Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Show Me the Money: Financial Clarity in Mediation
Transcript
- 0:03Hi, everyone. Welcome to Show Me the Money, Financial
- 0:07Clarity and Mediation. My name is Rachel Serwin.
- 0:09I'm a student ambassador of BHBA, and I'm delighted
- 0:12to introduce today's speaker, Eric Wenon. Eric
- 0:16brings nearly 35 years of legal experience to
- 0:19his practice, embodying versatility, innovation.
- 0:22and a deep commitment to conflict resolution.
- 0:25He began his career at Hill, Wynn, Troup, and
- 0:28Meissinger, navigating high -stakes matters,
- 0:30exceeding $500 million in complex litigation
- 0:34before founding EAW Advisors Legal. Since then,
- 0:38he's distinguished himself as a trusted mediator,
- 0:42business advisor, and litigator. In addition
- 0:45to his legal practices, Eric has ventured into
- 0:48diverse industries, including international trade,
- 0:51fashion, real estate, and technology gaining
- 0:53invaluable insight into business dynamics and
- 0:56corporate interpersonal relationships. And now
- 0:59let's get started. Hi, everyone. Welcome. Thanks
- 1:04for coming to the webinar. And I hope we can
- 1:09have a good session. There's going to be a few
- 1:11points during the webinar where I'm going to
- 1:12ask for questions. Feel free at any point to
- 1:15put some questions in the Q &A. And when we take
- 1:19These stops, I'll be addressing those. The first
- 1:24thing that's very important to think about is
- 1:26what are we evaluating? It's important to focus
- 1:31that we're talking now in terms of the context
- 1:33of mediation. Does the person on the other side
- 1:37have the ability to pay a settlement? We're not
- 1:39talking about going all the way to the end and
- 1:41getting a judgment that you can enforce, that
- 1:44you can appeal, that you can. garnish wages,
- 1:47liquidate property. That's not what we're trying
- 1:50to evaluate at this point. You're sitting in
- 1:52a mediation and it comes up at some point that
- 1:54there's an inability to pay and you need to know
- 1:57to factor into the value of your case, whether
- 2:01it's real or not. So that's a very, very important
- 2:04difference, distinction that we should be focusing
- 2:07on. The other thing that's very important is
- 2:09it's equally crucial both for the plaintiff and
- 2:12the defendant. So a lot of times I'll be talking
- 2:14about the plaintiff wants to know this or the
- 2:17plaintiff needs to know that. But it's actually
- 2:19super important for the defendant because once
- 2:22they're able to show if there's a true issue
- 2:25of inability to pay, the language in the room
- 2:28changes, we're able to get settlements done.
- 2:32It's also very important for the defendant to
- 2:34be able to evaluate the financial situation of
- 2:36their own client. Clients are not always very
- 2:39honest and they need to understand what's going
- 2:41on and whether the inability to pay. is real
- 2:44or not. All right, let's move on. All right,
- 2:49so now what I'm going to do is I'm going to do
- 2:51a little live, you know, random exercise in showing
- 2:57you how to do a pre -mediation evaluation based
- 3:01on public information. So I believe it's very
- 3:04important before you start a mediation, really
- 3:06right when you're in the middle of a case whether
- 3:08you're having mediation or not, you should dig
- 3:10into the parties and you should see what kind
- 3:12of assets are available. understand who they
- 3:14are. And these are a couple of things. You'll
- 3:18see here a series of different searches. This
- 3:21is especially important when there is a personal
- 3:23liability that's at stake. So I gave you a few
- 3:26examples here. I do a lot of employment. So in
- 3:29a fee harassment action, affiliate or property
- 3:32rages, intentional towards fraud, fiduciary breaches,
- 3:37things like that. It's not so much for the scenario
- 3:40when we're talking about corporating a piece
- 3:42of pierced corporating, piercing a corporate
- 3:45veil, which is, you know, farther down the line
- 3:48once you get the judgment, it's for immediate
- 3:50personal liability that's recognized by law.
- 3:53So I'm going to go ahead and share my screen
- 3:55now and we're going to do kind of a live example.
- 4:02Okay, so you hopefully can see my screen. So
- 4:06here you have the tabs open that are mentioned
- 4:09in the slide. And we're going to just take a
- 4:13random example. I was thinking my girls go in
- 4:17the mornings to community goods to get their
- 4:20machas at $15, $20. And they tell me every morning
- 4:23how amazing they are. So that came to mind this
- 4:25morning. So I'll just walk you through. Again,
- 4:28this is just meant for demonstration. Who is
- 4:32the owner of community goods? OK, so it comes
- 4:39up with this gentleman here, Pedro Cavalier.
- 4:43So let's go ahead and just take his name here,
- 4:47copy it. And now we're going to go into the first
- 4:50of the links that you have here. This is called
- 4:52True People Search. This is an incredible tool
- 4:56where you can find information based on name,
- 4:59phone numbers, addresses, and email. So if I
- 5:01just type in the person's name, I hit Search.
- 5:05It's going to come up with a bunch of people.
- 5:07Let's suppose it's the one in Beverly Hills.
- 5:10We're going to click on that. And it's going
- 5:13to give you a lot of information about him, including
- 5:16his current residence. So once you have his residence
- 5:19address, you can take that. You can go into the
- 5:22next slide over here, which is a software called
- 5:27PropStream. This has an amazing amount of data
- 5:31with anything to do with real estate. So let's
- 5:35say you just take that address, you drop it into
- 5:37PropStream. It's going to find the address. Then
- 5:42you click on the particular property. It's going
- 5:45to show you ownership. So now it's showing the
- 5:47house and the ownership of a limited partnership.
- 5:49But what's also very interesting is if you click
- 5:52over here on linked properties, it'll show you
- 5:54all the properties that are related to the owner
- 5:56of his property in any way. So they're a partner
- 6:00in a corporation, any kind of link between them.
- 6:03So on this particular profile, it's a huge profile.
- 6:07It's 354 properties, $800 million in equity.
- 6:12And it shows you the entire list of all the properties.
- 6:16And you can see the different names. So these
- 6:18Metro Shell, personal names, et cetera. And then
- 6:23if you need to dig in deeper to look at a company,
- 6:25what you do at that point is you go over to open
- 6:27corporates. And you can do a search for, let's
- 6:32say, Pedro. You can search as an officer. You
- 6:41can search a company name. OK, yes, I'm going
- 6:52through here. Verify. I don't know why it's not
- 7:10coming up under the name. So normally, again,
- 7:19if you take any of the list of names or companies,
- 7:22you can search by the name of the company or
- 7:24by the officer. For example, if you take one
- 7:28of my companies, You type in E -A -W advisors,
- 7:33and you do a search. You're going to see my entity
- 7:36here. It's based in California. It's based in
- 7:39Texas. You can click on it. You can see who the
- 7:42officers are. And you can see who all the related
- 7:45companies are. The same thing, again, if we do
- 7:49one more time, let's see if it works this time.
- 7:53Pedro Cavalier. OK, so this time it worked. So
- 8:00here you see a variety of Pedro Cavaliers. And
- 8:03if you look down here, you'll see Community Goods
- 8:07Act, I think, where my daughters go, Pacific
- 8:08Design Center. So that kind of closes the loop.
- 8:12And you can see all the related entities. So
- 8:14that's a way where you can quickly look at a
- 8:17lot of data on property ownerships, on company
- 8:21relations, on all sorts of things like that to
- 8:23get an initial feel. Some other links that I
- 8:26pointed out, this is the Bureau of Security and
- 8:30Investigative Services. So many people have licenses.
- 8:33So you can come in here and you can search a
- 8:35license, whether it's a contractor or security,
- 8:38all the different license, and it will give you
- 8:40all the related companies. So sometimes you might
- 8:43see a situation where somebody is using a license,
- 8:45closing a company, opening another company. You'll
- 8:48be able to see that pattern. In fact, if they're
- 8:50going out of business or they're just shutting
- 8:51their shelves. Other things that I think you're
- 8:54familiar with, you can come on to the superior
- 8:57court, you can type a search by a litigants name,
- 9:00and you can see the history on the litigation.
- 9:04Same thing with PACER, you can go and cite federal,
- 9:07you do an advanced search by party name, and
- 9:11you just type in the party's business personal
- 9:13and you'll see all the different causes of action
- 9:15that are out there. Going through all that information,
- 9:18you're going to have an initial picture before
- 9:20you even step into mediation. in terms of assets
- 9:23and related entities. All right. So I'll stop
- 9:26sharing. So does anyone have any questions with
- 9:31regard to that part of the presentation so far?
- 9:37Okay. All right. Wonderful. So let's go ahead
- 9:39and keep going. So this is all pre -mediation.
- 9:43All right. So now you're in the mediation and
- 9:48the defendant is claiming an ability to pay.
- 9:51and you need the defendant to provide some documents.
- 9:54So the first sensitive issue is these people
- 9:57are fighting, these documents are very, very
- 10:01private. The last thing they want to do is turn
- 10:03it over to the other side. So you have an honest
- 10:06discussion, which is if you're going to claim
- 10:08an ability to pay, you need to provide some kind
- 10:12of information. Without it, the plaintiff is
- 10:14going to basically think it's another crying
- 10:17wolf. I would say more than half of my mediations,
- 10:22people are saying they can't afford to pay. So
- 10:25the plaintiffs are ignoring it, to be honest
- 10:27with you. So what do I do? I explain to the parties
- 10:33and the attorney exactly the documents that I'm
- 10:36going to be asking for, which I'm going to go
- 10:38over in the next couple of slides. And then I
- 10:41review them. I'll pause the mediation. It takes
- 10:43them usually a half an hour to an hour, depending
- 10:46on how complex and how large the company is,
- 10:48and I'll review everything. And then when I'm
- 10:51done, I will go back and I'll provide what I
- 10:54found in the summary and exactly how I'm going
- 10:56to present it to defense and their counsel and
- 10:59get their OK before I ever say anything to plaintiff's
- 11:02counsel and the plaintiff. Also in that, I'll
- 11:06ask for permission to share certain specific
- 11:09information. Like, for example, I might say to
- 11:12them, is it OK if I let them take two random
- 11:14bank statements, random months, and I can give
- 11:17them opening and ending balances, money in, money
- 11:20out, so that they feel like, you know, be sure
- 11:23that I'm not in any way, you know, trying to
- 11:25skew things one way or the other. But what's
- 11:28extremely important is I will never provide a
- 11:31single document that's given to me to the plaintiff,
- 11:35ever. I don't want the responsibility. I think
- 11:38it's an area to make a lot of damage. And it'll
- 11:40come up. Defense will say, I have nothing to
- 11:42hide. Go ahead and give it to them. I will not
- 11:44do that. If defense counsel wants to email plaintiffs
- 11:46counsel with documents and copy me under mediators
- 11:50privilege or not or confidentiality or non -disclosure
- 11:53document, they can do that. But I will not do
- 11:56that. I will just be providing verbal summaries
- 11:59of the documents and what I think and what my
- 12:01impressions are, everything cleared by defense
- 12:04in advance of what I'm going to be sharing. And
- 12:07again, And so far, in the times that I've had
- 12:11to do this financial analysis, the actual providing
- 12:14or not providing the documents has not prevented
- 12:17a settlement. My analysis, my being able to answer
- 12:21the question, being able to share some of the
- 12:24details has been enough to move things forward
- 12:26so we get the settlement. And again, another
- 12:29reminder, we are looking at all these documents
- 12:31again in the context of mediation. Can this company,
- 12:35can this person afford to pay today to settle
- 12:38an amount that's being requested? Are you asking
- 12:42for a million dollars and the company has $150
- 12:46,000 of cash, is full of debts, has no ability
- 12:50to borrow, has eight different litigations are
- 12:52going on. What is the reality? It doesn't mean
- 12:55that the plaintiff or the plaintiff's attorney
- 12:57has to change their position. If they want to
- 13:01go to trial, they want to get a judgment, They
- 13:03want to liquidate assets. They want to go against
- 13:05a private home above a homestead exemption. They're
- 13:08free to do it. But we're looking at it as of
- 13:11settlement value on the day that we're doing
- 13:13the mediation. Very key distinction to focus
- 13:16on. I'll give you an example of a case where
- 13:21I did this financial analysis. It was a sexual
- 13:24harassment case. It was the second day of a mediation.
- 13:27It was on a Sunday. It was during the week of
- 13:30trial. plaintiff was asking for mid seven figures
- 13:33and the company had been boasting in the press
- 13:36about its success and it was saying things like
- 13:40you know we're open we're worth over 750 million
- 13:43they acquired three months ago this company five
- 13:47months ago another company and plaintiff had
- 13:50done all the searches. She had everything bookmarked.
- 13:53She knew exactly what was going on. And as soon
- 13:56as this thing came up about inability to pay,
- 13:59she pulled out article after article, highlighted,
- 14:02redlined, and she wasn't buying it. And the problem
- 14:06was that we were talking in a settlement arrange
- 14:08that was above insurance limits. And these owners
- 14:12needed to put in personal money to get this deal
- 14:15done if they wanted to get it settled. I told
- 14:18them what I needed, which we're going to go over,
- 14:20which is basically bank statements, tax returns,
- 14:24P &Ls, loan statements, things like that. I stopped
- 14:28the mediation for about an hour and I did the
- 14:31review. What the numbers showed was this was
- 14:35a company that was doing around $7 .5 million
- 14:39a month of deposits and was spending $7 .4 million.
- 14:43So if you look at a bank statement, you'll have
- 14:45a starting balance, additions, subtractions,
- 14:49ending balance. So they had about $150 ,000 as
- 14:52a starting balance. $7 million would come in,
- 14:55$6 .9 million would go out, and they'd have $100
- 14:58,000 left. So that's about 1 .5 % of working
- 15:03capital. They were maxed out on all of their
- 15:06loans. And you see in certain months, there's
- 15:09transfers coming in just to cover the payroll.
- 15:11The payroll was over $4 million a month. So I
- 15:15went through all of that. And now at this point,
- 15:19all the owners are in the room. And I look at
- 15:22them and I say, listen, if I was running your
- 15:24company, I wouldn't sleep at night. And the guy
- 15:27looked at me and said, I don't sleep at night.
- 15:32I said, let me give you a theory. You're out
- 15:35there boasting, and the plaintiff knows about
- 15:37it, of all these companies that you're acquiring.
- 15:41But I think your sector is going out of business,
- 15:44and you're not really acquiring these companies
- 15:46for money. You're just basically getting them
- 15:48all for free, just to say that you're growing
- 15:51when everyone else is reducing, because that's
- 15:53exactly right. In fact, what it's doing is it's
- 15:57making this company sink even quicker, because
- 15:59you're taking on all that payroll. with insufficient
- 16:03profit to offset it. And he said, absolutely
- 16:06right. So we had a connection going over the
- 16:10numbers. And what's kind of ironic is the numbers
- 16:13are very cold. It's very difficult to talk with
- 16:18the people about them. You have to be very sensitive.
- 16:21You need to be confident because people will
- 16:23push back on you also. So you have to feel comfortable
- 16:26with the numbers. But when you do it, it's another
- 16:29way to make a very, very close bond with parties
- 16:33on both sides. Because now you have these owners
- 16:35of the company telling you, listen, I can barely
- 16:38make payroll. I'm not sleeping. And you'll see
- 16:42from the further documents we can look at their
- 16:44compensation, what they're taking out of the
- 16:46company every year. So after I did that and I
- 16:50had all that information, I asked them again.
- 16:53I gave them exactly what I was going to tell
- 16:55them. Here's what this shows and this shows and
- 16:56this shows. and I told them we have two years
- 16:59of bank statements. What I'd like to do is have
- 17:01plaintiff or plaintiff's counsel pick three months
- 17:03randomly over 24 and 25, and I'll tell them the
- 17:07numbers on the opening and closing so they can
- 17:09understand better. After we did that, the case
- 17:14got settled. I wouldn't say the plaintiff became
- 17:16sympathetic at all for these defendants, but
- 17:19they were able to understand the reality of the
- 17:21situations, and again, evaluate the financial
- 17:24circumstances for settlement. They could have
- 17:27gone, they could have continued in trial, they
- 17:29could have tried to enforce a judgment and continued
- 17:34with the case, but they felt that they got a
- 17:37good number and they accepted the settlement.
- 17:43The next thing we're going to talk about, is
- 17:48what do you ask for? So here are the documents
- 17:50that I asked for when I do a financial analysis.
- 17:52I asked for the bank statements for two years
- 17:55for all accounts. I asked for loan accounts,
- 17:57two years for all accounts. I asked for tax returns
- 18:01the last two years. And I asked for a year to
- 18:04date profit and loss statement and balance sheet.
- 18:06And then I have a catch all, anything other,
- 18:09any other significant. litigation or extraordinary
- 18:13situation that would affect the ability to pay,
- 18:16I give them the option to pull all that information
- 18:18and provide it to me. How do you review all of
- 18:23these things? We're going to go in detail for
- 18:25each one in the next slide. Really what you're
- 18:29looking for is trends, consistency, and inconsistency.
- 18:34Let's say you have the tax returns. You have
- 18:36two years. A lot of times the tax return will
- 18:38refer to the prior year on the summary page.
- 18:42You'll actually have three years of data. If
- 18:45you see a company that's going 20 million, 10
- 18:47million, 5 million in sales, it gets you to scratch
- 18:51your head. Similarly, if the profit is going
- 18:55from 500 ,000 to 200 ,000 to negative, you're
- 19:02gonna start to see some kind of trend. On the
- 19:04other hand, if you see a company that's exploding
- 19:06in sales and exploding in profits, you're gonna
- 19:09feel differently. And then the other one is obviously
- 19:11kind of a straight growth. So you're going through
- 19:14and you're looking all the time for trends, consistencies
- 19:17and inconsistencies. And I'll tell you what parts
- 19:20of the returns you need to look out for to get
- 19:23to good information that you can transmit to
- 19:25the plaintiff and help you make your evaluation.
- 19:29All right, so now I'm going to talk about each
- 19:32type of information and I'm going to rate them
- 19:34in terms of the reliability and what you should
- 19:36look for. So bank statements. For me, the bank
- 19:38statements are the number one most important
- 19:41piece of information. They're objective, they're
- 19:45real, they're extremely hard to fake. And, you
- 19:48know, you think about them in your personal life.
- 19:50If you have a banking account, checking account,
- 19:53and a savings account, you're making your money
- 19:56and you have, you know, 15 ,000 left over every
- 19:59month after you pay your expenses, or 50 ,000
- 20:01or 100 ,000, and you have a couple hundred thousand
- 20:04in the savings account, and someone's coming
- 20:07after you and asking you to pay two, three hundred.
- 20:10thousand that's going to completely wipe out
- 20:11all of your savings and your things you know
- 20:14you're going to have this reality this feeling
- 20:16of i don't have the money to pay it you know
- 20:18even if i wanted to sell it i literally don't
- 20:21have the cash on hand to spend and you know it's
- 20:24not the time for people again in mediation to
- 20:26say well go sell your house or they might tell
- 20:29you go take a loan, take a credit line, if you
- 20:31have credit lines that are already maxed out.
- 20:33There definitely could be discussions about going
- 20:35and borrowing and things like that, but there's
- 20:38a reality of where you are at that minute in
- 20:40your life. And that's what we're trying to do.
- 20:42We're trying to get a snapshot of both the company
- 20:44and the individual at the time of mediation.
- 20:48So why do I say the reliability is high? So it's
- 20:51very hard to... to commit fraud on the bank accounts.
- 20:55I mean, there's some people that want AI bank
- 20:57accounts, but it's rare. It's also there's a
- 21:00game where you ask for all the accounts and they'll
- 21:02hide certain accounts. But what makes it very
- 21:06difficult is that the way that people bank is
- 21:09they're not banking thinking about they're going
- 21:11to get sued. So they're banking in their normal
- 21:14course of business. And when you look at some
- 21:15bank accounts, if a company has an operational
- 21:17account, a savings account, a loan account, you're
- 21:20going to see transfers back and forth between
- 21:23the accounts all day long. So if someone doesn't
- 21:26provide you an account, you can be sure when
- 21:28you're looking through the transfer, you're going
- 21:29to see an account number and you're going to
- 21:30say, what is that? and you're gonna see the money
- 21:33that's coming in and coming out from the loan
- 21:35account. You're gonna make sure it ties into
- 21:36the loan account. So the transfers between the
- 21:39different accounts is gonna have a lot of clarity
- 21:42that it's very hard for someone to pull a fast
- 21:45one on you. And so that's why it makes them,
- 21:50they make them very, very reliable. So the things
- 21:54that you're gonna look for in the bank accounts,
- 21:56I referred to them a little bit earlier. They
- 21:58start out, I couldn't give you a sample bank
- 22:00account because they were private and they couldn't
- 22:03create a fake one for me even though I tried.
- 22:07So you have a starting balance beginning of the
- 22:10month, which is basically how you ended the month
- 22:12before. So it'll say, your balance is 250 ,000.
- 22:16Your additions, for example, in the example that
- 22:18I gave earlier, in the sexual harassment case,
- 22:21they were depositing about $7 million. seven
- 22:24and a half million dollars every month over coming
- 22:26in you'd see all the deposits coming in and then
- 22:29the subtractions is all the payments so they
- 22:31can be made paid by check paid by wire you would
- 22:34see also in there the payroll that was being
- 22:36being deducted every two weeks and then an ending
- 22:39balance so you have the whole story you have
- 22:42a picture of what it looks like and as you're
- 22:44looking over 24 months you're going to see the
- 22:47trends again if you see a company that constantly
- 22:50is running 1 % or 2 % cash flow on its sales
- 22:55over many, many months, that's someone that's
- 22:59on the edge. If you see a company, for example,
- 23:01that normally had $2 million starting and ending
- 23:05balances that are going down to $500 to $200
- 23:07to $100, that's another story. The opposite.
- 23:10If the company is getting built up, and there's
- 23:13a good cash flow in the main account, and you
- 23:15see that they're paying off that or there's a
- 23:17separate savings account, which we'll do to get
- 23:19more interest, then you'll know that there's
- 23:21money that's coming out. So when you're doing
- 23:24it, you're kind of trying to get like a feel,
- 23:26a little bit more of like reminds me of the matrix
- 23:28with all the lines. You're trying to get a read
- 23:31on what the documents are telling you. The more
- 23:33you do it, the more obvious it will be. So also
- 23:37when you're looking through the bank statements,
- 23:40you're looking for high fixed expenses. So you'll
- 23:43see rent. So this company was $292 ,000 in monthly
- 23:47rent. You'll see payroll. So I mentioned it was
- 23:50over $4 million in payroll. So you'll see the
- 23:52$2 million payroll. You'll see the corresponding
- 23:57taxes. And then two weeks later, you'll see it
- 24:00again. So you'll see these kind of numbers that
- 24:02will make sense with you. And you're going to
- 24:04see we're going to tie those numbers into the
- 24:06tax statements to make sure that everything looks
- 24:08well. The other thing that's very important when
- 24:10you're looking at bank statements is you want
- 24:12to look for round numbers. Okay, round numbers,
- 24:1650 ,000, 100 ,000, 200 ,000, 500 ,000. The way
- 24:20of business, those numbers are not natural numbers.
- 24:24Those normally come from loan money coming in
- 24:27or loan money going out or bonuses being paid.
- 24:31When you see large round numbers, those are the
- 24:33ones that should immediately start highlighting
- 24:35and trying to figure what is going on here. Oh,
- 24:37this is coming in from a loan account. Oh, they
- 24:40have a credit line. They're bringing out $100
- 24:42,000, $200 ,000. You see money coming in every
- 24:45month or every two months, but you don't see
- 24:47payments back to the credit line. So the way
- 24:50the credit lines talk about, we'll talk about
- 24:51them in the next slide, is you pay interest only
- 24:54on the balance of the credit line. So if you
- 24:57have extra cash in the bank and you're a smart
- 24:59businessman, you're going to pay that money back
- 25:01to the credit line as soon as you can because
- 25:03you don't want to pay interest on that balance.
- 25:06So you should see money going in and out. And
- 25:09the trend of the money going in and out is something
- 25:11also that's very important for you to look at.
- 25:13So those big round numbers is something you should
- 25:16be focused on. OK, so loan statements. So similar
- 25:22to bank statements, so these are separate statements
- 25:24for either credit lines or different type of
- 25:26loans. The reliability is also very, very high.
- 25:31And you're looking again for the trends. What's
- 25:34the balance? You have a million dollar loan,
- 25:36you'll save a million dollar credit line, $700
- 25:39,000 available. went out this month 200 ,000
- 25:43got paid this month 100 ,000 so it looks very
- 25:46similar to a bank account and when you're comparing
- 25:48it again over two years you're going to understand
- 25:51very quickly what is the health of the company
- 25:53what is going on why are these numbers changing
- 25:56why at one time we have full availability why
- 25:58are we have no availability But you also have
- 26:02to kind of be smart in thinking about it. It's
- 26:03just not because a company has no availability
- 26:06of credit at a particular day that they're unhealthy,
- 26:09right? Because a lot of times people will use
- 26:10their credit lines for seasonality. So if it's
- 26:13a company that's buying a lot of merchandise
- 26:15and it's, you know, October, September, October,
- 26:19they're bringing in a lot of merchandise for
- 26:20the holiday season, they might need up all of
- 26:23their credit line. But if you look in January
- 26:26and February from the prior year, you'll see
- 26:28that there's a ton of cash that comes in. that
- 26:31fills it back up. So you want to also kind of
- 26:34be alert to why the credit line is moving. Is
- 26:37it something to do with a healthy company, a
- 26:40non -healthy company? Is it a trend that has
- 26:42to do with seasonality? So there's lots of reasons
- 26:45to explain it. All right. The next thing that
- 26:49we're going to look at is tax returns. So this
- 26:53is a bit of a shock for some of you, maybe. So
- 26:57for the reliability on the tax returns, for me,
- 27:00is medium to low. So these are documents. Obviously,
- 27:04they're signed under penalty of perjury. There
- 27:07are serious penalties if they're fake. There's
- 27:13audit rights. There's lots of things. But I don't
- 27:16consider the tax returns to be very reliable.
- 27:19And the reason is is that on a tax return, you
- 27:21can very easily manipulate the final numbers.
- 27:25So the main goal of the tax return, depending
- 27:27on the company, is either to show a lot of income
- 27:31because you want to borrow money and you're doing
- 27:33well or to show the least amount of income so
- 27:36you don't have to pay taxes. So there's many
- 27:39other things that are driving tax returns. So
- 27:41I'll give you an example. For example, you have
- 27:43a company that has a lot of inventory and the
- 27:46inventory on the books is worth three dollars
- 27:49a widget. and you decide that your profit for
- 27:54the company is too big that year and you mark
- 27:55it down from $3 to 270, you do a journal entry
- 28:01and you say out of style or whatever the reason
- 28:04is, all of a sudden your taxes drop tremendously.
- 28:08That's something that's a subjective change.
- 28:11It's not an objective change. It's something
- 28:12that can be done with one journal entry. So in
- 28:17terms of the real health of a company, I don't
- 28:20look so much at the tax returns. However, what
- 28:23is very important about the tax returns? The
- 28:25same things, the trends, the consistencies, the
- 28:27inconsistencies. So if you have two years and
- 28:30it's showing two or three years and you see sales
- 28:33going from 10 to five to two or 10 to 15 to 20
- 28:37or two to two, all of those things are going
- 28:40to give you kind of an idea. of the validity
- 28:43of what the defendant is claiming, of whether
- 28:45they're just paying their bills, whether the
- 28:47verge of going out of business, whether they're
- 28:49on the edge of doing bankruptcy, whether they're
- 28:51actually healthy. It's going to give you a lot
- 28:54more information. So now what I'm going to do
- 29:00is I'm going to pull up some tax returns, and
- 29:06I'm going to tell you the things on the tax returns
- 29:08that are important for you to keep a look at.
- 29:10So let me pull up some sample documents. All
- 29:16right, thank you for letting me share. OK, hopefully
- 29:20everyone can see my screen. So this form here
- 29:24is called an 1120S. So this is a corporate tax
- 29:28return. So most corporations will either file
- 29:31an 1120 or 1120S. 1120 is for a corporate tax
- 29:35return, a C corp. where there's taxation at the
- 29:38corporate level. 1120S is called a pass -through
- 29:41entity. So the calculation is done, but then
- 29:44the profits are passed through or the negative
- 29:47to the owners. So there's only a single taxation.
- 29:50So in this example, we're using an 1120S. It's
- 29:52very similar to a regular 1120. And I'll highlight
- 29:57some of the things that you guys should be looking
- 29:59at. And then in the slides, we'll go back to
- 30:01them and I'll give you more detail. So right
- 30:03here, line 1A is gross receipts. So what is this?
- 30:05This is income. This is the money that came into
- 30:08the company that's going to be offset by the
- 30:11cost of goods and other type of things here.
- 30:13Then you're going to have your total income here.
- 30:16Line 1 through 6 is very important to see basically
- 30:20what's going on. If it's sales, it's the same
- 30:22thing. When I'm talking about the 5, 10, 15,
- 30:24or the 2, 2, 2, you should see it here over the
- 30:26multiple years. Line 7, very important, compensation
- 30:30to officers. How much are the owners of this
- 30:32company being paid? Are they pulling out millions
- 30:36and millions of dollars every year? Have they
- 30:39pulled out in the past a million dollars every
- 30:41year? In the last two years, they pulled out
- 30:43zero and zero. What does that tell you about
- 30:46the company? Where is the company feeling internally
- 30:49to be reflected on how much they're going to
- 30:51pay to the owners? It's a very good insight.
- 30:54It's almost like an insider trading. It's what
- 30:57are the owners thinking about their own company?
- 30:59Salaries and wages. So these are the total salary
- 31:02and wages. So like in the case I talked to you
- 31:04about earlier, there was about $4 million a month.
- 31:06So you'd expect to see here around $48 million
- 31:09a year of salary and wages on this tax return.
- 31:13If you see 48, 49, 50, whatever it is, something
- 31:16close to that, you're going to say, OK, it makes
- 31:18sense. If you see $75 million, then you're going
- 31:21to inquire, well, why is there $20 million more
- 31:24after taxes? on the return. And you might find
- 31:26out, oh, well, there was this $5 million or $10
- 31:28million bonus that didn't show up anywhere else.
- 31:31So it's also another thing that's important to
- 31:33look at for owners. Then you can come through
- 31:38the return. There's a lot of things that we'll
- 31:40go through. Another thing down here that's important
- 31:44is items affecting shareholder basis on 16A distributions,
- 31:49line 16D. Line 16E, repayment of loans to shareholders.
- 31:55So often when companies are building, the owners
- 31:58of the company will lend money, their own money,
- 32:01back to the corporation. They can do it two ways.
- 32:03They can either put in fresh money or they can
- 32:06defer their compensation. So that account called
- 32:09a shareholder account, loan account, will increase
- 32:11over time if they're doing that. And then the
- 32:15idea is when the company is healthy, they're
- 32:16going to repay the owners. So if you see that
- 32:20someone is taking a salary and repaying their
- 32:23loans to themselves, that indicates that there's
- 32:25excessive cash flow. And on the other hand, if
- 32:28you don't see that that's happening and there's
- 32:29very low compensation, it shows more that a company
- 32:35is really just kind of getting along. Schedule
- 32:39K, what I'm gonna talk about. Okay, schedule
- 32:41L. So this is called a balance sheet. So a balance
- 32:45sheet is very simple. It's basically a snapshot
- 32:48of your assets and your liabilities. So it's
- 32:51not really based on income and expenses and profits,
- 32:54it's what do you have. So also very helpful line
- 32:58one cash. So this is telling you at the start
- 33:00of this year how much cash do you have in the
- 33:02bank. So did you have a hundred thousand? Did
- 33:04you have a million? Did you have five hundred
- 33:06thousand? How did you end the year? Okay, you
- 33:08started with a million, you have a hundred thousand.
- 33:11By the way, these numbers should coordinate with
- 33:13the bank statements. So if you see a company
- 33:16had tremendously high cash at the beginning of
- 33:19the year or the opposite, this is the real money
- 33:21that's on hand at the end of when the return
- 33:24was done. And that's a very important thing to
- 33:28look at. The other thing that's important to
- 33:30look at is receivables, which is basically how
- 33:32much money is owed to the company by outside
- 33:34vendors. Payables, how much does the company
- 33:37owe. And the combination of those three things
- 33:40and some other factors in here, we don't have
- 33:42a lot of time to go into too much detail, you'll
- 33:44get a feeling of the health of the company. OK,
- 33:48so this is a K1. So a K1 is what's provided to
- 33:54each owner of the company. So this is very important.
- 33:57It'll show you who the owners are. It'll tell
- 33:59you their percent ownership. It'll tell you what
- 34:02percent of the profit of the ordinary income
- 34:04they're getting. It'll tell you if there's any
- 34:06other kind of compensation. So this gives you
- 34:10a very key understanding at an owner level of
- 34:12what's going on. And this is also a compensation
- 34:16of offices. So this talks specifically about
- 34:18how much the offers are making as salary as compensation,
- 34:23as opposed to the ownership. of the profit that
- 34:27they're pulling out, if there is profit. Okay,
- 34:30so those are the key forms. We're gonna go back
- 34:32to the slideshow. All right, so we just talked
- 34:38about the 1120S and went through it quickly,
- 34:40but I put it out for you here in the materials.
- 34:44So line one, gross receipts or sales. You're
- 34:46looking for the trends and the sales. And you
- 34:49can also compare it to the market. So if you
- 34:50have somebody who's in the alcohol business,
- 34:52if you have someone who's... in the beverage
- 34:56business, whatever business that they're in,
- 34:57if you have doctors, whatever you're looking
- 35:00at, you can very quickly now go online and see
- 35:03what the trends. And if you see that there's
- 35:05a sector that's growing quickly and in your returns,
- 35:08it's going down and down, you should inquire
- 35:10what is going on. On the other hand, if you confirm
- 35:13that your company is going down and down in a
- 35:16sector that's going down, it's also part of the
- 35:18story. OK, compensation of officers. I mentioned
- 35:21how much are the owners pulling out, salaries
- 35:23and wages. Does this match the bank statements
- 35:26in terms of the amounts you see going out? Ordinary
- 35:29business income. So most people would be surprised
- 35:33if you take the ordinary income as a percent
- 35:35of the sales, and most companies make between
- 35:395 % and 10 % of sales. which is a relatively
- 35:43small number. If a company sells 10 million,
- 35:46they're making between 500 and $1 million of
- 35:49profit, 500 ,000. Now, in that 500 ,000 to 1
- 35:52million, they may already be taking out compensation
- 35:55and wages and other things that are above the
- 35:57line, but it's usually not a huge number. Again,
- 36:01you should calculate the percent and you should
- 36:03look at the percent. If sales are going up 5,
- 36:0610, 15, And percent income is going up 3, 5,
- 36:118. The company is not only making more money,
- 36:13but it's not only increasing its sales, but it's
- 36:16more profitable. On the other hand, like you
- 36:18know in a lot of the technology companies, if
- 36:20the company is going up 5, 10, 20, and its percent
- 36:24of revenue is going down in the other direction,
- 36:26so they're in this idea that they're going to
- 36:28invest, invest, invest, and lose money to get
- 36:30market share, it tells you a completely different
- 36:32story. And again, you're very easy to go online
- 36:36these days and check what the industry averages
- 36:37are so that you can go through that. All right.
- 36:43OK, so the Schedule L, the balance sheet we talked
- 36:46about. So this is the key items you should look
- 36:48at. In your package, you have the sample forms
- 36:52and you have this so you can go back and forth.
- 36:54So the cash, again, what did you start with?
- 36:58What did you finish with? Very, very key in the
- 37:01context of mediation. How much money do they
- 37:04have now in the bank? How much do they have available
- 37:07to them? The debt, everything like that. Is it
- 37:10consistent with the bank statements, receivables,
- 37:12money owed to the company, payables? money company
- 37:15owes to others, and then distributions. So at
- 37:18the bottom, there was a section there on items
- 37:20affecting shareholders. Have there been distributions?
- 37:23Have the shareholders been paid back for their
- 37:24loans? All right. Again, schedule K and compensation.
- 37:32Again, these are highly reliable documents because
- 37:35this has to be consistent with the ownership
- 37:37year after year. that'll tell you who owns the
- 37:40company and how much each person is taking out
- 37:42as ownership and whether there's interest or
- 37:45other things that are being paid. Compensation
- 37:47to officers is also something that's going to
- 37:49be very reliable so you can get an idea on what's
- 37:52going on there. OK, so let's take a break for
- 37:57a second. Does anyone have any questions with
- 38:00respect to reviewing the The the financials the
- 38:06tax return documents with the loan statements
- 38:09So we do have one where you mentioned determining
- 38:16Averages for certain industries are asking if
- 38:19you have a general resource for that I don't
- 38:23I don't have something I mean honestly I would
- 38:25just do kind of some Google searches and then
- 38:27what you'll do is in Google searches You'll find
- 38:30industry averages. There's like an IBIS report
- 38:33That is one that's used by a lot of the forensic
- 38:35accountants. That's helpful. But it really depends
- 38:40on the industry. And again, you're not acting
- 38:43as a forensic accountant. You're not supposed
- 38:45to know every detail. But it's just, again, if
- 38:48you're looking at whatever industry you're looking
- 38:50at, whether it's marijuana, OK, what's going
- 38:53on in the marijuana retail space these days?
- 38:55What's going on in the agricultural space? You'll
- 38:58get some trends, as you can understand. All right.
- 39:02So we have a couple of questions. First question
- 39:06is, it seems like as a neutral mediator, you
- 39:08are actually doing the job of forensic accountant.
- 39:10Please explain why this isn't outside the role
- 39:13of a mediator. So again, it's done at the request
- 39:19of the parties. It's done at a time in the mediation
- 39:23when there's a claim of inability to pay and
- 39:26you're stuck. In the case I gave you, we were
- 39:30millions and millions of dollars apart. And I
- 39:33believe that it's part of the job of the mediator
- 39:35to do whatever they're capable to do to help
- 39:38get the deal done. So hiring a forensic accountant
- 39:42in the middle of the mediation is usually not
- 39:45an option. It is an option, and we'll talk about
- 39:48one of the examples later on where we're. during
- 39:51trial and I actually pulled in the forensic accountants
- 39:54so and your ability to be able to read the reports
- 39:57and question them. So I think it's something
- 40:00that's an add -on if a mediator is capable to
- 40:02do it. I think it's an added benefit and the
- 40:07forensics accountants are very expensive and
- 40:09often not an option unless they've already been
- 40:11declared as experts. Another question, how do
- 40:15you handle overly generous salaries? So You know,
- 40:19it's something that comes up. So in this other
- 40:22case that I was talking about with the $7 .5
- 40:27million, when you looked on the compensation
- 40:30to officers and on the K -1, three years ago,
- 40:34they took out about a million dollars a partner.
- 40:37The subsequent year, they took nothing and they
- 40:39took like $180 ,000 in compensation. And the
- 40:43year we were talking about, they also had taken
- 40:45nothing out. So I said to them, what's going
- 40:47on? I mean, how are you claiming an ability to
- 40:49pull when you're pulling out a million dollars
- 40:51each? And they looked at you and said, listen,
- 40:54we've run in the company for 10 years. It's the
- 40:57first time we pulled out money. We needed to
- 40:59pay back some of the loans and things that we
- 41:02had. And we felt comfortable doing it. And you
- 41:05can see for the last two years, we haven't had
- 41:07the ability to pull anything out. And you asked
- 41:09for an explanation. Again, you have to tread
- 41:13lightly because you need the permission from
- 41:17the defense in terms of what you can share with
- 41:20plaintiffs. If they feel comfortable saying to
- 41:24the plaintiff, listen, the owners have taken
- 41:26only $180 ,000 of salaries for the last two years
- 41:29or whatever it is, it will usually soften the
- 41:32plaintiff if you're comfortable that you have
- 41:34the numbers accurate. On the other hand, if they
- 41:37don't feel comfortable and they're drawing out
- 41:38a lot of money, you can confront it with them
- 41:41and you know you don't have the okay to share
- 41:44it you don't share it you share what you can
- 41:46share so that's how i would deal with it all
- 41:50right i'm reading another question okay so it
- 41:55says early on you mentioned doing searches such
- 41:57as pro search and true people do you know if
- 42:00these reports are current and how often are they
- 42:01updated so we have the information we're getting
- 42:03is current so i believe that the ones i showed
- 42:06you are almost all in real time Property search,
- 42:11I've used a lot in my businesses to investigate
- 42:16different kind of real estate and different kind
- 42:18of deals. It takes some time for them to get
- 42:20information in. Maybe they're a month or two
- 42:23months behind all of the recordings. In there,
- 42:26you can also see all of the loans, whether there's
- 42:28the equity on the property, but they're pretty
- 42:30up to date. Again, it's a point of conversation.
- 42:34If it comes up, you can talk with the person
- 42:37about it. Well, listen, You're claiming you're
- 42:39in a partition case, for example. I do a lot
- 42:41of partition actions. So you're in a partition
- 42:43action, and the person is saying, I can't afford
- 42:46to buy off the other party. I want to do this.
- 42:48And then you look at it, and he's got 12 other
- 42:50buildings that are paid off. And you talk with
- 42:53the defendant. Listen, what's going on? And you
- 42:55can kind of see how he explains it and how you
- 42:58want to shorten the other room. But I would say
- 43:01they're pretty accurate in terms of timing, especially
- 43:03what we need for mediation. If you need to do
- 43:07evaluation on one of the parties with the thought
- 43:09that an acquisition by one party or the other
- 43:11will resolve this dispute, should you use an
- 43:13outline expert? So I would say the general answer
- 43:19to that is yes. If it's really you're stuck on
- 43:24what's the true value of a company, I wouldn't
- 43:27think that a mediator would feel comfortable
- 43:29putting that number. I am able to read and analyze
- 43:34business valuations from different accountants,
- 43:39forensic experts. It's something that I've done
- 43:40a lot of. So I feel comfortable reading those
- 43:43reports. So that's something you can offer your
- 43:46opinion on. But honestly, like most of you know,
- 43:48when you have a forensic accountant, the plaintiff
- 43:51forensic accountant will say it's 20 million
- 43:53in the defense. Expert will say 1 million. I'm
- 43:56going to share an example with you that something
- 43:58came up recently. So it's better to have, if
- 44:01it's really something that's purely on value,
- 44:04and you need an accurate number, and that's what
- 44:06the parties, you should ask them to do that prior
- 44:09to the mediation, or you can pause, or you can
- 44:11do something. I would say that that's outside
- 44:13the box. However, if you're in a mediation, and
- 44:19people have a dispute, and you're able to do
- 44:22an evaluation, and you can take certain multipliers
- 44:25that are customary, And you can say in your opinion,
- 44:28listen, I think this company, based on these
- 44:30kind of multipliers, and the plaintiff and the
- 44:33defense attorneys have to be involved and shouldn't
- 44:35bear all the burden on the mediators, is worth
- 44:38one to three or something like that with their
- 44:40large range. And if that's enough for both sides
- 44:43to feel comfortable to negotiate, then it's the
- 44:46same as any other negotiation. Same as any other
- 44:49negotiation. You know, if you're negotiating
- 44:51between one and three or two and five or whatever
- 44:53the number is, if you guys agree kind of on the
- 44:56on the outskirts of the numbers and you want
- 44:58to resolve it, then maybe the primary focus is
- 45:01not to have an exact valuation. Maybe you don't
- 45:04need to have three point six five million dollars.
- 45:06And here's all the reasons it's worth three point
- 45:08six five million. You know, one will be in a
- 45:11hurry that they want to stop the fighting. One
- 45:12wants to get the money out. One use it for something
- 45:15else. One wants to buy out. He'll overpay. There's
- 45:17many other factors. So in your particular question,
- 45:22if they're really focused on having an accurate
- 45:24number and working from there, I would say yes.
- 45:27But I can also comment that normally if both
- 45:29sides hire business valuators, they will be vastly
- 45:33apart. So it's part of the negotiation. OK. I
- 45:38think that's all the questions that are in the
- 45:41Q &A. So let's move on. Here's an example. This
- 45:46is a wage and hour case. This was a Beverly Hills,
- 45:48very prominent doctor, and it was for improper
- 45:53wages with overtime and meal breaks and things
- 45:55like that. She was exposed to personal liability.
- 46:00The employee was very close to the doctor and
- 46:02had worked for her for many years. The doctor
- 46:04is highly successful and she lives an opulent
- 46:07lifestyle. However, when it came to pay a settlement,
- 46:10she claimed an inability to pay. and the plaintiff
- 46:13didn't buy it for a second because she was basically
- 46:16knew every single thing about this person's life
- 46:18was you know acting an assistant and employee
- 46:21and living through everything and and you know
- 46:24when it came to paying x number of dollars she
- 46:27was not having it so it came up in the mediation
- 46:32and we got stuck we got stuck we were you know
- 46:35numbers that were wildly apart so I said, listen,
- 46:39if you really want to do the inability to pay,
- 46:42provide me this set of documents that we just
- 46:44talked about, and I'll do an evaluation. Stop
- 46:47half an hour, an hour, depending on how complicated
- 46:50it is, how much experience you have doing it.
- 46:53I went through, and shockingly, what the document
- 46:56showed was that the doctor had no idea about
- 46:59her own finances. She was completely getting
- 47:02ripped off by the person who was managing her
- 47:04practice. She had a huge credit card debt. She
- 47:08had loans that she didn't even know about. I
- 47:10mean, she was in really dire straits. I mean,
- 47:12she was just out there living the life but had
- 47:15no idea what was going on. So that was very difficult
- 47:18for her emotionally to deal with in the mediation.
- 47:23But again, very important aspect that people
- 47:25don't focus on is doing this evaluation makes
- 47:29a very strong connection with the person. If
- 47:33you have empathy and you do it in a soft way
- 47:35and you're going through someone's personal life
- 47:37and their numbers where they're the most vulnerable,
- 47:40especially in the city where there's a lot of
- 47:41show off, you get very, very connected to that
- 47:44person. It helps a lot. It helps tremendously.
- 47:51Then carrying that information into the plaintiff's
- 47:53room, again, very, very important. I'll keep
- 47:57repeating it. You have to make sure that you
- 47:59get the OK from the defendant to say exactly
- 48:02what you're going to say. So I write it down
- 48:05on a piece of paper, and I say, this is what
- 48:06I'm going to say. Here's what this shows. Here's
- 48:08what this shows. Here's what this shows. Here's
- 48:10what's going on. Here are the trends. Here's
- 48:12this. Here's that. Here's your debt. Even I might
- 48:16mention, whatever. If you knew about it, here's
- 48:20what's going on. I would like to let them know.
- 48:24get some specific sampling? Can they pick randomly
- 48:27four months or three months out of the two months
- 48:29of bank statements or loan statements? I'll give
- 48:31them opening and closing balances, things like
- 48:34that, which normally they agree to because it's
- 48:36innocuous. And then I take that information into
- 48:39the plaintiff role. And the plaintiff has kind
- 48:43of an aha moment of, wow, they're not sympathetic,
- 48:48I wouldn't say, because they feel like they've
- 48:50been wrong, whether it's you know, lack of proper
- 48:53rages or harassment. I mean, they're not all
- 48:55of a sudden sympathetic for the person. But there's
- 48:59a different feel in the room of evaluating the
- 49:02case, again, for settlement purposes only. Not
- 49:05if we're going to go all the way. Not if we're
- 49:08going to go to trial, and that includes trial
- 49:09budgets and appeals. And, you know, even if we
- 49:12have the absolute best case in the world, a good
- 49:15attorney will tell you it's still 50 -50. None
- 49:17of that. You know, can this person write this
- 49:20check today? That's the question. Can they or
- 49:24can they not? Obviously, they're going to want
- 49:26to write a smaller check and the plaintiff is
- 49:28going to want a bigger check. What is the point?
- 49:33Sadly, or correctly, however you want to look
- 49:36at it, plaintiffs want retribution sometimes
- 49:39through payments. When they think that a million
- 49:42dollars will hurt the person and actually 500
- 49:45,000 or 200 ,000 would be super damaging, they
- 49:48get that same kind of, you know, same kind of
- 49:51retribution and then they can let down their
- 49:53guard and they can focus on what's important
- 49:55for them. You know, how is this money going to
- 49:58change your life? Do you want to move on? Do
- 50:00you want to get this black cloud over your head,
- 50:02that pit in your stomach? Do you want it to be
- 50:04gone? Do you want to use the money for your kids?
- 50:06Do you want to go on a cruise? Do you want to
- 50:07spoil your mom? However you want to do it and
- 50:09they can get focused away from the anger and
- 50:14focus on what they can use the money for. Again,
- 50:18this is another way on the plaintiff side that
- 50:20you have a tremendously personal conversation
- 50:23now with this plaintiff where you're talking
- 50:25about what's going on, you're talking about their
- 50:27personal life, you're making very deep connections,
- 50:32and it allows you to get in and to be good at
- 50:34what you do. Let's go ahead and continue. All
- 50:41right, so I mentioned it again, but I want to
- 50:42go over it. I want to make sure you guys have
- 50:45a slide on it. You've gone through, you've done
- 50:47all the review that we've talked about. You have
- 50:50now all the documents. You have now how to look
- 50:52at all the documents. How do you present it?
- 50:55So again, super important, guys. I'm going to
- 50:57repeat it. If you make this mistake, it can go
- 51:01really bad. So first you do, you present to your
- 51:04defendants. This is based on information that
- 51:07you got from the defendants. You base it. You
- 51:10tell them exactly what you're going to say. You
- 51:12get the permission on the dialogue. You get their
- 51:15commission. You confirm with them that you're
- 51:17not giving any documents. If they want to give
- 51:19them, the lawyer can give them, but you're not
- 51:21doing it. They can share through council. Then
- 51:24if there's any specifics, you get their sign
- 51:26-off on it. When you feel comfortable, and you
- 51:30want the party to be saying yes. At this point,
- 51:33I'm talking to the business owners. Here's what
- 51:36I'm going to tell. this person who's suing you
- 51:38and their attorney are you okay with this this
- 51:41this this this you know and sometimes they're
- 51:44hesitant because they don't you know they don't
- 51:46want to share but you know you have to go ahead
- 51:48and explain without having real information the
- 51:51plaintiff's side is not going to take it into
- 51:52account they're just not going to do it i mean
- 51:55they're not going to believe it so um and then
- 51:58once you do it you go and you present it to the
- 52:00plaintiff And sometimes you just want to simplify
- 52:03it like we talked about earlier, you know, this
- 52:04is not very complicated stuff once you get your
- 52:07hands around it. You'll talk about, listen, a
- 52:09business finances is similar to your personal
- 52:11finances. You have your checking book, they have
- 52:13their checking book. They have money in that,
- 52:15you know, available or they're paying their bills
- 52:17every month. And you just kind of walk through
- 52:19it. If you have permission, you talk about salaries
- 52:23and bonuses because often plaintiffs think that...
- 52:25These owners are making millions and millions
- 52:28of dollars. You talk about debt, you talk about
- 52:30ability to borrow. If there's other litigations
- 52:35out there, you can mention that as well. Let's
- 52:39go ahead. These are some of the common issues
- 52:43that come out. Plaintiff might say, well, the
- 52:46defendant has this huge home up in. in the states
- 52:51or in Malibu or wherever they're living. So you
- 52:54can talk about a homestead exemption, which is,
- 52:56you know, protects the first, it's not very high
- 52:59fairly county numbers. It's currently $722 ,000.
- 53:03So there is a homestead exemption. But again,
- 53:05you know, the focus for those kinds of things
- 53:07is, listen, you know, in order to do that, we
- 53:09have to go all the way to the end. We have to
- 53:12get a judgment. We have to get permission to,
- 53:15to, to have liability to garnish to, to. put
- 53:19a lead amidst a very, very, very difficult time
- 53:21-consuming and not obvious process. So you explain
- 53:24to it, you know, they're going to talk to you
- 53:26about fancy lifestyles. You know, I saw her do
- 53:28this and I saw her do that. And she brought his
- 53:30first class and all these kinds of things. So,
- 53:32you know, you have to be ready to kind of discuss
- 53:34that and how it looks in the documents. This
- 53:38is something that comes up often is the defense,
- 53:41you know, is basically fighting in the mediation
- 53:44saying, oh, we don't have any money. We can't
- 53:46pay. We can't pay. And, you know, it turns out
- 53:49that they do need to pay something and then they
- 53:51ask for a long payment plan. So they'll say,
- 53:54okay, you know, we'll pay 300 ,000, but we need
- 53:56to pay it over five years. Where five minutes
- 53:59ago, they were saying they had no money and they
- 54:00were going out of business. So, you know, that's
- 54:04something you have to be ready for that comes
- 54:06up and be ready to deal with that. Bankruptcy.
- 54:11So everyone, or not everyone, most of the times
- 54:14someone throws out the bankruptcy rule. Well,
- 54:18go ahead. I'm going to go BK. I'm going to do
- 54:20this. Let them sit in line with all the other
- 54:24creditors. So the bankruptcy threat for me has
- 54:29very, very little force. Why? Because people
- 54:33don't understand how devastating it is for a
- 54:36company or an individual to file for bankruptcy.
- 54:39It really wipes you out. It cancels any licensing
- 54:43you have, any borrowing ability, reputation,
- 54:47any credit you have with clients, client relationships.
- 54:51If you want to stay in that sector of business,
- 54:54post -bankruptcy, if you leave people with millions
- 54:57of dollars unpaid debt, you're done. You're done.
- 55:01You're done on a personal level. You have to
- 55:03report it. It's almost impossible to apply for
- 55:07credit. It's almost impossible to do business
- 55:10these days without credit. So it's an extraordinarily
- 55:13game over remedy. And honestly, it's very rare
- 55:18that I see a case that just the case itself will
- 55:22push someone into bankruptcy. So there are cases
- 55:26that have nine lawsuits. And you see the pattern.
- 55:29You see them on the verge. It looks like it.
- 55:32But it's rare when there's a case, especially
- 55:35at the time of mediation, where the person can
- 55:37say with a straight face, if you don't accept
- 55:39this, I'm going to go BK next week. Maybe you'll
- 55:43have to go get your judgment. You'll go BK after
- 55:45the judgment. But then still, the case is going
- 55:47to be open. There's still going to be the stress
- 55:49for the plaintiff and the defendant. So I really
- 55:52downplay the whole bankruptcy. Again, it's a
- 55:57very good way to talk with the defense, with
- 55:59the owners of the company. I hear your lawyer
- 56:02talking to you about bankruptcy. Tell me how
- 56:04that's going to affect your relationships. I
- 56:06mean, you've been in business for 25 years. You
- 56:08have credit with all your vendors. Yes, I do.
- 56:10How's it going to affect? How's it going to do
- 56:12this? How about your licensing? How are you going
- 56:16to do for borrowing moving forward? Are you planning
- 56:19on closing down? And you get that conversation
- 56:21coming out. And the defendant will say, you know
- 56:25what? This is really not an option. This is really
- 56:27more like a game over. I'm not saying it doesn't
- 56:29happen. but I personally discredit it very much
- 56:34in a mediation unless I'm talking with the owners
- 56:37and they say information that makes sense and
- 56:40they're already meeting with counsel and they
- 56:43have their schedules ready and they're on the
- 56:45verge and they rather not and they have 10 different
- 56:47litigations and if they can sell them all for
- 56:5010 cents on the dollar they'll stay alive and
- 56:52if not they'll throw everything into the BK.
- 56:53It happens but for me it's a very very rare.
- 56:56In all the mediation I've done a case has not
- 56:59settled based on a bankruptcy threat, ever. Another
- 57:04issue that will come up is the defense say, OK,
- 57:06we'll go in. We're going to appeal. So great.
- 57:11I mean, most plaintiff attorneys are hoping you're
- 57:13going to appeal. Because if you appeal, as you
- 57:15know, you have to post a bond. And then they
- 57:17don't have to be worried about chasing the money
- 57:19in the future. So the threat of appeal is not
- 57:22something that's very useful. Except, except,
- 57:25and this is a big except, is the timing of the
- 57:28plaintiff getting the money. A lot of these cases
- 57:32settle a case that has a value of let's say $300
- 57:37,000 and the plaintiff who needs money today
- 57:41might be willing to take less faster. For sure,
- 57:45if they have to go all the way to trial and they
- 57:47go to appeal, it's going to be two, three years
- 57:49before it gets resolved and they're old or they
- 57:52have needs or whatever the situation is that
- 57:55they want to have money today. So in terms of
- 57:58the appeal, in terms of the timing, if you win,
- 58:01and also the risk of winning, the unknown if
- 58:03you're risking of winning, is also something
- 58:06that needs to be discussed. And the other thing
- 58:09that, again, depending on how close you are with
- 58:11counsel and the client I talk about often is,
- 58:14listen, have you talked about a trial budget?
- 58:18And the counselor are sometimes hesitant to tell
- 58:20their clients it's going to cost them another
- 58:22150 ,000 to 250 ,000 to go through trial. So
- 58:26I'll prompt that conversation. I'll pull the
- 58:28attorneys out. Have you shared this? Do they
- 58:30understand that they're in it for, whether they
- 58:32lose or not, that they're in it for another 150
- 58:35,000, 250 ,000, cost of depositions, cost of
- 58:38exports today are off the charts. Do they understand
- 58:42that? Do they want to give part of that cost
- 58:44of defense or all of that cost of defense to
- 58:47get rid of this case? If there's a 50 -50 case
- 58:51they're going to lose, they're still going to
- 58:52have to spend that money. So that's another thing
- 58:55that I go over with defense also. All right.
- 59:02I think this is the last example I'll share with
- 59:04you. So this is a real estate case. I actually
- 59:06just did this one a couple of weeks ago. This
- 59:09case was scheduled to start trial that week.
- 59:11It was an eight figure demand. And now at this
- 59:15point, someone asked earlier about forensic experts.
- 59:19So expert reports had just been literally a day
- 59:22before the mediation exchange. Plaintiff had
- 59:24done theirs, defendant had not done their rebuttal.
- 59:26So in the mediation, I asked the forensics to
- 59:29come in. So I brought in the plaintiffs. I asked
- 59:32them to put up their report. I went through it
- 59:34with them. I asked them a lot of questions based
- 59:37on their assumptions. and prodded gently on things
- 59:43where I thought they were pushing it a little
- 59:45bit. Then I did the same thing on the other side.
- 59:49I had the defense forensic expert who had reviewed
- 59:51and written a form of the bottle, come in, what
- 59:54are you thinking? Show me how you're doing your
- 59:56evaluations. In this example, one company as
- 1:00:00a company that went out of business, gave the
- 1:00:03value at over 20 million and the other side had
- 1:00:05it under a million. A huge, huge gap. obviously
- 1:00:09a dispute on liability, but also on just the
- 1:00:12damages if one party won or not. So we were able
- 1:00:16to do the analysis with the experts in the room,
- 1:00:18again, with the defendants, with the business
- 1:00:20people being there in the room with you and talking
- 1:00:24about the assumptions. Is that a fair assumption
- 1:00:27for growth rate? Is that a fair assumption for
- 1:00:30where the industry is going? Is that a fair assumption
- 1:00:35on value of existing clients? And you go through
- 1:00:38and you talk about the assumptions and the businessmen
- 1:00:41that are in the room are shaking their head.
- 1:00:45That's maybe pushing, I don't really agree with
- 1:00:47that. And they're participating. And all of a
- 1:00:49sudden, instead of being between 1 million and
- 1:00:5120 million, we're at three to five million. Without
- 1:00:55anybody confirming it, but a range that feels
- 1:00:58more realistic to people. and it helps to have
- 1:01:01a more defined discussions. The parties are now
- 1:01:04involved in the process. The two business people
- 1:01:06fighting on each side, they know their industries
- 1:01:09very well, and they're participating, and we're
- 1:01:11getting a range. So now we have a fight on liability,
- 1:01:17very difficult liability issues that could go
- 1:01:21everywhere. And then, OK, well, what if you do
- 1:01:23win? What is left? And how much is it going to
- 1:01:26cost you to get there and all the other things?
- 1:01:30So in that case, we did that and we settled the
- 1:01:34case with the more clarity. So it was a financial
- 1:01:37analysis using forensics, but the only reason
- 1:01:39the forensics were used was because they were
- 1:01:43teed up for the trial and that's where the reports
- 1:01:46are. So I put in here before we got that earlier
- 1:01:49question, forensic accounts are very expensive,
- 1:01:52typically not practical option for mediation,
- 1:01:55except when a case is on the eve of trial and
- 1:01:58you have access to those to those documents and
- 1:02:00those reports. And you can be involved in the
- 1:02:03interpretation and getting people, mostly to
- 1:02:09get the parties involved and engaged on how they
- 1:02:12see the valuations also is very important. So
- 1:02:16I think that's, oh, okay, one more slide. So
- 1:02:21second session. Okay. So, you know, some people
- 1:02:24kind of spin their heads thinking, okay, well,
- 1:02:26how is it possible to do this in the middle of
- 1:02:28a mediation? Normally, the issues of inability
- 1:02:31to pay don't even come up until the afternoon.
- 1:02:35How can you get these documents that quickly?
- 1:02:37How can you review them quick enough? I do it.
- 1:02:41I keep the mediation going. It's my practice
- 1:02:43as long as it takes. If the people are able to
- 1:02:46get me the documents. It's five minutes of documents.
- 1:02:50Download a couple years of statements. You should
- 1:02:52have a folder with your tax returns. You should
- 1:02:54have your bank statements. You're running a decent
- 1:02:56sized company. It shouldn't take you more than
- 1:02:5815 minutes to pull these documents together.
- 1:03:01And then with time, with expertise, if you need
- 1:03:05people to help you do it, you can do a quick
- 1:03:08evaluation and get a feel. Again, remembering
- 1:03:11your feeling that you're trying to get now is,
- 1:03:12again, is to influence the mediation. But sometimes
- 1:03:16you just can't get it done. It's too big, it's
- 1:03:19too much information. I have now a company, a
- 1:03:21$2 billion company that we did a first mediation
- 1:03:24on. Again, right on the end, four or five o 'clock
- 1:03:29on a full day mediation says, well, you should
- 1:03:32know that my client doesn't have the ability
- 1:03:34to pay and they're losing tons of money and X,
- 1:03:37Y, and Z. I said, okay, well, why are you just
- 1:03:39mentioning it now? I said, well, we thought we're
- 1:03:41going to get it done for a real number. I said,
- 1:03:43are you able to provide backup? I mean, the plaintiff
- 1:03:46is just not going to take your word. I gave him
- 1:03:49the list of all the information. He sent it to
- 1:03:52his client or went into a different room with
- 1:03:54his client. Client said, I'll provide all of
- 1:03:56that information for Eric's eyes only. And now
- 1:03:59I'm in the process of doing the evaluation. It's
- 1:04:01very, very complicated, everyone, because it's
- 1:04:03such huge numbers. But I'm doing it. And now
- 1:04:06what I'll do is in between the sessions, I'll
- 1:04:09reach out. I'll talk to the CFO. I'll get more
- 1:04:12information if things don't make sense to me.
- 1:04:15So sharing information has a very positive impact
- 1:04:18on the plaintiffs because the default is that
- 1:04:21defendants will say no, usually, to sharing.
- 1:04:24So when a defendant is open and sharing and I
- 1:04:26tell them this is all the stuff I'm looking at,
- 1:04:28I give my summary, they scratch their heads.
- 1:04:30They think, well, maybe there's a serious issue.
- 1:04:32I mean, most companies would not provide this
- 1:04:34information. Maybe I do need to take a pause
- 1:04:37and think about this. And the opposite has happened
- 1:04:40to me also where, you know, there's a claim of
- 1:04:42inability to pay. I had a tech startup saying,
- 1:04:45you know, we can't pay, we can't pay. We'll give
- 1:04:47you all the information. Supposed to have a second
- 1:04:50session. Two weeks later, decided they were gonna
- 1:04:52shut down and not give any information. So that
- 1:04:55obviously made the planet feel like they had
- 1:04:57something to hide. Okay, thank you guys, everyone,
- 1:05:03for attending. We're five minutes over, but I'm
- 1:05:05happy to stick around as long as you like. to
- 1:05:08take questions and if you're ever in the middle
- 1:05:12of doing this or you need to consider how to
- 1:05:14do an evaluation, call me. I really mean it.
- 1:05:17I'm happy to do it. I love doing it. I love mentoring
- 1:05:20people. If you need that feedback, that second
- 1:05:24pair of eyes, it would be my pleasure. Sometimes
- 1:05:28when you're doing something that has a financial
- 1:05:30need, it's good to have maybe a second mediator
- 1:05:32in the room that you can bounce ideas off or
- 1:05:35lean on that person to do that part of the of
- 1:05:38the evaluation for you. All right. Let me see
- 1:05:41if there's any more questions. Okay. So there
- 1:05:48was a question that for the wage and hour case
- 1:05:50with the potential personal liability, do you
- 1:05:52ask for financial documents for both the company
- 1:05:55and the individual? Absolutely. So if we go back
- 1:05:58and you look at that slide, hopefully you have
- 1:06:00the materials, you'll see that I did a financial
- 1:06:02analysis, both on the doctor's business and also
- 1:06:06her personal financials. That's where I was able
- 1:06:08to see where the money was going back in between
- 1:06:11and she was being kept in the dark. Yes, I did
- 1:06:14both of it in that case. Have you had cases where
- 1:06:17the defense walks and what they claim is a bulletproof
- 1:06:20asset protection trust overseas? Again, if the
- 1:06:26defense wants to claim that they are judgment
- 1:06:31-proof or protected and they're never going to
- 1:06:35get to them and they walk, then okay, there's
- 1:06:37nothing you can do. The defendants has to be
- 1:06:42willing to work under the assumption that unless
- 1:06:45the plaintiff can verify through a mediator or
- 1:06:48through something else, the claims that they're
- 1:06:51making, then they're not going to believe it.
- 1:06:54They're just not going to believe it. If somebody
- 1:06:57walks like that, it's for me, it's an example
- 1:06:59of somebody claiming being judgment -proof or
- 1:07:02asset -proof. not wanting to share the information.
- 1:07:05And I don't think that's going to get them very
- 1:07:07far with an aggressive plaintiff attorney. What
- 1:07:11do you do when the opposing party produces unsigned
- 1:07:14tax returns? OK, that's a great question. I normally
- 1:07:20don't focus too much on that issue, if the tax
- 1:07:23returns look real to me, because there's a lot
- 1:07:26of e -filing. So if they seem consistent or multi
- 1:07:29-year, there's nothing that's really fishy. I
- 1:07:33won't focus on that. I might mention it, but
- 1:07:35I won't stop my review to get them. I'm going
- 1:07:38to say, listen, I'm going to jump in. I'm going
- 1:07:39to do the review. But I'd like to ask, how am
- 1:07:42I going to present it to have signed version
- 1:07:43or e -filing certificates? Any other questions?
- 1:07:51OK. Thank you, everyone, for attending. It was
- 1:07:54absolutely my pleasure. I really mean it. Feel
- 1:07:57free to reach out. Any way I can help would be
- 1:08:00my pleasure.