Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Handle Early Lockup Expiry
Transcript
- Lucas: So, Luna, we talk a lot about the IPO itself, but there's this quiet window that opens a few months after the debut, and it can make or break how a company is perceived for years. I'm talking about the lockup expiry, and specifically, what happens when that first lockup ends right after a company's first earnings call as a public entity. Luna: Yeah, that's usually the moment when the stock can tank or soar, depending on how many insiders are selling and how the company frames it. I remember Airbnb's first lockup expiry — it was a mess, wasn't it? Lucas: A total mess. Airbnb went public in December 2020, and their lockup expired in September 2021. The stock had been trading around $200, and within a week it dropped below $150. Insider selling was massive, and the company had to issue a secondary offering to absorb the supply, but it still felt chaotic. Luna: Right, but that's an extreme case. What about the companies that handle it smoothly? What does a well-executed lockup expiry look like? Lucas: A good example is Palantir. Their lockup expired in early 2021, and they had a massive secondary offering — something like 228 million shares — but they structured it as a direct listing, which meant there was no new capital raised, just a liquidity event. They also had some large investors like Founders Fund participate, which showed confidence. Luna: So the key is that the company doesn't just let insiders dump shares without any coordination. They work with underwriters to create a structured sale, maybe a secondary offering, and they communicate the plan to the market. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what we're seeing more of today, especially with the recent wave of tech IPOs. Take a look at the current market — Palantir is up almost 6 percent over the last five days, trading at $186. That's partly because they've been very disciplined about post ipo share management. They even did buybacks before their lockup expiry, which we covered a couple episodes ago. Luna: And Airbnb has since done a $2 billion buyback, which helped stabilize their stock. But the lesson is that the first lockup expiry is a real test of a company's investor relations team. Lucas: Absolutely. So let's break down the playbook. There are three main things a company can do to manage the first lockup expiry: first, they can negotiate an early release of some shares, but that's risky. Second, they can do a secondary offering to create a controlled sale window. Third, they can just let it happen and hope the market absorbs it. Luna: And the third option is what Airbnb initially did, and it blew up in their face. But what about companies that try the early release? I've seen that backfire too. Lucas: It can, because it signals that insiders are eager to sell, which often spooks investors. A famous example is Facebook — before their lockup expired in 2012, they allowed early sales for employees to diversify, and the stock dropped below the IPO price. But they also structured it with a plan that kept the company's story intact. Luna: So the real trick is to give the market a clear narrative. If you're a CFO, you want to say, 'We're not selling because we don't believe in the company; we're selling to diversify, and we have a plan.' Lucas: Right, and that's where the earnings call becomes crucial. If the lockup expiry falls right after the first earnings report, the company can use that call to reset expectations — we touched on that in a previous episode. They can highlight strong quarterly numbers, reaffirm guidance, and even announce a buyback to offset selling pressure. Luna: So timing matters. Some companies intentionally set their lockup expiry to align with their earnings cycle, but they can't always control that. What about the legal side? Are there any restrictions on when insiders can sell? Lucas: There are insider trading windows that typically open after earnings, and the lockup is separate from that. But companies can also impose their own trading windows or require insiders to use Rule 10b5-1 plans, which are pre-scheduled sales that show good faith. That's something we've seen more of recently. Luna: And those plans are also a signal to the market — they show that insiders aren't just reacting to the stock price, but following a disciplined plan. Lucas: Exactly. And I think that's the key takeaway for today: the lockup expiry is not just an event, it's a negotiation between the company, its insiders, and the market. The companies that handle it well — like Palantir, despite its unconventional path — they come out stronger because they've proven they can manage shareholder value. Luna: So what should investors watch for when a company they own goes through a lockup expiry? Lucas: First, check the size of the lockup relative to shares outstanding. If it's more than 20 percent, that's a big overhang. Second, see if the company has announced a secondary offering or a buyback. Third, listen to the earnings call — if they're confident, they'll talk about long-term fundamentals, not just the selling pressure. Luna: And also look at the insider sentiment. If you see insiders buying during the lockup period, that's a huge vote of confidence. But if they're all queuing up to sell, you might want to be cautious. Lucas: Right. And that's where the data comes in. For example, if you look at recent tech stocks, you have companies like Shopify and Coinbase, which have had their lockups expire in the past couple of years. Shopify's stock has been steady, but Coinbase saw a dip after its second lockup. It really depends on the context. Luna: Yeah, and I think the broader lesson is that post ipo companies are learning from the past. They're being more proactive about managing these events, which is a positive sign for the market. Lucas: One thing we haven't mentioned is the role of short sellers. They often target companies right around lockup expiry because they anticipate the selling pressure. That can amplify the drop, but it also creates an opportunity for long-term investors if the company's fundamentals are solid. Luna: So it's a double-edged sword. But I guess the takeaway is that a lockup expiry is not always bearish — it can be a catalyst for the stock to finally trade at its true value. Lucas: Exactly. And that brings me to something we've been talking about behind the scenes. When we look at how companies communicate during these critical moments, it reminds me of how we run this show — we're careful to give you context and insight without the noise. If you find these conversations useful for what you're building or running, consider supporting the show on buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep us independent and ad-free. Luna: Yeah, we've had listeners say that a few episodes helped them think differently about their own company's equity plans. That's always great to hear. Lucas: So back to lockup expiries — one more thing I want to highlight is the growing trend of 'staggered lockups.' Instead of one big expiry, companies are now releasing shares in tranches over a longer period. That reduces the cliff effect and gives the market time to digest the selling. Luna: Right, I've seen that with some biotech IPOs. It seems like a smarter way to handle it, but does it always work? Lucas: Not always. If the company's performance is weak, even a staggered lockup won't save the stock. But it does remove the overhang more gradually, which can be less disruptive. For example, if a company has a lockup that releases 20 percent at six months and another 20 percent at twelve months, investors have a clearer picture of when the supply will hit the market. Luna: And that clarity helps institutional investors make decisions. They can plan their entry points, which might actually increase demand over time. Lucas: Absolutely. So, looking ahead, the next few months will be interesting for some of the recent IPOs in the tech sector. We'll see if they follow the old playbook or adopt the newer, more nuanced approaches. Either way, it's a critical period for them. Luna: And for investors, it's a chance to see which companies are really ready for the public markets. It's like a second debut. Lucas: That's a good way to put it. Thanks for joining us on Tech IPO Conversations. We'll be back with more insights soon.