Latest / Shades of Jade Podcast / Combating Outrage Culture, with David Beckemeyer
Transcript
- 0:14Hey everyone, today we're joined by David Beckmeyer, host of the
- 0:17Outrage Overload podcast. David is an expert in political
- 0:21polarization and media literacy, focusing on reducing toxic
- 0:24outrage and promoting civil discourse.
- 0:27With insights from social psychology and communication
- 0:29studies, David helps listeners understand the mechanics behind
- 0:32outrage media and offers practical strategies for
- 0:35fostering unity and understanding in a divided
- 0:38world. Welcome David.
- 0:40I am wondering what inspired you to start your podcast Outrage
- 0:44Overload? Well, thanks.
- 0:47It's it's, I really appreciate you having me on the show.
- 0:50Yeah. So, you know, I mean, well, it's
- 0:53kind of look around, right. But I mean, there was sort of,
- 0:57you know, for me, it was you sort of had the 2016 elections
- 0:59and people were getting pretty riled up about that.
- 1:03And I, and I saw a lot of these two, you know, arguments online
- 1:06and, and I saw a lot of people, you know, sort of canceling each
- 1:09other or arguing with each other and even in real life, right?
- 1:12I mean, even in real life, see, like everybody has a story.
- 1:15They kind of don't talk to Uncle John anymore or whatever, right?
- 1:18And our other kind of relationship relationships have
- 1:23been severed. So I saw that happen with sort
- 1:25of the then and then it ramped up again.
- 1:27We had, we had COVID hit and lockdowns and a lot of fights
- 1:30over COVID policies and whatnot. And and again, same kind of
- 1:34thing you had people fighting about that, you know, And so I'm
- 1:38kind of in the middle of all that.
- 1:39It's around me. I see it happening with people
- 1:41around me and I'm part of it too.
- 1:43I was one of those guys out on Twitter saying stupid stuff,
- 1:47right? And then, but then as you watch
- 1:49this and see that, wait a minute, this is not just people
- 1:51saying stupid stuff on Twitter. Like, like I say, you're really
- 1:53not talking to like your best friend anymore.
- 1:55This kind of thing over politics or over some of these things.
- 1:59And so then that got me thinking about what's happening with us.
- 2:01And, and I'm kind of a science nerdy sort of guy.
- 2:05And what I, when I looked at what people are looking at this,
- 2:08I kind of discovered there's sort of academics talking about
- 2:11it, but the audience they're speaking to is more sort of
- 2:13academic to academic. So it's two academics going back
- 2:16and forth for an hour and a half.
- 2:18And most of us are kind of out of that loop at some point, like
- 2:21we're not there with them anymore.
- 2:22So I thought, well, maybe I can bring on some of these same
- 2:24people, scientists, practitioners, others that are
- 2:28looking at some of these problems and make it more
- 2:30accessible, kind of make it a little faster paced without
- 2:33going all the way to sort of a 2 minute, you know, sound bite on,
- 2:36on TV or social media. We can actually cover it and
- 2:40enough nuance that and but without going maybe into full,
- 2:43full weeds for an hour and a half.
- 2:45Yeah, yes, I have found myself guilty of of rage baiting I
- 2:52suppose. You know, you get mad and then
- 2:54you want to tell people you're mad and why you're mad.
- 2:59And it's what upsets me is that those videos are the ones where
- 3:04I will get 10 times the amount of views versus the ones where
- 3:09I'm just being a nice person. You know, it's a it's
- 3:13disappointing. So what kind of guests do you
- 3:16have? I mean, you kind of you kind of
- 3:19mentioned the various, the various types, but is that so
- 3:24you're looking at it from a scientific approach?
- 3:28Yeah, I try to, but I also bring in.
- 3:30So, you know, a lot of it is political scientists, social
- 3:33scientists, psychologists, neuroscience, that area, because
- 3:37there's a lot of people looking at these issues from that
- 3:39perspective. And I also think it helps us
- 3:41kind of understand something like why do we do the rage bait
- 3:44thing? Like why do we like it and all
- 3:45this kind of thing? Why does it get more likes and
- 3:47all that kind of stuff? So it helps us kind of
- 3:49understand those dynamics. And then I also talked to what I
- 3:51call practitioners. So folks that I have, you know,
- 3:54maybe a nonprofit or other organization out there that are
- 3:57doing sort of boots on the ground work in some way, right?
- 4:00Which I think we lose sight of because it's not covered in the
- 4:03media a lot, right? We don't realize there's
- 4:05thousands of organizations that are taking this seriously,
- 4:07seriously in a non partisan way, trying to bring people together
- 4:11in some way. Try to look at some of these
- 4:12problems, try to lower the temperature.
- 4:15And, and so I try to highlight some of that because like I
- 4:17said, a lot of us try to bring some of the positive because
- 4:19that's one of the problems that I've learned in this space is
- 4:21that or in our situation is that we have these misperceptions of
- 4:25everything. We have these misperceptions
- 4:26that everything's terrible. We have these misperceptions
- 4:28that everybody on the other side is horrible and looks just like
- 4:31the caricature that Fox News or MSNBC gives us.
- 4:34And of course, it's not true. When you go read real people,
- 4:37you don't see that. And then I also bring in I, I
- 4:39kind of sometimes do do what I might call sort of adjacency
- 4:42type stuff. So I, I'm a tech nerd.
- 4:44So I was in tech for many years. So sometimes I'll find these
- 4:47overlaps between tech and there is beginning to be more and more
- 4:50tech kind of trying to be applied to some of these
- 4:53solutions. So we think of a lot of times
- 4:54all this tech only does the bad stuff, but there are people
- 4:57trying to look at sort of tech for good, if you will.
- 5:00Yeah, I have noticed that there's been an increase in in
- 5:04tech and AI being involved in this in and often times for the
- 5:09good. But you like you said, you
- 5:10usually hear about the bad. I had no idea that there were
- 5:12other organizations out there working towards this at all.
- 5:19Yeah, I just got back from what the Well, it's their first ever
- 5:23in person summit. So they they in the past have
- 5:27done these sort of online. So they did big groups sort of
- 5:30in a big giant Zoom call over over a day or two.
- 5:33This one we did live at first One live is the Listen First
- 5:37project is who organized it. And Listen First Project has a
- 5:41number of member organizations of which I'm one, and it's
- 5:46called the Listen First Coalition basically.
- 5:48And I think they have about 500. But experts have recognized like
- 5:52thousands of organizations doing this.
- 5:54But at this summit there was, I think, I don't know, I never
- 5:57heard the final head count, but 70 ish, 100 ish people there
- 6:01representing almost that many organizations.
- 6:04And we all got to sort of meet in person and, and look at how
- 6:07are people looking at these problems and what are they doing
- 6:09in their communities and things like that.
- 6:11So you know, it's like you say, a lot of us don't even know.
- 6:13I wouldn't have known all that was out there had I not been
- 6:16participating in this organization for a while.
- 6:18Yeah, you, you mentioned, you know, being part of your
- 6:22community. And I was just talking to one of
- 6:24my friends about, about all the hate that's out there.
- 6:30And she, she made a similar point that we need to start
- 6:35getting to know people in our community again.
- 6:37And, and instead of assuming who, who we think they are
- 6:41online on the, you know, the town Facebook page, actually
- 6:46talk to them and have a discussion with them.
- 6:49And because you'll find that you have a lot more in common with
- 6:51them than you realize. Yeah, I mean, I'm certain I'm
- 6:57not. I want to sort of point out
- 6:59I've, I've been, I've probably read dozens and dozens of
- 7:02research papers in this space and I've had over 100 interviews
- 7:04of, of experts, you know, in these categories that I, that I
- 7:08have on the show. And so I've obviously learned a
- 7:10lot, but I still want to make sure like I'm not the final word
- 7:13on everything here, but I definitely learned a lot.
- 7:15And over this time. And one thing that surfaces a
- 7:18lot, and it was, it was a major theme of this bridging summit I
- 7:21just went to in, in the DC area at Mount Vernon, is that, you
- 7:27know, it takes more than dialogue and talking.
- 7:29And it, a lot of it starts like you say, in community, it, it
- 7:32starts with working together, getting to getting to talk and
- 7:35meet with real people. So you're all kinds of people
- 7:38are going about that all kinds of different ways, everything
- 7:41from, you know, service, your alliance, which is doing like
- 7:45years of service, service work, and also just all kinds of
- 7:48community work where organizations come in and help
- 7:51communities identify problems that they can go address
- 7:54together. And then they, you have to sit
- 7:57down and work with someone on a problem you both think is
- 7:59important. You know, you're going to learn
- 8:01about each other, You're going to realize they're real people.
- 8:03They have kids, they go to the same schools.
- 8:05You know, they, they, they care about the same pothole, pothole.
- 8:08You do, you know, there's so many things like you say that,
- 8:11that where we can find commonality and you're going to
- 8:13be differences, right? And, and, and in these
- 8:16situations where you have a shared goal like that is, is you
- 8:19will work through those differences and you'll come away
- 8:22with a lot of skills and understanding that, like we say,
- 8:25all these, all these stereotypes, you know, all the
- 8:27stereotypes have a grain of truth, right?
- 8:29But you find out like real people are much more nuanced
- 8:31than that. And you know, there's many
- 8:33situations when you actually go through that you find, OK, I
- 8:37don't, I'm not any closer to agreeing with this person on,
- 8:40you know, these seven issues or whatever, right?
- 8:42But you know, I will defend them for having the position they
- 8:46have. I will also defend them if
- 8:47people attack them in these kind of brutal ways that we see
- 8:49online and stuff like that. And I will attack them.
- 8:52I will defend them for people that sort of attack them as
- 8:54being like a bad person and having bad intent.
- 8:57I mean, they just see the problems differently and they
- 9:00see that they see the solutions differently, that they see who
- 9:03who how to get there differently, right?
- 9:05But, you know, I think this is where we really get into where,
- 9:09you know, we talk about, I mean, don't talk about it, but when we
- 9:11see it, this increase in political violence, one way you
- 9:14get there is by starting to just see people as kind of evil and
- 9:17with bad intent and this kind of stuff.
- 9:20And not just sort of seeing the world differently, but having
- 9:23really bad intentions and bad morals.
- 9:24And, and you sort of just bundle everybody into those groups.
- 9:28And that's where, you know, that's how we get to these
- 9:30situations where we, we, we start seeing violence as an
- 9:33option because, you know, I can't get them to change their
- 9:35mind and look how bad they are and they're doing these bad
- 9:38things. And, you know, this starts to
- 9:40sound suddenly violent, starts to sound reasonable.
- 9:42And we don't want to go there. Right, Yeah.
- 9:47So I don't know if you've run across this at all, but when I
- 9:50was in school for my master's, it was a political science
- 9:54degree with the focus on environmental policy.
- 9:57So we we talked a lot about passing environmental policy and
- 10:01we discussed staging protests or demonstrations and stuff like
- 10:06that. But there were hints of like,
- 10:11well, sometimes it might be OK if you use violence.
- 10:14And I'm like, I don't think we should be teaching that though.
- 10:19Do you come across that at all? Yeah, I mean, there's a school
- 10:23of thought that, you know, some things were achieved and it, it,
- 10:29it, it involved violence to get there.
- 10:31You could think about union strikes and things like that and
- 10:36maybe probably you could probably come up with others.
- 10:38Obviously we had the revolution against the, the British.
- 10:43But you know what we find historically when you, when you,
- 10:46when we look at things, I mean, generally that's not the, the
- 10:49most effective way to, to, to effect change, right?
- 10:52Generally, you build consensus and in, especially in a, in a
- 10:56liberal democracy, you know, a Republic like ours, you build
- 11:00consensus and, and you know, the people eventually have their
- 11:04voices heard. And, and you know, when you look
- 11:07at the successful ways of doing that, it, you know, violence
- 11:10wasn't the best way to do it. And, and you look at some of
- 11:13these ways when violence was involved, many times we, we hear
- 11:16about these stories where it kind of worked in some
- 11:18definition, but you kind of miss all the times that didn't work,
- 11:21right. All it resulted in is a new
- 11:23regime or something, you know, that's maybe worse than the one
- 11:27before and you just to continue the cycle, right.
- 11:29So yeah, you definitely see it. There's definitely a school of
- 11:32thought like we're out of options.
- 11:34And that's kind of what a lot of us are trying to show people
- 11:37that that's that kind of thinking is what gets us in
- 11:40trouble. Yeah, How would you suggest we
- 11:45change your minds to transition to give more attention to
- 11:49positive things instead of negative things?
- 11:51Because I think once you get in that cycle, it's, it's hard to
- 11:54break, you know, I'll, I'll find myself doing scrolling.
- 11:57And then it's like, hey, you are wasting your time.
- 11:59You've got plants to water, like you've got stuff to do instead
- 12:03of putting yourself in in a bad mood.
- 12:05And I can put my phone down, but I, I catch myself doing it and I
- 12:10try to be aware for the people who aren't aware.
- 12:12I I can't imagine how it's ruining their day and their
- 12:17outlook on life. Yeah, it's absolutely a
- 12:21challenge because there's so many folks, you know, with
- 12:24incentives to sort of use all of our dinosaur emotions against
- 12:29us, right. And we fall, it's pretty
- 12:31natural. Humans fall into this pretty
- 12:32fast. We all do it.
- 12:33There's nobody that has like, it's not a thing that the right
- 12:36does. It's not a thing the left does.
- 12:37Like we're all guilty of these. We all have the same brains.
- 12:40We all, we all have the same, you know, we we all suffer from
- 12:43from a lot of these same tendencies, right.
- 12:45And and the people with these bad intent kind of know how to
- 12:48do that. It's not that hard.
- 12:49Like you can pull us into it. So it's it's right there to be
- 12:53had everywhere you are. So yeah, a lot of it's and and
- 12:57you know, one thing I've found is the most effective is if
- 13:00we're gonna sit around and wait for sort of our politicians to
- 13:03lead this in the right direction, it's just, it's not
- 13:05gonna happen. It's gotta come from sort of the
- 13:08bottom up, you know, in in some way, it's got to come from us
- 13:11starting to do this in ourselves with ourselves and then with
- 13:15folks on our side. You have a lot more influence
- 13:17with people on your side than you do with somebody who
- 13:20disagrees with you, right? Or someone's on quote UN quote
- 13:22sees you as the other on the other side.
- 13:24You don't have as much. So we spend all our energy talk,
- 13:27you know, saying stuff to our side.
- 13:29That's the message we want the other side to hear.
- 13:31Well, it's not getting us anywhere, right?
- 13:33Your side probably already thinks it and the other side is
- 13:36never going to see it. And if they did see it, they're
- 13:38not going to take it seriously. So a lot of it can, can start
- 13:41with ourselves, right? And then, but then you go
- 13:43quickly to your local community, right?
- 13:44And we talked a little bit earlier.
- 13:46You mentioned it before you're getting to know neighbors,
- 13:48getting getting involved in the in community things more
- 13:51because, like you said, you're going to get a new, better
- 13:54nuanced perspective of, of real people.
- 13:57And it's really hard, right, because you know, it's, it can
- 14:00be really uncomfortable, especially if you've been in
- 14:03your bubble for a long time and you go start to talk to somebody
- 14:06that has different views. They're going to say a thing
- 14:08that's like, or you're going to maybe the other way around,
- 14:10you're going to say a thing that you think in our mind.
- 14:12This is how also how human brain work, brains work.
- 14:14We just sort of assume because we came to this conclusion, it's
- 14:17just natural. Like everybody also thinks this
- 14:20way, right? So in in our in our bubbles,
- 14:23everybody kind of does think that way.
- 14:24So we can say these things and other people, yeah, that sounds
- 14:26good. But then if you get outside that
- 14:28bubble and you say this thing that to you is so natural, how
- 14:31could anybody see the world a different way?
- 14:33And you say the thing and they're like, well, that's
- 14:35crazy. You know, that doesn't make any
- 14:37sense to me. And, and your mind just sort of
- 14:39breaks. It's like, well, there's
- 14:41something wrong with you if you're not seeing it my way,
- 14:43right? And that's kind of where our
- 14:44brain goes right away. So building some skills in that,
- 14:48which can be difficult. I'm a certified moderator with
- 14:52an organization called Crossing Party Lines where we hold these
- 14:56dialogues online. So you can get a jump on a zoom
- 14:58call and get some practice with these kind of conversations and
- 15:01basically a quote UN quote, you know, sort of safe environment.
- 15:04It's not totally safe. You you're going to be feeling
- 15:05sort or something in a Zoom call, but they're moderated.
- 15:08And so there's guardrails and boundaries and stuff like that.
- 15:11But it doesn't mean you know, you'll win your argument.
- 15:13In fact, that whole conversation isn't about winning.
- 15:16It's about everybody sharing and everybody learning how to
- 15:19listen. Right.
- 15:21So I think so. So that's one thing.
- 15:24You talk about shutting off your phone.
- 15:25I mean, that's one thing, too. You can just spend less time,
- 15:27maybe even put guardrails on it, like, hey, I'm going to doom
- 15:30scroll. Only this long.
- 15:31Yeah. And then, you know, you talked
- 15:34about maybe finding some more positive things.
- 15:36I wish that was easier to do. We've talked a lot like IT folks
- 15:41trying to do some of those kinds of things like can we find a
- 15:44more positive, you know, news outlet somewhere that would sort
- 15:48of assemble some of these more positive things.
- 15:51And I think the more in common people try to do that and the
- 15:54all sides people try to do that as well.
- 15:56So you can kind of look up those, what they do online and
- 15:58see if, because I think they put out like A, and there's another
- 16:01one I'm not remembering now that puts out like a daily.
- 16:04Here's three good things that happened today.
- 16:05And not only three good things, but like 3 sort of surprising
- 16:08things. Like you maybe this Democratic
- 16:10senator or something did something that's kind of out of
- 16:13character and maybe would he put up a Republican in a positive
- 16:16light or something like that or vice versa, right?
- 16:18Stuff you wouldn't the size stuff we don't hear about very
- 16:20much because we mostly only hear when they're telling us how
- 16:24terrible the other side is, right?
- 16:26So some of that kind of stuff. But so that's a challenge like
- 16:29trying to seek out that kind of good information because of
- 16:32course the news is trying to give us all the other stuff.
- 16:34But, and people often talk about sort of getting out of your
- 16:37bubble and even that could be kind of hard because you can get
- 16:41frustrated when you go read, let's say you're on the left and
- 16:44you go read Fox News or something.
- 16:46You can also get frustrated from that cuz you're seeing them say
- 16:49all these things that you think are wrong and they're lies and
- 16:51they're in tracks. So it didn't actually lower the
- 16:54temperature very much. So trying to find a little bit
- 16:57more balanced stuff, maybe a Wall Street Journal story, you
- 17:01know, maybe, you know, if you're on the right, maybe a, a, a
- 17:05Washington Post. But again, you might be kind of
- 17:06mad because it's going to look like they're maybe spending it,
- 17:09which sometimes they are, right. I mean, I think we have this
- 17:12idea that everybody's out there telling lies, but really there's
- 17:15just a lot of narrative creating, right?
- 17:17They're not always telling bald faced lies.
- 17:19Sometimes they do. It's more about how they, what
- 17:21they leave out, I think is what usually is making it, making it
- 17:25more like a red alert kind of thing because they leave out
- 17:28like they'll say this thing happened and then you find out
- 17:30later when you look into it, OK, that thing happened, but also
- 17:34this, and they also said that and there was this other thing.
- 17:36And so when you really put them all together, OK, they're, it's
- 17:39not that bad. Like it wasn't that big of a
- 17:40thing that everyone tried to make it into.
- 17:42So that, that can be really hard, just a challenging
- 17:44landscape. But I would say start locally,
- 17:46start with yourself, start with people on your side, like call
- 17:49them out, you know, even if it's polite one-on-one, not call them
- 17:52out in public. But like, hey, dude, you know,
- 17:53that thing you said about that thing, you know, that's going to
- 17:56make people kind of mad. Maybe there's another way to say
- 17:59that next time, you know, and maybe even give them examples.
- 18:02Maybe you can have ChatGPT help you write a less toxic version
- 18:06of that thing that you maybe you could have said this.
- 18:08And and then there's probably a better chance someone on the
- 18:10other side might actually, you know, take, take something away
- 18:14from it and someone on your side maybe won't get so riled up
- 18:17about it for no reason. So I think that's a big one is
- 18:20we don't spend enough energy. And you mentioned it before that
- 18:23we started that you try to talk to folks on your own side
- 18:26sometimes to get them to chill out a little bit.
- 18:29That's one of the hardest messages for me to get out to
- 18:31people on on my show is when we talk about, I do a lot of these
- 18:35men on the street interviews. I'm, I'm talking forever.
- 18:37I'm sorry. We do these men, we do these, I
- 18:40do these men on the street interviews where I just take
- 18:41somebody, you know, and, and, and ask them some general
- 18:44questions, you know, about like their media habits and things
- 18:46like that. And I never, I never.
- 18:51A couple of interesting things I've learned about that.
- 18:53One is I never ask anyone their political affiliation, yet they
- 18:56always tell me at some point, like they always feel compelled
- 18:59to tell me their political. It's interesting that it's so
- 19:02much of our identity. We want to make sure we get that
- 19:03out there somewhere in the conversation.
- 19:05But I never ask. But the other piece about that
- 19:07conversation is I just go into 100% listen mode, right?
- 19:10So I don't push back and I don't, I may probe some more
- 19:13like I'm trying to understand what they're saying, but I don't
- 19:15really push back and say, you know, and, and you can see this
- 19:18change in people as you start to do that where they aren't
- 19:22expecting that, right? They're so used to, it's almost
- 19:24like they say the thing and then stop for a second to see what
- 19:27I'm going to say back, right? And then when you don't say
- 19:30anything back or don't push back on it, they're like, wow, that's
- 19:33weird. And then they, and sometimes
- 19:35they mistake it from maybe tacit approval, but it, you really see
- 19:38them open up and, and, and, and become more willing to share
- 19:41their views and get more comfortable in it.
- 19:43And, and it's it, what it shows to me is how used to we are
- 19:47having like confrontation about anything we say, right?
- 19:50We're expecting a fight, especially if we say something
- 19:52that's, you know, kind of a deeper held thing that we don't
- 19:54always share. And we say that thing and we're
- 19:56kind of just waiting for someone to attack us.
- 19:58Now. What's he going to say to this
- 19:59one, right? And when it doesn't happen, you
- 20:01really see this change in people.
- 20:03So I, I, I've learned, learned a lot from that, that, you know,
- 20:07we're, we're definitely sort of keyed up for a fight.
- 20:11Yes, yeah, I agree. I while you're while you're
- 20:17talking about. I know I said a lot there.
- 20:19No, you're fine. You're fine.
- 20:22I, it, it made me think about a lot of different instances and a
- 20:25lot of different things. And I'm, I'm sure my audience is
- 20:27tired of hearing me say this, but I, I have voted both ways.
- 20:31And so it was interesting where I kind of shifted to a different
- 20:37direction. But because I was in school, I
- 20:40was a vegetarian, everyone assumed that I was on the left,
- 20:45you know, And then someone else was like, no, she's a
- 20:47Republican. And it's like at that point, cuz
- 20:50that was I think the 2016 election era.
- 20:53And it was like, well, I've never called myself a Republican
- 20:57before though either because I didn't, I guess I didn't have a
- 21:02label for myself in, in Iowa to, to caucus.
- 21:07You do have to register a certain way.
- 21:09So I am a registered Republican right now.
- 21:12And I don't like that, that you're having to put yourself in
- 21:16a box. But it this also made me think
- 21:18of my conservative friend and my liberal friend back in the COVID
- 21:22era. They were fighting about
- 21:24ivermectin and the conservative friend was taking it.
- 21:28And the liberal friend was jumping down his throat about
- 21:32like, you can't be taking horsty warmer, blah blah.
- 21:35And it's like, wait a minute, why are you assuming that he,
- 21:39that he didn't get the human prescription, you know, for it?
- 21:43But then there was another assumption from him.
- 21:45So they were both coming at this conversation with assumptions
- 21:50without actually knowing what, what's the actual, what's
- 21:54actually happening? You know, it's, it's almost like
- 21:57they're, they're arguing for no reason because they, they failed
- 22:00to actually try to understand what the other person was, was
- 22:05saying. And I think, like you said, that
- 22:08people are so geared up for confrontation, for arguments
- 22:14that they're not even taking a minute anymore to think like,
- 22:18OK, well, how did you mean that? You know, to, like you said, to
- 22:22push back to get a better understanding.
- 22:24They're just ready for their response.
- 22:27Yeah, right. And, and, and I think this is a,
- 22:31another opportunity where we have to, you know, force
- 22:35yourself to spend more, more time listening when you do go
- 22:37into those dialogues, because one of the challenges about our
- 22:41natural tendency is we know they have got the wrong idea.
- 22:45So we're going to convince them the right idea.
- 22:47And so our sort of go in with this, this motivation that
- 22:50somehow we only win if we change their mind.
- 22:54And I think there's a better mindset if you can try to adopt
- 22:57it of and I talk about it kind of like the idea of let's go in
- 23:01this like a detective story, like, and then we're on the same
- 23:04page. I sort of have a shared goal,
- 23:06like let's play like detectives and try to understand why we see
- 23:09this differently as opposed to me.
- 23:11I only. So then we can both win because
- 23:13we could both learn something from it and come away
- 23:15understanding better how the other person sees it.
- 23:18Because if you set yourself up that your goal is to persuade
- 23:21them to change their mind, it's almost assuredly not going to
- 23:26work, especially if that's your main goal.
- 23:28And you're and you're, what you're going to start doing is
- 23:29throwing, you know, Fox News or MSNBC Fox factoids out there.
- 23:36That's not going to work for anybody, right?
- 23:37It's not going to get you anywhere.
- 23:38So you're almost set up for this, this conversation to fail.
- 23:42So if you can change your mindset a little bit to let's
- 23:44see if we can go together to both understand better about why
- 23:47we see it differently and, and, and maybe even set some other
- 23:51guardrails like I will listen or 5 minutes or whatever, as long
- 23:56as you also agree to listen for 5 minutes, something like that.
- 23:59Because the, the big problem is we spend so much time talking
- 24:02and this is what's happening on social media.
- 24:05Everybody's talking, especially on social media and nobody's
- 24:08listening, right? And everybody thinks somebody's
- 24:09listening. You're all just shouting into
- 24:11the void. Yeah, yeah.
- 24:15It's again, if you aren't on, it's like it's, you're entering
- 24:19into a whole different world when you jump online and it's
- 24:23like, OK, well, did any of what, what I just said or anything
- 24:29even just matter because put the phone down and walked away and
- 24:32it, it didn't actually change anything.
- 24:34You know, of course, when you're inciting violence or whatever
- 24:38and then causing people to go out into the real world and and
- 24:42do bad things, that's a little bit different.
- 24:44But I had I don't know how to I I do like your idea about, OK,
- 24:51I'll listen for 5 minutes, you know, and then you listen for 5
- 24:54minutes. So then you can at least get the
- 24:55point across without interrupting and arguing.
- 24:59I think that that would go a long way for a lot of people.
- 25:02Yeah. And some people even take it
- 25:03further, like, you know, and, and if you are going to have a
- 25:06if, if you, if you have the opportunity to, to have a
- 25:09conversation like that and you're able to mix it with
- 25:11physical movement, like if you go on a walk together, there's
- 25:14like some neuroscience about that.
- 25:16That says, right off the bat, we're kind of doing something
- 25:19together. We're walking, we're physically
- 25:20doing a thing. And it actually helps, you know,
- 25:23kind of make you more receptive to that person.
- 25:25So if you can actually go for literally a walk and have that
- 25:28conversation And, but sometimes, you know, you could even think
- 25:31about, well, the first time we do this, I'm not going to talk.
- 25:34I'm not going to really push back at all.
- 25:35Like I'll just let you have the whole conversation.
- 25:37And then at some point though, I'm going to turn it around and
- 25:39say, OK, I've given you 3 times or I haven't said anything.
- 25:42Are you OK if I now say something back?
- 25:45You know, so sometimes it can be that much because some people
- 25:47aren't ready to have, you know, to have that.
- 25:49So if you have the patience and the willingness to do that, you
- 25:52can even take it that far. I wanted to comment on something
- 25:55else that you said too, that you know, like you're vegetarian and
- 25:58you so you know, you have these other sort of traits and, and
- 26:01parts about you that then people are going to make these
- 26:03assumptions like, oh, then you therefore you must be.
- 26:06And that's something there's a lot of science about this, that
- 26:08that's something we do a huge amount, right.
- 26:10We have all this kind of signaling that as soon as you, I
- 26:13mean, we, I had a person on that was like, we were, and this is
- 26:16such a human thing to do. But in their research, they were
- 26:19able to get people to this point where if you liked a pencil,
- 26:24that meant you must also dot dot dot dot dot, right?
- 26:26They were able to take something totally apolitical, but they
- 26:28were able to kind of group things and and group people and
- 26:31show that it's such a human characteristic in us.
- 26:33We would decide something about someone just on whether they
- 26:35like pencils or not, you know, and and so it's and so obviously
- 26:39with politics, it's even more so.
- 26:40So this idea that you have those cross, you're one of those
- 26:43people with those cross cutting views.
- 26:44You said sometimes you vote the other way.
- 26:46You said you kind of built that these boxes for this one, but
- 26:50then you but then you're really over here.
- 26:51Well, the reality is most of us are like that to 1° or another.
- 26:55But those people that are like that in a larger way where they
- 26:59have cross cutting views like, you know, I mean, maybe, you
- 27:02know, they're abortion on this side and gun control on that
- 27:05side and they're, you know, something else.
- 27:07These people with these cross cutting views are to some
- 27:09degree, a lot of research shows these maybe our saviors, right?
- 27:12If those people can get out there and show that not
- 27:15everybody fits in these boxes and they can also show their own
- 27:19side, not everybody fits fits in boxes either, then you know that
- 27:24they may be the a path towards everybody kind of Oh yeah,
- 27:27picking up on this more nuanced that that world is more nuanced
- 27:31than Fox News and MSNBC want to tell us it is.
- 27:34And that's been shown to be a big factor in reducing sort of
- 27:38the the extremes, right? Doesn't mean people agree on
- 27:40everything. Doesn't mean we all come to the
- 27:42middle ground and we're always agreeing.
- 27:44But it means we're we, we, we can have be be in the same room.
- 27:48We can have productive dialogue with people.
- 27:50And we don't hold those really extreme views where we're we're
- 27:54just so locked in that we're not very flexible so that that
- 27:59people like you could very well be our path out of some of this.
- 28:04Do you see on so I see this happening with Republicans right
- 28:09now. They are actually attacking each
- 28:12other because they might not be holding the view.
- 28:16I I see there's a lot of fighting about Israel, a lot of
- 28:19back and I guess they're not fighting, but the response to
- 28:24Charlie Kirk's assassination. Some are like this is war and
- 28:27others are saying we need to forgive and it's, and I guess
- 28:32I'm not really seeing them fight about that.
- 28:33But the Israel, the Israel topic is a huge thing with Republicans
- 28:37right now on whether or not we should be supporting Israel as
- 28:40much. And I think it's ripping the
- 28:43party apart. Do you see that on the left as
- 28:46well? Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 28:48I mean, both parties suffer from this sort of ideological purity
- 28:51test kind of problem. And I think Democrats and, and
- 28:53the left have been even harsher at this historically or
- 28:58certainly over the last few decades, where like, if you
- 29:01violate one of these norms one time, you are like out, like you
- 29:05could never recover, you could never get back.
- 29:07And I think the right has been a little more forgiving, like you
- 29:09violate A norm, but as long as you come back and say, Hey,
- 29:12either I was wrong or I, I now support this other thing, you
- 29:15know, they, they just invite you back in, right?
- 29:17Whereas Democrats are like, once you broke one thing, you're
- 29:19like, you're out. You can never come back.
- 29:21And, and, and, but both sides suffer this ideological purity
- 29:24thing. And it's not good for us, right?
- 29:25Because you know, you know, our, our, I love, I love that our
- 29:30politicians, particularly the Congress, you know, we have
- 29:35these, these ones we love because they're, I mean, maybe
- 29:38you or I don't, but a lot of people love these ones that just
- 29:40go grandstand. They get on their soapbox and
- 29:42they yell and cheer. They tell us how terrible the
- 29:44other side is, blah, blah, blah. And then you look at their
- 29:47record, they haven't actually done anything.
- 29:49Like they didn't propose any laws.
- 29:51They didn't try to ever talk across the aisle.
- 29:53If you rate them on what their responsibility is by the
- 29:56Constitution, you know, they aren't doing any of the things.
- 29:59They aren't doing oversight. They aren't creating laws.
- 30:01They aren't working with the other side.
- 30:02They aren't doing any of the things that the Constitution
- 30:05puts them in charge with. But we love them because they're
- 30:07yelling and screaming all the time.
- 30:08So some of it comes back on us, right, that we are not holding.
- 30:12And then and then so we, we, we do that and then we go, but
- 30:16Congress isn't getting anything done.
- 30:18It's like you're why Congress isn't getting anything done.
- 30:21You keep voting for these people that just stand there and scream
- 30:24and shout all day. And I and I'm saying that's true
- 30:26for the left and the right. Yeah, yes, I I wish that there,
- 30:30that there were scorecards for politicians because yes, you're
- 30:36right. It's oh, they're out there
- 30:37fighting for us. No, they're just screaming.
- 30:40And then they're not. And then now they're going on a
- 30:42on a summer break for a month and not doing anything.
- 30:46And that, that also didn't remind me.
- 30:48You mentioned working across the aisles, so I remember there was
- 30:53something that AOC and Ana Paulina Luna worked on together
- 30:57and I came across it and no one else was reporting on it.
- 31:01And it's like, well why isn't this getting attention?
- 31:03But you what was the? Was it a Twitter page or a
- 31:07website that you mentioned that posts 3 positive things per day?
- 31:11I think it's like a e-mail list, you know, so you get like in
- 31:14your e-mail every day. You get, maybe it's not every
- 31:16day, but every maybe once a week you get like a, you know, a
- 31:19little list of positive things that happen.
- 31:22I wish that there was more attention brought to to the ones
- 31:26that are actually trying to to work with people.
- 31:29I do see that John Federman is getting a little bit more
- 31:31attention for his kind of crossing the aisles, whether it
- 31:35be positive or negative, it kind of depends on the person.
- 31:38But I do appreciate that he's actually trying to to understand
- 31:44the other side and. Yeah, and I think somebody like
- 31:46Spencer Cox, you know, he's a Republican in in Utah, he he's
- 31:50sort of had a reputation for doing this for a while.
- 31:53And you know, it's challenging within your own party, right?
- 31:55Because if you take this view that I'm going to tell you the
- 31:58other side isn't evil, now I'm going to be seen as evil on my
- 32:02side, right? My people are going to complain
- 32:03at me because I'm not screaming at the other side enough.
- 32:05So it's it's kind of brave of these politicians willing to do
- 32:08it. There.
- 32:10There is a site and I forget, I'm forgetting the name now, but
- 32:13it, it's, I want to say it's like legislative I, I forget
- 32:17what it is. But there is a website that does
- 32:20track some of this. And it, it, it talks about
- 32:23mostly about their legislative effectiveness.
- 32:25It doesn't really talk about their role in oversight because
- 32:29that's also supposed to be a role of Congress, by the way.
- 32:33And, and then they have, they just like they've seen them let
- 32:35that go, like they don't seem to do any oversight anymore.
- 32:37But, and I, I forget exactly what it is now, but I'm sure I
- 32:39can get it to you for your show notes.
- 32:41OK. And, and I, I also saw a new one
- 32:44that I don't know a lot about yet, but it's, it's called, what
- 32:51is it called? It's called bridge grades.
- 32:54And what they're doing is specifically rating members on
- 32:59their how much they do talk work across the aisle.
- 33:03So it's totally non partisan. It doesn't even tell you.
- 33:05I mean, it doesn't even focus on whether they're blue or red.
- 33:08It just rates them on how much are they, you know, proposing
- 33:12bills that then have a a Co signature or a endorsement from
- 33:15someone on the other side, stuff like that.
- 33:17So you can very quickly look at, you know, see this rating for
- 33:20your congressman and the F still for senators.
- 33:22But yeah. And it's called bridging grades.
- 33:24And that was interesting. I mean, I think we kind of have
- 33:26to take all these in the aggregate and kind of look at
- 33:29all of them. But it doesn't hurt to look at
- 33:30like like my guy in my area is like great F.
- 33:34Like, you know, he's, he's, he's supposed to be this, you know,
- 33:38liberal guy that's just great for the world.
- 33:40But then you look at this, he's like a great F on his bridging
- 33:43capability. And they they call those
- 33:44dividers, right? So people that you either get
- 33:47like an AB score or ACF score or something like that.
- 33:49There's sort of no middle ground.
- 33:51You're either on the upper side, which makes you a Bridger or
- 33:54you're on the lower side, which makes you a divider.
- 33:56And he's he's like the worst kind of inviter divider.
- 33:59He's like an. F And he wins every time.
- 34:02Like he can't lose because it's a democratic area.
- 34:04Like half the time nobody even runs against him.
- 34:07Yeah, yeah, I'm, I'm definitely going to check that out because
- 34:11that's, that would be interesting to look at.
- 34:15I so the, the, is the government shut down right now.
- 34:19I saw that they're going to revisit it.
- 34:22So I saw that Rand Paul voted against the continuing
- 34:27resolution and and then and Thomas Massie will do that as
- 34:31well almost every time. And I see they get attacked on
- 34:37the right for it so bad. And it's like, why are we,
- 34:41whether I agree with him or not, why are we attacking people for
- 34:45for voting how they believe? I it's and I like that they that
- 34:52they do that again, whether I agree with what they with it or
- 34:56not. I do like that they're not
- 34:59caving like John Fetterman. They're not caving to the the
- 35:02pressure of their party. They're voting how they believe.
- 35:06Yeah, and we need that needs to become more of a norm.
- 35:09I mean, I get it, they want party unity and they want all
- 35:11these things. But sometimes it's part of
- 35:13unity, especially with our two party system that's really got
- 35:15everything locked down. Is it very hard for third
- 35:18parties to make any inroads? The more they do that, just the
- 35:22more nothing happen. Again, we we, we, we create this
- 35:25system that does these things and then we complain that they
- 35:27don't get anything done. Well, there, it's because of
- 35:29this that they're so locked into their own side and then they
- 35:32never, never want to. You know, the founders, you
- 35:34probably studied this. I've listened to some of your
- 35:36episodes about this that I mean, the founders built this country
- 35:39and the idea that people could get in a room and work through
- 35:42their differences and had to, they had to, like our government
- 35:45is designed for it to be hard to get things done on purpose,
- 35:48right? That way you don't have the sort
- 35:50of majority rule kind of idea. So even when you're in the
- 35:54majority, you have to build coalitions and do the work to
- 35:58get to get support for these ideas.
- 36:00And that usually means also you're going to compromise a
- 36:01little bit, like you're going to probably have to take this piece
- 36:04out and, and, or add this piece in in order to build those
- 36:07coalitions. And both sides are going to have
- 36:09to have to do that. And right now, we as voters like
- 36:12compromises become a bad word, working across the aisles become
- 36:16like a bad word. And so I constantly kind of put
- 36:19it back on us, like, you know, we've met the enemy and it's us,
- 36:22right? And we have to get better at
- 36:25appreciating how our government was designed to work and what
- 36:29what has to happen for things to work.
- 36:30We're going to have to give a little sometimes.
- 36:32Like you can't have this no compromise attitude about
- 36:35everything. It's just you have to build
- 36:37consensus, you know, and I and people talk about like, oh,
- 36:39Democrats needed this. And you see the same thing with
- 36:42Republicans. They needed that to win
- 36:43election. I'm like, what they need to do
- 36:44to win election. Just have popular ideas, you
- 36:47know, have ideas, people. What then you'll win election.
- 36:49You won't have to do all these tricks with gerrymandering and
- 36:51all that. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 36:54That's, you know, I was just thinking about the redistricting
- 36:57this morning and I, I just don't, and maybe you heard me
- 37:04talk about this. Iowa is just like, I mean, I was
- 37:07a small state, so it's just split into fours.
- 37:10And I guess in my opinion, that's just the fairest way to
- 37:14to do it. But I but another person had
- 37:18explained to me, well, if there are certain populations all
- 37:21living in a small group that like their voices might not get
- 37:26heard. So I still haven't decided how.
- 37:31I think the best way is to go about that to be the most fair.
- 37:38What? What do you think about it?
- 37:41Well, I think the right way in general is, you know, the idea
- 37:46of like what New York and California has done with these
- 37:49independent bodies and just taking that to a, you know, a
- 37:52better, you know, a fuller implementation that it can't be
- 37:56rigged, you know, as much. So I, I think that's the, that's
- 38:00probably the best approach that we and, you know, it is
- 38:03difficult to have national mandates for that kind of stuff
- 38:06because we've designed our system to be Federated.
- 38:09So states have power to do things the way they want,
- 38:12especially with elections. So we kind of have to figure out
- 38:15if we could mandate something and how that might look.
- 38:17But but I think independent commissions are the way to get
- 38:20there, right? Independent commissions of
- 38:22experts that are going to try to do that fairness thing in a non
- 38:24partisan way, you know, And so you know, and again, everything
- 38:29has its edges, Nothing's black and white, everything has Gray
- 38:32around the edges. So there's going to even when
- 38:34you have that, you're going to have situations like you do see
- 38:36in New York and California where even those commissions get
- 38:39accused of of unfair play. But I think it would be it would
- 38:43be a step in the right direction at least to have those kind of
- 38:46commissions. And again, let's add some
- 38:48oversight. Like start doing your job,
- 38:50Congress. Yeah, I cannot believe how much
- 38:55they get paid to do so well. But yeah, sorry to interrupt.
- 39:01I just wanted to tell you about one of my sponsors real quick.
- 39:07Sometimes I get on a roll cleaning or gardening and I need
- 39:10a boost but don't have time for a meal.
- 39:12Big Fork Brands Pork Jerky is the perfect choice to keep my
- 39:15momentum, offering high protein snacks for on the
- 39:36I personally think the original flavor of the pork jerky hits
- 39:39just right after tackling a big chore.
- 39:41It's a little salty and very flavorful.
- 39:44My discount code gives you 20% off your entire order and it's
- 39:47currently the best deal available.
- 39:49Just visit bigforkbrands.com and enter in my promo code, JADE.
- 39:53That's JADE at checkout. So what are some of the most
- 39:59hopeful trends that you're seeing in the way people are
- 40:02responding to outrage culture? Well, you know, I, I've been
- 40:08disappointed as everyone, everyone has often with, you
- 40:11know, some of the things that experts have often talked about
- 40:14is this idea that we could have some kind of exterior threat.
- 40:17You know, that was a shared threat that we'd all sort of
- 40:19find some unity to fight that threat.
- 40:22So COVID didn't do that went the other direction.
- 40:24We got more divided over it. And there's a lot of arguments
- 40:27you can make about why that how that care about that way.
- 40:31But I see these events like the attempted assassination on Trump
- 40:34last, you know, in Butler last year, the the assassination of
- 40:40the senator in Minnesota and now the assassination of of the
- 40:45successful assassination of Charlie Kirk.
- 40:47And I thought these moments, I always hope these kind of
- 40:50moments could be more unifying, you know, that we could start to
- 40:54see it. And so far it hasn't gone in
- 40:55that that direction, right? The the president assassination
- 41:00attempt did for like a little while.
- 41:01There were a few days where people talked about, you know,
- 41:04things have gone too far. We need to drop the temperature.
- 41:07We saw that kind of language happening Didn't last very long.
- 41:10We saw this a little bit with 911 with 911 back at back in
- 41:142001 or for a while, the country kind of came together and
- 41:17started thinking about working together more.
- 41:21Didn't last that long. Again, didn't last that long.
- 41:24So I from the front, but so I I'm hoping that it won't take
- 41:27that. I'm hoping that that, but people
- 41:30often talk about, like I said, the experts often talk, talk
- 41:32about sort of hitting rock bottom, you know, sort of like a
- 41:35drug addiction kind of problem, right.
- 41:37And So what will Americans see as their rock bottom and you
- 41:41know, in a non partisan way, because it doesn't work if it's
- 41:43just sort of seen as a partisan rock bottom, like I'm going to
- 41:47blame this president because the economy went bad and it'll be
- 41:50fixed because I'll vote for the other side next time.
- 41:53Like something beyond that attitude, like that attitude
- 41:55isn't getting us anywhere, right?
- 41:58So, but so the, but the positive that I'm seeing the most is all
- 42:02this effort, How much energy, how much research is being put
- 42:05into this the subject, how much boots on the ground work is
- 42:09being done all around the country and how, you know, many
- 42:12of those efforts are showing promise, showing more than
- 42:16promise. Like there, there are situations
- 42:19like Rich Harwood has the Harwood Institute and they go
- 42:22around to very divided areas and get people to work on a project
- 42:26together. And you've seen some of these,
- 42:28there's another group called Urban Rural Action that's doing
- 42:30that. And they, they go into some of
- 42:32the most divided places and get a project where the, they, they
- 42:38come up, they, they help the community come up with a shared
- 42:41problem to work on. So that kind of stuff shows we
- 42:43can do it, right. And you know, there's a lot of
- 42:47barriers, right? There's the incentives from like
- 42:49we keep talking about this stuff doesn't make in the news.
- 42:51Nobody's heard of these organizations because it's not
- 42:53making the news enough. But it's it's so if if we can
- 42:57start and I think there's a demand for it too.
- 43:00If you look at the more in common studies, they this is a
- 43:02little bit old now, but it's, the research still holds up.
- 43:06There's this idea of that what they call a exhausted majority.
- 43:10So there's people, you know, that are locked into their sides
- 43:14on on each end, But then there's sort of the rest of us that are
- 43:17more like what you're talking about.
- 43:18Sometimes they cross vote, sometimes they hold issues that
- 43:21cross, you might consider crossing sides and you know, and
- 43:25they're just exhausted by all this fighting, right?
- 43:27And it's, it's a vast majority. So if we can kind of bring the
- 43:31exhausted majority like to realize there's more people like
- 43:34them. There's this idea in science of
- 43:35like plural ignorance where we think nobody else thinks like us
- 43:41or maybe nobody else sees this thing the same way.
- 43:44If we can get that message out that there's a whole bunch of
- 43:46people that see things like like you do in terms of the, the
- 43:49frustration with politics and if we can hit, if we can really
- 43:52bring that to light. So those are all things that I'm
- 43:55encouraged by. But I have to say it's, I see
- 43:58that it's still a big challenge. And I, like I say a lot of it is
- 44:00us because we're, we're susceptible to these actors try
- 44:04to driving us and, and we have to get, we have to get so much
- 44:08better about seeing this stuff and saying, no, don't do that.
- 44:12Like this guy in my district. Stop doing that.
- 44:17Yeah, yeah, it's, yeah. We, we think that if we shared
- 44:22more of these positive things and got the words out, word out
- 44:25there for a lot of those. I was just listening to an
- 44:28episode of Doctor Phil's show last night where he was talking
- 44:34about helping a college where the students were all fighting
- 44:38about politics and having them do where they stand across from
- 44:42someone with different views. And you have to just, you know,
- 44:46OK, well, what do we have in common?
- 44:47Have you had that type of thing? And apparently it was pretty
- 44:50successful doing that. And I, I do see that, you know,
- 44:56all these conservatives are going out there and, and going
- 45:00to college campuses to talk to students like Charlie Kirk did.
- 45:03Steven Crowder brought his Change my mind booth back.
- 45:07And I, I can see the, how that hope opens up dialogue, but I
- 45:10don't know if it's as effective as projects like you're talking
- 45:14about where you're actually working together as a group,
- 45:18finding more in common that way. I mean, that would be something,
- 45:22it would be really cool to bring projects like that to to a
- 45:26campus. Yeah, it it seems like all the
- 45:30research is pointing to that, that it's much more durable if
- 45:34you can actually go work together.
- 45:36The the conversation is a start, right?
- 45:39And doesn't hurt to build those skills and a group like crossing
- 45:44party lines or others that are out there that's free.
- 45:46You can you can participate in those conversations, you know,
- 45:48can help build those skills. They have workshops as well.
- 45:53And so those skills are good. Like they're going to help you
- 45:55in your personal life for sure. And if we all start to just get
- 45:59better at it, and it's really hard, like I said, it's like
- 46:01all, everything in our nature makes us not want to do it
- 46:04right. So it's really hard.
- 46:05But but yeah, but it looks like with most the research, the
- 46:09talking is like a start. It's a good thing.
- 46:11But what really makes it more durable and having a more last
- 46:14lasting impact is to work on projects together somehow, like
- 46:18find a way to work together on on shared some kind of find some
- 46:22shared problem you want to work together on and work through it.
- 46:25Like, you know, and I think a lot of people think, well, what
- 46:29I'm going to say, like the thing you're going to work on is like
- 46:31the hardest thing to work on. No, you can set those aside.
- 46:34Like if we think there's just no way we can come to agreement on
- 46:37this one, how about these two? Like we don't have to put
- 46:40everything aside because we're setting that one thing aside.
- 46:43We can still work, find stuff to work on, and that starting point
- 46:46then can open up the door. So now I'm ready to maybe talk
- 46:50about some of these harder ones, right?
- 46:51So you don't have to start with the hardest problem in the room.
- 46:55Yeah, I I think we need to get back to being able to agree to
- 47:00disagree as well. Like, no, no one has to agree
- 47:04with 100% of what of what you believe.
- 47:07But I think if we realize that we might not agree on this, but
- 47:15we both think that this is the best.
- 47:17It's not, I'm not believing this to take your rights away or to
- 47:22hurt you or a certain group of people.
- 47:24I'm believing this because I think that that's what's best
- 47:27for people. And I, I do believe that with
- 47:31certain things, people think that it's just a judgmental
- 47:36thing or a, or I just don't like you people or, you know, I don't
- 47:40like this type of group. So this is how I feel on this
- 47:44where it's it's deeper than that.
- 47:46Yeah. We've sort of trained ourself
- 47:48just to see it that way and we have to kind of unlearn that, I
- 47:51think. And beyond just agreeing to
- 47:55disagree, I think the other side of it that kind of relates to
- 47:57that pretty closely is we have this idea in our head that
- 48:00somehow if the other person is allowed to share their views,
- 48:04that then somehow that means I agree with them, right?
- 48:07It doesn't. You can do both things like you
- 48:09can try to understand where they're coming from without
- 48:12changing your mind. No one's forcing to change your
- 48:13mind. Like, OK, maybe they would
- 48:15change your mind. Maybe they maybe they have a
- 48:16good story to make sense. But you don't have to.
- 48:19Like you can keep the thing. You can still believe the thing
- 48:21you believe, right? I mean, sometimes I think we
- 48:23have this fear that I'm going to hear a thing that might change
- 48:25my mind. OK, that might even be true.
- 48:28But you aren't required to like you can just believe what you
- 48:31believe and the other person can believe what what they believe
- 48:34too. And those things can exist at
- 48:36the same time, like you can understand each other better,
- 48:39but not change your position at all, right?
- 48:41That's that's OK. Like that works.
- 48:44You can do you can hold both those thoughts at the same time.
- 48:46And I think it's hard for us to do that because we see this idea
- 48:49of even hearing them somehow makes us less, you know, less of
- 48:55a of a member of our tribe. Right, that's I I have seen that
- 49:02as well. We need to be listening to each
- 49:04other more. And it.
- 49:05Needs to be made okay to do that.
- 49:07Yeah, it needs to be made okay to do that.
- 49:09And you know, it's OK to say I don't agree with you, but I
- 49:13have. But if you can get to the point
- 49:14where I can sort of see how you came to that conclusion.
- 49:17But even that our own side sometimes will call us like an
- 49:22apostate for saying the other. You can see how the other person
- 49:25thinks that. Like you're not even allowed to
- 49:27have that kind of a thought. Right, right.
- 49:31Yeah, it's. Yeah, and we need crazy.
- 49:36Time. And like I said, I mean, so much
- 49:38of it starts with us. I mean, I think if you look at
- 49:40Trump like I think Trump's a bottom up movement, right?
- 49:42The Republican Party wasn't going to Trump saying please be
- 49:46our guy, right? This came up from the bottom
- 49:48right. They didn't want him either.
- 49:50They didn't want him either. Exactly.
- 49:52So, you know, I'm still don't want him, but but I mean, he
- 49:55came from, you know, from up from the bottom.
- 49:57So I think if you look at people that say this, you can't, well,
- 50:00that'll never work. Like we'll never get anywhere
- 50:02from the bottom up. Obviously you can, right.
- 50:05The guy's been president twice. So, so, you know, I think we
- 50:09have to keep that as a, as a, you know, just a reminder that
- 50:13yes, we can do things from the bottom up.
- 50:16Yeah, that is a very good point. OK, so the other question I had
- 50:22was how can we teach people to be more critical of the
- 50:26information they see online and in the media, which you did
- 50:30point that out a bit. I know I personally don't watch
- 50:34Fox News or CNNI don't watch any of it.
- 50:36I read what what I'm consuming and I'm and I try to do both
- 50:43sides, you know, as far as what I'm reading.
- 50:46And sometimes it is very frustrating because it's like,
- 50:49also like you had said earlier, they might not be lying, but
- 50:53they're leaving out an important part of the story.
- 50:55And sometimes it's like, why do I have to spend so much time
- 50:59getting to the truth of this? But but yeah, how?
- 51:02How would you suggest people be more critical of the information
- 51:05they see? Yeah, it's a really, you know,
- 51:09it's it's so unfortunate that, you know, there isn't like a
- 51:14magical place you can send people and say, well, this will
- 51:16always get you the, you know, quality information or whatever,
- 51:19right? And so what's the information
- 51:23landscape that we're in is really a challenge for all of
- 51:26us, right? Even people that are pretty good
- 51:28at this kind of thing, it can be a challenge, right?
- 51:30Even the sourcing is hard. The, the, you know, things like
- 51:35even all these rating sites, right?
- 51:36So you can they rate sites on sort of reliability and bias and
- 51:39stuff like that. But just remember that's like an
- 51:41average, that's like an aggregate score.
- 51:43So even somebody that maybe is rated well does take the Wall
- 51:47Street Journal or something, right?
- 51:48They're rated pretty highly for reliability.
- 51:50I think they lean to the right in terms of those ratings, but
- 51:54they still write garbage sometimes.
- 51:56And likewise, you know, a publication that's not rated
- 52:01that highly sometimes writes really good stuff, puts out
- 52:03really good stuff, put a lot of garbage, but they also put out
- 52:06really good stuff. So it's really hard to just say
- 52:08listen to read these three things or listen to these three
- 52:11shows and you'll get the best perspective out there.
- 52:13Unfortunately, it's really hard and so and and the other
- 52:18challenge, sometimes even the look at both sides things has
- 52:22its flaws because if I'm getting 2 versions of garbage, yeah, it
- 52:27still didn't really learn anything, right?
- 52:28I'm still wasting a bunch of time to get 2 versions of
- 52:31garbage. So it's really a heavy lift lift
- 52:33for us all. I think there are some good
- 52:37tools that that can sort of help if people know about the 1440
- 52:41news. It's like a week, a daily
- 52:42newsletter. They do a pretty good job to
- 52:45pick the stuff that that is not over the top, you know, biased.
- 52:50Obviously you're going to land at a page that isn't on a normal
- 52:53news site, whether it's Wall Street Journal, New York Times,
- 52:55Washington Post, whatever. But they tried to do a pretty
- 52:58good job. Just select down to the ones
- 53:00that didn't, aren't taking a really hard line partisan
- 53:03stance. And you get a daily e-mail from
- 53:06them listing off, you know, a bunch of things from the day.
- 53:09So that's a pretty good one. Tangle News is sort of a
- 53:13different approach at it. They do typically one issue a
- 53:18day and they sort of drill down on that one issue and they do a
- 53:23good job of surfacing. They call it the what the right
- 53:26is saying, what the left is saying.
- 53:27And then they give their take and they do a pretty good job
- 53:31surfacing a lot, a good sort of general sense of what the left
- 53:35and what people on the right are saying about the topic.
- 53:38And they have, I don't know, they, they have a hard time
- 53:40describing exactly what they are, But I think you could say
- 53:43that the editors try to be centrist is probably the best
- 53:47way. They're they're not super
- 53:49partisan for sure, but you know, all of those words are hard to
- 53:54even define right, the whole left, right spectrum is hard to
- 53:57define all that. But you know, they're a good
- 53:59source for, I think getting a good sense of what the left and
- 54:01right is saying and then kind of giving their take.
- 54:04And I think there's another similar kind of thing you can
- 54:08look at called All sides that is also a source for a lot of other
- 54:12material that tries to do the same thing.
- 54:14When they sort of put together summaries of what's happening on
- 54:17the left and right and, and, and give you some background on
- 54:21that. And they typically are are
- 54:22picking, you know, pieces of information that are better.
- 54:26Like I say that's you can't guarantee it's going to be
- 54:28great. You can't guarantee it's not
- 54:29doing the things we're saying where it left some stuff out.
- 54:31I I think one of the big things I always tell people is
- 54:34especially if it really is getting you riled up, that's the
- 54:37question to step back and ask what are they leaving out?
- 54:39Because they probably are leaving something out.
- 54:41Yeah, that's one of the best things you can do is and who
- 54:44else is talking about this and you can't find any other sources
- 54:48maybe on the other side or anywhere else.
- 54:50It's probably a semi made-up story.
- 54:52Like there are there something about it that's fishy if only
- 54:55one side is talking about it. So those are some tricks.
- 55:00But I'm I'm I'm sympathetic because it is a tough problem.
- 55:03There's no magic answer. Yeah, I when I started doing
- 55:08this, I started in December and I had no idea it was going to be
- 55:13so much work to just put out like a 10 minute update.
- 55:17Like for example, my episode that I am recording later today,
- 55:21I had 22 pages of notes and it it's down to an 88 page script.
- 55:28There's so much crap in there, you know, that it's like, I
- 55:33mean, a lot of opinions and everything inserted into things.
- 55:36And I try to try to just do like the factual stuff.
- 55:40Sometimes if something's irritating me, I'll put my own
- 55:43opinion in. But yeah, I had no idea it was
- 55:46going to be so much work just getting to to the the facts and
- 55:53the entire picture of each headline that's out there
- 55:56basically. So yeah, I can see where people.
- 56:00Would get lost, yeah. And you and you also, you know,
- 56:03and maybe this is a place where AI could help a little.
- 56:06Yeah, Sometimes they're just logical fallacies in some of
- 56:09these stories. And I think AI could help us
- 56:11point out that kind of stuff, like when it's in order to
- 56:14create that narrative. Sometimes I think they do some
- 56:16logical fallacies. And I think AI could help with
- 56:18that. So when we talk about AI being
- 56:20really dangerous potentially, I think that's true.
- 56:23There are potential places where AI could maybe help with some of
- 56:26this. Yes, I, I have had where I have
- 56:30just so much stuff, but it's like, OK, well, what, what's the
- 56:34real story here? And I just ask crock like, Hey,
- 56:39can you just summarize what's going on here?
- 56:41And often times it is different and it points out, oh, well, I
- 56:47didn't hear that part, you know, and then it'll kind of summarize
- 56:51everything. So then I, I'm like, OK, so I'll
- 56:53put this in my own words. And it does save me some time
- 56:56and it does help help with those stories where it's like there,
- 57:00there seems to be a spin on this one.
- 57:04Well, and when there is, which is a lot of times, especially if
- 57:06it's a little bit sort of a controversial topic, the other
- 57:09thing about AI that I worry about, some people say, well, I
- 57:11just use AI, take the answer. And so it's all I'm all good.
- 57:14But you know, with something like perplexity AI and most the
- 57:17others are starting to also cite sources.
- 57:20I mean, you'll find this that the sources they picked probably
- 57:22weren't comprehensive, right? And, and you know, so even, I
- 57:28mean, AI could definitely be informing, especially to give
- 57:31kind of a zeitgeist of what the world thinks.
- 57:33That doesn't necessarily mean that it's a fully, fully a
- 57:39nuanced, complete story. Yes, and I have caught Grok
- 57:44making mistakes. It took it like months to
- 57:47recognize Mike Johnson as speaker of the House, you know,
- 57:51type it's like, well is, are there no articles that mention
- 57:54that he became speaker of the House?
- 57:56Like what sources are you pulling?
- 57:59So there there are things where I've kind of been like, no, I
- 58:02think I'll argue with it. I'll think I think you're wrong.
- 58:06And then it'll do like a deep search and then it comes up with
- 58:10with better information. So you do have to kind of make
- 58:15sure that you're looking into the sources and what they're the
- 58:18whatever AI platform you're using is being thorough enough.
- 58:24So did you, did you happen to listen to the episode with Evan
- 58:29Jaqua or have you talked to him from the Solutions party at all?
- 58:35I have not. I'm a little bit aware of what
- 58:37they're doing, but I'm not super aware of it.
- 58:39OK, it's so he mentioned, you know, we were kind of talking
- 58:44about scorecards earlier. He mentioned using a rating
- 58:49service of all of these journalists and news sources.
- 58:54And you get graded like A through F on how factual you are
- 59:00or how how often you make mistakes, stuff like that.
- 59:04And I think that that could be really helpful for people
- 59:08looking to get their news from a reliable sources.
- 59:11I've noticed a lot of people after a certain age are having a
- 59:18really hard time with the Internet with finding out
- 59:21whether they are viewing things that are from a reliable source.
- 59:25I've, you know, I'll get sent like, oh, you should buy these
- 59:28flowers. And it's clearly AI created type
- 59:33type things where I can see the AI is tricking people.
- 59:36And I just thought that that was a really good idea that he had
- 59:41of, of grading your news sources.
- 59:43So, you know, hey, this one tends to be unreliable.
- 59:47Maybe don't use that as a source for people who who are kind of
- 59:53just wanting to get their information quick and not have
- 59:56to look into anything. They could just go to that a
- 59:58rated news source. I don't know how to implement
- 1:00:02something like that but. Yeah, I mean, the challenge is
- 1:00:05like I said, one of the challenges, like I said, is that
- 1:00:07these publications, most of the publications, even the ones that
- 1:00:10are rated highly, put out some bad stuff too, right?
- 1:00:12And and even some of the ones that are rated poorly sometimes
- 1:00:14put out good stuff, you know? So that's one of the challenges.
- 1:00:17I do like the idea of almost rating individual journalists,
- 1:00:21but again, it's going to be an aggregate because they probably
- 1:00:23do good stuff and bad stuff too. But so that that's that's a big
- 1:00:27challenge with all these rating systems.
- 1:00:29I mean, it's not a bad indicator like a, it could be a reasonable
- 1:00:31place to start, but just because because somebody has a really
- 1:00:34high rating doesn't mean they're always only doing really good
- 1:00:37stuff. And I think we have to also
- 1:00:38separate opinion pieces from news pieces.
- 1:00:40So just just remember if it's an opinion piece that the editorial
- 1:00:45rigor is much different compared to a new an actual news piece.
- 1:00:49So like typically I was, I was mentioning the one of the, I
- 1:00:54forget now, but one of the partisan papers, generally their
- 1:00:57opinion stuff sort of garbage, but their news is actually
- 1:00:59pretty good. So it can be hard to kind of
- 1:01:02keep that in mind, but I I, and that actually another point of
- 1:01:06this I want to bring up is this is another piece that can help
- 1:01:09kind of think about like the quality of the thing you're
- 1:01:12reading too, is if nobody has put a by line on it, nobody who
- 1:01:17wants to put their name on it, then this is probably bogus.
- 1:01:19Like might have been put together by AI or somebody did
- 1:01:22some cut and pasting because you know, you want to see if there's
- 1:01:25a byline and if there's a byline, then you can go look at
- 1:01:27that personal, what kind of stuff have they written before?
- 1:01:29Where do they stand on this or that?
- 1:01:31And you can get a, you can get some history of that author.
- 1:01:34So if it, if it has no byline, I would say that's probably
- 1:01:37garbage. No one's willing to put their
- 1:01:40name on it. Yeah.
- 1:01:41That's a very good, very good point.
- 1:01:44So is there anything else that you want to any other point you
- 1:01:48want to drive home or anything else that you would like the
- 1:01:51audience to know about your podcast or anything else?
- 1:01:58Yeah, I mean, I think the, I think the biggest thing is this
- 1:02:03is, as I said, this is a challenging problem.
- 1:02:05So it can be a very intimidating, I would say start
- 1:02:08small, right? I mean, I think it's easiest to
- 1:02:10start small and and don't be intimidated by, you know, for
- 1:02:16some of us, it's overwhelming, right to say, I've got this
- 1:02:19friend who are maybe their former friend and there and we
- 1:02:23broke the friendship. And maybe you don't even start
- 1:02:25there. Maybe you start that may be a
- 1:02:27goal someday you want to reestablish that friendship or
- 1:02:29something like that with that person.
- 1:02:31But maybe that's not where you start, right?
- 1:02:32Maybe you start somewhere else, building some of these other
- 1:02:34skills. Maybe just talking to people in
- 1:02:36real life, like you said, meet your neighbors a little bit, get
- 1:02:39used to having some of those conversations and you know, and
- 1:02:43then maybe you can have a strategy to approach your
- 1:02:46friend. So I, I would say start small,
- 1:02:47start local. I mean, that's the best, the
- 1:02:50best way to get better at this and go outside your bubble.
- 1:02:55Of course, locally, like I'm lucky, you know, there was a
- 1:02:58while I was even thinking, well, we should move to an area that's
- 1:03:00more uniform, you know, but I actually really appreciate now
- 1:03:04that I live in a very purple area.
- 1:03:05So you can pretty much randomly walk down the street and find
- 1:03:08people on left or the right. And I actually really appreciate
- 1:03:11that now and appreciate being in a purple neighborhood.
- 1:03:16Yeah, I sometimes I think, you know, I had, I had people
- 1:03:20delete, delete me, just unfriend me completely because I voted
- 1:03:24for Trump. And it's and I think about them
- 1:03:26sometimes and it's like, you know, we've been friends for a
- 1:03:29long time and never had a conversation and just because of
- 1:03:33who I voted for, threw the friendship away.
- 1:03:35So I don't know if it's worth repairing, but I sometimes it's
- 1:03:39tempting to, like you said, just go and stay in your own bubble
- 1:03:45and where it's comfortable. But but then as someone who's
- 1:03:51more centrist, I'm losing all my other friends that most of the
- 1:03:56time we agree on stuff. There's just certain things that
- 1:03:58we're not and, and you're, you're missing out on assets.
- 1:04:03Like even if you don't know the, if you, even if you don't know
- 1:04:06the person, I, I kind of like that my area, you don't also, I
- 1:04:11mean, I was conservative, but I wouldn't say that it's so
- 1:04:15conservative that it's not similar to what you mentioned
- 1:04:19where I don't know how someone voted just by looking at them.
- 1:04:23I'm going to talk to somebody on the street no matter what they
- 1:04:26look like you, you know, I, I really don't care how they
- 1:04:29voted. I'm going to be nice to you
- 1:04:31either way. So I do have, we do have the
- 1:04:34Iowa nice thing going on that that I am happy about.
- 1:04:38But but I do think you make a good point that that we we could
- 1:04:42be putting ourselves out there a little bit more to try to
- 1:04:45understand each other instead of fleeing, you know?
- 1:04:50Yeah, it's. Hard.
- 1:04:52It's definitely hard. It's intimidating.
- 1:04:54Something you said there I think is another really huge 1 is
- 1:04:56that, you know, in this work, it, it sounds like a platitude
- 1:05:00or whatever, but I mean, kindness goes so far, right?
- 1:05:04I mean, so, and you're like, OK, I guess I should not be
- 1:05:07surprised by that, right? But when the science really
- 1:05:10backs that up that these, those, that the, the community, that
- 1:05:15the, the bonding that's built to kindness has such an impact to
- 1:05:20how everything else goes. So that's a great place to
- 1:05:22start. You know, I don't know you, you
- 1:05:25probably noticed this, that, I mean, sometimes you're having
- 1:05:27these conversation with people and they're, they're so caught
- 1:05:29up in their sort of politics world.
- 1:05:31It's like so become so important to their identity and their
- 1:05:34movement. Like we're talking about, I
- 1:05:36don't know, fishing or we're talking about something else.
- 1:05:38And there's some of them are trying to catch hints.
- 1:05:39Is this guy left or is he right? Is this guy left or is he right?
- 1:05:42You know, they're just trying to find these hints like all the
- 1:05:44time. And I say the wrong thing,
- 1:05:46suddenly I'm going to be kicked out of it.
- 1:05:49Yes, I in that I think that has gotten so much worse.
- 1:05:52I, my husband says that he comes home, he comes home complaining
- 1:05:57about someone talking about politics at work.
- 1:05:59And it's like, why? Why is anyone discussing
- 1:06:01politics at work? You're stuck there working now
- 1:06:05you're being held captive. I just say, you know, I think in
- 1:06:09some settings it's inappropriate as well, but it's really taken
- 1:06:13over. It's become so normalized, and I
- 1:06:15think social media has helped with that too, that we have
- 1:06:18these social media political arguments or some people do, not
- 1:06:21everybody does. But for the folks that are doing
- 1:06:22it, that they then carry that into real life sometimes, right?
- 1:06:25That I'm just going to walk into a room and say something super
- 1:06:28political, like for no reason. It's like, is that necessary?
- 1:06:31Like I thought we were having like a birthday party.
- 1:06:37It's such a good point. You know, suddenly everyone's
- 1:06:39kind of uncomfortable, even if you kind of agree with them,
- 1:06:41you're you're uncomfortable. Like if we need that right now,
- 1:06:43that. We're gonna eat cake soon.
- 1:06:46What's? Yeah.
- 1:06:47Where's this conversation going? Yeah.
- 1:06:50Yeah. Yeah, it's unfortunate that we,
- 1:06:52that, you know, it's sort of come to that.
- 1:06:54So anyway, yeah, no, I think being kind is a great place to
- 1:06:57start, right? Yep.
- 1:06:58I talked about starting small, starting smalls, being kind,
- 1:07:01right? Raising your kids Like, OK, I
- 1:07:03feel like I can't solve all these big problems that are out
- 1:07:05there in the world. Hey, raise a good family, raise
- 1:07:08good children. That's that's a huge step
- 1:07:10towards, you know, making things better.
- 1:07:12So even if that's all you ever do, I say all, but I mean, if
- 1:07:16that's what you do, if that's your contribution, you don't
- 1:07:18have to get involved in politics, right?
- 1:07:20Raise good kids. It's a great, it's a great way
- 1:07:22to spend your time. Yeah, Yep.
- 1:07:26All right. Well, yeah, I, I appreciate you
- 1:07:30coming on to the podcast. I think it's it's a very
- 1:07:34important topic and great conversations to have.
- 1:07:40Where can people find find your show in it and you have enough.
- 1:07:45You have two. Yeah, I actually have three
- 1:07:48shows if you count like a little thing I do called Outrage
- 1:07:51Science Bites, which is like if for folks that don't want to
- 1:07:53listen to her, 45 minutes, it's like a little little 10 minutes
- 1:07:56and under little snippets of some of the science that we
- 1:07:59talked about. But yeah, the The Flag Shop
- 1:08:01podcast is outrage overload. And it's the best place to find
- 1:08:04all this stuff is at outrageoverload.net.
- 1:08:07And that's also where my contact info is.
- 1:08:09And I know is you're probably the same boat as me.
- 1:08:11I love hearing from you. Like people think, oh, he's a
- 1:08:13big star. He doesn't want to hear from me.
- 1:08:15Oh no, I want to hear from everybody.
- 1:08:16And I will answer every e-mail eventually I will get get get to
- 1:08:20it and I will answer it. And also I love, I have like a
- 1:08:22speak pipe thing. You can leave me a voice message
- 1:08:24through that. So I, I love hearing from
- 1:08:26people. So if you listen to an episode
- 1:08:28and you thought Manny got it wrong, that was terrible.
- 1:08:30I want to hear that too. Like this is great feedback.
- 1:08:33We as podcasters love, love this kind of feedback.
- 1:08:35And, and I, I will say, like on my show, as you know, with the
- 1:08:39podcast, you don't necessarily get the kind of demographic data
- 1:08:42automatically, but I've done polling and, and the self
- 1:08:44reporting is I'm sort of 6040 blue to red.
- 1:08:47So I'm pretty proud that I have a somewhat diverse group.
- 1:08:51And I will say that the, the, the people on the right that
- 1:08:55sometimes complain like, no, I brought too much of my bias in
- 1:08:58or I didn't bring the right people in.
- 1:08:59And there's no way. Look at this, they complain, but
- 1:09:01they support the show like they're they're so glad to see
- 1:09:04somebody like trying to bring a balanced perspective to things.
- 1:09:08I think the world is hungry for that.
- 1:09:11Yes, yeah, I I think everyone should go check it out.
- 1:09:15I will put the links in the show notes as well.
- 1:09:18So yeah. And.
- 1:09:20If you hear something you don't like, let me know.
- 1:09:22Let me know. I do want to hear it, yeah.
- 1:09:26Sounds good. I'm too scared to say that.
- 1:09:29Yeah, but I probably should. I mean, any contact is better
- 1:09:33than no contact I suppose. Yeah, I mean, the more, you
- 1:09:36know, sort of serious it is, the better.
- 1:09:39I usually send me a bad word that's fine, but it's not.
- 1:09:42I'm not gonna help me very much. But yeah, if you have some
- 1:09:44serious critique, I love it. I'd love to hear that stuff.
- 1:09:49So yeah, sounds looking forward to hearing from everybody.
- 1:09:52Great. All right.
- 1:09:54Sounds good. Well, I thank you again for
- 1:09:56coming on to the show and I will talk to you soon.
- 1:10:01Great. Thank you.
- 1:10:02Thank you.