Latest / Deep Dive / Why Everyone Lies About Your Business Idea (And How to Find the Truth)
Transcript
- 0:00If you walk up to your own mother right now, like today,
- 0:03and pish her your most brilliant, carefully thought out
- 0:07business. Idea Oh, she's going to lie to
- 0:09you? Just directly to your face.
- 0:11Absolutely. And welcome to the deep dive.
- 0:13We are so thrilled to have you here with us.
- 0:15We always consider you the listener, to be like the
- 0:18essential third person in these conversations.
- 0:21And today, you and I are going to learn how to become human lie
- 0:25detectors. Though we should probably
- 0:29clarify right up front, right? We aren't talking about studying
- 0:31micro expressions or, you know, looking for shifting eyes or
- 0:34anything like that. Right, no polygraphs today.
- 0:36Yeah, exactly. We're talking about
- 0:37fundamentally changing the questions we ask and really how
- 0:40we view the very concept of value itself.
- 0:43Which is something I mean we just desperately need.
- 0:46Because whether you're trying to launch a startup, pitch a new
- 0:50workflow to your boss, or honestly buy a gift for someone
- 0:54who is impossible to shop for. Oh, I know that pain.
- 0:57Right. We spent a chunk of our lives
- 0:59trying to figure out what people actually want, and our default
- 1:02method for doing that is just completely broken.
- 1:06Totally broken. So to figure out how to fix it,
- 1:08we have this incredibly cool stack of sources today.
- 1:12First, we're pulling from the Mom Test by Rob Fitzpatrick.
- 1:15Great book. Yeah, it's basically a street
- 1:18smart tactical survival guide for entrepreneurs who are just
- 1:22tired of being lied to by polite customers.
- 1:24And to ground those on the ground, tactics, we're pairing
- 1:27it with a deeply influential academic paper.
- 1:31It's by scholars Robert Lush and Stephen Vargo.
- 1:34Yes, the heavy hitters. Yeah.
- 1:35And it's a defense of this paradigm shifting economic
- 1:38theory they call service Dominant logic or SD logic.
- 1:42OK, so what's fascinating here is that while Fitzpatrick gives
- 1:44us the conversational rules to like, stop getting bad data.
- 1:48Lush and Vargo give us the underlying economic
- 1:50architecture, right? They explain the mechanics of
- 1:53why those rules actually work. So we're essentially connecting
- 1:56the dots between, you know, a casual coffee shop customer
- 1:59interview and a high level macroeconomic theory.
- 2:02I just love it. Let's get right into the biggest
- 2:04trap, which Fitzpatrick calls the pathos problem.
- 2:07This is such a common mistake. It really is.
- 2:10Because we are terrified of failure.
- 2:12We tend to go to people and ask is this a good idea?
- 2:17But the moment you do that, you've ruined the experiment.
- 2:20Like you've exposed your ego. You are essentially begging them
- 2:24for emotional validation. Right.
- 2:25And because human beings are social creatures, you know, we
- 2:30prioritize politeness over brutal honesty.
- 2:33So they will give you that validation.
- 2:35Every single time. They absolutely will.
- 2:37I mean, it's a defense mechanism for social cohesion.
- 2:40And if we connect this to the bigger picture, the reason we
- 2:44asked that terrible question in the 1st place is because we're
- 2:46operating under a flawed economic worldview, OK?
- 2:49Lay it on us. So Lush and Vargo, call it
- 2:51Goods, Dominant logic or GD logic.
- 2:54For the last couple of centuries, basically thanks to
- 2:57the Industrial Revolution, we've been completely obsessed with
- 3:00the unit of output, the tangible thing.
- 3:03Like the widget on the assembly line.
- 3:04Precisely the widget. Under GD logic, we assume that
- 3:07value is something manufactured inside a factory and then
- 3:10embedded into a physical product or, you know, a piece of
- 3:13software. So when you ask someone do you
- 3:16like this idea, you're asking them to evaluate the object
- 3:19itself, completely divorced from the context of their actual
- 3:23life. OK, let's unpack this with the
- 3:24sources example because it just perfectly illustrates how
- 3:27painful this trap is. Imagine an entrepreneur wants to
- 3:30build a cookbook app for the iPad.
- 3:33Oh yeah, I remember this. One yeah, so he goes to his mom,
- 3:36ego fully exposed, he asks you use your iPad a lot, right?
- 3:41Would you buy an app that's like a cookbook for $40?
- 3:45Such a loaded question. Exactly.
- 3:48Now she doesn't want to hurt his feelings so she gives this
- 3:50polite non committal. Which he immediately interprets
- 3:53as oh I need to pitch harder. Right.
- 3:55Instead of backing off, he starts listing features.
- 3:57It has videos and a built in shopping list.
- 4:00You just dig in a hole. Yep, the pressure mounts.
- 4:02She doesn't want to be unsupportive, so she finally
- 4:04caves and says Oh yes honey, that sounds amazing, $40 is a
- 4:08great deal. Will it have pictures of the
- 4:10food? And he walks away thinking he
- 4:12has ironclad market validation. He goes and spends like 6 months
- 4:16coding this thing, entirely unaware that he just built a
- 4:20business based on a polite fiction.
- 4:22Because he focused on the good, the app itself, and ignored the
- 4:26underlying human reality, he forced her to rationalize a
- 4:30price outside of an actual purchase environment.
- 4:33And Fitzpatrick actually uses this brilliant analogy that I
- 4:36just can't stop thinking about. He says trying to learn from
- 4:39customer conversations is like excavating A delicate
- 4:42archaeological site. That's a great way to look at
- 4:44it. Right.
- 4:45The truth about what someone actually values is buried deep
- 4:49underground, and it's incredibly fragile.
- 4:51When you walk in and ask, is my product a good idea?
- 4:56It's like bringing a bulldozer and dynamite to the excavation.
- 4:59You just obliterate. It you shatter the truth into a
- 5:02million useless pieces. It's a perfect visual.
- 5:05You destroy the site because your tools are just too blunt to
- 5:08excavate properly. You have to throw out goods
- 5:10dominant logic entirely. OK, So what do we replace it
- 5:13with? You have to stop looking at the
- 5:15object and start looking at the benefit the person is trying to
- 5:19achieve. And this brings us to Lush and
- 5:22Vargo's alternative framework Service.
- 5:25Dominant logic, right? But to understand it we have to
- 5:29completely redefine the word service.
- 5:31OK, I am bracing myself because academic definitions can get a
- 5:34little dense. I promise it straightforward.
- 5:37So in SD Logic service, and that's singular, is the
- 5:41application of specialized competences.
- 5:44Meaning what exactly? That means applying your
- 5:46knowledge and your skills for the benefit of another person.
- 5:50Under this framework, a physical product is never the end goal.
- 5:54A physical product is simply a distribution mechanism for
- 5:56service provision. OK, wait, let me stop you right
- 5:58there because I read that part of the source and I have to
- 6:00admit I was skeptical. Fair enough.
- 6:03If I go to the hardware store and buy a lawnmower, I am buying
- 6:06a machine with metal blades and a gas engine.
- 6:09Calling a lawnmower a service feels like we're just playing
- 6:12academic word games. I get that it does sound like a
- 6:15semantic trick at first glance, but this raises an important
- 6:18question. Why did you buy the lawnmower?
- 6:21Well, to cut the grass. Exactly.
- 6:23You didn't buy a lawnmower because you wanted to own a
- 6:25collection of metal blades and spark plugs.
- 6:28I mean true. You bought it because you wanted
- 6:30the outcome of a neatly trimmed yard, perhaps to maintain your
- 6:33property value or to have a nice place for your kids to play.
- 6:36OK. Yeah, that makes sense.
- 6:38The manufacturer applied their engineering knowledge into a
- 6:41physical form so that you could achieve that benefit.
- 6:44If you view the lawn mower as a good, you obsess over the motor.
- 6:48Right. If you view it as a mechanism
- 6:50for service provision, you are forced to look at the human
- 6:53behavior. Oh I see, so it forces you to
- 6:55look at the human beings goal rather than the chunk of metal?
- 6:59Precisely. And this shift in perspective is
- 7:01so vital that Lush and Vargo built their entire theory around
- 7:06it, arguing that all economies are, at their core, service
- 7:09economies. This is their foundational
- 7:11premise 6. Now, didn't the text mention
- 7:14some pushback on that from other economists?
- 7:16Something about modern trends. Yeah, definitely.
- 7:20Critics like O'Shaughnessy and O'Shaughnessy argue that SD
- 7:22logic was really just a trendy reaction to the fact that
- 7:26Western economies have shifted their GNP heavily towards
- 7:30service industries. Like consulting and software
- 7:33instead of manufacturing. Exactly.
- 7:35But Lush and Vargo firmly reject that.
- 7:38They argue that since the dawn of human trade, every exchange
- 7:42has always been about exchanging applied knowledge and skills.
- 7:46We just got temporarily blinded by the mass production of
- 7:49physical goods during the industrial era.
- 7:51And this blindness is exactly what leads to what the MOM test
- 7:55calls a premature Zoom. Yes, the premature zoom.
- 7:58If you forget that you are looking for the underlying
- 8:01behavior, you zoom in on a fake problem.
- 8:04The book has this great scenario about a fitness app.
- 8:07Let's say you're trying to build something in the health space.
- 8:10So you walk up to a guy and ask what is your biggest problem
- 8:12with going to the gym? Well, there's the bulldozer
- 8:14again. You're already assuming he cares
- 8:15about in the first place. Yes, you've prematurely zoomed
- 8:18in, and because of that human desire to be polite and helpful,
- 8:22he's going to invent a problem for you.
- 8:23He's going to lie. Yeah, he'll say, well, the
- 8:26commute to the gym is just too long.
- 8:27I guess it's a convenience issue.
- 8:29So you run back to your laptop and spend a year building an at
- 8:32home. Super convenient fitness app.
- 8:35Oh no. But what you failed to excavate
- 8:37was that this guy hasn't voluntarily exercised since high
- 8:40school. His actual behavior is sitting
- 8:43on the couch. Right, he described his
- 8:45idealized self, not his actual. Self Exactly, which is why
- 8:49Fitzpatrick says you must anchor people to their past actions,
- 8:52not future hypotheticals. That is so key past actions.
- 8:56Instead of asking about his biggest gym problem, you ask
- 8:59when was the last time you worked out?
- 9:00He says five years ago. You ask why?
- 9:03He says, I just really don't care about fitness.
- 9:05Boom, you just saved yourself a year of your life.
- 9:08And this highlights the core danger of qualitative feedback.
- 9:11Once you start talking to people, you're going to
- 9:13encounter a mountain of noise, no?
- 9:16And both of our sources agree that if a conversation ends with
- 9:19someone saying this is a great idea, I love it.
- 9:22You haven't actually succeeded, you've just collected bad data.
- 9:25OK, let's drill down into that bad data because Fitzpatrick
- 9:28categorizes it into 3 distinct traps that we need to actively
- 9:33deflect. Compliments, fluff and ideas.
- 9:37OK, let's start with compliments.
- 9:38Now compliments are the most insidious because they feel so
- 9:41incredibly good. Someone says I love the design
- 9:44or this is brilliant. It just strokes the ego you
- 9:46exposed. But it's fool's gold.
- 9:48It cost them nothing to say it, and it gives you a false
- 9:51positive. The source advises that when you
- 9:54get a compliment, you have to emotionally ignore it and
- 9:56deflect. Just brush past it.
- 9:58Yeah, you just say thanks so much, but let's get back to how
- 10:01you currently handle this workflow.
- 10:03You pivot away from the praise. Which leads right into the
- 10:06second trap. Fluff.
- 10:08Fluff is anytime someone speaks in generic statements like I
- 10:11usually do this. Or far more dangerously, when
- 10:15they make future tense hypothetical promises.
- 10:17Oh. Those are the worst.
- 10:18Yeah, like I might use that or I could see myself paying for
- 10:21this. The book actually shares a
- 10:23terrifying anecdote about fluff. The author talks about a startup
- 10:28he was involved with where they fell for the ultimate fluff
- 10:31phrase. I definitely buy that.
- 10:33Ouch. They heard that phrase enough
- 10:35times that they went all in. They thought they had market
- 10:38validation, and that polite future tense hypothetical ended
- 10:42up costing them $10 million. $10 million evaporated because of a
- 10:47conversational pleasantry. It's mind blowing.
- 10:49When you ask a hypothetical question, people don't answer
- 10:52based on reality, they answer based on who they wish they
- 10:55were. The best version of themselves.
- 10:57Exactly the person who always budgets perfectly, who exercises
- 11:02daily, who keeps their inbox at 0.
- 11:04So when you hear that fluff, you have to anchor it back to
- 11:06reality. How do you do that?
- 11:08Well if someone says I would definitely use a budgeting app,
- 11:11you don't say great you ask. Have you ever searched for a
- 11:14budgeting up? Show me what you did last week
- 11:17when you realize you overspent. So you force them to point to a
- 11:20specific historical application of their competences.
- 11:24Exactly. And that brings us to the third
- 11:26type of bad data, which I think trips up a lot of really smart
- 11:29people ideas or feature requests.
- 11:32Yeah, this is a big. One, when someone says it would
- 11:35be amazing if this synced directly with my calendar, our
- 11:38instinct is to write that down as a brilliant suggestion.
- 11:42Because we treat it as a directive rather than a symptom.
- 11:44Right. And there is a wild story in the
- 11:46text that perfectly captures why this is so dangerous.
- 11:50A founder was building an analytics dashboard and pitched
- 11:53it to MTV. OK, the MTV executive said.
- 11:57We need you to add custom data analytics.
- 12:00So the team spends months building this gorgeous
- 12:03Interactive Data dashboard. They launch it and MTV doesn't
- 12:06even log. In, of course not.
- 12:08Instead, the reps say, actually, could you just e-mail us a CSV
- 12:11file of the numbers? The frustration those developers
- 12:14must have felt. Oh, but it gets worse.
- 12:16No way. Yeah.
- 12:16So they build an automated CSV exporter.
- 12:19Then MTV comes back and says, actually, can you make it APDF
- 12:22and stick our company logo in the corner?
- 12:24You're kidding. Finally, the founder is just
- 12:26losing his mind. He asks the MTV reps Why do you
- 12:30want this? None of you are actually reading
- 12:33the data. What do they?
- 12:34Say the MTV Rep casually responds.
- 12:36Oh, we don't look at the data. Our clients just really like
- 12:39getting a fancy report emailed to them every Friday.
- 12:43It makes them feel like we're doing a lot of work.
- 12:46A stunning revelation of what was actually happening, right?
- 12:48They didn't want data analysis, they wanted a tool for client
- 12:51appeasement. If that founder had just paused
- 12:54when they asked for analytics and said talk to me about why
- 12:57you need that, what happens if he don't have it?
- 12:59He could have saved months of heavy software development.
- 13:02Seriously, he could have just had an intern manually type up a
- 13:05one page PDF every Friday. This MTV story perfectly
- 13:10illuminates one of the most vital and perhaps
- 13:13counterintuitive concepts in SD logic.
- 13:16They call it Foundational Premise 10, which states that
- 13:19value is always uniquely and phenomenologically determined by
- 13:23the beneficiary. OK, phenomenologically
- 13:26determined. You're going to have to
- 13:27translate that for me. Like how does that actually work
- 13:29in the real world? It's a dense academic term,
- 13:31sure, but the mechanics of it are actually quite elegant.
- 13:35It means that value is not an objective reality, OK?
- 13:38It doesn't exist inside the lines of code or the sleep
- 13:41design of a product. Value only springs into
- 13:44existence based entirely on the lived experience and perception
- 13:48of the person using it. Oh I see.
- 13:49So to the founder, the value was complex data sorting.
- 13:53Yes, but phenomenologically, in the actual lived experience of
- 13:57the MTV Rep, the value was entirely about avoiding an angry
- 14:02phone call from a client. So the value isn't what I say it
- 14:05is, it's whatever the user experiences it to be.
- 14:07Exactly. If you don't dig beneath the
- 14:10feature requests, you will build what you think is valuable and
- 14:13completely miss the phenomenological value that the
- 14:16user is actually willing to pay for.
- 14:18Which brings up a really crucial dilemma.
- 14:20If compliments are bad data, if hypotheticals cost you $10
- 14:23million, and if feature requests lead you down a rabbit hole of
- 14:26misunderstanding, how do we know when we are actually succeeding?
- 14:30If we strip away all the polite noise, what is the actual
- 14:32signal? Well, this is where we have to
- 14:34transition from gathering information to securing action.
- 14:37And here's where it gets really interesting, because Fitzpatrick
- 14:41points out that having a pipeline full of what he calls
- 14:44zombie leads is basically the entrepreneurial equivalent of
- 14:48being put in the friend zone. I love that analogy.
- 14:51Explain how that plays out. Well, think about it.
- 14:54You have these people who keep taking meetings with you.
- 14:57They constantly tell you your idea is brilliant.
- 14:59They say you're so smart, but they never actually pull out
- 15:02their credit card, right? You are constantly hanging out,
- 15:05grabbing coffees, having pleasant conversations, but the
- 15:08relationship is never actually advancing.
- 15:12You're stuck in a cycle of polite inaction.
- 15:14You're burning your own resources while receiving
- 15:16absolutely nothing in return. So how do you break out of the
- 15:19friend zone? You have to force a resolution.
- 15:21OK, how? The source argues that a meeting
- 15:23is only successful if it ends with real advancement or a
- 15:26tangible commitment, and a commitment is not a promise to
- 15:30touch base later. No, definitely not.
- 15:32A real commitment means the person is willingly giving up a
- 15:35currency and in the business world there are three major
- 15:38currencies, time, reputation or cash.
- 15:42And if they aren't willing to part with one of those three,
- 15:45you have collected absolutely 0 signal.
- 15:47Exactly, and let's be clear about what giving up time
- 15:50actually looks like. It's not a 5 minute phone call.
- 15:52No, a time commitment is them saying I will sit down with you
- 15:55for two hours next Tuesday to beta test this software with my
- 15:59whole engineering team. That's a real investment.
- 16:02Right. And reputation risk means they
- 16:05are putting their own social capital on the line.
- 16:07They're willing to introduce you to their boss, the key decision
- 16:10maker, or they're willing to give a public testimonial.
- 16:12Which is huge. Yeah, and cash obviously is a
- 16:15deposit, signing a letter of intent or buying a prototype.
- 16:19This concept of force commitment is deeply tied to how Lush and
- 16:22Vargo view the actual creation of value in an economy.
- 16:27How so? In SD Logic, they argue that an
- 16:30enterprise cannot deliver value, it can only make value
- 16:33propositions. This is foundational premise 7.
- 16:36Wait, really? So a business can't actually
- 16:38hand someone value in a box? We're just making suggestions.
- 16:41That is precisely what they argue.
- 16:43You can offer the potential for value.
- 16:46You can build the lawnmower, but the value doesn't materialize
- 16:50until the customer actively participates.
- 16:52SD logic calls this value Co creation.
- 16:56Value isn't created in a factory, it is Co created in the
- 16:59market through interaction. So when Fitzpatrick says you
- 17:04must force a commitment, he is essentially demanding evidence
- 17:07of value Co creation. I see the connection now.
- 17:10If the customer isn't willing to give up a currency, their time,
- 17:13their reputation, their money, then they are not participating.
- 17:16They are not Co creating and therefore objectively no value
- 17:21actually exists regardless of how many times they say.
- 17:23I love this idea. It is the ultimate reality
- 17:25check. But I have to say, practically
- 17:27speaking, asking for that commitment can feel super
- 17:29awkward. Most of us are terrified of
- 17:31coming across as a pushy, needy salesperson.
- 17:35We don't want to ruin the pleasant vibe of the meeting.
- 17:37It requires a significant shift in posture.
- 17:39How does the text suggest we navigate that awkwardness?
- 17:42Well, Fitzpatrick suggests a brilliant mental trick called
- 17:45the advisory flip. OK, I like the sound of that.
- 17:47Yeah, instead of going into a meeting with a needy mindset,
- 17:51desperate for them to validate your ego or buyer product, you
- 17:55completely flip the script. You go in evaluating.
- 17:58Them evaluating them. Yes, you mentally frame the
- 18:01interaction as a search for industry advisors.
- 18:04You are looking for knowledgeable people who
- 18:06actually understand the nuances of the problem you're trying to
- 18:09solve. That completely changes the
- 18:11power dynamic in the room. You're no longer subordinate
- 18:14asking for a favor. Exactly.
- 18:16You aren't begging for a sale, you are assessed if they have
- 18:19the vision to see the problem clearly and if they try to brush
- 18:22you off with a stalling tactic like this.
- 18:24Sounds great. Let me know when it launches a.
- 18:25Classic brush off. Right.
- 18:27You use that advisory posture to push for a commitment.
- 18:30Today you say, actually, could you introduce me to your tech
- 18:33team so I can make sure I understand the integration
- 18:35hurdles? Pushing for reputation risk.
- 18:37Yes, or the absolute gold standard the book mentions.
- 18:41Is someone asking can I just buy this messy prototype right now?
- 18:45Which is the ultimate currency exchange.
- 18:47It is. And here's the best part.
- 18:49If you push for that commitment and they say no.
- 18:51That's a good thing. That is still a massive win.
- 18:54Rejection is fantastic data. It finally gets you out of the
- 18:57friend zone. It's the wishy washy, polite
- 19:00middle ground that slowly drains your bank account and your
- 19:03sanity. It is a rigorous, sometimes
- 19:06uncomfortable process, but an an entirely necessary one.
- 19:10By forcing the issue, you're forcing the market to show its
- 19:13true hand. You move past the superficial
- 19:15obsession with the product itself, and you engage in the
- 19:19real, messy work of uncovering applied human competences.
- 19:24OK, So bringing this all together for you, the listener,
- 19:26we've covered a massive amount of ground today bridging the gap
- 19:29between street smart entrepreneurial hustle and the
- 19:32deep macroeconomic architecture of how markets actually function
- 19:36It's. A lot to process.
- 19:37But synthesizing this gives you a legitimate superpower.
- 19:40Whether you're prepping for a high stakes boardroom pitch,
- 19:42trying to figure out if your side hustle has legs, or just
- 19:45trying to navigate human relationships, you now know the
- 19:48secret to cutting through the noise.
- 19:50The polite noise. Right.
- 19:52You know to ignore the polite compliments.
- 19:54You know, to steer people away from their idealized future
- 19:58tense hypotheticals and drill down into the reality of their
- 20:01past actions. Actions speak louder than words.
- 20:03Always you understand that a physical product is never the
- 20:06goal, it's just a delivery mechanism for a service.
- 20:10And most importantly, you know that opinions are entirely
- 20:13worthless. Just utterly worthless.
- 20:15You have to look for tangible commitments of time, reputation
- 20:18or cash to prove that real value is actually being Co created.
- 20:22It's a profoundly powerful lens through which to view human
- 20:26interaction, and I think it leaves us with a lingering,
- 20:30somewhat philosophical thought to Mull over.
- 20:32Oh, I love a good philosophical thought.
- 20:35Well, if SD logic dictates that we can only ever offer value
- 20:38propositions, and that true value is always
- 20:41phenomenologically determined by the person receiving it, yeah,
- 20:44What does that mean for our personal lives?
- 20:46Oh wow, I see where you're going with us.
- 20:48Think about the unsolicited advice you give to a friend in
- 20:51crisis. Think about the extravagant
- 20:54gifts you carefully select for a partner, or even just the
- 20:57persona you project at a neighborhood block party.
- 21:00Are we all just walking value propositions?
- 21:03Are we just moving through the world, making offers and waiting
- 21:06for the people in our lives to decide what we are actually
- 21:09worth to them based on their own lived experience?
- 21:12Well, that is absolutely going to keep me up at night.
- 21:14The human lie detector turned inward.
- 21:17Something to think about. We want to thank you so much for
- 21:19joining us on this deep dive today.
- 21:21We hope you take these tools, use them to dig carefully past
- 21:25the polite lies, and start Co creating some real tangible
- 21:29value out there in the world. Until next time, keep asking the
- 21:32right questions.