Latest / The Morning Rundown / Redistricting Reality Check, a CDC Transparency Question, and an Early Flu Season
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I'm on my second coffee, a dark roast, and I can
- 0:17[Maya] already tell the news has been busy.
- 0:20[David] Second?
- 0:20[David] It's barely past the opening music.
- 0:23[Maya] Don't judge me.
- 0:24[Maya] Welcome to the Morning Rundown.
- 0:26[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 0:27[David] And I'm David.
- 0:28[David] Maya, you promised me short list today.
- 0:30[Maya] Three stories.
- 0:31[Maya] Short, I swear.
- 0:33[David] Go.
- 0:34[Maya] One's about the midterm map, one's about the CDC and how it
- 0:37[Maya] reports measles, and one's about flu season showing up early.
- 0:41[David] Early?
- 0:42[David] Wait, really?
- 0:43[Maya] Yep.
- 0:43[Maya] Hold that thought, boo.
- 0:44[David] And the CDC one, is that a numbers story or a trust
- 0:47[David] story?
- 0:48[Maya] A bit of both.
- 0:49[Maya] It's about what the agency is saying about measles deaths and what
- 0:53[Maya] it isn't.
- 0:54[Maya] We'll stick to what the reporting actually says.
- 0:56[David] Good.
- 0:56[David] I'd like the short list to actually stay short.
- 0:59[Maya] Brisk, I promise.
- 1:00[Maya] No lectures.
- 1:01[Maya] Okay, maybe one small coffee lecture.
- 1:04[David] Fine.
- 1:04[David] Measles and flu in the same hour, so we're all gonna feel
- 1:07[David] a little itchy and sniffly by the end.
- 1:09[Maya] Totally.
- 1:10[Maya] You know what I mean?
- 1:11[David] Sadly, yes.
- 1:12[David] So where do we begin?
- 1:13[Maya] Let's start with the midterm map, where the plan was bigger than
- 1:17[Maya] the payoff.
- 1:18[David] Oh, that one's good.
- 1:19[Maya] Okay, so the map.
- 1:21[Maya] NPR had a piece on October twenty-second, and the gist is Trump
- 1:26[Maya] prompted a rare wave of mid-decade redistricting.
- 1:29[David] Rare is right.
- 1:30[David] Normally, you redraw once after the census, and everybody goes home.
- 1:34[Maya] Right?
- 1:34[Maya] And NPR says it gave Republicans a boost toward holding the House.
- 1:39[Maya] A head start, basically.
- 1:41[David] A head start, not a finish line.
- 1:43[Maya] Exactly.
- 1:44[Maya] NPR's point is that the voters will determine whether it works.
- 1:47[David] Which, I mean, come on, that's the part the mapmakers can't draw.
- 1:51[Maya] Nope.
- 1:51[Maya] No pencil for that.
- 1:52[David] Still, a head start is a real thing.
- 1:55[David] In the long race, being a few steps ahead at the gun
- 1:57[David] matters.
- 1:58[Maya] Unless the track turns out to be bumpier than the brochure said.
- 2:02[David] So how big is the head start?
- 2:03[David] 'Cause Republicans were counting on thirteen seats from the new maps.
- 2:06[Maya] Wait, thirteen?
- 2:08[Maya] That's a lot.
- 2:09[David] It is.
- 2:10[David] And House Majority Whip Tom Emmer told Axios they won't win all
- 2:13[David] thirteen.
- 2:14[Maya] Huh.
- 2:15[Maya] That's the guy whose job is counting votes saying it out loud.
- 2:18[David] Yeah, and he didn't say the edge is gone.
- 2:20[David] Axios reported the edge remains, it's just smaller than expected.
- 2:24[Maya] Smaller than expected.
- 2:26[Maya] Okay, that's a polite way to say it.
- 2:27[David] Politicians have a whole dictionary for that, you know what I mean?
- 2:30[David] But credit where it's due, admitting it early is better than getting
- 2:33[David] surprised in November.
- 2:34[Maya] Totally.
- 2:35[Maya] So where did the shrinking happen?
- 2:37[Maya] Because I saw Axios had a later piece October twentieth.
- 2:40[David] They did.
- 2:41[David] Republicans are confident about three Southern pickups, and that's after the Supreme
- 2:45[David] Court's voting rights decision.
- 2:47[Maya] So that part of the plan is holding up.
- 2:49[David] That part, yes.
- 2:50[David] Then it gets thinner.
- 2:52[David] Axios says Republicans have conceded one redrawn Ohio seat.
- 2:55[Maya] Conceded?
- 2:56[Maya] Like, already?
- 2:57[Maya] Before anybody votes?
- 2:59[David] Already.
- 3:00[David] And Texas is the one that jumped out at me.
- 3:02[David] Five redrawn seats there.
- 3:04[Maya] Okay, and?
- 3:05[David] Axios reports Republicans are confident about two of those five.
- 3:08[Maya] Two of five, in Texas.
- 3:11[David] Out of five redrawn seats, they're confident about two.
- 3:15[David] Say that out loud and it sounds like a different plan than
- 3:17[David] the one that got pitched.
- 3:18[Maya] A plan pitched with a lot of confidence, as I recall.
- 3:21[David] And the main House GOP super PAC has pulled out of TX-28.
- 3:25[Maya] Hmm.
- 3:26[Maya] That's a money signal, right?
- 3:27[Maya] Nobody pulls cash from a race they feel good about.
- 3:30[David] That's the read, though I'd be careful.
- 3:32[David] A super PAC moving money can mean it's lost or it can
- 3:34[David] mean it's safe enough.
- 3:36[David] Axios framed it as part of the shrinking boost.
- 3:38[Maya] Fair.
- 3:39[Maya] Hedge accepted.
- 3:41[David] And Emmer's own argument is that pickups elsewhere could still leave the
- 3:44[David] party ahead even if it loses seats in California and Utah.
- 3:48[Maya] So the math is still alive, just tighter.
- 3:50[David] Tighter is the word.
- 3:51[David] The plan was thirteen, and the reporting talks about confidence in some
- 3:55[David] seats and not in others.
- 3:57[Maya] So it's not a collapse.
- 3:58[Maya] It's more like a spreadsheet with a few cells turning yellow.
- 4:01[David] Right.
- 4:02[David] And look, from where I sit, this was legal.
- 4:04[David] Aggressive, sure.
- 4:05[David] Both parties have played hardball with maps when they could.
- 4:08[Maya] Yeah.
- 4:08[Maya] Nobody's drawing these in crayon by accident.
- 4:11[David] Nobody.
- 4:12[David] But a map is a starting position, and the voters get the
- 4:14[David] last word.
- 4:15[Maya] And I'm not gonna guess how that goes.
- 4:18[Maya] Too many moving pieces.
- 4:19[David] Smart.
- 4:20[David] The people who predicted this stuff confidently usually end up eating their
- 4:23[David] words.
- 4:24[Maya] And honestly, that's the healthiest way to look at map.
- 4:27[Maya] Nobody gets to declare a winner before the ballots are counted.
- 4:30[David] Right.
- 4:31[David] Draw the lines, make your case, then let people decide.
- 4:34[Maya] Speaking of numbers people want to trust, there's a different institution facing
- 4:38[Maya] questions about its own counting.
- 4:40[David] The CDC.
- 4:41[Maya] The CDC.
- 4:43[Maya] And it's about measles deaths.
- 4:46[Maya] Okay.
- 4:46[Maya] So David, this one's short on details, but the headline alone made
- 4:49[Maya] me sit up.
- 4:51[David] Go on.
- 4:52[Maya] The Guardian ran a piece on October twenty-second.
- 4:54[Maya] The headline says, "Experts are alarmed by a less transparent CDC as
- 5:00[Maya] US measles deaths rise."
- 5:03[David] Wait, less transparent?
- 5:04[David] That's the expert's phrase?
- 5:06[Maya] That's in The Guardian's headline, yeah.
- 5:08[Maya] And The Guardian reports the agency is declining to say which state
- 5:12[Maya] the latest measles death happened in.
- 5:15[David] Huh.
- 5:15[David] Not even the state.
- 5:17[Maya] Not even the state.
- 5:18[Maya] And it's also delaying reporting on other measles deaths.
- 5:22[David] Okay, so I want to be careful here because I can already
- 5:24[David] hear people filling in the blanks.
- 5:26[Maya] Totally.
- 5:27[Maya] I mean, come on, everybody wants a villain by lunchtime.
- 5:30[David] Right.
- 5:30[David] But what do we actually have?
- 5:32[David] We have a headline and a summary line.
- 5:34[David] We don't have the agency's reason for holding back.
- 5:37[Maya] And we don't have the death count either, at least not in
- 5:39[Maya] what I've got in front of me.
- 5:41[David] So no guessing.
- 5:42[David] Could be a privacy call, could be a backlog, could be something
- 5:45[David] else entirely.
- 5:47[David] I don't know, and neither does anyone reading a headline.
- 5:50[Maya] Which never stops anybody online.
- 5:52[David] Never.
- 5:53[David] But here's what I keep coming back to.
- 5:55[David] A state name sounds like a small thing.
- 5:57[David] It isn't if you live near it.
- 5:59[Maya] Yeah.
- 6:00[Maya] Like a parent deciding about a school or clinic visit wants to
- 6:03[Maya] know if this is down the road or across the country.
- 6:07[David] Exactly.
- 6:08[David] And delayed numbers are the same problem.
- 6:10[David] If the count shows up weeks late, it's history by the time
- 6:13[David] you read it.
- 6:14[Maya] Hmm, and that's where trust comes from, right?
- 6:16[Maya] People will forgive a messy number if it's on time.
- 6:19[Maya] They get suspicious when it goes quiet.
- 6:22[David] A conservative like me would add one thing.
- 6:24[David] We lean on these agencies to be the neutral referee.
- 6:27[David] When the referee goes quiet, even for a boring reason, the doubt
- 6:31[David] does the damage.
- 6:32[Maya] So the fix is simple.
- 6:34[Maya] Say what you can, say it fast, and explain what you can't.
- 6:37[David] Plain and boring, which is what you want from a health agency.
- 6:41[Maya] And it's a fair ask.
- 6:42[Maya] Nobody's demanding the agency be exciting, just that the information shows up
- 6:46[Maya] while people can still use it, and that someone says plainly what's
- 6:50[Maya] being held back and why.
- 6:52[David] Right.
- 6:52[David] Timely and a little dull beats late and polished every time.
- 6:56[David] That's the whole ask, really.
- 6:58[Maya] Speaking of which, boring CDC numbers are exactly what we need next
- 7:03[Maya] because they're the backdrop for the flu.
- 7:05[David] And flu season is already knocking.
- 7:07[David] So let's see what the early data says.
- 7:10[Maya] Okay, flu, and I'm already reaching for a tissue just saying it.
- 7:15[David] Sympathy sniffles.
- 7:16[David] Go ahead.
- 7:17[Maya] CNN ran a piece on October 22nd.
- 7:20[Maya] The headline says a mutated virus is driving the country into an
- 7:24[Maya] early flu season, especially on the West Coast.
- 7:28[David] Early how?
- 7:29[David] Like a week early?
- 7:30[Maya] Months.
- 7:31[Maya] CNN says flu season is picking up months ahead of schedule with
- 7:35[Maya] a mutated virus spreading in some parts of the United States.
- 7:39[David] Months.
- 7:39[David] Wait, really?
- 7:41[Maya] That's the report.
- 7:42[Maya] And I'll say it plainly, I'm not gonna make it sound scarier
- 7:45[Maya] than it is.
- 7:46[David] Let's slow down on mutated for a second because that word does
- 7:49[David] a lot of work in a headline.
- 7:51[Maya] It does.
- 7:52[Maya] In plain terms, it means the virus has changed.
- 7:55[Maya] That's all the word itself tells us.
- 7:57[David] Right.
- 7:57[David] And I don't want anyone hearing a movie monster word and panicking.
- 8:01[Maya] Agreed.
- 8:02[Maya] What I can tell you is what CNN says.
- 8:04[Maya] A mutated virus is spreading in some parts of the country.
- 8:08[Maya] How it differs or what that means for any one person isn't
- 8:12[Maya] something I have from the sources in front of me.
- 8:14[David] Good, because I want a baseline first.
- 8:17[David] What did the CDC say before that piece came out?
- 8:20[Maya] Right.
- 8:20[Maya] And this one's older.
- 8:22[Maya] The CDC's weekly surveillance report covers the week ending October 3rd.
- 8:27[David] So about three weeks before CNN.
- 8:29[Maya] Roughly, yeah.
- 8:30[Maya] And the CDC says flu activity was still low at that point.
- 8:35[David] Low.
- 8:35[David] Okay.
- 8:36[Maya] But it had risen since late August or early September.
- 8:40[Maya] So low but climbing.
- 8:42[David] Hmm, which is how every flu season starts, honestly.
- 8:45[David] You don't go from nothing to a hospital hallway overnight.
- 8:48[Maya] No, thank goodness.
- 8:50[Maya] And the CDC also says the highest activity was already on the
- 8:54[Maya] West Coast.
- 8:55[David] Same region CNN is pointing at.
- 8:57[Maya] Same region, yep.
- 8:59[Maya] The CDC report ties that to two of its numbered regions, nine
- 9:03[Maya] and 10.
- 9:04[David] Which I couldn't map for you without a cheat sheet.
- 9:07[David] West Coast is fine by me.
- 9:09[Maya] Same.
- 9:10[Maya] Now, here's a detail I like.
- 9:12[Maya] The CDC says early season activity is higher than usual for this
- 9:16[Maya] time of year.
- 9:18[David] Higher than usual.
- 9:19[David] Hmm.
- 9:20[Maya] But within expected seasonal variation.
- 9:23[David] Okay, so that's the part people will skip.
- 9:26[David] Higher than usual and still inside the normal range of how these
- 9:29[David] seasons wobble.
- 9:30[Maya] Right.
- 9:31[Maya] Some years just start earlier than others.
- 9:34[David] Which makes higher than usual sound a lot less scary, at least
- 9:37[David] as of that early October snapshot.
- 9:39[Maya] That's the idea.
- 9:40[Maya] A notch above typical, but still inside the normal wobble, not a
- 9:45[Maya] different universe.
- 9:46[David] Fair.
- 9:46[David] But I'm gonna say what a listener is thinking.
- 9:49[David] If the CDC says low and CNN says early, which one do
- 9:52[David] I believe?
- 9:53[Maya] Both, because they're snapshots from different dates.
- 9:55[Maya] The CDC gives you early October, low, rising, West Coast leading.
- 10:00[David] And CNN says that since then it's picked up.
- 10:03[Maya] That's what CNN reports, yes.
- 10:05[Maya] Nobody here is calling anybody wrong.
- 10:07[David] Here's why timing matters, though.
- 10:09[David] Flu isn't one national switch.
- 10:11[David] The CDC put the highest activity on the West Coast, so someone
- 10:14[David] out there may be living a different week than someone else.
- 10:17[Maya] Right.
- 10:18[Maya] CNN says some parts of the United States, which is careful wording.
- 10:22[Maya] Not everywhere, not equally.
- 10:24[David] So the honest answer for most of us is that the national
- 10:27[David] story only goes so far.
- 10:29[David] Our sources don't tell us how your area compares, so your local
- 10:32[David] numbers are the thing to watch.
- 10:34[Maya] Which is a boring answer, but it's the useful one.
- 10:37[Maya] Early or not, what counts for you is what's happening near you.
- 10:40[David] And that's not a dodge.
- 10:41[David] It's just where the reporting stops, and I'd rather say so than
- 10:44[David] pretend.
- 10:45[Maya] Right.
- 10:46[Maya] I'd rather stop where the sources stop than fill the gap with
- 10:49[Maya] a guess, even if a guess would sound more exciting.
- 10:52[David] Totally.
- 10:52[David] What I don't have is a number for how much it's picked
- 10:55[David] up since early October.
- 10:56[David] The sources we have don't give one.
- 10:58[Maya] No, and I'm not going to invent one.
- 11:00[Maya] Anyone watching the CDC's weekly updates will see it as it comes.
- 11:03[David] Practical angle, though.
- 11:05[David] If you're on the West Coast, is there anything to do?
- 11:07[Maya] Nothing in our sources says that, so I'll stay in my lane.
- 11:10[Maya] I'll just say if you were already planning to get a flu
- 11:13[Maya] shot, nobody's stopping you from doing it sooner.
- 11:16[David] Mom advice.
- 11:17[David] Accepted.
- 11:20[Maya] I contain multitudes, mostly tissues.
- 11:23[David] One more thing.
- 11:24[David] If you see a flu number somewhere that sounds different, check the
- 11:26[David] date on it before you react.
- 11:28[Maya] Good rule for everything, honestly.
- 11:30[Maya] A number without a date is just a vibe.
- 11:34[Maya] Okay, so quick lap around the table before we let you go.
- 11:37[David] Map first.
- 11:38[David] The Republican redistricting edge exists.
- 11:40[David] It's just smaller than the sales pitch, and voters still get the
- 11:43[David] final say.
- 11:44[Maya] Then the CDC, measles deaths, and a lot of questions about what's
- 11:48[Maya] getting reported and when.
- 11:50[David] Hmm.
- 11:50[David] And flu showed up early this year with the West Coast out
- 11:52[David] front.
- 11:53[Maya] Which brings me to the practical bit.
- 11:55[Maya] Check your local health department's flu page this week.
- 11:58[Maya] Takes two minutes.
- 11:59[David] Before the waiting room does it for you.
- 12:01[Maya] Exactly.
- 12:02[Maya] And two minutes is nothing.
- 12:04[Maya] You spent longer than that deciding on a coffee order.
- 12:08[David] Guilty.
- 12:08[David] I changed my mind twice at the counter and still second-guessed it
- 12:11[David] on the walk back.
- 12:13[Maya] That's the most relatable thing you've said all week.
- 12:16[Maya] David, thanks for the company, and thanks to everyone for listening.
- 12:19[David] Yes, thank you for spending part of your morning with us.
- 12:22[David] We know there's a lot competing for it, and we don't take
- 12:24[David] that for granted.
- 12:25[Maya] Come back tomorrow.
- 12:26[Maya] We'll have a fresh batch of headlines, a fresh pot of something
- 12:28[Maya] hot, and if I'm lucky, a slightly cleaner keyboard.
- 12:32[David] Wash your hands, Maya.
- 12:33[David] I'm looking at your keyboard, and it's looking back.
- 12:37[Maya] Rude, but fair.
- 12:38[Maya] And that's the rundown.