out on some of the the
- 32:45biggest gains of any asset in human history if you don't at
- 32:49least have a small allocation. So does that fit into sort of
- 32:54the way you pitch Bitcoin at all this this idea that it's
- 32:57actually riskier not to have any allocation?
- 33:00We've talked about that. No, we have talked about that
- 33:02and that and that has been an internal discussion.
- 33:04Is it, and you hear this from other groups, right?
- 33:06Just have like a 1 to 3% allocation to Bitcoin like your
- 33:09toll risk return across your portfolio, your your riskiest
- 33:12return increases you know meaningfully just having a very,
- 33:16very small piece of of Bitcoin in in the allocation.
- 33:20I think what trips up a lot of folks is, is if you're to think
- 33:25about just real assets in general and the real asset
- 33:27bucket within a within a portfolio, right, it's a mix of
- 33:30commodities, maybe real estate, precious metals, gold, it's it's
- 33:35combination of things. And so you know what we've heard
- 33:40and this is something that's occurred in the past is you know
- 33:43we don't have just an individual allocation to gold, right.
- 33:46We may have a strategy that invests across gold, silver, you
- 33:51know, other types of of metals, you know commodity, other types
- 33:55of commodities. But you know why would we have,
- 34:00you know, just like a gold only or a Bitcoin only piece to that,
- 34:03right. And then it kind of gets to the
- 34:05point of bucketing. Where do you put it right.
- 34:08Allocators, institutions like to have a very neat place to have
- 34:14their investments in. So it's very easy to say, okay,
- 34:17this is an equity, this is a bond, this is a venture capital
- 34:21investment, this is a private equity buyout investment.
- 34:24But where do you put Bitcoin right?
- 34:25Is it a DC asset? Is it a real asset?
- 34:32And then in terms of the the value proposition, right, a lot
- 34:37of people say digital gold store value but your partner already
- 34:40about the growth of lightning network in L2 and kind of that
- 34:44medium of exchange really starting to pick up.
- 34:46You know that's that's valuable And so how do you kind of think
- 34:49about that aspect of it and how do you bucket it from that
- 34:51perspective. And so then you talk about all
- 34:54these different then diagrams or or trees that start splintering
- 34:58out from use cases and where you bucket it and people just get
- 35:02over it just becomes overly complicated.
- 35:06And then at the end of the day you say okay, it's a one or 2%
- 35:08position, why are we spending all this time on A1 or 2%
- 35:11position in the portfolio. So yeah, it's it's interesting,
- 35:17but these are all happening real time and I also think that you
- 35:24tend to see more more talk, more conversation happening during
- 35:29various hype cycles. And so I'll be just to see kinda
- 35:33how the ball moves forward going to the next bull market.
- 35:36But yeah, that's kinda some of the background behind it.
- 35:39Logan quadboxes, we're gonna sit figure this out now cuz this is
- 35:45something we've talked about in recent weeks.
- 35:48We gotta, we gotta do a little working group here.
- 35:51What is the new bucket? We've been saying like you just
- 35:53have to create a whole new bucket for this.
- 35:55For which bucket? Which bucket does it go in?
- 35:57Or is it a new bucket? It's a new bucket.
- 36:00Well, a couple. So Logan, I'm glad you quad
- 36:02boxes, this is a really good point to discuss because a
- 36:05little inside base we've hadn't having a lot of these
- 36:07conversations Lauren, since we've last chatted.
- 36:09And the the common things you brought up are things we've been
- 36:11discussing with large institutions.
- 36:13And this is partially where it's exciting between the pod or just
- 36:17advisory services like they need the support whether it's for
- 36:21them or their clients, whether it's wealth management and the
- 36:24FAS or the end client into helping them understand this.
- 36:28And you made this like key point of like it's not sexy, but it's
- 36:31not sexy for a number of reasons.
- 36:32Like it's not sexy if it's not 100 bagger because maybe not
- 36:35venture right now in the truest sense or a token, but then it's
- 36:38very sexy if it's a like commodity or gold or a bond like
- 36:42so they're not. It's like the lens keeps moving
- 36:44around and the bucket like on how do they position it.
- 36:47But then also it's something we think about is the fact that the
- 36:51strategy is so simple it doesn't look like a strategy.
- 36:56To the institution, but it actually is the supreme strategy
- 36:58that we're going to support with and the the idea is that you buy
- 37:02and you hold it for whatever the the timeline is that you need to
- 37:06see the return. You know, we know in the green
- 37:08you're in three plus years or whatever, but it's like this is
- 37:10what you do with it and you sit on your hands and you just let
- 37:12it sit there. And everybody in this whole game
- 37:14working with institutions has said the complete opposite,
- 37:16right. They told you to do all these
- 37:18fancy things and they never get to see the game.
- 37:21So anyway, that was a kid. But like we put some really good
- 37:24materials we can even pull up on the screen in the different
- 37:26buckets with PE Venture and how they can like start to benchmark
- 37:29in the quartiles. But you hit on all the common
- 37:31tropes that come up and it's just about dispelling it.
- 37:33And you reference listening to the episode with Brian.
- 37:35And that's why we're really excited with Brian and Jackson.
- 37:38Also recently coming on is that he's been doing this at the
- 37:41highest level right? Working with institutions and
- 37:43helping them understand and how to articulate and pull the
- 37:45research together. And I don't think there's a
- 37:47silver bullet. It's just understanding what
- 37:49matters to the individual and then or that that sector of the
- 37:53institution when you mention real assets venture or whatever
- 37:57P/E and then giving them the right materials and having those
- 38:00conversations and then ultimately they're gonna have to
- 38:02like find the end of the rabbit hole.
- 38:04You can only start the the journey for them.
- 38:08Yeah. I also think too right, if the
- 38:11liquidity profile makes it difficult, because if it's a VC
- 38:15investment, it's locked up. Once you go into the VC fund,
- 38:18you're locked up. There's nothing you can do.
- 38:22You don't see the marks very often quarterly if you're lucky
- 38:27and with Bitcoin is 24/7 and there's a running, you know,
- 38:32there's a consistently running scoreboard going on with how
- 38:37you're doing with that. And you're reminded over the
- 38:40over the weekend when you're, you know, hanging out with your
- 38:43family or you know trying to get away from the screens.
- 38:45So it that's also a psychological barrier that I
- 38:48think that has an effect as well.
- 38:51Yeah, I I did recently put out a piece trying to analyze this
- 38:58this problem of of how do how do we think about Bitcoin in in
- 39:02terms of what assets it compares to like what's your opportunity
- 39:05cost of capital. And how that plays in the
- 39:08Bitcoin and and and what's the hurdle rate for you know when
- 39:13you're allocating to an asset like this and you know breaking
- 39:18it down I mean over the last halving era it's been 45% kegger
- 39:23for for Bitcoin and every halving era has, has been a
- 39:27reduced kegger just as the the upside volatility has has
- 39:31dampened over time. And so you know going forward
- 39:35maybe it's 25% over the next 40 years kegger, but that's venture
- 39:41capital, that's the expected returns for venture capital
- 39:44which is the top end of of the risk profile, right, Like that's
- 39:47as risky as you get. You're being paid that well for
- 39:51locking up capital for 10 years and and and it's going to be
- 39:55pretty binary. You're either going to
- 39:56underperform or you're going to be a part of Google or you know
- 40:00Uber or whatever and and your your fund is going to over
- 40:02perform. To outperform and but you know
- 40:06with with Bitcoin looking forward it it it's got this
- 40:10increasing scarcity mechanic that is guaranteed and that
- 40:16seems to be driving a lot of this the the kegger here So that
- 40:2025% may be largely based on a programmatic mechanistic reality
- 40:29playing out and and at the same time it is 24/7 liquid which is
- 40:36the kind of so it's low risk in a weird way and it's completely
- 40:41liquid which those are the kind of the characteristics of U.S.
- 40:44Treasuries which yield 4 or 5%. And so you're talking about an
- 40:50asset that appears to have venture capital returns and yet
- 40:54U.S. Treasury risks and and that just
- 40:57breaks everything like if that's true that's that's the
- 41:01opportunity to cost capital that should be the hurdle rate for an
- 41:03incremental dollar allocated to an asset class.
- 41:06It's Bitcoin. Like Bitcoin should be the
- 41:08default but that's just so outside of how people can you
- 41:12know have to think because I'm sympathetic to like the mandate
- 41:16is capital preservation and if you're wrong on Bitcoin then you
- 41:21screwed up. You know if if you're an
- 41:22institutional capital allocator and you make that mistake that's
- 41:26your ass. You know, you're you're done.
- 41:30But 14 years has has only like made it clearer how this thing
- 41:36is, is moving, why it's moving in this direction.
- 41:39And and I don't know, the next four years looking forward seem
- 41:42clearer than any prior four year period with Bitcoin.
- 41:46And at some point like, you know, Bitcoin is a 12 thousandth
- 41:51of the world's assets. And if the institutional
- 41:56allocator strategy is to maintain diversification across
- 42:01the world of value, at some point you have to own a slice of
- 42:04that that little tiny thimble of a bucket.
- 42:08And so when does that happen? Yeah.
- 42:12One one thing that is really interesting Marty brought up is
- 42:18the risk like the risk associated and I think.
- 42:22There's a different way to position the risk.
- 42:24And the risk is like, well, or I don't, I don't, maybe not
- 42:26different way to position, but there's a form of like risk on,
- 42:29oh, like you don't have exposure, you're going to miss
- 42:31out on the greatest asymmetry. And then there's the other form,
- 42:35which I think you touched on, Jesse and you mentioned early,
- 42:38Lauren, on the 5% benchmark of like real returns and like one,
- 42:43how do you measure the real? Is it like, you know there's a
- 42:45nominal, but then what is real compared to inflation?
- 42:47Because it is plus inflation. So let's say real, you
- 42:50referenced 5% plus invasion, let's call it 3%, right in
- 42:55quotes. So we're at 8%.
- 42:57The reality is like I think we'd all agree here it's not really
- 43:0033 and so is it 12, is it 15 whatever the number is when it
- 43:06when people start to recognize and and I also think This is why
- 43:09it comes from a bottoms up because individuals recognize
- 43:12that like they're buying less food every day and less
- 43:15day-to-day expenses are getting more.
- 43:16And so it's like, how do I protect myself?
- 43:19But ultimately this is where that gradual and suddenly
- 43:20happens is the institution is like feeling the risk because
- 43:24how do you capture that 10 to 15 or whatever the benchmark
- 43:27actually starts to become, what's the actual hurdle rate?
- 43:30And then where do you find it? That's where the whole BlackRock
- 43:32thing is so fascinating because I think they kind of know this,
- 43:35right? It's like, well, how do you
- 43:36actually get out of this hole? Well, before you jump in here,
- 43:39like another part of that risk too is like if you miss out on
- 43:43bitcoins value appreciation it. Appreciating value typically
- 43:47means that things are going bad in the other part of your your
- 43:51portfolio. That's why Bitcoin is accruing
- 43:54values, because people are finally getting the light bulb
- 43:56moment where oh, I probably need to own this asset over all these
- 43:59other assets. And if you're on the sidelines,
- 44:01you're missing out on the value appreciation of Bitcoin.
- 44:04And you're also suffering the losses of the other parts of
- 44:07your portfolio that are bleeding because people have finally
- 44:11recognized like, oh, this is a sinking ship and they have
- 44:14gotten. Into the lifeboat.
- 44:18Yeah, I mean point. But I think going back to
- 44:22Jesse's point, if Bitcoin breaks things, that's very scary,
- 44:28right? Like that's insanely scary and
- 44:33it's your point, like okay. Well, for breaks things you
- 44:35probably won't have an allocation to it.
- 44:36Well, things break, and that's why Bitcoin succeeds, right?
- 44:40Right. But also I think that leads to.
- 44:44Apprehension of you know, Bitcoin is a paradigm shift in a
- 44:47way from what people have been used to.
- 44:49There's been whole careers we we've had a what, a 40 year bull
- 44:53bull running bonds since the early 80s in terms of just
- 44:57yields continually decreasing and that's that's the whole
- 45:01career, that's several careers for for people in in our
- 45:04industry. And so it is a paradigm shift,
- 45:07and it takes time for that paradigm shift to really work
- 45:11its way through. The system so.
- 45:16Yeah, I think that's where like the it's really been a I think
- 45:20pivotal mindset shift for Jesse and I.
- 45:23And I think as we think about like the digital gold, digital
- 45:27gold's good. There's nothing wrong with
- 45:29digital gold to start 2% get in. We all know you buy 100 bucks,
- 45:33200 bucks as an individual and you start to pay closer
- 45:35attention. So I don't think digital gold
- 45:38breaks anything. I think it's a nice entry point.
- 45:41There's a lot of upside that still gives us what like 20 acts
- 45:46I guess from here, even more from like Bitcoin's current
- 45:50price. And I think that's an easy
- 45:53narrative. And I think that's also where
- 45:54BlackRock is focused on and we're starting to see other
- 45:56institutions come in, makes a lot of sense.
- 45:59It's easy to handle and not have to go down the rabbit holes of.
- 46:02Multiple layers and cryptocurrencies and all the
- 46:05things. It's also part of it.
- 46:08I know you guys have, you know, certain focuses when it comes to
- 46:11the ESG side and that's also I think where it's important that
- 46:14like Blackrock's leaning into that or I don't know if
- 46:16BlackRock fully has yet, but like I know the KPMG article,
- 46:19it's not coincidence KPMG comes out a week or two later with
- 46:22leveraging, you know, the fact that Bitcoin is ESG, which is
- 46:26something that you know we don't.
- 46:29Lean into but we've always said if you ever were going to like
- 46:31guide by a principle of environment, environmental,
- 46:34social and governance like Bitcoin was always the one that
- 46:36embodied it, embodied it the most.
- 46:38When you think about what does it do for the environment, when
- 46:39you think of, you know, energy or the social aspects of giving
- 46:43a form of currency that is accessible to all seven plus
- 46:47billion people on the planet Earth, like what else can do
- 46:49that that's open other than the Internet?
- 46:52So I think that like as this continues in that now the the
- 46:55narrative is somewhat on our side because the institutions
- 46:57are picking it up for for reasons we can debate.
- 47:01I think, I think it happens a lot faster and maybe that's a
- 47:05good transition on the ETF stuff or I don't know, Jesse, you have
- 47:07something. But I think that's a good be.
- 47:09Good to hear how you guys are thinking about that.
- 47:11Yeah, I mean I think I think the last 10 minutes we've just
- 47:13thrown a lot of our thoughts at Lauren about how capital
- 47:17allocators should be doing things.
- 47:19Me most of all and ultimately I'm sympathetic to it.
- 47:24It's like it is a problem of where do you put this thing in a
- 47:27portfolio, like do you what bucket does it fit in?
- 47:31And it's a very high bar to create a brand new bucket.
- 47:36And I've thought about this a fair bit, especially in the last
- 47:39six months. And you know, unfortunately I
- 47:42think the answer is you kind of need to have a new bucket for it
- 47:46if you're going to really do it right.
- 47:49And that's a really high bar. So barring that treated as
- 47:55digital gold right like and and then fit it in with the the hard
- 47:59asset part of the portfolio and try to justify it being a few
- 48:05percent when the hard asset portion of the portfolio is
- 48:10probably only a few percent on its own.
- 48:13You know so it's hard to hard to really get enough exposure to
- 48:18Bitcoin when you when you fit it in in that way.
- 48:21But but at least that's a start and you know, I, I, I, it's I
- 48:26think it's just an impossible problem.
- 48:27And and Lauren you're on the front lines of of trying to help
- 48:33make sense of this for your clients of where does this fit
- 48:37in and how does this work with how people currently think about
- 48:41things and how they've structured their portfolio to
- 48:43work. And it's just so tough that like
- 48:47the best answer is create a new bucket and nobody wants to do
- 48:50that. Yeah, yeah.
- 48:52And I think part of it too is the origination of Bitcoin,
- 48:57right? It came after the GFC and it was
- 49:00made for individuals to have some sovereignty and rights
- 49:05back. And this is the first asset that
- 49:10I know of that. The individuals were able to
- 49:13adopt it first and then the institutions came in after,
- 49:15right? Or you know it's usually the
- 49:18other way around where it works top down, not bottom up.
- 49:21So I think that also leads to to to issues like okay.
- 49:26Going back to my comment on my families have have looked into
- 49:29it more than the institutions like I can just hold it as an
- 49:32individual because I don't care about bucketing.
- 49:36And also you know, I I get the the personal benefits of owning
- 49:39it directly. Versus institutions like Okay, I
- 49:42have to own it in a certain vehicle.
- 49:46Where do I put it? There's just all those other
- 49:49considerations. It wasn't designed.
- 49:51It wasn't created as a product for institutions first and
- 49:55foremost, yeah. What's fascinating about the top
- 50:02down approach that you referenced though is it all
- 50:05still starts with the individual, just like at the
- 50:07very beginning, IE like. The individual in part of a
- 50:11investment committee or corporation is the one that's
- 50:15going to drive this. They're going to get it, they're
- 50:19going to grok it and then they're going to work with their
- 50:21peers. Similar to you having the
- 50:22conversation with your colleague and having these kind of
- 50:25conversations. And it's it's maybe takes a
- 50:28while but it ultimately comes from individuals coalescing
- 50:31around you know a framework and then diligence in it and then
- 50:35come into a committee and and it and that's in.
- 50:38We've seen this with Saylor, right, because he just had, he
- 50:41was atypical in the governance structure that he had and being
- 50:44in the place that he was in, but he still had to get everybody on
- 50:47board. And he was able to really kind
- 50:50of, you know, force that through the door in the sense of here,
- 50:52like this is the academic literature.
- 50:53Here's the process. You know, you guys tell me if
- 50:56I'm nuts or not, but you're going to look at this.
- 50:58And when we all know that, if anybody earnestly looks at this,
- 51:01it's very, very hard to refute what's happening.
- 51:05And that there's not a bunch of error between 0 and 26,000 that
- 51:09we're at right now. There's actually fundamentals
- 51:11that are happening and that have been happening for the past 15
- 51:14years and will continue when you look at it.
- 51:17And so I think that's where the the individual still will be
- 51:20very important and something I've always thought like whether
- 51:23it was Unchained or here when we had these discussions with
- 51:25prospective clients or just partners or or or folks looking
- 51:28at the spaces that individual matters so much because that's
- 51:31the person that makes up. The entity and they're the ones
- 51:34that are going to go and listen to a pod like this or share it
- 51:36or have the conversation and go out of their way.
- 51:38And to Jesse's point, those touch points continue to to
- 51:42compound until decisions made or I think Ross Stevens in
- 51:46Massmutual, another good example of the impact he's had from you
- 51:50know taking a stand. He was a leader in organization
- 51:52and then the impact he's had will never fully like grasp, but
- 51:55I think it just continues to compound year over year.
- 51:58As you know Bitcoin is exists. Yeah, that's a great point.
- 52:06I've got a a bow to tie on this bucket conversation.
- 52:11I was listening to Invest, the latest episode of Invest Like
- 52:16the Best Patrick O'Shaughnessy at Will England from Walleye
- 52:19Capital on. And in the beginning of that
- 52:22episode, he told the story of the robber barons during the the
- 52:26railroad. In the railroad craze in North
- 52:31America and he mentioned James J Hill specifically, which I found
- 52:36very interesting because James J Hill is like one of the few like
- 52:39Titans of industry for back in that day that I've really dug
- 52:42into. And he made the point like
- 52:44comparing James J Hill and the robber barons of the railroad
- 52:48boom in that period and comparing them to like the tech
- 52:51sector in this period. And he was like the tech guys
- 52:55have nothing on what James J Hill and those guys did.
- 52:58They literally pulled. The world with them and said,
- 53:00hey, we're going to make it so everybody can access North
- 53:03America from coast to coast. So we're going to build these
- 53:06railroads and to tie the bow on this bucket, like I think that's
- 53:11we need like a James J Hill in the investment arena to say,
- 53:15hey, we're literally going to pull everybody along.
- 53:17Here's this new bucket because Michael, I couldn't stop and
- 53:20think when. You mentioned like the energy
- 53:24like that, like when you think about Bitcoin, it's digital
- 53:26gold. Then you had to mention energy
- 53:28at the end like it's an energy play, like it's energy sector
- 53:30play, it's integrating with the energy sector right now.
- 53:33When I mentioned earlier Lightning, like it's a high tech
- 53:35play, like it's it's going to be the payments layer of the
- 53:39Internet. It is this whole new bucket.
- 53:41And I'm not putting the pressure on you, Lauren, but I do think
- 53:44we need a James J Hill. Like at your level, did you say,
- 53:47hey, there's this whole new bucket?
- 53:49You can, you can look at it as digital gold and put 1 to 2% of
- 53:53your hard commodities allocation into it, which will be maybe 20
- 53:59bips of your overall allocation into it.
- 54:01But you'll make some money, but you're going to miss out on a
- 54:04lot of these big things. It's actually a really good
- 54:07corollary, because in the railroad, I'm listening to
- 54:10something else about the railroads and JP Morgan, and
- 54:12there was a lot of people that lost a lot of money.
- 54:15When they were investing because there was unscrupulous actors
- 54:17when they were actually like setting up the railroads.
- 54:19But you ultimately have to go. The first people through the
- 54:21door are not going to get it right completely.
- 54:23And we've seen this with like tech.
- 54:25We can have a fiber in the backbone being laid out as
- 54:28infrastructure is being and a lot of people go bankrupt.
- 54:30But over time, there's like fundamentals that are there and
- 54:34I think the same similar railroad and like this asset
- 54:36clause. Marty, what if this evangelist
- 54:39that this champion of Bitcoin that emerges, what if it is, is
- 54:45Larry Fink? How would you feel?
- 54:47About that, would you would Larry Fink be suddenly be a
- 54:51friend, a friend to Marty if if he is the one articulating how
- 54:57you know what the ESG thing we were wrong, but Bitcoin actually
- 55:01does accelerate those pie in the sky goals in terms of a more
- 55:07stable energy future. That's the thing and Larry Fink
- 55:11is the one saying it. How do you feel, Marty?
- 55:13It's fine. If he wants to pump my bags, he
- 55:15certainly can. But I don't think Larry Fink is
- 55:17equipped to be that that guy because he wants all the Bitcoin
- 55:20to sit in that ETF. And like we mentioned many times
- 55:24over the last couple of months, like that is the last place you
- 55:26want your Bitcoin. Because as we've been talking
- 55:29about the utility from the medium exchange perspective,
- 55:33that's being added via L2 S, like lightning, space chains,
- 55:37Fetty Mintz, whatever. Like you're going to want to tap
- 55:39into that. And he's not.
- 55:42Going to want people to have their Bitcoin not sitting in his
- 55:45ETF, so I'd find it hard to believe that he'll be running
- 55:48with those narratives as well. But if Larry wants to pump our
- 55:52bags, do it. I got my.
- 55:54I got my private keys. I'd love to see Peter Thiel and
- 55:58Larry Fink having a fireside Chad Bitcoin 2023.
- 56:02I think that would be quite the quite the show.
- 56:07Yeah that would be great. Yeah it it it is it's worth
- 56:11thinking about how the guests of of you know the the Miami
- 56:15Bitcoin conference over the last few years have have evolved.
- 56:19And you know, suddenly we had Michael Saylor on stage and then
- 56:24and then the next year it was the the president of a sovereign
- 56:27nation making a big announcement.
- 56:31And then this year we had like a presidential candidate launches
- 56:35candidacy on stage, you know, at a Bitcoin conference projecting
- 56:42that forward. You know, it may be only a few
- 56:45years until we have real Titans of finance trying to insert
- 56:52themselves in into the Bitcoin world.
- 56:54As you know, thought leaders or experts on Bitcoin, because you
- 57:00know, by my ETF that could happen in the next couple years.
- 57:04I think it and I think it does happen as soon as next year
- 57:07where it's at the big conferences.
- 57:08I was finding out like the money 2020 which is a big one in Vegas
- 57:11last year that was 20%. It was actually surprising me,
- 57:1320% was crypto and 80% like Trad 5 fintech stuff and that was in
- 57:18kind of what a slower market. But you can imagine that that
- 57:21just continues where the the Trad 5 conferences end up.
- 57:25Pick coin conferences. I mean, I'll just say I was in
- 57:282022 and I ran into several mutual acquaintances.
- 57:33From the Trifi world that were there just trying to learn.
- 57:36And you know some of those from a credit hedge fund that had
- 57:38nothing to do with Bitcoin was there just because they wanted
- 57:41to learn about it. And they went to the Orlando
- 57:42Bravo. I saw him at the Orlando Bravo
- 57:48presentation that he gave with with the other free, the other
- 57:51individual individual or part of the panel.
- 57:53But you know, I mean you have people kind of Incognito they're
- 57:57trying to figure out, you know at these conferences trying to
- 57:59figure it out. So it does happen.
- 58:03That's interesting. So be be nice to the person in
- 58:05the seat next to you at the Bitcoin conference.
- 58:07It could be a a hedge fund guy trying to learn about this asset
- 58:12and genuinely wanting to know more.
- 58:14Yeah. And I do think it's fair to to
- 58:16call out that while there are hesitations from institutions
- 58:21and intermediaries and consultants and pensions, there
- 58:24is also folks internally them or they're on the same wavelength
- 58:29of what we're talking about here like it they're there.
- 58:34Maybe there's there's some time, there's some committees there,
- 58:37there's ETF that needs to happen before they, but like it's it's
- 58:40all happening. It's the same as an individual.
- 58:43There's just a curve of like where they enter in and then
- 58:46where they exit or where they end up the allocation.
- 58:49But I do think it's it's it's a pretty exciting time from the
- 58:54ability that I don't think we've seen it as derested as it is
- 58:59ever been in the history of its existence.
- 59:02I mean, Lauren is proof pudding of that, right?
- 59:06Like these people, these people exist and I guess we've been
- 59:12hogging the mics here. But I do want to bring up this
- 59:16question which is like, do you view like actually nailing how
- 59:21you guys advise on the Bitcoin side of things and allocating to
- 59:25Bitcoin for your clients as a way to differentiate Canterbury?
- 59:29From your competitors out there, because if you guys get this
- 59:31right and you lead your clients down the right path, they're
- 59:34gonna be very happy and I imagine that leads to more
- 59:36business down the road. Yeah, no, absolutely.
- 59:39I mean, that's something we're actually thinking about, not
- 59:42with just Bitcoin, but other types of strategies, other
- 59:45things like how can we be? As forward to thinking as we can
- 59:49with what we offer and the service we provide to our
- 59:52clients. And so for instance, we've
- 59:55created an internal digital asset working group.
- 59:58It's not quite the Bitcoin working group, it's not called
- 1:00:00that yet. But you know something that we
- 1:00:03created two years ago just to get educated and to try and
- 1:00:08learn more about the space and those types of internal working
- 1:00:15groups tend to lead to? Official investment committees
- 1:00:19which lead to eventually to allocations recommendations to
- 1:00:22our clients. So kind of the nice thing about
- 1:00:25our, our position in the marketplace, you know we're not
- 1:00:29one of the larger consultants, we're not small RRA, we're kind
- 1:00:32of in the middle in terms of the the groups that we advise on and
- 1:00:36and the assets we we advise on. So we kind of have that ability
- 1:00:40to to to think of new things and try to think outside the box,
- 1:00:44but still have the scale you know to to implement proper
- 1:00:48strategies and and get kind of best execution on the
- 1:00:50strategies. Yeah, it's that.
- 1:00:59I mean that brings up another point is like scale, like you
- 1:01:02can actually come in in scale once they've made the decision
- 1:01:05of what does that scale look like running with the
- 1:01:08hypothetical that people get it and then they begin allocating
- 1:01:13accordingly. Yeah.
- 1:01:16I'd love to make that a little bit more granular.
- 1:01:18I have a question for you, Lauren.
- 1:01:19I I don't really have a great grasp on how big are the pools
- 1:01:26of capital for different types of institutional allocators, but
- 1:01:32more specifically, how? How relevant are those the those
- 1:01:39different pools of capital in terms of how able they are to
- 1:01:42move into something opportunistically like Bitcoin
- 1:01:44or you know, to be able to move quickly like in my head a hedge
- 1:01:48fund can, you know they they could they might have 5
- 1:01:52positions. So you know if they decide that
- 1:01:55Bitcoin is one of them that it could be 20% or even more.
- 1:01:58I mean, Bill Miller has 60% of his of his personal portfolio in
- 1:02:02Bitcoin. And so in that sense like the
- 1:02:05hedge fund kind of tips the scale pretty quickly in terms of
- 1:02:08ability to move fast and and the amount of wood they can put
- 1:02:12behind the arrow. How you know illuminate me, I a
- 1:02:18little bit more on like how is that in reality on the
- 1:02:21institutional side in my head the end endowments and
- 1:02:25foundations will move incredibly slowly and they will dip a toe
- 1:02:30and incrementally go from there. I think that's right, but.
- 1:02:34Is that how you see it? No, that's right.
- 1:02:37And you know we meet with clients on a quarterly basis
- 1:02:40typically. So that's four times a year,
- 1:02:42right. And so there's a lot of things
- 1:02:45you need to cover if you're only meeting with the client, you
- 1:02:48know, 4 * a year officially. You know, obviously we have
- 1:02:50discussions and conversations quite a bit with groups, you
- 1:02:54know, on an ad hoc basis. But when you're talking about a
- 1:02:59whole portfolio and you're trying to add something new to
- 1:03:03that portfolio, it takes a lot of cycles and a lot of education
- 1:03:08and getting folks comfortable with the decision.
- 1:03:12And to your point, Jesse, on the ENF side, it is more gradual and
- 1:03:15slower for a few things. One is you typically have
- 1:03:19several trustees and board members that have various
- 1:03:22opinions that have different backgrounds come from different
- 1:03:26areas, different industries that need to come together to make a
- 1:03:29consensus on that on that decision.
- 1:03:31So we're as an advisor, we're recommending something, we're
- 1:03:34not making that discretionary choice for them, right.
- 1:03:37It's at in the days the clients decision whether they want to
- 1:03:39invest in something or not. We're doing our best to bring
- 1:03:41forth the best opportunities to them.
- 1:03:44But at the end of the day it's their decision on the advisory
- 1:03:46side. And so a lot of it is getting
- 1:03:49consensus, make sure everyone is well to speed on the value
- 1:03:52proposition and is well enough educated to know what they're
- 1:03:55investing in versus on the family side, you usually have
- 1:03:59one or you know just a few different decision makers where
- 1:04:03they can just make that decision right away.
- 1:04:05They don't have to really worry about bucketing as much.
- 1:04:08And depending on their willingness and ability to take
- 1:04:10risk, that allocation can kind of vary.
- 1:04:15And so yeah, it's gradual. It's definitely a toe dip at 1st
- 1:04:19and then as folks get comfortable you know it can lead
- 1:04:23to larger allocations. But just to give you like a
- 1:04:26sense, yeah, I work a lot on fixed income and credit and
- 1:04:31we've been advising clients on private credit more recently and
- 1:04:35that's been a two to three-year process from when we started
- 1:04:38talking about it with clients to now getting actual commitments
- 1:04:42and and and and allocations to it.
- 1:04:45And that's something that's been you know private credits been
- 1:04:47around for 1015 years prominently and in the in the
- 1:04:52community and but just because it's a new asset class and
- 1:04:55something that clients haven't had previous exposure to, it
- 1:04:57just takes cycles, it takes reps.
- 1:05:01So hopefully that gives you a sense of kind of the timeline
- 1:05:03and why when you hear institutions are coming okay,
- 1:05:07there may be a few people who believe in that, but it just
- 1:05:09takes time to get through all the different cycles of that.
- 1:05:15What do you think takes more time in where the apprehension
- 1:05:18lays more with the fundamental understanding why there's value
- 1:05:22or? Why they could whether there's
- 1:05:23an allocation makes sense because you can look at results
- 1:05:27but then it's like, well, why would they continue or do you
- 1:05:30think that there's there's buy in there or there there there's
- 1:05:33more buy in there. But then it's like how do you
- 1:05:34safeguard it? Because all you hear about is
- 1:05:35how everybody loses their Bitcoin.
- 1:05:37And I know it's not a, it's not one way or the other, but like
- 1:05:41just what your instincts tell you or what you've seen, Where
- 1:05:43do you think is harder barrier for for somebody to to crock or
- 1:05:48understand? Are you referring to just
- 1:05:51directly with Bitcoin in terms of why it's hard to get over
- 1:05:53that hurdle of allocating? Yeah.
- 1:05:55And just like the not necessarily the with Bitcoin,
- 1:06:00but I guess we can focus on Bitcoin is just looking at the
- 1:06:03asset and thinking through, OK, let me think, you know, in my
- 1:06:08mind I picture this as somebody looking at it and says OK, well
- 1:06:11this has been the best performing asset.
- 1:06:13It's done this. We've seen it go up.
- 1:06:16I can get it, but then I don't know if I make a material
- 1:06:18allocation that it's actually going to be there is all I hear
- 1:06:20in the news is how it ends up in landfills or whatever.
- 1:06:22Or it's the other side where it's like I don't actually fully
- 1:06:25grok. Like how this can have any value
- 1:06:28in quote UN quote intrinsic value.
- 1:06:29And so forget about custody, custody like somebody's figured
- 1:06:32it out. I just don't buy into that like
- 1:06:34where do you see larger barrier and I know they both exist, but
- 1:06:38like just in your mind what do you think takes longer for
- 1:06:41somebody to in the institutional space to really?
- 1:06:44Feel comfortable in making any kind of allocation?
- 1:06:46Yeah, Yeah. I would say the latter is
- 1:06:49definitely a bigger piece because if you don't believe in
- 1:06:51the thesis, it doesn't matter. Everything else doesn't really
- 1:06:54matter, right? You're just gonna automatically
- 1:06:56dismiss it and not do the work or look into it.
- 1:06:59The custody side and the rug pulling and the bad actors that
- 1:07:04that's hopefully our job of figuring that out before we even
- 1:07:07bring that to a client. So if that happens then our
- 1:07:10client's allocated to that or got exposure to that on our
- 1:07:12watch. Shame on us.
- 1:07:15That's why clients hire us. And so I'd say the bigger hurdle
- 1:07:19is just understanding the value proposition, the role it plays
- 1:07:25and the differentiation has to other assets in your portfolio.
- 1:07:28But isn't it a little bit of like a chicken or egg thing?
- 1:07:30Because a lot of folks, at least from the individual side,
- 1:07:34hesitate to. Look at this, because of the rug
- 1:07:37pullings and it goes to zero and not Bitcoin.
- 1:07:40But like that it's like which cryptocurrency do I go to?
- 1:07:42What if it's not Bitcoin? What if it's the other one?
- 1:07:44Or how do I secure it? Cuz it ends up so they never
- 1:07:47actually go down to even start the process on the diligence or
- 1:07:50looking at it as an asset class. No, I think that's fair in a way
- 1:07:57though. I think it's kind of self
- 1:07:59selecting, right? Or or you're gonna, you're gonna
- 1:08:02find whatever fits your kind of preconceived narrative or notion
- 1:08:06behind it. So, you know, if you look at the
- 1:08:08block fives and Fdxs of the world, you'll say, look, there's
- 1:08:11the evidence that this is all just, you know, nonsense, you
- 1:08:15know, discounting the 14 years prior of or or just looking at
- 1:08:19the actual technology itself, right.
- 1:08:21And and and how you can actually custodate yourself.
- 1:08:24So yeah, it's not right because. It's something I think a lot, a
- 1:08:30lot about because we hear the number of 200 million or
- 1:08:32whatever that hold Bitcoin. But we know a majority or large
- 1:08:35portion of that or somebody that has 50 to 100 bucks on Coinbase.
- 1:08:39And I feel like a lot of that individual or, you know, entity
- 1:08:42that it's a flyer because it's just like, oh like maybe this
- 1:08:45could work out, but maybe it couldn't because history shows
- 1:08:48that all these bad things happen.
- 1:08:49And so it's like how do you like?
- 1:08:50It's just this interesting like dynamic or paradox of like, I
- 1:08:53can't look into it because I just it's ephemeral and there's
- 1:08:56nothing tangible related to it. So I can't actually think about
- 1:08:58going deeper. But then there's the other side.
- 1:09:01So it's no, I think that's a good point because privately you
- 1:09:06can do that. Like you can own 100 bucks of
- 1:09:08Bitcoin in cold storage and say I'm just gonna have this as a
- 1:09:12hedge. I don't have to tell anybody
- 1:09:13about it. It's not very much of my total
- 1:09:16net worth. If it does, great, awesome.
- 1:09:19If it doesn't like, it's private.
- 1:09:20I don't have to say that I lost a bunch of money owning Bitcoin
- 1:09:24versus if you're a public institution and you go through a
- 1:09:27formal IC process and you have it on your portfolio and
- 1:09:30everyone, all your stakeholders can see it.
- 1:09:32Now that's a different story, right?
- 1:09:34Because now there's the public opinion and and the the fact
- 1:09:38that everyone knows whether you did well or you didn't do well
- 1:09:42by owning that investment. So I think that's part of it
- 1:09:46too. And that's probably what some of
- 1:09:48the differentiate you see with institutions versus individuals.
- 1:09:51On an individual level, you can keep it somewhat private.
- 1:09:54At the institutional level, everybody knows, right, pension
- 1:09:57plans, they have to make everything public of what they
- 1:10:00own. And I'm sure you know the groups
- 1:10:02that own the FT X's end and block Fives the world that was
- 1:10:07not. That's something they'd never
- 1:10:09want to have to go through again, I can guarantee you that.
- 1:10:12Yeah, the whole concept of career risk is one of the
- 1:10:15biggest hurdles here. There's people that lost their
- 1:10:18careers because of FTX and Block 5.
- 1:10:21And ironically, it's like it's folks working at pensions and
- 1:10:25endowments. Seeing the Ontario teachers
- 1:10:29union, was it make that misstep that probably keeps them from
- 1:10:35wanting to touch Bitcoin? Ironically there, you know.
- 1:10:40Well, you go back to the the individual.
- 1:10:42This is like Lauren, what you were saying made me like, really
- 1:10:44think about credit to fidelity. It's like career risk, like
- 1:10:49Abigail Johnson 2014, like mining, letting people use it in
- 1:10:52a thing. And I did a quick search like, I
- 1:10:54mean, we knew this, but it's like, it's her grandfather's
- 1:10:56business. Like, of course you're going to
- 1:10:58pick the right thing no matter what anybody says because it's
- 1:11:01your family's business. It's not like this academic, you
- 1:11:05know, just ephemeral, like, well.
- 1:11:07If I make the, you know, like whatever the term is, nobody got
- 1:11:10fired for, you know, choosing Apple or whatever, it's like she
- 1:11:12doesn't care about that. She cares about like my
- 1:11:15grandfather's gonna care if I lose his business or if I don't
- 1:11:17like pick the right decision and for them to like be the first
- 1:11:20they're. So it's just cool to see.
- 1:11:23But then also it makes sense that it's like it's a family
- 1:11:25owned entity. So you're gonna, it's gonna be a
- 1:11:27different tie versus like the career risk of making the
- 1:11:29decision. Yeah, but this goes back to the
- 1:11:32other point we were. Mentioning earlier, at some
- 1:11:35point in the future Bitcoin succeeds like the career risk of
- 1:11:39not getting in becomes higher than the career risk of not
- 1:11:42getting in. Yeah, and it getting in.
- 1:11:45Excuse me? It seems to me like like people
- 1:11:48like Lauren are are providing an awesome service of being willing
- 1:11:54to engage with this stuff and and actually take it on and say
- 1:11:57you know what, this has merit and this belongs in our clients
- 1:12:00portfolios to the extent that they're willing to have that
- 1:12:03conversation. And that right there is already
- 1:12:05differentiated it. And to me it seems like a way
- 1:12:08to, you know, if you're, if you have differentiation in the
- 1:12:13investment world and you're picking winners and we think
- 1:12:16bitcoin's going to be a winner, that that's such an opportunity,
- 1:12:21a career opportunity, not just a career risk.
- 1:12:24And you know, like, I hope that I hope that people hope that
- 1:12:29institutional allocators are getting advice from.
- 1:12:32The Laurens of the world rather than you know the the Super
- 1:12:37senior tenured advisors who you know are like Charlie Munger or
- 1:12:44or Warren Buffett and their attitudes towards towards
- 1:12:47Bitcoin because that's not those aren't the people who are going
- 1:12:51to win in this arena. And you know, I, I just think
- 1:12:56it's a career opportunity for, for Canterbury, for.
- 1:13:01People like Lauren and hopefully the institutions find that
- 1:13:06signal in time or they get on the train as it's leaving the
- 1:13:12station, you know, like that's fine too, yeah.
- 1:13:17I know we're brushing up on time here, but I do want to throw out
- 1:13:22a question to you, Lauren, about like, we are pretty in Bitcoin.
- 1:13:29Like we're. Financially, socially,
- 1:13:33professionally, we're all in. And there's this side is well
- 1:13:38known sort of phenomena like there's a Bitcoin bubble, we're
- 1:13:41in it for somebody who you're in Bitcoin too, but you're also
- 1:13:48pretty involved in the traditional asset allocation
- 1:13:51space. So what can the Bitcoin bubble
- 1:13:54be doing better to make your job easier?
- 1:13:58That's a really good question and it's definitely a bubble.
- 1:14:02And what the nice thing about being out here in Nashville now
- 1:14:05is, you know I've been trying to go to feed the Bitcoin Park
- 1:14:07events and meeting some people out there and it's a 180
- 1:14:13departure from my day-to-day job.
- 1:14:14And the other people I interact with in my in my day-to-day for
- 1:14:17for good, I mean and and people across the border are great,
- 1:14:21friendly, nice. But you're right Marty, it's a
- 1:14:24bubble. Twitter is a bubble.
- 1:14:27Definitely. I haven't spent enough time or
- 1:14:31much time on Noster, but I would probably say that's a bubble in
- 1:14:34terms of, you know, kind of getting the same tropes and and
- 1:14:39thoughts. And I I would say, yeah, I I
- 1:14:43think there's a different level and spectrum of how people view
- 1:14:49Bitcoin and the importance that Bigman plays in their lives.
- 1:14:54And people can tend to get pretty dogmatic about that.
- 1:14:59But you also have to live kind of in the realm of reality of
- 1:15:03where things are today. And you know, the best way to
- 1:15:08get people on board and to understand the narrative is to
- 1:15:10be patient and to try to connect, you know, what's going
- 1:15:15on on Twitter and you know the thoughts and and and and all the
- 1:15:19stuff that's happening there with the real world of how
- 1:15:22people think about investing. And.
- 1:15:24And it's a good question in terms of how do you kind of
- 1:15:28bridge that gap, right? Because it is in a way, very two
- 1:15:31different, very different roles. And and in many regards, it's
- 1:15:35how social media is today, right, Like depending on your
- 1:15:38ecosystem or echo chamber, you're only going to see things
- 1:15:41that kind of pertain to your role view on things.
- 1:15:44So how do you kind of bridge that gap?
- 1:15:47I think maybe it's just being open and patient with others who
- 1:15:51are trying to understand maybe where you're coming from now.
- 1:15:56It's a good question. So you're saying we shouldn't
- 1:15:59tell people to have fun staying poor?
- 1:16:03Probably not 100% of your net worth and Bitcoin That it's
- 1:16:08just. That might sound reasonable and
- 1:16:13fair based on the work you've done and everything, but to the
- 1:16:16normal person who is not in this every day, they're gonna think
- 1:16:19that's absolutely insane. I agreed.
- 1:16:23Yeah, yeah. I wonder what the meme will be
- 1:16:26in the next bull market. I mean, Udi came up with the
- 1:16:29have fun staying poor and it hasn't.
- 1:16:32It doesn't feel like it's aged well.
- 1:16:34It was quite a a moment of of bull market arrogance on the
- 1:16:38part of bitcoiners to embrace that one.
- 1:16:40But I'm sure there will be another one, another meme that
- 1:16:42emerges in our in our euphoric, our brief euphoria that happens
- 1:16:48in the in the bull markets. And you know when we spend 90%
- 1:16:51of our time and and sideways are down pain.
- 1:16:55Yeah, I would also mention maybe, you know, in terms of
- 1:16:59there's a lot of drama that happens on Twitter, right,
- 1:17:01People with different viewpoints and a lot of going after people
- 1:17:07like that doesn't show well either from the institutional
- 1:17:09side. Like people don't want to see
- 1:17:11that drama. They don't want to, they don't
- 1:17:12care. People don't care.
- 1:17:15It's about like proposition of the of this asset.
- 1:17:18Like I don't care about the back and forth.
- 1:17:21Are you trying to one up somebody on Twitter?
- 1:17:24Yeah, so. I I remember when I was still, I
- 1:17:30was still an Altcoiner and I was starting to be like, okay, maybe
- 1:17:34the bitcoiners are right and and I checked in on Bitcoin and it
- 1:17:39happened to be at a point in 2018 or 2019.
- 1:17:44It's probably late 2018. When there was like a Bitcoin
- 1:17:48cruise and like that was like the big event of that week or
- 1:17:51month or? Whatever.
- 1:17:54Yeah. And I like, I like, checked in
- 1:17:56on that and it was a bunch of drunk douchebags, you know, on a
- 1:18:02cruise fighting with each other, like, you know, verbally.
- 1:18:06And I was like this. This clearly is not the signal.
- 1:18:09Like this can't be a good asset if these are the clowns who are
- 1:18:12associated with it. And that's really just Twitter,
- 1:18:15you know, That's what Twitter is, is 1 giant like verbal fight
- 1:18:20like that. Well, there's also the clowns in
- 1:18:23the the, the just in this asset class like I always talk about
- 1:18:28from an operator perspective and like coming from, you know, big
- 1:18:31companies, you think of the Googles and Weworks like in all
- 1:18:34of that. But there's also like the
- 1:18:36formation of like the firms, if you think about like.
- 1:18:39The big firms like Block Fi, Genesis, TCG, like these were
- 1:18:43the marquee firms and Wall Street is just literally just is
- 1:18:47going to mop the floor because they they they blew themselves
- 1:18:50up and now they're about to step in.
- 1:18:53You got edx, you got BlackRock, you got you know Fidelity,
- 1:18:56Schwab like they're coming here and just like like okay we time
- 1:19:00to go and it's just like it's it's showing like these guys had
- 1:19:05you know very little. It's one thing to be a tinkerer.
- 1:19:09And to come in and and get be early but you know it's like
- 1:19:12that saying where the person you know you can give somebody like
- 1:19:17some money or whatever they can win the lottery but they're
- 1:19:19quickly gonna give it back if they didn't earn it, if they
- 1:19:21didn't deserve it or whatever the thing it's like very similar
- 1:19:23like you could build a great big business or in if you're in the
- 1:19:26right time. But if you didn't actually like,
- 1:19:28if you were just writing tailwinds versus had
- 1:19:30fundamentals, you've seen it just like completely evaporate.
- 1:19:34And so that's really like I think the next 10 years as the
- 1:19:36market infrastructure works out and you have the right operators
- 1:19:39and executors, we'll see the real like Googles and Amazons of
- 1:19:43this next 20 years that are going to build long term
- 1:19:46sustainable businesses and moats around them.
- 1:19:50Yeah. No, no, I think, I think that's
- 1:19:52exactly what I was going to say. Michael, too is like we've
- 1:19:54talked a lot about this recently and I'll be the first to put my
- 1:19:58hand up. I've been in the middle of these
- 1:19:59Twitter brawls historically, but I think the last year
- 1:20:02particularly. I really resigned myself to a
- 1:20:06try to stay out of that as much as possible.
- 1:20:08I get tempted, I get pulled in, pulls me in every once in a
- 1:20:11while. But really my focus has been
- 1:20:13like, all right, I believe in this like it's going to happen.
- 1:20:16But if it's going to happen, we need the critical infrastructure
- 1:20:19that is going to, number one, get the world there.
- 1:20:22Number one, show the world that there's utility and fundamental
- 1:20:25value here. And the number two, get them on
- 1:20:27boarded into the asset and the infrastructure that the leverage
- 1:20:30once they're in. And that's like heads down
- 1:20:34building. Like there's too many
- 1:20:35conferences, there's too many stupid Twitter fights.
- 1:20:38It's like, all right, we have the tools at our fingertips.
- 1:20:40Go build the tools and let the tools show the world what this
- 1:20:44thing can do. Instead of you screaming at the
- 1:20:47world what it can do, you actually have to go build it.
- 1:20:49And that's part of the reason why on RAMP exists and why this
- 1:20:52podcast exists and want to blow smoke up our own ass.
- 1:20:54But that's part of like what we're trying to do here is be
- 1:20:57that that bridge that tries to break out the bubble.
- 1:21:00Talk to people like yourself, Lauren, to be this bridge of
- 1:21:05like, hey, we're not all completely crazy.
- 1:21:08Yeah, it's building, but it's also to your point, creating
- 1:21:11long term relationships with people and building trust and
- 1:21:14that takes time. That's not done over Twitter,
- 1:21:16right? It's like having real world
- 1:21:19conversations, discussions like this, and that's how you're
- 1:21:24really gonna get people on board, is building that trust
- 1:21:27and having a long term thought process to it all.
- 1:21:32Yeah. There's also real opportunity
- 1:21:33cost with noise and distraction. So you can always find out, you
- 1:21:37know, say like show me where you're, don't tell me what
- 1:21:39you're saying or like show me your portfolio.
- 1:21:41It's like, don't tell me what you're saying on Twitter.
- 1:21:42It's like show me what you're doing.
- 1:21:44To Marty's point, it's like you spend all your time there, like
- 1:21:46how much time can you really be? Or you could be doing a lot more
- 1:21:50if you didn't have the focus split 5050.
- 1:21:52So it's it's just a real world application of like, focus.
- 1:21:55Yeah. Well Lord, I want to thank you
- 1:22:01for for joining this for joining us this week.
- 1:22:04It's been extremely illuminating to get your perspective and I I
- 1:22:09do think the institutions are coming meme, if you've been
- 1:22:14running with that. I think this discussion is a
- 1:22:16good level setter to understand how these institutions actually
- 1:22:19move in the pace at which you can expect them to move, if they
- 1:22:25ever will, into this asset class.
- 1:22:27So thank you for your time today.
- 1:22:29And before we wrap up, if you have any sort of parting notes
- 1:22:32for the listeners out there, there's anything you want to get
- 1:22:34out there that you think we should touch on before we wrap
- 1:22:36up? No, thanks for having me.
- 1:22:38This is great. Glad to be a part of it.
- 1:22:40It's nice to be on APOD guys like this, which is a departure
- 1:22:44from my for my day-to-day. And no, I would just say, you
- 1:22:48know, it's. Yeah.
- 1:22:49In terms of Bitcoin, I think it's just continuing to.
- 1:22:52To do the work and get the story out and and and and educate and
- 1:22:58you know we're still it's a meme too we're still early but it's
- 1:23:01true from education standpoint across a lot of very smart
- 1:23:05sophisticated investors. They just need the education on
- 1:23:08on what Bitcoin actually is and the differentiation between that
- 1:23:11and other digital assets. So for those who are in that
- 1:23:16seat, or. Are you know have kind of a
- 1:23:20voice to do that as they just keep going and keep continuing
- 1:23:23to just bring out information and educate.
- 1:23:24Awesome. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:23:27And just to add an echo to that, we really enjoy like speaking
- 1:23:32for the guys, but me like enjoy these discussions and it's
- 1:23:36exciting to like start to have them with the level and caliber
- 1:23:40of what you guys are doing. And so I'd encourage to the
- 1:23:44point of like interest. Jesse and the the team have put
- 1:23:48a lot of good material that can empower individuals and entities
- 1:23:52to go and share and start to have the conversations and we
- 1:23:55welcome the reaching out. We started to get inbound from
- 1:23:58folks that listen to those podcasts that are interested
- 1:24:00that are further have their institution or their firm
- 1:24:04further down the curb on getting the education to the end end
- 1:24:07kind of like allocator. And I think there's more out
- 1:24:11there, but it's like there's always some, some folks have
- 1:24:13more initiative or willing to kind of stick their neck out and
- 1:24:15reach out. Like we welcome the cold
- 1:24:16outreach, whether it's via e-mail, via the website, via
- 1:24:18LinkedIn, because we have all these materials and they're
- 1:24:21ready to go. And we have a lot of exciting
- 1:24:23things planned for this month, the next month where it's going
- 1:24:26to really round out all the things we're doing that will be
- 1:24:28able to support folks like Lauren, institutions, pensions,
- 1:24:30endowments, high net worth. So it's really great to have
- 1:24:34Lauren on. And then as a teaser next week,
- 1:24:35we're actually going to have somebody from the Fidelity
- 1:24:37Digital asset team joining. And they're really excited to
- 1:24:41share what they're working on and some of the stuff they're
- 1:24:42seeing with the ETF wealth management.
- 1:24:45So I think we'll make September and October partially
- 1:24:47institutional because maybe there's an ETF coming sooner
- 1:24:51rather than later, but don't know anything in particular.
- 1:24:57And and yeah, I would just sort of add to what Marty said before
- 1:25:01of like institutions are coming as a meme and this is how it
- 1:25:06actually happens, but. They're still coming and and in
- 1:25:10fact it's it's just slow. It's just gradual.
- 1:25:14There may not even be like a gradually then suddenly in in in
- 1:25:17this situation. It might just be gradually
- 1:25:20little bit more, little bit more, little bit more.
- 1:25:22And the institutions that are arriving right now, the
- 1:25:26institutions that are coming and and arriving in the next 18
- 1:25:31months, are the ones that regretted missing out on
- 1:25:352020-2021. And I think have been doing
- 1:25:38their due diligence since then or or getting ready, laying the
- 1:25:41groundwork, getting the investment committee on board
- 1:25:45and that's a small, that's going to be a small group, but a
- 1:25:48bigger group than any prior institutional adopting group.
- 1:25:53And so that's the nature of this thing going forward.
- 1:25:56It's gradually, but it's happening.
- 1:25:58So the institutions are coming. It's just not all at once.
- 1:26:05You heard it here first, thank you guys for joining us this
- 1:26:08week. Lauren, thank you for your time.
- 1:26:11It was incredibly insightful. So thank you.
- 1:26:16And we will see you guys next week where we'll talk about
- 1:26:19Fidelity filing for an Ethereum ETF.
- 1:26:23See you then.