Latest / The Learning Corner by Precursor / Episode #93: Vertical AI Today with Nic Poulos of Euclid Ventures
Transcript
- 0:00AI is software, and so, you know, a lot of people are are kind of, I think, extrapolating.
- 0:05You know, they see a headline, hey.
- 0:06Software is dead.
- 0:07Well, that means all apps are dead.
- 0:09Well, that's obviously not the case.
- 0:11Right?
- 0:12Software stocks have more or less recovered or at least, you know, over over 60%.
- 0:16So what does that mean?
- 0:18Well, you know, it means maybe SaaS or at least some categories of it are still kinda sticky,
- 0:24and it's gonna take a while.
- 0:27It's the week of August 31.
- 0:29Welcome to the Learning Corner, a Precursor Ventures podcast.
- 0:32Welcome to the Learning Corner by Precursor.
- 0:36I'm Mia Farnam, and I'm joined by our GP and managing partner, Charles Hudson.
- 0:41We're also doing something different this week.
- 0:43So instead of our usual three articles, we're sitting down with Nick Polos, general partner
- 0:48at Nuclear Ventures.
- 0:49Nick co writes The Verticalist and also co hosts The Verticals podcast.
- 0:54It's safe to say we've got one of the sharper minds as it pertains to vertical AI and
- 0:59software on the podcast.
- 1:01Nick, thanks so much for joining us today.
- 1:04Thanks for having me, guys.
- 1:05You're too kind.
- 1:06Excited to be here.
- 1:07Nick, do you mind walking through Euclid, genesis of the fund, what you guys focus on,
- 1:12background yourself just quickly for the listeners?
- 1:14Yeah.
- 1:15Absolutely.
- 1:15You know, Euclid is an inception stage fund focused exclusively on vertical AI.
- 1:20So we back founders building AI native solutions suited to specific verticals
- 1:27throughout the economy.
- 1:28We launched a few years ago, really, to focus in on this first check opportunity vertical.
- 1:34And my partner Omar and I, who co founded the fund, we've been focused on vertical platforms
- 1:40most of our careers as early stage VCs.
- 1:42And we've featured a bunch of your articles and excerpts from podcasts throughout the Learning
- 1:46Corners, so we thank you for publishing good content.
- 1:49We'll jump into it, and we've bucketed into a couple different themes.
- 1:52But at the highest level, we're steamrolling somehow into the end of q three, and it does
- 1:58feel like the entire venture world has gathered around vertical AI as the main play.
- 2:04And that's been, you know, the fund's conviction since before it even had a name.
- 2:10Nick, question for you.
- 2:12How has that thesis held up, and what surprised you the most about how fast it's moved and
- 2:17gained so much attention over the past year?
- 2:19It's been really exciting to see.
- 2:21Omar would tell you too, when when we launched the fund, you know, we had to try to explain
- 2:25what we even meant by vertical AI.
- 2:28You know, why why is this an interesting category?
- 2:30What is the relation to vertical SaaS?
- 2:32There was a lot of explaining.
- 2:34My As partner, Omar, likes to say, when you're when you're explaining, you're losing.
- 2:36We were very eager for for the rest of, you know, the ecosystem to jump in.
- 2:41And, you know, I think it was of course, we weren't the only ones that saw it.
- 2:44It was inevitable.
- 2:45You know?
- 2:46You guys have been investing in the space too.
- 2:48I think what we've seen now is that there's enormous appetite throughout the rest of the
- 2:53economy.
- 2:54So, you know, not not just engineering teams at at massive companies in Silicon Valley, but,
- 2:59you know, the medical practices, the trades, the retail stores.
- 3:04Literally everyone is looking at what's happening, even if you're not a follower of big
- 3:08tech, and saying, well, maybe this can help my business.
- 3:12And from my perspective, that is a twenty year opportunity at minimum, and we are in the first
- 3:20first half of the first inning.
- 3:22So I think it's the most exciting time, you know, to be investing in this space and
- 3:27probably as as a VC in general.
- 3:29Charles, we've talked about this a couple times in the podcast of folks who kind of moved in
- 3:33and out of themes when they become hot.
- 3:36On the vertical AI side, are there is there, like, a moment that you can remember of, like,
- 3:40when it really felt like people were, like, starting to reach out to be like, this is my
- 3:45new thing area that I'm focused on.
- 3:46It's critical.
- 3:47When Sarah Towell wrote her post about, like, sell the work, not the software, I think a lot
- 3:53of that was, for me, the first time I think I started hearing people say, maybe this will be
- 3:58a thing.
- 3:58Maybe you can take this domain expertise.
- 4:00Then I think in our ever wandering in the woods for a durable moat conversation we've been
- 4:06having as an industry for two years, I think at some point, people said, perhaps knowing
- 4:09something about the category that you're building in and what matters and who the
- 4:14customers are and what the leverage points are might be better than just generally throwing
- 4:18spaghetti against the wall.
- 4:20So I think as people have tried to find something that feels easy to explain but also
- 4:24consequential, I think a lot of people figured out.
- 4:27I also think, Nick, it feels to me like there's a bunch of my friends who were vertical SaaS
- 4:32investors who were like, how do I not just flush all of my accumulated knowledge about
- 4:36these verticals?
- 4:37So perhaps I can reuse this by moving into vertical.
- 4:41But the more I read about what you all have written and the more we invest, the more I
- 4:45think there really is a real difference between vertical SaaS and these vertical AI companies
- 4:49just in terms of how they operate, what matters a bit.
- 4:52I mean, you know you know a lot more about that than I do, though.
- 4:54I think we're all we're all trying to figure it out.
- 4:56You know, if you kinda think about the the numbers behind this market opportunity, you
- 5:00know, we looked at couple 100,000,000,000 in, you know, an opportunity for for SaaS.
- 5:05Now we're looking at a market of, you know, potentially tens of trillions in terms of
- 5:11services and and labor that can potentially be addressed.
- 5:15Obviously, it's not gonna be all of that.
- 5:16Right?
- 5:16But, you know, everything's been shaken up in terms of what makes for a big market when you
- 5:22can, as you said, as Sarah has said, do the work as opposed to just being a software
- 5:28solution that you've got to train your workforce on and learn and use yourself.
- 5:32And along those lines, we have to kind of talk about the death of SaaS and the conversation
- 5:37around it.
- 5:38It's just ever prevalent.
- 5:40In the founder's guide to vertical AI that you guys published, I think there was a quote in
- 5:45there that said AI is still software, and reports of the death of SaaS are greatly
- 5:49exaggerated, especially for vertical companies with real workflow dev.
- 5:53Has there been any evolution on that thinking, or where are you where's your head now?
- 5:57Yeah.
- 5:58I think there are kind of two two sides to this maybe gripe that we have.
- 6:01I mean, one is just purely semantics.
- 6:04And, you know, I don't know if listeners even care about this.
- 6:06Maybe it's like an inside baseball venture thing.
- 6:09But, you know, if you if you look at what AI is, right, it's it's code.
- 6:13It's software.
- 6:14Right?
- 6:15It we are talking about, you know, user facing maybe they're not crud apps anymore, but
- 6:21they're apps.
- 6:22And so as you think about what software means, AI is software.
- 6:27And so a lot of people are kind of, I think, extrapolating.
- 6:30They see a headline, hey, software is dead.
- 6:33Well, that means all apps are dead.
- 6:35Well, that's obviously not the case.
- 6:37Right?
- 6:37But I I think the other is that is maybe fueled by by, like, a, you know, a bit of a a mantra
- 6:43we have at Euclid.
- 6:44Bill Gates is probably most famous for it, which is, you know, humans tend to overestimate
- 6:50what can be done in the short term and underestimate what can be done in the long
- 6:53term.
- 6:54You know, extrapolating that, look at public markets, look at software stocks.
- 6:59It's been, I guess, almost a year since SaaS pocalypse or at least the day of it.
- 7:05Software stocks have more or less recovered or at least, you know, over 60%.
- 7:10So what does that mean?
- 7:11Well, you know, it means maybe SaaS or at least some categories of it are still kind of sticky
- 7:17and it's going to take a while.
- 7:18I do still think it is a bit overblown.
- 7:21But there's some reality to it as well, right?
- 7:24I mean, I think we all probably agree that UI, that databases, a lot of things you associate
- 7:31with historical systems of record are just not as valuable as they once were, and you need to
- 7:35find new modes.
- 7:36Yeah.
- 7:37I've I've been talking to a friend of mine all week.
- 7:40He showed me a product, and I was like, well, where's the headless And he's like, what do you
- 7:45he's like, I'm just done with other people's UIs, and I feel like there's a lot of
- 7:49conventions in software, things that we've struggled that used to be points of
- 7:53differentiation, points of pride for developers where I'm just like, I I kinda don't care care
- 7:59anymore.
- 7:59And as a software buyer, I've noticed the things I care about and prioritize.
- 8:03So I told our CFOs, like, I don't think I'll ever buy another software product that doesn't
- 8:07have an MCP server and a REST API that I can hit with whatever agent I want of choice.
- 8:13That's like a must have product requirement.
- 8:15I still get pitched by vendors who are like, oh, we're working on it.
- 8:18I'm like, well, I can't use what you have today with the way I work if you don't have these
- 8:22things.
- 8:23And that was not something I said a year ago.
- 8:24Nick, is that what you're seeing too across the market?
- 8:26Like, that is what customers are asking, and you can't really fall below that line?
- 8:30I think it depends on what what world you're in.
- 8:32If you have folks that are on the cutting edge that are trying to develop things, and we are
- 8:37internally, obviously, all start ups, Silicon Valley, like, you need that now.
- 8:42Right?
- 8:42That, like, Charles, like you said, I mean, it is it is table stakes.
- 8:46I mean, we literally dropped our old CRM because that, you know, that that process is
- 8:51moving too slowly.
- 8:52And it's like, you know, you gotta read the writing on the wall.
- 8:55But I would say, you know, if you are in a category that, you know, kind of a real world
- 9:01vertical, right?
- 9:02So let's say you're an outpatient physician's practice or, you know, you're a roofing
- 9:07contractor, you you may not care as much.
- 9:10You may care more about, you know, what have you done for me lately and what work are you
- 9:14gonna handle soup to nuts.
- 9:15And so I think eventually that sort of interoperability will be critical because
- 9:21that's just where the world's going.
- 9:23But I think there are some categories, some of the legacy ones where SaaS adoption still isn't
- 9:29that high.
- 9:30And so maybe they just wanna skip it, they want you just to do the work for them, they don't
- 9:35wanna get in the weeds.
- 9:36I was like, one of my other questions for you was just I think when I first heard of vertical
- 9:40AI, I think a lot of people said, oh, this is gonna be for these, like, very niche, small,
- 9:45previously unaddressable areas.
- 9:47But I'm like, but why can't it be for everything?
- 9:50Like, why why like, vertical AI doesn't have to mean small niche, previously uninteresting.
- 9:56And I I'm just curious, like, how you're thinking about how broad the thesis is has
- 10:00evolved as you guys have lived with it.
- 10:02I mean, I think this is a common interpretation of whether it's vertical SaaS or vertical AI
- 10:07is, okay, that means it's like some hyper specific thing.
- 10:11And there's room for those too.
- 10:13But at the end of the day, the way I see it is, you know, you need you need solutions across
- 10:18the entire economy.
- 10:20You need solutions for retail, for supply chain, for pharma, for investment banking, for
- 10:26podcasters.
- 10:26Right?
- 10:27And some are small, but a lot are really big.
- 10:29And to be honest, if we can address, you know, services, if if we can perform tasks that
- 10:37historically only humans could, soup to nuts with AI, then your TAMs and your ACVs as a
- 10:44startup can be much broader.
- 10:46And we are seeing this.
- 10:47We are seeing a lot of founders building in vertical categories we've invested in.
- 10:53Historically, mindset was this is like a hard ceiling of $20.30 ks ACV.
- 10:59But when you get in there and you say, hey, we can do this, we can do that, we can do soup to
- 11:02nuts, we can be you know, the CRO you never had, whatever it is, like, they're willing to
- 11:08pay so much more.
- 11:09So I think we need to rethink some of these things.
- 11:12You know, the way I think about it internally is that in the world of AI, right,
- 11:17specialization is the dividing line.
- 11:20There are horizontal specializations, but by nature vertical is specialized.
- 11:25Whether you're training a model or you're just building that ecosystem, like a harness or a
- 11:31headless system, you're collecting specialized data.
- 11:34The future is specialization, but that specialization can be big or small.
- 11:38That bridges in well to the conversation around defensibility.
- 11:42I think also while investors have gathered around vertical AI as their new favorite place,
- 11:47I think founders had also realized that as well.
- 11:49So what, Nick, is your version of defensibility right now in vertical AI?
- 11:53I know some people lean hard on prior experience that's deep.
- 11:57Others have advocated for speed and go to market.
- 12:00What are you thinking there?
- 12:01I mean, it's funny.
- 12:01In a lot of ways, we feel that there are really two primitives of defensibility that really
- 12:07haven't changed from software to AI.
- 12:09The first is data, and the second is workflow.
- 12:12Maybe the formats have changed, but, you know, I think long term defensibility for startups we
- 12:16invest in, we think about one data.
- 12:18So this could be first order data, so proprietary data that, you know, let's say
- 12:23you're Thomson Reuters and you've been annotating case law for forty years with
- 12:27humans.
- 12:28That's something probably no one else has.
- 12:30You know, you also have the second order data, which is basically just understanding how
- 12:34people do things.
- 12:35Right?
- 12:36If you think about how historically a an accountant would go about handling taxes, well,
- 12:42sure, you may know how to do the math, but like the exact steps in the process, that is data.
- 12:49And in a lot of ways it hasn't been abstract out of humans' heads.
- 12:52So one category is data.
- 12:54I mean, second is workflow.
- 12:57And, you know, I think in some ways still integrations, some of which are open, some of
- 13:02which are hard and require partnerships, can still be, you know, defensible.
- 13:06But I think you also have things like network effects.
- 13:08Right?
- 13:09So if you have stakeholders in an industry, so let's say in construction, you got GCs on
- 13:15board, you got subs on board, you got architects on board.
- 13:17Having everyone there, I think we all can understand how that's defensible.
- 13:21And last, I would say, in that larger workflow bucket, you know, you have platform effects.
- 13:27So if you can do everything for someone, functions a, b, c, and d, you just get harder
- 13:33to pull out.
- 13:34You know, I think that's is still valid as well.
- 13:36So those are our two pillars still.
- 13:38And then in an diligence conversation, a founder walks in the door.
- 13:41Those are kind of the answers that you want when you're having that first conversation, or
- 13:45how do you kind of want it delivered to you?
- 13:47I think our firm's invested at similar stages, which, you know, is very early, is the easy way
- 13:52to put it.
- 13:53And so I don't expect a founder to know all of the answers, but I do expect them to have a
- 13:59vision and for that vision to align with one of those.
- 14:02Look, the other things you mentioned, speed, okay, you can argue whether technically it's a
- 14:07moat, it's table stakes in my view, you gotta have it.
- 14:10The right to build that thing, the knowledge to build it, to know what to build and to see that
- 14:14vision, that's also critical.
- 14:16And so I wanna hear that knowledge.
- 14:17I wanna hear that earned insight of what's the data that matters, what's the workflow that
- 14:22matters.
- 14:22Charles, anything that's evolved in your thought process when you think about
- 14:25defensibility in this space?
- 14:27So much of the search for the moat, I think, has been this, like, desire to find a silver
- 14:31bullet.
- 14:32In talking to lot of our portfolio companies, I'm like, it's not one thing.
- 14:36It's like having a good platform, having good onboarding, having good customer service,
- 14:41knowing something about your customer, actually caring.
- 14:44The it's all of these little things that all add up.
- 14:48Whereas I think before in the SaaS world, it was lines of code.
- 14:51Like, I've got a I've got a three year head start on you because there's no way for you to,
- 14:55like, quickly catch up technically.
- 14:58And I think a lot of those technical moats, there was this comfort in them.
- 15:01You're like, oh, that company's been writing code for three years.
- 15:04They must have something that's hard to replicate.
- 15:06And now a lot of things I just mentioned, like customer service, caring, a good platform,
- 15:12those are things that are harder to observe externally.
- 15:15And it's funny, Nick.
- 15:17Like, I like, you probably I buy a lot of software for precursor.
- 15:20We we buy more software now than ever.
- 15:22And my experience dealing with vendors across the landscape, even selling the same product,
- 15:26is, like, radically different.
- 15:28Some people are like, hey.
- 15:29We wanna make this work for you.
- 15:30We've got all these things we can do for you.
- 15:32We're gonna come in and and do the work for you.
- 15:34And other people are like, here are API docs.
- 15:37And you just realize until agents are making these decisions on behalf of customers, some of
- 15:41the human facing stuff does matter at the margin, particularly if the products feel the
- 15:46same to the end user ex ante.
- 15:48I think this is a really good point.
- 15:50In this market, everything is changing.
- 15:52Like, three months ago, six months ago, right, you know, how how people are structuring their
- 15:56harnesses or what models they're using for what, it all changes.
- 16:00But I think the what doesn't change is that distribution matters because the more customers
- 16:06you're solving these problems for, the more you learn.
- 16:09And, you know, probably the more you're locked in.
- 16:12And so customer support for deployed engineers, whatever you want to call them, that's a thing
- 16:18right now.
- 16:19Moving into a different direction, the Euclid team, you guys published a great report, the
- 16:232026 vertical report back in April, I think.
- 16:26And you shared that vertical AI captured around 56% of exit value with a median vertical exit
- 16:33value of around 500,000,000.
- 16:35And we've talked about how that used to be a really strong exit, but today's market has
- 16:40really shifted the narrative around of, like, what is quote, unquote good look like and mean
- 16:45to different groups of people.
- 16:47How are you thinking about that venture and fund math?
- 16:50I feel like you've said a couple things about that on LinkedIn and different places as well.
- 16:54It's always helpful to take a step back and kind of immerse yourself in reality in a world
- 16:58that just wants to talk about OpenAI and Anthropic all day.
- 17:03I mean, not to say that I mean, those are a big part of our reality now.
- 17:07But in terms of you know, as as managers, in terms of thinking about liquidity, I think it's
- 17:12helpful to remember that, like, a $500,000,000 exit still is a great exit.
- 17:16You guys have been in the industry for a while now too.
- 17:18If that doesn't move the needle for your fund, I think that's tough.
- 17:23You know?
- 17:23And I mean, look, it's different if you're you have do 100 investments a year and all
- 17:28strategies on the spectrum can work.
- 17:30You know, I think if the way I've I've thought about building Euclid along with Omar is, you
- 17:35know, we want to have significant stake in the companies that we support because, one, that
- 17:40allows us to be really hands on and work with our companies and help them.
- 17:44But also because, you know, if there's a win, of course, primarily we want it to be the
- 17:49founder's win, but we want it to be game changing for Euclid too.
- 17:52And so we the trick is, I think, investing in businesses that we feel have that right tail,
- 18:00you know, that could be Decacorn's plus if everything goes right.
- 18:05But, you know, I think the beauty of Vertical AI is that you do have more optionality for,
- 18:12you know, real exits if that that maybe come earlier.
- 18:16And those can be game changing for the fund.
- 18:18Like, there's not many categories where the median exit value sits at that high of a value,
- 18:22which speaks volumes about the potential of where it sits.
- 18:25I mean, I personally also think, and maybe side point real quickly here, but there are a ton of
- 18:32strategics, but also just legacy vertical SaaS companies out there that are $5.10,
- 18:37$30,000,000,000 companies that do not have an AI strategy.
- 18:42And they probably have a CEO who's talking about something, and it's probably BS.
- 18:48And all of their incentives are aligned towards paying down their debt or whatever else it is.
- 18:54Right?
- 18:54And eventually, these companies are gonna have to look around and realize we need a strategy.
- 18:58You know, I think if I were to make a prediction, sometime in the next couple years,
- 19:02I think we're gonna see a renaissance of this sort of mid market M and A in the, you know,
- 19:07couple 100,000,000 to couple billion dollar range.
- 19:09Which can still be substantial for funds that are sized appropriately.
- 19:13Like, those don't
- 19:14those move the needle.
- 19:15100%.
- 19:16It's basic math, but I think easy to lose track of in a world where, you know, you've got
- 19:21trillion dollar companies.
- 19:22Moving kind of into the last segment, I know you made a couple predictions before the end of
- 19:26the year of 2025.
- 19:28One of the things you projected was that deep tech as a category was gonna fragment.
- 19:34Do you think that's happening now?
- 19:37And if so, what have been the signs that have illustrated this for you?
- 19:41It doesn't seem to me to be happening quite yet outside of the fact that defense has really
- 19:46taken on kind of its own thing just because so much is poured into it.
- 19:51And I think for the really successful ones, makes sense.
- 19:54Like, those will specialize in defense and navigating government probably is its own
- 19:58thing.
- 19:59But I don't know.
- 20:00I think you've kind of like I'd be curious to get your guys' view too, but I think you kinda
- 20:05see this packaging and repackaging effect in Venture where, like, you know, deep tech
- 20:11becomes a thing when people feel like they need an escape from software for whatever reason.
- 20:16But then you kind of turn around and you say like, well, Okay, what actually is this?
- 20:21Because biotech, hardware, defense, all very different things.
- 20:26Or even some people will bucket in AI infrastructure in there.
- 20:31So I don't know.
- 20:31I'm sure that, to be honest, the many very, very smart allocators that are out there
- 20:38probably already think about it that way.
- 20:40But yeah, I mean I I think at some point you'll probably see some of those categories go the
- 20:46way of, you know, green tech in the Solyndra era and like it just doesn't work.
- 20:51It's too expensive.
- 20:52It burns too much money.
- 20:53And some will, you know, kind of break out and be their own thing.
- 20:57I'm old enough inventor to remember when a lot of firms had, like, health care and IT
- 21:01practices.
- 21:01They had, like, two firms under the same umbrella, well, needless to say, IT mostly won.
- 21:07I think given the scales of these industries, it's inevitable that I mean, I think we already
- 21:11have some defense only deep tech specialist firms, and I think the desire for people to
- 21:18create specialist firms as a way to stand out, that will continue on a
- 21:22One last production prediction before we close out the show, but at the end of last year, you
- 21:26also predicted that religious institutions would either issue guidance on AI or start
- 21:30sanctioning AI tools for their communities.
- 21:33Have you been able to keep a pulse on where that is now that we're almost through with
- 21:372026?
- 21:37And where do you sit on that one?
- 21:39I can't claim that I've kept a really close pulse on it, but, you know, I I mean, I have
- 21:42seen that, not to say that platform Catholicism over all others, but the pope is is fairly
- 21:47visible.
- 21:48And, I mean, I think he's made pretty consistent, you know, statements.
- 21:51I don't know if we've seen, like, a formal and cyclical on can you use AI to worship?
- 21:57But I I think it's inevitable.
- 21:59I mean, it's a there are obvious eventual moral questions that surround it, and so seems it
- 22:05seems to be going in that direction.
- 22:06I feel like I've never seen as many deals as I have this past year.
- 22:09Maybe it's the tailwinds of so many people rushing into religious communities than years
- 22:13prior, and that's a whole other conversation itself.
- 22:16But then that speaks to the begs question the for the organizations that are hosting those
- 22:19communities, like, what are they leveraging to build a better connection with them and a
- 22:22better front door?
- 22:23I've had way more, chats with founders building in that space.
- 22:27So it's almost a convergence of it.
- 22:28I don't know if we're quite yet there I think a mainstream one fits, shoes fits all, but it's
- 22:33definitely on the top of my brain.
- 22:34We are all out of time today.
- 22:36Nick, thank you so much for joining us in Learning Corner.
- 22:40Charles, of course, thanks for shopping in as well.
- 22:42Thank you so much to our listeners for jumping in as well.
- 22:45Please like and share, with friends, and we will talk with you all next week.
- 22:49Thank you.
- 22:49Bye.
- 22:50Thank you so much, guys.