Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #65.🎙️ |Public Inquiry - Review of Week Beginning 18th May 2026|
Transcript
- 0:04It ought to have been a reasonably straightforward week,
- 0:08a mere technical discussion about the abandonment of a rural
- 0:11road. Instead, it developed into an understanding and belief by
- 0:17the earth protectors of just how far the DFI is prepared to go in
- 0:21the erosion and hollowing out of its procedural safeguards to
- 0:25punch through this application, as I described in podcast number
- 0:3062 Retired civil engineer Douglas Hill challenged the
- 0:34legality and compliance of the roads abandonment process,
- 0:39saying he would not jeopardise his professional integrity by
- 0:42participating in this noise and calling for other engineers in
- 0:46the room, some who were former colleagues of his, to examine
- 0:50their conscience. My belief is they told their collective
- 0:57consciousness to go and sit in the corner as they got on with
- 1:01what can only be described as a process verging on criminality,
- 1:07there was huge shock in the room that a highly experienced roads
- 1:10and safety expert representing community concerns self excluded
- 1:14himself from the process and was finally barred from attending
- 1:17any further sessions by the commissioners during During the
- 1:23week, many representations were made from the local community
- 1:26about the importance of this road to the area, from turbary
- 1:30rights to training routes for runners and boxers and
- 1:33everything in between. We were left to no doubt about how
- 1:37essential this road is for connection and community that it
- 1:40is a vital element of the matrix supporting commercial and
- 1:44farming activities, leisure and tourism, health and well-being
- 1:49of the locale. Local woman Olivia McCullough's contribution
- 1:53was deeply moving, describing the road as part of us capturing
- 1:58what this fight is about. This, the emotional reality of
- 2:02ordinary people, contrasts the language used by consultants on
- 2:07their spreadsheets who refer to human beings as receptors. I'm
- 2:12still trying to work out at what point communities became
- 2:15receptors, lived experiences become data points, and
- 2:19sensitive landscapes become impacts to be mitigated, it's
- 2:24very bloody obvious. If you can strip the humanity out of
- 2:27community, then the lived reality of these communities
- 2:30disappears behind technical language and consultants'
- 2:33reports. But it's all okay, because DFI is still claiming
- 2:39neutrality. When probed, they repeatedly insisted they had not
- 2:43made a decision on the road abandonment order. Yet,
- 2:47unsurprisingly, draft abandonment documentation
- 2:50already exists. This inevitably increases the perception that
- 2:55decisions have already been made ever before any evidence has
- 2:59been heard. They admitted they carried out no independent
- 3:03assessment on whether the road is necessary, effectively
- 3:06handing this responsibility to Delrayan and the PAC. Again and
- 3:12again, community repeatedly challenged why public
- 3:16infrastructure is being surrendered for private
- 3:19financial interests, and once again, it was felt by all
- 3:24third-party protectors that DFI are acting less like custodians
- 3:30of public infrastructures and more like facilitators for the
- 3:34applicant. I believe it's a bit like Ireland during the war,
- 3:39neutral on the side of the allies, DFI, to all intents and
- 3:44purposes, is looking like it's neutral on the side of the
- 3:47applicant. If that's not the reality, then the department is
- 3:52doing a remarkably poor job of demonstrating otherwise. The
- 3:56timetable now appears to be operating on the same scientific
- 4:01principles as a lava lamp. Every time you think it's settled,
- 4:06somebody gives it another shake, and the whole thing starts
- 4:09floating off in a different direction again. Landscape
- 4:13hearings are cancelled, and then they're not, and then they are
- 4:18threatened. Judicial reviews also begin to impact inquiry
- 4:21scheduling. This leads to anxiety for third-party
- 4:26protectors, the only unsalaried people in the room, I might add,
- 4:30who repeatedly raise concerns about wasted leave from work,
- 4:34extra expert costs, duplicate attendance, and procedural
- 4:38unfairness. It is true to say the process increasingly feels
- 4:43inaccessible and exhausting for ordinary people trying to
- 4:46participate, and you would have to hope that those
- 4:51administrating this process never one day find themselves
- 4:55depending on the same system for fairness, empathy, and equal
- 4:59truth. Statement from the start we have always said we are stand
- 5:04for the air we breathe, the water we drink, the earth that
- 5:07supports us, and the health of communities both now and in the
- 5:11future, but after this week it feels like we are also being
- 5:15forced to defend democratic values at a time when we can
- 5:18already see in the United States how quickly public trust,
- 5:23institutional integrity, and basic safeguards can begin to
- 5:27collapse once those in power stop respecting them, and really
- 5:32that just about sums up this week. For more detailed account
- 5:37of each day, go to our website, don'tmind us.com it'll be in the
- 5:41show notes below, or indeed listen to the three preceding
- 5:45podcasts before this podcast. And finally, a request: if
- 5:50you're listening to the podcast on Spotify, do give us a follow,
- 5:54and if you listen to us on Apple, give us a review and hit
- 5:57the star button as well. It really makes a difference and
- 6:01helps us to get our voices out even further. We'll see you all
- 6:05next week.
- 6:06Bye.