Latest / No Way Out / Peak Performance with Jeff Sutherland, PhD
Transcript
- 0:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right, welcome to no Way Out.
- 0:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Today we have a special guest with us who graduated from West Point, went on to fly reconnaissance aircraft in Vietnam the RF-4C Phantom.
- 0:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He went on to get a PhD at the University of Colorado.
- 0:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He is the co-creator of Scrum and looked at the Minaka and Takiyuchi Harvard Business Review article and that's where you got the idea or the name Scrum from that, the new product development game.
- 0:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's also one of the signatories of the Agile Manifesto.
- 0:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In the studio today we have Dr Jeff Sutherland and our new co-host today in the Asia Pacific, steve McCrone.
- 1:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So both of you welcome today.
- 1:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Thanks for inviting us.
- 1:07Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Glad to be here.
- 1:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thank you, kia ora.
- 1:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So hey, steve, I don't know if you know this, but going back about 10, 12 years ago, I was living in Europe, had an opportunity to meet Dr Sutherland in Amsterdam, and he really planted the seed for what we now know as Agile X.
- 1:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the reason behind that is, he said hey, what you need to do is take a bunch of former aviators, special operators, military members, martial artists, and go stomp out all the bad Scrum and Agile out in the world.
- 1:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do you remember that, jeff?
- 1:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah, okay.
- 1:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And here we are fast forward to today and, looking back at that, I had no idea what he meant then.
- 1:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do have an idea now, but I want to hear from you, dr Sutherland, what's going on in the Agile community.
- 1:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Go back to that conversation you and I first had years ago and look at where we are today too.
- 2:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's changed, what's going right, what's going wrong?
- 2:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, I think the situation is the same or maybe even worse.
- 2:11Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The last data we had from the Stannish Institute was 58% of Agile teams, of which 88% of some kind of Scrum, are late, they're over budget, they have unhappy customers, they're Agile in name only, and that is what I hope that you and our fellow fighter pilots and martial artists could help fix, because a lot of it it's about split evenly, I think, between management.
- 2:44Jeff Sutherland, PhD: In my new book, I talk about the seven deadly sins of management that destroy Agile transformations, also the way the Scrum masters and the teams function today.
- 2:59Jeff Sutherland, PhD: In my new book, I'm focusing a lot on neuroscience.
- 3:02Jeff Sutherland, PhD: There's seven neuroscience accelerators that I point out in the book and you can see whether they're activated when you meet with a Scrum team.
- 3:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You can see it right away Either the energy is really high and people are really pumped, or everything's flat, nothing's happening With teams that do not have.
- 3:25Jeff Sutherland, PhD: As we know in martial arts, if you don't have the focus and you don't have the move, you wind up on the mat, and that's where most Scrum teams are.
- 3:38Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're on the mat, not able to execute.
- 3:41Steve McCrone: A number of our clients use your methods, jeff, so thank you for that.
- 3:47Steve McCrone: What's going well Over the last 12 years since you and Ponch had that discussion?
- 3:54Steve McCrone: What's been the benefit?
- 3:59Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, a lot of the companies are doing quite well with Scrum.
- 4:03Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Microsoft, all their development products, are done with Scrum, and Amazon, all their products are done with Scrum.
- 4:12Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I was told by people in my classes from Apple that the reason Apple meets all its dates is that they do Scrum by the book.
- 4:24Jeff Sutherland, PhD: When I asked what book, they said the red book.
- 4:29Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Scrum the odd of doing twice the work and half the time Apple does it exactly like the red book.
- 4:35Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The companies that are actually executing well are totally dominating the market space.
- 4:42Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's the good news.
- 4:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The bad news is that if you're not doing it well, then you're really severely limited and non-competitive.
- 4:55Steve McCrone: What's the difference between what Apple might be doing and what some of these other companies have been doing?
- 5:00Steve McCrone: Where's the gap?
- 5:02Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, the company that I run an investment company in and we're about half our investment is in Tesla.
- 5:10Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I followed that really closely.
- 5:11Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I actually done training inside of Tesla Scrum training.
- 5:15Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They do a little bit of Scrum but not a lot, but they are absolutely the most agile company in the world.
- 5:23Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Ford used to do one feature update a year.
- 5:30Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They do 20 a week.
- 5:32Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're a thousand times faster than Ford.
- 5:35Jeff Sutherland, PhD: How do they do it?
- 5:36Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They have autonomous teams that are digitally mandated by AI.
- 5:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Everything is visible on monitors, what needs to be done where they are, and the teams swarm to make what happens needs to happen, and so agility is really effective in companies like Tesla and the companies that are in their domain that don't start doing exactly what Tesla does.
- 6:11Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're going to go into bankruptcy, many of them probably this year.
- 6:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 6:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, jeff, in your new writings you talk a lot about the second law of thermodynamics and I want to go back to the cockpit and you know on the podcast here we talk a lot about John Boyd's observable anti-decided NAC loop, as well as energy and maneuverability theory.
- 6:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to go back into your background, not just at West Point but in Vietnam, flanned the reconnaissance missions, learning about John Boyd's unit loop and a little bit about EM theory, and you wrote about an interesting connection between EM theory and Little's law.
- 6:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to go there and before we do that I just want to kind of set the conditions on the EM theory and my understanding of it from fighter aviation.
- 6:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: John Boyd is the co-creator of energy maneuverability theory.
- 7:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He was actually trying to understand the second law of thermodynamics and apply that to fighter aviation.
- 7:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're talking about a complicated system without the human involved.
- 7:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just how do those aircraft perform, or how do they get peak performance given different contexts altitude, air speed, air density, things like that.
- 7:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So he used a closed in my mind a closed system approach to create a way to understand aircraft agility in the air.
- 7:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to see if you can build on that some more or offer up any other insights on EM theory, on where we're going with this?
- 7:41Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, I've been going back to.
- 7:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: One of the most interesting things that's happened in physics in the last two decades is Wolfram's physics project, where he's used his simulation tools and his team of theoretical physicists.
- 7:56Jeff Sutherland, PhD: He has worked for him to try to simulate the universe, and there's a couple of fundamental principles that are driving everything.
- 8:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: One is what he calls computational irreducibility, which simple rules generate very complex behaviors that are unpredictable.
- 8:16Jeff Sutherland, PhD: In fact, for even simple things like a project plan, you need infinite computing power to compute when it's going to be done, which, of course, no human has and so you never know when it's going to be done.
- 8:32Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And in order to deal with this unpredictability, you have to do things in small increments and at the same time we have and I think this is where boys start to come in, we have developers in neuroscience.
- 8:50Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The latest and greatest theory in neuroscience is Friston's free energy model of the brain, because we have been in an environment of unpredictability and our survival depends on prediction.
- 9:04Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The brain is evolved as basically a predictive engine and it's constantly you're constantly trying to predict what's going to happen, every second.
- 9:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's energy efficient.
- 9:18Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right, that's an energy energy, and if your prediction is correct, then that gives you lots of energy to do also some other stuff.
- 9:27Jeff Sutherland, PhD: If your prediction is wrong, then you have to correct your view of the universe and do all kinds of things that waste a ton of energy.
- 9:37Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And what Boyd is trying to do is, by rapid response, change what is going on.
- 9:48Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So the simulation in the enemy's mind is out of sync with reality.
- 9:53Jeff Sutherland, PhD: This caused what Friston calls Bayesian surprise and the cost of the Bayesian surprise he tries to make as big as possible so that they're talking about the second law of thermodynamics, so that entropy takes over and everything just accays and they can't function right.
- 10:16Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So Boyd is playing off these fundamental principles that are at the level of physics, and the reason I'm starting to talk.
- 10:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's build on this more.
- 10:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let's go back to the cockpit.
- 10:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You and I are in a 1v1 dogfight.
- 10:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I paint on the bottom my aircraft, the canopy, and the reason I paint that borrowed ideas from either biomimicry or animal kingdom to create that mismatch.
- 10:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you and I are fighting, we come to the merge.
- 10:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We understand a little about the EM theory.
- 10:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm trying to create that mismatch for you by painting the underside of my canopy right, or underside of my aircraft with the canopy, to show you that when I'm belly up to you, I'm actually not belly up to you.
- 11:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what competition looks like, even in sports, is.
- 11:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're always trying to create those mismatches to inject surprise right, surprise into the other, the opponent's OODA loop.
- 11:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you expand on that and make sure?
- 11:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I think.
- 11:21Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The really interesting thing about Friston's theory is that it's not only a theory, it's the mathematics that they're putting into robots, because a robot has the same problem.
- 11:33Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It's running a simulation, something happens, the simulation's wrong.
- 11:38Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Now they got to rewire everything right, and so that's what you're trying to do with the canopy painted the bottom of the aircraft.
- 11:46Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I come up, I think you're upside down, and all of a sudden I wake up.
- 11:49Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It's not what I thought.
- 11:50Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Now I have to redo everything right, and that redo has a cost.
- 11:56Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And in Scrum we call those impediments right.
- 12:00Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Yeah, we go to try to do something and then we're blocked, and then there's a significant cost in unblocking and redoing and figuring out what to do.
- 12:13Steve McCrone: So humans are inherently very, very good at managing in complexity.
- 12:17Steve McCrone: It's part of our evolutionary journey and it seems and I think bring back to your initial point, jeff that management blocks us from doing that.
- 12:29Steve McCrone: What's to do?
- 12:30Steve McCrone: If you take Cal Friestin's work, it's notoriously very hard to comprehend.
- 12:36Steve McCrone: I've been reading on that subject for a couple of years and I won't claim any expertise.
- 12:40Steve McCrone: So how do we bring that to your typical team, your typical Scrum team, your typical management meeting?
- 12:48Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, one of the reasons I started writing my new book is that the Chinese trainers were telling me what do we say to these Chinese managers that think that micromanaging and telling everybody what to do is the best way to get stuff done?
- 13:03Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And so my thought was you're not going to convince them by telling them that Scrum says so, right, you're going to have to give them a deeper education, like how things really work.
- 13:18Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So let's go back to physics and build up from physics in the neuroscience, and the neuroscience then came up into complex adaptive system theory, in which there's a massive amount of research, far bigger than Scrum or Agile, on complex adaptive systems that show there's mathematically provable theorems that show that autonomous units that have maximum degrees of freedom evolve a system faster, as long as you don't go over the edge of the complexity into chaotic behavior.
- 14:01Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right, you can mathematically prove that.
- 14:02Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So my idea whether we're working on it, I don't know is to sit down with the Japanese manager and say you know, this is the way things work.
- 14:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You can't really tell when things are going to be done.
- 14:18Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Have you noticed that, no matter how much you beat people up, they're still late?
- 14:22Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And what physics shows us?
- 14:26Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It has nothing to do with programming or Agile or anything else.
- 14:30Jeff Sutherland, PhD: What physics is shows us that these are the basic rules and, in fact, your brain has evolved to actually work this way.
- 14:40Jeff Sutherland, PhD: If you watch what you're thinking and you ought to manage in accordance with these fundamental principles things are unpredictable.
- 14:50Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You have to try things in short intervals, you have to be constantly adjusting and adapting.
- 14:56Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And going back to John Boyd's Oodleoo, that's probably one of the best explanations of this ever right that people can understand.
- 15:05Jeff Sutherland, PhD: This is the way it works in fighter aircraft in the air.
- 15:10Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So, that's my try.
- 15:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, I'm trying to get a different discussion.
- 15:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're doing the same thing, Ish, in parallel, where we talk about how neurons work, how cells work and you're very familiar with cells working with Markov blankets and the same thing that we're talking about the free energy principle in neuroscience.
- 15:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're interested in doing that too.
- 15:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we go in and we do human factors training.
- 15:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We show them a strupe test or whatever it may be that gives them an illusion, and we walk them through what does active inference look like, the free energy principle look like, so they can experience it for themselves.
- 15:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that similar to what you're trying to do when you're talking about educating leaders on how things are?
- 15:54Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Yeah, I think you're running in parallel with this.
- 15:57Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It sounds like.
- 15:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, but as you've been in this business quite a long time, you've been helping create peak performers, organizations with peak performance.
- 16:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is this a good teaching technique to show folks something that is pretty advanced when it comes to neuroscience, but bringing it back to something they can learn and see that's tangible Is that a good experience?
- 16:22Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The thing about neuroscience is what it shows now in a provable way by more and more research is that the basic principles on which the great coaches operate, the way Olympic teams was trained.
- 16:37Jeff Sutherland, PhD: When I was at West Point, the Olympic Gymnastic team trained alongside us, the.
- 16:45Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Our assistant coaches were members of the Olympic team and our head coach was the head coach of the Olympic team.
- 16:52Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So every day I would have the senior guy in the Olympic team.
- 16:58Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I was on parallel bars.
- 16:59Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The senior guy in the Olympic team on parallel bars would work with me three hours a day every day for years, and what I learned from that is that Every time you get up on the bars and do an exercise it's always wrong.
- 17:18Jeff Sutherland, PhD: But there's no judgment.
- 17:19Jeff Sutherland, PhD: There's just here's what you can do to improve that one.
- 17:23Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That improvement is endless.
- 17:28Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It just never ends.
- 17:30Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The rigor of that is something that you might experience in the Special Forces team, but most Scrum teams never have experienced the rigor of continuous improvement at the Olympic level.
- 17:46Jeff Sutherland, PhD: But the style of coaching I got is now reinforced by the neuroscience parameters I'm talking about.
- 17:57Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And so the problem with coaching is it was hard to explain how a great coach works right, because they're always working the team.
- 18:11Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're working the individual, they're working the team.
- 18:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: What they do looks unpredictable because they're trying to counteract one type of behavior and move it in a different direction.
- 18:21Jeff Sutherland, PhD: But the neuroscience principles tell us what is going on Particularly.
- 18:29Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're highly relevant to Scrum teams like the ones I talk about.
- 18:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, going on the neuroscience path, we understand a lot about psychological flow, peak performance and going back to EM theory.
- 18:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In the jet, that is peak performance for those aircrafts Coming to the merge of 350 knots altitude, wings and proper configuration Peak performance how do you get to there?
- 18:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In fighter aviation Neuroscience, we know a lot about the flow triggers and flow in a team is actually really good because it's a high-performing team.
- 19:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So my view of Scrum is you're trying to protect the team so they can focus, so they can have their shared goals, that shared risk.
- 19:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can blend those egos.
- 19:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're familiar with each other, they have that close listening.
- 19:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All those things need to merge, or actually not just emerge, but can be taught and they can be learned, because we learned that in aviation.
- 20:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just want to check with you on this Is this where Scrum should be?
- 20:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is getting those teams of peak performance in complex environments?
- 20:33Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, all of these factors are talking about peak performance.
- 20:36Jeff Sutherland, PhD: What I'm trying to do now is I don't know if you can see this, but now this is measurable.
- 20:42Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So that top line is my energy.
- 20:45Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right now I'm sitting at I'm over 75%, which is pretty good.
- 20:54Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's late in the afternoon here I'm still over 75%.
- 20:58Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I was only at 85 when I got up.
- 20:59Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And it also has a histogram of stress, and what you want to do is get the stress in the blue, and so I've learned through this.
- 21:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The health care guys have convinced me that I should develop a Scrum framework for health and performance, and these analytics come from firstbeatcom in Finland.
- 21:27Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're used to train Olympic teams and what you want to do is get the energy really high and the stress really low, Because any athlete, whether they're jumping the high bar or they're swimming or running, they're really great athletes.
- 21:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It looks effortless for them because they've removed all the impediments.
- 21:50Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And if you remove all the impediments to your personal function today we can measure in real time 24 by 7, your energy level and your stress level will be down around 5% if you have no impediments.
- 22:08Jeff Sutherland, PhD: What I've found is, if you do that, you get into a flow state where time kind of advantages and it's really easy to get stuff done.
- 22:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Absolutely.
- 22:24Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And the other thing I'm starting to talk about is actually in the MIT Sloan Review.
- 22:29Jeff Sutherland, PhD: This past week there was an article called the Eye in Team In the Agile Manifesto.
- 22:37Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It says we are interested in individuals and interactions more than process and tools.
- 22:46Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It starts with the individual, and so in a recent company meeting, everybody was not everybody, but a lot of people were complaining about sustainable pace, and so that means either the scrum is set up wrong or you're not maintaining yourself as an individual.
- 23:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So you have very high energy, very low stress and it's stable.
- 23:12Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It's a maintainable situation.
- 23:15Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And I told them I want you to put on a watch and I want to come into every retrospective and all I want to see is show me your watch, because anybody on the team that doesn't have very high energy and low stress is going to slow the team down.
- 23:33Jeff Sutherland, PhD: High performing teams are not possible without high performing individuals.
- 23:39Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Then you can talk about the interactions, and that was the point of the Sloan article.
- 23:45Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You need to train individuals for performance before you focus on the team performance.
- 23:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: OK, let's build on that.
- 23:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because, on a technical aspect, the technical skills are one thing.
- 23:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How I do my development, how I fly a jet, how I fight fires, all those things, I have to learn those technical skills.
- 24:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: On peak performance with teams, you still have to learn the interaction skills, the collaboration, what we call teaming.
- 24:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then, from our backgrounds, we ended up with what is known as crew resource management, which is the foundation of team science today.
- 24:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the team scientists, those researchers are telling us we have to learn those teaming behaviors, which can be individual behaviors, they have to be self-similar, they have to be good practices because they can always get better.
- 24:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's where, going back to the earlier point about stomping all the bad and scrum out, agile and scrum out and what's going on out in the industry, what I see is people do not take the time to learn those interactions, those skills.
- 24:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's one piece.
- 24:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The other piece is I think right now, the average person gets about 11 minutes of work done a day.
- 24:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's where we are.
- 25:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the context, the conditions that they're working in, is deteriorating their mental health, right, this is not a.
- 25:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What we're trying to do here is increase the well-being of individuals by creating the conditions and giving them the tools they need to be, I'll say, peak performers or high-performing teams.
- 25:23Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Yeah, but my I mean our background in martial arts tells us it doesn't matter what the environment is.
- 25:29Jeff Sutherland, PhD: If you have the right centeredness, the right technique and the right energy, you determine the environment.
- 25:37Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Yes, and scrum games can even do that.
- 25:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Particularly if they know where they are, what's important, and they can collaborate together, they can actually create enough force so that management has to change.
- 25:53Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And I'm talking about that now a lot with the trainers because I'm using Newtonian physics to explain it.
- 26:02Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Force equals mass times, acceleration You're trying to accelerate a team or an organization.
- 26:08Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The bigger the organization, the more force you need.
- 26:14Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Work is force applied over distance.
- 26:18Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You have to apply that force over a long period of time.
- 26:23Jeff Sutherland, PhD: This is why you need sustainable pace, and I asked one of the original XP guys how much faster was the first XP team going at a sustainable pace compared to other teams at Chrysler?
- 26:37Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And he said 52 times faster.
- 26:40Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's a stable pace for that team.
- 26:44Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So if work it was force over distance, power equals the amount of work in a given time.
- 26:57Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So to do twice the work in half the time which is what the scrum book is all about you need four times the power.
- 27:05Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right, and what I'm arguing is that we can measure this on the launch.
- 27:11Jeff Sutherland, PhD: If your energy is at 75, like mine is now, and my stress is at five, then I've got a proxy for that.
- 27:19Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Power reading is 75 divided by five.
- 27:21Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's a lot of energy to apply to the problem.
- 27:27Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And, in terms of the problem being moving an organization, that is the energy to work on removing competitors, convincing people, being like the best scrum masters.
- 27:41Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They like bulldogs, they just grab ahold of your leg and they won't let go.
- 27:47Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And that includes managers' legs.
- 27:49Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right, and that's what changes the environment.
- 27:55Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right, if you sit around like I'm just the victim, the management is so bad they're destroying everything.
- 28:00Jeff Sutherland, PhD: My health is going into the toilet and I'm just the victim.
- 28:04Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I'm going to lie down and die.
- 28:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's where a lot of people are right.
- 28:08Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So if you're not the victim, you're going to get up off the floor, you're going to power yourself up and you're going to take down the opposition.
- 28:16Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right, that's John Boyd's philosophy that works.
- 28:20Steve McCrone: So we're and that's what.
- 28:22Steve McCrone: Sorry, jeff, I like this.
- 28:25Steve McCrone: The most stressed and high-energy people in the room tend to be the managers, and that permeates particularly the stress across the team.
- 28:36Steve McCrone: It would seem to me everything you just said there is a big mismatch between the skills, knowledge and abilities of your average managerial person compared to what we've just said in respect to their ability to coach, their ability to bring the team together around that energy and minimize the stress involved.
- 28:57Steve McCrone: What needs to change?
- 29:01Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, I mean, I don't want to put all the managers in the same box, because there are some really great managers that have the energy and the insight and the power to really move organizations.
- 29:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I'm just saying a lot of the people we work with, the organization is floundering and the managers do not know the basics of Boyd's energy maneuverability, the basics of the way things work that are unpredictable.
- 29:32Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You have to work at short integrals, you have to constantly update your plan.
- 29:36Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You have to expect and adapt constantly.
- 29:39Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're not doing that.
- 29:40Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're trying to say, oh, the plan is X and I'm going to come back in six months and it better be X and 100% of the time it's not X.
- 29:50Jeff Sutherland, PhD: One of the most amazing things I found working with investors I work with a couple of different investment groups, have them for decades now.
- 29:58Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I remember when I first started with Open Adventure Partners, they'd implemented Scrum everywhere.
- 30:02Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The reason they did it is the investors said to me our biggest problem is we get in a board meeting, they present a Gantt chart when the price is going to come out, and then the financial guys put the financials on that Gantt chart and we have to make a decision as investors whether, when are they going to run out of money?
- 30:24Jeff Sutherland, PhD: When did we need to give them no money?
- 30:25Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's what we're thinking at every board meeting and we can never come up with the answer, because the Gantt charts are always wrong.
- 30:35Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And I said to the investor I said always wrong.
- 30:41Jeff Sutherland, PhD: He said yes, in 30 years I have never, ever seen a Gantt chart.
- 30:47Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I asked there were eight other investors in the room.
- 30:49Jeff Sutherland, PhD: We went to each one.
- 30:50Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Have you ever seen a correct Gantt chart?
- 30:53Jeff Sutherland, PhD: No, no, no, no, no, no, no.
- 30:56Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They are 100% wrong.
- 30:58Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So that means managers that are depending on a Gantt chart.
- 31:02Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They are totally and completely clueless.
- 31:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They are totally out of reality and they need to change their mindset and they need to change their behavior.
- 31:14Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And the only way you're gonna do it and we're gonna do it with the work we do with management teams is it has to be an emotionally powerful display of how screwed up they are and a demand that they step up and actually run a company in the way it needs to be run to be more successful.
- 31:40Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I mean, they're just not gonna change unless you're in their face.
- 31:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that Gantt chart you're talking about is a map that is developed by people who don't look outside, right.
- 31:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So go back to the free energy principle.
- 31:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That map is not reality, it's not the terrain and, worse, it's created by people that don't have the contact with the outside environment.
- 32:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I agree with you that is a fundamental problem.
- 32:04Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Even if they do have the contact, you could create a Gantt chart that is correct given the information at this instance and it's gonna be wrong by eight o'clock tomorrow morning.
- 32:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right, the same thing with the map.
- 32:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When we build a map, it's in a complex environment.
- 32:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's gonna be wrong the moment we take another step right.
- 32:21Steve McCrone: Yeah, yeah.
- 32:22Steve McCrone: So in uncertainty, to use the phrase, we have three options suppress it, ignore it or adapt to it.
- 32:31Steve McCrone: And it seems to me that suppressing and ignoring have been the favorite methods.
- 32:38Steve McCrone: And now what we're talking about is adapting to the reality of the world, as opposed to suppressing it through the Gantt chart or any other predictive model.
- 32:46Steve McCrone: Right, that adaptation takes an amount of moral courage.
- 32:51Steve McCrone: You're standing up to the conventional wisdom.
- 32:53Steve McCrone: You're standing up to those who refuse to believe the Gantt chart's wrong.
- 32:57Steve McCrone: We just need a better chart, jeff.
- 32:59Steve McCrone: We just need more detail.
- 33:00Steve McCrone: That seems to me to be the hurdle.
- 33:04Steve McCrone: It's certainly the one that I encounter the most, and I think your passionate pleaser is like get in their face.
- 33:11Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's why we have the scrum values right, openness and transparency, respect for people so they will be open and then courage to state the truth.
- 33:22Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And I remember I was talking to ING Bank.
- 33:30Jeff Sutherland, PhD: If you remember, they implemented the Spotify model many years ago and a company I worked with was we're doing a lot of the training in there.
- 33:37Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They would bring me in and I remember I had 40 trainers in the room asking how they could be better trainers and I said you need to not tell people what to do, but reflect the reality of what's going on, because I met with a lot of teams today and a lot of them are not doing very well and unless you expose that clearly to them so that they actually have an emotional effect, they're not gonna change.
- 34:11Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And that means that you need to have the personal power to confront them with the truth.
- 34:19Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And those 40 trainers were shocked that that was their mission, because they'd been dodging and avoiding that.
- 34:31Steve McCrone: So Actually you can see that in a lot of government agencies where people are actually insulating themselves from the emotional response of their decisions or of the reality of the world.
- 34:43Steve McCrone: So I think that's it.
- 34:45Steve McCrone: Yeah, I remember, I mean this reminds me again.
- 34:48Jeff Sutherland, PhD: coming back to the Air Force, I was asked to be with the head of maintenance and support for the US Air Force right, all the aircraft of the Air Force and I said I know what your problem is.
- 34:59Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You're supposed to have 80% readiness and you only have 40% readiness and you want more budget next year and the brass wants you to cut your budget.
- 35:10Jeff Sutherland, PhD: She said that's absolutely right.
- 35:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I said if you could do twice the work in half the time which the Scrum book is all about, your problem would go away.
- 35:21Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And she said my challenge is, in order to do that, I have to fire half of my commanders.
- 35:31Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I said well, you have a choice.
- 35:36Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You can either sit in your seat and do nothing, waiting for a retirement or another assignment, or you can actually be a leader.
- 35:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's hard to do, right In today's context.
- 35:56Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Not many people want to know At West Point, the leaders they put in front of us get it all the time.
- 36:01Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Yeah.
- 36:04Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The leaders they put in us were.
- 36:05Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I mean, obviously General Patton wasn't alive when I was there, but the people they put in front of us were like General Patton, and he took no prisoners, sorry, not even as his own forces.
- 36:21Jeff Sutherland, PhD: If they were not doing what needed to be done, including his own commanders, they were working someplace else in a hurry.
- 36:31Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's leadership.
- 36:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You get the right people in the right place and you do not tolerate dysfunction?
- 36:40Steve McCrone: It seems to me, jeff, particularly in the last few years, people have been abdicating leadership responsibility in the way that you've just described leadership.
- 36:50Steve McCrone: Now they don't want to be in that place.
- 36:52Steve McCrone: That gap has been filled by what we refer to as the merchants of certainty that have created formulaic approach to agile, formulaic approach to strategy, formulaic approach to organizational development.
- 37:03Steve McCrone: That's a great sound.
- 37:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I like that.
- 37:07Steve McCrone: That's.
- 37:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Diego.
- 37:09Steve McCrone: Espinosa's phrase, and I thank him for it.
- 37:12Steve McCrone: How do we stop that happening again?
- 37:14Steve McCrone: How do we stop the merchants of certainty coming in and taking the free energy principle, the Oodaloo, the complex adaptive systems theory, the stuff that we are very passionate about, and creating formulas?
- 37:29Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I think one of the things we're doing at Scrum Inc is trying to upscale all the trainers and coaches to operate at a higher level.
- 37:39Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So, for example, we've worked with some of the big consultancies like Bain has been a partner for us for years and those guys are very good at going in with a slide deck at the management level and they can convince anybody of anything and their logic is impeccable.
- 37:57Jeff Sutherland, PhD: But many of the agile coaches they're down there working at the team level.
- 38:02Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're not able to really talk to the management and make the case in a way that really communicates.
- 38:09Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So we need to have those of us who are really agile need to be better at explaining to management than you know, the merchants of certainty or whatever the phrase was.
- 38:29Steve McCrone: They have a.
- 38:30Steve McCrone: The merchants of certainty have a big marketing budget.
- 38:33Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And after produce results.
- 38:35Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So like we have two really good case studies here right now with with rocket mortgage and John Deere I think you probably have seen both of them Both of those companies did say for 10 years For those 10 years John Deere stock price didn't budge.
- 38:53Jeff Sutherland, PhD: We came in and implemented scrum at scale, which focuses on prioritizing the impediments in the organization and implementing a clean, effective scrum, and John Deere stock price goes up almost 400% one year.
- 39:09Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Those are the kind of results that convinced management that they should change their behavior.
- 39:17Steve McCrone: Yeah, good, I mean, one of our favorite sayings at AGLX is we're not going to change the world by educating people.
- 39:24Steve McCrone: We change the world by doing good work with good clients, and I think that's a great example.
- 39:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, Jeff, there's been a lot of folks writing on LinkedIn lately that agile's dead or dying.
- 39:36Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You know, that's what I get your take on.
- 39:38Jeff Sutherland, PhD: People were saying agile's dead 20 years ago.
- 39:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 39:42Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You know the universe is agile and the minute you take the eye off that ball, the John Boyds of the world are going to take you out.
- 39:53Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's not only you they're going to take your whole company out.
- 39:55Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Do you know?
- 39:56Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The 75% of companies are dead by the time they're 15 years old, and that is going to accelerate.
- 40:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Ai is going to cut that at least in half.
- 40:08Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So, whatever company you're in, you have a window of seven years or less to radically change your behavior or you are going to die.
- 40:19Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right that, that is the reality.
- 40:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's the second law right.
- 40:26Jeff Sutherland, PhD: If you think you could not be non agile and survive, you have been smoking pot in the back room too much.
- 40:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let me ask you this you go back to the agile manifesto and you're right in there.
- 40:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That it's.
- 40:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're searching for better ways, right?
- 40:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You've been at this for a while.
- 40:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where have the better ways come from?
- 40:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are you seeing over the last 22 years of agile?
- 40:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's what's working in your mind?
- 40:53Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I think the most agile company in the world today is Tesla Okay, with SpaceX a close second and the reason is they have they have implemented complex adaptive systems theory.
- 41:05Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They have autonomous teams collaborating together towards a common goal.
- 41:10Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That goal is constantly manifested on screens on the assembly line in the company.
- 41:18Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You can see exactly what's going on all the time and the team swarm to make those numbers go up Right and they're on a mission to change the way the world uses energy and and there are a thousand times faster than Ford has been historically.
- 41:39Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So we we have emerging a really full implementation in a way of what scrum was kind of the starter kit, right To get to get to that level.
- 41:57Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Google and Amazon and Apple have done some of the same thing.
- 42:04Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So we have a great company.
- 42:05Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You go down the list of the top 100 companies.
- 42:07Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Anyone that is, any of them that's a technical company is agile.
- 42:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You can't today get the top 100 companies as a technical organization without being agile.
- 42:23Steve McCrone: So I guess to the comments on LinkedIn about agile dying, what I see is a growing gap between agile done well to the principles of complex systems theory and then agile done to a formulaic process.
- 42:42Steve McCrone: I copying someone else's agile experience and expecting that same thing to work the same way for you.
- 42:47Steve McCrone: Is that true?
- 42:50Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I think this is.
- 42:51Jeff Sutherland, PhD: This kind of talk is really old thinking.
- 42:53Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right now, the analysts are saying on the average, the whole industry is twice productive this year as last year.
- 43:02Jeff Sutherland, PhD: 46% of the people in GitHub are using Microsoft co-pilot to write most of their code.
- 43:10Jeff Sutherland, PhD: By 2030, the analysts are saying, the technology will evolve so that the teams are at least 30 times faster and maybe 100 times faster.
- 43:25Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So I would say to these people that are worried about agile being dead how are you going to get 100 times faster in the next six years?
- 43:35Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Because if you don't, you're going to be out of business.
- 43:39Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So if you don't like the word agile, come up with something else that's going to make you 100 times faster.
- 43:46Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Let's talk about that, because we're wasting our time talking about agile is dead when you're going to get crushed like you're going to be run over by a steamroller called AI with teams running 100 times faster.
- 44:00Jeff Sutherland, PhD: We are in a state of emergency Wake up people.
- 44:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's great.
- 44:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is why I think you're going back to first principles and going back to the early part of the conversation about going after that gut, going after that emotion to show people how things actually work and your first principles In one way.
- 44:23Jeff Sutherland, PhD: To me, agile doesn't matter, Scrum doesn't matter.
- 44:26Jeff Sutherland, PhD: What matters is computational irreducibility, which says everything is unpredictable.
- 44:35Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Now I'm really working on the entropy issue, because entropy is all about things falling apart to disintegrating, becoming random.
- 44:44Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's happening faster and faster.
- 44:47Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That means companies, instead of taking 15 years to die, are only going to take seven years to die in the near future.
- 44:54Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Everybody particularly manages.
- 44:58Jeff Sutherland, PhD: What are you doing about that?
- 45:00Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I don't care if you talk about agile.
- 45:05Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I want to talk about how you survive by being 30 to 100 times faster than you are today.
- 45:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That is the challenge in front of us as business people.
- 45:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Jeff, I want to talk about the connection to the military.
- 45:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Don Rynardson has a background in the US Navy.
- 45:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have the great book Team of Teams by General McChrystal, your work in Scrum.
- 45:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Talk to us, Walk us through what exactive lessons are really working from the military thinking that you're seeing, if any, I'll build on this more.
- 45:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have high reliability theory that's grown into resilience engineering that's underpinning DevOps, the culture of DevOps.
- 45:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have human and nervous performance, which is built on a lot of these things as well from the military.
- 45:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why are the lessons from the military so important in today's business industry?
- 46:01Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, right now one of Scrum's biggest customers is the British Navy, the Royal Navy, because the first sea lord brought us in there and said we need to move faster.
- 46:18Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The bad guys are moving faster than we are.
- 46:21Jeff Sutherland, PhD: He said we're going to start at the top.
- 46:25Jeff Sutherland, PhD: We're doing our planning for the next 10 years.
- 46:28Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It's usually really painful.
- 46:30Jeff Sutherland, PhD: We're going to use Scrum to execute the plan.
- 46:33Jeff Sutherland, PhD: When that came in faster than anybody ever expected, they said now we're going to roll this out to all the forces.
- 46:40Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Then he got promoted and he owns not only a big chunk but part of the civilian military operations.
- 46:51Jeff Sutherland, PhD: He started to spread it throughout the organization.
- 46:55Jeff Sutherland, PhD: They're asking us we need to go faster.
- 46:58Jeff Sutherland, PhD: One of the latest things they're asking us the man-machine interface.
- 47:04Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Today all our forces are now an aircraft.
- 47:08Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It's a man coupled with a machine.
- 47:10Jeff Sutherland, PhD: With the rise of AI, they want to know how can they use AI to better implement Scrum and also better to implement the man-machine interfaces.
- 47:24Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Basically, how to go faster, be more adaptable.
- 47:29Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Execute John Boyd's loop at a significantly faster pace is their goal.
- 47:36Jeff Sutherland, PhD: On the one hand, they have this huge bureaucracy that they have to move out of the way.
- 47:47Jeff Sutherland, PhD: On the other hand, they're really serious, just like a martial artist.
- 47:51Jeff Sutherland, PhD: We have to move with more power and strength.
- 47:55Jeff Sutherland, PhD: We have to do it faster.
- 47:56Jeff Sutherland, PhD: We're learning a lot from them.
- 48:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's interesting.
- 48:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Today I had to answer a question for a client on human-machine teaming.
- 48:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The way I did it was through the OODA loop and some work that Steven and I did a few years ago with Dave Snowden, really emphasizing the strengths of machines and the strengths of humans.
- 48:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you understand that, you'll understand that you need to keep the human in the system.
- 48:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I want to come back to something on EM Theory here.
- 48:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is interesting EM Theory.
- 48:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When John Boyd created that and this is going back to Vietnam, he was running around the country telling everybody F4 should not fight a MiG-21 based on the paper.
- 48:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: On paper, they should not fight each other.
- 48:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Our weapons school, our fighter weapons school, said wait a minute, you're forgetting about one thing the person in the cockpit.
- 48:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We get the math, we get the numbers and all that, but once you put that person in that system it's a complex adaptive system now, but a crew in there, they can do things, they can fight now because they have their mind.
- 48:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is what we're going with.
- 48:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Human machine teaming is there are strengths in the complicated system that when you add a person to it, machines do things better than humans in computations, things like that faster, and there are things that humans do.
- 49:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is more important now than ever before is understanding everything.
- 49:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You just pointed out that you have got to understand how to get peak performance not only out of your human systems, but your socio-technical systems, your human machine teaming, right, absolutely.
- 49:28Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I mean, I tell people, look at the Starship Enterprise.
- 49:31Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Can the captain get the enterprise out of the dock without the computer?
- 49:35Jeff Sutherland, PhD: No, you can't even get out of the dock, and that's probably true with some of our airplanes which two of our airplanes as well?
- 49:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You can't even get out to the runway without the computer, right, right, right.
- 49:48Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And a lot of people don't understand that, even though everything they do today is largely around computers and stuff like that, like we're talking now on Zoom or on Riverside.
- 50:01Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So take that another level and look at what happened when the computer became the world chess champion.
- 50:14Jeff Sutherland, PhD: One year later, a team of people with laptops, with AI and the laptops, beat the computer world champion.
- 50:25Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And a few years later, the same thing happened with Go.
- 50:29Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It's as the military says, it's the man-machine collaboration that wins.
- 50:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right and then adding scrum to this.
- 50:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Going forward, you have to have those feedback loops, which you're still gonna have, machines that are, like you pointed out, your watch earlier.
- 50:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's, to me, human-machine teaming.
- 50:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's getting some information that we just don't have access to right.
- 50:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you still have to use the machines to understand the context, the environment, use that feedback and build on that to improve future performance, which, to me, is still using scrum.
- 51:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you will plan brief, execute, debrief.
- 51:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Plan execute, assess, framework.
- 51:11Jeff Sutherland, PhD: A really interesting happened to be some years ago in Zurich, where a guy from the IBM Research Lab in Zurich came to one of my classes or one of the events we had, and he says you know?
- 51:23Jeff Sutherland, PhD: He says the supercomputers are gonna be running scrum.
- 51:28Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And I said what do you mean?
- 51:32Jeff Sutherland, PhD: How do you know it was gonna work?
- 51:34Jeff Sutherland, PhD: He said if it works in people, it's gonna work in the computer.
- 51:36Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And I said well, to have a dynamically changing backlog, the chips are gonna have to run differently.
- 51:41Jeff Sutherland, PhD: He says oh yeah, you need a special kind of chip.
- 51:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: He says we already have prototypes of chips that will dynamically rearrange backlog in the supercomputers we're building.
- 51:53Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So you know, in one sense, the basics of scrum are gonna be a common language between the machines and the people.
- 52:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and then to me you know I don't like taking anything away from scrum we use it quite often in the right context.
- 52:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The scrum is, in my view, is a plan, execute, assess.
- 52:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a cadence of accountability.
- 52:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: To do anything has all these awesome things in it, and I see people attacking it all the time.
- 52:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, hey, I don't know if you know, but all good teams, all great teams, they plan, execute, assess.
- 52:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It doesn't get any easier than that, right?
- 52:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's how they do that, though, it's how they communicate, it's how they create the goals, it's how the context it's created for them, how the impediments are removed, and I think that's what matters, right.
- 52:44Steve McCrone: And I think also that's why, in my new book.
- 52:47Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I mean, I'm mentioning scrum, constantly pointing back to it, but I'm talking constantly about physics, about neuroscience, about complex adaptive systems.
- 52:54Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's where scrum is.
- 52:58Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Any methodology or any framework is a higher level of abstraction, trying to address fundamental principles.
- 53:08Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So I'm trying to show there are six levels of abstraction.
- 53:14Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I talk about my book.
- 53:15Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Agile is at the top.
- 53:17Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The Agile values are just a summary of a huge amount of stuff beneath it.
- 53:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, hey, jeff, I know we're gonna wrap up here in a few minutes.
- 53:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Some of the things that we're working on are connecting a lot of the lessons from Agile, if you will, to human and organizational performance.
- 53:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What we see is go back to the free energy principle.
- 53:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do we reduce the energy individual spend on trying to understand these different initiatives in their organization?
- 53:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's where you're going with your first principles, your writing and all that is.
- 53:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you make that a lot easier?
- 53:47Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, what I've learned from healthcare.
- 53:49Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I'm running a healthcare company now with scrum and putting together a scrum framework to radically improve your health by iterating quickly.
- 54:01Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Yeah, high energy and low stress is basically the only two things that matters.
- 54:07Jeff Sutherland, PhD: If you can't, I don't care if you're an 80 year old person that can't get out of bed or a 22 year old marathon runner.
- 54:15Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The only thing that matters is getting your doubling the energy that you have and cutting your stress in half.
- 54:23Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That's what will make you win a marathon and that's what will get you out of bed in the morning.
- 54:29Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right?
- 54:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, you've been writing a little bit about Buddhism in your book too, and then Eastern philosophies.
- 54:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We picked up a lot of meditation, breath work here to get in that peak performance as an individual.
- 54:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I see the parallels of what you're doing.
- 54:47Jeff Sutherland, PhD: What I've found is my doc actually gave me a prescription Jeff, you need to meditate 15 minutes every day, same place, same time.
- 54:56Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I see you.
- 54:58Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I took my watch and then I figured out okay, what is going to double my energy and cut my stress in half?
- 55:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: How is that meditation going to do that?
- 55:08Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And I found that it's been for me.
- 55:12Steve McCrone: Jeff, sorry, I asked you a question.
- 55:13Steve McCrone: It seems to me we're talking about AI augmenting human decision making, and I read your article on Buddhism and it seems to me that there's a real focus there of embedding ethical decision making within the framework of optimization for teams and outcomes, and this is particularly relevant, I guess, in the military and in healthcare at the moment.
- 55:36Steve McCrone: You get a comment on that.
- 55:40Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, I think it really is all about entropy, things decaying into randomness, everything breaking down.
- 55:51Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It's not only what Joad Boyd tries to create through the uter loop, but when you go into battle, that's what happens on the battlefield right away.
- 56:00Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Right, klausowitz talks about the fog of war.
- 56:03Jeff Sutherland, PhD: People get killed, lots of smoke and rumors floating and people are afraid.
- 56:09Jeff Sutherland, PhD: All this stuff, everything is disintegrated into entropy.
- 56:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And the interesting thing to me is for somebody who's not only studied but practiced Tibetan Buddhism for 50 years of war, is that this is the problem that the Buddha was wrestling with.
- 56:25Jeff Sutherland, PhD: He was confronted with people getting sick, getting old and dying.
- 56:30Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And if you now study the literature coming out of Harvard, you realize, now that we have the technology, that you don't have to get sick, you don't have to get old and you don't even have to die.
- 56:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And if you look at how that technology works, it gives you a lot of insight into how the businesses work and how the OODA loop works, because the human performance is getting, particularly in the military, in flying, a lot of human performance is strength, energy, power, focus, right.
- 57:13Jeff Sutherland, PhD: That is fundamental to fighter pilot and if you don't have that, you can't even get through fighter pilot training.
- 57:20Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You have to have a really high level of that even to get through the training.
- 57:26Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And this, a lot of this focus, is dependent on the cellular performance of the cells in your body and as you get older they start to lose track of the original blueprint.
- 57:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: It's kind of like a DVD that gets scratches on it All of a sudden.
- 57:50Jeff Sutherland, PhD: The sound is funny and the video is clouded, and that's what you experience.
- 57:57Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You don't want to experience that in an aircraft in common, right, but as you get older you do.
- 58:03Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And what David Sinclair at Lab at Harvard has shown us that every cell actually has an original blueprint and you can cause the cell to look at that and reset.
- 58:20Jeff Sutherland, PhD: And that is the most amazing thing that science has found Error.
- 58:30Steve McCrone: I think the insurance we think.
- 58:33Jeff Sutherland, PhD: AI is going to change things.
- 58:34Jeff Sutherland, PhD: When the 60-year-old general can start flying around like a 22-year-old fighter pilot, it's going to be a really different world we're living in.
- 58:48Steve McCrone: The health insurance industry call that the actuarial escape velocity.
- 58:53Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Yeah, absolutely Escaping your life insurance.
- 58:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, Jeff, I want to again thank you for not only being here today, but everything you did for getting us going, giving us the positive reinforcement ideas.
- 59:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Many years ago we reconnected again when the book came out.
- 59:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're already doing twice the work and half the time.
- 59:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Back in 2014, you and I and some other members, we looked at the daily standup.
- 59:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You changed the scrum guide.
- 59:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the relationships.
- 59:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We just worked with you at Scrum, at Scale.
- 59:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Everything you've done for not only our country but for businesses all around the world.
- 59:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just want to thank you.
- 59:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's fantastic to have you on the show.
- 59:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's good to have you on a Rolodex to give you a call and ask questions and see what's going on Again.
- 59:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just, I can't thank you enough for being here today.
- 59:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to turn it over to you to see if you have anything that you want to.
- 59:44Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Well, it's really great to connect up with you again.
- 59:49Jeff Sutherland, PhD: I just want to say I think we are at a time in history that is pivotal.
- 59:54Jeff Sutherland, PhD: There is more technology change going on than ever in history, and in another five years, the world is going to be a totally different place, and one of the things I really feel about Scrum and its value set is we need to train these AI to move into a positive place, because the alternative we don't want a Terminator scenario for the planet, and so what we're talking about here, particularly from the agile value side of things we need to work with these computers and get them thinking in the positive way that we've, the positive way and the human centered way that we try to create in the agile community.
- 1:00:43Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So I think we all those of us here and all of us in the agile work have a great responsibility right now, in the midst of the biggest change that's ever happened on the planet.
- 1:00:56Jeff Sutherland, PhD: So that's what gets me jumping out of bed every morning like trying to make it.
- 1:01:03Jeff Sutherland, PhD: You know, let's take, let's take whatever.
- 1:01:06Jeff Sutherland, PhD: Whatever good we've done so far with agile, let's take it to the next level.
- 1:01:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Couldn't agree with you anymore, steve.
- 1:01:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any last comments.
- 1:01:14Steve McCrone: No, I think that's a really good way to end it.
- 1:01:15Steve McCrone: I think let's take that to the next level.
- 1:01:18Steve McCrone: Cheers Right, thank you.