Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 🚨 The Great Divergence: Extreme Greed on 99th Percentile Valuations
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the deep dive. We heard from a lot of you
- 0:02wanting, well a clearer picture of the total market temperature
- 0:06right now. Yeah, what's the real feel out
- 0:08there? Exactly, but looking at the
- 0:10sources you sent over for today, it's less like a single
- 0:13temperature and more like, I don't know, a weather map
- 0:15showing a Blizzard right next door to a heat wave.
- 0:18That's a really good way to put it, because today we're looking
- 0:20at some pretty deep contradictions in the US
- 0:22financial market. This is November 2025 and things
- 0:26are diverging sharply. So our mission today is
- 0:29basically to synthesize all this conflicting information for you.
- 0:32We're digging into valuations, sentiment, the macro picture.
- 0:36Trying to understand what's behind this great divergent as
- 0:40they're calling it, right? How can the S&P 500 be flirting
- 0:43with all time highs? You know, up near 6720, even
- 0:47touching 6796, while market anxiety seems to be through the
- 0:51roof. It's a puzzle, but before we
- 0:53really get into the weeds, we absolutely have to stay at our
- 0:55usual disclaimer. Everything we discuss is based
- 0:58on the publicly available sources provided for this deep
- 1:00dive. It's purely for educational
- 1:02purposes. We aren't investment advisors.
- 1:04This isn't advice. You really need to do your own
- 1:07homework, your own due diligence before making any financial
- 1:10decisions. Absolutely essential.
- 1:12OK, so let's get to the core issue because it's, well, it's
- 1:16pretty wild. The market isn't just showing
- 1:18mixed signals. It's like it has split
- 1:20personality disorder totally. You've got extreme greed showing
- 1:23up in asset prices and at the exact same time extreme fear
- 1:29just dominating investor sentiment.
- 1:31How does that? Even work, it feels completely
- 1:33unstable. That's the word for it.
- 1:35Unstable equilibrium. Yeah, something's got to give,
- 1:38right? The big question is which side
- 1:41cracks first, the sky high prices or the deep seated fear?
- 1:45OK, let's unpack the greed side first.
- 1:46Those eye popping valuations. We should probably start with
- 1:49the big long term indicators, the ones that usually only
- 1:52scream this loud before, well, major trouble.
- 1:54Right. And if you look at the market
- 1:56through that long term valuation lens, the warning lights are
- 1:59definitely flashing bright red. Take the Buffett indicator.
- 2:03Ah yes, the total market cap relative to GDP measures the
- 2:07size of the market against the actual economy.
- 2:09Exactly, and right now the sources put that reading at
- 2:12around 220%. 220% wow. Yeah, that puts the market
- 2:17squarely and strongly overvalued territory.
- 2:20Just think about the stock market valued at more than
- 2:23double the entire US annual economic output.
- 2:26That's a lot. And didn't Buffett himself say
- 2:28something like 75% to 90% was sort of the reasonable zone?
- 2:33He did. So we're, you know, miles above
- 2:35that. And crucially, this 220% level
- 2:38is even higher than the 180% we saw back at the absolute
- 2:42peakofthe.com bubble in 2000. That's incredible context.
- 2:46By the way, for anyone wanting to track this daily, there's
- 2:48actually an app called Buffett Indicator you can search for and
- 2:51download from the Apple App Store.
- 2:52It gives you the latest numbers. Good tip.
- 2:54And statistically, this 220% reading is 2.2 standard
- 2:59deviations above its long term trend.
- 3:01That's not just a little pricey, it's an outlier.
- 3:03OK, so the Buffett indicator is screaming caution.
- 3:06What about the other DIG 1, the Shiller PE, the say PE ratio
- 3:09that smooths earnings over 10 years, right?
- 3:11It does gives a very long term view and it tells a similar
- 3:14story. The CP ratio is currently
- 3:16sitting around 39.3. 39.3 and the long term averages.
- 3:20About 17.7. So 39.3 puts us in the 99th
- 3:24percentile historically. The 90 99th percentile.
- 3:27Good grief. So basically almost the most
- 3:30expensive it has ever been. Almost the only time it was
- 3:32higher was literally December 1999 right at the.com mania peak
- 3:37when it hit 44.2. So yeah, long term valuation
- 3:41looks like pure unadulterated greed.
- 3:43But here's where the first part of the paradox starts to make a
- 3:45bit more sense. Right?
- 3:46Because shorter term PE ratios aren't quite as insane.
- 3:50So why the difference? Now we get to the engine behind
- 3:53this. It's all about narrow
- 3:54leadership, immense concentration.
- 3:57Risk, meaning the whole market's valuation is basically being
- 3:59propped up by just a handful of stocks.
- 4:01Pretty much. It's heavily dependent on these
- 4:03really euphoric forward-looking earnings estimates for a tiny
- 4:07group of AI focused mega caps. You know, the ones everyone's
- 4:10calling the Great 8. OK.
- 4:12So the overall S&P 504 PE is high, maybe 22.7 or so, but that
- 4:16number hides the real story. Exactly.
- 4:18It's the dichotomy and earnings expectations that's key.
- 4:21So what are the numbers showing there?
- 4:23Well, look at the consensus earnings per share, the EPS
- 4:25estimates for 2025. For those great 8 stocks,
- 4:29analysts have actually raised their estimates by about 3.9%.
- 4:33They're betting big on continued AI dominance.
- 4:35OK, optimism there, But what about the rest of the market,
- 4:38the other like 492 companies that's.
- 4:40Where it gets grim for the rest of the S&P 500, you know,
- 4:44representing broader corporate America, manufacturing,
- 4:48cyclicals, everything else. EPS estimates have been cut
- 4:51significantly by 4.2%. Wow, a 4.2% cut for most of the
- 4:56market versus a 3.9% raise for the chosen few.
- 4:59That's a huge divergent right there.
- 5:01It really is. It means the underlying health
- 5:03of the broad market looks weak. Earnings pressure maybe
- 5:06recessionary signals outside that tech bubble.
- 5:09So the market's overall strength is basically balanced on the
- 5:12head of a pin reliant on this handful of great 8 stocks
- 5:14continuing to deliver perfection.
- 5:16Very fragile. Extremely fragile, classic
- 5:19narrow leadership. The average stock is definitely
- 5:22under pressure, pressure. And you know, this fragility
- 5:25leads us right into the other side of this contradiction in
- 5:28fetter psychology. Yeah, the extreme fear part.
- 5:31If prices are showing a record greed driven by these few
- 5:35stocks, why are investors apparently so scared?
- 5:38That's the multi trillion dollar question, isn't it?
- 5:41Prices near highs, but fear is just palpable.
- 5:45Let's look at the sentiment indicators.
- 5:47CNN's Fear and greed index. What's that?
- 5:49Reading now. Down around 23.8.
- 5:52Deeply in extreme fear. 23.8 wasn't that way up near extreme
- 5:56greed just a few months ago it. Was just 10 weeks ago, it was
- 5:59near 80. That's a massive swing towards
- 6:02fear, suggesting investors just don't trust this rally at all.
- 6:05It's like they're waiting for the other shoe to drop.
- 6:06And we see that fear in the options market too, right, with
- 6:08the VIX. Absolutely.
- 6:09The VIX, the volatility index, is trading around 19.50 to 1997.
- 6:14Let's call it near 20. Which is elevated.
- 6:16Definitely elevated. It signals rising uncertainty.
- 6:20You see, at real complacent market tops, the VIX often drops
- 6:23below 15 because everyone thinks risk is vanished.
- 6:27A VIX near 20 means people are actively paying up for
- 6:30protection, buying puts. They're hedging.
- 6:32They expect turbulence. So the fear is being priced in
- 6:35to some extent. It is, and it's not just
- 6:37traders. Look at the AAII survey, the
- 6:39individual investors. Their pessimism is chronic.
- 6:43How chronic? Bearish sentiment among retail
- 6:45investors has been above its historical average for 49 out of
- 6:49the last 50, 51 weeks. Think about that.
- 6:52For basically a whole year, the average Joe investor has been
- 6:55more bearish than usual even as the index climbed.
- 6:58They are not buying this rally. 49 out of 51 weeks.
- 7:01That's deeply entrenched skepticism.
- 7:04And this widespread fear isn't just, you know, irrational
- 7:06panic. It seems to be a pretty logical
- 7:08response to the growing uncertainty in the macroeconomic
- 7:11picture. The macro fog you mentioned
- 7:13earlier, this ties into the government shutdown, doesn't it?
- 7:16Directly the shutdown that started what, early November
- 7:192025? It's thrown a wrench into the
- 7:21works by halting the release of critical economic data.
- 7:25The data the Fed in the market need to actually see what's
- 7:27going on. Precisely.
- 7:29And the biggest casualty is the labor market data, the October
- 7:332025 employment situation report.
- 7:35That's the big one with non farm payrolls and the official
- 7:38unemployment rate. It was supposed to come out
- 7:39November 7th. But it won't be published.
- 7:41Nope. The Bureau of Labor Statistics.
- 7:43The BLS shutdown operations, so the report is delayed
- 7:47indefinitely. We're flying blind.
- 7:48So the Fed tasked with managing employment and inflation doesn't
- 7:52have the main employment number. What was the last official rate
- 7:54we got? The last official unemployment
- 7:56rate was 4.3% back in August. Now the market is forced to rely
- 8:00on proxies and they don't look great.
- 8:03What are those proxies telling us?
- 8:05Well, the private ADP jobs report came in really weak, only
- 8:08at a 42,000 jobs. The Chicago Fed put out an
- 8:11estimate suggesting unemployment might have already ticked up to
- 8:144.4%. And maybe most worryingly,
- 8:17announced job cuts jumped to the highest level for an October
- 8:20since way back in 2003. OK.
- 8:23So the limited signals we do have on jobs point towards
- 8:26weakening. Seems that way.
- 8:27And it's not just jobs. Inflation data is murky to the
- 8:31last official CPI reading for September showed inflation still
- 8:34sticky at 3.0%, still above the Feds 2% target.
- 8:39But the October CPI report also delayed.
- 8:41So uncertainty on jobs, uncertainty on inflation the Fed
- 8:44is trying to navigate with a broken dashboard.
- 8:46Totally. They and the market are trying
- 8:49to justify these 99th percentile stock valuations based on patchy
- 8:53data, estimates and, frankly, a lot of hope.
- 8:56While the core economic indicators are just dark, that
- 9:00alone could justify the extreme fear we're seeing in sentiment.
- 9:03OK, So huge uncertainty there. Let's pivot to the bond market,
- 9:05often called the smart money. What's happening with the yield
- 9:08curve? It was inverted for ages,
- 9:10signaling recession. Right, But that's changed
- 9:12dramatically. The yield curve is actually
- 9:14uninverted. It's steepened.
- 9:15The spread between the 10 year and two year Treasury yield is
- 9:18now positive, about plus .54% or 54 basis points.
- 9:23So a normal upward sloping curve, usually that's seen as a
- 9:25good sign, right? Like the economy is recovering.
- 9:27Normally yes, but you have to look why it's steepening this
- 9:31time. The sources are pretty clear.
- 9:33This isn't necessarily an all clear, it's what traders call a
- 9:36bull steeper, which sounds good, but the drivers are concerning.
- 9:41How so? What's driving it?
- 9:43It's being driven by two conflicting things.
- 9:45First, the short end of the curve, like the two year yield,
- 9:48is falling. Why?
- 9:50Because the market is convinced and the Fed is signaling that
- 9:53they've started cutting interest rates.
- 9:55And why are they cutting rates? Because the economy is
- 9:57weakening, they're reacting to those proxy signals of rising
- 10:00unemployment and a slowing economy.
- 10:03So the short end is falling for bearish reasons.
- 10:05OK, rates cuts due to weakness push the short end down, but
- 10:09what about the long end, the 10 year yield?
- 10:11That's the other weird part. The 10 year yield is staying
- 10:14stubbornly high or sticky. It's hanging around 4.11%.
- 10:18It's refusing to follow the two year yield down significantly.
- 10:21Why would it stay high if the Fed is cutting?
- 10:24Several structural reasons, it seems.
- 10:26One, persistent worries about inflation maybe not falling as
- 10:29fast as hoped. 2, the sheer volume of government debt being
- 10:33issued because of the massive federal deficit, tons of supply
- 10:36hitting the market. And three, maybe less demand
- 10:39from foreign buyers for U.S. debt, meaning domestic buyers
- 10:42demand a higher yield. So the bond market is basically
- 10:45saying, yeah, the Fed's cutting because things look shaky short
- 10:49term, but we still have these longer term problems like
- 10:52inflation and deficits keeping long rates propped up.
- 10:55Exactly, it's a really complex message and that sticky 4.11%
- 11:00long term term yield is incredibly important when we
- 11:03think back to the extreme greed and stock valuations.
- 11:06How does it connect? Well think about those great A
- 11:08growth stocks. Most of their value comes from
- 11:10earnings expected way out in the future decades from now.
- 11:13To figure out what those future earnings are worth today, you
- 11:15have to discount them back using a risk free rate.
- 11:18And if that baseline rate is higher, like 4.11?
- 11:20Percent. Then the present value of those
- 11:22distant earnings gets hit hard. It shrinks a 4.11% risk free
- 11:27rate, provides really stiff competition for socks,
- 11:30especially those relying on far off growth.
- 11:32It makes sustaining those 99th percentile valuations on the
- 11:36great 8 much, much harder. It's a major headwind.
- 11:39OK, wow, So pulling this all together, free listening, we've
- 11:43got this great divergent. It feels like a really unstable
- 11:46situation. Completely.
- 11:47You have euphoric prices, especially in a few mega cap
- 11:50stocks pushing valuations to historical extremes.
- 11:53Fighting directly against this backdrop of deep investor fear
- 11:57fueled by genuine macroeconomic uncertainty and this data
- 12:00blackout. It puts the market on a knife
- 12:02edge. It's vulnerable.
- 12:04Any catalyst. Maybe a big earnings missed from
- 12:06one of the great 8, Maybe the eventual release of jobs data
- 12:09confirming a sharp slowdown could potentially break that AI
- 12:12driven euphoria. This just doesn't feel like a
- 12:14healthy, broad based bull market at all.
- 12:16It feels expensive, narrow and fundamentally anxious.
- 12:19That sums it up perfectly. That tension is the defining
- 12:22feature right now. So as we wrap up, let's leave
- 12:24you with one final thought, kind of looping back to the sentiment
- 12:27data, we talked about the AP ratio being at that 99th
- 12:32percentile, a level only really seen at the.com peak.
- 12:35Right, extreme valuation. But we also saw the AAI data
- 12:39showing retail investors have been incredibly pessimistic,
- 12:41mostly sitting up this rally for what was it, 49 of the last 51
- 12:46weeks. Yeah, deep skepticism there.
- 12:47So if you have valuations at historic peaks, likely driven by
- 12:52institutional money and algorithms while the retail
- 12:55crowd is still hiding in fear. What happens when the tide
- 12:57turns? Exactly what does that imply
- 12:59about how fast or how sharp a correction could be?
- 13:02If the retail money never really came in to support the top, how
- 13:05quickly could the professional money head for the exits when
- 13:08that euphoria finally breaks? Maybe that divergent and who is
- 13:11participating is the most fragile part of this whole
- 13:13setup. Something to think about.