Latest / Windy City Breakdown / Cubs pitching ponderings and analyzing Alex Bregman's struggles
Transcript
- Andy: Hey everybody, welcome into another episode of the Windy City Breakdown. I'm Andy Martinez, joined by my co-hosts, Kyle Milinovich and Tony Andreckie. Guys, the ⁓ Cubs are still sh they've won. They've won a couple more games than than the last time we recorded, but let the it's still it's still not great ⁓ with the Cubs. Tony, I I want to start with you. You were at the ballpark on we're recording Wednesday morning. ⁓ you were at the ballpark Tuesday night. Give me give me give me something. What's going on with the Cubs? Tony Andracki: First, did it? Well, so before we get into Cubs, I am wearing a Bears shirt today and we see Caleb Williams is officially on the Madden cover. So I just I feel like that's like the biggest news right now. And I was curious your thoughts, especially Kyle. He's the first ever Bear, obviously first ever Bears quarterback. So like we're living in a world where what's that phrase? Like we're it feels like we're living in a simulation because we have a Bears quarterback on Madden, which is crazy. Andy: Is he the first ever bear? Ky: Mm-hmm. Andy: Yeah. Tony Andracki: But like I was curious your guys, especially Kyle, is there a Madden curse coming? Ky: Yeah. Yeah, that was my first thought. I kinda didn't like it at all. I was I was I thought you were going there. ⁓ but I was actually looking this up. I think Patrick Mahomes won a Super Bowl when he was ⁓ on the cover of Madden a couple of years ago. ⁓ and Josh Allen won an ⁓ V P. When he was on the cover of Madden a couple years ago. So I I had a feeling somebody was gonna team me up with this, so I looked it up a little bit. ⁓ those are two instances of no curse, but there's about Tony Andracki: Yeah, yeah. Ky: Forty seven other instances of a curse. I was that I was thinking, I was going down a rabbit hole. Can you think of the most random player to ever grace the cover of Madden? This might yes. That I mean that's what that's exactly who I thought too. I was like, damn, pe ⁓ Madden twelve, Peyton Hills is on the cover. I mean, what that guy had what one good year? And he they're just like, you know what, white white running back, let him rip. Andy: Paytonhill is Paytonhill's? Tony Andracki: Peyton Hillis. Literally. Andy: I mean it's accurate. It's it it it's i it it's great who do you ⁓ who was on the the last few years, Kyle, ⁓ of the cover? Do you know off the top of your head? Ky: I mean it's crazy. ⁓ I Josh Allen. Tony Andracki: McCaffrey was on one of ⁓ recently. Christian McCaffrey's on one recently. Andy: Was it the year he tore his ACL? Ky: ⁓ Tony Andracki: ⁓ it was one of the it was one of the years. Ky: No no. It was right after. Andy: Okay, all right, here, I pulled it up. I pulled it up, I pulled it up. Saquon Saquon twenty-six. Saquon had pretty he was he had a fine year by but like by his standards, not great. ⁓ McCaffrey was the year before twenty-five, so I think that was the year he tore his ACL. ⁓ Ky: ⁓ no, that wasn't part of the Reddit search I saw. Andy: Josh Allen was twenty four. Tony Andracki: Wait, McCaffrey never toured his ACL, he just had like other injuries. Yeah. Andy: ⁓ was it? I thought it a tornado. Excuse me. Sorry. ⁓ jet Ky: No, I'm the only one who tears their ACL around here. Tony Andracki: Mm. Andy: J John Madden was twenty three and then Brady and Mahomes were twenty two. Ky: Was John Wait, was John Madden? Tony Andracki: So actually, yeah, really really and Brady didn't really have like a cursor. Yeah, Madden. Ky: Was he what did that happen af I'm assuming after his death? Otherwise if that was before, that's like the ultimate dead in curse. Andy: Yeah, I would I yeah, yeah. If it was I if it was before that's that's the ultimate Madden curse. But no, I'm pretty sure it was after. Ky: That would make sense. Okay. Brady and Mahomes. Yeah, then I think Mahomes went it was him and Brady. That was when Mahomes won it. Against the Niners. So that would make sense. ⁓ but I yeah, I mean, besides like the manicurse, I guess it's cool. I don't really I hope it doesn't like jinx them. I kinda hate that there's like so much there's such a spotlight on the Bears. I kinda like when they fly under the radar, play a bunch of noon games on Sundays. I don't want the prime time three twenty five or seven o'clock Sunday night spots. Andy: Yep, yep. Ky: 'Cause that just sets sets us up for embarrassment. But that really doesn't have anything to do with the Madden cover. But I hope there's not a jinx, 'cause that would suck. Tony Andracki: What a negative way to view fandom. Andy: Seriously. You sound like me. Ky: Yeah. Well you know what? You know why? It's 'cause the Cubs the Cubs have really hurt me recently. So now I'm just I'm turn I'm morphing into negative Andy. That's really all it is. Andy: Mm. Well, it's the thing, like the the Cubs are kinda like the the Bears, right? Or like the Bears are kinda like the Cubs where there's a lot of hype going in, there's a lot of hype going into this Cubs season and the Cubs have kinda let everyone I I mean they're they're they're they're over five hundred, like in the grand scheme of things they're okay, but it's been really ugly recently. So it's like ⁓ all right, go ahead, Tony, sorry. Tony Andracki: That's the th No, that's that's the thing, is like, ⁓ Kyle, you retweeted from the Winnie City breakdown account Chuck Garfine's stats of the Cubs record versus the White Sox record, which is the same run scored average. ⁓ was there another one in there? ⁓ but either way, it's like the Cubs and White Sox to date, to Wednesda as of Wednesday morning, are essentially having the exact same season. And somebody posted a meme Ky: ⁓ Tony Andracki: Which was great. I I feel like it's so hard to use it, but it's one person on one side of the bus looking at like the brick wall of a cl or the rock wall of a cliff and it looks depressing, and the other person looking at like the bright, like scenic view, and they're like this this meme has never been more accurate. And it's true. It has not been. Like all the people are on of White Sox fans and in White Sox Kingdom is on the left side, like loving this because they're thirty t they're three games above five hundred and they're, you know, thirty two wins at this point of the year and all that. Ky: Mm-hmm. Andy: Yep. Tony Andracki: Everybody in the Cub set is like, ⁓ my God, the sky is falling, what's going wrong? And it it's it's funny the difference because it's because of how they each got here, right? Like there were no expectations for the White Sacks. The Cubs had expectations, pretty high expectations, and then were made even higher by being arguably the best team in baseball through May eighth, and then since then have been arguably the worst team in baseball. So things are bleak for sure, and it's been almost a month now of being the worst team in baseball or close to it, which is depressing. Andy: I was gonna say I was having a conversation with Scott Merkin, ⁓ the White Sox Mmobby dot com beatwriter. ⁓ I was covering the Tigers this weekend, this past weekend from W dot com. And I was talking to him how fast things changed because I covered the race, Runmoby dot com in like early May, I think it was, or or maybe late April is kind of around then. And the White Sox I told him I was like, the White Sox at that time looked like the worst team I'd cover. They did not look good at all and I was like, It's gonna be another long season. Just looks so so horrible. ⁓ and then when they played the Cubs, I went in thinking like, ⁓ this is where the Cubs kinda cause they were it was the slump was just starting and I was like perfect time to play the White Sox 'cause I like again I had this preconceived notion that the White Sox were really, really struggling because of when I had last seen them. And when I saw them play the Cubs, I was like, Wow, this team is a lot better. Like so much better than what even what they were even that last time I saw ⁓ And then when I saw them play the Tigers, and granted the the I will go on record right now and say that the Tigers are the The worst team I've covered this year. The worst worst team I've seen there. They are really, really struggling. A lot of it is injuries. There's a lot of things that ⁓ going wrong with them. But they are they are really, really, really struggling right now. ⁓ but they they made the Tigers look even worse. The the White Sox just looked so much better. And that was without Murakami, who hurt his hamstring ⁓ in the first inning or second inning of that first game. ⁓ I'm curious what that injury is gonna do because I think that shortens the lineup. That that lineup was looking a little bit deeper. Tony Andracki: My card. Andy: ⁓ with with Murakami, but it's fascinating to see just again, like you're at the same point, but like it just looks so much more optimistic on one side and and so much more bleak on on the other side. And like this is this was our our first topic that we were going to get into on the pod. ⁓ you know we're getting it like six in six minutes into it, seven minutes into it. But ⁓ there's a lot of names on the White Sox where it's like interesting. It's like, ⁓ that guy might be an all-star. That guy's got an all-star shot. And then you look over at the Cub side and you're like Who is the Cubs All Star? We we had the conversation yesterday, like is who like everyone has won and the Cubs are thirty two and twenty-nine recording on Wednesday, three games above five hundred. And I don't know if I can definitively say who the Cubs All Star is this year. ⁓ I'll start with you, Tony. Like who who is it? Who am I who am I missing? Tony Andracki: Well, it has to be Ben Brown right now because I think he's the only guy on the team that has a decent case. And that seems ridiculous because he spent the first month of the season, which is half of the season to date, in the bullpen as a multi inning reliever who wasn't even racking up saves. So I mean, how often do one multi inning relievers make the all star team like almost never? And two, setup guys even make the all star team like very rarely too. So he's only made five starts in the rotation. He's having a great year. He looks good, but that's just more an indictment on the rest of the Cubs roster. There's not a single other player on this team that looks like an all-star. Now, two weeks ago, Shoda would have been the easiest easy choice because he had a 2 4 ERA or whatever it was and looked really good. But now he's got blown up in in ⁓ three straight starts, I think it is. ⁓ so he's out of the mix, I think, almost assuredly, because that's the other thing. Is you look around the NL, you got, and this is just off the top of my head, Ky: Mm-hmm. Tony Andracki: Christopher Sanchez, Jacob Mizarowski, Paul Skeens, ⁓ Kyle Harrison, all all four guys are clear cut all stars. Skeens, I know, has been a little bit hit a little bit of a rough patch. But like Harrison even has like a one seventy RA. Mizorowski and and Christopher Sanchez are incredible. That's not even including Shohei, who will make the team as either a hitter or a pitcher. ⁓ and then like Chris Sale and who I mean, who else am I missing? But like there's there's like seven or eight like legit dudes that are gonna be on this pitching staff well, well before we get into the Ben Brown. There's just nobody ⁓ like Ian Hap is the only other guy that I think has a decent case. And that's because he like far and away leads the Cubs in homers, ⁓ and his counting stats look pretty good. But like, can you imagine if Ian Hap is the Cubs all-star? Just b based off of like what the the public perception is right now, the fact that he's struggled over the last month and I mean, I imagine Andy, you said this and and it would actually be really funny. Like I'm rooting for it to be Hap in the sense of like I like Hap. I think he's he's a good dude, a stand up dude, but like the fan reaction to Hap being the Cubs lone All Star would be unlike anything we've ever seen. Just like they're vitriol directed at him. Andy: It would also be something because he's the guy who's gonna be a free agent. He's the guy that probably isn't coming back next year. ⁓ he's the guy that you decided we're not gonna pay this guy, we're we're we're not gonna go into the future with this guy, and he would be the lone all-star. ⁓ again, this is a whole h huge hypothetical because there's still a few weeks before the all-star cases really pan out and and a lot of things can change, obviously. But like it would be something if that's the guy that ends up being the all-star and Tony Andracki: Yeah. Andy: you look at the other guys that you had committed money to, Danzi Swanson, Bregman, even Nico Horner, PCA, and and they're not in the all-star conversation. ⁓ that's not to say that like they're they're not good players or anything, but like that would be there's there's quite a bit of irony in that, ⁓ i if that's how it kind of plays out. But Kyle, y hit me with some set like what what what's going like is it Ben Brown? Is it Ian Hap? Like who is the Cubs all star? Ky: has to be Ben Brown. Like just looking at his numbers and it's crazy to think like where Ben Brown was on the Cubs roster. I know we talked about it in the pods leading up to the season, how he was a fringe guy could start the season in Triple A potentially. ⁓ then yeah, in the first month he was in the bullpen and we were saying I think this was before maybe the Boyd injury that we should just he should just stay in the bullpen, right? He's pitching well, don't mess what he's got going on. Tony Andracki: Yeah. Ky: ⁓ but now looking at his numbers, obviously he's been in the rotation. What did he I didn't watch the game on Saturday, but I think that's he threw seven innings, three hits, one run, something like that against the Cardinals. I mean, from everything I mean, I I saw from that game, he looked it's not like he pitched well. But his number he's got a 14 1.4 F war or B war. Baseball reference B war, right? Stay Hockey. ⁓ 192 ERA. Yeah, he's only started five games, but still. Tony Andracki: Exactly, yeah. ⁓ huh. Ky: 51 innings, 53 strikeouts, a whip under one. Like it's it's not great. It gives me like ⁓ I'm trying to think like Travis Wood being the Cubs lone all star in twenty eleven or twenty thirteen, whenever that was. It's like it's like everybody, every team needs an all-star, which is kind of a crazy rule in itself. ⁓ but it's gotta be Br Ben Brown at this point, right? Like I don't know who else would be. Andy: Yes. Tony Andracki: Well yeah, and and Brown actually like did a whole scrum yesterday and all the T V cameras like surrounded him and he just ⁓ like Kyle, you said it his arc, which he even talked about, has been pretty nuts for the last two months. Like he was a guy who got option in June last year, had a five nine ERA all last year, got option in mid September, wasn't even a factor in this team down the stretch. Go ahead, Andy. Andy: Real quick, I I was gonna say he got optioned the day that the Cubs clinched their playoff spot in Pittsburgh. So he was not even in the playoff celebrations. I remember like I remember thinking when he got optioned, because I was in Pittsburgh that day. When he got optioned, I'm like, there's a very real chance that they clinch a playoff spot and there's a champagne celebration and he just got sent down to triple A, Iowa, and his season in the big leagues is effectively over. So sorry, I just wanted to add that 'cause that was crazy. Tony Andracki: ⁓ yeah. No, that's a super important point because like last year he was such a non factor. I forgot that he was in the rotation for the first like almost two months of the season or like month and a half. ⁓ because he earned that spot out of coming out of the opening day on an opening day roster. But yeah, he really struggled and so he got option twice. Remember he was actually on the NL ⁓ NL D S roster, not the wildcard roster. So against the Brewers. I think he only pitched once, right? But ⁓ Andy: DS, yep. Tony Andracki: But yeah, like it was just this weird up and down year and we we had no idea what to expect with him. We talked ⁓ on this podcast, like we're not even sure what role he's gonna be in. He's in a multi ending relief role, then he gets in a high leverage role, and now he's in the rotation. The fact that if he does ⁓ the fact that he's even in the all star conversation is crazy. And so he just talked about his arc and he's like a year ago at this time. I was just looking over my shoulder all the time and I was like, What do you think the biggest difference is? And he's like, Well, probably the ERA. Ky: Mm-hmm. Tony Andracki: And it was like a really funny moment 'cause like obvious y yes, he has an ERA literally four point exactly four points lower. He it's a one nine two ERA right now versus five nine two. But like he elaborated more and understood what I was asking of like the biggest difference in why he's not like looking over his shoulder this year compared to last year is he just has this unique perspective. He he one, he added a sinker, he had never had it, he throws it about twenty percent of the time. He's made the change up a lot better, throws that more often. So he just puts different things in opposing hitters' heads now. It's not just a one-two punch of here's my fastball, here's my breaking ball, pick one, flip a coin, and you know which one is gonna be thrown. And and even counsel said he kind of got boxed in with that. But it's also a mindset thing. And Brown admitted that he's like proven something to himself this year and that he he feels like he was he wish he could go back in time and tell himself a year ago, right before he got option, that like you're so close to to doing you know, to to putting it all together. But he also said, like, even right now, I understand that I'm so close to the other end of the spectrum, to like it all blowing up. And that's just I thought that was a really interesting and honest perspective that I don't hear often from guys that they don't when they're going well, they don't want to talk about, ⁓ well this could blow up quickly. ⁓ but I I just thought that was all really cool from Ben Brown. And I don't think he'll end up being the all star. I think one of the offensive players or somebody will like step up. But just the fact we're even talking about it is pretty crazy. Andy: Yeah, it really is. And it kind of speaks to the pitching staff's woes, really, where y you would think that, especially where they were a few weeks ago, that y there would be more conversation for like Shodemanaga. but it's shown how how much he's fallen off, like you mentioned. And I wanna wanna talk about Jamison Tylon and Shodemanaga's struggles, especially with the with the home run ball, because that's been I mean, that's just been killer to their outings and you know it's part of their game. You know their fly ball pitchers ⁓ that are are gonna induce pop ups or fly balls. ⁓ but it just seems like every time they go out there, it's like, Well, he's gonna give up two two home runs probably. Is it gonna be two solo shots or are they gonna be two big blasts that knock him out? What do you guys make, Tony, I'll start with you. What do you guys make of the what do you make of the home run issues that both of these guys are having? Tony Andracki: Well, they've gotta stop. I think that's the the flat out answer. And yeah, right. And I and I give council credit. That's one thing that I've always really admired and liked about council is he'll just flatly tell you what it is and what the situation is and not try to hide the ball. And I think Ross kind of hit the ball a lot and a lot of managers do and Joe Madden did a lot, right? They're they're not gonna just they would try to protect guys and stuff, but council's like Andy: Yeah. Big brain. Ky: Yeah. Tony Andracki: We gotta stop giving up so many home runs. Like Jameson Tyone needs to execute better. Shodem Minaga needs to execute better. Like he'll just flatly tell you what it is. And that is the case. ⁓ Tyone only gave up one homer last night, Tuesday night to the A's. It was a bad pitch. It was a hanging curveball, like middle middle to Nick Kurtz, the the one you know, there's probably two guys in that lineup that you don't want to do that to, but ⁓ but pitched really well apart from that. You know, the the only other run given up was like Andy: Yeah. Tony Andracki: couple seeing I singles led to a two out single and bam, you know, he he turns in a quality start, goes gets into the seventh inning, only gives up two runs. Big, big step in the right direction for J Mo. Shoda i we just know that this is who he is, right? When he's living at ninety one, ninety two and he also doesn't offer ⁓ much more than like two pitches. He's he's pretty much just that like fastball splitter guy, right? Like he he does throw other pitches just not as often. w it it's about execution for these guys because their stuff isn't elite and and they they have to get by because they execute because they're they're commanding the ball in the right spot and they're changing things up. And when J Mo yanks a fastball to you know low and in to a left handed power hitter like Brandon Lau as he did last Wednesday in Pittsburgh, it's gonna get hammered for a home run. And when Shodan Minaga leaves you know is trying to go above the zone or at the top of the zone and leaves one like sort of middle middle, it's gonna get hammered. 'Cause these are big league hitters. It there's a there's a little bit of a luck factor. Like both guys right now are are not their mistakes are not being missed. The opponents are hitting them. And I always think of the Dan Heron thing and ⁓ of like Dan Heron's like, I'm three ⁓ three one, I'm gonna throw a pitch in the strike zone because guys pop up in batting practice sometimes, right? And it's true, they they do. Right now they're just not missing them, but it it's absolutely a concern. And and I think without last night Curious you guys' thoughts over on the homer. But like one thing I was thinking going into last night was like if JMO struggles again, I he might be the guy that's bounced when Matthew Boyd comes back in a week and a half. Like I I'm I don't think it's a given. I think it's probably Colin Reid of the bullpen, but like I think there's at least a question whether Jamison Tyone can sit can stays in the spot. They're not gonna DFA him. I don't think they're gonna release him, anything like that. But like it could be like a hey, you know, whatever's ailing you go on the IL, figure it out type of thing. I just think last night changed that at least a little bit in my mind. Ky: I mean it's it's funny you ⁓ you obviously messaged us beforehand saying you you think J ⁓ L's gonna have a good start and and by all intents and purposes he did, right? Like Nick Kurtz is one of the best first hitting first baseman in the league, so he's gonna get he's gonna get ya every once in a while. By the way, great nickname, Big Amish. Did you know that was his nickname? Tony Andracki: Mm. Yeah. What is it? Ky: Nick Hurtz's nickname is Big Amish. Tony Andracki: ⁓ yeah, I did, yeah. He's not even Amish. Andy: I did I did not know that. That is a great nickname. Ky: I had no idea. Yeah, ⁓ probably not. But I feel like that was just like a tip. Tony Andracki: Speaking of which, ⁓ bet one of the best fantasy baseball names I've ever seen is Ow My Nick Hurts. Ky: Mm. Wow. Wow. Great nickname. Great name there. Tony Andracki: Yeah. Ky that's that's a very Kyle fantasy baseball team name. Andy: Yeah. Ky: Yeah, actually that right on. ⁓ I'm trying to think what was I to s who are we talking about? Tony Andracki: Nick Kurtz Jars and Ty. Andy: Jameson Tion. Ky: J-Mo. J-Mo. Jesus. I've honestly forgot what we were talking about there. I was just thinking about Nick Hurtz. ⁓ now I can't stop laughing when I say his name. The home run ball obviously has played JMO, but it's just crazy how he le like he's given up by far the most. I think it's he's given up 20 home runs this year. The next, I think, is 16. If I'm not mistaken, I don't have the numbers right in front of me. But Shoda has given up 13. I I I think I was looking at when I was looking up last night, it was tied for six, like. Tony Andracki: Yeah. Ky: The home run ball i it's I don't know how you stop it. I mean, hopefully they pitch at Wrigley a lot where the wind's blowing in and they they're a benefactor of that, but going off what you're saying, when Boyd comes back, I don't think you can move J Mo to the bullpen. I think he's the type of guy that he figures it out as the season goes on. I was looking at his numbers as the the season progresses and it there wasn't really a a strong correlation, like he has Like a I'll say a a four seven two ERA in June, then maybe a f something like a four something in July, and then maybe in August and September it lowers. But I mean we we remember what he did in the postseason, right? He had the game three start against the Padres, the game was it game three against the Brewers as well? So two elimination games and he dealt. ⁓ so I think this is a guy you really just have to hope he's a veteran guy that can figure it out. But Tony Andracki: Game three, yeah. Ky: on the flip side of the token. Flip side of the coin? Flip side of the token. Either way. ⁓ I know you guys are just making fun of me. ⁓ the home runs need to stop. It's Yeah, I know. The home runs need to stop. It is like getting insane. I mean, is it I don't know, I don't have his game logs in front of me. What has he made? Like ten starts, eleven starts this year. Has he given up a home run in every start? Has he given up a home run in every start so far? Tony Andracki: Op openly. Andy: twelve. Tony Andracki: No. He's giving up a home run like seven or eight straight. Ky: But it's it And it yeah, and I think the Cubs might be one and eight or two and six in his last eight starts, which I know he's on the last year of a deal, but a guy you're paying what is it, like close to fifteen million more. Or yeah, like you need you need better production out of that. And if the if the Cubs are gonna get to where they wanna go, you need better production. Andy: It's like eight yeah. Sixteen, yep. Tony Andracki: Sixteen. Andy: Yeah, and one thing with JMO too, where it's like I know Boyd and and Cabrera coming back, but like Boyd wasn't like his all star self when he went on the IL, and you don't know what he's gonna be like with the knee issues. Cabrera has I mean, we've talked about it. There's been so many question marks with what he's gonna be with, what what is what is he. ⁓ he's he's missed time in the past with elbow issues. So like I there's you kind of just need the innings out of James and Thailand because like Even I I think back to a few starts ago where he had given up w a ton of runs against the Reds and he still gutted out six innings. Like that's huge, especially given where they're at in their pitching situation. Y you almost just need the innings more than anything. And and I think that's valuable. And to your point, Kyle, like he kind of always does seem to figure it out. Like if you think about it, his first year, remember that first half, he was statistically one of the worst pitchers in in baseball. And then he had a really good start in New York. And then after that, he literally went on a ⁓ like a a really, really good heater that he became one of the best pitchers in baseball over that span. So like I think there is some truth to like, hey, maybe he'll figure it out. ⁓ at the end of the day, like, this is a team that's trying to win the playoffs though. So like or get in the playoffs and and win and go deep. If that's not happening come July, come August, then you start having serious conversations about like well, w what do you do with that? But I don't I don't think just where they're at out of necessity. I don't think they're at that point where they can afford to to just do that. ⁓ Ky: Mm-hmm. Andy: But I'm curious, Tony, and and you kinda touched on it, like what what the rich Yeah, go ahead, go ahead. Tony Andracki: Well we'll real quick on the J Mo point. So I I said it ⁓ it was on CSGO last Wednesday after J Mo's last start, and I was saying that I feel like I have more confidence in J Mo turning it around than Colin Ray and being better the rest of the year than Colin Ray. And a lot of people like in the comment section on the show were like couldn't believe it. Which ⁓ I there's a little recency bias, but Colin Ray hasn't been that great either. He's pitching today, so we'll see how his outing is, you know, today Wednesday. Ky: Mm-hmm. Andy: Yeah. Tony Andracki: But like he since the start of May, he has like a five plus ERA. J Mo is like a six, even with last night's good start. So it hasn't been great, but like it hasn't been great for any starting pitcher, any Cubs pitcher basically, not named Ben Brown and who you have in the rotation. And I just I feel like to the point that you guys have both made is I feel like J Mo is a guy that will figure it out. And he just he has like A plus intangibles, right? Like like maybe even A plus plus, like everything he's been through, like beating cancer. you know, like he's a huge, huge clubhouse guy. He's one of those guys who's like not just friends with the pitcher, makes an impact on the pitching staff. Like he's really ⁓ respected, well respected and highly regarded by the the position player group too. And like he's this guy that like I just feel like he's so mentally tough that he will figure it out. Colin Ray, I think, you know, deserves a lot of credit and is a good swing man and has, you know, filled admirably a lot of roles for the Cubs for two years. But if you give me one of those guys the rest of the way, I'm putting J Mo in my rotation like ten times out of ten then over Colin Ray. Andy: And I I think I think who's more likely to start a playoff game, even where they're at right now. I think it's always going to be Jamison Tion. And I think you would always rather have Jamison Tion than Colin Ray in that situation. but yeah, I'm I'm curious like what the return of Cabrera and Matthew Boyd mean for the rotation, what it means for for their like what happens to Jamison Tion Colin Ray and all these guys, like I think that is very interesting. But Ky: Yeah, I agree. Tony Andracki: Yes. Andy: I'm curious to see like what they are when they come back because like I mentioned, I don't think you're automatically penciling an all star and a guy that you paid a pretty high price ⁓ in a trade in the off season to just come in and just perform at that level right away. But they really just need these pitching this pitching to come back and get healthy. Tony Andracki: They do, yeah. And and they need like you mentioned Andy, Matthew Boyd wasn't himself. He wasn't like the ace before he got hurt. ⁓ but Edward Cabrera has been a a disappointment, like flat out. He I think it's eight straight starts or seven straight starts before going on the IL, giving up at least three runs. And ⁓ and his last start before he went on the IL, he gave up like I think three unearned. So technically he only gave up one earned, but still he he has not pitched well for a month and a half before going on the IL. And I think it's I it's it's huge getting them back. But like I just I have questions about how effective they're gonna be. Like them coming back is not enough. They have to come back and be pitch really well. And Cabrera has to pitch up to his elite level stuff. And Matthew Boyd doesn't have to necessarily be the guy that he was for the whole first half of last year, but he needs to be at least the guy he was in the second half of last year and and just pitch better than he has so far that we've seen him from this season. So them coming back is great. But they like how effective will they be? Because the Cubs need starting pitching the worst way. You you can't start another even if it's not a ten game winning streak, you can't go on a good stretch where you win ten of twelve or ten of thirteen without good starting pitching. Be and they just they don't have that right. Andy: And guide go. Ky: Quick before to cut to cut you off. So on the the Edward Cabrera ⁓ front, you're right, Tony. He's it was what one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, seven straight starts before his last one where ⁓ he gave up at least three earned runs. His last one was four runs, but only one was earned. in his ten starts, he's had multiple walks in one, two, three, four, five, six of ⁓ And three of those have been three plus walks, which has been a killer for him. ⁓ so that's my Edward Cabrera stat. JMO has given up at least one home run in 11 or 10 of his last 11 starts. ⁓ he's actually four the Cubs are four and four in his last eight starts, not two and six like I said, moron. ⁓ I know who who let this guy talk. ⁓ but still giving up that many home runs very detrimental. Great word. ⁓ and then lastly on the Cowan Ray front Tony Andracki: What an idiot. Mm. Ky: Did you know that he's led all Cubs pitchers in innings pitch since the start of 2025? His two hundred and eighteen and his two hundred and eighteen and two thirds is first. Shoda is second with two fourteen and two thirds, and then Matthew Boyd is two ⁓ three and two thirds. But ⁓ there there's nothing to say that that's more just like a wow, yeah, a wow stat that Callin Ray's leading ⁓ the Cubs in innings pitch over the last two years. I don't know if that's a good or bad thing. Tony Andracki: Whoa. Andy: You did not, but I'm not surprised. Yeah. Ky: or just a credit to him for being available, which is probably the biggest thing, but that was my third set, and I'll throw it back to you in. Tony Andracki: Go back go back to March twenty twenty five and tell yourselves that over the next year and two months, Colin Ray would have more innings pitched, would lead the Cubs in innings pitched over Justin Steele, who was healthy at the time, over Matthew Boyd. ⁓ even tell yourself this in like August or whatever of last year when Cade Horton was still was around and you know pitching well. Like over Shota, that's that is actually like a mind blowing stat. If it doesn't Andy: That's an insane set. Tony Andracki: It feels like other guys have pitched more too, but I mean I know Showda missed six weeks and Voids now missed time, so I I get it. Ky: Mm-hmm. Andy: Yeah, that's crazy. But one thing about the pitching, like y we're we're talking about Jamison Tyron's struggles and and what he's gone through and and then there's definitely merit to it, right? Because he has struggled, as we pointed out. But when you have a good outing from him, like you did on Tuesday night, you have to, have to, have to win those games. You have to have the offensive performance that gets you the win on those days. And that hasn't been happening. Like they they it feels like when they get a good pitching performance. They're not getting the offense. And when they do somehow get the offense, they're not getting a good pitching performance. ⁓ or i it it's it's just mind-b boggling. And as we mentioned with the All Star conversation, there's a lot of these guys that you paid a lot of money. And I'll start with Dansby, ⁓ that are struggling offensively because Dansby at the beginning of the season, what I thought was gonna, what I thought was a key point in his development or in his his season this year was he was walking a lot in April. His walk rate had gone up. And I thought, okay, if he's struggling at the plate, that's fine because he's still gonna walk, right? Like i when he starts struggling because it happens, the walk rate is up. So it that will that will help mitigate some of the the woes. But the walk rate has cratered too. And now now you couple that with with the slump and it's just it's just magnifying some of the offensive woes that the Cubs have. Tony Andracki: Yeah, I think the Tuesday night's game was enlightening on where the Cubs viewed Danzby Swanson. When he was up in the second inning with two outs, they had first and third, Hap was on third, Alcantra was on first. They had Alcantra steal and stop, trying to do one of those high school first and thirds, because as counsel said after the game, they knew that the a that the A's would throw down and that Langliers is slightly wild, so they thought maybe they could steal a run. But Dansby was up. And so that tells you that they don't feel like Dansby Swanson could get a hit with two outs. Now it's difficult for anybody, fine. In today's g day and age, you know, with two outs, you you want to steal a run if you can. But they they felt so there's such a lack of confidence for Danzy against the lefty, too. It's not a a tough righty who throws a bunch of sliders low in a way that it's really difficult for Dansby to pick up. This was against the lefty. So that tells you one thing. Later in the game, two outs, nobody on, cubs down one in the eighth inning. Dansby Swanson pinch hit four by Moises Ballesteros. And Council said after the game, Dansby was healthy. They were just trying to get a ball who a guy who could put a ball in the seats. The wind was blowing in. They feel like Moises Ballesteros, even with wind blowing in, has a better chance of putting the ball in the seats than Dansby Swanson, who Dansby hits twenty plus homers a year, and Ballesteros has never obviously done that. in the big leagues, but like I don't think he even hit twenty homers in the minors last year. Maybe he hit just over, right? So like I I think Da I feel like Dan's be has more power than Bias Terris. I Bias Terris is a better hitter. ⁓ but that tells you all you need to know. Like when you're at the point where you're pinch hitting for your hundred and seventy five million dollar man or whatever it is, hundred and seventy million dollar guy who's making twenty five million okay. You know, he's making twenty five plus million this year, like sorry. You come to my house you get my wife's name right. Ky: One seventy seven. Andy: Seven Yeah. Ky: Come on, get it right. Yeah. Tony Andracki: ⁓ Like w whatever. Dude's making a lot of money, not hitting. They're pinch hitting for him and they're they're trying to do high school first and third type plays to steal runs when he's up. Like this shit is really, really bad with him right now. Ky: His last 20 games, so this is dating back to the end of the Cubs second 10 game winning streak. ⁓ no! It just went away. He was hit, I think he was hitting 138. He has no home runs, or maybe one home run, but it's just on the year, he's hitting 181. His OPS plus is 80. Like you can go down the list. Hit his numbers are atrocious. And like he's I don't know what his like actual strikeout rate is. Tony Andracki: Yeah. Andy: That's not good. Ky: He's at fifty three strikeouts right now. I don't know if you could find that quickly, Andy, but he is just not Andy: Paught up, yeah. Tony Andracki: I think it's only like a tick above where it normally is. Ky: It just God, it just seems like he's striking out so much. Tony Andracki: He's I if I remember correctly, I think I was looking yesterday. ⁓ Andy, are you looking up? I think the big thing was hard hit and line drive rate are both down for him. Andy: I'm bound up, yeah. Ky: ⁓ Actually his strikeout rate is the lowest it's been with the Cubs and the lowest it's been maybe since twenty twenty, ironically. Tony Andracki: Yeah. That's what I'm saying. Like so it's it's not the strikeouts, it's the quality of contact has not been very good for her. Andy: Yeah, twenty three point two percent strikeout rate, thirteen point two percent walk rate. ⁓ Ky: Yeah, I mean And going and real quick, going back to like you bringing up Biasterles pinch hitting for him, this is something when you're watching, it's you know, late in the games and the cubs have been trailing a lot lately. I've been keeping an eye on like, hey, will will Craig pinch hit for Dansby? Like he's obviously struggling. ⁓ you want him in there for his glove, but at the end of the game, like you need offense. ⁓ and I I can't recall a time where Craig or I guess in his first year with Rossi, ⁓ where Dansby's been pinch hit for because of his lack of offense. But this so him being pinch hit for for bias Darylson. Yeah, great point where Craig was saying he want they were looking for someone to put the ball in the seats and the wind was blowing in. It's like, ⁓ man. I don't know. Maybe just maybe somebody who could get on and can run a little bit. Like that's that's how bad or down bad Dansby is right Tony Andracki: Yeah. Andy: He his line drive rate is down from twenty two point four percent in twenty twenty five to fifteen point four percent in twenty twenty six. His ground ball rate is slightly up. It was forty one point two percent last year and it is forty two percent this year, and his fly ball rate is up from thirty-six and a half percent to forty two point seven percent. ⁓ Tony Andracki: He's also popping up more than he ever has in his career. Or like more s since twenty eighteen. But yeah. Andy: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, that's right. Ky: Do you think there's a bit of a bit of bad luck in yeah, like he obviously the the exivy low and everything you guys just mentioned is valid, but his batting average on balls in play the last with the Cup, so twenty twenty three was two ninety seven, twenty twenty four three hundred, last year two ninety eight, this year only two ⁓ six. Do you think there's a little bit of bad luck involved in that, or is it just this is kind of who Dansby is? Tony Andracki: There there is so no, I I agree. I think there is bad luck because anecdotally I feel like I've I've seen a bunch of times where he's hit the ball hard online drives that have been caught, but particularly up the middle and like other teams are just shifting him really well because he he doesn't go to the opposite field a ton and when he does it's kind of just to the right of second base. So they always have a guy there and I feel like he's hit some balls right on the screws that go right to the second baseman on the other team for a line out or ⁓ ground you know, ground up whatever. So I do think there's an element of bad luck, but like his expected batting average is still only two hundred. Like he's his just overall profile is one of the worst hitters in baseball, which matches up with his stats as one of the worst hitters in baseball. Andy: Yeah. Yeah, I was gonna say his hard hit hard hit rate is down five percent, but it's kind of in line where it was in twenty twenty four. His barrel rate is down four percent. It would be the lowest of his career. and yeah, you mentioned the expect batting average. The expected slug is three fifty nine, which would be the lowest since his second year in the majors, ⁓ when he had a three twenty four slug. So i it's the the quality of the contact isn't isn't necessarily good either. Ky: For us. And he and I and I don't know if we're gonna I don't know if we're gonna get into this more, but like hit him hitting with runners in scoring position, and this is not specifically a Dansby only issue, but him hitting with r runners and scim hitting with runners in scoring position, he's hitting one forty-five. And it's seemingly there's been numerous times with there's a a guy on second and or guys on second and third, a guy on second with two outs, and it's just ⁓ Dansby's coming up. It's like it's almost like the pitcher's coming up again. Andy: Which kinda sums up Go ahead. No, dive right in. Dive right in. G hit me. Ky: You know? Like him him in that nine hole, there's just no threat there. And yeah, we could go into it if you want to go into it more, but the Cubs as a whole, I don't I mean the Cubs as a whole, I don't have their ⁓ their team numbers as an aggregate with runners in scoring position. Maybe and you could pull that up. I have it on an individual basis, but I'll go down the their real quick, the the core players who are playing every day and their their batting average with runners in scoring position. PCA three sixteen. Tony Andracki: Yeah. Andy: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, go for it. Go Kimmy, what do you got? Ky: Michael Bush, 300. Carson Kelly, 289. Those three, I mean, good. Obviously. I I think probably over 260, you would say, is pretty good. That's where the the drop-off happens. Nico, who's been historically one of the best hitters with runners in scoring position in Cubs franchise history, 242. Bayesteros is hitting 200. Happen Bregman, your, you know, really your two, three, four hitters this whole season, or three, four, five hitters this whole season, both hitting 194. Dansby, yeah, at the bottom of the order, one forty five. But the one that's really killing you is Seya. Sayya who's he's been hitting fourth or fifth this whole year. He's hitting one twenty three with runners in scoring position. One twenty three. And yeah, like I it's Tony Andracki: Say yeah. What was John Lester's career average? One fifteen, I think, one ten. Ky: ⁓ God, what was it? It was like w yeah, it was something like that. Like it's literally like John Lester hitting fourth. It's insane. I have to put up what John Lester's average with runners in scoring position was. And if it's higher, I'm gonna lose my mind. But I don't know what you do different. Like I d I know Craig has said like you can't teach it, but it's crazy. Tony Andracki: Dude, right? You're talking about with Biasteros who's hit in his head in the two hole a bunch too. So Biasteros, Nico, Hap, Bregman, and Saya, who have filled up, you know, the two through five spot on largely on a daily basis, are all hitting Nico's above two two hundred, right? But the other guys are like basically John Lester when you come to play, when you put ⁓ like all together, ⁓ like a touch better than that. That's crazy. You're right. Kyle like it is like the pitcher is coming up again. This is Ky: Mm-hmm. Tony Andracki: It's nuts. I I can't I cannot believe this. And there's the whole regression of the mean. They should get better, positive regression, whatever you want to say. It it should be better. But like even in April when they were doing well, they were only fourteenth in batting average runners to scoring position, two fifty one. It was just they had the most opportunities in baseball. In May, they hit only one eighty eight as a team, second worst average with runners to scoring position. ⁓ in in all of baseball. I think the Tigers maybe were the only team that was below them. But like one eighty eight with runners in scoring position, I I just I can't I cannot believe it. I really can't. I would rather have Jake Ariadda, prime Jake Arietta up at the plate than four of at least of the guys in the roster. Andy: So I have the the full season stats. The Cubs have the second most played appearances with runners in scoring position at six ninety five, trailing the Pirates. They have the ninth most runs scored with runners in scoring position with two tie. That's the good. The really bad and the really ugly is the OPS for the whole year is six sixty six, twenty seventh in baseball. And the batting average, ⁓ which I think batting average is is a I think OBP is better than than batting average, but in runners and scoring position, you want hits because that's gonna drive lead to runs, ⁓ more so than walks necessarily. ⁓ see ya, Kyle. ⁓ and ⁓ yeah, go ahead, go ahead, go. Ky: No, real quick, I have I've I've one quick one quick fact before I jump off. ⁓ you said you rather have prime or Jake Arietta prime Jake Arrietta. ⁓ you rather have Jake Arrietta up with runners in scoring position than Seya. Well, contraire. ⁓ Jake Arrietta's batting average with runners in scoring position in his career was one twenty six, where Seya this year is one twenty three. So you technically are not wrong. And with that, I leave you guys. Genius. Tony Andracki: I'm a genius. Sika. Andy: Sick Kyle. ⁓ 222 batting average for the Cubs, 29th in baseball with runners in scoring position. So that's just to say, it is not it's just not good with runners in scoring position, which yes, you can be I think both things can be true. You can be ecstatic and be glad and believe that you're getting so many opportunities that it's gonna lead to runs and it should lead to regret positive regression, as you said. That is very, very true. But I think it's also very, very true. that this is not good enough and that this is a worrying trend that you are in June on June third, you know, two months into the season and you are just not generating really consistent offense with runners in scoring position, which is what you should be doing as a as a baseball team. Tony Andracki: Yeah, and and to me I think I I know we'll get into this a bit too, so maybe this'll kinda like kick it off a bit, but I think Alex Bregman is the guy that I'm turning to to get them out of this. Like Seya, of course, needs to be better and Hap, we ⁓ we know the strikeouts and fans are losing their mind watching so many of these guys, particularly Hap and Sea, come up throwing into scoring position. But it's Bregman for me. I feel like every game I'm watching, Bregman comes up with a guy in scoring position and doesn't come through and The fact that he he drove in a run last night Tuesday night with a ground out, that was his nineteenth RBI of the year. Two months into the season. I mean he's literally on pace for sixty RBIs, or less than that, I think actually. ⁓ with a guy who a highest paid player hitting two three. I think I think those are the only two spots he's hit in. Maybe he's hit fourth once or twice here. So he's hitting two or three in the order. He is your leader, he's the guy you signed to be a leader. Andy: For your highest paid player. Tony Andracki: He is supposed to be one of your best players, if not potentially your best. ⁓ one of your best hitters, if not potentially your best, like all around hitter and and offensive player. But he's supposed to be like your run producer and and you need a guy to come through. And he just ha he has not been coming through. And he didn't come through first and second last night. You know, Nico and and PCA have been doing well hitting one, two, whichever one has been hitting in either spot, right? It's Nico against lefties, PCA against right he's leading off. But like both those guys get on in the bottom of the ninth, you're down one, you have your two fastest and best base runners on ⁓ on the bases, and then you have Bregman, what what was it? Bregman, Seiya, and Hap coming up. You're like I think traditionally you'd be like, ⁓ this is at least one run, but is there a possibility of them walking off? But lately you're just like they're not gonna get out of this, or they're not gonna get a run, the game's gonna be over. And and that was true. They didn't even move Nico to third. Like Bregman's at bat. I heard so many people want like calling for a bunt and and crucifying counsel for not calling for a bunt. It's Alex Bregman. It's a dude who's making thirty million dollars, whatever he's making this year. He again, your highest paid player hitting three with a long track record. You're not freaking bunting with Alex Bregman. You should not bunt. You shouldn't have to. But I will say the fans are valid because I actually had that same thought watching the game from the press box. Should the cups bunt here? Because I have no confidence in Alex Bregman. To get the job done. Yeah. But but also I wouldn't have had any confidence in say ⁓ delivering. Now he if things played out, he flew out to deep right. It would have been a game tying run if Bregman got the bunt down. But like I I just it's crazy to me that you got first and second, you're heart of the order, you're three best hitters coming up, and you don't get a run when you absolutely needed it against a guy who's like far he he's not Mason Miller, right? You know, it's ⁓ Andy: That's where he's at. Tony Andracki: I'm drawing a blank on what that that guy's name was. He was closing. Scott Barlow and then somebody else. It's it's crazy. It's it's the state of the offense right now is bad. Andy: Yeah. It really is and it's just like and I kinda wanna I I know we had the conversation about the Tucker versus Bregman thing and I kinda wanna save it with Kyle because I think Kyle for for next week's by Cause McKyle will have some some awesome stats. But it's it's f I kept thinking like he the I I brought up the splits on an earlier podcast where in in April he struggles and then in May he heats up and then June, July is really when he like kinda takes off and it's kind of been like that. But I look at May and I there's no there's Tony Andracki: Yeah. Andy: You see it and there's there's not a real pathway to believing that that's what's gonna happen. ⁓ now maybe you could say Wrigley Field and the wind starts blowing out and things like that. And sure, like maybe that is a case. And and of course he's got the track record that I will b like it it it is possible, but like he's the one guy that you need to turn around and there just haven't been signs of it yet. And until there's the you start seeing the signs. I thought the signs happened. I thought the signs were coming the White Sox series. ⁓ at at Soxbar because he hit some balls that were I mean he roped them and kind of bad bad ⁓ bad to ball luck, right? They got caught, there were deep fly balls. But I was like, okay, now he's turning the corner and it it just hasn't happened. And you're right, this is the guy that they need to turn around. And let me tell you, if you're if yesterday would have been a great time to turn it around, you're not turning it around with the bunt. So you want him swinging away. You want him swinging away. ⁓ and I know you want this situation where you wanna be winning ballgames and you and you're trying to do all you can to win ballgames. Well two run homer wins you that ballgame. And and and and you're not gonna get that by laying down the butt. And and again, I'm also a believer that like it it's not ri like it's not to say if he he if he went down to bunt that he would lay it down and and then if he if he misses the bunt everyone's talking about like, Well, why did you bunt? So like there there's no perfect way, but like I I think the best way to do it is to just keep letting him swing. Tony Andracki: Yeah. Andy: as ugly as it is and and you just hope that it turns around, but to this point it just hasn't happened yet. Tony Andracki: Yeah, it's I I thought I agree with though that White Sox series looked like that first game, you know, that we were both at. Like he had two balls in the warning track, ⁓ got two hits, looked good overall. And then the Pirates series, I think he had like six or seven hits in the Pirates series, he had a couple, if not three, multi hit games. Looked good. and it just hasn't happened. Then, you know, he hits a home run in Saint Louis. Like there are these kind of like tea leaves that he's like Andy: Yeah. Tony Andracki: you know, little this little trail where like you squint hard enough, you're like, okay, Bregman might be figuring this out a bit. But like, yeah, when the slugging percentage is still in the three fifties in June, and like I said, you're not even at twenty RBI without being hurt, hitting in the middle of the order with guys in front of you all the time. You know, RBIs aren't everything that they say they're a team stat. But I'll tell you what, that's a Bregman stat right now because the team has been performing for him. He has come up well more than enough times Andy: Here's the path, right. Tony Andracki: to have way more than twenty RBI. He should be at least at the thirty, thirty-five you know, point ⁓ of this season right now because we're in June and because he's had so many opportunities. So yeah, I we can harp on it and you know and go on and on and and we are every week right now, about the runners and score and position thing. It will change, it will get better. I don't know when and I I do think with runners and score in position, and I've heard Ryan Flaherty, the coach bench coach, talk about this on the radio too, but like there's a mental component to that situation that there's not in other situations hitting because you squeeze the bat a little bit tighter, you are aware of not coming through with runners to scoring position as a team. And you always want to be the dude that gets the hit and that ends it and ends the losing streak and gets the big hit for the team and so on. ⁓ but Ian Hap did that in Pittsburgh and wasn't able to carry that forward. Because it's a it's a tough thing to like forget that feeling. They'll figure it out. I but in the meantime it's just it's tough to watch. Andy: Yeah, I think the more concerning thing is what's happening around them, right? Where they're now six and a half games back out of the the the division with ⁓ behind the Milwaukee Brewers where you know, I that that that whole six and a half in June is is not insurmountable by any means, but it is concerning given how the Brewers have performed and it feels like every year they they have a a long winning streak that kind of propels them and they haven't had it yet. So ⁓ I'm not saying that they're they're gonna go off on a tear, but I'm Tony Andracki: Cheese, yeah. Andy: I'm also not saying that it isn't impossible. So I'm curious to to see what kind of pans out and we'll see what we're talking about next week, right? Maybe we're talking about how they figured it out and went on this this hot streak and we're crushing the ball with Rennies and scoring position. Yeah. I mentioned Yep. I mentioned that ⁓ you know on the last podboard that this is the spot on the schedule where they they kind of need to turn around and I'm curious to see if they do. But Tony, it's it's been a blast chatting with you and with Kai who had to jump off early. Tony Andracki: This is this is the stretch of the schedule where they have to. They're about to play the two worst teams in the N L. Andy: Thanks as always to everyone who tunes in and subscribes and listens to the podcast. Make sure to rate and subscribe. ⁓ give us a follow button on social media. It's been a blast. And and keep hitting us with suggestions and anything else. For Tony, for Kyle, I'm Andy. Thanks for listening as always.