Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Reading Income Statements and ... The Footnotes!
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. This is where we break down the
- 0:02financial source material so you can walk away with insights
- 0:04that. Will really.
- 0:05Separate the smart investors from everyone else.
- 0:08Today, we are plunging head first into corporate finance.
- 0:11Specifically, we're targeting the numbers that most people see
- 0:14in the news and just completely misunderstand.
- 0:16You see the headlines all the time, right?
- 0:18Company X reports. Massive revenue or bottom line
- 0:22profits are soaring. And for a lot of people that
- 0:25sounds like a green light. But the research we analyzed for
- 0:28this deep dive is pretty clear. Relying only on high revenue or
- 0:32that final profit number is often a huge and very costly
- 0:35mistake. So our mission today is to
- 0:38unpack the One Financial statement that really dictates a
- 0:40company's survival. That's the income statement or
- 0:43the PNL. We're going to show you the
- 0:44three core margin metrics. Think of them like an X-ray into
- 0:48a company's real health. And then, and this is where it
- 0:50gets really interesting, we are going deep into the footnotes
- 0:53because that is where all the, let's say, ingenious and
- 0:56sometimes insidious tricks are hiding.
- 0:57That's the whole game right there.
- 0:59I mean, the distinction between the money coming in and what's
- 1:01actually leftover is the core lesson.
- 1:04We have to stop thinking that earning money is the same as
- 1:06keeping it. Every dollar that comes into a
- 1:08business goes through a series of these really crucial filters.
- 1:13If you only look at the end result, you totally miss the
- 1:16damage that's done at each stage.
- 1:18So we need to talk about gross operating and net margins.
- 1:22OK, let's do it. Let's start right at the top at
- 1:24the source of the cash. We begin with revenue.
- 1:27Revenue is just the total sales recorded.
- 1:29The sources use a simple analogy that I think works really well,
- 1:32a little milk tea shop. So if you sell One Cup of milk
- 1:36tea for, say, $10, that $10 is your revenue.
- 1:40Simple as that. Right.
- 1:41But obviously it cost money to make that tea.
- 1:43So the very first deduction is what we call the cost of goods
- 1:45sold, or Kai GS. This is the direct cost tied to
- 1:49making that one product. For the milk tea, it's the milk,
- 1:51the tea leaves, the cup, the sugar, you know, let's say all
- 1:55that adds up to $4. OK.
- 1:57So $10 in revenue -4 dollars in Kai GS, we're left with $6.
- 2:02And that $6 is our gross profit. So we get the basic idea, but
- 2:07how does this work when you scale it up to, you know, a huge
- 2:10tech company? The math is identical.
- 2:12It doesn't matter if it's dollars or yuan, or if it's
- 2:14thousands or billions. So let's take a phone
- 2:16manufacturer. If they sell $100,000 worth of
- 2:19phones, that's their revenue. And if the parts, the factory
- 2:22labor, all the components cost $40,000, that's their Kochi.
- 2:25Yes, they're left at the gross profit of $60,000.
- 2:28And from that we get our first key metric.
- 2:30Exactly. We turn that into the gross
- 2:32profit margin. You just take the gross profit,
- 2:33the $60,000 and divided by the revenue of the $100,000.
- 2:37So that's 60%. 60% That sounds pretty good, but what does that
- 2:40number actually tell an investor?
- 2:41What's its real significance? Oh, it's huge.
- 2:44It's massive because it reflects the strength of the product
- 2:47itself. It tells you about the company's
- 2:49competitive Moat. A high gross margin means you
- 2:51have strong pricing power, maybe a tech advantage, something that
- 2:54your rivals can't just copy easily.
- 2:56It tells you how much money you keep before you even pay for
- 2:59like rent or the marketing team. So if the gross margin is weak,
- 3:04it basically means your product is a commodity.
- 3:06You're just fighting over pennies.
- 3:08That's it. You're struggling to charge
- 3:10anything more than what it costs you to make it.
- 3:12That makes perfect sense. Yeah.
- 3:14OK, so we've got our $6 of gross profit from the milk tea.
- 3:16The product is viable, but now we have to actually run the
- 3:19shop, right? Keep lights on, hire people.
- 3:24This brings us to the second filter, operating expenses or
- 3:27OpEx? Right.
- 3:28And OpEx is everything else you need to run the business.
- 3:31You know whether you sell One Cup of tea or 1000, this is your
- 3:33rent. Utilities, employee salaries,
- 3:36and the big ones are usually sales and admin and also R&D
- 3:40research and development. So for the tea shop, let's say
- 3:43those costs come to $3.00. We take that $3 of OpEx from our
- 3:47$6 of gross profit. Now we're left with $3.
- 3:51That's the operating profit. And for the tech company, that
- 3:55six oh, oh, oh, oh gross profit has to cover the salaries for
- 4:00the engineers, the marketers, the office lease O say that's
- 4:03three oh, oh, oh, oh, oh in OEX, that leaves them with an
- 4:06operating profit of $30,000. Which gives you an operating
- 4:09profit margin of 30%. And this number for many, many
- 4:12analysts is the gold standard. It's probably the most important
- 4:15number on the whole statement. Why more important than gross
- 4:18margin? Because it shows you how
- 4:19efficient the management is. The gross margin is about the
- 4:22product. The operating margin is about
- 4:23the whole system. I mean, you could have a
- 4:25fantastic product with a high gross margin, but if your
- 4:27operating margin is terrible, it tells you the company is just
- 4:31bloated, it's poorly run, or it's wasting money on sales
- 4:34campaigns that don't work. It's the real test of whether
- 4:36management can turn a good product into actual cash.
- 4:40OK. So product strength, then
- 4:41management deficiency, now we're at the final stage, the last
- 4:44filter before the money actually gets to the shareholder.
- 4:47Correct. The final deductions are things
- 4:49that are sort of outside the day-to-day business.
- 4:51This is mainly interest you have to pay on bank loans and of
- 4:54course taxes. Everybody pays taxes.
- 4:56So in our little tea shop analogy, if those final costs
- 4:59are say $1.00, we take that from our $3 of operating profit and
- 5:04we are left with $2.00. That is the net income, the
- 5:07famous bottom line. And for our tech company, you
- 5:10take the $30,000 operating profit, you subtract the
- 5:14interest in the taxes, and you're left with, say, $20,000
- 5:18in net income, which means the final metric, the Net margin, is
- 5:2220%. And when you see profit in the
- 5:25headlines, this is almost always the number they're talking
- 5:28about. All right.
- 5:28Let's just let's quickly pull these three layers together for
- 5:30everyone. Gross margin is the product's
- 5:32competitiveness. Yep, it's Moat.
- 5:34Operating margin shows the management's efficiency, sort of
- 5:37the health of the core business engine.
- 5:39The most important one in my view.
- 5:40And net income is just the final result for shareholders after
- 5:44everyone else gets paid. And here's a really critical
- 5:46warning we pulled from the sources.
- 5:49You can never, ever use these margins to compare companies in
- 5:53different sectors. It's a classic, classic mistake.
- 5:56Right. Think about that high gross
- 5:58margin. We mentioned a software company,
- 6:01once they've built the software, it costs almost nothing to sell
- 6:04another copy. So their gross margin could be
- 6:0685 percent, 90%. Exactly.
- 6:10But now compare that to a giant supermarket.
- 6:13You know, a Walmart or something.
- 6:15They're buying physical cans of soup and reselling them.
- 6:18Their gross margin might only be, what, 25%?
- 6:21And a listener might look at that and think the software
- 6:23company is obviously a much Better Business, but.
- 6:25That's not true. Their business models are just
- 6:27fundamentally different. The supermarket wins on
- 6:29incredible efficiency and massive scale.
- 6:31The software company could easily fail if their operating
- 6:34expenses, their R&D, their sales team are so huge that they burn
- 6:39through that beautiful gross margin.
- 6:40So the key is to compare within the same industry, 2 grocery
- 6:44stores or two software companies.
- 6:46Exactly. That's where you find the truth.
- 6:48If one grocery chain consistently has a higher
- 6:51operating margin, you've probably found the better run
- 6:54company. OK, so if the margins tell the
- 6:56honest story, where do we find the story?
- 6:59Well, the lies, the little deceptions managers used to make
- 7:02the story sound better than it is.
- 7:04Now we get to the fun part. We move away from the big
- 7:06numbers on the income statement and we go to the footnotes.
- 7:09This is the stuff Warren Buffett says he reads first.
- 7:12I love the analogy the sources use for this.
- 7:15Buying a used car. The income statement, the big
- 7:18revenue, the soaring profit. That's the shiny paint job.
- 7:22It looks great, the engine seems fast.
- 7:24But a smart car buyer knows the real story isn't on the surface.
- 7:27They don't look at the Polish, they look for the greasy oil
- 7:30stained repair records. And in a financial report, those
- 7:33repair records, they're the footnotes.
- 7:36There's a saying on Wall Street if you find one cockroach on the
- 7:39kitchen floor, there's definitely more in the cracks.
- 7:42The footnotes are where you find the cockroaches.
- 7:44These are the clever accounting tricks they use to pump up the
- 7:47numbers without actually improving the business.
- 7:50Let's start with a classic cockroach example.
- 7:52Number one, changing the depreciation policy.
- 7:56This is a totally legal way to instantly create paper profit,
- 8:00as long as you mention it in the tiny print.
- 8:02So let's imagine our factory again.
- 8:04They buy a big machine for $10 million and originally their
- 8:08accounting policy says this machine has a five year useful
- 8:12life. OK.
- 8:13So with a five year life, the depreciation expense is
- 8:16$2,000,000 per year. That 2 million gets subtracted
- 8:20from your profit every single year.
- 8:21It's a real cost. But now here's the trick.
- 8:25It's the end of a bad quarter. Management is about to miss
- 8:28their earnings target. They need to find $1,000,000 in
- 8:31profit. Fast.
- 8:33So what do they do? They can't sell more products,
- 8:35so they go into the footnotes and they just change the
- 8:37accounting policy. They decide the machines useful.
- 8:39Life isn't five years anymore. Now it's 10 years.
- 8:42And just like that. Just like that, the annual
- 8:45depreciation expense drops from 2 million to 1,000,000.
- 8:48The company's paper profit instantly jumps by $1,000,000.
- 8:51They hit their target. Without selling a single extra
- 8:54product, it's just it's pure financial engineering.
- 8:57It is, and it's allowed as long as they disclose it.
- 9:00But what does it tell you? It screams desperation.
- 9:03If you only read the main statement, you see profit went
- 9:06up. But if you read the footnote,
- 9:07you see why you found your first cockroach.
- 9:10OK, that's a subtle one. What about cockroach?
- 9:13Example 2 related party transactions.
- 9:16This one sounds a bit more shady.
- 9:18It can be. This one often points to really
- 9:21low quality revenue that's going to cause problems down the line.
- 9:25So here's the setup. Company A is having a tough
- 9:28quarter. They're not going to hit their
- 9:30revenue number for Wall Street, and they've got a warehouse full
- 9:33of inventory that nobody is buying.
- 9:35So the trap is in the last few days of the quarter, Company A
- 9:38makes a huge sale of all that inventory to some small unknown
- 9:42company, let's call IT company B and.
- 9:44Boom, they recorded as revenue. The quarter is saved.
- 9:47The income statement looks fantastic.
- 9:49But then you dig into the footnotes.
- 9:51And you find a tiny little sentence that says Company B is
- 9:54actually owned by the CEO's brother-in-law, or even worse,
- 9:57that Company B only exists because Company A gave them a
- 10:01big loan to buy the inventory in the first place.
- 10:03So it's not a real sale, it's just moving boxes from your left
- 10:06hand to your right hand. Precisely.
- 10:08The goods never reached a real customer.
- 10:10They just move them around to create the illusion of a sale
- 10:14and you, the investor will pay the price later.
- 10:17When all that inventory has to be written off or the loan to
- 10:20Company B is never repaid, it's a huge red flag.
- 10:24Let's talk about one more. This one hits the operating
- 10:26margin indirectly capitalizing routine expenses.
- 10:30This one is very subtle. Normally routine costs, you
- 10:34know, painting the office, minor software updates, that's just a
- 10:37regular maintenance cost. It's an operating expense or
- 10:39OpEx. It reduces your operating profit
- 10:41today. What if management wants to make
- 10:44that operating margin look better?
- 10:46Well, they try to argue that this expense isn't just
- 10:48maintenance, it's a long term investment, capital expenditure
- 10:52or CapEx. They might say a big software
- 10:54update is actually a new asset that will last for 10 years.
- 10:58And was that? Due.
- 10:58By relabeling it from OpEx to CapEx, it doesn't reduce their
- 11:02operating profit this year. Instead, the cost gets spread
- 11:05out over many, many years through depreciation.
- 11:09So they can take a $5,000,000 hit and instead of it hurting
- 11:12profit today, they turn it into a tiny half $1,000,000 hit for
- 11:16the next 10 years. So they instantly boost this
- 11:19year's operating profit by almost $5,000,000 without the
- 11:23business actually performing any.
- 11:25Better. Exactly.
- 11:26It's just hiding the true cost of keeping the lights on.
- 11:29It really all comes back to seeing through that short term
- 11:31financial engineering. O for you listening.
- 11:34What this all means is when a company is shouting about huge
- 11:36profit growth, your job is to go deeper.
- 11:39You have to check those footnotes.
- 11:40Did they change depreciation years?
- 11:42Did they push a bunch of inventory onto a related
- 11:44company? Did they suddenly decide
- 11:46painting the office was a 10 year asset?
- 11:48Absolutely. And the last piece of advice
- 11:50here is to be so skeptical of those big one time gains that
- 11:54pop up in net income. Sometimes the company's main
- 11:57business is really struggling. You can see the operating margin
- 12:00bleeding cash, but then they suddenly sell their headquarters
- 12:03building for a huge profit. That one time sale makes the net
- 12:07income for that year look incredible, makes the company
- 12:11seem wildly profitable. But if you want to understand
- 12:14the long term value, the real operational health of the
- 12:17business, you have to prioritize the operating profit margin
- 12:21always. If that number is trending down,
- 12:23the core engine of the business is in trouble, no matter how
- 12:26flashy that final net income number looks today.
- 12:29That's the number of management really can't hide from, not
- 12:31easily anyway. That's right.
- 12:32It all comes down to understanding the layers and
- 12:35knowing which ones are the easiest to manipulate.
- 12:38So if the gross margin shows the product's power and the Net
- 12:41margin shows the final most easily distorted result, here's
- 12:44something to think about. What current industry or what
- 12:47company out there right now might be showing a really high
- 12:50Net margin while its operating margin is actually revealing
- 12:53that the main engine of the business is losing cash?
- 12:56Something profound. I'm all over until our next deep
- 12:58dive.