Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 237. Mistake It Till You Make It: Learn Faster and Fail Smarter
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: The best communication is architected for understanding.
- 0:06My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:09Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:11Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:15Today I am really excited to speak with Astro Teller.
- 0:18Astro is a computer scientist, entrepreneur, and inventor.
- 0:22He serves as Captain of Moonshots at X, Alphabet's Moonshot Factory,
- 0:27where he oversees audacious, high impact technology projects.
- 0:31He has written two novels, and the nonfiction book, Sacred Cows: The
- 0:35Truth About Divorce and Marriage that he co-wrote with his wife.
- 0:38He's also a new podcaster, hosting the really fun and
- 0:42insightful The Moonshot Podcast.
- 0:44Welcome Astro.
- 0:46I am super excited to be chatting with you.
- 0:48I've been excited ever since we arranged this.
- 0:50Thank you for being here.
- 0:51Astro Teller: Thanks for having me.
- 0:52Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 0:52Shall we get started?
- 0:53Astro Teller: Yeah, let's do it.
- 0:54Matt Abrahams: To begin, I'd love for you to define for our audience
- 0:57what you mean by a moonshot.
- 0:59Astro Teller: Sure.
- 0:59So we think of this as the blueprint for moonshots, and in order for us to have
- 1:04something that counts as a moonshot, it has to have three components.
- 1:08One, there has to be a huge problem with the world that you
- 1:11can name and you wanna solve.
- 1:13Number two, there has to be some kind of radical proposed solution that, however
- 1:18unlikely it is, you could make that thing.
- 1:21This is like a science fiction sounding product or service.
- 1:24We could agree ahead of time if you could make it, it would resolve
- 1:27that huge problem with the world.
- 1:29And then three, there has to be some kind of breakthrough technology that
- 1:33gives us at least a glimmer of a hope that we could make that science fiction
- 1:37sounding product or service that would solve that huge problem with the world.
- 1:41Once you have those three things, we're not done.
- 1:44That means you have a moonshot story hypothesis, you have a testable
- 1:49hypothesis, and from there the question is how quickly can we verify that you're
- 1:55wrong so we can move on to the next idea?
- 1:59Because anything that fits those three criteria that I just named, exciting
- 2:05as they are, it is exactly because it is so unlikely to work that we have to
- 2:11be constantly pursuing the reality that each one of them is likely to be wrong.
- 2:18Matt Abrahams: So the goal is actually to come up with these audacious
- 2:21ideas and strivings and then to as quickly as possible negate them.
- 2:26Astro Teller: Yeah, of course, we want any particular moonshot we come up with
- 2:30to turn out to be a once in a generation opportunity for the world, but since most
- 2:35of them aren't, wanting to win, wanting to get it to be right, each time leads to
- 2:42sadness after sadness, and denial kicks in that slows up the efficiency of being the
- 2:49learning machine that we would aspire to be, verifying which of the many that we've
- 2:54started is in fact worth doubling down on.
- 2:57Matt Abrahams: You said several things there I wanted to dive deeper into.
- 2:59So you see this as learning, and it's a learning machine, as you
- 3:04said, which leads me to wonder, is there a particular type of mindset
- 3:08that you try to bring about in your organization that looks at it this way?
- 3:12Because many people don't think of projects this way.
- 3:14They start a project, they want it to be successful, not let's start
- 3:16a project and figure out all the reasons why it won't be successful.
- 3:19Can you talk a little bit about that mindset?
- 3:21Astro Teller: Sure.
- 3:21Lemme give you one or two examples.
- 3:23I mean, the first is, if you were working at X, I would say, can we
- 3:27pre agree, before you've come up with something and then fallen in love with
- 3:30it, that if it's a one in a hundred chance of working, it has a ninety-nine
- 3:34percent chance of not working.
- 3:36Which means that if you tie your sense of self-worth to getting a
- 3:41yes, you're just lying to yourself.
- 3:43You think that you are the one percent and you're always gonna win.
- 3:46But this can't be Lake Wobegon, where we're all above average.
- 3:50So that's one way to help put some intellectual guardrails
- 3:54around what we're about to go do.
- 3:55Here's another way of doing it.
- 3:57Think of the last really hard thing that you and a team did.
- 4:01I'd ask each of your listeners to think about that.
- 4:03Now, imagine you lose all of the hardware, all of the software, anything except
- 4:09what's in your and your team's heads.
- 4:11How long, once you've succeeded, would it take for you to go
- 4:14back and rebuild the solution?
- 4:16Having already verified what it is.
- 4:19Most people say somewhere between five and twenty percent of the time that it took.
- 4:23And for moonshots, it's much closer to five percent than twenty percent.
- 4:27Let's call it ten percent on average.
- 4:29What are we gonna call that other ninety percent of the work?
- 4:32It's learning.
- 4:33Most of the work isn't the making of stuff, it's the learning what to make.
- 4:38And the more you are shooting over the horizon, which is what a moonshot is,
- 4:42the more of the journey is exploration, not the settling that happens afterwards.
- 4:49So if you agree conceptually, intellectually that we're on a
- 4:54learning journey, then scary as it is to be wrong, we need to focus on
- 5:00the moments where we learn something.
- 5:02And when do you learn something?
- 5:03You learn something when you have a model about the world, and then
- 5:06in some way you get some data that tells you you are wrong.
- 5:09You learn nothing when you're right.
- 5:11At best, you deepen grooves in your brain.
- 5:13If you are wrong, whatever else we wanna call it, that feels bad.
- 5:17That's a failure of a kind.
- 5:18If you hate failure, you will emotionally avoid that moment, which means
- 5:23you're emotionally avoiding learning.
- 5:25If we just agreed we're gonna spend ninety plus percent of our time
- 5:29learning, then we need to destigmatize failure so we can have our learning
- 5:34loops be as tight as possible.
- 5:36Matt Abrahams: So a moonshot mindset is really about seeing learning as the goal.
- 5:40How do you inculcate and support that, and how do you produce
- 5:44anything if, for many companies, productivity is what's the goal?
- 5:48So how do you produce the amazing things that you've done and help people see
- 5:53learning as the goal, not productivity.
- 5:56Astro Teller: It's very hard to prevent people from chasing progress.
- 5:59Even at X, there's a decent amount of it, even though I'm constantly
- 6:03going around trying to stamp it out and redirect people towards learning.
- 6:06So it's not hard for the end result of a lot of learning to turn into
- 6:13something very valuable that looks ultimately like great progress.
- 6:17During the journey, the thing that is hardest to fight is you feel,
- 6:22especially, once you've done some learning and you've found something
- 6:25that works, it's so hard for you as an X'er not to feel like I found it.
- 6:30I'm right.
- 6:31Now, just let me build it and then I'll give it to the world
- 6:33and we're gonna be great.
- 6:35And I just have to say, we, the leadership at X, have to say over and over again,
- 6:39I know it feels like you found it and you know more about the teleporter, if
- 6:43that's what you're working on, than I do.
- 6:45But I'm telling you from induction, having watched this hundreds of
- 6:48times, now you are not correct yet.
- 6:51You have a lot to learn.
- 6:52And what you think is the answer isn't the answer.
- 6:55It's not that I don't want you to be right, it's just my experience tells
- 6:58me you have a lot more to learn, so I need you to stay in learning mode.
- 7:02Keep your humility and your curiosity really high for
- 7:06another two or three years.
- 7:08It's helping people to do that that's really hard.
- 7:11Matt Abrahams: I find it really interesting that humility and
- 7:13curiosity are what keep the flames going for learning.
- 7:17How do you capture the learning across the different teams?
- 7:21We had Amy Edmondson on, and she talks a lot about the right kind of failure,
- 7:25and learning from the failure, and the processes you can put in place.
- 7:28What are some of the best practices you've implemented?
- 7:30So if somebody learns something, that learning is cascaded so others
- 7:34can benefit from that learning.
- 7:35Astro Teller: There's a bunch of different ways.
- 7:37The truth is, some of it is just institutional knowledge, and that's
- 7:40sort of a background radiation that's very real at X. There are lots of things
- 7:45that we capture, we actually have a document called headwinds and tailwinds
- 7:50to remind us of some of these learnings.
- 7:53These kinds of things tend to be tailwinds in our experience.
- 7:56These kinds of things tend to be headwinds.
- 7:58That doesn't mean you can't ignore one of them if you want
- 8:02to or if you think it's worth it.
- 8:04But these are good reminders from the past that we've learned.
- 8:07We have maybe twenty percent of the people who work at X
- 8:11aren't on one of the projects.
- 8:13They're in these central teams.
- 8:14So this is like finance, legal, public policy, some business development, a
- 8:19lot of sort of hardware prototyping.
- 8:22And what happens is they go over here and they help the teleporter
- 8:25team, and then they go over here and they help the time machine team.
- 8:29And so they act as a kind of vector transplanting interesting ideas and
- 8:35learnings from one team to another.
- 8:37So even if those teams don't talk to each other very much, because they share
- 8:42these central teams, the central teams can move good ideas back and forth.
- 8:46Matt Abrahams: So you actually have a structural element where there are people
- 8:49spoke and hub and the those folks in the hub bring those learnings across.
- 8:52I find that really helpful for other people to think about in their
- 8:55organizations, how they might do that.
- 8:57Astro Teller: Yeah, it is hub and spoke from a help perspective, but
- 9:01it is not, as the concept of the visualization of hub and spoke might
- 9:06imply, a highly top down process.
- 9:09Discovery is mostly a bottoms up process.
- 9:12It's very hard to dictate, so you have to create some structure and
- 9:17guardrails, but then let people be pretty free range within those
- 9:21guardrails, or they won't ultimately find things that are unexpected.
- 9:25Matt Abrahams: So you have to have just enough boundary setting to keep
- 9:29things moving forward, but not so much that people can't be creative.
- 9:32And we've seen that a lot.
- 9:33We've talked a lot about improvisation and how that mindset helps.
- 9:36And in improv, they have some rules and that's what allows for that creativity.
- 9:40Astro Teller: Right.
- 9:41Let me give you an example.
- 9:42Obviously we have to have a performance management system.
- 9:45It'd be weird if we didn't.
- 9:46The temptation across the whole world, so including at the Moonshot Factory, is
- 9:51to have our performance management system be one that rewards people for outcomes.
- 9:56You rang the bell.
- 9:58You got the million dollars or the big deal you signed.
- 10:01Good for you.
- 10:02Bonus promotion, whatever that is.
- 10:04That is the death of radical innovation.
- 10:07Because if I'm asking you to do things that have a one in a hundred chance of
- 10:11success, and then you get rewarded on the basis of a yes of a success, you'll very
- 10:17quickly learn to pretend you're doing radical innovation, but find ways to get
- 10:22the safety of like, okay, maybe it's not as radical, maybe it's not as innovative,
- 10:27but I'll dress it up so it looks like that, and I'm pretty sure I can make
- 10:30this work even if it's not that exciting.
- 10:32And so I'm gonna focus on this thing because I know I'm only gonna
- 10:36get rewarded when I get a yes.
- 10:38All humans will do that.
- 10:40And so the performance management system we have directs people back towards
- 10:45the habits, not towards the outcomes.
- 10:48What are the kinds of things like humility and curiosity that tend to have wild
- 10:55success as a long-term side effect?
- 10:59And then you have to trust, and this is a big scary trust fall, that those outcomes
- 11:03will happen when you focus on the habits.
- 11:06Matt Abrahams: And you have good evidence that will happen.
- 11:08It's harder from a management point of view to measure those kind of things
- 11:12versus did you ring the bell or not?
- 11:14That's a very binary, easy thing to do, so you have to have more flexibility and
- 11:18openness as managers, I guess as well.
- 11:20Astro Teller: Yeah, and this is a struggle to this day at X. It is so much harder to
- 11:25train managers to hold people accountable to habits rather than to outcomes that
- 11:31they routinely will try to find ways to hack the systems so that they can reward
- 11:35people for outcomes, or they'll gripe about their performance management system.
- 11:39I get it, and that's an example where we're trying to create some guardrails.
- 11:44Let them use some creativity within those guardrails, but also make sure
- 11:49that they're pointed in this case towards the habits rather than the outcomes.
- 11:53Matt Abrahams: I really like this idea of rewarding people
- 11:55for habits, not for outcomes.
- 11:57I want to take a step back.
- 11:58We haven't actually heard from you an example or two of
- 12:01what you guys have created.
- 12:02Can you share one moonshot that was successful so we can have
- 12:05an appreciation of the different types of things you work on?
- 12:08Astro Teller: Let me give a few examples.
- 12:10Google Brain, which is one of the places that caused the explosion of
- 12:16industrialized machine learning that is now the sort of hot topic in the world,
- 12:20that came from X. That's an example.
- 12:22Uh, the self-driving cars now called Waymo.
- 12:24Those came from X. Uh, Wing, the drones for package delivery, which are actually
- 12:30doing almost as well as Waymo and people haven't caught on that it's going to
- 12:36be as big a deal, that came from X. And I will give some more examples,
- 12:40but let me use Waymo as an example.
- 12:42So this is now fifteen years ago.
- 12:45Huge problem with the world.
- 12:47More than a million people a year die in car accidents in the
- 12:50world because of human error.
- 12:52More than a trillion dollars is wasted between sitting in traffic
- 12:57and all of the costs of the accidents, even leaving death aside.
- 13:01Between a million lives and a trillion dollars, that's a problem worth fixing.
- 13:05Radical proposed solution.
- 13:07What if, just like we got to the place with elevators where we
- 13:12realized you didn't have to have a human driving the elevator.
- 13:16You could just trust the elevator to drive itself.
- 13:19We could get behind the idea that if they could drive themselves, we could get to
- 13:26the place where these metal boxes, like an elevator, take the passengers where
- 13:31they need to go, and you just push a button and say, here's where I want to go.
- 13:35And it takes you there much safer.
- 13:37And there's all kinds of benefits, including, maybe particularly, the lives
- 13:41that are being saved because those metal boxes can now take themselves there much,
- 13:48much safer than a human driving the car.
- 13:50So that's the radical proposed solution.
- 13:53And then there was a set of, at the time, new technologies, how to coordinate lidar,
- 13:59radar, and cameras around a vehicle.
- 14:04There had been some evidence, before we started on what is now called
- 14:08Waymo, from the DARPA Grand Challenges.
- 14:11The first of which in 2006 was one by Stanford here.
- 14:18That car was called stanley.
- 14:20Matt Abrahams: And DARPA, just so people understand, is something that the US
- 14:22Federal Government, it's a funding source for creative ideas that can
- 14:26be used for defense and other things.
- 14:28Astro Teller: Exactly.
- 14:28And so there was this worldwide, or at least countrywide, grand
- 14:31challenge that was announced about cars that could drive themselves.
- 14:35And while even in the second time it was run, there were three groups
- 14:40that completed the hundred and fifty miles, they were out in a desert.
- 14:43It was one one thousandth the difficulty of what Waymo currently has to do,
- 14:48but it was enough evidence that maybe it just, maybe it was time.
- 14:52Matt Abrahams: I love that example and many people listening perhaps
- 14:55have not seen a Waymo or been in one, I have, and where I live is
- 14:59where a lot of them were tested.
- 15:01So I'm a little more used to it.
- 15:02It is freaky to be in the back of a car that has no driver, but
- 15:05it is absolutely cool as well.
- 15:08I want to come to something that you just did.
- 15:11You just told us, not just about Waymo, but you told us a story.
- 15:15How important is storytelling in defining and realizing moonshots?
- 15:20Astro Teller: I think storytelling is phenomenally important.
- 15:23But I watch people at the Moonshot Factory get a little bit confused about this.
- 15:28At least when I say storytelling, I don't primarily mean marketing
- 15:32or just getting someone excited.
- 15:34I mean, if you worked at X and you're proposing that we start a moonshot for
- 15:39teleportation, let's say, I need from you an architecture of understanding.
- 15:45Where are we trying to go?
- 15:47What makes us think we might be able to get from where we are to there?
- 15:52And how should we interpret things along the way?
- 15:54What's that set of lily pads that you can envision?
- 15:58You'll be wrong.
- 15:58I'm fine with the fact that you're wrong, but if you can't paint that picture
- 16:03so that we have a hypothesis to test, it's very hard to get behind the idea
- 16:09that the upside of getting there will be worth the risks if you can't even
- 16:13paint an idealized picture of how we would get there in a controlled way,
- 16:18where the costs aren't out of control, where nobody gets hurt, et cetera.
- 16:22Matt Abrahams: The idea of an architecture of understanding is what a story provides.
- 16:26And the outcome of the story for you that's important is a hypothesis that
- 16:29can be tested, and that's a really unique way, I think, of looking at storytelling.
- 16:34So you've added podcast host to your list of titles and accomplishments.
- 16:38What do you think about the hosting gig and what motivated you to start the show?
- 16:42I listen and I love it.
- 16:43I've learned a lot.
- 16:44It's really cool for me to be in person with you after having
- 16:47listened to you in my headset.
- 16:49What brought it about?
- 16:50Astro Teller: First, if people are interested, they can just look up
- 16:52Moonshot Factory, Moonshot Podcast.
- 16:56We were turning fifteen years old and at least one of the things was, you
- 16:59know, we're trying to get a little bit less secret and we wanted to
- 17:02start exposing some of how we work and what we've done, what we've learned.
- 17:08Partly because we want to empower other people to take their own moonshots and
- 17:13giving them that learning opportunity, hopefully gives them a boost.
- 17:18Rather than me, just blah, blahing about moonshot taking, what we've done is we've
- 17:24sliced it up into about fifty minute episodes, ten of them in the first season,
- 17:29where we've given people who've come through The Moonshot Factory a chance to
- 17:33tell their stories, what they've learned.
- 17:36So you get to hear in the first person what it was like
- 17:38to be taking those moonshots.
- 17:40And these are some people who are now luminaries in their
- 17:43field, Sebastian Thrun, or Andrew Ng, or Jeff Dean, and others.
- 17:48And how did we get to something like Google Brain?
- 17:50How did we get to something like Waymo, the self-driving cars?
- 17:55And when you hear from them the mistakes they made or those initial things that
- 17:59gave them the faith to start, that, that seed crystal that they thought
- 18:04was worth building on, I hope it then helps other people, not only understand
- 18:09us and the moonshots we take, but inspire them to go do some of their own.
- 18:13Matt Abrahams: It's very inspirational and it's really cool to hear in
- 18:16their own words what they've done.
- 18:18And there are learnings that come.
- 18:19I have listened and thought differently about ways I team with
- 18:23people and the ways that I think about the decisions I need to make.
- 18:27So I'm excited that you're doing it and I'm excited to listen to season two.
- 18:31Before we end, I ask all my guests three questions.
- 18:34One I create just for you, and then the other two are similar.
- 18:36Are you up for that?
- 18:37Astro Teller: Sure.
- 18:38Matt Abrahams: I'd be very curious, what's a current moonshot you're
- 18:40working on that has you really excited?
- 18:42Astro Teller: We started this about eight years ago.
- 18:44This is very typical of the moonshots we take.
- 18:46They seem crazy when we start them, and then at least occasionally, much
- 18:50later, they turn out to be in the right place at the right time, is
- 18:53a moonshot for the electric grid.
- 18:56It turns out that everyone would like to make software that helps the
- 19:00electric grid get better, including us.
- 19:02And you can't.
- 19:04You can't until somebody has a circuit diagram for the grid itself.
- 19:11If you don't have a digital twin for the grid where every wire is, where every
- 19:16inverter is, where every transformer is, no software on top of that will help
- 19:21you manage what you have or plan for the future or optimize it in real time.
- 19:26And so what our team, Tapestry, did over the last seven years was build out
- 19:33the tools for taking in a wide variety of data, including the very noisy and
- 19:38imperfect data that grid operators have about their own grid, 'cause they
- 19:42don't have a map of their own grid.
- 19:44And then using lots of different sources, street view cars, drone data, satellite
- 19:50data, lots of different inputs, we can then use induction and deduction to do
- 19:56the detective work and back out the exact grid that a particular grid operator has.
- 20:03And then we can help them manage the grid they have, plan for
- 20:07the future of their grid, and optimize their grid in real time.
- 20:11Matt Abrahams: So it's as if you've decoded the genome for the grid and
- 20:13now we can do some work with it.
- 20:15That sounds very useful and hopefully very beneficial.
- 20:19Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 20:22Astro Teller: I enjoy giving public talks, and so oration has
- 20:27always been very interesting to me.
- 20:28And I have watched a wide variety of public speakers, not because I'm going
- 20:34to be any one of them, but to understand how each of their patters functions.
- 20:40You know, Martin Luther King Jr., great speaker, his preacher style, there
- 20:44are things you can learn from that.
- 20:47James Baldwin, amazing speaker, not a preacher, somewhat professorial, but
- 20:53with a calm angriness because of the specifics of the life that he led.
- 20:59Barack Obama very professorial.
- 21:02My grandfather, Edward Teller, actually, was another great public
- 21:06speaker, and I learned a lot from watching each of these people.
- 21:10Matt Abrahams: Yeah, they each bring a really interesting approach that you can
- 21:13then synthesize, and by the way, your TED talk is one that everybody should
- 21:16listen to because you deliver it very well and it's very exciting to learn from.
- 21:20Final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into a
- 21:23successful communication recipe?
- 21:26Astro Teller: I personally don't love the start with a personal story.
- 21:30I would encourage people to get real, as in honest, get
- 21:36specific, and you can be human.
- 21:40So when we tell a story, like in our podcast, we use visuals from the field,
- 21:48from the actual people who were doing it.
- 21:50We explain what we were trying to do and how where we actually
- 21:55ended up wasn't that, getting real.
- 21:58We show people how we harvest value, even from being wrong, and can have
- 22:03fun in the process of learning.
- 22:05And when you get a cycle of those three things, while that doesn't feel like Mary
- 22:10Jane in Idaho start of the sort of New York Times article, it is deeply human.
- 22:16You can feel what it feels like for these people to go through it.
- 22:19It's exciting, it's meaningful.
- 22:21You can see yourself in it.
- 22:23It's memorable because of those things.
- 22:25So that's how we try to do it.
- 22:27Matt Abrahams: Be real, be specific, be human, and all of that allows
- 22:30you to connect through emotion.
- 22:32I appreciate that recipe, and I appreciate this conversation, Astro.
- 22:35This was fantastic.
- 22:36You've talked about architecting to understanding, and you certainly did
- 22:39that for us, and I hope all of us can build these habits and reward ourselves
- 22:43for these habits and not just outcomes.
- 22:45Thank you for your time.
- 22:46Astro Teller: Thank you.
- 22:46That was a lot of fun.
- 22:50Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 22:52Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 22:54To learn more about creativity and innovation, please listen to episode 70
- 22:58and 20 with Jeremy Utley and Tina Seelig.
- 23:01This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 23:07Our music is by Floyd Wonder.
- 23:08With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 23:11Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 23:14Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 23:17Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok ,and Instagram.
- 23:20And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 23:24learning content, and our newsletter.
- 23:27Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes,
- 23:31AMAs, Ask Matt Anythings, and much more at fastersmarter.io/premium.