Latest / The Koerner Office - Business Ideas and Deep Dives with Chris Koerner / How to Generate Big Profits from Little Email Newsletters | Ep. #165
Transcript
- 0:00These businesses are sitting on hundreds of thousands of emails.
- 0:02They're sitting on a goldmine. I think it's a huge opportunity.
- 0:05That's like mid 7 figure business just if you converted
- 0:08those emails to a daily newsletter.
- 0:09The things that interest me the most right now, these operators
- 0:12who are building newsletters on the side or smaller capacity,
- 0:16yet are bringing in more revenue than newsletters 10X their size.
- 0:20Where do you see local newsletters heading?
- 0:21Every time I logged on Twitter or X there was like 10 new local
- 0:24newsletters like popping up. We're all having a crazy
- 0:27success. Like blew my mind.
- 0:28So very bullish. Find local newsletters.
- 0:31What tips would you give people to start their first newsletter?
- 0:34Yeah, so, OK, if you ever wanted to know how to better monetize
- 0:41your e-mail list or how to better monetize someone else's
- 0:43e-mail list, if you don't have one for yourself, maybe you want
- 0:47to start a local newsletter from scratch or any newsletter for
- 0:50any topic from scratch. This is the podcast for you
- 0:53today with Tyler. We talked about local
- 0:55newsletters, interesting newsletter concepts, newsletter
- 0:57trends, how to grow a newsletter, referral program,
- 1:00how to start from scratch because most of you will be
- 1:02starting from scratch with a newsletter, how to use paid ads,
- 1:04how to use a referral program, Co registration, yadda, yadda,
- 1:08yadda. You're going to love it.
- 1:09Newsletters are super hot right now.
- 1:10They're going to be hot in 10 years.
- 1:12This isn't going anywhere. If you want to use Beehive, this
- 1:14is not a promotion. I was not paid to do this
- 1:16episode, but it would be appreciated if you used my
- 1:19affiliate link. And you'll get 20% off for your
- 1:21first three months with my link only.
- 1:23And I'll get a little kickback as well.
- 1:24You'll find that in the show notes.
- 1:26Please share with a friend and enjoy.
- 1:27I'm just so fascinated at what you're seeing from the inside.
- 1:31That seems to be really creative, unique, successful
- 1:34that people might be surprised about.
- 1:36Yeah, the things that interest me the most right now are kind
- 1:41of like against what everyone looks at in the newsletter
- 1:44ecosystem. So everyone looks at like
- 1:45Morning Brew, Axios, the scam, the hustle.
- 1:48Like scale is what they went for, and scale is awesome.
- 1:53I think having a large distribution list and influence
- 1:56to over that many people is like really interesting, but it's
- 1:59hard and it requires some money. It requires a lot of strategy.
- 2:02I've been really interested by these operators who are building
- 2:06newsletters kind of on the side or doing it in a smaller
- 2:09capacity, call it 10/15/20 thousand subscribers, yet are
- 2:13bringing in more revenue than newsletters 10X their size.
- 2:16And so like niching down on a specific customer profile and
- 2:21niching down on like the value and the ways that you can
- 2:24monetize an audience has been really interesting to see.
- 2:28And so to give you an example, I love Creator Spotlight.
- 2:31They're like, it's one of our newsletters that we send to
- 2:32400,000 people and they feature creators of like all different
- 2:36sizes and they featured 1-2 weeks ago called Design Buddies.
- 2:41It's like a design community. I think there's maybe 10 to
- 2:4315,000 people in this community. And rather than just doing paid
- 2:46subscriptions and advertisements, which they do
- 2:50advertisements, they do these design cohorts 4 * a year where
- 2:54like they already have like, you know, 15,000 people that are
- 2:57interested in design and they host these cohorts called like a
- 3:00two week cohort. And they make 6 figure revenue
- 3:03just from being able to tap into like events.
- 3:06And then they also do recruiting, right?
- 3:07So all of the companies that exist who want amazing design
- 3:10talent, like you could do job boards, you can reach out on
- 3:13social or you could just go to this newsletter community that
- 3:16has 15,000 designers that have already been vetted and they're
- 3:19like very high intent and charge a company like whoever you know,
- 3:24twenty $30,000 placement fee to find the designer for them.
- 3:28To me was like very interesting of thinking outside the box of
- 3:30how to leverage the audience that you have to extract
- 3:34revenue. He was curious how we can
- 3:36monetize this like 100,000 subscriber YouTube channel and
- 3:39like me being, Oh my God, just do throw some ads on it, maybe
- 3:41do some like branded placements like whatever.
- 3:44And someone consulted him to host like a surf school twice a
- 3:47year with like 50 people. It was like.
- 3:49In person. In person $5000 like high ticket
- 3:53item. But he knows that he has an
- 3:55audience of 100,000 subscribers who are going to him to watch
- 3:58surf content. He started printing like 250
- 4:00five, $100,000 a year off or just like hosting like these two
- 4:04surf events. So I actually think the content
- 4:06like top of funnels like IRL event, like very high ticket,
- 4:09especially cause most people who follow content kind of like you,
- 4:14you like they, they, they see your face, they hear your voice
- 4:16over and over again. Like you build that brand
- 4:17Infinity and that trust over time.
- 4:19And so like, I actually think it's easier to sell a high
- 4:22ticket item as like a trusted voice that people go to over and
- 4:25over and listening say, I don't know.
- 4:27I thought that was like super smart.
- 4:29I thought like the design cohorts was like a really
- 4:32interesting like newsletter to IRL event.
- 4:34I was like, that's really creative.
- 4:35Well, one framework I like that that reminds me of is with any
- 4:40audience, like 1% of people, and this is just a totally made-up
- 4:43number. Only 1% of people will buy your
- 4:45thing or click your ad or whatever, right?
- 4:47So on one hand, it's like, all right, you got to pick that one
- 4:50thing. You got to pick the highest and
- 4:51best use of your audience. Maybe it's a $5000 surf school,
- 4:55but on the other hand, it's like OK, if you find 100 different
- 4:58things, then theoretically everyone in your audience will
- 5:01have need for something from you.
- 5:03Maybe 1% of clicking ads, 1% are going to a surf school, 1% are
- 5:06joining a paid community, 1% are attending your events, 1% are
- 5:10renting a bathroom for their wedding.
- 5:12You know like 100 different ways to monetize and and then some.
- 5:15Or if you like really know have like a stranglehold on exactly
- 5:18who your audience is, ideally it's 100% are interested in
- 5:22anything that you're kind of interested in.
- 5:23There is like a laundry list of things.
- 5:25But like maybe it starts as a surf school, but then it's like
- 5:28going vertical, like selling surfboards.
- 5:30And then it's like, you know, other types of content.
- 5:33It all starts to having an audience.
- 5:34And I think you just have to be savvy.
- 5:36And once you have the audience, there's so many different things
- 5:38to do. I mean, if we're just going to
- 5:40use paid ads to acquire 10 to 15,000 targeted Subs, now these
- 5:44are like designers. It's not just like Facebook, but
- 5:47what are we talking like 2 to $3.00 a subscriber
- 5:49conservatively to find those subscribers?
- 5:52When I was at Morning Brew, I ran a lot of the paid
- 5:53acquisition and then I think it was much cheaper than if done
- 5:56well, you could probably get a subscriber for $0.50 to like
- 5:59$1.50. I think you still can today.
- 6:02I'm just thinking of like designers specifically.
- 6:04Yeah, I mean you can acquire probably someone who's loosely
- 6:07interested in design located in the US for call it 2 to $4.00 an
- 6:11e-mail. So 40 to $50,000 to stand up a
- 6:16list that big and we're just looking at a spreadsheet.
- 6:18There's a lot more to it. You you've got to know how to
- 6:20write, you've got to have a good personality, they've got to be
- 6:22engaging emails, you got to have some skills.
- 6:25But 40 to $50,000 to stand up a business doing 6 figures a year
- 6:29through 4 events a year and placement fees of 20 to $50,000.
- 6:34Or or you know 10 to 30% of first year salary, right?
- 6:38I mean, I'd even go one step further and say you don't even
- 6:40need the forty $50,000 to stand it up.
- 6:42So here's how this works. I make you free videos.
- 6:45I actually know what I'm talking about.
- 6:46I have no greasy sales pitch at the end.
- 6:48And if you implement what I talk about, you'll make a lot more
- 6:50money and have a better life. And all I ask for in return is
- 6:53that you hit the subscribe button and maybe even the
- 6:55notification bell just like that.
- 6:57Thank you. Typically.
- 6:58If you are going, let's use the design example.
- 7:00If you're going to create this community around designers,
- 7:02you're probably a designer yourself or already embedded
- 7:04into that community. I think that's actually where
- 7:06most people fail is when they try to take on something because
- 7:08they see an opportunity. They're not an expert in that
- 7:10space nor do they like have any business like operating, right.
- 7:13Or passion for the space. Yeah, like I should not me
- 7:16personally, Tyler Dank should not create a design community.
- 7:19I love design. I know design all the time.
- 7:22It's not like, but that's not me, right?
- 7:23Like I, that's not the communities that I, I spend time
- 7:25in. So if you already have like this
- 7:28design cohort, whether it's friends, Co workers, whatever,
- 7:31get them to subscribe to the newsletter for free.
- 7:33So you have a base of like 50 to 75 if you provide value and it
- 7:37all starts with value, right? It's creating content or
- 7:40providing value that makes them want to stick around.
- 7:43A lot of people think you can have the morning brew referral
- 7:45program and all of these different like growth tactics
- 7:47that we promote on Beehive. And just by growth hacking your
- 7:51way to scale that you're going to make it successful.
- 7:53And I think a lot of people find out the hard way that that
- 7:55doesn't work. Let's say you have good content,
- 7:57you have your base of 50 to 75 people that you know from like
- 8:00your community. If it's good content, it's very
- 8:02easy to share. And like you can ask them like,
- 8:04hey, can you share with like one person from like your design
- 8:07courses or like your prior job or whatever?
- 8:09Quickly it multiplies 100 and 5200.
- 8:11And then fortunately like leveraging some of the tools
- 8:14that we've built. So boost is one of them.
- 8:16Boost is best basically just Co registration.
- 8:18And so if I so for example, I recommend three other
- 8:23newsletters on B Hive, they each pay me $2.00 for every
- 8:26subscriber that I send them. So if I'm spending $2.00 to
- 8:29acquire an e-mail on Facebook or Instagram, they come in through
- 8:33my flow and they subscribe to one of those 3 newsletters.
- 8:36I'm break even right off the bat.
- 8:38I paid $2.00 to acquire the subscriber.
- 8:40They're now on my list forever until they unsubscribe and I got
- 8:43paid back $2.00 immediately. If they subscribe to two of
- 8:46those emails, I'm in the black $2.00.
- 8:47It's like I made money through growing, and if you can do that
- 8:50sustainably, then you put in $1000 into this growth strategy
- 8:54and if you get $2000 out, now you have a surplus to pour that
- 8:57back into growth. I think that's what a lot of
- 8:59these newsletters have found out, that you can create this
- 9:02growth flywheel where you pay to acquire subscribers, but you
- 9:07make more money on the back end, whether it's from boosts or ads
- 9:10or paid subscriptions. And once you're in the black,
- 9:12you just keep reinvesting it and very quickly can get the 1015
- 9:16thousand subscribers. I kicked myself to this day for
- 9:19waiting so long to to boost to do Co registration because I had
- 9:23this limiting mindset of like, I don't want to compete.
- 9:25I don't want to give my competitors all these
- 9:27subscribers. Then they're going to be
- 9:28distracted. Instead of getting one e-mail
- 9:30from me, they're going to get 3. And so we were talking about
- 9:33segments before I hit record, I started the segment from before
- 9:36and after the time I boosted and I noticed no increase in like
- 9:40open rate or click through rate like it just it just grew the
- 9:43pie. I just started getting free
- 9:44money essentially right and it offsets your paid acquisition
- 9:48cost or if they're organic subscribers then you're it's
- 9:51just a net profit. And Boost really came out of my
- 9:54experience that Morning Brew realizing that I was spending
- 9:57$600,000 a month acquiring subscribers from Google,
- 10:01YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, Snapback, and anything, anywhere
- 10:04we can spend money. We were testing.
- 10:06Does that turn into acquiring subscribers at a reasonable cost
- 10:09and are they quality subscribers?
- 10:11That's the other classic mistake that I think a lot of growth
- 10:13marketers and definitely like if you're a newsletter operator who
- 10:16doesn't come from a growth background, you can look at a
- 10:19very shitty acquisition source online that may maybe get you
- 10:22subscribers for $0.10 and then you do Facebook and it's $2.50.
- 10:28And so you'd say like, oh, well, it's obvious to invest in the 10
- 10:30cent one because it's, you know, considerably cheaper than trying
- 10:35to avoid doing that. That's why I should have chosen
- 10:37the easier numbers. But yeah, it's considerably
- 10:38cheaper, right. But what you don't realize is if
- 10:41the subscribers you acquired for $0.10, they open one in 20
- 10:44emails, but the subscribers from Facebook opened one and two
- 10:47emails, then you're actually you have to normalize it and get the
- 10:50more active subscriber. And that was something that took
- 10:53me like 6 months to learn at Morning Brew that not all
- 10:55subscribers were created equal. And the actual acquisition cost
- 10:58is really just the top of the funnel.
- 11:00You need to normalize it for opens.
- 11:02I created a segment, I, I ran Facebook ads for a month like
- 11:06religiously and I tracked everything in segments and UTM
- 11:09parameters. And then I created a segment for
- 11:11the same time period of all the organic subscribers I got.
- 11:14And that's been like 3 months now.
- 11:16And I've gone back and looked at that segment every week or two.
- 11:19And my paid subscribers actually open and click more than my
- 11:22organic ones, which is beautiful.
- 11:24Like that's perfect because I can pull, I can control that
- 11:27lever and I can dial up or down the ad spend as I want.
- 11:30That's why I mentioned like, you know, stand up a newsletter for
- 11:3250 grand just because it's nice to be able to know that like you
- 11:36can kind of find cheat codes or shortcuts where like really the
- 11:39long term sustainable thing, like you said, is to have
- 11:42something you're passionate about, something you're
- 11:43knowledgeable, knowledgeable about, lead with value and then
- 11:47kind of figure out the monetization leverage later or
- 11:49paid ads later. Yeah, I actually remember what I
- 11:51was going to say now, but, but what I was going to say was I
- 11:54started off by saying how we were spending five, $600,000 a
- 11:57month on paid acquisition and that we normalized or whatever.
- 12:01But then after like testing Facebook, Instagram, whatever,
- 12:04whatever, you realize that the subscribers who are the most
- 12:07engaged were just subscribers from other e-mail newsletters.
- 12:10Which makes perfect sense, right?
- 12:12If someone is opening. Their habits.
- 12:13Is actively opening their e-mail and already subscribed to other
- 12:17newsletters and they're going to click on a link in another
- 12:19newsletter to subscribe to an additional newsletter.
- 12:22Think those are your people, right?
- 12:23And so we started advertising in like the points guy and all of
- 12:28these different newsletters and that was always our highest
- 12:30quality acquisition source. So we built Beehive.
- 12:33We always knew from day one that we're going to build some sort
- 12:36of network effect of how do you promote and grow the the other
- 12:41newsletters in the ecosystem knowing that those were the
- 12:43highest quality of readers. And certainly, Long story short,
- 12:46that's how the recommendations and Boost feature came to be.
- 12:50I think that's just a great framework for business.
- 12:52Like if you want to grow a podcast, the best way to do it
- 12:55is to appear on other podcasts. Because you're appearing in
- 12:57front of people that already have a podcast in their daily
- 13:00habits, there's much less friction.
- 13:02You're not going to convince someone to start listening to
- 13:04podcast with your podcast. I think the principle applies in
- 13:07newsletters or really anything. You just remove the friction.
- 13:10I'd also say the principle of being open minded and testing
- 13:13absolutely everything is the best way to grow and like
- 13:17experiment, right? So I think going in the low
- 13:19hanging fruit is, hey, I have $1000 to spend on acquisition.
- 13:22I'm just going to use Twitter and Google because that's what I
- 13:25know best. At Morning Brew, we we sponsored
- 13:28the the New York City Wi-Fi in subway stations and it worked
- 13:32terribly. But like we were, we had the
- 13:34mechanisms to be able to track and we were able to say yes to
- 13:38any sort of acquisition source knowing that on the back end
- 13:41we'd be able to track how quality it was and if it was
- 13:43good, we double down. But you never know what you're
- 13:45missing out on. And there's so many different
- 13:47ways to acquire readers or customers regardless of what
- 13:50your business is. So yeah, I think being open to
- 13:52experimentation is extremely important.
- 13:54I probably say that once a month on this podcast.
- 13:56Test everything except drugs. I completely agree.
- 13:59Like right now I have a billboard in Tomball, TX for my
- 14:03podcast. There's no QR code, there's no
- 14:05domain name. It's not a thing.
- 14:07People don't do it. But I, I got to know.
- 14:09I have to know. And I found, you know,
- 14:11workarounds to track it. But like testing a different
- 14:15marketing concept with a different industry, like cross
- 14:17testing all those things is just like by crack.
- 14:20I just love it so much. We tested the back of Ubers
- 14:23where they have the little like iPad screen they can like play
- 14:26the different games on if you like, I forgot the name of the
- 14:28company, but it'll like shuffle through like games and like news
- 14:31or whatever. And like every, every five
- 14:34slides you would see a morning brew ad.
- 14:36And like we tried that and actually worked pretty well.
- 14:39I think that being open to experimentation, there's like a
- 14:41lot of alpha there. And then the other classic thing
- 14:43for anyone who's done like brand, not a brand marketing,
- 14:46but like performance marketing is like as soon as they launch a
- 14:49new channel and there is less competition, it's a gold mine if
- 14:53you're early to adopt. So Facebook launched Facebook
- 14:56stories and no one even I like, I've never used a Facebook story
- 14:59and like the normal person, I don't know what normal is
- 15:02considered, but most people be like, hey, I don't even use
- 15:04Facebook or I don't use Facebook stories.
- 15:06I don't think that's going to be successful.
- 15:07But if everyone thinks that there's no competition.
- 15:09So if you're the first one to adopt Facebook stories, then
- 15:12your CPMS are so low that you get crazy high conversion.
- 15:15There's no competition, You're not paying a ton of money.
- 15:18And I think we printed subscribers for like 30-40 cents
- 15:21for a month or two before it adopt more brands adopted that.
- 15:26So being early to a platform works really well.
- 15:29Yeah, it's funny you say that. This is kind of a random side
- 15:31note, but I had lunch with this guy who manages multiple
- 15:34Instagram accounts of million millions of followers.
- 15:37And when Instagram stories first came out, he learned that if he
- 15:40pushed like a paid Instagram story to an account just to get
- 15:44more subscribers, he could acquire subscribers for like 3
- 15:47to 6 cents. Not subscribers, Instagram
- 15:49followers. He would push a story with an
- 15:51affiliate link and that story would earn on average like 20 to
- 15:55$0.30 per subscriber. And he was one of the biggest
- 15:59spenders of Instagram Story ads in the world, so much that Mehta
- 16:03was reaching out and saying, like, why are you spending so
- 16:05much on Instagram Stories? Like, what are you doing?
- 16:08And it, you know, the window closed, it always does.
- 16:11But while it was open, he just, he just printed money.
- 16:14Yeah, there's, there's opportunity everywhere, right?
- 16:17Yeah, but you got to be testing. So 99% of people listening to
- 16:21this have no newsletter and I would say most of them are, are
- 16:24like newsletter curious cause 30% of this podcast are business
- 16:28owners, 70% are aspiring business owners.
- 16:31So we kind of started talking about that 10 minutes ago.
- 16:34How to start your first newsletter?
- 16:36Get your first 5075 friends, have them share it.
- 16:39What other tips would you give people to start their first
- 16:43newsletter? When you ask like what do I see
- 16:45that is interesting in the newsletter space right now?
- 16:47The one that my initial answer was people who have figured out
- 16:50a way to monetize a smaller audience but have outside upside
- 16:54in terms of outsized upside in terms of like the revenue that
- 16:57they can extract from that audience.
- 16:59The other thing that I think is really interesting is the way
- 17:01that business, like certain businesses have adopted e-mail
- 17:05newsletters and like a content forward strategy for growth.
- 17:09And the way that I describe that as like Breck's, for example,
- 17:13the, the business credit card for startups has a community
- 17:16newsletter on BI that promotes the different community events
- 17:19that they host in New York, LA, San Francisco.
- 17:22But what it is not, which I think a lot of business owners
- 17:25can't wrap their head around, is it's not, hey, we have credit
- 17:28cards. Here's an amazing deal.
- 17:30Click here to sign up and open up an account with us.
- 17:32I think the way that most business owners think about
- 17:35e-mail is here's a list of 100,000, either existing
- 17:39customers, past customers, past orders, whatever it is, this
- 17:43database of 100,000 emails. And we sell T-shirts and today
- 17:47we're going to do a 5% off or 10% off.
- 17:49And I'm going to send an e-mail to all 100,000 people about this
- 17:5210% off promotion with the hope that 2000 people click another
- 17:56500 purchase T-shirt or two. And by hitting send, I just made
- 18:00$10,000 in sales. So video is cool, but you know
- 18:03what's better? Long form audio via podcast and
- 18:06my newsletter, TKO pod.com. Go there to subscribe for free
- 18:10to my newsletter. It's one e-mail a week, very
- 18:12tactical. And then go to my audio podcast,
- 18:143 episodes a week. Stuff like this.
- 18:16You're going to love it all free, no sleazy sales bitch.
- 18:18TKO pod.com. And so I think that's like
- 18:21traditional e-commerce and that works, right.
- 18:23Like I think like the the old adage for e-commerce is like the
- 18:26easiest way to make money is just send another e-mail because
- 18:28that you're sending to a large enough amount of people, you
- 18:30will get conversions. What I think the savvier brands
- 18:33are doing now is building a full content strategy where there's a
- 18:37bit more of a long tail and the goal isn't for conversion today.
- 18:41It is nurturing these customers and these leads to think higher
- 18:44about, think more highly about you as the brand, the value that
- 18:49you provide and more just like general likeness.
- 18:52And so we do that at BII. I'd even say like my personal
- 18:55newsletter, Big Desk energy in a way, is that like we, we send
- 18:59tons of emails as a business that is not about signing up or
- 19:03upgrading to our account. It is we know who our target
- 19:06audience is, whether it's publishers, content creators,
- 19:09small businesses, whatever. Let's create content that they
- 19:12would find valuable irregardless of it.
- 19:14It has nothing to do with BI. We just think it's valuable to
- 19:17them and it's coming from our house account or me.
- 19:21And by doing that, they look forward and they build this
- 19:23habit of opening our emails. They trust us as like a fault
- 19:27leader in this e-mail content creation space.
- 19:30And when it does come time for a purchase decision against us,
- 19:34who has been providing them constant content, constant value
- 19:37and educating them and helping them in whatever way we can via
- 19:40content and this other brand that they've either never seen,
- 19:43never received content for, or every time that they engage with
- 19:46them, it's just like a hard sale.
- 19:47It's easier to have more allegiance to the brand that's
- 19:50provided you more value. So it's like a, it's pausing
- 19:53like the, the instant gratification of like needing
- 19:56sales today with like, let's nurture these customers through
- 19:59content that they'd find valuable.
- 20:00And I think that I've seen that through a handful of brands and
- 20:02it works extremely well. It's kind of like SEO, like SEO
- 20:06works so well because so few people focus on it because they
- 20:09don't, they don't focus on it because it takes months to pay
- 20:12off, right? And what you're describing to me
- 20:14is like brand building. I picture like Yeti and Red Bull
- 20:17doing this perfectly. Like I'll go to YouTube and
- 20:19watch Yeti videos about saltwater fishing and they don't
- 20:22mention Yeti once. I can just see the cooler in the
- 20:24background. But I kind of like Yeti now
- 20:27because I like that video and Red Bull's the same way.
- 20:29And both of those companies have amazing high trust, high Net
- 20:33Promoter score brands primarily driven by this content that they
- 20:37put out. And So what you're saying is
- 20:39like, it's almost like taking a transactional business and
- 20:43saying, hey, we're now kind of like an influencer.
- 20:46Like we're, we're almost like an individual influencer that has
- 20:49high affinity and high trust with an audience.
- 20:52We're taking a long term approach.
- 20:53We're never going to be able to attribute these dollars to these
- 20:57dollars, these dollars going out to these dollars coming in.
- 20:59But we just believe and trust that it's going to do good
- 21:01things for us and we're going to play the long game right.
- 21:04Yeah. I mean, I'd even say it's not
- 21:05mutually exclusive, right? Like you can play the long game
- 21:08and nurture these customers and provide value while also sending
- 21:11a once a week like more direct transactional e-mail of like
- 21:14here's a new product, here's the sale we're doing, here's
- 21:16something that you should buy. But I think so the, the reason I
- 21:19brought that up to answer your question is you said that 30% of
- 21:23your audience is like business owners.
- 21:25And I'd be curious how many of those 30% actually have like a
- 21:27content strategy beyond just aggressively posting and
- 21:31promoting their products, their promotions versus how many think
- 21:35of content from like a first principle of like, if we, Sir,
- 21:38if we sell outdoor gear, like what, what is content that is,
- 21:42is it the top trails in America? And like every week we do, we
- 21:46share different trails, different hiking, different
- 21:48campground reviews of different types of whatever it is.
- 21:51Like I think there's like a a whole content strategy that can
- 21:54be deployed for nearly any business.
- 21:56And it doesn't take that much thought.
- 21:59I think it takes like a brainstorming session for like
- 22:0130 minutes to kind of figure out like what would your customers
- 22:03actually want more of and if you can be a leader in that space.
- 22:06I mean, we do it for Creator Spotlight.
- 22:08Creator Spotlight started as when we are just starting off,
- 22:12we had so few users and we were like trying to educate other
- 22:16people of like why they should use the platform and also like
- 22:19uplift those users that are having success in our platform
- 22:22by putting them in a spotlight. So I would choose a user like
- 22:25more or less at random every week we would do a whole like
- 22:27write up on them and we'd send it to all of our customers being
- 22:30like, look at this user who's having success, they're using
- 22:33these 5 features, they're making this much revenue.
- 22:35This is how quickly that they're growing and it was valuable to
- 22:39the rest of our customers because they like they could see
- 22:41and get inspiration from this other user who is having success
- 22:45in the platform. And now it's just it's own
- 22:48vertical of the business. We don't even promote Beehive at
- 22:50all. We've even gone beyond choosing
- 22:53Beehive customers as the people that we promote.
- 22:55We promote Youtubers, influencers, content creators,
- 22:59publishers, like I said, the design person that I mentioned
- 23:02at the beginning of the podcast for the sole purpose of we know
- 23:05that our customers want to get inspiration and learn from other
- 23:10people in the space who are having success.
- 23:13And where I used to think the only way to monetize an e-mail
- 23:15was with ads or paid subscriptions and reading
- 23:19Creative Spotlight, I found twenty other ways that these
- 23:21creators and publishers are finding ways to extract revenue
- 23:24from their audience. So it's helped me even think
- 23:26about the landscape. And so that's just another way
- 23:29of like using content as a way to nurture leads and eventually
- 23:32drive sales. Where do you see local
- 23:34newsletters heading? Do you do you think that's a big
- 23:36opportunity? I'm.
- 23:37Not going to say we went all in on it, but we hosted this day
- 23:40long webinar about a month ago and then we also launched the
- 23:43local newsletter accelerator program at Beehive.
- 23:46So I think applications are still open depending on when
- 23:48this goes live. That's like a natural trend that
- 23:51we saw where I'd say December, January of this year, every time
- 23:55I logged on Twitter or X, there was like 10 new local
- 23:58newsletters like popping up. Like in my face.
- 24:00We were all having the crazy success.
- 24:02They're like just partnered with five local brands already sold
- 24:04out all the inventory for Q1 or went from 100 of my friends
- 24:09signing up to like 5000 people in the community and like 1/4.
- 24:13And it blew my mind the the success that a lot of these
- 24:15local newsletters were having. So long term, to answer your
- 24:19question, very bullish on local newsletters.
- 24:22And I think it makes perfect sense.
- 24:24I'm subscribed to probably two or three different newsletters
- 24:26in Los Angeles that are just like top restaurants that this
- 24:30person has tried recently, different events that are
- 24:32happening this week. It's just like a a guide of like
- 24:35what's happening in the community.
- 24:37I think there's a lot of different flavors of local
- 24:39newsletter. For me, it's more consumer in
- 24:41terms of like restaurants and events.
- 24:43So it's like activity based and like the experiences.
- 24:46Others are more like news related of what's happening in
- 24:50local politics, what what's going on in like the community.
- 24:54Are there any, I don't know other other things that are are
- 24:56going on, but like hyper focus on a specific geographical
- 24:59location. And then I think the business
- 25:01opportunity there is every community has tons of small
- 25:04businesses that are looking for customers.
- 25:06And the hardest part about monetizing like a very large
- 25:08newsletter is as great as e-mail is, it is difficult to
- 25:12understand exactly who these people are.
- 25:14And you can do surveys, you can try to hydrate the data and be
- 25:17like, I just screwed this this many emails And they are, you
- 25:21know, opening from the Northeast of the United States.
- 25:23But like you have to work really hard to understand and like
- 25:26beehives building a lot of things to help make this easier.
- 25:28But to understand, like, what are their true interests?
- 25:31Is it a 25 year old female who lives in the Northeast or are
- 25:34they a 50 year old male who lives on the West Coast?
- 25:37And you can't really get that from the e-mail itself.
- 25:40And so it's harder to be able to figure out like if you are going
- 25:42to monetize with ads, who's the right advertiser to serve this
- 25:45audience. Whereas if you are building a
- 25:48newsletter for Annapolis, MD, then the only people who are
- 25:52most likely to subscribe to that newsletter are people who live
- 25:55in Annapolis or near Annapolis. Which means any small business
- 25:58in Annapolis would be interested in sponsoring this newsletter
- 26:02because they know they're getting in front of 5010
- 26:03thousand 15,000 local residents who could be a customer.
- 26:07And so it makes the monetization angle great.
- 26:10Also think like it probably feels pretty good to support
- 26:12small local businesses. So I think a lot of them are
- 26:15having a ton of success. And then I think one of the big
- 26:18asymmetric bets is you can acquire subscribers for local
- 26:21newsletters at like half or a third of the cost of any other
- 26:25newsletter. Like if I go look for business
- 26:27subscribers on Facebook ads, I'm going to spend about $1.50.
- 26:30But if I go look for Plano, TX residents for my Plano, TX
- 26:35newsletter, it's going to be about $0.50.
- 26:37But then conversely, the CPMS, the amount of money I can charge
- 26:40for those ads is like twice because it's so targeted.
- 26:44So your cost to acquire is 1/3 or half of what another
- 26:47newsletter would be. And the amount you can charge
- 26:49per viewer is significantly more.
- 26:51And then like if you look at oversaturation, it's not going
- 26:55to happen. There's 100,000 cities in
- 26:56America. There's hundreds of thousands of
- 26:59neighborhoods, like their neighborhoods with 20,000 people
- 27:01in them. You can get even more hyperlocal
- 27:03than just a city. And with Ryan and Nap Town Scoop
- 27:06in in Annapolis, he's got more subscribers than people live in
- 27:11Annapolis because you have people that like used to live
- 27:13there or tangential to it. And then he launched a business
- 27:17freaking renting out bathrooms vertically integrated, you know,
- 27:21like, who would have thought? So I think 10 years from now
- 27:25local newsletters are going to be a big opportunity.
- 27:27Yeah. I mean, Even so now like my
- 27:29growth years are turning a bit in terms of like how all the
- 27:32growth hacks you could do to try to scale in like a single
- 27:35geographical location, you could do direct mail.
- 27:37I would like it's so first of all, I'm a huge fan of direct
- 27:40mail. We haven't had an amazing use
- 27:42case for using it at B Hive yet. But like the physical direct
- 27:45mail I think works super well and like a hyper for us.
- 27:48It's like, where would you even send that for BIV?
- 27:50And then we could choose different locales, right?
- 27:52But if you have an Annapolis newsletter, it might cost $5000
- 27:56to send like a highly targeted postcard for your Annapolis
- 28:00newsletter to every household within like these 5 zip codes,
- 28:03right? You could also go to five of the
- 28:06most popular pizza places, give them like a bunch of cards to
- 28:09hand out and be like, if you can get people to sign up for my new
- 28:11like your customers come in and if you can give them this, I'll
- 28:14add you to the newsletter at the bottom of like, here's the top
- 28:17pizza places. And like just do like affiliate
- 28:19deals where like you're actually not even picking in revenue, but
- 28:21you're using it for customer acquisition.
- 28:23Out of the fact that I could drive to any local establishment
- 28:26and find a way or a partnership for them to help me grow.
- 28:29So as they grow their business and bring in more and more
- 28:31customers, they can also Dr. new subscribers to me think that's
- 28:35super interesting. I think local news is like a
- 28:37massive thing. And like there's probably like a
- 28:38broader shift in terms of like lack of trust in like the larger
- 28:43media companies and even in local news, right?
- 28:47I just think like the established media is going
- 28:49through a period where there's a lot of distrust from like the
- 28:52general public. And I don't know if trusting
- 28:55someone you a newsletter on the Internet that you met for the
- 28:57first time, it was like more trust.
- 28:58But it seemingly it it does seem that way.
- 29:00Yeah. I think there's a ton of
- 29:01opportunity there. What other newsletter trends are
- 29:04you seeing that people should be looking out for, whether it's
- 29:07like the type of newsletter or how people grow their
- 29:09newsletter? Is it weekly or daily, the
- 29:12length of the newsletter? Like what are kind of some best
- 29:15practices that you have in mind? Yeah, I'm seeing more like
- 29:18design for emails, which I've been saying forever in the sense
- 29:22that most emails look terrible. Like no one puts time into
- 29:25making them look good. I think there's like real alpha
- 29:27and like spending the hour or two to have your newsletter
- 29:30template totally jump out of the inbox and be something that
- 29:33people actually remember weekly versus daily versus monthly.
- 29:37Kind of depends on like who you're serving, like what the
- 29:39the value prop is and the different content you're
- 29:41creating. So it's like hard to see like a
- 29:43ton of different trends around that about length depends right
- 29:47Again to like your value prop. So if your value prop is I'm
- 29:51going to distribute information and as bite sized as possible
- 29:56because it is utility for the readers and like maybe shorter
- 30:00is better. We're seeing like a lot of
- 30:02independent journalists leave traditional media, launch
- 30:05newsletters on beehive and like do like investigative
- 30:08journalism, I think is really interesting.
- 30:10It's like full scoops like New York Times S but longer type
- 30:14newsletters that are just like deep dives and like any given
- 30:17topic. I think creativity is like all
- 30:20over the place in the newsletter spot.
- 30:21So there's like newsletters that use images and GIFs.
- 30:24So I tell a story. I'm blanking on the name and now
- 30:27I feel bad because I would love to give them a shout out, but
- 30:29it's every day they explain a different topic all through
- 30:34images and sorts of cartoon draw of images to tell a story and
- 30:38educate someone like how something works in the world.
- 30:41Emails like pretty flexible, right?
- 30:42It could be, it could be a short, it could be alerts like
- 30:45real time news happening. It could be deep dives, it could
- 30:48be cartoons, it could be super well designed or plain text.
- 30:52Like there's a lot of different things you can do with it.
- 30:54The biggest trend that I've seen this is local.
- 30:56Outside of that, I think like everyone's going in every which
- 30:59direction in terms of like cadence, length and acquisition
- 31:02strategies. Have you ever seen someone take
- 31:04like a corporate e-mail list? Like I'll just use one of my
- 31:07companies as an example, Texas Snacks, we sell Texas Snacks and
- 31:12it's a Shopify store. We have about 150,000 emails and
- 31:17we're just doing the basic. We're just sending out deals and
- 31:19promotions and yadda yadda. Is there a world where you could
- 31:22take that and convert it into like a daily newsletter with a
- 31:25tangential topic like, you know, trends happening in the South or
- 31:29in Texas or Texas, food recipes or whatever, and treat that as a
- 31:33separate business entirely? And literally, like, you can put
- 31:36your own ads in there. You can sell sponsorships in
- 31:38there. Because I look at newsletters
- 31:41and you might cringe at this, but like I'll take the amount of
- 31:44subscribers, cut it in half and say if this is a daily
- 31:48newsletter, if I have 100,000 subscribers, I can make $50,000
- 31:51a month top line. I like a, a good CPM, like in a
- 31:54business niche. So if I look at, you know, my
- 31:57Texas snacks list, it's like 150,000 subscribers at a decent
- 32:01CPM that could be $60,000 a month business as a stand alone
- 32:06in addition to the promotional emails we're sending.
- 32:08Is there a world where that could be another business or, or
- 32:10you could build an agency going into companies and saying, hey,
- 32:13give me your e-mail list. I'm going to turn this into a
- 32:15new revenue line for you guys. Yeah.
- 32:18I mean, what you just said sounds super smart, right?
- 32:20Like I think that's like what every company should be doing is
- 32:22like looking at their assets in terms of what they view an asset
- 32:25now is like an e-mail list or database of emails that they
- 32:28send the promotions and whatever else to.
- 32:32So like can we actually build media around this?
- 32:34If you're asking me if do I think there's a business of
- 32:36like, I think there's a huge opportunity for agencies or even
- 32:40an individual, right. You're a high agency individual
- 32:43who either loves writing, has a network of writers or knows how
- 32:47to use AI tools in a way that actually makes good content.
- 32:50On the other side of it than to be able to go to a business
- 32:53that, you know, has a large database of emails and say,
- 32:55like, I can create a net new revenue stream for you that also
- 32:58has like, it'll bring in money day one because we can monetize
- 33:01with ads or we could do affiliates.
- 33:04So like it's a, it's net new revenue off the bat, but also
- 33:07should improve the NPS and you know, just like the the goodwill
- 33:13of your core business in parallel.
- 33:16So kind of like what we discussed earlier, I think
- 33:17there's a huge opportunity for for someone to do that.
- 33:20I see it as like two different strategies.
- 33:21You can go the Yeti route and just say we're not going to put
- 33:24ads in this. This is just our content
- 33:26strategy. We're playing the long game.
- 33:27And then you could say we want to have our cake and eat it too.
- 33:30We want to play the long game, but we also want to directly
- 33:32attribute this new revenue. I don't see a lot of people
- 33:35doing that, but I think that could be an interesting
- 33:36opportunity. And some of these businesses
- 33:38have massive databases of emails, right?
- 33:41So there's so many of these, like, smaller newsletter
- 33:44operators who are scrapping by to get like, 10 new subscribers
- 33:47a day and, like, thrilled at the fact that they grew by 100
- 33:50subscribers in a week. Where these businesses are
- 33:52sitting on hundreds of thousands of emails that, you know,
- 33:55they've been in business for, call it a decade.
- 33:57And every customer that's ever checked out on their website,
- 33:59they save their e-mail and they like, Will Remarket here and
- 34:02there. But they're sitting on a
- 34:04goldmine. Yeah, I think, I think it's a
- 34:05huge opportunity. This is fresh on my mind.
- 34:08I had a zoom a couple hours ago with a guy that's buying a
- 34:10company out of bankruptcy. They have a million not emails,
- 34:14but a million active emails and he's buying the company for like
- 34:17a half $1,000,000 and they sell physical goods that you're going
- 34:22to do an e-commerce play and all that.
- 34:24I had this conversation with him.
- 34:25I'm like dude, that's that's like a mid 7 figure business.
- 34:29Just if you converted those emails to a daily newsletter,
- 34:31you'd have to sell the ads. In my experience, that's the
- 34:33hardest part, is just filling the ad space, assuming you were
- 34:36doing a traditional monetization route.
- 34:38But he hadn't even thought of that.
- 34:40He's like, oh man, I could monetize the emails.
- 34:42I thought I was just going to send promotions to them, but I
- 34:45think there's something there. I think I might have to look at
- 34:48all these bankruptcy filings and see if there's any alpha there,
- 34:51maybe there's some like huge companies with like very asset
- 34:54light, so low cost bankruptcy and I just want the e-mail list.
- 34:58Yeah, that could be really interesting.
- 35:00Last question, this one's kind of selfish.
- 35:02I want to know personally what is the 8020 of just a killer
- 35:06referral program because from what I understand the Milk Rd.
- 35:09crushed on referrals, but they seem kind of like an outlier to
- 35:12me. It's referral programs hard.
- 35:14I'm guessing like she's got to have a ton of value.
- 35:17Like whatever you give away for free for one or five.
- 35:19It just has to be really, really good.
- 35:21Is there more to it than that? So from the Morning Brew
- 35:25experience, what we leaned into is like pure fandom, Like
- 35:28Morning Brew built like this cult following of people who
- 35:31like built it into their routine and their habit to wake up every
- 35:34morning and read the newsletter. And we had the mug logo, we had
- 35:37the conversational tone. It was super relatable.
- 35:40You've read it and felt like you were receiving news from like
- 35:42your best friend and through that entire like brand building
- 35:45exercise when we created a more complex referral program.
- 35:49So there was like seven rewards, call it.
- 35:52It was like a bug AT shirt, a hat, a backpack, additional
- 35:55content like people were bought in because of the fandom.
- 36:00So that's like one thing that's like again, going back to like
- 36:02brand building and playing like a long long term game.
- 36:05Like we leaned into that milk Rd's a great example.
- 36:07I actually do think that is the 8020 rule is like far too often
- 36:11people either looked at the money brew example or get way
- 36:14too greedy and thinking like, oh, if I can get my own readers
- 36:17just to refer more readers, then like I should incentivize them
- 36:20to get like 10 people. And so you have like this big
- 36:22reward at like 5 referrals or 10 referrals.
- 36:26Most people aren't going to do that.
- 36:27And we even saw that a morning drill.
- 36:29But one referral is so easy because the barrier is so low
- 36:32that you can copy a link and send it to your best friend or
- 36:34your mom or the person sitting next to you.
- 36:36And you get that instant gratification of like whatever
- 36:38reward is that one referral. So what Milk Rd. did was Milk
- 36:42Rd. covers crypto news. They spoke to 15 crypto experts.
- 36:48They wrote like a one page. They spent a day and wrote like
- 36:50a really great one pager of saying, if you refer just one
- 36:53person, we'll give you the advice or the the projections of
- 36:57what's going to happen in the crypto market according to these
- 36:5915 experts. And the very of entry was so low
- 37:02at just one referral. And like the other kicker is it
- 37:04was totally free. They spent a day creating that
- 37:07asset, but they're not going to like USPS and like shipping
- 37:11stickers and every Friday they're just they set it up on
- 37:15BI. It's fully automated and as soon
- 37:17as someone got their first referral, it sent an e-mail.
- 37:20I think that was it. So it took time in creating the
- 37:22asset, but $0.00 after that and the barriers were so low, they
- 37:26just needed people to share 1 referral.
- 37:28So I kind of think that is the 8020 rule.
- 37:30It's like what is enticing enough to incentivize someone to
- 37:34share with just one person? And if you can do that, like
- 37:37that's the hardest part is 0 to one, one to two, one to five,
- 37:40whatever is easier because they've already done the
- 37:43behavior and you can continue to push them further.
- 37:47Yeah, and all of that is amplified if you if it's just a
- 37:49freaking great newsletter and they feel proud referring it and
- 37:52they're fans and like the Morning Brew, right?
- 37:53Like they just felt bought into it.
- 37:56It's all quality, right? Like I could sit here for an
- 37:58hour and give all of the growth tactics that we use that morning
- 38:00brew or that I use for my newsletter or what I've seen on
- 38:02the platform. You can't growth hack your way
- 38:05into success there. It has to come from like the
- 38:08nucleus actually being quality. And so that's why I'd recommend
- 38:11people spend the most of their time.
- 38:13OK, well, Tyler, this was perfect.
- 38:16We know where to find your your company.
- 38:17I'll have links everywhere, but where can we find you?
- 38:20I'll plug the newsletter. The newsletter is my number, my
- 38:22number one thing that I'm focused on right now.
- 38:24So mail.bigdeskenergy.com, maybe drop that in the description
- 38:29below. But it's a weekly newsletter for
- 38:32anyone who's interested in startups, entrepreneurship.
- 38:35It's really just me sharing the journey of building the company.
- 38:38A lot of transparent insights. That's a great newsletter.
- 38:41I'm a subscriber myself. And what about your Spotify
- 38:43playlist, man? I mean, come on, you got a
- 38:45Spotify playlist? I assume once they get into the
- 38:48funnel they'll see the Spotify playlist but yes it is it Big
- 38:50desk energy. Big desk.
- 38:52I got it up in front of me as I do a hell of times of the day.
- 38:55But yes, Big Desk Energy is also Spotify playlist with the best
- 38:58music to help you focus. But you're not making much money
- 39:01off that one though. I'm the only person dumb enough
- 39:03to build a newsletter off of a Spotify playlist, which I don't
- 39:07make money off of, but that's what makes me unique I guess.
- 39:11Hey Nap Town Scoop built the, you know, bathroom rental
- 39:14business off their newsletters. There are no rules I.
- 39:16Didn't I didn't ask you about that, but I was going to be
- 39:17like, what the hell. I I this is the first I've heard
- 39:19of that so. Did you not know that?
- 39:20Yeah. No can can.
- 39:21Can you share more of what? What does that mean?
- 39:24I tweeted about luxury bathroom rental as a business like 2
- 39:27years ago. It got 1,000,000 views.
- 39:29He read it and he's like that's amazing.
- 39:31I think that would work. I think I could find events and
- 39:34people to rent these out through my newsletter.
- 39:36And so he hopped on my podcast and we talked about it publicly
- 39:40and then he bought a $20,000 like trailer bathroom and
- 39:44started renting him out at weddings and he got almost all
- 39:46of his bookings from his newsletter.
- 39:49Like of all things. That's.
- 39:51He wouldn't have had a successful real world physical,
- 39:54sweaty startup if it weren't for his newsletter.
- 39:57All right, this is the first I've heard of that.
- 39:58But yeah, I've, I've never of, of all the interesting ways that
- 40:01I've seen people parlay A newsletter into something, the
- 40:04newsletter to bathroom rental is brand new to me and and really
- 40:07awesome. It's quite the pivot.
- 40:10Oh yeah, well, thanks for having me.
- 40:12Yeah, man, thank you. All right, don't forget to come
- 40:14back for my episode all about local newsletters and luxury
- 40:18trailer bathroom event rental business.
- 40:20And don't forget to use my Beehive affiliate link for a
- 40:22discount in the show notes. Thanks again.
- 40:24And we'll see you next time on the Kerner Office.