Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Unmasking the Invisible: Indoor Air Quality's Impact on Health
Transcript
- 0:00Music.
- 0:14Podcast for the American Council of Engineering Companies. And today,
- 0:18I'm very pleased to be joined by Randy Huckabee with Ken Phil,
- 0:22talking about a very interesting and important aspect of engineering,
- 0:27especially something that our engineers should be aware of when they're designing
- 0:31facilities, both industrial and commercial,
- 0:35really any facility that people work and spend time in.
- 0:39And that's the issue of indoor air quality.
- 0:42Randy, thank you very much for joining us on the program this morning.
- 0:47Yeah, no problem. Thanks for having me again. Yeah, it's great to have you back on.
- 0:50And for those in our audience who are not familiar with Camp Fill,
- 0:54could you give a description of the company and the work that you do?
- 0:58I know that really that environmental control and dust that we had you on before
- 1:04talking about specifications on industrial dust collectors, kind of the air quality related issue.
- 1:11But explain what Cancel does and where you are in the market?
- 1:15Sure. So Cancel as a whole works in cleaning up air.
- 1:19We're most known, widely known for what we do in commercial spaces.
- 1:23So we're here, we're talking about hospitals, hotels, schools, things like that.
- 1:28But the division that I work in is specific towards air pollution control.
- 1:31And this is in industrial spaces, specifically manufacturing process is anything
- 1:37from metal to food and food, pharmaceutical, plastic, woodworking, those kinds of things.
- 1:45And we specifically make dry dust collection and oil and mist collectors as well.
- 1:51Fantastic. And, you know, this is something which is very important,
- 1:55indoor air quality, because it's regulated.
- 1:57Of course, it's something that our professionals need to know about.
- 2:01You know, they're trying to design facilities that take in the context all of
- 2:06the different variables they have to worry about. Of course,
- 2:10you know, everyone's concerned about indoor air quality, especially after the COVID-19 pandemic.
- 2:15I think that the pandemic had a way of refocusing people's attention on exactly
- 2:20the air they're breathing inside, confined spaces.
- 2:22So this is a very important thing to talk about.
- 2:25What are some of the, you know, that you found are some of the common causes for indoor air quality?
- 2:35Well, the first one, I mean, you may not believe it, but indoor air quality
- 2:39is already two to five times more polluted than outdoor air quality.
- 2:44So oftentimes it's just a lack of outdoor air quality or recirculation or simply
- 2:50not taking care of your HVAD system. That's a big, big cause.
- 2:55And then things such as general wear and tear on your building,
- 2:58cracks or leaks, lots of excessive traffic going in and out of man doors,
- 3:03overhead doors, forklift entrances, things like that.
- 3:06Those are large contributors, much larger than people really think.
- 3:09Obviously, those are important to us at Canfield. But being on the air pollution
- 3:13control side, we really focus on the equipment side.
- 3:16And a lot of people also don't focus enough on the dust being generated from their processes.
- 3:21And this is where the really, really harmful dust comes into play and what we
- 3:27focus on protecting people and processes from.
- 3:30Yeah, really, we're talking about,
- 3:33all varieties of material or particulate matter that can be kicked up in the
- 3:40normal course of working.
- 3:42And you're right, HVAC, I don't know, that's the something that you're specifically focused on.
- 3:48Sometimes it's not top of mind. Personally, residentially, I found that out
- 3:53myself when I had someone clean my HVAC, and then we put it in a UV system for
- 3:58that purpose, because they realize, hey, you know,
- 4:02you got to clean this stuff. You got to stay on top of it.
- 4:05And if you're dealing in an industrial situation, a lot of times,
- 4:09you know, you need to have a proper control.
- 4:14So, of course, you have to deal with exactly what's being checked up.
- 4:17I mean, with all the different ranges of particulate matter,
- 4:21what are some of the really leading health impacts with poor indoor air quality?
- 4:28Well, it starts real small. If we start on the small side, there are items that
- 4:33could be confused with a common cold, allergies, or seasonal items.
- 4:37We're talking headaches, congestion, like a cough, something that mimics a common
- 4:43cold, eye irritation, skin irritation.
- 4:46If you're in that environment every day, something that a lot of people become
- 4:50accustomed to, sadly, and they don't realize that it's attributed to poor eye
- 4:54AQ, where a visitor who's there for one or two days, you know,
- 4:58they kind of noticed it. And then when they leave, they immediately get better.
- 5:01You know, that's a really small indication.
- 5:03Now, on a more serious side, we've got things like silicosis coming from silica processing.
- 5:10We've got hex chrome cancer causing carcinogens out of the metalworking industry
- 5:15that can go into groundwater.
- 5:18You know, now we're learning about PFAS or polyfluoroalkalines that come,
- 5:22that are the never-ending chemical.
- 5:25They can be made, but they can't be destroyed.
- 5:28So things like that that are more harmful, more serious, people are becoming
- 5:32more aware of and we're learning how to deal with these.
- 5:36And this is, of course, you know, something that you mentioned PFAS,
- 5:40that's a highly regulated area.
- 5:42What are some of the other regulations that kind of cover issues related to indoor air clog?
- 5:48Again, it starts really, really broad. So we've got the Clean Air Act of 63
- 5:53and 1990 that kind of pushed those regulations down and gave us OSHA out of the EPA.
- 6:00And then it goes even further down the line than that. You know,
- 6:04we've got ASHRAE regulations for indoor air.
- 6:06We're talking about offices and things like that. And then we've got things
- 6:11like MSHA for mining, regulating those exposure limits.
- 6:16We've got NIOSH and ISPE for pharmaceutical world, the FDA for food and drug administration,
- 6:24kind of specific industries in those larger markets where they've known to have
- 6:28a lot of issues back in the day, but they're becoming more and more prevalent.
- 6:33And the restrictions are starting to get tighter and tighter,
- 6:36and people are actually starting to regulate them a little bit.
- 6:39So I expect to see this more and more as we research and the industry start
- 6:45finding more cause to some of these symptoms that we've seen over the years.
- 6:50Yeah, and it seems as though, you know,
- 6:53the medical field is kind of every year they're kind of discovering more causes
- 6:59and links to environmental factors when it comes to quality of health and different
- 7:06aspects of upper respiratory system, you know, of conditions,
- 7:11things that are more environmental than they are, let's say,
- 7:14caused by something biological.
- 7:16And states are taking a lack of role in regulating the quality of the air both outdoor and indoor.
- 7:24That, of course, means that our industry has to respond that when they're designing.
- 7:30Large or really any size industrial or commercial facilities,
- 7:37that this has to be top of mind.
- 7:39How does Canfield kind of come in and help the engineering firms kind of figure
- 7:45out the specifications for even looking at issues related to indoor air quality?
- 7:52There's a couple different ways. First is, you know, we work with the engineering
- 7:56firm to determine what the dust is, you know, how it could be best handled.
- 8:01So is it going to be an oil or mist collector?
- 8:04Is it going to be a dry cartridge collector like we make, or is it outside the
- 8:08temperature limits, you know, maybe a bag house or some pre-separation is needed.
- 8:12So really what the dust is, how small and fine the particulates might be,
- 8:19and what kind of technology would work best.
- 8:22And then really working backwards to what the emissions or regulations are in that industry.
- 8:28Whether it's dictated by that state, that company could be their insurance provider
- 8:33or some other regulatory agency.
- 8:36So between those regulations and the actual dust that's being processed,
- 8:40CAMFIL will work to determine the equipment and then the media or filtration
- 8:45efficiency needed to get to that emission level that they're wanting.
- 8:49And that kind of sets you apart, right, because it's not just the design and
- 8:55construction of the filtration systems.
- 8:59It's really going from the start working with those engineers in determining
- 9:03what needs to be built exactly,
- 9:06you know, what kind of particulate matter that you're dealing with and then
- 9:10really understanding from site selection all the way into the design phase,
- 9:14what needs to happen, right?
- 9:17Absolutely. Even within dry dust collection itself, there's so many technologies out there.
- 9:22There's vertical cartridges, which is what we specialize in. There's horizontal.
- 9:29There's something called air-to-cloth ratio that you need to take into consideration
- 9:33to make sure that you're evacuating the appropriate amount of particulate.
- 9:37You don't want to take too much because you could affect the quality of the
- 9:40product that's being made, but you've got to take enough so that all the hazards
- 9:44are removed from the process.
- 9:47So we work from the very beginning with the engineering firm to know exactly
- 9:53how much we're evacuating and what we're evacuating from the space.
- 9:59Absolutely. And that's really critical to your point.
- 10:02Like, you know, the idea of reaching zero particulate matter or zero,
- 10:09you know, dust or what have you is probably impossible because it depends on
- 10:14exactly what's being done in the facility.
- 10:16If you lower too much, to your point, it could actually lower the quality or
- 10:20disrupt the actual manufacturer of what they're trying to actually accomplish.
- 10:24So it's really finding that line where you're preserving employee and the health
- 10:30of the people surrounding the facility and also making sure that you can actually
- 10:34get done what that facility is intended to do.
- 10:37But for, you know,
- 10:40engineers who really don't have a lot of experience or know all the ins and outs of, let's say,
- 10:50the chemistry side or really a lot of the biological side of air quality,
- 10:58you know, how do you work with them to kind of, I guess, bridge that gap?
- 11:04I mean, what kind of expertise, what kind of backgrounds do your experts bring
- 11:09to a project to help them define the specifications for whatever equipment they need to have?
- 11:17Well, we've been in the industry for about 30 years now with our current product, our standard product.
- 11:22And so we have a lot of ways we can look back on how if systems were applied
- 11:28to maybe a similar type process or similar type dust.
- 11:31So we have a lot of those existing kind of standards that we can go by.
- 11:36And that's one method. Another method is we have an internal network of sales
- 11:41force reps, dealers who all over the world,
- 11:44it's not just in the Americas, it's all over the world who are working with
- 11:47some of these large companies right from the ground up in their R&D facilities.
- 11:52So sometimes we have to focus and go all the way back to the original manufacturer
- 11:56and see what best practices we can apply there as well.
- 12:00But we're also willing to do test sites, some beta sites with our customers if they're unsure.
- 12:07A lot of these OEMs are unsure of how their process is going to finish at the end of the day.
- 12:10So we'll work with them, supply some test equipment, and, you know,
- 12:16we can verify particulate, we can monitor it throughout, we can see how long the system will last.
- 12:22Compare it to some in-house standards, some ASHRAE standards that we test to
- 12:27every day, every week, and really see what best practice should be used moving
- 12:32forward as the process develops.
- 12:35So it's kind of a combination of best practices that we've known forever.
- 12:39And then we can apply any new testing technology to a customer site that we
- 12:46can deploy as needed throughout and grow with the customer.
- 12:51That's really good to know because it really is that full-service approach to make sure that any.
- 13:03Plan that's put in place can actually, at the start,
- 13:08really determine what needs to be addressed and really how to go about that
- 13:13with holding to those regulatory standards is critically important.
- 13:18Yeah, one question I have is related to kind of the marketplace,
- 13:21because do you see, you know, in your experience,
- 13:24is it not, I imagine not just new construction or new facilities being designed,
- 13:31but a good amount of retrofitting on existing facilities to meet current standards.
- 13:36How do you see that market breakdown between retrofitting and just brand new,
- 13:40you know, on-stack design of filtration systems?
- 13:45Obviously, there's been a lot of growth in the new construction in the last
- 13:50couple of administrations in the U.S. especially.
- 13:53So North America has seen a lot of new construction growth recently.
- 13:57The EV battery world is actually the hottest growing industry here in North
- 14:01America, and that's full of a lot of unknowns.
- 14:04That technology kind of differs from one end of the spectrum to the other.
- 14:08And so we've got a lot of different things going on in that new construction,
- 14:12but you kind of hit it on the head that a lot of retrofitting needs to happen.
- 14:16A lot of these regulations are new and people were unprepared when they set
- 14:20up their manufacturing facilities 10, 15, 20 years ago.
- 14:24The good news is a lot of these, a lot of air pollution control equipment can
- 14:28still be utilized and either added onto, upgraded.
- 14:33You can, a lot of them are modular and you can add to the system size as needed,
- 14:37or you can make the systems work together. So I would say right now we're about...
- 14:43On our equipment side, we're about 30% new construction and probably 40% retrofitting to the market.
- 14:53And then we've got a little bit what I would call in-between add-ons,
- 14:57replacing systems, not just adding to them or upgrading them.
- 15:02So there's a little bit of an in-between there in the R&D world as well.
- 15:07Which goes back to the idea of really involving experts from capital at the
- 15:12start, because you also have to look at expansion and scale over time so that the facility,
- 15:18you might have a system that's designed for only so much production.
- 15:22But if you expand production out of the facility, that's going to have to also augment over time.
- 15:27So building for scale is also in the sort.
- 15:30So this is really good information. For our member of firms that are in the
- 15:36process right now of dealing with indoor air quality issues,
- 15:40where should they go to visit Canfield and how should they navigate to the right
- 15:45person to start talking to us?
- 15:47Great websites. Canfield.com is our main website.
- 15:51I highly encourage anybody to go there. It's really easy to navigate onto our
- 15:55air pollution control section on that page.
- 15:57So it'll just say Canfield APC division on one of them and that will get you
- 16:02right to where you need to go.
- 16:03We offer a website in several different languages as we're a global company.
- 16:08So it's readily available everywhere you need to go. If you're a company simply
- 16:11looking for filters or retrofitting the collectors you have,
- 16:16We have an aftermarket department that also has a link on that website as well.
- 16:21But there is a chat bot on most of those, and they'll take you right where you need to go.
- 16:25That's awesome. I know it's kind of a quick dip into a very deep pond here when
- 16:31you talk about these indoor quality issues, but it's a good start to the conversation.
- 16:36And Randy, I want to thank you again for being part of the program.
- 16:39Is there anything that we didn't touch upon that you want to make sure that
- 16:41our audience knows before we wrap up? No, you know, I think one thing is just
- 16:46that it's really not as difficult as it seems if you contact the right people.
- 16:50Obviously, air pollution control is easier if you start at the very beginning of your processes.
- 16:55But we know that's not how we know that's not how it typically works is we're
- 16:59kind of after the scenes, after the product is made. You know,
- 17:03how can we protect the people and the process?
- 17:07And that's what we're here for. So any step along the way, don't hesitate to
- 17:11contact Canfield or one of our representatives, because we can help.
- 17:16Fantastic. Well, Randy Haudenby, Product Manager at Canfield,
- 17:19thank you again for being part of the program today. Really look forward to having you on again.
- 17:24Yes, I do too. Thank you. Fantastic. And again, this has been Engineering Office
- 17:29Podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 17:32Music.