Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Meet and Confer: Making It Meaningful and CCP Compliant
Transcript
- 0:03All right. Good afternoon, everybody. Welcome
- 0:06to Meet and Confer, Making it Meaningful and
- 0:10Code of Civil Procedure Compliant. I am Ryan
- 0:15Wetteking, co -chair of Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:19Family Law section. Family Law section is sponsored
- 0:23by White Zuckerman, Lawyers Mutual, Sober Link,
- 0:27and Our Family Wizard. White Zuckerman provides
- 0:30a wide variety of resources to complete almost
- 0:33any project large or small. They also provide
- 0:36traditional accounting and tax practice services.
- 0:39We invite you to contact them to discuss your
- 0:41specific accounting needs and learn how they
- 0:43can be of service to you. Learn more at WZWLH
- 0:49.com. SoberLink provides objective real -time
- 0:53data that can be used to reduce disputes over
- 0:55alcohol consumption, leading to less conflict
- 0:58in custody cases. To help ensure smooth negotiations
- 1:01for a more efficient legal process, consider
- 1:04using SoberLink's trusted alcohol monitoring
- 1:06system to eliminate hearsay and protect your
- 1:09client's best interest. With an unprecedented
- 1:12combination of features, including advanced reporting,
- 1:14facial recognition, tamper resistance, Real -time
- 1:18results in customized testing, the discrete system
- 1:21has been the leader in remote alcohol monitoring
- 1:24since 2011. Learn more at soberlink .com. For
- 1:29five decades, Lawyers Mutual has been the only
- 1:32California -based company to continuously provide
- 1:34lawyers throughout the state with professional
- 1:37liability insurance coverage. Their experience
- 1:39and expertise are complemented by the fact that
- 1:42Lawyers Mutual is directed by a group of dedicated
- 1:44lawyers. They offer special rates with competitive
- 1:48premiums for a wide range of areas of practice,
- 1:51including family law. Learn more at lawyersmutual
- 1:54.com. Last but not least, our Family Wizard is
- 1:57a co -parenting platform designed to help families
- 2:00communicate more effectively, reduce conflict,
- 2:02and create reliable court admissible records.
- 2:04Features like tone meter, AI, shared calendars,
- 2:09expense tracking, and in -app audio and video,
- 2:12calling help, support, compliance, and video
- 2:15calling help support compliance and better outcomes
- 2:18for families navigating custody matters. Now,
- 2:22before we begin today, I would be remiss if I
- 2:26did not do a plug for our family law section
- 2:28meeting, which is this afternoon at 4 .30 p .m.
- 2:32Please feel free to join. If you haven't joined
- 2:36a family law, VHBA family law section meeting
- 2:38yet, I think that they are an invaluable way,
- 2:44it's an invaluable way to network with colleagues
- 2:47from across the county, as well as kind of get
- 2:52a State of Department II update from Judge Kaufman,
- 2:55who appears at all of our meetings, and also
- 2:58to get a little bit of CLE. We've been doing
- 3:02a little modular CLEs, five to 10 minutes. to
- 3:06kind of keep everybody sharp and improving on
- 3:12all fronts. So if you can't make it, send an
- 3:14associate. The family law section meetings are
- 3:18efficient. We try to get you out within 30 to
- 3:2245 minutes. So join us this afternoon. Now, I
- 3:26am delighted to introduce our speakers, Anthony.
- 3:30Storm, Tony Storm, as many of you might know
- 3:33him by, and the honorable Mark Yuhas. Tony Storm
- 3:37is a mediator with Signature Resolution. He spent
- 3:40his early career litigating criminal matters
- 3:42at the United States Attorney's Office before
- 3:45moving into family law. Tony and I, by the way,
- 3:48are both alumni of Walser Melcher Yoda. So how
- 3:51about that? Yeah, developing his practice at
- 3:54Harris Ginsburg and Walser Melcher, later co
- 3:56-founding Storm Paley and LLP, where he focused
- 3:59on high asset dissolution, spousal and child
- 4:02support, and property division. He currently
- 4:04serves as president of the Beverly Hills Bar
- 4:06Association, previously chaired its family law
- 4:09section, and was appointed to the State Bar of
- 4:12California's Family Law Executive Committee.
- 4:14And he has lectured for bar associations throughout
- 4:16California on topics including complex property
- 4:19division, hidden assets, and privacy during divorce.
- 4:23The Honorable Mark A. Yuhas has served as a judge
- 4:26of the Los Angeles Superior Court in a general
- 4:28family law assignment since his appointment by
- 4:30Governor Gray Davis in August 2002, and is actively
- 4:35involved in judicial education as an adjunct
- 4:37professor of law at Southwestern Law School.
- 4:40as well as a regular instructor for the Center
- 4:44for Judicial Education and Research in the Los
- 4:47Angeles County Bar Association. He serves on
- 4:50numerous committees dedicated to improving the
- 4:52justice system, including the Judicial Council's
- 4:54Family Law and Judicial Advisory Committee, the
- 4:57CJER Governing Committee, and is a chair of the
- 5:01Access and Fairness Committee for the Los Angeles
- 5:03Superior Court. Judge Yuhas earned his undergraduate
- 5:06degree from Colorado College and his JD from
- 5:09the University of Puget Sound. School of Law,
- 5:12now known as the Seattle University School of
- 5:15Law. Is that right? That is, yes. I have two.
- 5:18UPS is now known as, but Seattle U has its own
- 5:22law school. So yes, we can get, we can go down
- 5:26this trail, but yes. Anyway, with that, I will
- 5:31let you both take it away. Great. And I am not
- 5:35an alumni of Walter Melcher, so I'm the odd man
- 5:39out. At Judge's night, we laugh together about
- 5:44meeting and conferring, and Judge's continual
- 5:47repetition of this request. The truth is, while
- 5:51laughing is nice, we are serious. Why? It helps
- 5:56your clients. It helps you. It helps the court.
- 6:01Meeting and conferring facilitates the effective
- 6:04presentation of evidence and efficient use of
- 6:07court hours. So while you may smile when you
- 6:11say meet and confer, please keep smiling and
- 6:14do it. Thank you. Well, we had a lovely introduction
- 6:19from Judge Kaufman. I think we have 30 minutes
- 6:21here, so we should get the ball rolling. We all
- 6:25know we have to meet and confer. We all know
- 6:26we have that very substantive obligation that
- 6:30we need to take seriously. It is not a formality.
- 6:33It is not something that, hey, I sent an email
- 6:36two days before the discovery deadline and told
- 6:39them they have to produce a refiling emotion.
- 6:41The courts can really tell the difference, and
- 6:44it shows you're credible. Frankly, we were talking
- 6:47about this program earlier, and a good meet and
- 6:49confer oftentimes avoids the motions that you
- 6:53might need entirely. So as you can see, up we
- 6:57have three pillars we're going to discuss. That's
- 7:00the 2016 .040 Good Faith standard, the new AB
- 7:05711 declaration requirement that came into effect
- 7:10this past January, and the informal discovery
- 7:14conference. Meet and confer really helps avoid
- 7:19unnecessary motions. But when a motion becomes
- 7:23necessary, well -documented efforts help you
- 7:28win the motion build credibility, not doing it
- 7:33destroys both. We had some introductions from
- 7:38Judge Yuhas. I don't know. I mean, from Ryan
- 7:41Wedeking. We have limited time, Judge Yuhas.
- 7:43Do you want to talk a little bit about your background?
- 7:46Not really. I can't, but we should probably talk
- 7:49about the merits. Right. So let's skip our bios.
- 7:53I'm good with that. And move straight to the
- 7:56program overview. We've got five modules here
- 8:00that we're going to talk about. The statutory
- 8:02framework, what good faith actually means, what
- 8:07AB 711 now requires, which essentially adds meeting
- 8:11and conferring about a reporter in the courtroom,
- 8:17a certified reporter, and best practices. We'll
- 8:21start with the statute. We'll end with our...
- 8:25proposals or suggestions that you could use in
- 8:27your practice right away. So let's move on to
- 8:33slide five. Thank you. We did it already. The
- 8:37statute's pretty short. A meet and confer declaration
- 8:40in support of a motion shall state facts showing
- 8:44a reasonable good faith attempt either in person,
- 8:48by telephone, or by video conference to informally
- 8:52resolve each issue presented by the motion. Each
- 8:56issue is very specific. It's not just, hey, your
- 9:00responses weren't adequate, so provide a new
- 9:03one. It doesn't just say, hey, list the top couple
- 9:07issues and we'll say we got it from there. Each
- 9:11issue means every issue. It's the same threshold
- 9:15we need across all discovery issues, whether
- 9:18they're interrogatories, RFPs, RFAs, or depositions.
- 9:24Let's talk about what good faith actually means
- 9:28in practice. Judge Yuhas. Go ahead. I apologize,
- 9:33but before we get sort of going here, I think
- 9:35it's really important to keep in mind a couple
- 9:37of things. Judges, I will speak for myself, but
- 9:41I think I can speak for most of the family law
- 9:43bench. Discovery disputes. are not a pleasant
- 9:48way to spend your day. It's not a pleasant way
- 9:51for you as an attorney to spend your time, your
- 9:54client's money, your efforts and energy. It's
- 9:56not a pleasant way for judges to have to wade
- 9:59through a bunch of stuff and figure out what
- 10:00should this be, should you, you know, this be
- 10:03compelled, this not be compelled? Can I narrow
- 10:05this? Can I do that? So, I think that a good
- 10:09solid effort at meeting and conferring to show
- 10:14the judge that you've actually worked hard on
- 10:16figuring out, do you really need this information?
- 10:20Is the other side willing to give you something
- 10:23as part of what you're asking for? And when you
- 10:26think about it, yeah, I really don't need or
- 10:28want this, but I really need or I really want
- 10:30that. And so if you sit down and work together,
- 10:34you can jettison the part you don't need and
- 10:36focus on what you really do need, which is going
- 10:39to keep you out of court and is going to keep
- 10:42your billing down, which is going to make your
- 10:45client happy. Happy clients refer to other clients
- 10:48and that sort of thing. So I think it's really
- 10:50important when you look at any motion to meet
- 10:54and confer. and sit down and talk to the other
- 10:57side, try to work it out, show the judge you
- 11:00did work it out. I apologize, Tony. I didn't
- 11:02mean to sort of get on my nerves. No, you didn't.
- 11:04You're actually talking about what I wanted to
- 11:06get to. I think we're generally talking about
- 11:10meeting and conferring is not just form. It has
- 11:13to have substance. Too often litigating, we just
- 11:16get letters that are obstreperous that says,
- 11:19your objections are meritless. You need to compromise.
- 11:22You need to... I think having these 40 page meet
- 11:27and confer letters are one thing, but sometimes
- 11:29you just got to get on a Zoom too with the parties
- 11:32and talk it through, just like you're suggesting.
- 11:35What do you need? Why? The blanket, pound, sand,
- 11:39stonewalling approach ends up with an expensive
- 11:43motion, waste time. The judges we were talking
- 11:47about earlier, and you could speak about this,
- 11:49get fatigued over making all these decisions
- 11:52over and over again that are really, some of
- 11:56them are pretty apparent. Bank statements, for
- 11:59example, things that you're entitled to in a
- 12:02family law proceeding, you shouldn't have motions
- 12:04about. Maybe there's a compromise. Oftentimes,
- 12:08these can be resolved with a protective order.
- 12:10The LA Superior Court has a form protective order
- 12:14that people should be using, but don't. And it
- 12:17will resolve a lot of these issues about whether
- 12:20you're looking at, for example, a partnership
- 12:22agreement or something that involves a third
- 12:24party and that's your basis for not producing
- 12:27it. Point being, it's all about compromise and
- 12:32being reasonable. We're not trying cases by ambush
- 12:36anymore. And a good prepared attorney knows what
- 12:41they need to know and what they don't necessarily
- 12:43need to know. And I think when you get these
- 12:47motions, the separate statements where, give
- 12:51me all the documents that you've ever created
- 12:53about the other side. And then the objection
- 12:57is three pages of vague and ambiguous. And we
- 13:01all know that what you've done is you've hit
- 13:04the macro on word. This is your objection number
- 13:07seven. The next one's objection number 12. And
- 13:10then so there's no thought that's gone into the
- 13:14objection. There's no thought that then has gone
- 13:16into the why I need the material. And then it
- 13:19just becomes a giant mess that you're sort of
- 13:22dumping in a judge's lap. And the judge is you
- 13:25know, maybe more or less likely to look at it
- 13:28and go, I don't know, I'm not gonna figure it
- 13:30out, denied. And so that's the risk you run.
- 13:35You need to outline and explain every deficiency.
- 13:39That's what it means by, you know, every issue.
- 13:42You have to be very specific and discuss it.
- 13:45Usually when the opposing party, I think it was
- 13:47Judge Saltman that said this, that when the opposing
- 13:49party can explain... The issues as well as the
- 13:53other side, you know, you've had an effective
- 13:54meeting and conferring, right? Um and too often
- 13:58We see these boilerplate objections without any
- 14:03thought that They're just uh rote objections
- 14:07vague and ambiguous where everybody knows I I
- 14:10had one at one point they objected to the word
- 14:13you I mean everybody knows what you is. It's
- 14:16just and when that goes before the judge You
- 14:20just look like you're stonewalling. Make your
- 14:23objections matter. Get to the point. Be aware
- 14:27of all your timing, all your deadlines. I think
- 14:30that's something that's often overlooked. We
- 14:33can move on, I think, to the next slide unless
- 14:36there's something here you want to cover, Joju
- 14:38Haas. I think we met it in our discussion. I
- 14:44think we went ahead for a little bit. But yeah,
- 14:47timing and deadlines is really important. You're
- 14:50not going to send your meeting and meeting confer
- 14:52letter Five days before the discovery deadline
- 14:55and says you need to produce it in three days
- 14:57and our motion is prepared Meet and confer before
- 15:01the motion is filed. You can extend the deadlines
- 15:04by an agreement in writing There's no reason
- 15:08not to courts. I'm sure don't like to see people
- 15:12that aren't In fact, this gets to the local rules
- 15:16of civility with the LA Superior Court that basically
- 15:19says be nice and be reasonable and grant reasonable
- 15:23extensions. I don't think courts like to see
- 15:27people that won't grant extensions and file motions
- 15:30that take three months to resolve and put all
- 15:33these issues that tend to be pretty obvious before
- 15:36them when it should be a matter of talking things
- 15:39through. And that's why the statute's there.
- 15:42Great. So there's a question in the Q &A. And
- 15:46the question is, if you send a bunch of emails,
- 15:48you call repeatedly, the other side doesn't respond.
- 15:51So you can't have a meet and confer. What do
- 15:54you do? And my answer would be, do a declaration
- 16:00that's pretty straightforward. that basically
- 16:05says, look, I called on this day, this day, this
- 16:08day. Here's the emails. Here's I tried to reach
- 16:11out. The other side didn't do anything. And oh,
- 16:14by the way, Your Honor, I had to bring this motion
- 16:17because the other side won't talk to me. And
- 16:19therefore, I think you've got a stronger argument
- 16:22for sanctions at that point as well. Well, I'll
- 16:25even add on to that. I think there might be another
- 16:27step that people can do before then. And we'll
- 16:30talk about this later, but the informal discovery
- 16:32conference. there's a judicial council forum
- 16:35that you can fill out and say, hey, and in that
- 16:39brief description of the issues, that's where
- 16:40you put your declaration to say, your honor,
- 16:43I've tried meeting and conferring and there's
- 16:45no response. It's not going to go over very well
- 16:48when you're in front of the judge that somebody
- 16:50hasn't even responded. And it's really not, they
- 16:54either did or didn't. So you can't pretend whether
- 16:59they did or didn't. And if that, I think that
- 17:02I think that usually gets people in gear and
- 17:04they respond. They usually get something like,
- 17:06oh, that was unnecessary. I think the judges
- 17:11like to see people now in person for those discovery
- 17:14conferences because they'll sit in the hall.
- 17:18When you sit in the hall, how common, Your Honor,
- 17:24do you say you have a PAC schedule and you tell
- 17:27the people to go meet and confer before they
- 17:29hear it? Yeah, go sit in the hall for a minute
- 17:31and talk. See what you can get worked out. And
- 17:34you'd be surprised the number of things that
- 17:36can actually get worked out when two attorneys
- 17:40sit down with each other. And even if the other
- 17:43side is self -represented, when you've got people
- 17:46that are sitting down in good faith trying to
- 17:48reach a resolution. Because, I mean, honestly,
- 17:52you want to decide what your client's future
- 17:55looks like. Your client wants to decide what
- 17:57their future looks like. You don't really want
- 18:00a judge to make a decision unless you absolutely
- 18:02have to. And so if you can take control of that
- 18:05and work it out and get past whatever the hump
- 18:09you need to get past is, I think that makes it
- 18:12better for everybody. But while you're doing
- 18:14this, be cognizant of your deadlines. If you
- 18:20have that 45 -day deadline, that window to file
- 18:22your motion, If nobody's responding to you, they're
- 18:26not granting requests, you really don't have
- 18:28a choice at that point, because you have to preserve
- 18:30your rights. So calendar, calendar, calendar,
- 18:34and remember, it's not just 45 days to file.
- 18:37It's 45 days to file and serve. So if in fact,
- 18:42like the person asked, if somebody is just non
- 18:45-responsive and you've requested the Informal
- 18:49Discovery Conference, I don't know when that
- 18:52gets calendared. Every department's a little
- 18:54different. But if you can't calendar it within
- 18:56the 45 days, you may still, absent an extension,
- 18:59have to file. True. So other things that need
- 19:08to be conferred upon are deposition disputes.
- 19:12They should happen before depositions, not at
- 19:15the deposition. If there's something that, if
- 19:17you're waiting till during the deposition to
- 19:20confer about something, it's probably too late
- 19:23unless you have a referee there who's going to
- 19:26resolve it on the spot. If you have a dispute
- 19:30about something said, be cognizant of that deadline.
- 19:34I don't have it in front of me, but I want to
- 19:36say it's 60 days. I can double check. Actually,
- 19:40I think it's in the materials anyway, so it's
- 19:42probably there. But be reasonable. Extend the
- 19:46deadlines when necessary. And I think that people
- 19:52just need to know what the other person's asking
- 19:57for, understand it, grant reasonable extensions.
- 20:01And when that's done, these issues tend to resolve
- 20:04on their own. So let's move on to the next slide
- 20:08if we can. All right. The declaration requirements.
- 20:13We have a checklist of six items here. You have
- 20:17to list how you were The method of contact. Was
- 20:21it in person? Was it by phone? Was it by video
- 20:24conference? You don't need to do one. You could
- 20:26do all three. The issues presented. We see that
- 20:30often in separate statements. Each request and
- 20:34the deficiency, why you need what you need. Not
- 20:37just you need it because you explain why it's
- 20:40important for your case. Because if the other
- 20:44side doesn't understand it, certainly the judge.
- 20:46we'll wonder, what do they need this document
- 20:48for? Which doesn't mean to say that, you know
- 20:52what, I need the smoking guy. You don't need
- 20:54to give up your case. Just explain why it's relevant.
- 20:58Remember, very broad definition of relevance.
- 21:01And so why is it relevant? Why does that bearing
- 21:03on this particular case? Why do I need all of
- 21:08the bank accounts that go back to 1954? Why?
- 21:12And explain why it's relevant. And make sure
- 21:16you include what the opposing council said. What
- 21:19was their response? Was it compromise reach?
- 21:22Right. What's left after the first meeting and
- 21:27conferring? And now you need to confer about
- 21:30a certified shorthand reporter for the hearing.
- 21:36AB 711, that's the new requirement. Let's move
- 21:40on to the next slide. Suzy, what time do we end?
- 21:47We are scheduled to end around one, though you're,
- 21:50of course, free to continue. Thank you. I just
- 21:53want to make sure that we cover what we do. So
- 21:55AB 711, we can move quickly through this. It's
- 21:59very simple. You need to meet and confer about
- 22:03the other side's position on a CSR for a hearing.
- 22:07That's the new addition. I don't think there's
- 22:09much more to add to that. Do you have something?
- 22:13No, the purpose behind it was to make sure that
- 22:17Court reporter resources, we all know are quite
- 22:20precious. And so I've had a couple of situations
- 22:24where one side thought the other side was bringing
- 22:27a reporter and they didn't. And so there was
- 22:29no reporter. I've had situations where two reporters
- 22:32have come. And so the idea is to meet and confer
- 22:35so that A, you know that you've got a reporter
- 22:37if you want one, but secondly, so that we're
- 22:40not wasting precious court reporter resources.
- 22:44There's a big push. As you all know about court
- 22:47reporters and getting court reporters, voice
- 22:49writers are now acceptable in California and
- 22:52all of that. So I think the legislature and the
- 22:55judicial council are quite concerned that we're
- 22:58using court reporter resources, both court and
- 23:00non -court, as best and most efficiently as we
- 23:04can. So that's what's driving 7 -Eleven. It's
- 23:06just a, you know, talk about it. Yeah, I'll bring
- 23:09it. No, I won't. You do it. You know, that sort
- 23:12of thing, so that everybody knows what's happening
- 23:13with the court reporter. I think we can move
- 23:17on, because we have limited time to the informal
- 23:19discovery conference. This is a really important
- 23:21tool that I think is underutilized. People don't
- 23:26even know about it. There's a local forum, LACIV094,
- 23:31that I think everybody should look at. For situations
- 23:35where you have somebody who's just non -responsive,
- 23:39being unreasonable, it gets you in front of the
- 23:42judge. departments calendar it differently. It's
- 23:47a really, really great tool that should be used.
- 23:50It also brings people, usually, I think, face
- 23:54-to -face in the courtroom, and it gets resolved.
- 23:58Also, you might get an inkling in what the judge
- 24:01thinks about the dispute, and you end up without
- 24:04any motion because a judge might. I can let you
- 24:07opine about this, but if you see something unreasonable,
- 24:11A court may say, you know, if this comes before
- 24:14me and isn't resolved, I may order sanctions.
- 24:18Right. Right. You could get it intended from
- 24:20the judge. That's very helpful. Yeah. And when
- 24:24it's done, send your confirming email to opposing
- 24:27counsel of what happened. Invite them to say
- 24:31if you disagree with anything, let me know. The
- 24:33judge is there. He's going to know. But you need
- 24:37to protect your record. utilize the guidance
- 24:41from the judge. They frequently signal how they're
- 24:44going to view the merits of the case at these
- 24:46conferences, and that will help you shape your
- 24:49motion if you have to make one. It might help
- 24:52you resolve the dispute as well. And after that
- 24:56conference, I'd make one more attempt to resolve
- 24:58the issues. I mean, it's very possible after
- 25:00that conference, you don't just go and file your
- 25:02motion if it fails. Try again. You're going to
- 25:05look far more reasonable to the court, I think,
- 25:08that you've even tried to compromise after you've
- 25:12had the discovery conference, even if it didn't
- 25:16go the way you had planned it. So can we move
- 25:23on in the PowerPoint? Let's move forward. I know
- 25:27we're short on time. Just as you said, we would
- 25:31be, judge you, us. So we can move, I'd say, let's
- 25:37go to slide 13. There we go. So you don't need
- 25:40to use one of these methods. Use all of them.
- 25:42We've talked about it. I think we can keep moving
- 25:44forward documenting the effort we discussed.
- 25:48These are common pitfalls, which we should all
- 25:51know on the next slide. Don't be vague. Don't
- 25:54wait to the last minute. Be reasonable. Remedies.
- 26:00Your Honor, you want to talk about some remedies
- 26:02from the bench's perspective about when you see
- 26:05motions filed without an adequate meet and confer?
- 26:08Well, if the motion doesn't have an adequate
- 26:10mean confer the judge I mean sort of as a As
- 26:13an ultimate, I guess I'm gonna call it a terminating
- 26:15sanction, which is sort of an inappropriate use
- 26:17But the judge can say you didn't meet and confer
- 26:20motion to not I think that that Judges probably
- 26:26would be reluctant to do that. But I think it
- 26:28depends on an awful lot of different things I
- 26:31think that you know sanctions for not meeting
- 26:34conferring monetary sanctions are also available.
- 26:40Now, monetary sanctions, as we all know, are
- 26:42different from a regular family law sanction
- 26:45as opposed to a discovery sanction. The rules
- 26:48are different, the purposes are different, and
- 26:50all of that. And I'm guessing that... Many judges
- 26:54are probably reluctant to make a sanction award
- 26:58for any number of different reasons. But if you've
- 27:01got a good meet and confer, and you've shown
- 27:04that you've actually done what you're supposed
- 27:06to do, and the other side hasn't, like in the
- 27:08situation we had earlier, calls, emails, letters,
- 27:13no response, then the judge may very well be
- 27:15in a position where sanctions are appropriate.
- 27:20I will say that If you're going to ask for sanctions,
- 27:26I think it's important that you support those
- 27:28sanctions. How many hours did it take you to
- 27:31do something? Why did it take so long? You know,
- 27:34that sort of thing. Why the sanction number is
- 27:37appropriate? Because sometimes the sanction number
- 27:40can be actually quite high. If you've got a lot
- 27:43of requests for production that you've got to
- 27:46go through a lot of detail, there's a lot of
- 27:48detailed... meeting confers and all that, it's
- 27:51going to be expensive. So making sure the judge
- 27:53understands all of those things, I think become
- 27:57important if you want your sanctions. At the
- 28:01end of the day, your reputation on this case
- 28:04and on the other cases with the judge is really
- 28:07important. And if you show that you're the civil
- 28:11attorney that's trying to do the best you can
- 28:14to get through this without with the least amount
- 28:18of must and fuss, then I think that you're going
- 28:22to end up with a good reputation on this case
- 28:24with that judge and then on other cases as well.
- 28:27So I think credibility with the court in showing
- 28:31that you're trying to do the right thing becomes
- 28:33really an important part of all of this. good
- 28:36credibility is going to lead to a better outcome.
- 28:42And then there's the Carton case from not long
- 28:44ago where the District Court of Appeals said
- 28:47something along the lines of good judges are
- 28:51civil and good judges deserve attorney's fees.
- 28:56And so I think that's something, I think, also
- 28:58to keep in mind, that there's a big push, or
- 29:01rightfully so, big push for civility. And showing
- 29:05that you're doing everything you can do to make
- 29:08the litigation as smooth as possible is going
- 29:11to, again, make that judge think kindly of you,
- 29:14both in the sanctions area and also credibility
- 29:17for you when you're making your argument. Makes
- 29:20for a better motion if one's needed. The case
- 29:24that I love the quote from is Seegendal. It's
- 29:27not a discovery case. I'm sure you know the one
- 29:29that I'm thinking of where it says something
- 29:32along the lines of rules of procedure for reaching
- 29:34family law decisions aren't mere suggestions.
- 29:38They're commandments which ensure fairness by
- 29:40their enforcement. So follow the rules. And the
- 29:43rules tell you meet and confer. It's not meeting
- 29:47and conferring isn't lip service to check a box.
- 29:50Be detailed. Memorialize everything. Be civil.
- 29:55Communication is key. Compromise is key. Being
- 29:59creative, thinking a little bit outside the box.
- 30:02Look at it from the other side's point of view.
- 30:06I can see where they're coming from. If this
- 30:08person was my client, what's a possible compromise?
- 30:13The protective order I raised earlier. Often
- 30:16that resolves an issue if there's a third party
- 30:19right that's implicated here. I used to use the
- 30:23foreign protective order all the time. It's pretty
- 30:26good and I'd suggest that people look it up if
- 30:29they haven't and utilize it and know your court
- 30:32and utilize the informal discovery conference
- 30:35when you can. It can be a valuable tool to resolving
- 30:39the discovery dispute before you've spent a small
- 30:42fortune trying to get documents which you should
- 30:45have been able to get without the motion. Is
- 30:52there anything you wanted to add? We're two minutes
- 30:56over Judge Yuhas. No, I think we've pretty much
- 30:59said what we can say. Well then, thank you everybody
- 31:03for coming. I know this was a race through a
- 31:05lot of materials. If anybody has any questions,
- 31:09feel free to reach out and I'm happy to answer
- 31:11them best I can. And I appreciate your attendance
- 31:15and everything. Thank you. Thank you. This concludes
- 31:20today's presentation. Thank you so much, Tony
- 31:23Starm and Judge Yuhas for an excellent presentation
- 31:25today. And thank you so much to our audience.
- 31:27Have a great day, everybody.