Latest / Friends Like Us: Stories About Friendship, Community & Belonging / The Gentle Art of Guiding Without Controlling Your Friend | Friends Like Us
Transcript
- I watched her shoulders drop three inches when I offered advice she didn’t ask for, and in that tiny movement, I realized I had just broken something fragile. We think we are building bridges, but sometimes we are just closing doors. There is a specific kind of panic that sets in when someone you love is struggling, especially if they are younger than you or perhaps just newer to the world. You see the trap they are walking into, and your instinct is to grab their hand, pull them back, and say, "Don't do that." It comes from a place of deep care, don't get me wrong. But lately, I’ve been sitting with the discomfort of realizing that my instinct to fix things might actually be about my own need for control rather than their actual needs. Tell me more about that moment when you felt the urge to intervene. Was it urgent? Or was it just uncomfortable to watch them stumble? Because often, we mistake our discomfort for their danger. We want to smooth the edges of their journey because seeing them struggle makes us feel helpless. And isn't it easier to be the guide than to be the companion who sits in the dark with them? When you have been around the block a few extra times, you carry a library of mistakes in your head. You know which paths lead to dead ends and which ones offer beautiful views, even if they are steep. It feels like a moral obligation to share that map. I remember calling my friend Elena last year. She was twenty-six, standing at a crossroads in her career, terrified of making the wrong choice. I started listing reasons why Option A was safer, why Option B was risky, drawing on my own ten years of experience in that industry. I spoke with authority. I sounded wise. But looking back, I realize I wasn't listening to what she wanted; I was projecting my own fears onto her future. That’s the stuff we keep hidden—the arrogance of experience. We assume that because we survived the storm, we know exactly how to navigate it for someone else. But storms change. The wind blows differently for every soul. It is easy to dress up overstepping as love. We tell ourselves we are protecting them, saving them time, sparing them pain. But here is the hard truth: by removing their obstacles, we also remove their growth. When I mentor a younger friend, I have to constantly check my ego. Am I doing this for them, or am I doing this so I can feel needed? There is a subtle difference, but it changes everything. If I am doing it to feel needed, I will push too hard. I will make decisions for them. I will become the director of their life instead of the supporting actor. You’re not alone in this feeling. Many of us grew up believing that caring meant managing. We learned to solve problems to earn affection. So when a younger friend comes to us with a problem, we don't just hear a problem; we hear an invitation to step into our power. But power shared is different from power imposed. The shift happened for me when I started asking a simple question before offering any wisdom. Instead of saying, "Here is what I would do," I began asking, "Do you want support, or do you want strategy?" It sounds small, but it changes the entire dynamic. Support means I am here to listen, to validate, to sit with you in the mess. Strategy means you are ready to hear my perspective, to weigh options, to plan. Most of the time, people just want support. They want to know they aren't crazy for feeling overwhelmed. When I give strategy without being asked, it feels like criticism. It feels like I am saying, "You are doing it wrong." But when I ask first, I give them agency. I respect their autonomy. It allows them to choose whether they want my help or just my presence. And usually, they choose presence. They just need to know I’m there, steady and warm, while they figure out the rest. This brings us to the hardest part: letting them fail. Not catastrophically, mind you. I’m not talking about letting them drive off a cliff. I mean letting them make the small, painful mistakes that teach resilience. If I always catch them, they never learn how to balance on their own. I remember watching my niece try to tie her shoes for the tenth time. My instinct was to jump in and finish it for her. It was faster. It was neater. But I saw the determination in her face, the furrowed brow, the little huff of frustration. If I had finished it, I would have robbed her of that moment of triumph. With friends, it’s the same. If I send the email for them, if I make the phone call, if I clear the path, they remain dependent on my competence. They don't build their own confidence. I have to trust that they can handle the disappointment of a wrong turn. I have to trust that they will recover. And they will. Usually, stronger than I expect. So, what is my role then? If I’m not the savior, not the director, not the fixer... who am I? I am the witness. I am the person who sees them clearly, flaws and all, and stays. I hold space for their process without imposing my timeline on it. This requires a patience that doesn't come naturally to many of us, especially high-achievers who are used to results. But friendship is not a project to be managed. It is a relationship to be lived. When I stop trying to guide every step, I find myself more present. I notice more. I hear the nuance in their voice. I see the joy in their small wins because I’m not too busy planning their next move. The connection deepens when the hierarchy dissolves. We are just two humans navigating life together, sharing light where we can, but respecting that each other’s shadows are necessary for depth. If you are mentoring a younger friend, or just guiding someone through a tough patch, try shifting your language. Swap advice for curiosity. Swap solutions for questions. Ask them what they think is working. Ask them what scares them most. Let them lead the conversation about their own life. It feels counterintuitive at first. You might feel useless, like you’re not contributing. But you are contributing the most valuable thing possible: your belief in their ability to figure it out. That belief is contagious. It builds their self-trust. And isn’t that what we really want for the people we love? We want them to trust themselves. We want them to know that even when they stumble, they have the strength to rise. My job isn’t to keep them from falling. My job is to be there when they hit the ground, reminding them that they are okay, and that I believe in their next step. Thank you for trusting me with your time today. I hope you gave yourself permission to let go of the wheel with someone you love this week. Until next time, keep showing up, gently. I’ll be right here when you return.