Latest / Newcomer Pod / VC Haves and Have Nots (with Kate Clark)
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome, everybody, to this week's Newcomer.
- 0:02It's Tom Doughton here, joined by Eric, newcomer of Newcomer.
- 0:06We got Madeline Renbarger and our special guest, Kate Clark,
- 0:10my former colleague from The Information, joining us to talk
- 0:13about a piece that she wrote at Bloomberg, where she now is.
- 0:16Not the information we're we're trying to remind ourselves in
- 0:19Bloomberg. We have three former information
- 0:21people on the podcast. Information reunion over here.
- 0:25Yeah, yeah. Anyway, Kate, thank you so much
- 0:27for joining us. Thanks.
- 0:28For having me excited and. We're going to be talking about
- 0:31this story that you wrote recently about the difficult
- 0:34fundraising climate for venture capital firms.
- 0:37The headline on the story is it's never been harder to make
- 0:40it in venture capital, which is like a it's a stark message.
- 0:42It's like a very firm, paternalistic thing to tell
- 0:45people you're never going to make it, or if you do, you're
- 0:49one of the luckies. I don't think it would have been
- 0:51so extreme with maybe the the setup or the headline, but you
- 0:55can see in the story that the data tells a very specific
- 0:58story. It's quite grim.
- 0:59It's less than $5 billion that these emerging managers, which
- 1:03are people who have raised 3 or fewer funds in VC, like the
- 1:07numbers are quite, quite bad. It's really low.
- 1:10And for first timers, like people raising their first fund,
- 1:13it was around a billion dollars and we're almost halfway through
- 1:15the year. So I think that's why we sort of
- 1:17went so harsh the headline and from chatting with so many
- 1:20emerging managers, like it's really hard to raise a.
- 1:24Fund it. It's so hard to capture failing
- 1:26venture capital firms because they they sort of die slowly.
- 1:30I mean, even in the story you're sort of talking to some of the
- 1:32people who are kind of making it.
- 1:36Who do we know for sure is you mentioned a couple that are like
- 1:40actually calling it quits. This was something we were
- 1:43challenged with, which is like, can we get current examples of
- 1:46people who are considering or not considering quitting, but
- 1:50like who is willing to talk about how incredibly difficult
- 1:54and disappointing their fundraising process has been?
- 1:57Like, as you might imagine, people don't really want to like
- 1:59go on the record. There are a lot of conversations
- 2:01that were had privately, but people don't really want to be
- 2:03the face of this. So as you probably noticed and
- 2:06others did like the picture we used for this article was people
- 2:09who have success. A good firm, yeah, Chemistry,
- 2:12right? No, I'm not.
- 2:14But you mentioned like Foundry called it quits.
- 2:16I think there was another one you mentioned.
- 2:18Countdown Capital was a good example of like an emergency
- 2:21manager that called it quits. Didn't open view shut down in
- 2:232023 or something There have been there's been a few high
- 2:25profile ones that really shut down like publicly right versus,
- 2:29you know, kind of twiddling away an.
- 2:31Extreme situation where like a key man leaves and they had and
- 2:34they like all of a sudden implode.
- 2:36Like there are all these outliers that are examples of
- 2:39this, but like didn't really speak true to the trend, which
- 2:41the trend is like it's hard to fundraise.
- 2:43People aren't actually able to do it.
- 2:44And a lot of people are just like, quietly not succeeding.
- 2:48Well, yeah, I wanted to zoom out and I, OK, I want to have you
- 2:51on, you know, you're obviously sort of the expert on what's
- 2:54happening in Venture and so you're seeing the same things as
- 2:56us. Like narratively, it has been
- 2:58such a complicated time because it's like if it hadn't been for
- 3:04AI, we would have been clearly in a miserable downturn in
- 3:08sharps and venture capital and then the the narrative would
- 3:10have been clean. It's like everything's down.
- 3:13Pandemic was the hype time. Like funds are pulling back.
- 3:17Like everything's bad. But instead we had all this
- 3:20excitement around AI hype or not, you know, tons of funding,
- 3:25though some of the funding came from, you know, public companies
- 3:28and crossover funds and everything.
- 3:30But it, it was, it was a great moment to keep the the party
- 3:33going in what otherwise would have been a brutal downturn.
- 3:38So that's one complexifier. The other complexifier, of
- 3:41course, is Andreessen Horowitz, General Catalyst, Lightspeed
- 3:46don't seem to have problems raising, even though it's a hard
- 3:49time in venture capital. So yeah, why?
- 3:52Why? I guess why are emerging
- 3:54managers having a hard time when there is this sort of asset
- 3:59class that's keeping momentum going and the mega funds are
- 4:03keeping the lights on and raising larger funds?
- 4:05Why do you think emerging managers are struggling?
- 4:08I think it's just like a flight to quality or the limited
- 4:11partners like the endowments or the OR just like the rich people
- 4:15in the family offices. They in times like this where
- 4:18it's so uncertain and so volatile and you know, you have
- 4:20such an unpredictable president and all of these factors, you
- 4:23want to pile your money and just if you can get access into
- 4:26Sequoia, are founders fun or entries in because they have a
- 4:29track record of, you know, 10/20/30, in some cases 40-50
- 4:34years. And so it feels safe and it
- 4:35feels comfortable, to be clear, like it was always hard for
- 4:38emerging managers. So it's just like extra, extra
- 4:41hard now. And because of that, I think
- 4:43it's really just about reputation.
- 4:45And that's why you do have chemistry, which is the fun we
- 4:48talked about. That is the outlier that very
- 4:51quickly raised 300 ish million for their debut fund.
- 4:54It's because all these people come from those name brand
- 4:58firms, so they have the perfect recipe that LP is excited about.
- 5:02We were talking about like Dimension Capital last week
- 5:04where it's like 2 of them are from Lux, one I think from
- 5:07Obvious. You know why I'm asking you the
- 5:10questions I can't answer. So they're not easy.
- 5:12But why do you think it is the case that there's this narrative
- 5:16that, oh, you can spin out of the legacy funds and there was
- 5:21like, oh, you wanna be a founder or you wanna have been a great
- 5:24Angel investor? And like we had this real Locky
- 5:27grooms and the solo founder and a lot obviously still going
- 5:30strong and not Friedman and Daniel Gross.
- 5:33I mean, that's basically a firm at this point.
- 5:35But anyway, what? Why is it the case that now the
- 5:38narrative is you need to be spinning out of a big venture
- 5:43capital firm to raise? Yeah, I do think that there's
- 5:46momentum for spin outs, which like, so people coming out of
- 5:50these big funds, I think it's the same reason like they have
- 5:53on their on their resume, they spent five years there.
- 5:55So LP's feel like, oh, they know how to do their job.
- 5:58They have relationships. Like it's, I think it's the same
- 6:01as why people feel like they need to do a stint at like big
- 6:03tech company because you get that good experience and you
- 6:05build your work. Like I don't think you really to
- 6:08be a good investor, you obviously do not need to work at
- 6:10those firms. And actually a lot of people
- 6:12leave those firms because they don't feel like they're getting
- 6:14any good experience or like actually hands on with founders.
- 6:17But I think it's the perception LP's have, which is that they
- 6:21know what they're doing, they have the right relationships and
- 6:24like, especially if they get support from the GPS and the
- 6:27fund, like the fund invest, that really, really helps.
- 6:29If you were to look back at the last decade or so of startup and
- 6:34venture capital, and I've been thinking about this a lot
- 6:36because a friend of mine is writing a book about kind of the
- 6:38the Zerp era. And what would you say was the
- 6:42peak? What what would you say was the
- 6:43moment in which the getting was so good that you could launch
- 6:47these as an emerging manager? You know, raise the LP funding,
- 6:51get maybe fifty $100 million fund off the ground fairly
- 6:53quickly and get a return such that like you suddenly were in
- 6:57the game, even though you weren't a major player, you
- 6:59weren't a name brand, you didn't have maybe the deal flow of like
- 7:02a top tier firm. Like what?
- 7:03What era would you kind of pinpoint as like the height?
- 7:06Probably 2021, I mean like maybe 2020, like there was a period
- 7:10Eric, maybe you remember like when did like Brianne Kimmel and
- 7:13Locky Groom kind of like raise their?
- 7:15First, well there was certified. That was.
- 7:17There was the pandemic fake out, right?
- 7:19It felt like things were as crazy as they ever could have
- 7:22been almost what like 20-19 and I think locking and people were
- 7:27coming on earlier than the pandemic.
- 7:30But then it's like things we get scared and like people pull back
- 7:35because it's like, oh, the pandemic's gonna be terrible for
- 7:37the economy. And then everyone realizes, oh,
- 7:39actually it's gonna tank interest rates.
- 7:42So it'll be great for forward-looking investments.
- 7:44Like tech. Everybody's gonna be sitting at
- 7:46home so money can move much faster and everything,
- 7:49everybody's gonna be shifting to software.
- 7:51So all of a sudden all the tech stuff is gonna do really well.
- 7:54And so then it was like true mania, you know, I was, I mean,
- 7:58it was just insane period of time.
- 8:00Anyone could raise money. I mean, there was just a period
- 8:02where like if you worked at any startup, didn't matter what it
- 8:05was, you could like quit and raise $7,000,000 in like a
- 8:09month. It's what it felt like.
- 8:10I mean, it was ridiculous. And most of those people don't
- 8:13still even have funds. I think that that kind of like
- 8:16that chapter was short lived, but like it was absurdly easy.
- 8:20And a lot of those people also invested in stuff that got
- 8:22marked up way too high, was overvalued and like they they
- 8:25don't have good returns at all. So I think that's why they're no
- 8:28longer. One thing that's amazing to me
- 8:30is like in 2021, I mean, I I was saying like, this is wild.
- 8:33The party's crazy. Like I literally had stories
- 8:35like Emperor has no clothes sort of situation.
- 8:38But at the same time, there was the belief that like all the
- 8:42exits that were happening in 2021, they were sort of the fake
- 8:46exits. You know, it's like, oh, these
- 8:48are like the SPAC companies and the shitty ones that everyone's
- 8:52unloading. And the real exits, they should
- 8:54come like next year when the party keeps going.
- 8:58And then the market corrected at the end of the year and it was
- 9:00like, OK, that's not happening. You know, what's your view on
- 9:04like the fact that maybe we'll see, you know, trimes coming?
- 9:08You know, we just had gusto on stage at breaking the bank.
- 9:11Obviously, Stripe and SpaceX and everybody are sort of
- 9:15perpetually private. Like where were the exits that
- 9:18would have kept Venture and better standing with limited
- 9:21partners? That's the source of the crisis.
- 9:24Like there are no exits and it's funny when you see like 2 IPOs
- 9:28like there was 1. What was it Hinge Health last
- 9:31week? Yeah, Hinge Health went out last
- 9:33week and then yeah. And then Omada is looking to go
- 9:36out, maybe next week, Yeah. Right.
- 9:38And people get so excited and they're like see like IPO's.
- 9:40But that's not that does not solve this problem, which is
- 9:43that there are like hundreds of companies that are overdue to
- 9:45exit, whether it's MNA or IPO and it's not happening.
- 9:48So until that changes like this crisis for emerging managers and
- 9:52and established ones who are struggling isn't, isn't going
- 9:54away. But I don't know what you guys
- 9:56are hearing, but it doesn't seem to me like any of those things
- 9:58are expected to pick up dramatically anytime soon.
- 10:01I mean, there's been a little bit here and there and like hint
- 10:03health, but like, it feels like it's still quite stagnant.
- 10:06Right, I mean whiz was huge this Johnny I've thing is OK Tom
- 10:09weigh in on this. This is sidebar is the Johnny
- 10:12I've deal like a huge it's $6.5 billion like on paper that
- 10:16should be a like transformational.
- 10:19Yeah, Thank you, Kate. Thank you, Kate.
- 10:21It's a stock deal. No one knows how the.
- 10:23Yeah, we don't know how the open AI story is going to end up.
- 10:26I mean, they haven't even converted to being a profit
- 10:28company, but. I'm saying they could be a
- 10:30liquidity provider. Forget the investment returns
- 10:32from investing in open AI, they just acquire everybody and like.
- 10:36If they do it with cash, we can start to talk.
- 10:38But like if you're an LP and you're ending up with like
- 10:40essentially a profit participation unit from Open AI
- 10:43right now with the hope that it becomes a reasonable semi liquid
- 10:46stock, then sure, we can, we can have that conversation, but.
- 10:49Johnny, I've like incredibly more rich.
- 10:52I don't think that it put a lot of cash in the hands of venture
- 10:54capital firms. Yeah, I don't know the cap table
- 10:56didn't. The information had something I
- 10:58didn't dig into. It I'm usually guessing, but I'm
- 11:00pretty, I would imagine that he owned a majority of it and like
- 11:02I know they were a little bit investment, yeah, they'd done,
- 11:04but I don't think it was a ton. Yeah, it's certainly not going
- 11:07to be like a windfall for, you know, the early investors that
- 11:09backed just him, right? One question I had, Kate, to
- 11:13jump back a little bit. There's, you know, the
- 11:15conversation around the big guys getting bigger, but there was
- 11:17also this huge push around like seed funding really taking off
- 11:21that kind of was more resistant to the downturn and seed sort of
- 11:25continued to go. People wanted to back, you know,
- 11:27why see companies. That was a sector that had a
- 11:29little more resilience where kind of are the earlier funds
- 11:33like that, where of course the middle funds and someone who's
- 11:35trying to raise, you know, like a 500 million to a billion
- 11:38dollar fund are really struggling.
- 11:40Is it the same for the really early people or is there a
- 11:42little bit more breathing room there?
- 11:44Yeah. Like you'd think that if you're
- 11:45raising a small seed fund, it would be a lot easier than
- 11:48raising a mega fund. And I think that like the
- 11:51challenge is a lot of LP's have a minimum check size.
- 11:54And so actually they want to invest in funds that are like
- 11:56250 million or more. When those funds are smaller
- 11:59than that, like you can't be an endowment like writing a $1
- 12:02million check. Like it doesn't make sense for
- 12:04the time it takes to diligence a fund.
- 12:05So I guess what I'm saying is that it's still hard.
- 12:08I don't know specifically. About like, I think like a funny
- 12:10thing that I would say on this is like seed is expensive and
- 12:13competitive, which would make it seem like I guess it's a good
- 12:17time to be in seed, you know, or it's like it's crowded.
- 12:20But like obviously some of that is from the mega funds and the
- 12:23multi stage funds participating in SEED as like an option call.
- 12:27And I think a lot of the pure SEED investors feel like it's
- 12:30overpriced. So it's this weird moment where
- 12:33SEED is comparatively hot relative to the other rounds,
- 12:37but few people in SEED feel like, oh, it's a great time to
- 12:41be a SEED investor. That's always the case though.
- 12:43Like I, I remember writing a story exactly about this and
- 12:46when I was a TechCrunch and I think like this narrative is
- 12:48always there where it's like the big guys are taking all the
- 12:50deals and they're marking everything up and it's so hard
- 12:52to be in seed. I just think it's always the
- 12:54case. It's like the big funds do all
- 12:56we. Want.
- 12:57Yeah, everyone complaints that the big funds are jumping into
- 13:00demo day and pricing up all the like buzziest.
- 13:03YC route yeah, we're about to have AY combinator demo day.
- 13:05Exactly. We're heating up for the YC
- 13:08companies are overpriced narrative just now.
- 13:12Everyone starts texting me frustrated messages about this
- 13:15is ridiculous, Yeah. There's always drama.
- 13:19Kate, did you see as you were talking to people for this
- 13:21story, a particular asset class that got cold feet around tech
- 13:24and being an LP? I mean, the endowments are still
- 13:27probably the single largest across the board backer of these
- 13:30funds. I doubt that's going to change
- 13:32anytime soon. But like was there at the at the
- 13:35boom time a certain type of, you know, unlikely investor or LP
- 13:39that was starting to, you know, back these funds then as things
- 13:43started to turn just completely disappeared.
- 13:45The high net worth individuals are usually the first to kind of
- 13:47step back just because they had a lot of exposure to the public
- 13:50markets. But I mean, the endowments like
- 13:52this is a really unique time. Like the Harvard is at war with
- 13:55Trump right now. And while I'm not saying that
- 13:58directly relates to Harvard's venture capital fund investments
- 14:01like it makes them more. No, people are nervous about the
- 14:04endowments pulling back like that's going to a huge trickle
- 14:08down effect. I have definitely heard about
- 14:10several endowments adjusting their allocation.
- 14:12So doing less, not doing none, but doing less.
- 14:16And that has like he just said, that has huge impacts to the
- 14:19ecosystem. So I would it's a kind of the
- 14:21same thing as this as we're talking about earlier, like it's
- 14:24really hard to point to specific examples with this stuff because
- 14:27it's all so hush, hush behind closed doors and there's no
- 14:30proof. But like I think we can expect
- 14:32that a lot of endowments will do a lot less.
- 14:35The big X Factor and everybody's still trying to understand this.
- 14:38We just saw the sort of everybody goes to the Middle
- 14:41East thing, You know, Tim Cook's getting shit on for not going.
- 14:45But it's like, does sovereign wealth of various forms come and
- 14:49save everybody? Endowments and, you know, fund
- 14:52of funds in the US are seen as the rational investors.
- 14:56Does sovereign wealth come in and like, who cares about
- 14:58returns and give everybody money?
- 15:02I find it so hard to like, you know, yeah, it's like, oh, the
- 15:05funds that do well will get their, you know, rewards and the
- 15:08ones that don't will get their just desserts.
- 15:10When it feels like you have sovereign wealth, sort of
- 15:13investing for relationships and not, you know, non financial
- 15:17reasons, it's like hard to tell a sort of, I don't know,
- 15:21morality play around a venture performance or how do you how do
- 15:24you think about? That I don't think sovereign
- 15:26wealth is coming and saving firms.
- 15:28I really, I don't I think there's been this narrative for
- 15:30a long time that it's dumb money.
- 15:31And I do think that that has changed and people have realized
- 15:35that obviously there's, there's dumb people everywhere and
- 15:38that's, that's correct. But like people have realized
- 15:41that it takes years to develop those relationships.
- 15:44It's a really long process. You can't call them and be like
- 15:47I'm struggling to raise. Harvard's out.
- 15:49Come in, Piff or whatever. Yeah, exactly right.
- 15:52And actually, like a lot of those, those sovereign wealth
- 15:55funds have made their bets. And there was that period which
- 15:57we all wrote about, which was like 2 years or something where
- 16:00everybody was going to Saudi Arabia all the time.
- 16:02And I think people are still going.
- 16:04But I think that a lot of those sovereign wealth funds did like
- 16:07spent the time, then made some investments and like now a lot
- 16:10of them want to invest directly in like the LLMS and other AI
- 16:13companies. Right.
- 16:14Like, you know, they're, they're starting to back, you know, the
- 16:16companies themselves, they don't need to go through the VCs.
- 16:19Yeah. Right.
- 16:20I had an interesting conversation with someone about
- 16:22that recently and asking about, you know, sovereigns as LP's.
- 16:26And this was someone who is a VC in in the Middle East and
- 16:28they're like, you know, venture capital's not that important of
- 16:30an asset class. I know we think about it as an
- 16:33incredibly important thing. And it's part of this cool, you
- 16:35know, sector of the American economy and it's the new, you
- 16:38know, next generation of companies.
- 16:39It's relatively small compared to private equity, compared to
- 16:42the other things that sovereigns invest in, like buying ports or
- 16:45sports stadiums or teams or things like that.
- 16:48And so yeah, I'm interested to see maybe you've heard a bit
- 16:52about like if it's just like you kind of don't really rate as as
- 16:56AVC firm if you go to the Middle East and hold out your hat and
- 16:58expect them to just put money. But isn't that, to me, that's
- 17:01the opposite. It's like Venture is so small
- 17:03that like they they can save it if they think it's an
- 17:06interesting space with people they want to hobnob with.
- 17:09Or I don't know, Kate, what do you think?
- 17:10If a fund needs saving, you don't want to invest.
- 17:13Yeah, it's not cool. Yeah.
- 17:15Right, nearly they're not good enough and they I don't think
- 17:17the sovereign wealth funds would want to do that.
- 17:20And I my guess is like that a most sovereign wealth funds are
- 17:22not interested in emerging funds at all.
- 17:24They're interested in like entries in which.
- 17:28Right where they can write huge checks, yeah.
- 17:30Yeah, yeah, exactly. That's really important, so.
- 17:32Yeah, they're not. They're not like, oh, I'm going
- 17:34to be the anchor LP for this $30 million seed fund, you know?
- 17:37I, I mean, founders are founders of the lifeblood of Silicon
- 17:40Valley. But after that, emerging
- 17:42managers are, you know, a core part of the ethos.
- 17:45I, I did see Hex data analysis company with a cool CEO Barry,
- 17:52he raised from a new her new fund.
- 17:54I thought that was an interesting like, I feel like
- 17:56the founders who know, you know, will be like, OK, you're going
- 18:01off on your own. You're sort of an emerging
- 18:03manager. I have a good reputation.
- 18:05You have a good reputation. I don't need like the big brand.
- 18:08I feel like that's Silicon Valley at its best.
- 18:10When like the sort of person really matters and it's like
- 18:14they can be off on their own or at the big firm.
- 18:17It doesn't matter to me. It's.
- 18:18Certainly a huge calling card if you know, Elod Gill is on your
- 18:21cap table or Nat Friedman and Daniel Gross, which I know we've
- 18:23talked about, are actually quite larger than, you know, just solo
- 18:26and Angel investors. But it does seem like there
- 18:29still are these personalities that can sort of command this
- 18:31and have sort of this kind of upstart feel.
- 18:34Do like them a lot, like Eric was saying, like founders are
- 18:36drawn to that. And also I think in this
- 18:39environment, people really like it when somebody runs the fund
- 18:42because there's been so much personnel changes at these VC
- 18:46firms. And it's like either you could
- 18:48like go into business with Sarah Guo, who like clearly is calling
- 18:50the shots or fund, or you could like definitely AGP at
- 18:54Andreessen, who? She's dominant.
- 18:55Like that's a that's a fund that's crushing it, right?
- 18:58I mean, it's a fairly new fund. When we look at what companies
- 19:01we wanted through Bowl Valley, I feel like convictions and
- 19:03everything, yeah, so many of them.
- 19:05But if the narrative is like, OK, it's the bad time to be an
- 19:10emerging manager, relatively better time to be in a big fund.
- 19:14Does that mean that we're swinging back to a time where
- 19:17like brand carries the day? Or do you think, you know, if
- 19:21you're doing a deal with Andreessen, most founders who
- 19:23are savvy still care about like the particular person Or how
- 19:27much do you think it's like I'm looking to raise money from
- 19:30General Catalyst, Andreessen or it's like I'm looking to raise
- 19:33money from, you know, David or whatever?
- 19:36Andrew, I'm curious. What you think?
- 19:37But I think when it comes to the mega funds, it's not really
- 19:40about the people. And I don't obviously if it's
- 19:43Marc Andreessen or if it's and there's a few of there's a few
- 19:45people that like really matter I guess and at those firms.
- 19:48But like that's one thing. But I do think generally when
- 19:51you're raising from those. Right.
- 19:53You're raising from the platform.
- 19:54Yeah. Like you're raising the platform
- 19:56and that's a signal that you look that you wanted because
- 19:58you, because your customers might know those firms, whereas
- 20:01they might not know like conviction.
- 20:03Do you agree? Do you think like those GPS of
- 20:05those firms are really known enough that they carry that?
- 20:08I mean, I think if, you know, founders are asking for my
- 20:10opinion, which is what it is like I would want a partner
- 20:14where it's like, I like that partner.
- 20:16I trust them and I believe that they have pull within their
- 20:18firms. But I agree that often when you
- 20:22get, you know, one of these huge firms backing you, the appeal is
- 20:25like they have whole teams, they have a lot more money.
- 20:28They could potentially like follow on and, you know, and
- 20:31there are cases where it's like firms keep coming back round
- 20:35after round and like are useful and bring connections and but
- 20:40but then it is like I'm, I'm thinking of particular examples
- 20:43that I don't want to name. And it's like, I don't know,
- 20:45like the loyalty of the particular partner can matter a
- 20:48lot. It's like, does that partner and
- 20:50your board member actually like drive bringing the money back or
- 20:54not? Yeah.
- 20:55I mean it just depends on the founder and what they want
- 20:57because most founders like don't really want the VC to like
- 21:00actually do anything. Sure, we want them to be a
- 21:03capital allocator, but that's. Important.
- 21:06They don't really the rest of it's kind of annoying and but
- 21:08there are some founders who like maybe just really do need
- 21:11support in various areas and like that's cool.
- 21:13But I do think most founders I talk to like they don't care
- 21:16about any of the stuff we're talking about at all.
- 21:18They just care about whether they can raise money or not.
- 21:21They want signal, right? I mean, you or you think most
- 21:24founders are just like price optimizers?
- 21:27I think there's still signal. Yeah, I think so.
- 21:30But I just mean, they usually just don't care about kind of
- 21:33the particulars, let's say, the politics of a certain firm.
- 21:37There's been controversies with Andreessen, right?
- 21:38Over the years. When I've asked founders about
- 21:42that in the portfolio, they're like, huh?
- 21:45Yeah, right. Well, they never care about.
- 21:46Yeah, the little controversies that less reporters care about.
- 21:49You're like, what? They're in hot water for XYZ.
- 21:53It's like, oh, do they have a lot of money?
- 21:54And like do they do a lot of stuff like?
- 21:56Yeah. But yeah, the signal matters.
- 21:58I agree. The signal definitely matters.
- 21:59And that's why that's why you go into business with some of these
- 22:01funds because they will follow on and they will help you get
- 22:03customers. But but yeah, I just think
- 22:05overall it's kind of like founders don't really.
- 22:07Let's make a prediction about where we'll be in two years.
- 22:13I mean, I guess to me, it really comes down to the thing that you
- 22:16were getting AT and the whole point of all of this, which is
- 22:19exits, right? Like if there are exits, then
- 22:22there, there can be a persistence of, you know, this
- 22:25landscape or, or, or, or ecosystem of VC firms of like,
- 22:28you know, mid tier VC firms. And if there aren't, then
- 22:30they're going to die off. And I, you know, I hear the
- 22:34argument from time to time that like, oh, you know, private
- 22:37sales and things like that will give people liquidity.
- 22:41So you don't really need an IPO. But that's not really the
- 22:43outcome I imagine most founders and most employees wanted when
- 22:46they got into a company, certainly not as AVC is, you
- 22:49know, basically selling off to someone else.
- 22:52I think it's going to be rough if we don't see IPOs and I, I, I
- 22:58think it probably will continue to decline.
- 23:00Private tech you think is will be in decline in two years?
- 23:03I think so. I feel pretty confident saying
- 23:05that and with the caveat that maybe AI can pull a rabbit out
- 23:10of the hat and create, you know, this next wave of Internet, new
- 23:14platform, whatever you want to call it, that would create a
- 23:16whole ecosystem and, and, and new, you know, revenue streams
- 23:20and companies that can kind of live off of that.
- 23:21But absent that, I don't see why it wouldn't decline.
- 23:24Going up, Tom's like it may not be as much in decline as he
- 23:27thinks just because like companies are already developing
- 23:29all this infrastructure around tender offers and it's becoming
- 23:32the norm. And I think that will just be
- 23:35what everyone does if the markets really do continue in
- 23:39the direction they've been going on because opposite of a
- 23:41prediction. But like, I don't think we're
- 23:42going to have some major AI IPO in the next two years.
- 23:45Like that doesn't seem at all where we're headed at this
- 23:49point. So I don't think they'll be that
- 23:51liquidity. So as a result, what I do think
- 23:53will happen is tender offers will be the norm at every single
- 23:55company. And that's how you cash people
- 23:57out. That's how you cash out
- 23:58investors and employees and you keep people happy as long as the
- 24:01markets continue to be this frozen as far as IP OS.
- 24:05But why would you throw good money after bad because someone
- 24:08has to hold these? You know someone has to hold the
- 24:09bag for a tender offer, right? I mean, there's like outside
- 24:12capital coming in buying these shares don't at some point you
- 24:15would think, well, I don't want to buy at this price.
- 24:18I don't think I'm going to end up with a good return if I were
- 24:20to buy these shares. Yeah, I mean the secondary
- 24:22market, you know, trades down and people react to valuation.
- 24:26Madeline, you want to make a prediction?
- 24:28Yeah, I have a prediction. I think we're going to see
- 24:31another one of the sort of like second tier of the mega funds,
- 24:36like not quite the GC Andreessen size, but like ones that are
- 24:41kind of playing in that space like a Thrive.
- 24:43I think we're going to have a new one that will sort of enter
- 24:46the Canon of like mega fund doing other financial products
- 24:50besides BC. I mean, Thrive is already doing
- 24:52this. So my money is that it's going
- 24:53to be Thrive. But I do see like with the big
- 24:55guys getting bigger, I think there's going to be another firm
- 24:58that gets like like solidified and sort of like that banner
- 25:01doing something else in venture that's not just like traditional
- 25:04venture. Like Founders fund could if they
- 25:06want it it feels like. Founders fund always could they
- 25:09have amazing returns, but I feel like they don't want to do that
- 25:13in the same way that would be, you know, like to consensus for
- 25:15them. And they've traditionally Peter
- 25:17has just done, you know, separate firms if you wanted to
- 25:20do other strategies. Madeline, I think that's an
- 25:23interesting prediction now, anyway, Kate, any prediction?
- 25:26I mean, I think that we will see a lot of these mega funds, even
- 25:30though yes, they're doing well and they can raise money, I
- 25:32think they'll get a lot more creative about who the LP's are.
- 25:35Well, not creative. I think basically what I what
- 25:38will happen is a lot more of these firms will pursue like
- 25:40public pension funds, things like that they've avoided
- 25:43because that makes their returns public, which is great for us
- 25:45because then we can actually see how they're doing.
- 25:48But I think we'll start to. See return bonanza.
- 25:50They're getting out anyway. They're already going to, you
- 25:52know, bankers and getting them sent to every wealthy individual
- 25:55in the world. Yeah, right.
- 25:56Yes, exactly. But that shows you that that
- 25:58it's a lot harder. So I think we'll just see kind
- 26:00of like them seek out other types of limited burgers.
- 26:03Yeah, I'm bullish overall. I feel like I I disagree with
- 26:08Tom just in that like I feel like every sign is the
- 26:11technology remains core to what's happening in in our
- 26:16economy. Like I think there's a lot of
- 26:18value to be extracted from generative AII think the core
- 26:22themes are doing well. So to me that just means like
- 26:27this stuff will get sorted out. Stripe, SpaceX, solid companies
- 26:33generating in some cases profits, like maybe they're
- 26:36priced off like 1020%, but not in a way that's an existential
- 26:41crisis. I think clearly there are a lot
- 26:44of like software SAS investments that like are never coming
- 26:48through. And like, I feel like the
- 26:50biggest risk factor is just the sort of like, I don't know, $2
- 26:54billion Unicorn. Like how much does your fund
- 26:57hang on this like startup that was valued super highly in 2021?
- 27:01Like those people, they haven't like stomach the loss yet are
- 27:05clearly in trouble. But hopefully you know, you you
- 27:08load into open AI at the right time or you figured out some AI
- 27:12investment and you make it to the next wave or you didn't.
- 27:15But I feel like this wave is good, but it it killed a lot of
- 27:19the old guard. But overall, I think I'm I'm
- 27:21still bullish just on a pure like this thing lives or dies
- 27:26based on the actual promise of the underlying technology.
- 27:29And there's a lot of exciting stuff coming out of generative
- 27:32AI. That's great news for a
- 27:33newcomer. It's great news for Cerebral
- 27:38Valley. Yeah, hey, you're naughty.
- 27:40And what is your take or like do you just you agree with that or
- 27:43not? I don't like think about it
- 27:44like, oh, I'm optimistic or pessimistic, but I just think
- 27:46that there will continue to be a lot of funding to private
- 27:49companies. So I agree more with you in that
- 27:51and that I don't think that in two years there's going to be
- 27:54some massive depression for startups.
- 27:55Like I think things will continue to be.
- 27:58There'll be a ton of activity as long as this AI boom stretches
- 28:01on. Like maybe unless something like
- 28:04open AI or anthropic like implodes.
- 28:08Right. It would need to be like
- 28:10existential. Yeah, it would need to be like
- 28:12what would. I think change things, but I, I
- 28:14don't think that's gonna happen. We already got close enough with
- 28:17the Sam Altman saga, what, two years ago at this point or?
- 28:20Almost two years. Two years in October.
- 28:22November. And Tom, I mean, you did this
- 28:24story basically we're saying this whole hype cycle is
- 28:26predicated on like foundation models, like not collapsing.
- 28:30And you did a story like soon after starting to write for us.
- 28:32There's like, actually, yeah, there's some revenue there.
- 28:35They're not. It's not so ridiculous or like.
- 28:39No, I'm not. I'm not.
- 28:40If you, if you recall my argument, my argument was like,
- 28:43yes, if AI continues on its trajectory, not even continues
- 28:47on it, they have major financial structural problems.
- 28:49Anthropic burns billions of dollars a year.
- 28:52Open AI burns billions of dollars a year.
- 28:53I understand these companies are too big to fail right now and
- 28:56they can probably continue to raise money increasingly from
- 28:58sovereigns to persist. These aren't great businesses
- 29:01right now. Like we can talk about their
- 29:02revenue and the potential impact that they have on society, but
- 29:05like, let's get these fucking books together like every other
- 29:09industry would look at the burn rate and I used to.
- 29:11Be I learned this whole thing covering Uber and it was like
- 29:14they burn so much, they burn so much, they burn so much.
- 29:16I mean, this is just how startups do things, right?
- 29:19I know this before. We've seen the movie before when
- 29:22you were asking about what was the peak period for fundraising
- 29:25or something like, my mind immediately went to the scooter
- 29:27era, which is like. Oh my gosh, I haven't thought
- 29:31about the scooter era in years. That's like that was when I was
- 29:34really first starting out reporting.
- 29:35So like I always think about that because I remember being so
- 29:39every day my mind was being blown by these valuations.
- 29:41I mean you guys remember like ofo.
- 29:44Ofo. Yeah, that was the housing 1
- 29:46ofo. Like it?
- 29:47Was. Just crazy.
- 29:48And since then we've had multiple.
- 29:51And that was like transparently insane.
- 29:53I don't know. I know like Rulov and people
- 29:55believed in it, but it's like it didn't make any sense to me.
- 29:59Like, I mean, the risk with models which we we've talked
- 30:02about endlessly, is that like when they're cheap to deliver or
- 30:06do you no longer have a Moat? And therefore if it's cheap to
- 30:09deliver and you can make a lot of profit, everybody has it and
- 30:11therefore you're not differentiated.
- 30:13That, that to me is the like terrifying case for open AI that
- 30:17it's either really expensive to deliver, you don't make money
- 30:20because you're differentiated or it's cheap to deliver and you're
- 30:23not differentiated. But.
- 30:25I I want to be clear, I'm not on like the full extreme side of
- 30:27like the EDD Citrons of the world who think that these are
- 30:31full on, you know, House of Cards that are about to
- 30:33collapse. I think they have much more
- 30:35value than its critics would be willing to accept.
- 30:37I just think it's a major structural problem that we
- 30:39really haven't seen at this scale before.
- 30:41And you know, I also like I covered Netflix and I worked
- 30:44with a certain editor who I'm not going to name you, but we
- 30:46all work with him too. Who?
- 30:48Who made his career, not his career.
- 30:50He's done a lot of career things, but but a huge rallying
- 30:53cry of his was like this Netflix thing.
- 30:56It's not going to work out. Right, right.
- 30:58And not only did it work out for them, they figured it out sooner
- 31:01than the traditionals. Yeah, exactly right.
- 31:04Everybody else is wrong. Right, they figured out sooner
- 31:06and they got their books right faster and the the you know, the
- 31:08media companies that all jumped on afterwards ended up having to
- 31:11burn a huge yeah, anyway, total catastrophe.
- 31:14So we we've all seen it before, but this is tough.
- 31:17I I really think open AI is is it's not going to be an easy
- 31:20road to figure it out and we should be skeptical of it until
- 31:23they do. But I agree with you.
- 31:25Look, if these companies do end up becoming trillion dollar, you
- 31:29know, you know, entities as Sam Altman and apparently, as the
- 31:31Wall Street Journal reported, expects, you know, just their
- 31:33hardware division to be, then sure, it's going to be a
- 31:37financial bonanza for the industry.
- 31:38If you can create a new trillion dollar company, all bets are
- 31:41off. But absent that man, it's just
- 31:43everything that you wrote about Kate and you know, the software
- 31:45companies and things like that, It's just it's not going to be
- 31:48easy. And maybe to close off this part
- 31:50of it, like I'm sure all of our sources have told us in the
- 31:53past, like expect a die off. You know, there's going to be
- 31:56some sort of reverse Cambrian explosion in the next year or so
- 31:59where we see all these firms that raised in 2020-2021 aren't
- 32:03going to be able to make it and it hasn't happened yet, so.
- 32:06I know we're into like Year 5 of this at this point.
- 32:09It's. Not going to happen.
- 32:10It'll never be all at once like we like.
- 32:11It to me, right? The media's reputation is that
- 32:14like, we love to write about failure, but we hate to write
- 32:16about like slow failure. And you know, like a lot of
- 32:20these funds and a lot of these companies, they're dying very
- 32:23slowly. And by the time they really die,
- 32:25who cares about them anymore? And so honestly, it's like a lot
- 32:29of things just fade into non being.
- 32:32And unless you die in a splashy way, it doesn't sort of
- 32:36penetrate the narrative in quite the same way.
- 32:38Yeah, and usually if you die in a splashy way, you get to start
- 32:40a new company anyway, so. You can make your death splashy.
- 32:44Then you're like, oh, yeah, this person knows how to stay in the
- 32:46headlines. Like, let's give them another
- 32:47shot. Adam Newman, back at it.
- 32:49I was adopted to stay a shout out blow.
- 32:52All right, I wanted to end Elon Musk.
- 32:55Is is walking away from Doge something we've talked about
- 33:00fairly extensively on the podcast?
- 33:02Can we like queue up that Remember on American Idol when
- 33:05they would kick people off and they would play a bad day like
- 33:08Daniel Powder bad day? Stay you stayed the montage.
- 33:12Can someone make the edit real quick?
- 33:14The montage of Elon walking out of his little little fake office
- 33:16in the White House. Yeah.
- 33:19I mean, look, it's his. His time as a special government
- 33:21employee seems to be ending, but not before he seems to be
- 33:26shitting on everyone on the way out the door, including the big
- 33:28beautiful bill, and saying that it it defies everything that he
- 33:32was working for in Doge. Which is really an easy way to
- 33:35say that Doge failed and he can just blame it on the big
- 33:38beautiful bill. The media played an interesting
- 33:41role in all of this. And I not to make everything,
- 33:44you know, through the lens of how we write about stuff, but
- 33:46there was a lot of triumphalism I saw on the tech crowd after
- 33:50Trump won, basically saying the traditional media is dead
- 33:53because Trump, who was abhorred by, you know, mainstream media,
- 33:58was able to succeed. And you have all of these
- 34:00whatever you want to talk about. You give your example of what
- 34:03you think new media is podcast, let's say, winning that
- 34:06traditional media died. And of course you saw, you know,
- 34:08with the New York Times and, and the journal and everyone Wired
- 34:11in particular was really just bagging on doge throughout.
- 34:14It's it's time to a point that it was, you know, Elon lost huge
- 34:17amounts of credibility and, and, and approval ratings and all
- 34:20that stuff. I'm interested to see how as we
- 34:23kind of start to accept the fact that DOGE was a failure as it
- 34:27it's significant dwindles in Washington and Elon goes back to
- 34:30the private sector who the blame will be on for for Doge's.
- 34:34Failure. In some ways it sounds like what
- 34:36you're saying is leave media and pat yourself on the back.
- 34:37You can still tear down an American hero of you.
- 34:40I think so. I think so.
- 34:43And I think you will find that the tech people will be the
- 34:46first ones to say it was killed by the media.
- 34:48You know they're going to see it.
- 34:49It was a full on assault. If everything in the world now
- 34:52is like, you know, just like power and how much you can
- 34:55influence things, in some ways it circles around.
- 34:58It's like, OK, well, I guess the media still mattered.
- 35:00You know, it's such a nihilistic time.
- 35:03Here's. Here's my question.
- 35:04Which is it? Does the media matter or not?
- 35:06Because if it doesn't matter and it allowed Trump to win, that's
- 35:09fine. Stick to your thesis.
- 35:10But if it also killed Doge, which I imagine is what you're
- 35:13going to, I start hearing people say, then clearly what you were
- 35:15saying at first wasn't true. So I'm just, I'm just begging
- 35:18these people to pick a side. I don't know which side I fall
- 35:21on honestly. The other contradiction of this,
- 35:22which I think is very related to what you're saying, is that the
- 35:26media doge is terrible. They're firing everybody, It's
- 35:29the end of the world. And now the takes are like, he
- 35:32didn't do anything, he didn't succeed.
- 35:35So there is sort of incoherence also in sort of the media story
- 35:39of whether this was a big deal or not.
- 35:43I think I've seen smaller examples, but some more, I would
- 35:46say balanced coverage, which is that like this is, you know,
- 35:49they didn't do as much as they claimed they were ever going to
- 35:52do and that never happened. But like they did still do like
- 35:55quite a lot and like the what has happened with doge in the
- 35:59government, like we'll change a lot of how things operate.
- 36:02But they didn't really like it comes down to like they didn't
- 36:04really cut like that much waste because like the bulk of the
- 36:07waste comes from stuff that people don't want to touch.
- 36:09So or like my waste but spending, you know.
- 36:12I mean, they wanted, I mean, once you have people freaking
- 36:15out about their Social Security checks, I think it gets, you
- 36:18know, infinitely harder and, you know, at least it gets material.
- 36:22Kate, what do you think? I mean, talking to founders,
- 36:25maybe people that are closer to that persuasion.
- 36:29Is the feeling on Elon changing at all?
- 36:32Have you gotten a sense that people are like, maybe he
- 36:34overstepped his his bounds and he should just stick to being,
- 36:38you know, one of the greatest CEOs of all time rather than
- 36:40anything more than that? No, honestly, I, I think people
- 36:43really believe in Elon still and, and think that like, I
- 36:47mean, I, I don't know how much people have changed their minds
- 36:49in the last few days or the last few weeks.
- 36:51But like I think that I've learned that kind of regardless
- 36:54of what he does, he has a huge army of fans that just really
- 36:58believe, especially in his efficiency approach.
- 37:03I haven't seen that balter, but I what I'm interested in is
- 37:06seeing now that Doge is kind of disbanding and that chapter
- 37:10seems to be over. Like what are people like the
- 37:13and recent people who went and start and joined up that what do
- 37:17they have to say about it? Like I think there's been a
- 37:18little bit of trickling of blogs that are coming out and people
- 37:21are going to start talking and I'm definitely going to be
- 37:23listening to to hear kind of what the story of the inside of
- 37:26all that was like. One good thing potentially to
- 37:31come out of this, so it's been horrible and mostly bad, is that
- 37:34I do think Elon in some ways will have to acknowledge that
- 37:37doing things in government is different than doing things in
- 37:41the private sector. True.
- 37:43I think there was this sentiment that it's like, oh, we'll just
- 37:45bring the Silicon Valley ethos to government and we'll solve
- 37:48all the problems. But actually you do have to like
- 37:51get Congress and even an executive that's like trying to
- 37:55wield as much power as possible. You have to like get all these
- 37:58different parts of the executive to be aligned with you.
- 38:00You know, it's not just sort of like, it's not like running a
- 38:04company. And so I think that is a lesson
- 38:07that needs to be learned if we want to make actual sort of
- 38:11change and understand how government operates.
- 38:14The other thing I just want to say because we sort of started
- 38:17from a meta point of view, but I do think, you know, what Elon
- 38:20did was absolutely terrible. It's like people are literally
- 38:23going to die from not having USAID.
- 38:26Like he made all these extremely disruptive cuts for basically no
- 38:31benefit, saved basically no money, and just sort of messed
- 38:36up the government. I mean, cutting the CFPB is
- 38:39going to be very bad for a lot of businesses operating anyway.
- 38:42You know, we talked about that at the summit last week.
- 38:44Right. So the story is going to be like
- 38:47he failed, but it's like he he did cause a lot of problems
- 38:52along the way. And like man, you would think
- 38:56someone empowered to make so much drastic change and how
- 39:01America works would have better understood what he was trying to
- 39:03do before he started it. Yeah, I also wonder how much the
- 39:08gap between vision and actuality and bringing a Silicon Valley
- 39:12mindset to government didn't take into account that
- 39:14popularity matters and you have to actually.
- 39:17Understand that he needs to be funny.
- 39:19People need to like it, Yeah. Right.
- 39:21I mean like approval ratings. I know like for example,
- 39:23Facebook used to, I don't know meta face or whatever used to
- 39:26measure like Zuck's approval ratings and and how much the.
- 39:29Users that he's running for president in days, yeah.
- 39:32Yeah. And or you know, how much people
- 39:34thought Facebook cared about them, That was like a metric
- 39:36about that. But that's fairly rare.
- 39:38And for the most part, they they don't mind barreling through and
- 39:40making the changes they want. And failing fast is sort of a
- 39:43version of that. And the political realm just
- 39:45doesn't. It doesn't accept that like you
- 39:47have to roll into your vision the fact that you have to win
- 39:51people over to your side. Because in business, you only
- 39:53need, you need your true fans. Elon doesn't need everyone to
- 39:57love Tesla. He needs enough really
- 39:59passionate people. We don't we need, you know, the
- 40:01tiniest subset of people to love newcomer.
- 40:04But obviously, if you're representing America.
- 40:07You need to be more generally popular if if you want to appeal
- 40:11to the politicians that you need to do things who are worried
- 40:14about getting re elected. Right.
- 40:15And, and I think one of the bigger mistakes that they made,
- 40:19aside from just doge as a concept probably being unpopular
- 40:21is that the figureheads of the Trump right movement, the MAGA
- 40:25right movement went about it in a very trollish way that they
- 40:28thought that if they could piss enough people off, they could be
- 40:31vindicated in their in their process.
- 40:33And I think it just got to be very unpopular because these
- 40:37people are unlikable figures for the most part.
- 40:39And, and the approval ratings show it to be the case, right.
- 40:42Like Elon's approval ratings are extremely low.
- 40:44Zach's approval ratings are extremely low.
- 40:46I don't know where David Sachs is at, but I can't imagine it's
- 40:48great if. People in the general public
- 40:49have heard of David Sachs. I wouldn't peg it as in a
- 40:52positive light at this. Point yeah, tend on a happy note
- 40:56you know if you're if you're an LP listening to this go support
- 40:59your local emerging manager. They need your support right
- 41:02now. You know it's a dark time and
- 41:05these 4 emerging managers need your help.
- 41:08So we're you're. Doing the ASPCA ad.
- 41:11For emerging managers right now, exactly now.
- 41:15We're piping and Sarah McLachlan, we can get a yeah,
- 41:18arms of the Angel. Kate, thank you so much for
- 41:20joining us. I we're we're also huge fans of
- 41:22your reporting and and you're a fierce competitor too.
- 41:26So. Hopefully many more times.
- 41:28Thanks for having me, man. If you've been saying I've had
- 41:33enough of Madeline and Tom, I've got good news for you.
- 41:40Layoffs. Yeah, Mark, Someone called Mark
- 41:50Stenberg quick. We're pivoting we're we're going
- 41:53to the Cerebral Valley podcast for the next three weeks.
- 41:56Max Child and James Wilstrom and the Co founders of Volley and my
- 42:00Co hosts at Cerebral Valley will be helming the podcast with me.
- 42:05We'll be talking about everything that's happening in
- 42:07generative AI ahead of the Cerebral Valley AI Summit in
- 42:11London on June 25th. And then Tom and Madeline will
- 42:16be back. So stick around.
- 42:18We'll still be here. Subscribe to the newsletter,
- 42:20you'll see our names. Go live on sub stack if you have
- 42:23if you feel like your opinions are being denied, you have.
- 42:26You guys have endless ways to reach the listener here I'm.
- 42:29Just going to go to the Mike Solana podcast.
- 42:32Oh yeah, go on pirate wires up there.
- 42:34I'm just going to go right to pirate wires.
- 42:35Godspeed.