Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Why Elites May Have Destroyed Alexandria's Most Dangerous Knowledge
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever wondered if the greatest repository of ancient
- 0:03knowledge was deliberately torched to erase secrets that
- 0:07could change the world forever? Stay tuned into the mystery of
- 0:12the Library of Alexandria. Welcome back to the Jeremy Ryan
- 0:32Slate show. I'm your host Jeremy Ryan Slate,
- 0:35the CEO and Co founder of Command Your Brand.
- 0:39We help our clients to make the biggest impact on the biggest
- 0:42podcast. Get our free podcast guesting
- 0:45resource over at commandyourempire.com.
- 0:49Reminder if you're brand new to this channel to like this video,
- 0:51leave us a comment or smash that subscribe button.
- 0:55And today we're unraveling one of history's greatest tragedies,
- 1:01the mystery of the Library of Alexandria.
- 1:05Was it a history erased? Well, if you're like me with a
- 1:09podcast background where I've interviewed historians,
- 1:13politicians and the like, you know these stories aren't just
- 1:16about dusty books. They're about power, control,
- 1:21and what gets hidden from us. So picture this.
- 1:25In the 3rd century BC, in the vibrant city of Alexandria,
- 1:30Egypt, a library rises up holding up to 700,000 scrolls.
- 1:35The sum of human knowledge, from math to medicine, philosophy to
- 1:40poetry. Then, over centuries, it's
- 1:44destroyed by fire, war, or decree.
- 1:48For ages we've asked accident or an intentional erasure.
- 1:54Did rulers burn it to suppress dangerous ideas like advanced
- 1:59tech or forbidden truths? And here's why I find this
- 2:02fascinating. As someone who always pursued
- 2:06historical angles with a conspiratorial blend, the
- 2:09Library of Alexandria represents the ultimate What if in history?
- 2:14What knowledge was lost that could have accelerated humanity,
- 2:19and who benefited from its disappearance?
- 2:23Today, we'll dive deep into verifiable history, names,
- 2:26dates, places from sources like Britannica, Live Science, and
- 2:31World History Encyclopedia, while blending plausible
- 2:35conspiracies that'll make you question official narratives.
- 2:41We're going to keep it as balanced as possible, grounded
- 2:43as much in history as we can, but also spark imagination and
- 2:48stick around because modern scholarship might reveal if any
- 2:53remnants still survive or the erasure was total.
- 2:57This episode's pays for a thorough explanation, so stay
- 3:01tuned. All right.
- 3:02To understand the Library of Alexandria, we have to go back
- 3:07to the aftermath of Alexander the Great's conquest.
- 3:12Alexander, the Macedonian king born in 356 BC and died in 323
- 3:18BC in Babylon, leaving his empire to the his generals.
- 3:23On his deathbed, when asked who he left his empire to, he said
- 3:28the strongest, which could have been his biggest mistake.
- 3:31One of them, Ptolemy the First Sotair, a childhood friend and a
- 3:36trusted commander, seized Egypt and founded the Ptolemaic
- 3:40dynasty in three O 5 BC. He declared himself pharaoh,
- 3:45ruling from Alexandria, the city Alexander founded in 331 BC on
- 3:51the Mediterranean coast near the Nile Delta.
- 3:54Ptolemy, the First, ruling until 282 BC, envisioned a center of
- 3:59learning to legitimize his Greek rule over Egypt and attract
- 4:03scholars. He established the museum,
- 4:07dedicated to the Muses, Greek goddesses of the Arts and
- 4:11Sciences, as a Research Institute.
- 4:15The library was part of this, likely starting around 290 BC
- 4:20under his son Ptolemy the Second Philadelphus, who ruled from 283
- 4:25to 246 BC. The Ptolemy is aimed for
- 4:29universal knowledge, collecting scrolls from across the known
- 4:34world. Ships docking in Alexandria's
- 4:37harbor were searched, books found were copied, originals
- 4:42were kept, and the fakes were returned by Ptolemy.
- 4:46The third Ugartis ruling. From 2:46 to 2:22 BC, the
- 4:51collection swelled to perhaps 400,000 scrolls in the main
- 4:56library at the Royal palace, plus 42,800 in the daughter
- 5:01library at Serafium Temple. Alexandria became the
- 5:07intellectual hub of the Hellenistic world.
- 5:11And a note about the word Hellenistic.
- 5:13The Greeks called themselves Hellenes, so anything Greek is
- 5:16called Hellenistic. It blended Greek, Egyptian,
- 5:20Persian, and Indian ideas. As a podcaster who's discussed
- 5:24ancient wonders, I see this as a golden age of curiosity.
- 5:29A Ted talk of antiquity, if you'll have that
- 5:32conspiratorially. Did the Ptolemies hoard
- 5:35knowledge for power? Some suggest they suppressed
- 5:39rival texts to control narratives.
- 5:42It's plausible given dynastic politics.
- 5:45This era set the stage for brilliance, so let's meet the
- 5:49minds behind it. The library wasn't just storage,
- 5:54it was a think tank housing scholars who lived 8 and worked
- 5:58there, and it was funded by the Ptolemies.
- 6:02Demetrius of Falarium and exiled Athenian statesman organized it
- 6:09around 285 BC per Life Science. He catalog works systematically,
- 6:16A precursor to modern libraries. How about the key figures?
- 6:21Euclid, around 300 BC, wrote Elements, the foundational math
- 6:27text providing geometry theorems which are still taught to
- 6:31students today. Then Aerostenes of Cyrene, a
- 6:37chief librarian, around 2:45 BC, calculated Earth's circumference
- 6:43with astonishing accuracy, about 24,860 miles, which is close to
- 6:49the modern 24,901. Using shadows in the wells of
- 6:55seen now Ashwan and Alexandria, he also mapped the world and
- 7:01sieved rhymes. Archimedes of Syracuse, visiting
- 7:06around 287 to 212 BC, developed physics principles like
- 7:11buoyancy, that Eureka moment in the bath.
- 7:14Calimicus of Cyrene, A poet and cataloguer, created the Pinakeys
- 7:21120 volume bibliography and the first library catalog.
- 7:26The collections well, the Greek classics like Homer's Epics and
- 7:31Aristotle's work, which were brought there by his heirs.
- 7:34Egyptian medical texts, Babylonian astronomy, even
- 7:38Buddhist sutras from India translations boomed the
- 7:43Septuagint, the Greek Old Testament which was commissioned
- 7:47here around 250 BC. From my perspective, this
- 7:52screams innovation like ancient Silicon Valley conspiratorially
- 7:58did they uncover lost tech like the Antikythera mechanisms and
- 8:03hide it. It's plausible given secretive
- 8:06scholarly circles. So comment below.
- 8:09Who's your favorite ancient scholar from Alexandria and why?
- 8:14Let's discuss it in the comments.
- 8:16I always enjoy your picks. The library's decline wasn't one
- 8:21event, it was a series of blows spanning centuries.
- 8:26First, in 48 BC, during Julius Caesar's civil war supporting
- 8:32Cleopatra the 7th Caesar besieged Alexandria to block
- 8:37Ptolemy's fleet. He set fire to ships and the
- 8:41blaze spread to docks and warehouses, possibly burning
- 8:4540,000 scrolls which were destined for export.
- 8:49This is per Plutarch and Cassius Dio, ancient historians cited in
- 8:53Britannica. Not the main library, but a hit
- 8:57next around 27275AD, During Emperor Arulian's conquest of
- 9:03the Palmyran Empire under Queen Zenobia, the Brucholon district
- 9:09housing the main library was raised.
- 9:12This is per historian Emmanius Marcellaus.
- 9:16Then in 391 AD, Emperor Theodosius the First decreed
- 9:22against paganism and Patriarch Theophilus of Alexandria LED
- 9:27mobs to destroy the Seraphim, the daughter library.
- 9:31This was witnessed by Rufinus and Socrates scholar asterisk,
- 9:37but there's no mention of books burning but likely losses.
- 9:42Finally around 642 AD Arab conquest under Caliph Umar.
- 9:47But this is the tale of ordering books burned if contrary to the
- 9:52Quran. And this comes from 13th century
- 9:55sources but has been debunked by modern scholars at Live Science
- 10:00as legend, not fact. As for the gradual decline,
- 10:04funding cuts under Roman rule and scrolls decaying were moved.
- 10:09Personally this feels to me like slow motion tragedy knowledge
- 10:14slipping away conspiratorially. Were these accidents cover ups
- 10:20for targeted erasers? Some speculate that Caesar
- 10:23burned rivals Intel, so why the obsession with erasure?
- 10:29Well, theories swirl and let's unpack them as best we can here.
- 10:34A bit of conspiracy, a bit of history, and some fun.
- 10:38So first, political suppression. The Ptolemies and Romans
- 10:41controlled knowledge to maintain their power, and per World
- 10:46History Encyclopedia, rival schools were marginalized.
- 10:51It's a plausible conspiracy, but specific texts on democracy or
- 10:54tech were destroyed to prevent uprisings.
- 10:59Second, religious motives. Christian leaders like
- 11:02Theophilus saw Pagan works as threats.
- 11:06The Seraphim's fall aligned with edicts.
- 11:09Did they target heretical books? This is echoed in later book
- 11:13burnings and 3rd hidden survival.
- 11:17Some scrolls may have been smuggled to Constantinople or to
- 11:20Baghdad. The House of Wisdom in 8th
- 11:23century Baghdad, which translated Greek text, is
- 11:27perhaps from Alexandrian refugees.
- 11:31This is plausible as trade routes preserved fragments.
- 11:35It's a bit speculative, but looking at esoteric knowledge
- 11:38here, the theories of the hermetics which are hiding
- 11:43alchemy or astronomy could have been suppressed by elites.
- 11:47So how about some modern parallels here?
- 11:50This is like the Vatican archives hiding secrets.
- 11:52There's no evidence, but it does fuel debates.
- 11:56So what do you think about these theories?
- 11:58Accidental loss or deliberate erasure by the powerful?
- 12:03Drop your thoughts in the comments below and I might
- 12:06feature them on a follow up episode on this topic.
- 12:10The library's ghost lingers. It's model inspired modern
- 12:15institutions like the Library of Congress.
- 12:18In 2002, the Biblioteca Alexandria opened on the
- 12:23original site of the previous library, a $220 million marvel
- 12:29holding millions of books per UNESCO heritage.
- 12:32How about recent digs? Underwater Archaeology in
- 12:35Alexandria's harbor by Frank Gaudio in the 1990s uncovered
- 12:39Ptolemaic ruins but no library remnants.
- 12:43And this is per National Geographic.
- 12:45Scrolls from Herculaneum, which were buried by Vesuvius in 79
- 12:49AD, are being virtually unrolled, with AI revealing lost
- 12:54texts echoing what Alexandria might have held.
- 12:58Is history erased? Well, scholars like Lucanio
- 13:02Cafura argue much, survive through copies conspiratorially.
- 13:07Why is there no full recovery? Well, perhaps elites guard the
- 13:11secret still to this day. It's speculative, but it is
- 13:15intriguing. As I wrap this up and here's why
- 13:18I'm hooked In my podcast experiences, stories like
- 13:21Alexandria remind us knowledge is fragile and it's powerful.
- 13:27What was lost shaped our world and what remains inspires.
- 13:33So thanks for joining me on the Jeremy Ryan Slate show in this
- 13:36episode. If your curiosity was ignited,
- 13:40hit that subscribe button, like and share and head over to
- 13:43jeremyryanslate.com for more History with A twist podcast and
- 13:47everything else. So what do you think?
- 13:51What was erased or was it? What can we find or what's still
- 13:55out there? Comment below.
- 13:57I want to hear from you. Until next time, keep digging,
- 14:00Kee questioning, and I'll catch you on the next episode of the
- 14:04Jeremy Ryan Slate Show.