Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Are nicotine pouches, like ZYN, actually good for you? (Dr. Michael Schwandt)
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Welcome back to this as Van Color. You may have heard
- 0:10of the government of British Columbia introducing new rules around the sale of nicotine pouches
- 0:16such as Zen and Zonic. These increasingly popular products will now be put behind
- 0:21the counters of pharmacies in order to be out of reach for miners. But
- 0:26social media influencers, including Tucker Carlson, say that nicotine pouches are not only
- 0:32safe but good for you. More moderate voices don't go that far, but
- 0:36they say that nicotine pouches as a form of harm reduction can be an effective
- 0:41way to quit smoking. Here to give us his scientific insights is our featured
- 0:46guest, our researcher, public health physician and Vancouver Coastal Health Medical health officer,
- 0:52doctor Michael Schwant. And this conversation is supported by Shelter Point single malt
- 0:57whiskey, distinctly Vancouver Island and equally Shelter Points. So doctor Schwant, I'm
- 1:06on TikTok and a lot of these influencers are saying that nicotine pouches, particularly
- 1:11Zin, are good for you. So before we get into the nicotine pouches,
- 1:15let's talk about nicotine itself. I've heard that it increases cognitive ability.
- 1:19I've heard that it boosts testosterone. So is nicotine by itself actually good for
- 1:25you? We don't have a lot of great evidence for these claims. This
- 1:29is something that continues to be researched. What is known about nicotine very closely
- 1:33is it can be extremely addictive. So we see that rapidly and even with
- 1:37pretty small doses, that people can become physically dependent on nicotine and they can
- 1:41have long term addictions related to that, and that can come with withdrawal symptoms
- 1:45too, So headaches are even changes in mood when we withdraw from a substance
- 1:49like that. Interesting, and is that because nicotine basically gives you a dopamine
- 1:53hit, and so when you're addicted to something, the things that give you
- 1:57pleasure or dopamine actually start to narrow. Well, you've nailed it. It's
- 2:00really closely tied to what we call the rewards circuits in terms of our neurology.
- 2:06So this is a behavior that's extremely rewarding for the brain for the for
- 2:08our experience, but also when it's withdrawn can be come with its challenges.
- 2:13Okay, so now let's talk about nicotine pouches. Can you explain what exactly
- 2:16they are, because it's not chewing tobacco, it's something that's actually quite new,
- 2:22right, Yeah, this could really be described as a nicotine delivery system.
- 2:24So these pouches, we have synthetic nicotine. This is not tobacco leaves,
- 2:30but just nicotine powder, usually within a small pouch. And this can
- 2:34be held between the gums and the upper lip or the cheek, so you
- 2:38will have this constant delivery of nicotine right into the bloodstream. And many of
- 2:44these come with different flavors, so you'll see some of them marketed under flavor
- 2:46names like chill mint or cool Breeze, things like that. So they're meant
- 2:52to they're meant to be a pleasurable experience as well as delivering it, right,
- 2:54And I feel like those flavors mean that it's targeting kids, right.
- 2:59Yeah. It's challenging to say exactly what the intent of this marketing is,
- 3:02but we know that the effect of it from the recent history with vaping is
- 3:07that some of these flavored products, the way that they're positioned in retail and
- 3:10other factors like that can have an effect of impacting on reach to children.
- 3:16And youth. Okay, So again going back to TikTok, I'm seeing all
- 3:20these influencers and including some notable public personalities like Tucker Carlson, talk about how
- 3:24great these nicotine pouches are because of those reasons that I gave you, that
- 3:29they spur cognitive ability or whatever else. And they say that it doesn't come
- 3:32with the harms of smoking or even vaping. So what are the health risks
- 3:37associated with nicotine pouches such as zonic or z in And it's a really important
- 3:40point that's made there that most of the health harms from smoking cigarettes come from
- 3:45the combustion of tobacco, so lung cancer, heart disease, respiratory conditions,
- 3:51things that affect the lungs. We know that that's really from burning cigarettes and
- 3:54inhaling those heated vapors. So there is I think the realistic assertion that some
- 4:02of these other nicotine products can avoid some of those harms. But in the
- 4:05meantime, we know, especially for you, that nicotine exposure can have impacts
- 4:11on the developing rain. Oh. It can lead in some cases to difficulty
- 4:15concentrating, difficulty with memories. This is very important during learning, of course,
- 4:19and having that effect as well, as I'd mentioned on physical dependence and
- 4:24withdrawal can be very impactful for young people because of the experiencing headaches, dizziness,
- 4:29low mood when withdrawing from nicotine. This can be very it can be
- 4:31very challenging. But I'm an adult, so it's probably good for me right,
- 4:35or at least safe. Well, I think that most of the impacts
- 4:40that have been described, I think, well the local irritation that can occur,
- 4:44so sometimes it could be described as relatively minor compared to smoking cigarettes,
- 4:47so irritation of the gums of the inside of the mouth. In short.
- 4:53Longer term research hasn't really been done because these are close to brand new products.
- 4:58We know that tobacco products do have of impacts in terms of mouth counters
- 5:01of the mouth and throat, but these newer products aren't just well characterized,
- 5:04so we just don't really know what the longer term effects will be. Interesting
- 5:08now, one thing I've heard is that these nicotine pouches often have aspertain in
- 5:12them, so the way you're absorbing them through your gums, it's not actually
- 5:15being digested through the normal system, which means that we don't actually know what
- 5:19the results may be of consuming aspertain in that regard. Is that a fair
- 5:24concern. Yeah, it's a good point that these new products, these new
- 5:27delivery modes for nicotine just aren't really well aren't really well studied in terms of
- 5:30the potential health impacts. They're relatively new products, so we just don't know
- 5:34those longer term impacts. We do know that a big part of their design
- 5:38is just that rapid delivery of nicotine, because of course these products, when
- 5:42they have that rapid onset of nicotine in the system, that reward, as
- 5:47we mentioned in that addictive effect. Now in broad strokes, how would you
- 5:50characterize the health risks associated with smoking, cigarettes, vaping, and then these
- 5:57nicotine pouches. Oh, I would say quite clearly, smoking by far is
- 6:00going to be the most impactful. So you're going to have that whole suite
- 6:04of health impacts that are really well known at this point, multiple different forms
- 6:09of cancer impacts, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, a higher rate of heart disease,
- 6:15so many different which we've known for decades, which is known for a
- 6:17long time, and a lot of that is again specific to the burning,
- 6:21the combustion of tobacco and some of the additives that are in cigarettes. So
- 6:26a lot of that is going to be avoided by other nicotine delivery systems,
- 6:30but that key element, that risk of physical dependence and of addiction remains because
- 6:36this is an addictive substance. Do we know the health risks associated with vaping
- 6:41as well, because some people see that as a safer alternative to smoking cigarettes.
- 6:46Yeah, and I would say that vaping is definitely going to be lower
- 6:47risk than smoking cigarettes. I think this has been something we have some years
- 6:51of experience with right now. But again, when you're looking at that really
- 6:56superheated substances inhaling that directly, it's not without health impacts. We have seen
- 7:00descriptions of injury to the airways, injury to the lungs in some cases.
- 7:04So it's not without risk, but it's I think we need to be candid
- 7:09that this is safer than smoking cigarettes. Now, when it comes to the
- 7:12ban here in BC, I shouldn't call it a ban, but a restriction.
- 7:15In terms of the point of sale of zonic and zin and these nicotine
- 7:19pouches. There are a lot of people that say, hey, these nicotine
- 7:23pouches are actually great harm reduction tools for people to quit smoking. So the
- 7:28idea is just like you would use nicorette gum instead of smoking, you would
- 7:30now use these pouches and then ideally you know transition off of those. Is
- 7:36there a role for nicotine pouches in terms of harm reduction or being able to
- 7:41quit smoking, which, as you just said, has higher risks. Yeah,
- 7:44and these products like Zonic have been approved as natural health products by Health
- 7:47Canada. They're in an interest natural sounds all good, right, They're in
- 7:51an interesting space because they have a low amount of nicotine relative to cigarettes or
- 7:57vaping products. They're not inhaled, so they're not captured by the tobacco and
- 8:01vaping regulations that manage where we can buy tobacco vaping products, where those can
- 8:05be sold. I should say, the issue right now is managing in a
- 8:09balanced way where these nicotine pouches can be accessed. So for adults who might
- 8:16choose to use those, as they have been approved for reducing or quitting cigarette
- 8:22smoking, they can be accessed right now behind the counter in pharmacies, so
- 8:26you need to interact with the pharmacists to get them, rather than on the
- 8:30shelves of convenience stores. We had early observation and this is the case in
- 8:33most provinces of Canada right now, that these are inconvenience stores, gas stations,
- 8:37potentially between the chocolate bars and the chips, and as you might have
- 8:41seen, they are basically in containers that look more or less like a tin
- 8:46of mints or gout. So the idea is that they should not be in
- 8:50spaces where young people who are not using them in many cases to quit smoking,
- 8:54but using it as their first and only exposure to nicotine, potentially restricting
- 8:58that acts while still allowing adults to use it for the purpose for which can
- 9:03miner still buy nicotine pouches if they go to their local pharmacy and talk to
- 9:07a pharmacist. Yeah, it's an important point in BC. The regulation allows
- 9:11miners to they need to talk to a pharmacist about why. So a pharmacist
- 9:15would ask, as they would for some other products that are behind the counter,
- 9:16what you need this for, what's your intended use? So realistically,
- 9:20some miners are trying to get off of cigarettes, and we would applaud that,
- 9:24and so if this is a product that works for them, that's something
- 9:28that they could access but it would involve the interaction with a pharmacist, with
- 9:31their judgment, their expertise, and create a pretty fair amount of friction if
- 9:35we're honest, between a potential recreational use and the product while allowing somebody to
- 9:41use it for it's for the purpose that it's been licensed for. So in
- 9:43conclusion, what I'm hearing is nictine pouches may be a great tool for quitting
- 9:48smoking, but you definitely don't want to just start consuming nicotine by taking these
- 9:54nicotine pouches. Yeah, I think that the evidence for these as potential quitting
- 9:58tools is still coming in. I think that we'll see how these go over
- 10:01time. We know, unfortunately from vaping, that hundreds of thousands of Canadians
- 10:05now use vaping as their first and only exposure to make a team products,
- 10:09so they started to vate rather than using it as a quitting tool, now
- 10:13a product of habitual use. So definitely we would not recommend that adults or
- 10:20children in youth should begin to use these products recreationally. Extremely addictive and the
- 10:24harms are at this point still unknown. Fascinating Doctor Schwan, Thank you so
- 10:28much for clearing up all the TikTok pseudo signs that I've learned. I appreciate
- 10:33your time tonight. It's a pleasure mom. Absolutely, folks. That was
- 10:35Vancouver Coastal Health Medical Health Officer doctor Michael Schwant. Thank you to Shelter Point
- 10:41Single Malt Whiskey for supporting local conversations. Now after a little business, are
- 10:46protest getting too toxic? I have some thoughts up next