Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Steve Greenfield on Dealer-Built Tech Products, BYD’s Stock Drop and More
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It's Wednesday, February 25th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. Gonna have a special guest host today, Steve Greenfield. Gonna bring him in in a minute.
- 0:09We're talking about some dealer-built tech products, BYD's stock price, a new podcast, a few more things. Um, but I would be remiss if I didn't start the show
- 0:20by saying today is the premiere of episode three of the second season of The Truth About Car Dealers. It's the docuseries where Kyle and I travel around the country visiting dealer groups.
- 0:31Uh, people want transparency, so we're giving you transparency into what's really happening inside the stores. This time, we got to spend, uh, a little bit in Indiana with the Rorman Auto Group.
- 0:40You see Ryan Rorman looking so good there on the trailer. The consummate gentleman, and what an innovator he is with the group.
- 0:46Not just in technology, but we go down the line and see how the legacy that Bob Rorman started years ago has developed into one that serves people, takes care of people, that moves them through careers.
- 0:57And the result of that is actually a really innovative business that's able to serve customers where they're at and the way they want. So you can join us by, um, we're gonna be on LinkedIn Live premiere.
- 1:07It's also gonna be on YouTube Live, but we hope you're at LinkedIn. We'll be in the comments there. You can, uh, join, RSVP, get the premiere link so you don't miss it. Just go to thetruthaboutcardealers.com.
- 1:19thetruthaboutcardealers.com. There's a banner at the top. Click on that. Join us for the premiere. Um, I mean, we love talking about customer experience.
- 1:26You know, coffee bars, fast delivery, follow-up texts with just the right emoji. But if your team is disengaged, customers definitely feel it.
- 1:34Retail auto loses nearly 20 billion, that's with a B, dollars a year to turnover. And the dealers winning long-term are investing in the employee experience first.
- 1:43eSIQ measures how your team actually feels and gives you actionable insight before problems become resignations. We've gotten them, two weeks notices, if we're lucky. It's dealership-specific, it's clear, and it works.
- 1:55Check out how they can help you spot the warning signs at esiq.ai. That's esiq.ai. I love companies that help us make this industry one that people fight to join. One of those people is with us on the show today.
- 2:09Let's bring in the one and only Steve Greenfield. Steve, thank you so much for joining me today in the co-host spot. Yeah. It's great here, being here.
- 2:15A- anytime Kyle decides to go off and take a vacation, I'm very happy to be your second. Yes. It's, it's amazing. It's, it's so exciting to, like, just, oh, mix it up a little bit. Kyle can relax.
- 2:25He knows you got the helm and, and here we go. Um, hey, I wanted to start by talking about, so you have a, an email you send out every week, The Auto- Automotive Ventures Intel Report.
- 2:33If you don't get it, you should get it, automotiveventures.com. Um, the fir- the lead story was one of your fund's companies was acquired. Always a moment to celebrate, so congratulations. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Thank you.
- 2:44And tell us a little bit about the company and, and, uh, why, why you invested in it in the first place, and kind of what the next, what the outlook's looking like for them. Yeah, a- a- awesome.
- 2:51Um, well, the company's Algo- Algo Driven out of our first fund. So just frame of reference, you know, we're on our third fund. We've made 55 investments. And there you go. Um, there's Glen right there.
- 3:01So, uh, um, you know, this is one of the c- company we invested. Uh, 24 companies in that very first fund. We're now five years in.
- 3:07So we, we expect that some of the companies will start, um, you know, liquidating, selling, selling now, uh, find, finding buyers. And this was, uh, one of the first ones.
- 3:15Uh, the second, second company out of that fund that found a home. Uh, we're very happy. Um, Gle- Glen and Jaron built a really, really nice business.
- 3:23Um, you can kinda think of this, for, for the folks that are in the US, think of it as sort of some combination of Black Book, um, and residual value setting- Hmm...
- 3:31and vAuto for the Australian market and the Middle East. Um, they've actually got a, a good beachhead into the Middle East, the UAE, Saudi, et cetera.
- 3:38Uh, but it was actually, uh, started by two Australians, and, uh, has real- really good footprint with dealers down, down, Down Under, down in Australia.
- 3:46So, um, uh, the, the, um, the, the acquirers emergence, uh, work really closely with those, those folks. And they're, they're kinda building an inter- international platform for automotive which is very exciting.
- 3:57Um, Algo Driven will be a key piece of that. And, um, yeah, we're really, really excited. Um, you know, the, the nice thing about this world, as you know, it's a, it's a small world.
- 4:05So these entrepreneurs, you, you back them, they exit, and then, you know, inevitably at some point in the future they'll start another company. Without a doubt. And, yeah, so we, we, we wanna stay close to them.
- 4:14We've seen this o- o- over and over.
- 4:15And, um, you know, it's really, really cool to see, you know, two relatively young people, you know, build out their dreams and then realize a, a great outcome, and then, um, you know, just stay close with them.
- 4:27So it's great. We'll have a celebratory dinner here with them pretty soon. And, um, just, you know, it's great. But just, just the, the early innings for us in terms of exits out of that very first fund.
- 4:35Oh, that's exciting to see that, that full life cycle starting to hit. And, um, yeah, they'll be back. We've seen this. The most recent example for me is Ryan Austin, uh, formerly Gubagoo. Oh, sure. Right? Yeah, yeah.
- 4:46And, and I remember seeing him in the airport after the NADA which was, like, gonna be his last NADA after, you know, he fulfilled his obligations. And he was like, "I think I'm gonna do this and that."
- 4:55And of course the next year he's like, "Nah, I'm building this new company. It's called Lightflow and I'm back." Right? You can't get- Yeah. And he was on stage with, with us at the AutoTech Investments conference.
- 5:03And he won the pitch contest, so, um- That doesn't surprise me... kudos to him. I mean, he was up on stage with me holding the trophy. And, uh, yeah, he did an awesome job.
- 5:11A, a great, very crisp, uh, clean, um, well-articulated value proposition for dealers. And, uh, yeah, it's, um, he's off to the races again. So yeah, g- g- great, great example. Yeah.
- 5:21Well, it's always fun to watch you, uh, put so much heart and soul into not just the company, the tech, but really the entrepreneur.
- 5:28And, uh, you know, Gary Vaynerchuk always told me, he's like, "I bet on the jockey, not on the horse." Yep. And, um, that's a lot of the assessments you all are making and trying to, to get that jockey nice and strong.
- 5:36So congrats to see that one across the line. Let's talk about a little news, speaking of international news. Chinese EV juggernaut BYD is hitting turbulence, uh, even as they surpass Tesla in global EV sales.
- 5:47Investors are now backing away. It's a brutal price war. Shrinking subsidies and 400 other competing models have turned the world's hottest EV market into what analysts are calling an industry wartime shakeout.
- 5:59BYD stock has fallen roughly 40% in, from its May peak as January EV deliveries dropped 33% year over year. And overall EV, Chinese EV sales slid almost 20%400 EV models are now for sale in China.
- 6:13400, more than double what it was in 2019. Government incentives are going away. China reinstated half of its 10% vehicle purchase tax this year, with the full tax expected to return, uh, after next year.
- 6:26And analysts are estimating 40% of China's auto production capacity is unused, creating excess supply, accelerating price spiral known as involution.
- 6:35Scott Kennedy of CSIS said the industry is entering a wartime period, predicting the field will shrink from hundreds of EV markets down to just a handful long term. Yep.
- 6:46Yeah, there's something like 117 automakers in, in, um, in China, right? We've got, what, two or three here in the US, so- [laughs] How many can you name? Right. Oh- I can probably name six maybe in China.
- 6:55[laughs] Yeah, five, five or six maybe. But there, there, there... You know, there's, needs to be a clearing out. But this is, you know, that, that word invol- involution you're gonna hear more of. Oh.
- 7:02It seems to be, like, the, the, the Chinese MO, which is, you know, over- o- massive overproduction. Uh, build, build excess capacity, et cetera, and just force Darwinism so that only the strongest survive.
- 7:12And BYD will be one of the stro- strongest companies. Mm-hmm. It's well-operated, et cetera. But for the time being, you know, you, you, you nailed it.
- 7:19You know, think, think of the Chinese market as selling about 24 million new vehicles a year, compared to the US s- at 16. Is that all it is, 24 million?
- 7:28But they have production capacity, a- as you mentioned, for, what, 45 million. About 20 million excess capacity. Wow.
- 7:34So what's happening, because the, the, the home market is not profitable for any of the 117 automakers, there is intense pressure for this excess capacity to get exported. Mm.
- 7:44That's why we see all, all kinds of markets around the world where there aren't tariffs. The Chinese are very, very quickly taking market share.
- 7:50You remember when you were over in Kazakhstan here recently, that market went from 0% Chinese market share three years ago. Mm-hmm. Last year it was 50%. Half of the new cars are Chinese. And- It felt like that...
- 8:01if you ext- extrapolate that line out, you know, they're gonna squeeze out the legacy automakers in, in most of these other markets.
- 8:07And that's really the concern and why we have the tariffs here in the US, is because the Chinese have this intense pressure to export these cars.
- 8:15And ironically, when BYD exports a car, even with tariffs, it's much more profitable than it is selling that same unit back at home. So we're gonna see more of this massive export market out of China.
- 8:27I do think that there need to be far fewer OEMs. There don't need to be 117. So whether it's bankruptcies or mergers or whatever it might be, there will be a clearing out.
- 8:36Um, but, um, you know, I, I don't think that companies like BYD are going anywhere. In fact, I, I expect that BYD will continue to focus on being the largest automaker in the world. Mm-hmm.
- 8:46And they, they've got their sights right on Te- on, on, on Toyota. Yeah. Oh. Yeah, I mean, that makes sense too. I'm thinking about the, what we're seeing happen within Tesla even.
- 8:56Tesla looking at its auto manufacturing and looking at the capacity it has, is then reallocating auto manufacturing capacity to robots and humanoids. Yeah.
- 9:06And I wouldn't be surprised to see a lot of these, uh, manufacturers that have been building cars be converted into some next generation technology, like humanoid robots or some other type of robotic.
- 9:16Um, so they have the capacity for it. It makes a lot of sense. Uh, and you even mentioned in Kazakhstan, if you don't have...
- 9:24One of the benefits the Chinese market brings to a country like Kazakhstan is the ability to manufacture their vehicles in the country. Mm-hmm.
- 9:30And if you're a country that doesn't naturally have, um, a, an organic manufacturing environment for automobiles, why wouldn't you want an eager partner who's saying, "Hey, let's build some of these, or let's s- start selling some of them.
- 9:42Then you can put some of them together." It's a real economic booster. So, uh, three-dimensional chess for sure. I can't believe that- Mm-hmm... Chinese capacity is only 24 million. Right.
- 9:52I expected it to be so much more. Um, but their excess capacity is more than our entire market. [laughs] That's exactly right. Scary to think about. Yeah. It, it really, really is.
- 10:01Um, something that's not scary to think about is you have a new podcast coming out. I do. I do. And le- let's talk a little bit about that, because we're helping you produce this.
- 10:10And, um, it's gonna feature you, a bunch of startup founders, a bunch of industry advocates. And, uh, you're starting recording. You're gonna be releasing this soon.
- 10:17Tell us a little bit about the show and, uh, what your hopes are for it. Yeah. First shout-out to Nathan, who I know is bes- behind the scenes right now. W- without him, none of this would be happening.
- 10:25So- That's right... the guy's a prince, and I really, really appreciate everything that he's doing, and he needs to just keep peak pressure on me to keep this thing moving forward. [laughs] So that's great.
- 10:32Everybody needs Nathan. [laughs] Yeah. But no, look, look, I mean, this is a great collaboration with you guys. Really, really appreciate that. You know, we, it's long overdue.
- 10:40You know, I've got that newsletter now that goes out every Monday, as you mentioned. It's got, you know- How many people are on that list? Um, about over 16,000 people get that every Monday. Yeah. So that's great.
- 10:49You know, we've got good readership. And I have a lot of people that come up to me after my speaking engagements thanking me for the content, et cetera. So I'll always open to feedback, uh, around that.
- 10:58But, you know, what- whatever the analog is, um, in terms of, like, audio and video, we need to get done, and, uh, it's been long overdue. So Nathan's hap- uh, helping us make that happen.
- 11:07We will be doing longer format, you know, interviews with industry folks, whether, like you said, some of our entrepreneurs, some other folks within the industry, and catching up.
- 11:16And, and maybe, maybe provide a little more, uh, perspective on, like, how we think about the industry as investors. Get inside the heads of, like, successful entrepreneurs and how they think, et cetera.
- 11:25So it should be fresh, new content, hopefully for the industry. And, uh, hopefully people like it. Um, I think we're targeting here, you know, in, within, within a month we'll get some of this content out there.
- 11:34So as you digest it, if you're out there, um, and you follow us anyway, then please, uh, l- let me know.
- 11:39Let me know what you think, and if you've got suggestions for folks we sh- should interview and topics we should cover, I, I'm all ears. Yes. Yes. I love that. What is... Tell me this.
- 11:48Uh, you, you consume a lot of content, obviously, because you write and commentate on it. What are the things that you enjoy about a good podcast?
- 11:56Um, well, you know, just, I guess to state the obvious, some unique insight that I didn't have before. I, I like being...
- 12:02Well, also the, when I'm up on stage, I mean, I want audience members to come away with something new in their brain- Mm-hmm... that challenges them.
- 12:09And like I tell people, I want something to stick in your brain that's gonna wake you up at 3:00 AM that you obsess over. [laughs] And, and if I haven't done that, then I haven't really done my job as a speaker.
- 12:17And I think the po- podcasts are the same thing, right? I'm not looking to be in an echo chamber and simply hear co- confirming information to what I already believe. Mm-hmm.
- 12:25I, I want someone who's got an edge, who's gonna bring new information, who is gonna, like, ha- have a, an aha moment that I'm gonna obsess over afterwards.
- 12:34I think that's- Yeah, challenge something that you're thinkingYeah, exactly right. So I, I think we'll, we'll, we'll be trying to do the same thing.
- 12:39Br- bringing information that maybe you haven't heard before or, or a perspective that might be new to you to just change your way of thinking. And even if you disagree with it, I think that's okay.
- 12:49Um, that, that, that can just make your, your resolutions that much stronger. But, um, that, that, that'll be the goal anyway. And, and that's what I really a- appreciate with a podcast.
- 12:57It really stretches your thinking. You know, um, spent a lot of time speaking and doing a lot of podcasts and, and I used to have these big aspirations for what I wanted to communicate in a keynote or what I...
- 13:08And, and really after thousands of episodes recorded, I'm, I'm, I've got down to if people can just remember one thing- That's right... literally one thing. And I think that, that, the perspective that you have is it.
- 13:19Like, what can I, what can I seed into your brain that you think about later? Because that's, that's where value is if- Right... that's how you remember.
- 13:26The new podcast is called, uh, Greenfield, not because it's l- your last name, but because it's a term. It's, it's opportunity.
- 13:33It's new things that we haven't uncovered yet, and it is an Automotive Ventures podcast, and it will be releasing soon. We'll talk all about it when it's out.
- 13:39But hopefully, uh, you're gonna see some about it, read about it in the newsletter in the next few years here, if Nathan can, can stop getting lazy back there and, and get, get up and do something.
- 13:48And that guy's a workhorse, so- [laughs]... if, if you don't look after him, I'm, I'm gonna take him from you. [laughs] So you better watch out. We can share. There's enough of Nathan to go around.
- 13:55Nathan, I saw you unmute for a second. You were gonna say something. Well, I was just gonna say, hopefully it's not a few years. Hopefully it's a few weeks. What did I say, years? You said years, yeah. See? Yeah.
- 14:03That's exactly right. That's why Nathan needs to be here. All right, I think we've done enough damage for today. Thank you so much for joining us on the show.
- 14:10We have people like Steve out there making this an industry people fight to join. We're gonna learn something together. Maybe Steve will plant something in your brain that wakes you up at 3:00 AM. I don't know.
- 14:18[laughs] But we'll see you tomorrow morning. [upbeat music]