Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Unpacking Tragedy and Justice: Manslaughter Sentencing & Wrongful Dismissal Insights
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for Legally Speaking, joined as always by barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defence Lawyers, Michael Mulligan.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Morning, michael.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Hey, good morning, I'm doing great.
- 0:09Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Some fascinating stories on the agenda today, including a sentencing with respect to a random stranger attack.
- 0:16Adam Stirling: What can you tell us?
- 0:18Michael Mulligan: Well, a few things about it.
- 0:19Michael Mulligan: First of all, we can all feel, I guess, a sense of camaraderie when Victoria is not the only place dealing with these issues, that they extend to smaller communities in British Columbia.
- 0:33Michael Mulligan: This particular tragic case is from Trail BC, so a small community in the southeast, and the fact pattern is a terrible one.
- 0:49Michael Mulligan: The accused in this case and it's a sentencing decision, I should say, for a manslaughter conviction.
- 0:52Michael Mulligan: So it's a random, stranger attack that led to a death.
- 0:55Michael Mulligan: And the man who died was described as a 78-year-old man in ill health who was quietly living his life, battling against physical and mental disabilities, who was crossing the road when he was attacked by a 25-year-old man, indigenous man, who the judge described as having to that point quote as having essentially led a wasted life close quote to that date as a result of mental illness aggravated by chronic drug abuse and had a history of violent outbursts flowing from those things.
- 1:34Michael Mulligan: And the background of it was that that young man, the 25-year-old, had suffered from a number of things which we'll get to in a moment, but on that particular morning, as a result of mental illness and drug use, he was suffering from auditory delusions.
- 1:56Michael Mulligan: He went to his father's home.
- 1:58Michael Mulligan: He knew the father wasn't home and lit it ablaze, burning it down.
- 2:00Michael Mulligan: He left the father wasn't home and lit it ablaze, burning it down.
- 2:03Michael Mulligan: He left the house.
- 2:05Michael Mulligan: He then wandered through the town across a crosswalk and he at that point heard voices in his head and the judge accepted this to be so telling him that this random 78-year-old man had sexually exploited his daughter, which was untrue, completely delusional, and the 25-year-old mentally ill, drug-addicted man brutally attacked the 78-year-old and eventually stomped on him and kicked him.
- 2:36Michael Mulligan: He was wearing heavy boots and a month later it led to the 78-year-old passing away.
- 2:43Michael Mulligan: So that was the fact pattern Prior to the 78-year-old passing away.
- 2:44Michael Mulligan: The 78-year-old passing away.
- 2:45Michael Mulligan: So that was the fact pattern Prior to the 78-year-old passing away.
- 2:48Michael Mulligan: The 25-year-old pled guilty to the arson and he was sentenced to three years in prison for that.
- 2:55Michael Mulligan: He was charged with murder with respect to the 78-year-old and that matter went to trial and interestingly it went to trial by judge alone, which is rare, because with a murder charge you are required to have a jury trial unless both the Crown and the defense agree that a judge can hear the case.
- 3:15Michael Mulligan: So this was a circumstance where they both agreed, and so that's how the case proceeded.
- 3:21Michael Mulligan: The issue in the murder case was whether the 25-year-old accused formed the required intent to kill the 78-year-old man.
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: Right, murder is intentionally killing somebody, and on that point the judge had a doubt that that had been proven and so convicted the man of manslaughter.
- 3:43Michael Mulligan: Now one thing that keen listeners might ask themselves is well, look, if what was going on here is, this person is mentally ill and he was hearing voices and believed that this man had sexually exploited his daughter, why wasn't the man found to be not criminally responsible as a result of a mental disorder?
- 4:01Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 4:02Michael Mulligan: The reason for that is that particular finding and there's another case, if we get to it this morning, we'll talk about that involves somebody who was found to be not criminally responsible as a result of a mental disorder.
- 4:13Michael Mulligan: That finding is premised on the idea that the person suffered from what the law refers to as a disease of the mind, something sort of internal to them, with the idea that we're not going to, in a usual criminal way, punish somebody who just doesn't know what's going on.
- 4:34Michael Mulligan: Right, I think they're saving themselves from a dragon when they're hitting the person on the road.
- 4:36Michael Mulligan: We put those people in a secure facility and treat them for their mental disorder rather than into a prison cell order rather than into a prison cell.
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: But the complicating factor here would be one of the proximate things would be as a reason probably connected to the serious mental illness which this man has suffered from since, like 12 years old, he was also heavily addicted to drugs, and so you don't get to an NCRMD fighting if the sort of proximate cause of what you did was, you know, self-induced intoxication by drugs.
- 5:05Michael Mulligan: We do convict people and send them to prison when that is what caused you to, for example, have auditory delusions that a random person has, you know, assaulted your daughter, and so that would be why that would not fit and why this is a sentencing case and a conviction.
- 5:23Michael Mulligan: The thing about the case, one of the things I think notable about the case, amongst others, is it is a picture of what is at the root of these legitimate, serious problems that we're facing, not only in Victoria but around the province.
- 5:39Michael Mulligan: And you know, sometimes, in my view, they have wrongly identified the problem here as being some issue with our bail system.
- 5:48Michael Mulligan: In my judgment, this case is an example of what is genuinely at the root of many of these things, because you don't generally have people who are sober and mentally sound randomly attacking elderly people as they cross the road.
- 6:06Michael Mulligan: That's just not how people usually behave.
- 6:08Michael Mulligan: And then, reading this case, the sentencing decision, it paints a picture which is, I think, fairly comes to the conclusion the judge reached, which was this 25 year old had essentially led a wasted life.
- 6:22Michael Mulligan: But why that happened and what happened here probably shouldn't have been a much of a surprise when you look at what happened.
- 6:31Michael Mulligan: The man was indigenous.
- 6:32Michael Mulligan: His mother was described as somebody who was an abusive alcoholic.
- 6:39Michael Mulligan: Her family had suffered through the 60s scoop, which had a big impact on lots of Indigenous people, and so his parents separated.
- 6:49Michael Mulligan: He lived with the abusive alcoholic mother for a short period of time, then returned to Trailville with his father at the age of 11 or 12, where, according to the judge and judicial language he quote, received little parental direction close quote and quickly found his life deteriorating, didn't finish school, wound up at drug use, diagnosed with bipolar disorder, and then wound up being diagnosed with various other mental illnesses and an addiction to OxyContin.
- 7:16Michael Mulligan: And so that's what this young man's life turned into.
- 7:19Michael Mulligan: And so he then proceeded on a pattern of committing various offenses, including other violent acts.
- 7:26Michael Mulligan: But he's just living on the street, he's described as wandering the streets of trail and he's in this combination of mentally ill, drug-induced state when he engages in this behavior.
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: He had also been treated for a head injury.
- 7:47Michael Mulligan: No doubt that contributed to it, but this is what we have when you have people who you know.
- 7:55Michael Mulligan: We closed down many of the facilities where people who were mentally ill would have received custodial treatment, and we closed them with the promise that we were going to provide care in the community because that was more humane.
- 8:06Michael Mulligan: We didn't.
- 8:08Michael Mulligan: And so you have people like this young man and like we have in Victoria and Vancouver and all over the province, who are living wasted lives and who are wandering about, who are living wasted lives and who are wandering about, and from time to time some combination of that plus the drug use results in what this judge described, as you know, this person clearly not operating quote within the bounds of rational thought, and I thought this really summed it up.
- 8:35Michael Mulligan: The judge said look, given his upbringing, it might be said it was practically preordained that his life would culminate in this kind of an event, and it did.
- 8:48Michael Mulligan: And the judge described it as a horrific, cowardly, senseless act of violence but perpetrated by somebody that I've described right, which leads you to what do you do with this right?
- 9:00Michael Mulligan: Which leads you to?
- 9:01Michael Mulligan: What do you do with this?
- 9:01Michael Mulligan: One of the complicating factors here that judge had to deal with was that the man had already served his three-year sentence for the arson when he pled guilty to it, and then what happened is the 78 year old passed away and he got charged with murder, and so then the judge had to determine what is the appropriate sentence, bearing in mind the combination of a horrific, random attack on this person that took his life.
- 9:22Michael Mulligan: And how do you square that up with somebody who has the sort of background and upbringing that I've indicated right, which, of course, that is a consideration in terms of what is the degree of moral culpability weight against what do we do to just protect ourselves?
- 9:36Michael Mulligan: And clearly, what would help to protect us would be to provide appropriate treatment so that you don't have people who are like in this man's status, wandering around under the influence of drugs and who are profoundly mentally ill, receiving not what they need.
- 9:50Michael Mulligan: And so the judge had to deal with the issue.
- 9:53Michael Mulligan: There's this one of the concepts in sentencing is sort of a concept of a principle of totality.
- 9:59Michael Mulligan: One of the concepts in sentencing is sort of a concept of a principle of totality, like when somebody is convicted of more than one thing, you know what is the total sentence the person should receive right, and is that appropriate?
- 10:10Michael Mulligan: So here you have this three-year sentence for the arson burning down his father's home after he's hearing voices telling him to do that as well, and then this, and so the judge, taking all of that into account, concluded that an additional six and a half year sentence, added to the three year sentence which he'd already served, was the appropriate sentence, bearing in mind you know, there's a sort of a range of sentences for manslaughter that would ordinarily be between four and 15 years in British Columbia, depending on things like person's background and degree of moral culpability and so on.
- 10:46Michael Mulligan: And even though this was, as the judge described, horrific, cowardly and senseless and led to death, which I suppose all manslaughter is due, the conclusion was that an additional six and a half years for this, with some credit for time in custody, because after he served his three-year sentence for the arson, he was still waiting in jail for this trial, and so that's what we've done, that's the outcome of that case, and so we should certainly feel a little less alone.
- 11:16Michael Mulligan: But until we do something to address those underlying issues, these things will occur.
- 11:24Michael Mulligan: Because you know you need do nothing more than walk around, walk down Pandora in Victoria or an equivalent street virtually anywhere else in the province, and when you see you have hundreds of people who are living in the street.
- 11:39Michael Mulligan: Obviously, and it's obvious from looking at them, you hardly need a medical diagnosis to realize you've got people who are just profoundly impaired.
- 11:46Michael Mulligan: You know they're laying on the sidewalk and hunched over and you know many of those are taught.
- 11:51Michael Mulligan: All of those, almost all of those people are going to have some combination of mental illness and drug addiction, and if we don't solve that, we are not going to solve it with some change to bail provisions.
- 12:03Michael Mulligan: That's, I think, just a complete, complete myth, and if we don't sort it out, we are going to continue to have people like this man who will, from the way, in a virtually, you know, hardpredict fashion, wind up doing something like this.
- 12:19Michael Mulligan: That's horrific, and so I thought that was just worth sharing.
- 12:23Michael Mulligan: It probably couldn't be a clearer example of the sort of background that leads to that activity and what we genuinely need to address if we don't want to live in a province where this sort of thing happens from time to time, and if we don't do something to solve those underlying issues.
- 12:43Michael Mulligan: You know, as the judge found in this case, some of these things are going to be practically preordained, and that is what we need to do, and I hope we would get focus on that, because at the moment it appears to be our efforts to stop these things, at least in my judgment, are perhaps not focused in quite the right place.
- 13:02Michael Mulligan: If we want to avoid further random, horrific, cowardly acts of violence, it's pretty clear what we need to be doing and we're not doing it.
- 13:10Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from Trail.
- 13:14Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 13:15Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking will continue right after this.
- 13:18Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking continuing here on CFAX 1070 with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 13:21Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking will continue right after this.
- 13:21Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking continuing here on CFax 1070 with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 13:23Adam Stirling: Michael, our next story that's on the agenda a wrongful dismissal claim.
- 13:27Adam Stirling: It says here an oral contract, complete.
- 13:30Adam Stirling: So the day after a written employment contract, it says not enforceable.
- 13:34Adam Stirling: What's going on?
- 13:36Michael Mulligan: Yeah, so this is a wrongful dismissal case.
- 13:39Michael Mulligan: We've spoken about those before.
- 13:40Michael Mulligan: The idea there is that by default at common law, if you are fired without cause, you would be presumed to be due either notice that you're going to be fired or pay in lieu of notice, or, if the employer doesn't want to give you actual notice that you're going to be let go.
- 14:00Michael Mulligan: And this had an interesting twist in it that people I think should be aware of.
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: Two interesting twists.
- 14:07Michael Mulligan: One, this claim was brought in Supreme Court and on that front it should be noted that you can bring a claim for any amount of money in BC Supreme Court.
- 14:17Michael Mulligan: There's no limit.
- 14:17Michael Mulligan: If you're suing somebody for a smaller amount of money, you can do so either in the Civil Resolution Tribunal up to $5,000 or up to $35,000 in Provincial Small Claims Court.
- 14:30Michael Mulligan: This claim was brought in Supreme Court.
- 14:31Michael Mulligan: That relevance will become clear later.
- 14:33Michael Mulligan: The person in this case was 31 years of age.
- 14:37Michael Mulligan: She was 31 at the relevant time period when she was hired.
- 14:40Michael Mulligan: She was hired to be a developer of an operator of a software platform that enabled entrepreneurs to create, market and sell online courses.
- 14:49Michael Mulligan: So that's what the job was she.
- 14:51Michael Mulligan: Here's the interesting thing.
- 14:53Michael Mulligan: That is a contractual issue people should know about.
- 14:56Michael Mulligan: One of the concepts with contracts is the idea of consideration.
- 15:00Michael Mulligan: The law doesn't enforce bare promises, like if I just walk up to you and say, hey, adam, I'm going to give you a new car for your birthday, and you say great Right on.
- 15:10Michael Mulligan: Right on A new car.
- 15:11Michael Mulligan: I've always wanted a new car and I don't deliver on that.
- 15:14Michael Mulligan: You might be unhappy with me, but you can't sue me for just promising you a present.
- 15:19Michael Mulligan: But, on the other hand, a contract has consideration.
- 15:22Michael Mulligan: And so if I say to you hey, you know it's your birthday, I want to help you out.
- 15:26Michael Mulligan: I've got this car, it's worth $50,000.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: If you'll agree to pay me $1,000 for the taxes or something, I'll give it to you and we have, okay, great, now that's a contract, because we've each promised one another something, not just a present.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: Now, here, in an employment law context, you had this person who spoke about this job in an interview and then, in fact, the employer sent her a detailed email following up on that, which was some 60 pages long and had various things listing her compensation, stock options, health benefits, computer hardware, bonuses, all this sort of print-to-leave information, vacation schedules, work details, everything.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: And she responded to that as well, saying great, I accept.
- 16:15Michael Mulligan: And she responded to that as well, saying great, I accept.
- 16:17Michael Mulligan: And then, at 5 pm the same day, the employer sent a letter which was entitled Protection of Corporate Interests and it laid out a whole bunch of things which would not as happy and things like stop options and you know print to leave programs.
- 16:34Michael Mulligan: It was a five page letter saying various things.
- 16:39Michael Mulligan: Like you know, you get less notice if you're fired and you can't compete with us if you're fired.
- 16:40Michael Mulligan: Parental leave programs it was a five-page letter saying various things.
- 16:41Michael Mulligan: Like you know, you'd get less notice if you're fired and you can't compete with us if you're fired various other things, and she accepted that as well.
- 16:45Michael Mulligan: Now, a couple of years later, she wound up being fired without notice or cause and so she sued, saying hey, I didn't get the amount of notice that I should have been entitled to.
- 16:58Michael Mulligan: The employer said well, hold on, we sent you this letter at 5 pm about the protection of corporate interest and you signed off on that.
- 17:05Michael Mulligan: That limited how much you should get.
- 17:07Michael Mulligan: We don't want to have to pay you more.
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: Now the issue one of the central issues became.
- 17:12Michael Mulligan: Well, was that second thing a contract, or was the first discussion and then e-mail with all these details?
- 17:19Michael Mulligan: Was that second thing a contract, or was the first discussion and then email with all these details?
- 17:22Michael Mulligan: Was that the contract?
- 17:25Michael Mulligan: And here the judge found those first things, the discussion, and then the detailed email with all of these particulars of the job, 60 pages of information and the person saying yes, okay, great, that was the contract.
- 17:34Michael Mulligan: And then things sent later on, like at 5 pm, the letter about protecting corporate interests, limiting things like notice if you're fired.
- 17:43Michael Mulligan: The judge concluded that wasn't a contract at all.
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: The contract was done.
- 17:49Michael Mulligan: There was a contract already.
- 17:50Michael Mulligan: That thing that came along at 5 o'clock was the equivalent of the promise to give you a car for your birthday and it could have been made enforceable if there was some consideration for it.
- 18:00Michael Mulligan: Like if they at five o'clock said here's a letter about protection of corporate interest.
- 18:05Michael Mulligan: If you agree to all this, we'll agree to give you an extra anything dollar, you know, we'll give you an extra day off, something.
- 18:13Michael Mulligan: Then there's an agreement, a contract which is enforceable.
- 18:17Michael Mulligan: But there wasn't.
- 18:17Michael Mulligan: And so the net result here is that that letter sent later wasn't a contract.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: The contract was done, and so she was entitled to pay in lieu of notice.
- 18:30Michael Mulligan: The judge found here she's entitled to, in fact, five months of pay.
- 18:33Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found well, five months of pay would have been $41,000.
- 18:37Michael Mulligan: Subtract from that the three weeks pay which she was paid, $5,700.
- 18:42Michael Mulligan: And then subtracting and this is important mitigation earnings.
- 18:46Michael Mulligan: One of the other concepts with wrongful dismissal is you need to try to get another job.
- 18:50Michael Mulligan: You can't just say I'm just going to sit here on my couch and sue you, you've got to try to get another job.
- 18:55Michael Mulligan: And if you do, then what you get in your new job would be deducted from what you would get in terms of the pay in lieu of notice.
- 19:04Michael Mulligan: You haven't lost anything, right?
- 19:05Michael Mulligan: And in fact, if you got just the equivalent job or, let's say, even a better job, you might be entitled to anything at all.
- 19:11Michael Mulligan: Right, because you haven't lost anything.
- 19:13Michael Mulligan: You know, if your employer just comes in and capriciously says you're fired and the next day you're, you know, you're walking along and somebody else says, hey, I'll hire you.
- 19:21Michael Mulligan: In fact, I'll pay you 20% more, you say, great, you've got a new job.
- 19:24Michael Mulligan: You're not entitled to anything from the last person because, well, you got a new job and in fact, you to the judge was $31,647.44.
- 19:32Michael Mulligan: That amount is less than $35,000, which is the threshold for small claims court.
- 19:47Michael Mulligan: If you sue somebody in Supreme Court and you get less than what you could have gotten if you'd been to small claims court rather than Supreme Court, you are presumptively not entitled to receive your costs.
- 20:00Michael Mulligan: In Supreme Court there's that concept of cost you sue somebody, you succeed, they didn't settle and they should have.
- 20:05Michael Mulligan: You're going to get part of your legal fees paid and vice versa, to encourage people to resolve things.
- 20:10Michael Mulligan: We don't do that in Small Claims Court, because in Small Claims Court many people don't have a lawyer.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: It's supposed to be more informal.
- 20:16Michael Mulligan: We just don't do that.
- 20:17Michael Mulligan: You can get some minor costs for, like the expense of filing and, you know, serving the person, the documents and so on, but it's small potatoes.
- 20:26Michael Mulligan: So here she won in the sense that she got the $31,000.
- 20:30Michael Mulligan: But the judge said there was no good reason to bring this in Supreme Court and so she didn't get her costs and so she was successful on that contractual argument.
- 20:40Michael Mulligan: But at the end of the day she's conducted a trial in Supreme Court and she got an award of $31,000.
- 20:46Michael Mulligan: And so whatever you know, that amount would be minus whatever she's paid in terms of legal expenses to pursue this thing, because really it should have occurred in small claims court.
- 20:57Michael Mulligan: So interesting issues there, I thought, both because of the issue of what is a contract, what's required and how that played out, and that issue of where you are required and supposed to sue someone.
- 21:09Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 21:10Adam Stirling: 60 seconds left.
- 21:13Michael Mulligan: Final case.
- 21:13Michael Mulligan: It's another NCRMD case.
- 21:15Michael Mulligan: It's an interesting one.
- 21:16Michael Mulligan: It's a woman who suffered from a mental disorder.
- 21:19Michael Mulligan: She had repeatedly tried to apprehend or take other children, believing that the children were recognizing her to be their mother because of their glances at her.
- 21:30Michael Mulligan: She was found to be not criminally responsible for doing that back in 2018.
- 21:34Michael Mulligan: She's been held in a secure mental health facility ever since then.
- 21:39Michael Mulligan: She was applying to get out, denied, appealed that all the way to the Court of Appeal, and again she was denied on the basis that it's just necessary to keep her in custody to protect, prevent her from doing this to other children, given her lack of insight, violent ideation, psychosis and so on.
- 21:57Michael Mulligan: And it's an example, I think, of how those findings, those NCRMD filings, are not some kind of a go-free pass For this person.
- 22:06Michael Mulligan: She may well wind up in custody there indefinitely, because the medical opinion is that she just cannot be made safe in the public and her mental illness can only be managed in the public.
- 22:17Michael Mulligan: And she can only.
- 22:17Michael Mulligan: Her mental illness can only be managed in the confines of a strict custodial setting.
- 22:21Michael Mulligan: And so, in order to keep the public safe, which is the number one objective of the review board, she is likely to remain securely in a hospital indefinitely, and so it's an example of how those findings of NCRMD do not translate into you've got a free pass or you're getting out.
- 22:38Michael Mulligan: If you're somebody like this who remains a danger to children, you may or anyone you may find yourself in custody, potentially for the rest of your life.
- 22:46Michael Mulligan: So that's the 62nd last case.
- 22:49Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 22:53Adam Stirling: Michael, pleasure as always, until next week.
- 22:55Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 22:56Adam Stirling: Have a great day All.